Pakistan, Afghanistan, and Iran heading to war?

[@CaspianReport]

Stay better informed ground.news/caspian and access world-wide perspectives on global developments. Subscribe for 50% off unlimited access through my link.

[@gamingpro4275]

Bro saying this area is known fr women's r8 violation n unfriendly..just fr we didn't allow them in stripped clothes n bikini cloth in our own Muslim territory which is already similar to traditional culture n ancient religion Zoroastrian 😭😭🤡🤡🤣🤣 they wanna see openly bars n prostitution n only-fans as liberty... women r8 doesn't mean nudity n sexual liberation. its a woke culture. don't push ur culture in our land cuz u don't like Islamic asian culture..so know ur place. west is such an asshole this West n their media. women's r8 or human r8 actually is not the issue fr west. Their issue is to dominate other countries to establish a neo-colonial trap where no one can raise their voice independently.. example of women r8 n human r8 ..look at Afghanistan, Iraq,syria, and Libya what they did...how they treated women ? what war crimes they associated including rape, whom they wanna liberalize. look at recent Israeli war-crime in Palestine particularly children n women and little girl They make their funny videos w women's cloth n upload to internet. ..where goes women r8 at the time when they raped women n taking women's honor?? this is called Western women r8 n liberty which west generally criticises about? see the double standard!!? Caspian mention about Israeli-gaza-Hezbollah war but they didn't criticize Israeli like he is shitting about our Muslim countries, particularly Iran. iran at least doesn't rape Iranian women or foreign land to their women. Even though Iran recently made a bit ease about women's dress code bt that doesn't mean we allow in our Muslim culture which has Islamic n iranian values to cloth off women in public places. moreover, in the education centre..that girl was half mad n paid actor by the western fund or worked with some stupid foreign activist western org. to create an issue so that they can use them as an excuse to sanction alongside creating, instability in the Iranian society to counter a land that is the only threat to the West n their allies like Israel.

[@lusajokyando3480]

😊

[@insearchof9090]

Map is wrong. Though we don't want it to be shown in colors and added to be part of India, but we can't be hypocrite as well. If we say POK is part of India in other videos, i will say the same here. 😑 POK is integral part of India. Please correct your map. (Inside my heart: 🤩 thank you for not showing this T hellhole as part of India🥺✌🏼).

[@returo7297]

wheres safes place? deepsea or antartica? or greenland?

[@waitwhat....2473]

Ground new miss represented on Trump biggest and most resent lie as truth. Ground news is greatly with it's truth meter apperantly. This is exactly like how the media props up certin news stories to favor a political administrations across the world. Evidently. Ground news may miss report.

[@maquacr7014]

If you ever feel useless, remember that USA spent 3 trillion dollars in 20 years to replace Taliban with Taliban.

[@Open_56]

Also has wasted Billions in the "war of terror" and in aid to Izrael and Ukraine

[@m00semanus]

Sad but true

[@Bibinjeustasa]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@southeast7259]

The weapons industry called it "a good deal".

[@snato]

Also, USA had none other than Pakistan as their ally to prevent & exterminate Taliban

[@abdostaslam]

People from Balochistan are called “Balochs” meanwhile the language is called “Balochi”

[@drmeme42]

And Baloches (pronounced balosh) is a slang word for testicles in French

[@olegnurmagomedov750]

@@drmeme42 AHAHAHAHAHA. As someone who may be inclined to be racist toward Baloch people, this information is gold for me.

[@Bashir-n2x]

​@@olegnurmagomedov750 khalistan Jindabad

[@mtarkes]

Bollocks!

[@luisluis5306]

@@Bashir-n2x what dude?

[@bob8776]

“The Afghan Taliban has designated the Pakistani Taliban as a terrorist organization” _Insert Spider-Man pointing meme here_

[@theguybehindyou4762]

We already armed them, now we just need to tell both groups that the other side called them names.

[@truthseeker-nv6ny]

That is not true. Pakistan literally bombed Afghanistan a few days ago saying that Afghan taliban is not taking any action against the Pakistan taliban

[@clashking9710]

“Every modern conflict in Asia or Africa can be traced back to some British bureaucrat with a ruler and a pen drawing lines on a map.” - Sun Tzu (probably)

[@johnherrick7486]

Yes but the instability was there even before the British draw lines.

[@monatica3756]

@@johnherrick7486 please dont defend the british

[@abdulelahW]

@@johnherrick7486it was far more stable than Europe, then they exported their problems and filth in boats

[@efs83dws]

There was never peace in any of these regions even before the British left Britain.

[@johnherrick7486]

@@monatica3756 If you took that as a defense of Britain, you read it wrong.

[@jackdias9263]

can’t wait for the inevitable video on the Syrian civil war

[@mikenogozones]

Grab your popcorn 🍿

[@JinKee]

@@mikenogozonesi guess things will start to be FOI in about 50 years

[@hermaeusmora2945]

Why? It's not going to tell the truth that the "syrian rebels" that America and Israel like funding are actually Al Qaeda.

[@avppr3451]

he doesnt has the balls to call out the ex al-quaeda terrorists armed by cia, ops i meant the "freedom fighter rebels"

[@Andrew79334]

its not a civil war. its another front in the larger war between east and west. 24 hours after the cease fire isis and al quada funded and baked by turkey, the u.s and isreal started attacking the syrian government to distabilise supply routs that iran uses to supply weapons to the resistance in Lebanon and Palestine and iraq. also turkey and russia are having a dispute about the oil pipeline that runs through there as well. there are over 14 different facts in Syria fighting each other right now and no they arnt al on the same side. some are funded by turkey who are fighting isis who is funded and trained by the u.s and so on

[@meengla]

I am a Pakistani American. The regions to the west of Indus River are linguistically, culturally, economically significantly different from the much more populated regions in Sindh and Punjab, which are more like the northwest India. This video is spot on and sadly so.

[@umaryusuf537]

The video is over exaggerating the threat to both Iran and Pakistan when it comes to security Pakistan is safer today then it was in the early 2000’s he’s definitely not spot on

[@meengla]

@@umaryusuf537 It is all relative. The destruction in Pakistan between 2007-2015 had its origin in the western regions of Pakistan just as the recent rise in terrorism in Pakistan has its roots in the western regions of Pakistan. There were ethnic/sectarian conflicts in Sindh as well as in Punjab too but none affected the security of Pakistan like the violence from the western regions of Pakistan. So this video, while exaggerating about being 'the most dangerous place' in the entire world, does point toward something which has been affecting Pakistan for decades.

[@umaryusuf537]

@ yeah I’m not denying that the video has address a real issue in Pakistan all I’m saying is the video does drastically over exaggerate the extent of the issue portraying the issue as always getting worse when in reality it got better and still is better today compared to 2005-2015.

[@meengla]

@@umaryusuf537 Certainly it is an exaggeration to call this region the most dangerous for the world. Per the video itself, it is a 'resource starved' region, which doesn't attract big powers much. Unfortunately, for Pakistan itself, this festering wound is not healing for decades and decades.

