Catholic Unscripted 48 - 'Fiducia Supplicans V chastity;- anthropology & appetite.'

[@jefferyjambon4606]

it is so great to see Englishmen that are really Catholic!

[@debifox6555]

I gained much from this. My son is in a same-sex relationship, and he has literally said to me, "Maybe this is all there is for me." I've told him that he was made for so much more. This document from my church was a deep blow to me and to him. Shame on them all. Thank you. Just a note: There was a lot of background noise at points. It did become somewhat distracting.

[@oliverclark5604]

to debifox, A person in a valid union in blessing a couple in an invalid union invites in belief as belief meaning in uncertainty the keeping of the inseparability and qualitative equality of gift and need. This union exercises an absolute power of simultaneous authorisations of it ensuring its role and it insuring its identity. This invitation is to the gaining by the invalid union of validity as its need. The Declaration, Fiducia Supplicans (FS), 18 December 2023, approved by the consecrated celibate marriage consented to be joined in by Pope Francis in uncertainty of his belief in present moment real presence in his particular circumstances, out occults an occult, incest connected evil by applying Christ's teaching: "… if two of you agree on earth about anything they ask, it will be done for them by my Father in heaven” (RSV Mt 18:19). FS achieves this in allowing pastoral blessings of couples in irregular situations who both as together ask for this blessing demonstrating belief in conscience as meaning 'to see together'.

[@Hope20249]

I really enjoy listening to these episodes. God bless.

[@boomerreb4997]

This was truly a beautiful episode. God keep all three of you.

[@orarerosarium]

Not sure if this is the right video to post this comment, but I find Gavin’s analysis of Jungian theory & philos. to be of major importance. I could write a book on how it has been used to make people think there is no sin, no right or wrong. Thanks for illuminating this & other pitfalls of being Catholic/Christian in today’s world. We really need to be careful about what we “let in.” I hope we hear more from CU or Gavin about how psychology can put us down the wrong path. There is a famous Catholic Jungian analyst who has written many books. Many of us followed her, but years ago I was taken aback by this one quote. “There is very little right/wrong or good/bad in this world. There is, however, useful and not useful.” I’m thinking I have some cleaning of bookshelves to do. Speak, CU! Speak!

[@DrGAshenden]

Thanks Kate, in my middle period I became a convinced Jungian, though, partly because I believe he provided an antidote to the way, Freud had poisoned the well of religion. But I soon discovered the price for following Jung was much too high and entirely obscured, the issue of good and evil in the world. With some difficulty, I repented and returned to orthodox Christianity, a sadder man, but far wiser. We need to do what we can to free Jesus and the faith from the the Jungian perverse lens.

[@Antonia_D]

Jung was an occultist. As you intuited, we should stay far away from him.

[@JonathanRedden-wh6un]

I am a Protestant, believing in justification by faith etc. Catherine’s talk about trust when we are struggling seems to agree with that.I do appreciate your videos and experience a sense of fellowship listening to your ideas and dialogue. May you be strengthened in your ministries and service. Blessings from South Yorkshire.

[@Mark3ABE]

I am a Catholic and I also belief in “justification by faith, etc”. After all, we both use the same Bible (and, with the Church in England and Wales soon to replace the Jerusalem Bible with the English Standard Version, probably also the same translation). So, inevitably, we have no choice but to believe the same thing, in so far as it is clearly set out in the Sacred Scriptures. Of course, there is a slight divergence. The Council of Trent, while restating, of course, the doctrine of justification by faith, did discern a difference between the Protestant teaching, which appeared to say that we could attain saving faith by our own unaided efforts, while the Church of course, teaches that faith itself is a gift of God so that salvation is entirely by grace and our own saving faith is only part of that grace.

[@JonathanRedden-wh6un]

We too believe that faith is a gift from God according to His sovereign will.Thank you for your comment.@@Mark3ABE

[@newtexan1]

Protestants are not Christian’s. Only Catholics are Christians.

