Jews in India - Nathan Katz -

[@SrikanthIyerTheMariner]

I am a Hindu living in America ..this video made me Cry .. my heart grows fonder for an India that existed ..and probably still exists in the simplest of her people .yet untouched by materialism

[@TheContrariann]

❤🥺 We Hindus are very tolerant people and whole world is a family 👪 for us, But history and experience with Islamic Invasions have taught us not to be Tolerant of the Intolerant Islam. The struggle and problems of Israel and India are same - the Threat of Islam.

[@kabir9030]

Jews was welcomed in India because majority of India is Hindus which believes every religion is equal and leads to God with different paths all are true.

[@andreiivanov7553]

Your words are not different from reality

[@saratsaratchandran3085]

Amazing revelations! Learned a lot! Appreciated the pluralism and accepting nature my fore fathers who had no compunction in accepting different religions and thoughts without prejudice! A much needed aspect for world peace!

[@snair8448]

Hindus never turned away any refugees. Jews were just another people or Jati who asked for refuge and the local kings were generous as they were to all refugees. Hindus has no quarrels w these refugees’ religions coz we believe there r many paths to same goal! Unlike Christianity or Islam. Jews lived along w all other communities in India w/o any discrimination.

[@Punjabi_americans]

Not only hindus buddy all indians

[@saratsaratchandran3085]

@@Punjabi_americans it was the Dharmic people (Hindus, Buddhists, Jains and Sikhs);who were the natives of India until she got conquer by the predator foreign religions . We still suffer the consequence of it!

[@DB-pp5zt]

The term antisemitism was coined in Europe (I think by a German but not sure) and a phenomenon that mostly European Jews experienced. In fact, Jews live in the same neighbourhood as Christians, Hindus, and other Muslim communities harmoniously together in cities like Calcutta. The politics of the Middle East and the West is just “Fremd” for the Jewish in India. Till today, those Indian Jews who did decide to go to Israel in the 50s, 60s etc, still very strongly associate themselves to India. As an Indian and a true Mumbaiker (from Mumbai), I never heard of the word antisemitism when I lived in India. Yes, in 11th and 12th grade history class at School in Mumbai, we did learn about the World Wars, the resentment against the Jews (we learnt about how Germany tried to blame its economic downfall after the WWI on the success of the Jews in Europe), persecution of the Jews, the Holocaust which all seemed really belonging to a regressive world of the past. But I never thought to experience that such resentment still existed in Germany and Europe even after over 5 decades after the WWII. In 2000, I came to Germany on a scholarship program to pursue my further studies at the University in Stuttgart. I was shocked to hear what I heard silently discussed at private households: denial of the Holocaust (something that was not allowed to be spoken openly in Germany), hatred towards the Americans because they defeated the Germans and a whole load of regressive thoughts. I could not believe that so called Western countries still was backwards in many aspects. In fact, I missed the openness and diversity of Mumbai. In fact, even the Jews in Germany are so different than the Jewish community in Mumbai. I guess it is because the Jews in Europe have always had to live an alert life as for in Mumbai, they are free. The same applies to the Christians and Muslims in India. They are different compared to the Christians or Muslims here in Europe. I myself am an Indian Christian and I just cannot connect to the German Christians (I do not even feel comfortable to enter a church here in Germany).

[@dominicjohnson310]

Isn’t it interesting how the American Hollywood and British media hype up the west as being so modern and progressive?

[@vedicpride]

because of the Hindus

[@Punjabi_americans]

Bine minashe exiled from isreal by syiran emprore 27 centuries ago ,thanks to india keep alive nd safe ur people thousand years , im feel proud an a indian

[@holyrose911]

love to hear from you, because nobody knows much about this, love to go where are Jewish in India, fully freedom to all religions ♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️

[@vchandrashekar3653]

At 34:14 - "Lal Deval“ means Red Temple, not Red Fort. Deval is short for Devalaya meaning" House of Deva“ meaning temple. So the local people recognised it to be a house of worship.

[@SrikanthIyerTheMariner]

Rig Veda .. the most ancient Hindu scripture says " Truth is One ..it goes by with different names" We automatically recognize that the same Divinity reveals itself to man many times in many places..and it is interpreted based on local language/customs.. So Hindus don't just tolerate other religions ..we accept them equally valid as our own Just as my mother is the best mother there is ( for me) ... your mother is the best mother in the world ( for you) My God is the best in the world ( for me )..and your God is the best in the world ( for you) ... Hindus can respect that. This is Religious Pluralism. An Infinite God can be worshipped in Infinite ways. The issues that have surfaced when this beautiful Religious idea was rejected by "Some hard-line Muslims and Christian Missionaries" I qualify it ..because despite oppression/destruction of Temples by Muslim rulers .. Sufism took hold in India ...and most Hindus love Sufi mystics ...and in General Hindus and Muslims got along till 20th century I have seen with my own eyes ..a Hindu woman praying , with tears, at a Dargah Hopefully the world helps India protect Religious Pluralism. We are all children of the Same God.

