Mary Poppins Returns - Nostalgia Critic

Boost is only available at experian.com/nostalgia
Kidnapping wolves, evil bankers, and yet somehow it's the exact same story. Nostalgia Critic takes a look at how this sequel/reboot is less than practically perfect in every way. Let's take a look at Mary Poppins Returns.
Support this week's charity - internationalmedicalcorps.org/
Come see us at Indy PopCon & use code AWESOME - popcon.us/indy/
Come see us at Planet Funk Con - planetfunkcon.com/
Come see us at Salt City Comic Con - www.saltcitycomiccon.com/
Mary Poppins Returns is a 2018 American musical fantasy film directed by Rob Marshall, with a screenplay written by David Magee and a story by Magee, Marshall, and John DeLuca. Based on the book series Mary Poppins by P. L. Travers, the film is a sequel to the 1964 film Mary Poppins, and stars Emily Blunt as Mary Poppins, with Lin-Manuel Miranda, Ben Whishaw, Emily Mortimer, Julie Walters, Dick Van Dyke, Angela Lansbury, Colin Firth, and Meryl Streep in supporting roles.
Go to our Store for Awesome Stuff - theawesomestore.com
Get some Nostalgia Critic T-Shirts here - shrsl.com/?~96c0
See more at our Site: channelawesome.com
Facebook: / channelawesome
Twitter: / channelawesome
Instagram: / channelawesome
Like Doug on Facebook: / 127127037353766
The ONLY Official KZbin channel for the Nostalgia Critic and Channel Awesome.
New Nostalgia Critic episodes every Wednesday at 5PM CST.
New Top 5 Best/Worst every Tuesday at 5PM CST
New Real Thoughts or 1st Viewing episodes every Thursday at 5PM CST.
New Tamara's Never Seen every Friday at 5PM CST.
Classic Nostalgia Critic episodes are uploaded after they are cleared. TV Show Vlogs are uploaded on an inconsistent schedule, so check the playlists. Same with Doug Reviews, Sibling Rivalry, and Bum Reviews.

[@ChannelAwesome]

Yondu sends his regards! What would you like Nostalgia Critic to review in the future? Support this week's charity - internationalmedicalcorps.org/ Check out last week's Nostalgia Critic - kzbin.info/www/bejne/eGKyk5aLmLSsrtU Come see us at Indy PopCon & use code AWESOME - popcon.us/indy/ Come see us at Planet Funk Con - planetfunkcon.com/ Come see us at Salt City Comic Con - www.saltcitycomiccon.com/

[@takeshitatnall5496]

Detective Pikachu

[@deshawnedwards6412]

Please review The 2012 Three Stooge Movie please.

[@davhend]

Hey guys! Big fan. You have to check out 1991's Hudson Hawk starring Bruce Willis. He co-wrote it, so it's one of those perfect "Leave the story to the storytellers" movies like After Earth.

[@deshawnedwards6412]

Please review Barnyard (2006) please.

[@matthewmendolia8060]

I would love to see chicken run or the santa claus brothers. Love your videos, keep up the great work

[@Pigeonomoutr]

"You don't know what kids want!" "We are Disney, we TELL them what they want!" yep. that one is totally true xD

[@kaysimmons3788]

Pigeonomoutr that got dark for a second

[@mobbcentral4675]

Eh sadly true 🥺

[@camillebox8416]

Them and nintendo

[@shadowkingdarksin3980]

Is no one gonna say it ok i'm gonna say i like the original i even show my sisters kids the original 3 years ago when this came out they were so hype for this movie being a good uncle i bought them tickets to watch the movie but when some random guy watched the movie that day and said kids don't bother spending mony on wast of time i told him hey back off dude their just kids don't going crushing childrens dream to watch what they love and guy who was in his 30s try to push me i told push him harder and called the cops on him the moral story on that day is don't be those people becouse you don't want to be charged for harasment on children 😐

[@lamontyaboy718]

@@shadowkingdarksin3980 so... you guys got into a literal fight over a movie?

[@TheDeathmail]

"Powerful enough to steal from Star Wars?" "We own Star Wars." "Oh, very impressive."