[@alison4547-o8t]

Thank you,edifying and food for the road,looking forward to the next roadside stall.

[@LarryGi]

Great conversation, unfortunately it was somewhat hindered by the distracting background noises.

[@michaellong9526]

I will respond to Catherine’s statement that not enough people speak out on the struggles with difficulties with sexual appetites. I will now add my voice to those declaring for Christs Grace and its necessity in overcoming this scourage in our society. I was lost, far from God and the Church, absolutely ensnaredwith sexual appetites and unable to resist it or even wanting to. I remember one time thanking God that I lived in such a progressive free thinking society that I could witness the most intimate of sexual acts by the most beautiful of women I could imagine. When my whole life unraveled from this enslavement I hit rock bottom and in absolute terror of what I was experiencing called out literally to God to save me. And I mean literally instantly I experienced a miraculous intervention I still am in wonder at, and my obsessions were gone and like a magnet was drawn back to God, to daily mass, daily reading the bible, chaste life. None of this is by my power, I am incapable of this transformation. I worked in the mental health field professionally for 30 years and am aware of all the bio psychosocial theories and the psychological understandings of the psyche. Our modern Church is relying very heavily on this “science” to deal with this sexual disorder in our society. Probably because of issues in the past where the Church spoke in areas outside her role and hard science proved her wrong to her great distress and embarrassment. Now the Bishops defer to science, but unfortunately there is no “ hard science” truth for this issue. Currently it is all soft science sociology or mostly theoretical psychological understandings that the German bishops are citing. God draws good from evil, I believe the utter depravity of this time is bringing many people to the brink of despair, My message is that I was a man of the world following its ways ,learned in its philosophy and I could not contend with the powers and principalities ruling our society. I was a slave thinking I was free and being slowly reduced to nothing and spiritual desolation. All it took was from this place of desolation where nothing else had meaning did I finally turn to God and ask him to save me, and his response was instant and overwhelming in its effect. I am greatful in my formative years my mother was diligent in her Catholic faith and gave me an awareness that I had somewhere to turn. My concern is for those in these spiritually void days with no belief in God that they will not have the where with all to know to ask God for his saving Grace, And this of course is the only unforgivable sin , to not ask God for forgiveness. We must ask, we must ask! The supernatural reality of our faith and of a invisible God, a spirit made accessible to us by Jesus Christ made visible to us in his incarnation and cleaving to our humanity to allow us access to the Father, angels and demons, personify the powers and principalities we struggle with, They are real things at a spiritual level of reality. Intellectual pride and fear of being laughed at as foolish medieval peons is the reason for our hierarchies fall from supernatural faith, the shame for the teachings of our Lord. I was firmly in that camp and that way of life chastised me finally and opened my eyes to the reality of Gods truth though it be seen as foolish to men. As Jesus so often said, repent , turn to me for my yoke is light. The solution to the world’s calamities ,a convergence of catastrophes coming upon us now more easily seen, is spiritual, with a turning back to God. It is not in the power or philosophies of men. All glory and honor to God the father through our Lord Jesus Christ accompanied by the Holy Spirit and our blessed mother Mary.

[@oliverclark5604]

to Michael Long, on 10 June 2021 Pope Francis spoke of a "worldwide catastrophe". In context it appears he was referring to: "the great majority of sacramental marriages are invalid" (Pope Francis, 16/6/16). A person in a valid union in blessing a couple in an invalid union invites in belief as belief meaning in uncertainty the keeping of the inseparability and qualitative equality of gift and need. This union exercises an absolute power of simultaneous authorisations of it ensuring its role and it insuring its identity. This invitation is to the gaining by the invalid union of validity as its need. The Declaration, Fiducia Supplicans (FS), 18 December 2023, approved by the consecrated celibate marriage consented to be joined in by Pope Francis in uncertainty of his belief in present moment real presence in his particular circumstances, out occults an occult, incest connected evil by applying Christ's teaching: "… if two of you agree on earth about anything they ask, it will be done for them by my Father in heaven” (RSV Mt 18:19). FS achieves this in allowing pastoral blessings of couples in irregular situations who both as together ask for this blessing demonstrating belief in conscience as meaning 'to see together'.