[@umaryusuf537]

@ it’s entirely Pakistans faults it’s in this situation neglecting the baluch and supporting the Taliban has led to this

[@robertroberto4749]

Before the internet this kind of analysis was presented on secret meetings of CIA, KGB or MOSSAD😂😂😂😂😂

[@julietaaboka3285]

👏🥸

[@ah8893]

@@julietaaboka3285what an antisemitic comment

[@jonasbaine3538]

And in graduate studies

[@girishdubey724]

😂😂😂 Highly classified

[@HaamRadio54]

Wow that's actually crazy think......

[@skiddybop780]

'banning women from hearing each other' ? did i hear that right? no pun intended

[@eatinsomtin9984]

its fake

[@llawliet57807]

It's real lol

[@AThousandSunsinphysics]

Yes, Islamists say it's fake

[@resbalosa]

"Lol"what!?

[@cyan92265]

Western propaganda being desperate because Taliban clapped them cowboy cheeks and kept the Apache Helicopters afterwards.

[@edwardkopp1116]

That conflict between Russia and Britain in the region was called "The Great Game."

[@misterpsparrowbabble]

This is fascinating: Return of a King: The Battle for Afghanistan a 2013 history book about the First Anglo-Afghan War written by Scottish historian William Dalrymple

[@Joe-Przybranowski]

Afghanistan has zero chance of becoming a modern state and living in the eleventh century at the same time.

[@cXms-k8y]

Technology needs engineers not SJW And rules are not old or young Technology is You are linking Tech and laws or rules If you want to build a car you need car engineering knowledge and machinery Not ism or schism You intertwine both When machines were invented they were by conservatives of west not some liberals The fighter jets was literally if I am correct made by Nazi Germany

[@y.u.so.]

Who cares? It's most Islamic country ❤ unlike Pakistan or United Kingdom

[@kolikari3813]

They don’t need to once everything is turned to rubble

[@y.u.so.]

@@Joe-Przybranowski Who cares? It's the most Islamic country Unlike Pakistan or United Kingdom.

[@iflyabus]

You’d be surprised.

[@Kurkurkurdae]

Human rights group left the chat💀

[@vee-bee-a]

And the Geneva Suggestion has entered it..?

[@Thenoobestgirl]

They're too busy condemning Israel for protecting itself atm

[@Sir_Godz]

lets send the alphabet people there to celebrate their diversity and bravery

[@ahmadfrhan5265]

Human rights ? You mean white man up made laws ?

[@mazaluo]

Lol

[@D3K4RD206]

Thanks!

[@CaspianReport]

Thanks for the support!

[@imnackeredsirnackered948]

Afghanistan has 40 million people with a TFR or 5 children per family while Pakistan has 230 million with a TFR of 3.5 children per family. These nations populations are exploding and with many of it arid desert with unpredictable weather patterns and constant droughts these nations will ONLY get worse and worse. Afghanistan is predicted to double to 80 million by 2060 if their high birth rates continue to remain high.

[@SushmaVivek-xq4nv]

Historically borders were not that hard and people migrate lot...so human gradually escape from harder lands...even in India there are lot of Pathan origin people who originally belong to Pak Afghan side

[@YahmesAGI]

Hence the role of chinese intervention and the investment in the state. The Chinese see an opportunity the Afghans need it.

[@kolikari3813]

They can go push wheelchairs in japan 🇯🇵

[@saadsiddique750]

@@YahmesAGI And what opportunity did US see? The opportunity for war crimes and destruction 🤣

[@BaneTrogdor]

How 'bout they stop reproducing? Guess where all those people will immigrate to? Exactly

[@johnlock1605]

Taliban are Pashtun nationalist, there is no debating that. Ethnocentric nationalism has been rife in Afghanistan and the war since 1979 has made it much worse. People are killed because of their ethnicity. Taliban in late 90s engage in Hazara ethnic cleansing in Bamyan province. Religion plays a very important part in their politics.

[@maquacr7014]

Correct.

[@hbn747]

Religion and ethnicity is the ONLY reason of their killings

[@AustrianPainter14]

And you neocons demand Americans fix this somehow

[@ricardoxavier827]

And USA had the oportunity to split Afghanistan in small ethnical nations, to archieve peace by international borders law, without internal ethnical conflict oportunity. 1 ethnic 1 nation rule. The world cannot be only 200 nations. All the world must follow the Yugoslavia end.

[@ricardoxavier827]

In order to archieve social cultural dilution, they just archieve civil war, because we are predators and diferent ethnicks sharing the same nation, their natural warriors will always see on diferent ethnick an enemy to fight against, because their pleasure are to find enemies to fight against. The most peacefull nations of the world are not multi ethnical. 1 ethnick 1 nation rule. The world must divide in new more 800 smaller nations.

[@rezazazu]

As an Iranian I had little knowledge of all of these conflicts in this region. Thanks for the vidoe.

[@gvibration1]

Baluchistan, or Balochs in general, don't get any media coverage?

[@erfan3857]

​@@gvibration1The situation is bad but the guy is exaggerating in the video specially about Iran

[@kingp1n817]

​​@@gvibration1 They only cover who died where and who might be responsible for the attacks. No media outlet covers the entire story of conflicts in the region or their ethnic similarities. These countries are ruled by nationalists so they hate even pointing out ethnicity and would only rant about nationality

[@EsiSpy]

Overall Balochistan is a wild region and you will find armed men there But they are nowhere near powerful to make any problems such as a civil war. They use their weapon mostly in local arguments and fights not against the government.

[@Darkest_matter]

@EsiSpy they fight among themselves over small things, they are not unified... and even if they do find unity in their "ethnicity," why can't they extend that unity to the country they're a part of?

[@murtazarajabi8183]

Dude, in 1998, iran wanted to attack afghanistan mainly because their diplomats were killed in mazar i sharif by the taliban.

[@ricardoxavier827]

Herat was persia for long generations.

[@NaDa-jo7ic]

And mullah Omar's response to that was: only Herat is enough for them. Iran got scared and realized they were no match for the battle hardened tali's.

[@amazingamx1255]

@@ricardoxavier827 That was before Iranians became radical Shias. When Iran was sunni, we were all brothers

[@dwaynekeenum1916]

@@amazingamx1255they were already toppled in 90s

[@soroushshisheboran1462]

​@@amazingamx1255we were truly all brothers in one religion and language when sasanid empire ruled us all The language is farsi and the religion is Zoroastrianism Islam is the main enemy of all persian speakers for ever Arab invasion of iran destroyed every thing

[@Duskull666]

Can i ask you what maps program are you using? You have the most beautiful maps and animations!

[@Dango428]

I'm pretty sure these animations are custom made in premiere pro + aftereffects or some other equivalent editing software

[@rhs5683]

I aske the same once, but still dont know. My maps in QGIS are less fancy. 😥

[@JerronHonda]

so true!

[@theliato3809]

It’s definitely custom

[@bb6uk05]

CIA Resources

[@miguelcomas3157]

Pakistan wanted to keep Afghanistan unstable and weak, so it wouldn't slide towards india. Pakistan played itself

[@Banter-u3x]

😂😂😂 WTF you are talking about? Did USSR and USA invaded Afghanistan on request from Pakistan 😂😂.

[@proficience7748]

The fuck? 💀☠The U.S spent 3 trillion for their occupation of Afghanistan for Pakistan's sake? Okay, understood. 👍

[@gunner9936]

​@@Banter-u3x when usa invaded Afghanistan it was supported by Pakistan, so in way yes

[@Robespierre-lI]

Pakistan was not overly concerned with the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan. It supported the US invasion. So ... Draw the obvious conclusion. ​@@Banter-u3x

[@royzgaming441]

​@@gunner9936 Pakistan fought against USSR when it invaded Afghanistan

[@RajeshKumar-uj4qu]

You skipped the part why Baloch people are against Chinese.