[@rav-7072]

That got dark hella quick Disney has become powerful

[@TheDeathmail]

@@rav-7072 They even changed the power of the snap... that special snap is owned by Disney now..

[@TheDeathmail]

@Ryan Fanstone ??? Actually, Disney did an amazing Job with Marvel... because they actually could make their own thing. As a film series, the MCU is original, so they can start fresh. Their other stuff is stuff they did before or someone else did before that they want to either remake or make sequels for, even though they should be complete...

[@TheDeathmail]

@Luke Sampayo They owned Avengers before they owned Star Wars.

[@DrDolan2000]

And now they own Fox. Pretty soon they're gonna own Universal

[@reythejediladyviajakku6078]

“I don’t hate new things, I hate LAZY things!”

[@cjwrench07]

I personally HATE *Mystery Box* style of storytelling.

[@dicksimmons3147]

Like the Star Wars sequels

[@ncc-sv8jk]

BLU Scout Nnnnice

[@MiniSoot]

k

[@joycongod4831]

Yet rey is your profiled picture🤣🤣🤣

[@sparco956]

Dick Van Dyke is some kind of alien being able to be 96 but still regularly dance, act, and go to the gym

[@otterwithadarkside4422]

He is legendary

[@Sparrows1121]

Angela Lansbury died in 2022, she was in Bedknobs and Broomsticks 1971 movie and special guest in 2018 Mary Poppins movie, rest in peace. Love that 1971 movie

[@SuperSwordman1]

Oh my god, you talked about the difference between a villain and antagonist! Thank you God! More people need to talk about this!

[@skyjack1]

The BIG BAD VILLAIN is neither an antagonist nor a villain. He’s an excuse.

[@SuperSwordman1]

@@skyjack1 Huh?

[@angrytheclown801]

@@SuperSwordman1 I think he means that the monolithic evil, bathed in cliche is neither a villain or antagonist but an empty shell standing in place. If he does, he's not wrong.

[@SuperSwordman1]

@@angrytheclown801 Ah. Yeah if he means that totally nailed it.

[@drakke125Channel]

well...not all heroes are the protag...a protag can be surrounded by heroes, a villain can be a hero against an evil protag, the MC can be a bad person fighting against 'heroes' of another nation..but that's too complex =p

[@enderlovesbagels101]

“Well now in Disney snapping your fingers means something very different...” My new favorite quote

[@james13sylar]

I was expecting her to say "I AM INEVITABLE" and snap her fingers, but nothing happens, but then the original appears and says "And I am Mary Poppins, ya'll"

[@thescreenslaver8520]

Endersgaming345 I’m having flashbacks

[@blazedultimate]

That quote alone seems like something Thanos himself would say

[@kitkat2702]

"Money means nothing without caring." I love how Mr. Banks and his co-workers learn that in the original Mary Poppins but not Disney itself...

[@questworldiangreenknight7455]

Lol true

[@commenturthegreat2915]

The villain part annoyed me the most about the new film. I remember that when I watched it, I just felt this gnawing sensation that something was off, and that it wasn't truly Marry Poppins. I only understood why in animated section with the wolf. I just suddenly thought to myself, "Wait! This is an evil guy! There's a villain! Marry Poppins doesn't have villains! The whole point was about issues caused by good intentions but closed-mindedness, not about dealing with bad guys!" Really ruined the film for me.

[@grantslater861]

@@marrow1243 or they/them

[@marrow1243]

@@grantslater861 ...no. shut up.

[@daddydwaved]

Who cares just grow up man

[@commenturthegreat2915]

@@daddydwaved That is what George Banks would have said if it wasn't for the lessons he learned in the original Marry Poppins.

[@titaniumwolf8756]

Well it isn’t mary poppins…..it boring poppins

[@gregoryefs9898]

"Now in Disney, something DIFFERENT happens when one snaps their fingers" OH GOD, THAT WAS BADASS!!!

[@gavinsfriend3901]

Gregory Efs now Ton of people cry

[@johnfelicia734]

she doesnt have the infinity gauntlet

[@pastelhotmess9299]

Its clever!