[@jmichaelortiz]

Fabulous. Thank you!

[@Corolla97ww]

Great conversation. Some good insights.

[@bluelake28]

Wonderful conversation, thank you.

[@ichthus1890]

It would be most appreciated by me and many others I'm sure, if you would again take up the theme of Christ's continuing to suffer on the cross, that Gavin mentioned near the end. This is elusive to philosophical understanding, to arrive at through deduction. Perhaps an elucidation of the Sacred Heart of Jesus, mentioned by Gavin, along with practical examples for dull minds stunted by presumption. Thanks again to all three for a needed and helpful counterpoint to cascading apostasy in a world ginning up, it seems, for another go at world war.

[@stevensonrf]

Really, like the new intro😀👍

[@jaysonphilander6661]

It sounds like those pushing this document want God without Suffering. An integral part of Christianity is embracing one suffering as Christ did on the Cross

[@orarerosarium]

Yes! And, in a way, your comment reminds me of what Gavin said w John Anderson. People want utopia, but they don’t want to have to go through God to get it. These comments are very helpful to me. They make so much sense. “We” think we can make heaven on earth-that we can do it all without God.

[@marietheresa1709]

Very good! Thank u!

[@AnneEloiseOfCNY]

Thanks so very much. Your ending was marvelous! ✝️🛐💟

[@tumbletoes909]

Thanks guys. The last five seconds was brilliant! 😂

[@chrisjones-rd8it]

good one thanks doc!

[@josephmaxwell5033]

Self justification rules today. Instead of the natural order, in the commandments of God and the demand to holiness, we just now have self approved lust in the belief that it’s love.

[@Judithleaver]

Thank you 🙏 👏 The noise in the background was very distracting though. Someone washing dishes ??😂

[@DrGAshenden]

One of the three of us is surrounded by a loving family, who occasionally make their presence felt - As we can’t always record in privacy

[@marinka424]

Perhaps each person has a microphone which could be turned off if they’re not speaking for any length of time and if they know that they have noise in their background. Some people genuinely struggle to concentrate when there is distracting noise. It can interrupt your train of thought and be quite jarring.If technology (a mic turned off) can eliminate the noise, then that would be the all round considerate thing to do, and wouldn’t harm anyone.

[@nondeblah]

Bang! Sharing the sufferings of Christ. Can there be a greater intimacy?

[@johnf2023]

Fantastic insights! As an aside, I've never had Calvados before. Does anyone know Dr. G's preference?

[@patrickfahey6722]

Well I am listening to this episode after the revelation of Fernandez book about Christianity and sexual gratification became known. As we know Fernandez is also the author of blessing SS couples. The man and his boss should not be clergy.

[@oliverclark5604]

to Patrick Fahey, A person in a valid union in blessing a couple in an invalid union invites in belief as belief meaning in uncertainty the keeping of the inseparability and qualitative equality of gift and need. This union exercises an absolute power of simultaneous authorisations of it ensuring its role and it insuring its identity. This invitation is to the gaining by the invalid union of validity as its need. The Declaration, Fiducia Supplicans (FS), 18 December 2023, approved by the consecrated celibate marriage consented to be joined in by Pope Francis in uncertainty of his belief in present moment real presence in his particular circumstances, out occults an occult, incest connected evil by applying Christ's teaching: "… if two of you agree on earth about anything they ask, it will be done for them by my Father in heaven” (RSV Mt 18:19). FS achieves this in allowing pastoral blessings of couples in irregular situations who both as together ask for this blessing demonstrating belief in conscience as meaning 'to see together'.

[@TP-om8of]

This is a repeat, with a slightly differ title. But it’s worth watching again, for the last 5 seconds alone.

