Watch NYPD update on investigation into Brooklyn subway shooting

Police say a 36-year-old man was shot with his own gun after getting into an argument with another rider during rush hour in Downtown Brooklyn.

[@graymatters2]

The black woman who recorded the whole incident is the real hero. The incident could have easily been misconstrued

[@legaciesnubia424]

Period!!!

[@Exposingyou]

White man who invented the camera is a hero for creating it so she can use it.

[@proppamusic6210]

Real shyt

[@Joe-hz7fs]

LOL...Easily been misconstrued? There were over a dozen people recording the whole incident too...if the woman wasn't black you wouldn't have typed your comment...LOL...you're desperate for recognition...

[@williamhenry9705]

graymatters2 used a poor choice of words. Rather than type misconstrued should have wrote "been lied on like they lied on Darren Wilson." @@Joe-hz7fs

[@AO-po8kc]

No amount of technology can help a decaying culture.

[@daintyminnie9270]

tik tok can help

[@superawesomeminecaft]

no amount of tech can help a multicultural*** culture

[@kylemose8874]

Exactly. Most intelligent comment 💯 💥 🙏

[@dakotaxu4792]

So true!! Let me tell you something. I have lived in NYC for all my life and NOTHING has changed with the Usual Suspects from that Segment of Society we all are aware of. Their kids grow up the same as the parents. They don’t want to work, they rob people, they hate every other culture and are violent even towards their own people! It’s crazy how they go out of their way to make their own people bad. Obviously not all of them are bad. But the overwhelming majority of the younger generation is EXACTLY the same as the previous generation. I can literally walk home at 3 in the morning and if 10 Chinese individuals are walking towards me I could care less. But if it’s even ONE of THEM….. 99% I’m getting assaulted and robbed. You can’t change them. They have to do it in their own community by first addressing the issues and focusing on the younger generation.

[@superawesomeminecaft]

no amount of technology can help a multicultural* culture

[@danworth3669]

The police seem more concerned about the MTA's well being than the people who use it.

[@TG-fr8gb]

@danworth3669 The MTA is like yeah you got shot because you cheated us out of $2.80. Warning this is what happens when you jump the turnstile. 😂

[@joy2theworld488]

​​@@TG-fr8gb😂😂😂 I noticed they keep talking about the fair That has been the Main topic🤔

[@bidhrohi12]

Why is the police at fault? How about the black community being indoctrinated into thinking crime is okay? That's from these leftist activists. All this reparations talk and entitlement mentality.

[@Christian900]

You don’t get it

[@TheChariot99]

Um DUHHH! That's why they just stand by the turnstyle! THey don't give a sh*t about you. They give a sh*t about your money!

[@Sasquatch424]

The Subway system has turned into a crimeway system Whats going on down there

[@bleachknight90]

Not enforcing law and order. That is what. Matter of fact, they don't do that in the city as a whole. Because they don't want to spend the money on it and would rather put that money to garbage projects and lining pockets that sound nice to hear but ultimately do nothing for the city.

[@susanschutz260]

maga repubs is what happened & not seeing trump for the traitor he is.

[@noelt5257]

This press conference was a joke

[@LawandGossip]

💯

[@GerogeChan]

It was a money grab I bett you the nypd and jiano lieber were searching for 3 bucks in the subway they've all got plenty of money q way less stress waste of tax payer money they're all pigs

[@Vauxiinyourbag84]

ARE YOU JOKING?? YOU’RE TALKING ABOUT fare evaders?!

[@kylemose8874]

ikr wtf.

[@matelunddunlap2770]

Non fare paying customers account for nearly all violent crime in the subway.

[@odalisgonzalez6875]

They have lost their minds

[@user-mz4sl5rp5k]

part of the propaganda...

[@83Sladeone]

Right straight up ridiculous Smdh

[@A3Kr0n]

"They never pay the fare". It's amazing how this press conference devolved.

[@user-xg3uy6hq9g]

they are saying the violent mentally ill people are riding on the subway without paying. simplistic BUT in this case the man with the gun had entered without paying

[@nicolesanders8002]

Exactly 💯💯💯💯

[@victorssignsdesignsandmore3722]

Did the girl who stabbed him paid her fare? Maybe she did that is why her stabbing the guy is a non mention....because she Paid her fare.

