Celeste Is Generous, Technical, And Full Of Fruit

[@seventhpeasant]

I would watch the heck out of a full-length SMB3 video!

[@RT55J]

Seconding this.

[@SimonPotticary73]

Thirded!

[@coltonjohnson9739]

Me too!

[@logosvisuals]

one day on Action Button

[@HayleyWinter]

Watch an SMB3 video? Very very yes!

[@adamkuenning708]

Love Tim's stuff - wish it got more views

[@Skellingtor97]

I would also like to watch a feature-length doc review of SMB3

[@luckywilshire4291]

I have just discovered you Tim Rogers, but please know that I love you. Thank you for every word you've uttered.

[@rinvee]

shout-out for the feature length documentary of super mario bros 3

[@dirty_chanterelle]

i really enjoy how the game reminds me of umihara kawase in terms of aesthetic design, which is probably the best possible choice for a room-to-room puzzle action game

[@todddeitsch5779]

i would watch that.... i would watch that every day on your birthday then make a video of me watching that 27 years later

[@goji5887]

This is one of the funniest reviews I have ever seen haha, also, Celeste looks like an amazing game

[@wesleycostacesario3953]

Please do the full-length SMB3 video!

[@DreamInSongs]

Yes. I would watch the SMB3 review

[@iamalittleboat]

Celeste is so much fun :') please get to work on that feature length smb3 video asap

[@jgodden8022]

It only clicked for me whilst watching this that Tim is the same guy that made Video Ball! That was one of the funniest GDC talks I've seen.

[@Doomlaser]

documentary length smb3 review plz.

[@tylerttinsley]

I would watch a feature length review of Mario bros 3.

[@TomNook4200]

I would watch the smb3 doc

[@Snacko0]

I'd love that SMB3 review.

[@thebowlingguyatgoogle2517]

you are absolutely wonderful, thank you for brightening my day with your videos, i died at the hungry question.

[@glvanwijk]

Yeah, I’d watch that documentary.

[@alessiomadethat]

I, too, am here to say: I would partake of a feature-length docu-review of Super Mario Bros. 3 by one Tim Rogers, professional video game expert. Thank you.

[@ColorVortex]

Please do the SMB3 video, with GrandPooBear! :D

[@kylevanwagn3r]

I want to see a feature length documentary style review of Tim's reviews.

[@tabithadavies3277]

It's a literal crime that I've never seen this video before

[@WikiNikipedia]

I rewatch this video about once a month despite having played the game just for the joy of your commentary and watching Madeline jump.

[@fyompufyomp7480]

I really really want to watch that Mario 3 video

[@dayf722]

I love Tim's appreciation of games and the language he chooses to describe that appreciation. It is like delicious gamefruit in my ears. And yes, I would watch a feature-length Mario 3 video. Please. It's all I want now.

[@Action_Sloth]

I really like this guy's review style and delivery. Also I would watch any video in any length in this style

[@reallyidrathernot.134]

check out action button reviews. he's made a bunch of crowd funded videos, they're wild. and good.

[@Skinkemann]

This is a excellent video about a fantastic video game. I cannot believe the gall of TheKeits. I also say Yay to a SMB3-vid!

[@dan.downing]

Everything about this game is terrific. The menus, the music, the story, the mechanics and gameplay. It's not hyperbole to say, this game is a masterpiece.

[@reallyidrathernot.134]

I want tim's videos to have a trillion more views. also I'll watch a full-length smb3 video. Season two action button reviews.

[@Plumdizawg]

What happened with the SMB3 video? I’d definitely watch that.

[@InstantTrain]

I would watch that SMB3 video, Tim.

[@redcrimson1028]

Suddenly your favorite hat does t fit anymore, that was a good one lol

[@treadmillgaming5963]

I feel like it would be a lot of work to make a documentary length video about super Mario Bros 3, perhaps if it was preceded by a vacation, or a long nap

[@29jetplane]

I would love that SMB3 video

[@itanocircus2106]

I would watch a feature-length documentary-style review of Super Mario Bros. 3

[@ChiruroM]

I would watch it if and only if you did it...which was a given? Thanks.

[@DreamInSongs]

Great video!

[@halafoo36]

I would watch a feature-length SMB3 documentary!

[@OMalleyTheMaggot]

Not usually what I would expect from a Kotaku video. As in, it was good.

[@itanocircus2106]

I would watch the hell outta a SMB3 video

[@fardinfahim3478]

I would watch the SMB3 video, but I want the 1 hour battle system video way more

[@djdrocco]

Good review. Fantastic game.

[@henrijayy]

ironic irony is ironic

[@Froggore]

Tim - I would watch a feature-length documentary-style review of Super Mario Bros. 3!

[@omega4446]

I would totally watch a documentary on Super Mario Bros 3!

[@ishlocke3084]

I think he's being ironic about not being ironic when he says not to ask him if hes being ironic about not being ironic. Tim is a master of irony.

[@Reliken]

I sure would watch a feature-length review of Super Mario Bros. 3!

[@coolbossnessFTW]

I remember the Pico 8 version of this game. That was really cool.

[@akaRicoSanchez]

Spoiler: the Pico 8 version is included in the game.

[@junkmail2223]

this is excellent

[@myotakueric]

This guy need to quit kotaku and make his own channel. He's too good for them.

[@ShapeyFiend]

Damnit Tim I've been seeing you mention how good Landstalker is since like 2003 I want to see a video about it.

[@jensrushing1486]

I would watch that Mario 3 video

[@CragsCorner]

Please give us that SMB3 review :)

[@NoNickNoKick]

What's irony? Baby don't hurt me, don't hurt me, no moooooore!!!! oooh-oooh!