[@DrGAshenden]

It’s not a repeat - it’s the latest episode on a separate channel to offer a wider viewing opportunity. The title after CU 48 is jazzed up a bit it’s true. Perhaps that’s not an improvement.

[@DrGAshenden]

But thank you for the kind remarks.

[@sandraelder1101]

@@DrGAshenden I appreciate that you put the number and topic(s) in the title.

[@sandraelder1101]

If you try to stand on both sides of the fence, you end up splitting your pants and looking a fool. Better to stand on the right side and reach across to help others over. The Church has been brilliant at that before, expressing doctrine in new ways without compromising the Truth.

[@sandiemarian304]

Words can not express my thank you to you all. Apologies for the grammar. God is great, my thoughts with the same-sex blessing are to stand on the authority of the holy Bible. However, what has been highlighted to me is some knowledge about the Catholic church. I now believe that I can have conversations with my Catholic friends about their religion. I also know more about the church of England than I did before. For me, God has turned all this around and as a born-again Christian, I will keep on praying for the lost, my family and friends. Gavin mentioned we need to play the game and how true. Jesus said we must be wise. Another discussion was the bones of Adam at the feet of Christ, that was a lovely image to have in my heart. These are testing times for us/everyone. The God I know wants everyone on earth to hear the good gospel news the truth and be saved. Ref: Matthew 10:16, “Behold, I send you forth as sheep in the midst of wolves: be ye therefore wise as serpents, and harmless as doves.” King James Version (KJV)

[@MezzMcGillicuddy1]

Love it, the last 5 seconds was amazing! 😂

[@helenleach8491]

A complete and immediate change is possible if Jesus is turned to

[@gerardk51]

When people rush to defend Fiducia Supplicans (not here Deo Gratias) 2 words come to mind: 1. pretzels 2. hoops

[@denisjackson8310]

I have been a follower of Erik Varden for a while and so greatly appreciated Katherine’s reading of his excellent book on chastity . Needless to say I enjoyed the discussion but I do wonder if you are in some ways misunderstanding FS . Surely it will be an encouraging grace for many gay Christians to read it and gain an insight into possible transformation . It isn’t just a static blessing of gayness per se . It’s subtle because it is meant to be the beginning of an inner journey . Gavin seems convinced that it’s a blessing with no questions asked ! Surely some SSA people who may be struggling will find in this church teaching a means of grace towards healing and inner transformation . Yes all what you say , together with Varden ,is a great teaching but please be aware that there is a hidden and subtle pastoral aspect to it all . How will the sincere Christian homosexual find help in this document ? It’s beauty is in its caring pastoral message , not it’s dogma .

[@oliverclark5604]

To Denis Jackson, Yes, caring pastoral message. A person in a valid union in blessing a couple in an invalid union invites in belief as belief meaning in uncertainty the keeping of the inseparability and qualitative equality of gift and need. This union exercises an absolute power of simultaneous authorisations of it ensuring its role and it insuring its identity. This invitation is to the gaining by the invalid union of validity as its need. The Declaration, Fiducia Supplicans (FS), 18 December 2023, approved by the consecrated celibate marriage consented to be joined in by Pope Francis in uncertainty of his belief in present moment real presence in his particular ,circumstances, out occults an occult, incest connected evil by applying Christ's teaching: "… if two of you agree on earth about anything they ask, it will be done for them by my Father in heaven” (RSV Mt 18:19). FS achieves this in allowing pastoral blessings of couples in irregular situations who both as together ask for this blessing demonstrating belief in conscience as meaning 'to see together'. (I know of a Denis Jackson through my contact as a son of Colin Clark with B.A. Santamaria in Australia). Oliver Clark, [e-mail]

[@sandraelder1101]

44:28 But sexual acts within marriage aren’t always fruitful in terms of procreation. That doesn’t mean they aren’t meaningful. They bear other fruit such as bonding. One problem is that we look to things of this life, such as food, sex, friendships, entertainments to fulfill longings that can only be satisfied by eternal life with God. We are perpetually surprised & disappointed to find that earth isn’t Heaven.