[@hanshirt2953]

Nostalgia Wars

[@anikmonette2140]

@@johnfelicia734 And she apparently can kill at will by snapping her fingers, which could only be done once with the infinity gauntlet.(from what I remember at least)

[@BugsyFoga]

"I'm Mary Poppins Y'all" -Yondu

[@animaljam3335]

RIP

[@wizardvozk5874]

Nathaniel Foga dammit you beat me to it

[@timafterdark3759]

R

[@zydrakeshogun]

Fucking beat me to it.

[@AnthonymarioOrozco]

Even he would be a better Mary poppies than the remake

[@Swan5656]

We aren't going to mention the fact that Georgie's hat had his name on it? Even the costume department knew no one watching would know who he was.

[@coolbro8102]

First reply

[@charlottelouise1409]

I can't even remember the name of Bert's son.

[@S8EdgyVA]

Maybe they read the script

[@o0Scarrow0o]

Wanna know something that makes the original film even better? They wanted to put little surprises for the actors of Jane and Michael in the movie so there reactions in some scenes like the one with mary pulling furniture out of her bag are genuine

[@gregorymirabella1423]

*their

[@dianapevtsov]

@@gregorymirabella1423 For the general public: there = The place I'm pointing to that's not where I am. their = Belonging to them. they're = They are.

[@madmaster0015]

Child: "I want to feed the birds, father." Translation: "I want to redistribute the wealth, father."

[@jareththegoblinking3191]

Google Translate or is that just a regular joke?

[@c.d.dailey8013]

@@jareththegoblinking3191 Lindsay Ellis had this in one of her videos, maybe the one about Saving Mr. Banks.

[@BlueflagAlpha]

Birds - Am i a joke to you?

[@mas8705]

In fairness, those two coins weren’t going to amount to much.

[@squidrex6264]

@@mas8705📽🤔

[@cassidydoodles6072]

I don’t feel so good, Mr. Critic

[@ninja1man4u]

Clever girl...

[@coquette_dreams_heart]

My favorite things in this movie: -Songs -Lin Manuel Miranda

[@sarahluvs2sing166]

Literally the only things I like about this movie

[@kit_kat46]

This is the most accurate thing I've ever read.

[@coquette_dreams_heart]

@HahaItsPatrick that too

[@samanthagonzalez28]

I like those but don’t forget Emily blunt or maybe forget

[@SailorMaxie]

Take away everything else and it's just Hamilton

[@LJSohma]

Nostaligia Critic repeating "Magic Umbrella" with increasing irritation and confusion is the same mood of me watching Tangled The Series and going "Magic Hair" as Rapunzel's hair is completely ignored as a possible plot solution.

[@thetwistedsamurai]

Tamara is literally more accurate looking and sounding. What the hell.

[@thescratchyscratch7848]

the-twisted-samurai I think it’s the cheeks.

[@alyssam8977]

Exactly!!! Disney should have hired her instead!

[@zanabelle6569]

Boo hoo

[@thetwistedsamurai]

@@zanabelle6569 I'm not sad about it. It's just kinda interesting tbh.

[@pannacottafugo1875]

@Nicholle Dougherty. I don't know why you think he's sad about it, nothing they said indicated they're upset about it, to be honest you seem rather insecure since you go around 'negative (or people not blindly praising the movie...) either insulting people or saying you like the movie when no one's even really insulting you for liking it, it's just that some don't like the movie and have to right to express themselves.

[@AlexGarcia-tk9tv]

"We're Disney, we tell them what they want!" 🤣🤣🤣 BRILLIANT!!!!!

[@AlexGarcia-tk9tv]

Ekstij Amezie 😂😂😂

[@zekecasperanddeadpoolzgroovyst]

Alex Garcia To be fair the original Mary Poppins is kind of a guilty pleasure in my option. I just cannot get those damn songs out of my head like if I start mentioning one of the songs names it gets stuck in my brain like forever. Julie Andrews I have no problem with she's one of those actresses that get me frustrated in my speech wherever I love her work or hat..uh what was I talking about? Dick Van Dyke on the other hand is a awesome amazing actor for a guy whom can tap dance on a desk at the age of 93 like that I just really wish he was in more Disney live action reboots hell he could be Disney's cash cow cameo like the late Stan *the Man* Lee. But to be fair I don't really hate Mary Poppins or it's reboot sequel Mary Poppins Returns starring Emily Blunt I just find the songs downright pleasant and jolly just like Ms Poppins but maybe a bit too jolly I don't know I just cannot seem to get the song 🎵Spoonful of Sugar makes the medicine go down 🎵 *CRAP BLAST DASH IT ALL I DID IT AGAIN!!!!*