[@Curious-v3g]

It would be interesting to know that 🧐

[@relaxingmusic8618]

They are not in majority so they can't possess a significant threat. All the most baloch want is peace and development in their province. Separatists are not even 5 percent of total baloch population in Pakistan. If army handle the baloch kindly and stop extrajudicial killings just on the bases of doubt then you wouldn't find more patriotic people than Balochs and pashtuns in whole pakistan. They are just angry with present establishment in Pakistan and are not against the country itself

[@calvinhoward3808]

@@relaxingmusic8618 potato potato

[@RajeshKumar-uj4qu]

@@relaxingmusic8618 When were they happy with the establishment? That area is most underdeveloped, devoid of basic human rights, culture being eroded and majority of Baloch never accepted Pakistan as their country.

[@relaxingmusic8618]

@@RajeshKumar-uj4qu no separatists are only a minority. Majority of them want the autonomy on their resources while living in the federation of Pakistan. I live here in Pakistan with the Balochs at the border of Balochistan and Punjab so I know the truth better than any foreigners.

[@TanyaLairdCivil]

Ah yes, the famous central Asian empire - Coruscant.

[@ontariofirs7347]

Khorasan, Chromasia, Qwarazazm.

[@LowTierWitcher]

@@ontariofirs7347it’s a joke

[@coolbuddydude1]

The empire strikes back 😂

[@Choppa-yc7gq]

If not petrol the whole place would be just another god forgotten place on earth

[@aayankhattak384]

Pakistan's other militant group is Pakistan's army , which open fired on its own citizens by rifles yesterday

[@hasnmir_11]

pashtun youthia

[@Ahmad-cj4ef]

pashtun youthia

[@SARIM.2010]

Calling him youthia because he told the truth?

[@asuin190]

Yes. This channel is Bias. Pakistan army is not good.

[@hasnmir_11]

@@SARIM.2010 mera lora truth tum loogo ki waja sa pak army aur pakistan ko jitna nuqsaan hoa ha and ho rha soch ha apki

[@lionkills1]

US built roads in Afghanistan, costing over 5.6 billion. In 2001 the literacy was 8% in 2021 it was 47%. KABUL in 2001 vs 2020 looks completely different. There are many good things that happened under US occupation. minus 200k deaths afghan deaths. i

[@dwaynekeenum1916]

Glaze

[@hasanjamalkhan689]

they exploited resources ofc they need local pets to host them to exploit more resources for years

[@sdfghjkl-ml1ih]

​@hasanjamalkhan689 which resource?

[@Humbleguy-n6q]

Fact, USA turned our country from a desert into a city.

[@Rockyrock511]

@@sdfghjkl-ml1ih lithium to be exact

[@theparanoidcritic5743]

Pakistan is an artificial state formed solely on religion, let's admit it. Balochistan and KPK are closer to Farsi and Afghan cultures while Punjab and Sindh have literally been parts of India. Both India and Sindh are named after the river Indus (Sindhu) while Punjab (Panch Naad or Pentapotamia) was the cradle of the Indic civilization before being Islamised by Arab and Turk conquests. Their shared heritage, language and cuisine stands to this day.

[@brobrobear470]

You are correct but I sense that you mean this is a problem. The Swiss and Belgians r also this way. The difference is that they found a way to exist like that and thrive, if Pakistan was a wealthy country then it would have no problems either. In Iraq Sunni Shia is a problem but in Saudi the Shias don’t rebel. Money is a major factor. A richer Pakistan would not face any so called existential crisis. Most people of Pakistan are more proud of their ethnicity than any sense of greater union or loyalty to the state. But very very few Pashtuns want secession, in the 5-10 percent points. Baloch do a greater extent but it is only like 20-30 maximum. More Scots want independence then Baloch do but in Balochistan there is an insurgency because it is poor while Scotland is rich and is therefore not in rebellion despite something like 48% wanting independence.

[@Protonium.]

Well pakistan was ways an ideological state

[@BinodiniMahapatra-pz7vv]

Pakistan has always been an artificial nation

[@mohdaamir5979]

I would say it's more of India's success rather than Pakistan's Failure. There has been unrest in several countries since 1947 but India hasn't seen any major Civil War, despite having 3rd Largest Muslim Population In the world. And while the current BJP govt and its supporters do not like this, the credit actually goes to the person who created the Indian Constitution and those who kept it being followed for several years, i, e, The INC. I am afraid if India had chosen to be a Hindu and non secular state, then even here, thier would have been many military factions here which over the years would have kept country's economic progress limited. A majority Hindu state eventually means opression of minorities. And sure, if the minority is small, you can control it by force. But as i said, India has 3rd largest Muslim Population.

[@Bilbil_Billa]

So is India an artificial state then by your logic

[@davidwell686]

The average person living in "Afghanistan" could care less who is in charge and just live day to day.

[@Johnny13Tube]

That is true of all people, everywhere. Politicians, warlords, and corporate tycoons pit nations and ethnicities against one another

[@MusabNaveed]

I've always asked the Afghans when they propose their expansionist ideas, why stop at KPK and Balochistan, why not Punjab, Sindh and Kashmir? This stems from Racial Supremacism rather than Muslim Unity.

[@kju-dja213]

If they would go for Punjab Sindhi then they will be in minority so it would be like afghanistan is merging in Pakistan so why they would want that ? And why you guys always crave for this unity where were you in Xinjiang where uyghers are massacred

[@deathadder4999]

Why would they want to merge with other people 😂. They want to unite people who are like them.

[@ayaankhan-eh1xy]

Afghanistan gdp is less than Peshawar city

[@terrainofthought]

The only thing Afghans can expand into are their oversized shalwars. They never were and will never be a match for Pakistan. So stop fantasizing on their behalf.

[@parvadhami980]

Thanks Jinnah for separating that part

[@terrainofthought]

Or else you would have massacred us too the way you have been doin to Indian Muslims. So yes, thank you Jinnah for separating us from the Hindian Kafirs.

[@donnyleeisfree]

I have to think it would be more effective, and less lethal, if the minesweeper walks in front of EVERYONE.

[@bletwort2920]

I like how you sometimes pronounce Balochistan as "Balokistan" and sometimes as "Baloshistan". Btw it's "Balochistan".

[@parvadhami980]

It's a shame that he himself is an Ethnic Iranian yet he pronounced it incorrectly

[@Rockyrock511]

@@parvadhami980 he is an ethnic iranian living in west. there is sky ground different between iranian in iran and in west.

[@ivancho5854]

​@@Rockyrock511 So he's a Persian. Christian refugees from the Islamic Republic of Iran normally call themselves Persian in the West to distance themselves from the theocratic regime, while they wait for it to collapse.

[@ivancho5854]

​@@Rockyrock511 Hang on. I just read that he is an Azerbaijani Turk. So where is he from FFS? This is messed up. 😂

[@prashanthb6521]

This is a pressure cooker situation developing.

[@suhrtInsights]

First rate analysis! Fantastic research and production of the video. Kudos!