[@josephmaxwell5033]

He’s a knight rather than a Bishop!

[@Mark3ABE]

Gavin was about to say “Queen” but checked himself just in time!

[@arthurlong9756]

I am not sure if you no but there is a lot of background noise.

[@jesusruiz4017]

Please comment on the prayer of Jesus at the Last Supper to the Father

[@VivFrost-iy9qr]

Fantastic and helpful episode, but please can you pronounce the Latin correctly? Fay-du-chee-ah Sue-plee-cans. Sorry to criticise, meaning this in a friendly way.

[@stevedoetsch]

Thanks for pro-none-sea-A-shun! 😅

[@jamesarmes3098]

Do you mean Fiducia Leprechaun?

[@sandraelder1101]

Is it soo if there are two p’s? I thought suh. Never mind. I looked it up. U is always oo.

[@giuliakhawaja7929]

It’s a dead language. The Catholic Church has its own way of pronouncing Latin.

[@sandraelder1101]

@@giuliakhawaja7929 It does have pronunciation rules though, so there is a right and wrong way to say words. Classical Latin & Church Latin do have some differences, such as the g always being hard in Classical Latin but gn is “ny” in Church Latin, as in Agnus Dei.

[@jamesarmes3098]

What's with all the background noise, such a distraction.

[@sandraelder1101]

Family sounds. 😊

[@oliverclark5604]

A valid union in blessing a couple in an invalid union invites in belief as gift/need exercising an absolute power of simultaneous authorisations of it ensuring its role gift and it insuring its identity need. This invitation is of the gaining by the invalid union of validity as its need. The Declaration, Fiducia Supplicans (FS), 18 December 2023, approved by the consecrated celibate marriage consented to be joined in by Pope Francis in uncertainty of his belief in present moment real presence in his particular circumstances, out occults an occult, incest connected evil by applying Christ's teaching: "… if two of you agree on earth about anything they ask, it will be done for them by my Father in heaven” (RSV Mt 18:19), in allowing pastoral blessings of couples in irregular situations who both ask for this blessing demonstrating belief in conscience as meaning 'to see together'.

[@MacKenziePoet]

The first sign of a false religion is sexualization, as opposed to sanctification.

[@afifahhamilton8843]

You people might be a suitable trio to present a recent 'realisation' I have had (..maybe). That is that the word 'media' is very similar to the word 'Medea'. As you will know Medea was the lover then wife of Jason (of Argonaut fame) who, when he thought that ditching her and marrying the wife of a king nearby, Medea slaughtered all their children, and Jason was unable to have children with the next wife (can't recall why at this moment, but it's not necessary for my point). But the name 'Medea' means (apparently) 'schemer' and 'planner'. I suggest that the media is the planner and schemer of societies beliefs and apprehensions and will result in the murder of what should have been the children of fathers who were poorly advised. The media/medea ultimately cuts off its nose to spite its face. We, all of us, will be the victims, i.e. this includes those in the media (all of them/us). Time to ditch the whole lot of them? That includes you three! I'm open to hearing comments or thoughts on this.

[@tomthx5804]

Headline: "Filthy Fernandez Fumbles Fiducia Fiasco"

[@eoggblaine9725]

Three steps to hell towards the left, and one step back! Blasphemous, heresy is example enough. Any narrative which even describes this wickedness is unnecessary. When Jesus responded to Satan St. Luke chapter 4: 8 It is written: thou shalt adore the Lord thy God, and Him only shalt thou serve. Those 10 commandments which have been removed, from every town, city, and heart, profoundly state number 6. Thou Shalt not commit adultery. And some say yes but that is the Old Testament law. Jesus stated St. Matthew 5:17-18 Do not think that I am come to destroy the law, or the prophets. I am not come to destroy, but to fulfill. 18- For amen I say unto you, till heaven and earth pass, one jot, or one tittle shall not pass of the law, till all be fulfilled. Also St Matthew 7:21- 23 21 Not every one that saith to me, Lord, Lord, shall enter into the kingdom of heaven: but he that doth the will of my Father who is in heaven, he shall enter into the kingdom of heaven. 22 Many will say to me in that day: Lord, Lord, have not we prophesied in thy name, and cast out devils in thy name, and done many miracles in thy name? 23 And then will I profess unto them, I never knew you: depart from me, you that work iniquity.