[@adamblack6867]

She worked for the MTA and she stabbed him for not paying his fare

[@rman1302]

Smh there you are human that's right she provoke him to pull weapons out after stabbing him in the back it was men fighting no weapons right or wrong

[@deanmartin2332]

😂

[@jayc5756]

​@@rman1302Exactly

[@Raulski78]

The fare has nothing to do with the crime ,stop justifying the fact that the police are incompetent

[@juniortaveras3559]

Not a police issue, it’s a population problem.

[@peeweedee1Comedy]

Key Stone Cops ..This city and Department is Broken 😔

[@inconvenientexistenlism]

The subtle seemingly negligible things say a lot about a person's character and integrity.

[@tonye.5410]

Yes it does. It's called broken windows policing. If you evade fare, you have a character flaw. Easier for you to cheat and steal from law abiding citizens

[@Boricua-ni4nb]

✔️👌👍👍

[@superawesomeminecaft]

the black cop talking didnt even explain that the female stabbed the dude who was shot multiple times

@superawesomeminecaft yes because he was pummeling her bf. Watch the video. He was still being aggressive afterwards as well. I mean come on. He started it by assuming he was a migrant.

[@BigEightiesNewWave]

Because they call a white cop a white cop. They also call perps, like bad drivers, an old white guy. Seen MANY videos on here where the LE does this.@@chinablack9790

[@alexvidal6147]

Yes she stab the black man that had the spanish man pin down beating him, and before that he was yelling racial 0slurs at the hispanic couple

[@danhdo8233]

Still under investigation so they don't spill much

[@Grr8jon]

We investigate better than the cops. Just by viewing the footage.

[@superawesomeminecaft]

what additional information did they even talk about. In fact they told us less than we already know lol

[@yvonneb3074]

I heard him upset because he's blaming the migrants for beating up cops

[@mitchcarter442]

No mention of the stabbing by the female? Why there's missing info

[@solraczevehc3761]

She was defending her partner. I wish I had a woman like that.

[@jayc5756]

Exactly. SMH 🤦‍♂️

[@jayc5756]

​@@solraczevehc3761 No she wasn't. And they say that they wasn't even together, so that makes it worst. If she didn't stab him...maybe the whole shooting incident wouldn't even happen in the 1st place. SMH 🤦‍♂️

[@solraczevehc3761]

@@jayc5756 I still see it the same way. If I was getting attacked I wish someone would step in.

[@jayc5756]

@@solraczevehc3761 No, it was a 1 on 1 fight. 1 guy got the better of the other. It should've been over. He said it was...until he realize that he has been stabbed. That's when dude felt the need to take out his gun. It is what it is.

[@NYCHIPHOPNEWS]

It's unsafe even if the rest of the people got home !!! Now there's 100's traumatized from that experience, subway is filled with crazy and dangerous people!!!

[@domainmailbox3850]

Did you see all the children in the car?! They are now traumatized.

[@320ceman]

Looks like if the woman would have shut her mouth and stopped provoking the situation ,the confrontation would have ended with hands

[@20Manny]

Show me one time that the police stop the crime before it happens on the train. They usually stay in the entry and exit that’s it they not walking around

[@robertsontirado4478]

The city or government dwarfs hundreds of threats each day, those are not reported because why would they tell us.

[@rman1302]

Thats not what happened she stabbed him in the back then he draws a weapon

[@daintyminnie9270]

this is a pay your fare PSA...

[@shawnikat4127]

I don't care about the fare evasion right now. The weapon in and on the subway train is what you should be talking about. 🤔

[@alexvidal6147]

This is alot of BS

[@fendijae4376]

The Look Of Betrayal When She Stabbed 🔪 Him In The Back Was Heartbreaking 💔😢

[@user-dp7kn6ot6e]

Very disturbing she definitely escalated the situation

[@rman1302]

Exactly why does that count for nothing? She jook him in his back first

Watch the whole video!!!! She stabbed him when the guy was pummeling the other guy. Plz. Probably related or that’s her bf. The aggressor was the guy who was shot.