[@CaspianReport]

Yay, thank you!

[@Solid_Snake1]

Watching CaspianReport is like watching a Hollywood Blockbuster every time! More importantly factual, unbiased and quality visuals. Well done guys, you are amazing! 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

[@aliahmadi8044]

Used to be.

[@terrainofthought]

more like a mockumentary.

[@andrewjackson8421]

Another great informational video. You break down all the intricacies so we can understand what's going on behind the scenes. Thank you for all the research you do to make your channel so awesome. This is true journalism. Non-biased, simply reporting the facts and letting your audience decide where they stand on the issue.

[@jaqenhghar764]

Its all even more concerning with Pakistan having the nukes and Iran having the ambition to have them one day.

[@ivancho5854]

Meh, the world can survive a small scale regional nuclear war in the region. Besides, the Saudis will probably buy some Pakistan nukes and I suspect that Trump will soon give the green light to Israel to stop Iran's ambitions. That will leave Pakistan with a few smallish nukes which it can never hope to successfully maintain because they don't have the budget. So some won't reliably detonate and only be dirty bombs. Some doom and gloomers predict that it would increase global warming or cause a nuclear winter (probably at the same time! 🤣😵‍💫😂), but we had two used against Japan and 528 atmospheric nuclear tests between 1945 and 1980 without the world ending - that's FIVE HUNDRED AND THIRTY in total. Like I said... MEH.

[@boxcat18]

@@ivancho5854I like how your sipping the delulu tea very confidently to make yourself feel better

[@fortheregm1249]

@@ivancho5854 "Meh" ??? those tests are the reason we have so many people with cancer these days. background radiation is much higher today than it was 100 years ago. each test will extract a heavy price for decades. at the moment the chances of us getting cancer in our lifetime is 45%. so its not "meh".

[@ivancho5854]

@@fortheregm1249 Yea, meh. If the region was destroyed the world would be more stable. Ok, let me address your two claims (if you're still with me 😁): 1. Background radiation levels today are higher than before nuclear weapons existed. I very much doubt that. Ok if you walk around a test site, yes, but where people live? Only enough to inconvenience quantum scientists. If it's higher show me. Prove it. I'd be delighted to hear the science. 2. Linking increased background radiation levels to cancer. This is actually really interesting science. I can't remember the details, but you can look it up. Jets fly high enough so that aircrew are exposed to significantly higher levels than the general population and airlines were concerned that this could result in higher levels of cancer. They were focused on liability btw. Interestingly after conducting an extensive survey of past and present aircrew it was found that they had lower levels of cancer than the general population. The study was terminated. About the same time a major insurance company in the USA decided to plot the incidence of cancer and their locations. This was the first time that this was ever done. They expected that cancer levels would be higher where people lived at higher altitude than lower, again due to higher background radiation levels. The results showed the exact opposite to what was expected. It has been speculated that there may be an optimum level of radiation which stimulates our immune system enough to fight cancer successfully. I don't know if you are aware that cells in our body become cancerous on a daily basis and are dealt with successfully by our immune system. Cancer should be thought of as an immune system failure. (Btw I have heard that cancer has never been observed in sharks!) So raised background radiation levels could be good for us. 🤣👍 Feel free to look everything I've discussed up yourself.

[@BiggieTrismegistus]

Iran has been "six months away from having a nuclear weapon" for the last 30 years.

[@jeffburkhart7572]

Your channel is one of the most insightful sources of geopolitical theory. I'm a huge fan.

[@Qara_Oghlo]

Iran is building its own border wall between Pakistan and Afghanistan and it will be completed in the next 2 years. Also, the southeast of Iran is safe and the population there is very low, 2 million people live there and only the border areas are a little bit dangerous, which is mostly from the Pakistani side of the insurgency and drug and fuel smugglers !! Iran has repeatedly warned Pakistan and even directly targeted their camp in Pakistani soil

[@Dheeraj-y4f]

all will speak chineese in future and adopting han culture. china is tremendously investing there followed by debt trap

[@Rzai1989]

Pakistan has literally captured an indian spy from that region who was living in Iran to carryout terror attacks inside pakistan. So no your country is not blameless.

[@Rockyrock511]

@@Dheeraj-y4f safe ladakh from chinese influence first lil bro. you guys dont have problem with speaking english , who c0l0nized you. mentally sl3ve

[@monarkjain613]

​​​@@Rockyrock511 calling others lil bro while writing a comment that reflects somebody with a mental age of 5😂 . Please grow up and educate yourself instead of worshipping pdfiles.

[@ore_red1684]

@@Dheeraj-y4fi rather speak Russian

[@unkownsiner]

lol Afghanistan had its own ethnic problems. For years the Pashtunist governments of Afghanistan had and still do refuse to do a national census since they themselves know that they are a minority amongst minorities. There is no majority even with the massacres and genocides of other ethnic groups and the forced evictions and colonisation the non-Pashtun lands they still feel they’re not enough. Thankfully the Pashtun king sold off its kin to the British and drew up the modern legitimate durran line. Which every pashtunist govrment now refuses. Funny because they look up to that very same king that sold 90% of its people to the British because he was the one that massacred many Hazaras, Uzbeks and Turkmens along with Tajiks. The bastard tried eliminating the most native languages of Persian and Turki(Uzbek and Turkmen languages) and enforcing Pashtun which back fired since many Pashtun that went towards the western, central and northern regions of the country end up adopting those languages instead of Pashto since Pashto was never a scientific, cultural, political, religious or military language. It was a language of people who lived in the mountains but with the passing of time they have come down from and with their heavy population increase they’ve managed to take up more lands. If the Taliban tries to divide Pakistan(which I think should crumble because they’re the ones who brought the Pashtunist Taliban because they though they’d have soft power over Afghanistan because of their 40mil Pashtun citizens) then the Pakistani government would in turn empower the other ethnic groups against the Taliban. If the Pashtuns feel they’ve been divided by the British thanks to their king abdur rahman then the Uzbeks feel divided from Uzbekistan, Turkmens from Turkmenistan and Tajiks from Tajikistans and Shia Hazaras from Shia Iran and even the Baluch from their Baluchi brethren in Pakistani Baluchistan which of course the Taliban does not recognise and plans on further colonising those regions with their Pakistani Pashtuns and it’s already started .