[@helenleach8491]

Is someone making a cup of tea in the background?

[@theomimesis]

The DDF should withdraw the document Fiducia Supplicans. As a Byzantine Catholic I could no more assent to Fiducia Supplicans than I could to the Henotikon of Zeno, the Ekthesis of Heraclius, or the Typos of Constans, because - like all of those earlier documents - it (i.e., Fiducia Supplicans) fails to teach the truth about man's relationship with God. No one can bless sin.

[@dwpjoyce]

Don't worry, as a Roman Catholic, I can't submit to it either. Not that I have to, it is not magisterial teaching anyway, nor can it be.

[@davidmatthews3286]

Thanks for your lovely and lively conversation. However, I do get concerned when you keep talking about salvation leading to transformation and that helping us ‘get to heaven’. Surely, God’s big plan is that he will ultimately come to live with his people on a renewed earth (Revelation 21) rather than us joining God in some extra-terrestrial situation that you call ‘heaven’. Could you explain your thinking here?

[@gowoke_gobroke]

Since Rome is dying, perhaps the Papacy will move to Africa.

[@sandraelder1101]

Then we’d have to have another Catherine of Sienna to chase him back to Rome. Now, wouldn’t an African Pope be awesome?! 👍🏼👍🏼

[@pavelrazamazov2672]

Or Eastern Europe.

[@tomthx5804]

Next week: The group takes turns reading inspiring vignettes from Victor Fernandez new book "My Grace Filled Life as a Porn Star"

[@theien5929]

I am enraged over this, and ashamed of our prelates.

[@yj7598]

Sorry, isn't that the biography or auto biography of a certain Mr Voris?🙂

[@benmoi3390]

we are breath of living soul casted into an animal skin... the urges are from the beast I would say within but it'S trully around us as it's the envellop that we are in... God first commandment was "multiply" as he said to the beasts aswell... but he addedd for man... Dominate the beast... what fly in heaven with wings and the dragon of the depth of the sea/abyss that commandment is positive commandment of not submiting/worshiping animals/angels/demons idols... to not be dominated by that beastial nature that you are growing from... that's temporary... and we are called to be saved by the blood of Jesus... because the in the blood is the life/soul of the beast... and it's only by dying and being reborn by the Blood of God, Jesus his word made into flesh... that we can be free from the darkness of death... he is the prophete like moses sent to free us from the slavery of the our bestial nature... the call to chastity is a radical but yet effective and great one for those who are struggling, as for alcoolic to stop drinking is better to never drink again.... but the demonisation of sex thru the church as been too much... marriage is the original covenant of the creation... and the original sin isn'T to have sex... but the answer that Adam gave to God... instead of asking for mercy and admiting his sin, and asking for mercy for his wife that every husband is responsible of her sins as Jesus take the sins of his church... instead... he said... "it's the wife that YOU gave me" the original sin is a divorce, a breaking of the intimate Covenant of the reunion of the male and female into one being in the image of God... AND even worst Blaming God for our sins... that's exactly the sin of the LGBTQ who are openly stating that they are that way from birth... otherwise... it's because God made them that way... they reject any responsability on God...and yet call their Community the Pride community... pride being an overestimation of your own self inherent worth and ACCOMPLISHMENT... To submit the beast to the will of God and not the other way around is the path to life... To be aroused like a dog by a female/male passing by... that's to be submitted to the skin of beast that we are trapped in... To be aroused by your wife/husband commitment to God and to consecrate yourself to your family is the way of life. now to tame a beast and dominate it doesn't meant to shackle it in your basement, and starve it to death... some's beast are dogs or horses, easy to tame and get to obey... other are feral and wild and rebelious and very hard to tame... even if masturbation is a fall and bad it's still the less worst than a complet fall into darkness... as long as the struggle is their to not get confused by what love is as long as one understand that sex is a beast urge that need to be regulated like the need to eat and poop... we get to life without restrain on those needs and learn to tame those... sexual urges arise way later in life and yet we are so strict to those who fail instead of having a positive and pedagogical teaching and perspective of work and progress much like kids pooping in their pants... we give too much importance to the beast and sacrifice the children to it with condamnationinstead for their lack of self control... when it's of all the sexual perversion the less worst... as it's jsut a personal struggle with our own selve... to teach to avoid porno as it will just feed the urge and not be helping.... to encourage to just try to hold longer and longer like for baby pooping their diapers instead of having some fall into compleat perversion and reject the church altogether because of the severity of it's condamnation... that's the only charitable way to address that issue. To do it alot by yourself is still better than doing is with someone else out of marriage or worst against their consent...