[@shivendrasharma9205]

All are welcome if you really make a better place India to live in 🙏

[@abstubeindia6979]

I am most pleased Indian awareness of their map. Hip hip hurray.

[@vaghelas4719]

After Muslims attack and British rule 'Dharma ' declined and religion took over India.

[@youtuberate35741]

sorry sir but please Put proper map of India. Thanku

[@finalassault07oct42]

Shalom Namastey feom 🇮🇳

[@winstonbachan9661]

Jews are our Brothers That's All You Need To Know! Barouche Hashem and Shalomastae!

[@rahulreddy2163]

Indian map is shown wrong. Please don't accet distorted map

[@ChandraJamana]

Do we have a link to joiy

[@Swa264]

I think all jews should know this history 🇮🇳❤️🇮🇱

[@ChandraJamana]

Is there a link tojoin

[@ameyakatrekar7509]

Guys, please ignore the map error.... !!

[@ashoks5317]

Removing the shoes may the effect of Hinduism where one leaves the foot wear before entering the temple which is sacred place and to keep it clean

[@bethechange1945]

Least the publisher can do is add disclaimer or apologies and pin the comment

[@abstubeindia6979]

The map looks like headless human. In Indic university channel such map is really highly defamation. Please don't show that map

[@vishypai7554]

The persecution of Jews in Europe and west in general has a historical background specific to the west and rise of Christianity. India being so far away was not part of that historical background. Probably this is the reason there was no persecution of Jews in India. Also, India was tolerant towards all schools of thought and and religious beliefs.

[@shivaprasadmaralingappanav1647]

God is almighty

[@lathiyabhavik9080]

India should explore these places and make them tourism friendly. So, our jewish friend can visit those places and can know more about india. And ofcourse it will generate some jobs to india and help economy to grow.

[@Avtar_0]

There was no anti semitism because india(Bharat) is hindu majority. Always remember that

[@SouthindianNarendra]

If religion is a big topic here in india, how can buddhism, jain,

[@NirmohiHindu]

All fine but maybe unintentionally you have shown the wrong map of India. The pok is shown outside India.

[@lukasschneider]

Proper maps of India are only available in India, I'm sure you can understand.

[@lathiyabhavik9080]

@@lukasschneider yes, you are right.

[@an1ketsharma]

Wrong map of india

[@harikishan5158]

Damn.

[@wickdelphini2669]

The tragic truth is that Jews could never be allowed to thrive anywhere because of the amount of laws relating to various sectors such as technology, agriculture, medicine, construction, etc that have been formulated and meticulously followed by them as a community. Israel today holds that place for the practice of such laws. In India, the truth is that Jews appear happy because their laws have not been followed to the letter or the practicality as envisaged as written off in The Talmund, discussions of midrash, tanna, etc. Thus, you can seem happy when you do not do enough to actually appease Your Lord. Also, not the best of the tribes have lived in India. Israel too has a caste system like the original propagated by Lord Manu which is very strict and must be knowledgeable.

[@finalassault07oct42]

vishv ke kalyaan kee dharm adharm aadi-anant saty asaty kalesh kalank svaamee kee katha paramaarth kee shakti hai bhakti hai janmo kee mukti hai jeevan ka ye sampoorn saar hai yug yug se kann kann mein srshti ke darpan mein vedon kee katha apaar hai dharmon kee gaatha hai devon kee bhaasha hai sadiyon ke itihaas ka pramaan hai krshn kee mahima hai geeta kee garima hai grantho ka granth ye mahaan hai mahaabhaarat mahaabhaarat mahaabhaarat mahaabhaarat...

[@bethechange1945]

It's so sad to see incorrect Indian map

[@haroldjones9321]

Is there a correct map of India? Seems to morph over time. Should it be called Indiastan?

[@bethechange1945]

I'm not disliking the video because of the incorrect India map but not giving it like too

[@PratamEvents]

They welcomed the Jews and it was great. They did the same welcome to the brits, that did not work out so well for us :)

[@gahlawat6764]

Sir plz put right map

[@atish4523]

The presenter has got a wrong map and has used it throughout. Not sure how nobody objected. Fix that!!!

[@19683]

Dalits are Jew? What's the proposition.

[@samuelmatz]

The Hebrew Thomas came to India over two thousand years ago. He lost (murdered) his life there.

[@malmalhi007]

fable

[@kabir9030]

Thats Christian Thomas and he was mocking Hindu pagan beliefs so villagers killed him otherwise we have jews in India from 2th or 3rd century living here perfectly with respect on the other hand Christians still blame jews for killing Jesus.

[@malmalhi007]

@@kabir9030 there is no account of thomas ever landing in india.. hindus murderting thomas was to propogate the beauty of christianity and evil of being hindu.. where is the evidence.. online or otherwise

[@amsindia1555]

India map isn't accurate sir

[@chichagg]

use correct map of india, the map shows chinese & pakistani influnce

[@nainitalism]

get a long . Not anymore