[@jahanzebnawaz261]

intersting. I think Balochs would not have any problem cosing up with pushtuns. Does afghan northern turkic minorities have the mettle to fight pushtuns. Afghan national army couldnot stand a week against them after US withdrawl

[@unkownsiner]

@ the issue is there are no willing sponsors. War cannot be fought on an empty stomach or without the right tools. Unfortunately the neighbours such as Iran have been busy with Isreal. Central Asia has no interest and prefer to cozy up with anyone in Kabul to prevent a refugee crisis which can lead to many conservative practicing Muslims from Afghanistan such as the Uzbeks, Tajiks, Hazaras, Turkmens, Kyrgyz from entering their fragile states. Only 1 country supports mainly Pashtuns due to soft power and control of pashtuns(so they thought) are the Pakistani state. Regarding the army collapsing is absolute BS as the army higher ups told the foot soldiers and lower ranking generals to not fight and they kept on giving territory to the Taliban. The higher ups mainly being Pashtun(same ethnic group of the Taliban including the coward president). Afghanistan and its soldiers were negotiated not on the battlefield but in Doha and Washington and Kabul(presidents office in secrete even the non Pashtuns in government had no idea) and Islamabad. Afghanistan on the eve of its collapse seemed to be going in a certain direction where everyone was unhappy with the president of the country for taking ethnic centric mentality towards everything. To the point of coming on national TV in an interview asking the interviewer why do we have majority Pashtuns and Pashto speakers in prison. Why is that? Because majority of them were part of the Taliban and they were all captured during his and his predecessors regimes which they both are Pashtun. But the racism and stupidity and ethnocentrism was so open and normal that they couldn’t see it logically. So Afghanistan was heading in to 3 scenario. 1. Federalism where all major ethnic groups would run and control their areas and would govern their own affairs from appointing their own police chiefs to their own governors etc instead of the police cheifs and governors being appointed from Kabul and they usually were Pashtuns which had no relations to the land and people and were corrupt because the locals couldn’t hold him to account. All major ethnic groups would be able to use their own language in their own regions and adopt their cultural practices. You would’ve probably had guney Turkistan, Hazaristan, Badakshan, Kandahar, Jalabad, Heart as the states. Only people to not benefit from this was the Pashtun. Since the many years of colonisation of the north, west and central regions they thought they would loose the key location of power they colonised and all of that could be undone. Bear in mind the colonisation had been happening since the 1800s. 2. 2-state solution where the majority no Pashtun would establish a new government let’s call it Khorasan and the Pashtunistan(Pashtun regions of Afghanistan) where the Taliban would given how they like with their pashtunwali and ethnocentrism. Again Pashtuns would be on the losing end since they’d lose over 50-60% of the country and many land border ie trade etc. This would be unacceptable for the Pashtuns as they mentally think Afghanistan belongs to them because the very name Afghanistan means land of Pashtuns/Awghans which the name was given by the British over 2-3 hundred years ago. When over 40mil Pashtuns live in Pakistan but the whole population of Afghanistan is about 30-40mil. Similar to Mongolia or Azerbaijan where more people of that ethnic group lives outside of its so called “nation state” but Afghanistan is more diverse then those countries. 3. Total civil was leading to mass killings, genocide, rape and torture. This is why it was easier to give the government to their cousins the Taliban as the Taliban would impose violent regime over the country. Which the coward president did to persevere Pashtun hegemony over the country of Afghanistan.

[@Rockyrock511]

@@jahanzebnawaz261 umm they do.

[@cs-mi8ur]

​@@jahanzebnawaz261they will hit and run just like taliban - they don't need to fight.

[@open-course-delta-lake-h3k]

Great and super informative video Shivan! I'm from Pakistan, and this was informative even to me.

[@terrainofthought]

try opening a book for information once in a while.

[@TR_1984]

Probably one of your best videos yet, keep up the good work

[@MAKMAUG]

i live in quetta,lived my entire life in balochistan and the amount of errors and over generalisation about pasthuns,durand line is downright folly

[@thedamnedatheist]

well then, now's your chance to set the record straight...

[@hemadkhoja3427]

Anecdotal experiences don’t tell the story, just because you live there doesn’t mean you know everything. This video is not about how the average person thinks, it’s about how the geopolitics works

[@MAKMAUG]

@@hemadkhoja3427 point still stands

[@mikeboshko2623]

@@MAKMAUG what point? We want to hear about it

[@dammaguy1286]

@@MAKMAUG so what is your point.

[@mikesellers1879]

Very insightful video on an area not covered much by the media...that is why your KZbin content is valuable...many thanks !

[@sammu]

Taliban didn’t “ban women from hearing each other” as that would be nonsensical and impossible to implement. They said women cannot pray out loud in public, which is a legitimate position within a particular school of jurisprudence in Islam.

[@dsend23]

Hey, woman. Don’t speak- it is illegal to hear you talk

[@sammu]

@ Do instead what the Christians do, wear mini skirts to church once a week?

[@Mady-lo6qb]

Explain the rationale. Which Quranic verse are they deriving this ruling from? Because the only one I can think of is the one that tells the wives of the prophet to stop talking softly to men as it might trigger lust. So if the women pray loudly and in a harsh tone of voice that should be within the rules of the Quran. Allah's ears might blister but then whose fault would that be?

[@sammu]

@@Mady-lo6qb Why would I explain nuanced Islamic jurisprudence to a kaafir? If you were Muslim then we could have a discussion and I could walk you through the rulings and evidences.

[@sammu]

@@dsend23 Uhhh cool?

[@bellumfallax]

"Those who cannot forget history are doomed to repeat it." ~ Santayana's equally pessimistic disciple.

[@LibertyandFreedom4]

Caspian, EXCELLENT video. This is briefing worthy and a testament too your skill, please keep up the good work.

[@QabilAGhor]

*A BETTER SOLUTION* would be to merge Pashtun areas of Afghanistan with Pakistan. As you said, there are three times more Pashtuns in Pakistan than in Afghanistan. Furthermore, ethnic groups in Afghanistan don't like to be dominated by Pashtuns, anyway. They would rather have their own country or merge with Tajikistan and other neighboring nations. So what I am proposing is the only solution.

[@abdullahnasir2882]

No thank you. Afghani refugees in Pakistan are already a pain, no one wants another 20 million of their kins with their backwards racist ideology and beliefs.

[@abdullahnasir2882]

But the division of Afghanistan along ethnic lines is a much better option. Balkh and Badkhshan go with Tajikistan, Uzbek and Turmen areas with their respective ethnostates while Herat goes back to Iran.

[@QabilAGhor]

@abdullahnasir2882 That's exactly what I was suggesting. It would actually be better for Afghan Pashtuns as well. Pashtuns would not only become the largest ethnic group in Pakistan, they would benefit from a more liberal environment in Pakistan. In other words, the Taliban would lose influence and power.

[@QabilAGhor]

@@abdullahnasir2882 Many years ago, I had a strange dream. In that dream I asked, "what would Pakistan look like after 1000 years?" I was shown a map in which Pakistan was much bigger, and it included Pashtun areas of Afghanistan and Baloch areas of Iran. And it was glowing glowing brightly. I couldn't remember if Kashmir was part of it and therefore I was disappointed. But few years later, I had another dream in which Kashmir was part of Pakistan but it was reddish-brown color. I interpreted that to mean that Kashmir too will become part of Pakistan but it would retain its autonomy.

[@ahcmnt6552]

😂😂😂 please try

[@willmannon9185]

Very informative, thanks

[@CaspianReport]

Glad it was helpful!

[@Argentarius11]

Another great video!!!! Well done.

[@lawjef]

On the bright side, at least these 3 nations don’t possess nuclear weapons. I mean, other than Pakistan. And almost certainly Iran in a short period of time. But other than that…

[@williamsharp2532]

Funny but serious. I like it, but I suspect a tiny country to their west wont let Iran get that far.

[@maquacr7014]

​@@williamsharp2532 Iran is piterally days away from becoming a nuclear state. And there is nothing that tiny state can do about it. (Tiny state extracts all its power from West).

[@meteorknight999]

​@@williamsharp2532Iran already has 1 Thats why US didnt invade yet do you think a middle east country can mess with US and get away ?