[@sherrybarner7285]

They were together for sure that’s why she kept saying I didn’t do nothing send those aliens back they shouldn’t be here anyway

@@sherrybarner7285 yeah right 🤡 always the same usual suspects. Self defense!!!

[@tyronejenkins5296]

Did he die

[@inconvenientexistenlism]

@@tyronejenkins5296Pray he does.

[@tyronejenkins5296]

@@inconvenientexistenlism thanks

[@jaredjones9332]

Did the stabbing girl pay her fare? What does that have to do with anything? And what is the protocol after being stabbed? Im not defending the aggressor but i have more questions than answers from this and really did not expect fare evasion to be the theme. However, it is enlightening to see you guys show us where the priorities are.

[@susani.-partyonwithyarnandcroc]

The system is getting worse. My neice was assaulted on a bus last year and to this day the 104th still has no report on file. The police were called, ems and the bus was taken out of service. An eye witnessed stayed and gave all the info. My niece went to hospital. Two days later she went to the 104th and they have no report on file. She went to bus depot and they too say no report on file. How disgusting is this!!!

[@richardhill9931]

This guy is a joke 😂😂😂😂

[@juancarlostorres8250]

Well , the guy and the lady who were being harrasted and attacked , they acted on self-defense. They should not be prosecuted .

[@Frescothadon1089]

Self defense to what? They both using bare hands no weapons the boyfriend was getting pieced up but that doesn’t allow u to use a lethal weapon in self defense do I think the girl did the right thing to a extent she held her boyfriend down but that also led to the guy pulling out a gun

@@Frescothadon1089 plz child. He was pummeling her boyfriend. She did what any girlfriend would do. If she hasn’t done anything he probably pound him to death. Self defense! He started the whole incident period.

[@user-qc1lu1wi9b]

​@@Frescothadon1089you have to use a weapon when the attacker is heavier.... a light weight cannot out boxed a heavy weight

[@Frescothadon1089]

@@user-qc1lu1wi9b that’s cap if u got hands size ain’t shit it might take more hits but a big dude can get dropped quick the thing is I respect shorty for holding her man down but she should of used her hands or Maybe try pulling dude off to deescalate the situation her pulling out a weapon and poking dude was the reason guy went reaching for His weapon

[@LordTacotheGreat]

@@Frescothadon1089 lmao big dude drew a knife first, you can see it. he was slashing at the smaller dude when the girl stabbed him

[@ytc3182]

their names are 34 years and 36 years old. god forbid if they say the attacker's name is jamal jackson and what their races are

[@arielgomez637]

is this a joke ?? what does the fare have to do with any thing ?? if he wouldve paid the fare the same thing woulda happened

[@jayc5756]

Exactly. These ppl are jokes. SMH 🤦‍♂️

[@SIKE01]

took his own weapon and used it against him. embarrassing 😅

[@donnharlem9604]

Did you see that?

[@jayvee5911]

So if they pay the fare theyre good to shoot?

[@jonathanalonso6492]

it wasn't implied that it was _okay_ to shoot if you pay the fare, just that those who do pay the fare are also the ones that are rule followers/not maniacs that shoot random people in a subway over petty arguments.

[@legaciesnubia424]

Exactly 😂😂 they are so full of it

[@noelt5257]

😂

[@Christian900]

Of course it is not Think before you type

[@Christian900]

Of course it is not think before you type

[@helenacooke7061]

Who gives a shit about the fare. The fact is if you get killed on trains no one is going to say " wow, he didnt pay his fare".

[@juanblanco4702]

A person got killed and this fool is talking about paying the fare. WTF 🤬 What about the girl who stabbed the man and made him pull out the gun? That question is for Chief Stupido.

[@zackschneider-dl1mu]

Why is this not labeled as a hate crime? Man defending himself from someone who was being openly racist towards him. Where the "hate" outrage crowd?

[@donnharlem9604]

cap

[@solraczevehc3761]

Exactly

[@Floridavid576]

This press conference was atrocious!