[@krabbble]

6:36 I definitely would!

[@mjjmedia12]

Turkey Phone... probably the best name to ever exist

[@Chriscras2]

feature length reviews! Nobody would ever make those.

[@irurwurst]

id watch the doc, buddy

[@collinwr46]

When’s that SMB3 documentary coming out?

[@sheeptotherescue]

What about dust force? Of the reviews I've read, none have mentioned dust force, but the similarities are numerous

[@tylernelson02]

W-w-w-wait... you can hyper jump in towerfall?!??

[@SimonPotticary73]

I love this video. That is all. Move along now, move along.

[@travis.t7773]

so in stead of asking ironically if you like this game Im going to put a timestamp to the answer to this question because the explanation made me laugh out loud aka lol 0:55

[@travis.t7773]

and no im no doing this ironically

[@Deedubau]

Probably too early to ask this but will it be a GOTY contender?

[@fatalfeline]

Stamina in mysterious.

[@conradhughes7215]

Have you played Octahedron yet? it has a lot of the same design bits but also your head is an Octahedron... Octa-head Ron

[@louisd1827]

Enjoyable review

[@Czeckie]

this is my asmr

[@Pmonkeyxp52]

1 FEATURE LENGTH DISSERTATION ON HOW SMB3 IS THE PERFECT PLATFORMER PLEASE

[@Joaoppc98]

Are you being ronic about SMB video?

[@michaelholmes6477]

1.move 2.jump 2.climb. 4. dash

[@ballisticm0use72]

I call them screens

[@gerardo6370]

I like what you got

[@sprazz8668]

HRRNNNGGG ARE YOU BEING *IRONIC* MY GOOD SIR??!

[@Ciber2k]

But if Celeste is the Dark Souls of Mario, Which Dark Souls of... is Dark Souls for the Switch?

[@skytastrophe5221]

*Little Samson*

[@isaiahjoseph8502]

I feel likd they are strawberries because the game "Battleblock Theatre" had gems as collectables, but custom user made levels featured strawberries as collectibles rather than green little emeralds

[@Podoco_music]

i enjoyed this video.

[@Czeckie]

where's the smb3 movie?

[@kara-knight3364]

If you do make a documentary, make Chris Person direct

[@caseykoons]

Where's the SMB3 Video?

[@jgperes]

Yes, please, SMB3

[@EXHellfire]

so, that SMB3 thing is definitely gonna happen, because you said "shout me out in the comments" with full confidence, knowing that you'd be asked for it...

[@0Fyrebrand0]

DO THE SUPER MARIO BROS. 3 THING!!!!!!!

[@PolarbearYGT]

I love these but i think ign stole from you a day or so ago...

[@TheDrWillybeast]

SMB3 REVIEW!!!

[@tbowne05]

I also the 666th like on this video. SHOUT AT THE DEVIL!

[@nauthizzz]

Thank you for pronouncing GIF properly.

[@exeacua]

I shout you

[@dtrinitypersonal]

Were you being ironic about not being ironic about asking us not to ask if you were being ironic?

[@davidtroutman9906]

Are you being ironic when you say not to ask you if you're being ironic when you say not to ask you if you're being ironic when you say you're not being ironic when you say you like this game?

[@waytoobiased]

So are you saying Celeste is…fruity?

[@akaRicoSanchez]

There is some serious bullshit in this game though. Off the top of my head, some offenders are big rooms that require tight timing that is almost impossible to control through the whole room, so you just know you are going to die 400 times until the stars align, the fact that gripping walls is dependent of where the character faces, not the direction of the characters' movement (supremely annoying in the windy sections), there are many mechanisms that are stupidly finicky (the timing to get jump boost off clouds, the bump off the bumpers, the push off the exploding blocks in the core), there are sections with a thick layer of infuriating semi-random stuff (hello snowballs to the face, hello charging ghost-like thingies), some hit boxes are incomprehensible (Oshiro, ghost-like thingies), etc. It's still satisfying to overcome most of the game challenges though, but people with a tendency to break stuff when angry will probably find it to be a very expensive game. The worst problem for me though is indirectly related to the game. It so happen that when you use the D-Pad of a PS4 controller the grip is not very comfortable and the nature of the game makes me hold the controller way harder than I need and should (That would be an interesting study in biomechanic and game design, because the tightness of the hold varies greatly from game to game, it is probably friction related - like pressing forward harder when walking against the wind). As a result I have a super sore first joint of my left hand's middle finger. Tough is the life of hearts and strawberry collectors :(

[@theEpicFailSquad123]

3rd comment boi

[@portionsforcam]

This video format is unbearable.

[@trevorbush1749]

Cameron Davisson What about the format is unbearable?

[@nicbravo673]

I have found that I am able to bear it.

[@markfickett2591]

I guess Tim has a strong following. I was hoping for a quick review leaving me with an understanding of whether I'd like the game, and instead found a lot of personal narration and text/clips whoosing over the gameplay so I couldn't see it.

[@krp8154]

I do not like the jokes, Tim. I think though the game seems amazing, this video seems overly pretentious and too much like a puff piece- and not like from someone who genuinely likes the game. I think it is possible to inject some warmth into this format and still seem irreverent and robot-like. Just my 2 cents Timothy.

[@jockel9502]

Your first Tim Rogers video?

[@krp8154]

yes, are there better ones i should watch that will give this context?

[@killmoms]

You either get Tim or you don't. He is, as they say, an acquired taste. Disclaimer: I love him.