[@बामणराज-घ6च]

​@@meteorknight999depends on the usa leadership. Last time iran messed with usa usa destroyed half of the Iranian navy in just 72 hrs operation praying mantis

[@बामणराज-घ6च]

​@@maquacr7014from the last 5-6 years the iran is always a days away from getting nukes xd

[@eyeLikeCarrots]

09:25 see the idiot with the metal detector sweeping the ground just after two other guys walked over it......

[@MayankTrivedi2]

That was me 😢

[@Desmigalhation]

😂 there is no cure for stupid

[@iiiiviivneverivneveri6616]

he is looking for treasure ig

[@JJ-si4qh]

I've worked with foreign militaries like that. They are just "going through the motions". There is a huge competency gap Edit: On 2nd thought, they are probably doing training, and the 2 guys ahead of them were the tail end of another squad doing the same training. Still, they are too bunched up and would be casualties anyway. Still incompetent, but for a different reason

[@StreetDrilla]

Don't forget the idiot who doesn't realise he was even able to witness it because a camera is on the floor

[@ideas4682]

IF TWO NEIGHBORS ARE FIGHTING, IT MEANS THAT AN ENGLISHMAN VISITED ONE OF THEM YESTERDAY. OLD IRISH PROVERB.. As a Pashtune living here in Balochistan Ziarat Valley..I can say this Region is Middle East 2.0...Thank You @Caspianreport bro for Making such info content ❤🎉

[@intractablemaskvpmGy]

The notion that the "durand-line" was an arbitrary mark drawn on a map by a clueless Englishman is patently ridiculous. They created many borders with the full understanding of the divisions they would cause. It was by design

[@ivancho5854]

​@@intractablemaskvpmGy And that's why I'm proud of my forefathers. God save the King. 🫡🇬🇧

[@ivancho5854]

And how many Irish live and work in England? Gotta love how you lie to yourselves. 🤣

[@Ahmad-cj4ef]

exactly

[@littlerockforest2483]

Great job. I love to learn about history. I have subscribed.

[@g-gamer7363]

We pakistanis are living under military dictator ship there is no democracy or human rights

[@KyojuroRengoku98]

Then go live in India and Afghanistan ;)

[@bloggalot4718]

Even some Western countries are losing democracy and free speech with their politicians seeking total control of their population instead of serving their people.

[@AdityaRamachandranx]

@@KyojuroRengoku98You can keep him.

[@mamtasingh2703]

@@KyojuroRengoku98 no thanks

[@carlsimmons305]

I find your reports really interesting to listen too, thanks for creating the content.

[@FATHOLLYWOODB123]

America conquered Afghanistan in 3 months, and ruled it for 20 years, then voluntarily withdrew, if they stayed they would still be ruling it, it is conquerable

[@auraimmortal9600]

Soviets Cooked, British Cooked, USA Cooked, Graveyard of Empires 🇦🇫

[@simontaylor2143]

​@@auraimmortal9600 Mongols: "amateurs"

[@aadilsohail8549]

No one leaves conquered territory. No one. Especially not after you've dumped 3 trillion dollars into it. USA left Afghanistan with tail netween its legs. They didn't conquer it. They never conquered it.

[@Askeladd125]

​@@auraimmortal9600USA and Britain still exists and Is in better condition than Afghanistan 😂

[@ClipHolder-ke2ks]

Ideologically the usa lost, but militarily they won by a landslide and decided it wasnt worth spending trillions to help people who dont even want it. The us could have continued it's presence but it's more useful to spend that money elsewhere.​@@auraimmortal9600

[@dankhf7160]

I’m surprised no one has exploited this yet like the Saudi haven’t funded any side yet

[@MAKMAUG]

yet? the saudis were funding the taliban and pro taliban madrassas in pakistan before 9/11 and private donations continue to this day

[@exploreandlearn4808]

They have actually to counter iran

[@VTh-f5x]

Literally every group is funded by an outside power. US, China, India, Saudi, Qatar all fund multiple groups.

[@robocybo9616]

​@@VTh-f5xIndia? Hahaha those who need funds , can't fund shit to anyone

[@somalilandnew]

Talble with turn

[@padvinder8]

I have never heard of this conflict before. This is a very interesting and objective video. As always, thank you for this!

[@MyNewAge]

Welcome to the Islamic world

[@User_877]

Peshawar was always Indian, now Pakistani, but it’s India before Turkic invasion, but we still got it, even Kabul and ghandara is Indian but that was even way before Turkic invasions

[@Seerispure]

It was from Mauryan Empire to Kushan empire & Hindu shahi dynasty, so you are right it was ruled by ancient Indian but Persian Also have influence of Peshawar & Gandhar region

[@TheRealSith]

bro no one cares about india, stop going off topic ffs

[@afghanprology324]

Kabul isn't Indian and Peshwar isn't either so is Gandahara and the Indus Valley is in today's Pakistan. India only got its name from indus which they don't acquire.

[@captainkirkwood]

Best description of the iran 🇮🇷 Pakistan 🇵🇰 and Afghanistan 🇦🇫 history I've ever seen. Thanks so much. I look forward to more of your content.

[@traceyolsen308]

After watching this , saw another program called 'This border is completely pointless' about one of the really weird ones we have in Europe, where people cross borders multiple times a day, even in the same building, (in this case between Germany and Holland), hopefully the ones in this program will become as quaint and peaceful...and if the taxes are going towards the infrastructure of the area where they are paid, perhaps people can just imagine, or create virtually (?) whatever country they like, even if it never existed,... and providing they don't inflict it on anyone else , it can be as completely mad as they like.

[@thunderbear0]

No offensive but 2 ethnicities, Pashtun and Baloch. Both are Iranic origins are the main problem of all of this. Baloch came from Kurdistan to modern day Balochistan which is land of indic people. In 1887 Britian called it "Balochistan" While Pashtuns came on lands of Gandhara civilization from west of Hindukush range in Afghanistan. Now causing problems for everyone around them and claiming other people's lands.

[@najibullahghafori3739]

pashtuns came from northern Afghanistan, our historci land is Balkh and Badakhshan

[@olegnurmagomedov750]

Indian propaganda!!

[@Protonium.]

​@@najibullahghafori3739northern afghanistan does not have pashtuns

[@Dheeraj-y4f]

i think these migrations occur during muslim rule of india

[@thunderbear0]

@@Dheeraj-y4f yes. They came with Ghori and Gaznavi invaders. Who fought in their armies so sultans gave them Kabul and all of these lands to them.

[@MansoorKhaleeli]

Who is funding Caspian.

[@Harry-tm3ck]

Ya mom

[@Corey-vt8og]

100%

[@prakashtiwari8003]

Raa is saazish 😂😂

[@MateoMPM]

Ya mamá

[@TILENFABE]

He explains who is funding him in almost every video. But if you are implying that he is biased, I would mostly disagree, with very few exceptions. This channel is on a very professional level and very objective, at least compared to other content on yt. But of corse, as every human, he can be biased sometimes, I sometimes disagreed with some of his content in the past, but not to the point that I would see his channel as generally biased.

[@spidos1000]

Check out the guy @9:28 scanning the ground for mines when his mate has already walked over that area. 😂

[@shedactivist]

What a mess!

[@alih9325]

shoutout to the brits the pawns of Satan😂😂😂

[@TheXyxy2]

I didn't even know about this ongoing war between Iran-Pakistan-Afghanistan. Why the media doesn't talk about it?