[@edh.9584]

I can't tell if you're talking about Pope Francis or about the Biden administration.

[@joekey8464]

Stop this, no saints ever disobeyed the pope and the church.. No saint ever disobeyed the pope, even Mary in her many apparitions obeyed the church and instructed her visionaries to obey their priest and bishops. They are examples of extreme holiness, virtue and obedience to Christ and His church.. Padre Pio suffered persecution from the church, but obeyed his bishop.

[@Mark3ABE]

It is not quite a case of “disobeying” the Pope, since none of the three is, in fact, a Priest having a Pastoral ministry in the Church. As such, they do not (fortunately) need to decide whether or not to “obey” or “disobey” the Pope. As to expressing an opinion other than that held by the Pope - we have, of course, the example of St. Catherine of Sienna, who admonished the Pope, openly and without any apology, for residing in luxury at the expense of the King of France at Avignon (and therefore controlled by the King in matters of policy) rather than taking up the reigns of Government in person within his own territories. She expressed her strong disagreement with his policy and, in the end, he did agree that she was right and that he was wrong and he did return to Rome and took up the Government of the States of the Church in person and no longer submitted, in policy matters, to the King of France. This gave him the independence which he needed not only in political matters, but also in doctrinal matters. Then again, St. Athanasius was instructed by Pope Liberius to keep silent on the Arian heresy. He exiled him four times to try to get him out of the way. St. Athanasius paid no attention to the Pope, because he considered that there Pope was wrong, which, in the event, the Council of Nicaea found him to be. So, the history of the Church does teach us that a Pope can err and that he is subject to correction, even by a lay person and even by a lay woman!

[@oliverclark5604]

@@Mark3ABE A person in a valid union in blessing a couple in an invalid union invites in belief as belief meaning in uncertainty the keeping of the inseparability and qualitative equality of gift and need. This union exercises an absolute power of simultaneous authorisations of it ensuring its role and it insuring its identity. This invitation is to the gaining by the invalid union of validity as its need. The Declaration, Fiducia Supplicans (FS), 18 December 2023, approved by the consecrated celibate marriage consented to be joined in by Pope Francis in uncertainty of his belief in present moment real presence in his particular circumstances, out occults an occult, incest connected evil by applying Christ's teaching: "… if two of you agree on earth about anything they ask, it will be done for them by my Father in heaven” (RSV Mt 18:19). FS achieves this in allowing pastoral blessings of couples in irregular situations who both as together ask for this blessing demonstrating belief in conscience as meaning 'to see together'.