[@nfn4]

We are supposed to get to our destination safely. So why would we discuss that?

[@leekvision2673]

What the fuck are they even talking about?!?! Theft of services had NOTHING to do with that incident. This man has mentioned theft of services over 10 times, and very few cops give empathy to impoverished riders. There are more ppl who pay their fares and carry weapons on the subway than there are fare beaters with weapons. The MTA is steadily increasing fares, and the services are steadily diminishing. Homelessness, beggars, filth, and everything else associated with that piece of shit need to be addressed. There were 2 subway shootings and a bus shooting yesterday, so based on their logic, all of those were fare beaters smh.

[@user-md8of9yj1d]

So you can charge the guy who got shot with fare evasion and attempted murder and just being goofy and I heard the female 🐑 stabbed him wow talk about getting your negativity thrown down your neck

[@austinpowers1999]

THE PURGE HAS BEGUN

[@pukavoket]

Use an old technology: "Concealed Weapons" with permits to qualifying citizen not just Police!

[@HellonRIKERSISLAND]

Factssss

[@pukavoket]

@@HellonRIKERSISLAND You don't qualify, you stayed at the Rikers Island Hotel! :)

[@rlin2648]

Clearly self defense from the video.

[@Lobsterman5481]

100%

[@solraczevehc3761]

Yup

[@leannadamond662]

He fare has nothing to do with what happened on the train. The woman stabbed him and then he pulled his gun

[@eyestoenvy]

Piss poor leadership all around NYC & NYS

[@shirleesantiago8529]

Obviously people dont understand that fare evasion is a crime.. so basixally they are showing that he was not even supoosed to be on the train at all.

[@reactionary]

Fare evasion had no relation to the shooting. Paying a fare does not prevent people from shooting.

[@shirleesantiago8529]

@@reactionary is that what tf I said. Lol are you even from Brooklyn

[@user-hz7kv6js6l]

Instead of making exceptions for allowing "some" people to break the law to ride the transit without paying, why not offer discount tickets to students, seniors, and those people who are on assistants. NY has stupid laws.

[@yelitzacollado8214]

The men conducting this press conference might’ve not conveyed themselves properly Because everyone in the comments seem to be missing the point. They’re saying fair evaders are one way they get tipped off when someone has bad intentions, or a record. Because those type of people never pay!

[@talesfromthehoodtv503]

What happened to the girl that stabbed the guy ? She should face charges for attempted murder

[@ninacarranza5189]

She was defending her boyfriend

[@talesfromthehoodtv503]

@@ninacarranza5189 from a ass whooping? If he loses he loses,it was a fair fight until she pulled out a knife

[@KysaSiovan]

@@talesfromthehoodtv503 He should have kept his hands to himself and would not have gotten stabbed AND shot.

[@talesfromthehoodtv503]

@@KysaSiovan no,homie should have taken that ass whooping without his girlfriend stepping in, that's some clown shit

[@SparkleInYourEyes2024]

​@@KysaSiovanThe boyfriend threw the first punch

[@jcny08]

I have an idea for you to place the same kind of baggage scanner gates that they use in the airports to scan people's bags to get through the train styles in NYC subways.

[@elviramckoy-dc7yd]

I said the same thinh

[@domarq]

Unfortunately, this subway station was previously famous for Michael Jackson's "BAD (1987)" music video; directed by Martin Scorsese.

[@YTMANHERE]

1980s NYC is BACK BABY !!!

[@idkGBT]

The prices aren’t 💀

[@YTMANHERE]

@@idkGBT😂😂😂

[@8rr725]

@user-yf3ws7xs1f That was the 70s, which was worse lol

[@saneepeopleonly]

How did paying fare become the focal point of a violent crime? Millions of people getting to their destination safely is the a consolation?

[@reactionary]

What I learned from this press conference: NY subway fare is $2.90 cents.

[@charicewilliams5758]

What about that she stabbed him I didn’t hear them mention that he only pulled his gun out after being stabbed

[@iamafrican3821]

THE FARE?? WHHHT?!

[@JackRainfield]

I want people to pay their fare too but is this the crux of this matter?