[@gvibration1]

The Western left get nothing out of it.

[@sadliaq1590]

Not a war- just an underdeveloped region not controlled heavily by any government and ethnically dividing very similar people into modern nation states

[@Rockyrock511]

its not a war. only 2 skirmishes happen between iran and pakistan for the first time in history. the actual war is always happening between afghanistan and pakistan

[@meganhutchinson6435]

Your analysis is always well researched and insightful

[@d02v]

As an Indian, all I can say is 🍿

[@nethansamuel96]

It’ll disrupt our trade and create problems for us in that sea route

[@mamtasingh2703]

@@nethansamuel96 its already in problem as trump will again stop india from iran trade

[@ilFrancotti]

Sometimes, people reap what they sow.

[@giantspacemonstr]

that is just bs bro, from that reasoning, 9/11 can be said "PeOpLe ReAp Sow ThIngy", but that's just bs

[@Rockyrock511]

europe never reaped for its c0l0nialism. karma dosent exist buddy

[@lil__boi3027]

Taliban was founded by Pakistan, very much applies to this case​@@giantspacemonstr

[@pkumares]

Wonderful Analysis. Great work ❤

[@InsightGrid620]

ummah is in danger

[@ThePolymerisst]

Sounds like good news for the world

[@fawaaza.7743]

Hindu khatre mein hain lmaoo

[@rezazazu]

Ummah is the danger 😂

[@ISTP8w9]

No such thing as Ummah when they all do takfir of each other. Seems like everything is haram except another muslim's blood.

[@shadowgod1797]

your ummah lets jennifer lopez sing on the kaaba what a joke

[@ozhan10]

Everything in this video is exaggerated. All of these groups are very small and don't pose any actual threat to establishments they are just a bunch of guerilla fighters with no hope of actually achieving anything

[@maquacr7014]

TTP is dangerous. BLA can keep hurting Chinese interests.

[@butthebitebitbit]

maybe for now. i don't know why we should be confident it will stay that way

[@36736]

Ahmed shah abdali won third battle of panipat with few thousand men and British also captured entire subcontinent with numbers never exceding more than 100k

[@ozhan10]

@@36736 there was no jets tanks ballistics drones etc back then . Nowadays guerillas have no chance against modern armies .

[@ozhan10]

@@butthebitebitbit it has been the same for last couple hundreds years . Iran always has been regional power and stable enough militarily and Pakistan is nuclear power. Unless a country like US invades them like what happened to Iraq , anything else don't pose a threat!

[@Julio1jpg]

Amazing quality. Thank you for these videos.

[@Advaitamanta]

RAAAAAAAAAAA di sajish

[@ProudhonKropotkin]

Fun fact: The Turks are originally from Mongolia and Siberia. Now you know 🌈

[@jmdoza3938]

Chinese ancestry were thought to be the modern man.

[@SamarTareen]

Not Mongolia, no. Turkic tribes used to and still inhabit central Asia; modern day -stan countries of central Asia that became independent from the USSR. The Turkic migration westwards (and eventually settling in Anatolia) was, in part, due to the expansion of the Mongol empire under Genghis Khan

[@ThePolymerisst]

And most people who live in the so called Turkish country are just Muslim Greeks🤣

[@ProudhonKropotkin]

@@SamarTareen Wiki is the only site I found that doesn’t say they are Mongolian Siberian. I thought it was an undisputed fact. But, I googled Turk Mongolian DNA and one site says they are not related while another one says they are. I threw my hands up after that. I tried to figure out the Ashkenazi a couple years ago and ran into the same wall. I’m debating to take my original comment down or not, but I’ll keep it up for now. I still think it’s true-definitely disputed though. But thanks. I had no idea so many ethnicities in Central Asia are considered Turkish. I saw that the Uighur’s are Turkish as well. I had no idea.

[@captainnemo8072]

Some wealthy Omani Baluch are sympathetic to the independent Balochistan cause. Balochistan used to be controlled by Oman and was sold to the British.

[@deviouspirate1374]

Baloch are Kurd migrants, not natives.

[@NafeesBaloch-kt8vm]

You are native ​@@deviouspirate1374

[@captainnemo8072]

@@deviouspirate1374 The Brahvi people in Balochistan speak the Tamil language from southern India. Strange isn't it?

[@BrightStar-bz5oj]

Not Balochistan, only gwadar.

[@murradbaloch-lo9sd]

​@@deviouspirate1374dirty ass pusjabi baloch are natives you are ones who take Hindu and sikhs land using religion

[@shantanushekharsjunerft9783]

All lands to east of Indus belongs to India. All lands to the west of Indus belongs to Afghanistan or Iran. Pakistan should be somewhere in the middle 😂

[@jawadkhan3948]

That's like saying all lands to the West of Nile belongs to Libya, and all lands to the east of Nile belongs to Israel. Makes no sense. A river unites a nation/culture, not divide it. Also your country is not India just because you call it India. Real India is Sindh.

[@merciful1195]

Indus basin was never apart of India jeet cope

[@Rockyrock511]

jeet your decendents are from ganges river. for god sake stop claiming indus, harrapa and gandhara civillizations. only punjabis, gujratis and rajasthanis have some accountabillity to claim. 90% of your poulation is either dravadian or gangu

[@shantanushekharsjunerft9783]

@@Rockyrock511 you cannot claim anything. You are neither Punjabi nor Gujarati. You are squatters from Arab land who have come and occupied someone’s land. Sit on a camel and it will automatically take you back home

[@rubankumar2430]

​. What? Mujeets have some weird way of thinking.

[@MRjojojoseph]

Anyone know what song is playing at about 4:10?

[@sannagesh6376]

This is the best channel to gain knowledge in depth. Thank you.

[@Nick-Lab]

I thank the universe every day that I was not born in the Middle East, Eastern Europe, or China.

[@BrightStar-bz5oj]

That's not Middle East.

[@dammaguy1286]

lol you did not even mention the actual part of the world that this video was made about.

[@Research0digo]

you "thank the universe"? Is that who you're going to scream to when your car is upside-down and on fire?

[@Rockyrock511]

thats good but, balochistan region, afghanistan and pakistan dont come into middle east.

[@MidniteProphet]

@@Rockyrock511 They are connected to Iran and have you seen Balochistan it’s literally the Middle East how people dress and so on

[@AlfredoPuente8]

Afghanistan is about to end Pakistan whole career.

[@RehanPak1947]

Quite the opposite

[@shahidmahmoud2966]

Say it again 😂 like whatttttttt

[@zwartekobra]

Wouw interesting topics! Thank you for pointing out

[@aftekharyounas4841]

Pakistan army will respond accordingly when they do they will be no one to hear your cry

[@Rockyrock511]

whats the point. the nation has turned their backs on army. and army is responsible for it. they take all budget of pakistan to compete with india which has a 4 trillion dollars economy

[@zntshp5690]

By 1:20, I was already lost who's fighting with whom 2:33 Iran doesn't have a strict dress code, it just says no to clothes that shows public indecency (like bikini, backless etc. are considered as indecent). Even in Singapore, Malaysia you can't run around wearing bikini or no clothes at all. Only difference here is Iran will use force like moral police, while Malay will try to mitigate the situation peacefully as they see this as disgraceful act. You people talk about respecting other country's tradition, clothing, laws (the super open minded liberal view) and then proceed to implement your culture and logic on others. I get your point, that clothing should be a human choice. But well over half of Asia, Africa will consider this as western cultural aggression. Next time, before considering yourself unbiased or sponsoring ground news for more unbiased news, try to understand other people's POV a little.