[@anthonyhulse1248]

As intelligent theologians, maybe do some critical thinking about your response and urge to publish videos that cause confusion and concern among the laity. If everyone had kept their traps shut and had reflected on FS with some religious docility, in line with previous church teaching, including Pope Francis’s recent statement to the German bishops denying the possibility of same sex marriage, in a hermeneutic of continuity in other words, there wouldn’t be this mess. You and other talking heads on KZbin are the cause of the problem. But no, you like the attention. Morally, it’s grave matter.

[@Mar--Mar]

The morally grave matter is to lead the faithful into sin because they are unsuspecting and docile, and trust high clerics. Jesus has strong words for those who scandalize the little ones. And right now the little ones are very scandalised. It is not for nothing that Jesus tells us to beware of wolves in sheep's clothing and St Paul warns us that Satan can appear as an Angel of Light.

[@ichthus1890]

I don't see any hermeneutic of continuity in Cardinal Fernandez defense of FS when he said "We're blessing the relationship, not the union" , when FS includes no caveat to tell them to stop 'uniting'. Because if there were, there wouldn't have been a purpose for FS in the first place. FS is a clear break from Tradition, hence the backlash. This will be overturned in the end. And the end may not be too far away.

[@oliverclark5604]

@@ichthus1890 A person in a valid union in blessing a couple in an invalid union invites in belief as belief meaning in uncertainty the keeping of the inseparability and qualitative equality of gift and need. This union exercises an absolute power of simultaneous authorisations of it ensuring its role and it insuring its identity. This invitation is to the gaining by the invalid union of validity as its need. The Declaration, Fiducia Supplicans (FS), 18 December 2023, approved by the consecrated celibate marriage consented to be joined in by Pope Francis in uncertainty of his belief in present moment real presence in his particular circumstances, out occults an occult, incest connected evil by applying Christ's teaching: "… if two of you agree on earth about anything they ask, it will be done for them by my Father in heaven” (RSV Mt 18:19). FS achieves this in allowing pastoral blessings of couples in irregular situations who both as together ask for this blessing demonstrating belief in conscience as meaning 'to see together'.

[@louisewilkinson766]

Love you show it’s AWESOME 💕 However, The man drinking his wine on the show is NOT A GOOD LOOK ? IF HE WANTS TOO HE COULD PUT IT IN A COFFE CUP & BE A LITTLE BIT MORE DISCREET AS ITS A WELL KNOW THING THAT CATHOLICS LOVE THEIR ALCOHOL ; AND THERE IS A LOT OF ALCOHOLICS. IN THE WORLD TODAY & I just feel it would be a lot nicer if he Didn’t Drink his wine on the Show as it gives NON - CATHOLICS AND CATHOLICS THE WRONG MESSAGE ; I THINK HE CAN LEAVE IT AND HAVE IT AFTER THE SHOW ( UNLESS HE HAS A PROBLEM ???? 🤣🤣🤣) ONLY JOKING ALRIGHT VERY IMPRESSED WITH THE VARIETY OF SUBJECTS YOU ALL DISCUSS ; BEAUTIFUL PEOPLE THANK YOU ALL ! 💕😇🙏✝️💪🗝💯🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺

[@DrGAshenden]

Hello Louise, thakn you for your kind remarks. I'm not sure which of us was drinking wine, but I don't think the incidence of alcoholism is greater among Catholics than any other group. But there is a case to be made than Catholics know how to celebrate God's gifts of creation and are able to do so particularly because Catholicism is so mature and helpful about the balance between self-denial and celebration, between feast and fast. We would like to be able to model the new humanity that Christ is leading us into and not be afraid or hide, since we are accountable to him for everything. None of the the three of us are alcoholics, or addicts of any other kind, and we ar every grateful to be able to bring the celebratory aspects of our humanity into the field of intellectual and philosophical discipleship ina controlled and responsible way. No Catholic should be afraid of wine since the first miracle at Cana. We should be afraid however of the tempter who is always trying to lure us into excess. Wine is not the problem; our self control is the issue at stake I think. But thank you for your generous concern that no one should be lead astray or un-helped. Bless you.

[@organicpaul]

Yes something going on.