[@flibble89]

We don’t have a race problem in this country, we have a problem race.

[@levshneider]

Agree. In an overwhelming number of cases, the aggressor is black, rarely, Latino, and seldom, Caucasian or Oriental.

[@user-dh6zq2ko8g]

These black cops got to go..smh.. stupid people in every race

[@idkGBT]

@@levshneideroriental? Just say Asian

[@donnharlem9604]

Yes build the wall and free trips back too europe .Problem solved

[@levshneider]

@@idkGBT right

[@benle9867]

i like how he speak without reading ; straight from the heart

[@khalfanikeme]

Look its simple. He didn't pay so hes not backed by the mta insurance lawsuit wise. Ok regardless what the migrant did the black guy extremely picked the fight. Ok they both could get charged for fighting that's probation. She stabbed in self defense to protect her boyfriend she wouldn't have stabbed him for nothing. Which could be self defense with a good lawyer what probation maybe a light sentence. She didn't keep stabbing. Ok the black guy pulls 99% a illegal gun. He didn't shoot for getting stabbed probably cause he knows he started the fight. The guy takes his gun shoots in self defense. Its about how much these people who paid gets charged in self defense from somebody who didn't pay.

[@billygreen9301]

Not a peep about the guy in critical condition with a gunshot to the face. Let’s just focus on the massive $$ NYC loses when someone hops a turnstile to board a subway that’s going from pt A to pt B regardless if someone doesn’t pay. Or let’s act flabbergasted that more people aren’t focusing on how many people arrived where they needed to go. What?? Or maybe just focus on the fact that cops there actually moved toward the gunshots. Yeah bc that’s not their jobs right? To stop crime!!!!???

[@Unclelukes]

Allow me to be the only logical one here in the comment section. The "Arab" man who wrestled the gun away and shot the crazy lunatic with his own gun is the ONLY innocent person here and WILL NOT be charged. He's in the clear. What he did was SELF DEFENSE. NOW the WOMAN with the knife 🔪 who jumped in and stabbed the lunatic in the back while he was fighting the "Arab" should and probably WILL be charged with a crime because not only did she escalate the situation and caused a fist fight to become a DANGEROUS Gun fight by stabbing someone in the BACK with a KNIFE putting everyone in jeopardy, she also BROKE THE LAW. 1) It is ILLEGAL to bring a Knife or any dangerous weapon into the subway system. 2) She unprovokely assaulted someone with a deady weapon. 3) She FLED the crime scene that "SHE INVOLVED HERSELF IN" She knew she'd get locked up and charged, that's why she fled the scene. The aggressor had what was coming to him as far as karma, but the LAW is the LAW. And she broke the LAW. Which is why the NYPD is looking for her. Now, as for the guy who got shot with his own gun, IF HE SURVIVES, he will be charged and locked away in prison with injuries that will leave him scared for LIFE.

[@JosephNine]

THE COP'S & NATIONAL GUARD SHOULD DO AN INVESTIGATION ON WHAT WENT WRONG !!!!

[@user-dp7kn6ot6e]

It was the female passenger's knife she got it from her handbag/purse 👜 then stabbed him to the back with it 3 times until he was aware of what she was doing only then she stopped

[@Dasnapbackhut]

So where were you’ll to stop him hopping his fare you’ll showing us you’ll not doing you’ll job

[@jonny6170]

Imagine being upstairs in the police station hearing gunshots

[@grolsch1547]

He did not pay his fare 😅😅😅 black jesters

[@Narrow-Pather]

Don't find false comfort because they share your skin tone. People from all walks of life have lost it. *Be aware... and Beware* 🍃🙏🏾 Stay Prayed Up. 🙏🏾🍃

[@kalikush6286]

He was stabbed during a one on one fight

[@Jerseyan]

He didn't look mentally ill to me! spitting out racism against that Middle Eastern man with all the hatred he has against Latinos. no one is talking about the racist comments he made toward the man!

[@helpvictims]

Where the signs at every entrance of the train, that says "gun free zone" no weapons allowed.

[@StacyAdams-bl7kj]

WHY? They talking about fairs like thats going to stop crimes, unbeliveable.