[@mirozg]

"Only difference here is Iran will use force like moral police, while Malay will try to mitigate the situation" this is the only thing i think we cannot be liberal about. Everything else would be fine but policing people to dress like you want to diserves no understanding, especialy when the dress code is stricter than black tie event. You can think what you want about how other ppl dress, and you can dress how ever you think is propriate but leave others alone. It cant be the same as stealing.

[@nathanielcarreon5634]

What to do when your enemies are fighting each other, nothing.

[@kaneshkaTajik]

Unfortunately there was no real census in afghanistan by pashtun=afghan government, because they knew they're in minority so they stopped every census process. I can say that because the natives of khorasan/afg are tajiks=persians, they are over 40 or 45%.

[@BattingMyLashes]

Easy answer to all our problems: Afghanistan should become Khorasan and Pashtunistan. Or Pashtuns that feel sympathy with Pakistan and the Durrand Line can rejoin with Pakistan. I think this will be a good answer for everybody - people can choose what side they would like but Khorasan should not be ruled by the taliban. They should give Tajiks, Uzbeks, whoever else a chance to have a stable government.

[@afghanprology324]

Pashtuns aren't a minority in Afghanistan most likely and census didn't happen as the previous government failed to fulfilling their demographic statistics

[@afghanprology324]

​@@BattingMyLashes Splitting Afghanistan won't solve anything. Northern Afghanistan is diverse and Tajiks claim to be dominate Ethnic group in almost all northern provinces so therefore they won't migrate into Tajikistan side of North Afg leaving their homes for turkic in other places. Meanwhile if Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan had some of North Afghanistan Tajiks will just oppose them and consider their wanting form their own state. The Tajik idea of "Khorasan" is to separate North Afghanistan because of Persian nationalistic traits. Independent Pashtunistan will happen if Afghan Pashtuns and Pakistan Pashtuns of KPK agree to forming the state. And Pashtunistan alone will be powerful than the entire divided northern Afghanistan militarily and supposedly economically.

[@filipfenix]

stuck in teh 7th century.

[@amazingamx1255]

All of Khorasan used to be inhabited by Farsiwaans. Then The Turks and Mongols Genocided Khorsanis and settled the land under Genghis khan and Tamerlane. It was never Turkic land. It never had anything to do with Turks until Genghis Khans genocide

[@СимонаВаршава]

Azeri turkish propaganda😢

[@amazingamx1255]

@@СимонаВаршава Im Afghan not a Turd. Central asia is Afghan land

[@СимонаВаршава]

@@amazingamx1255 l am about chanel.

[@grimgoreironhide9985]

@@amazingamx1255So Kazakhstan is Afghan land too?

[@amazingamx1255]

@@grimgoreironhide9985 Southern Kazakhistan, yes

[@Helldiver211]

Really nice job with the pronounciation as a pakistani in canada i can confirm the pronounciation was right

[@mazharali8523]

While baloch would never accept afghanistan

[@amazingamx1255]

They would. Afghans are sunni Iranic people. Similar culture, languages and genetics

[@najibullahghafori3739]

@@amazingamx1255 most definitely

[@6ix9inetechashy]

True we baloch don't want to be part of Afghanistan ever.

[@amazingamx1255]

@@6ix9inetechashy Why not? Indians regardless of language want to be a part of India, Arabs are divided but desire to be united, western europeans are united in the EU, Why not western sunni Iranics unite?

[@sk-4464]

they would accept it over Pakistan anytime

[@mohamedali2858]

What are the effects of Western hegemony on Pakistan, Afghanistan, Iran, and the Middle East, and how are conflicts managed within these regions?

[@ivancho5854]

Haven't you heard the USA, and therefore the entire West, is sick and tired of policing the world and is going home? You're on your own. I expect that entire region to erupt into many wars for a couple of generations until it's utterly exhausted. There will likely also be large famines from unsustainable populations and pitiful local food production, while foreign aid from the West will be defunded when the new politicians realise that aid only feeds their enemies. Eg Yemen (btw the US are going to send them back to the stone age in 2 to 3 months, watch this space!) Merry Christmas 🎄 and good luck, you're really, really going to need it. 💀

[@Robespierre-lI]

How is anyone still talking about Western hegemony in 2025? Bizarre.

[@Robespierre-lI]

Western hegemony is a thing of the past. Why are you still focused on it?

[@sharadowasdr]

Caspian spoke about Balochistan and Pakistan for 16 straight minutes without mentioning India even once !

[@Robespierre-lI]

Unusual but smart. No one here really needs to hear about India every time Pakistan ïs mentioned. Eventually Pakistan will break apart. At that point, we will see what the Balochi and Punjabi people want with India. The Pashtuns will go their own way.

[@saadtariq1648]

80% Bullshit... 20% reality

[@SocialSavvyStrategies]

We in Pakistan are relatively safe without any conflicts affecting the majority of the population. Insurgency was not always constant in Pakistan but a way for political agendas to be fulfilled.

[@nicbahtin4774]

let them fight

[@giantspacemonstr]

as long as they don't crash planes into buildings or something

[@techtube8169]

bro you were spot on when you made this video. As i type this comment, Pakistan has launched airstrike iin afghanistan , and afghanistan has retaliated with a failed infiltration attempt, meanwhile Iran is engaged in petty skirmishes with afghanistan as taloban terrorist continue to terrorize pakistan and iran. Its like a wwe triple threat match. This is significant because Pakistan has tried for years, with patience, to win over afghanistan so it doesnt has to fight a war at two fronts considering the hostility with India. I tell you, this thing may feel like a storm in a cup at this moment but at any moment this can spread like wildfire.

[@CaspianReport]

You can't keep snakes in your backyard and expect them only to bite your neighbors.

[@hockeymanns9780]

@@CaspianReportI wish the USA never funded them to begin with. Lets begin with that shall we?💀🤡

[@UncleJoeLITE]

And I thought the Australian outback was bad! Thanks from Canberra 🇦🇺

[@Trag-zj2yo]

There are too many stupid people in this world

[@dr.python]

Pakistan is actually occupied by its own Punjab province, and they also treat Chinese citizens better than its own citizens

[@parthdeshmukh684]

Simply love the level of Animation used by Caspian Report

[@b_am]

Just to add more credibility to the case of Baloch nationalists, they, in fact, officially declared independence post-partition in 1947 in the name of the State of Kalat. Afterwards, they were forcefully invaded and occupied till this day by pakistan. Throughout the years, despite the land being a valuable asset for pakistan, from its strategic geographic position to soil full of natural riches, balochs have been subject to oppression, marginalisation, and other horrible things. Hence, sadly, baloch nationalists have taken to themselves the tough yet righful task of battiling for their rights. Many have taken peaceful approaches through politics and activism. however, unfortunately, some have taken the tougher route of ascending upto mountins away from their families and homes for the sake of protecting themselves and their loved ones in a battle that is endless in which all parties suffer except for the ones which are fuelling it, the west.