[@daveddj]

This is the most ridiculous press conference EVER. Hopping the turnstile more important than violent crime. Unbelievable.

[@Vauxiinyourbag84]

RIGHT LIKE WHAT THE FUCK? I COULDN’T BELIEVE IT.

[@chuckdeezy_313]

Not paying a $5 fare is not indicative of violent intent.

[@kasmirah9056]

The police hold the doors open for the Passengers to walk right in ..

[@83Sladeone]

Not paying the fare has zero to do with the situation! Smh

[@bpmforever]

Why is the emergency exit open like that? 🤔

[@shirleesantiago8529]

People need to go back to their own hometowns and leave NYERS TF ALONE. Notice only REAL NYERS did anything... Just stay outta BK

[@haveagoodday1041]

He was stabbed in the back first!

[@Raining345]

lol everyone in the comment section saying this is “the worst they’ve seen the subway”. This still doesn’t hold a candle to the shit that was happening in the 80s. The police are plenty competent, it’s the people that are dumb.

[@justcallmeebonee]

They are not telling us something because this press conference doesn’t make any sense. Maybe the couple have some type of immunity. 🤷‍♀️

[@aaronpalmer6364]

Using discretion means that they’re only going to arrest able bodied men from 18-80. Everyone else can still skip the fare.

[@jayc5756]

It wasnt that simple bruh. What type of Simple Captain yall got here? Wheres the lady that stabbed him? Hmm 🤔 She Definitely needs to be locked up...especially if shes not his girlfriend. These 🤡 talking and seem more upset about the dude not paying his fare, than what happened. SMDH 🤦‍♂️

[@legaciesnubia424]

OH PLEASEEEEEE the fare has nothing to do with the matter at hand. I seen tourists students working ppl invade the fare. What a ploy to distract from the issue

[@invalidsin5665]

They don't mind you filming other folks, but when it comes to them being filmed...

[@HuskyType]

Man enters subway with a gun, meanwhile MTA still wants their money 😂

[@jasonharrison1674]

If only the new York lottery offered a guess that suspects scratch off game 😅

[@Woktoharlem]

Sadly this is a perfect example of the current state of NYC. Commuters constantly in danger, people getting killed, fares continue to Hike while police presence continues to diminish and all they can talk about is Fare Evasion??? This is absolutely disgusting and disgraceful

[@proppamusic6210]

*I know people who is far from gangsta and dont pay fare*

[@makavelizu2922]

A Fair Evasion Conference. SMH.

[@briangambreli2667]

Paying the fair is more important than life? Let’s get our priorities right people. Oh man

[@BigEightiesNewWave]

Dr. Paul Kersey would take care of business.

[@bigtex970]

What are they talking about? Not paying your fare these guys need to be working at Walmart not NYPD

[@michaelanzelino5068]

This cop is talking about the importance on how the NYPD is keeping the quality of life and catching fare beaters. But in reality has failed to uphold neither of these. WTF is he talking about? And that was in the first one minute and fifteen seconds of his speech. I had just about enough. Don't need to hear the rest.

[@John-lk1pm]

Boy oh boy are we being misled.... If you're going to revamp start with Pennsylvania avenue.... Total shutdown of the subway keep everyone street level

[@4CornersGlow]

So the NYPD wants citizens to put themselves in harms way to record gun fights? Utter incompetency.

[@AbbyEllie69]

It’s just your perception that crime is running rampant in NYC… major cities, including New York, are NOT safe.

[@Boricua-ni4nb]

They are doing N0THING!

[@user-sv2pk4ib8u]

Something unexpectedly is going on with the people of New York right . People what’s the heck

[@phoenixglobalcap.a100trans7]

The fare had nothing to do with what happened, people with weapons pay for fares too. Also, yes people made it home safe but that doesn’t mean they weren’t traumatized. The bullshit. Say what’s real not fluff

[@greencoffee8224]

THE CITY NEEDS TO DO BETTER!!

[@dannysautorepair]

They should install metal detectors on the subway system, this is out of control.

[@Kristle12-7]

All he seemed concerned about was not paying the fare