[@AlexGarcia-tk9tv]

Amelia Beckley Glad to here that you enjoyed the movie, I'll admit the film itself is not as phenomenal as people make it out to be, but I was mostly just talking about how Disney is just controlling the media these days I mean don't get me wrong I love Disney but it's becoming more and more obvious that they're making movies just to push their political agendas and are especially using them to influence the younger viewers and I'm not saying it's wrong to teach children that times and ideas are changing but when it gets in the way of the movies overall story, it's only going to result an just a plain movie that parents will mostly use to distract there kids instead of it being a movie where kids will actually be invested in

[@manuelalbertoromero9528]

...Sometimes, I'm glad that studios like Laika and TRIGGER exist.

[@SkyHighGuys]

Not gonna lie it was kinda cute his nervous excitement with Marry Poppins 😂

[@ninjabunnywholivesinsideaw8216]

It was cute and funny! I was cracking up and grinning the whole time!

[@adamgrunther1367]

Simba bursts in. NC: Lion King! Simba: You don’t even know my name, do you?

[@mallorywingate103]

Is that line from the office? Robert California's line?

[@Alejandroigarabide]

Next he'll be calling Basil just "Great Mouse Detective", or Merida "Brave". If he did it for name recognition, he obviously doesn't trust his audience enough and had to spell it out, as if Lion King was some obscure movie and people with minimal knowledge wouldn't know its main character was named Simba.

[@henryg4377]

He didn't call Genie "Aladdin"

[@ShinGhidorah17]

That was pretty dumb of him.

[@TheQuashingoftheTub]

​@@Alejandroigarabide I think the specific idea, although poorly executed, is the entirety of Lion King and Dumbo were butchered, as opposed to a chunk of elements in Aladdin, Genie of course having been butchered since the original direct-to-dvd sequels.

[@TonberryShuffle]

"We're Disney. We TELL them what they want" No truer words.

[@questworldiangreenknight7455]

Ryan Brennan YES!!!!!!!

[@singwhiledrunkps4andxboxon550]

Did you know Disney bites

[@spider-phantom1524]

So true

[@dylansharp8471]

No.

[@Hufflepuffozian]

I prefer older Disney movies and only certain songs from this movie

[@HandmadeGoose97]

Honestly I prefer the "Yondu" version of Marry Poppins y'all

[@milkcatdog394]

LOL

[@jlord5078]

I would love to see Yondu in a Mary Poppins situation.

[@SteveCarras]

Me,too. (From "Guardians of the Galaxy 2", 2017---SAME year as GEORGIE and IT!)

[@KarstensCreationsKC]

29:13 "Is it me, or does she look like one of the between makeups in Mrs Doubtfire?" Nope. She looks like Medusa from The Rescuers

[@noahhecker6672]

The great thing about the original bank scene is that as a kid, Michael’s point of view makes more sense, but as you grow up, you begin to see George’s point of view more. In the new one there is none of that.

[@masonwheeler6536]

Honestly, watching it again today, that line about "feed the birds and what do you get? Fat birds!" is a little bit cringe. Feed the birds and you get _dependent_ birds, who keep coming back and begging people for food because they don't know any way to feed themselves. And if you feed them enough, they breed and you get more and more dependent birds and they become a nuisance, because they get in the way and poop everywhere. As a general rule, anywhere in a city where there's any serious number of pigeons tends to be a pretty bad place to hang around. It would be nice if the writers had come up with an alternative activity to spend the tuppence on that actually did some good.

[@nataliehuang1420]

*"I'M MARY POPPINS, Y'ALL!"* - The real Mary Poppins

[@overlord19980608]

John Adams never forget the daddy 😭

[@nugget3687]

From a movie that actually made me cry

[@yes2allponies126]

I did not know I needed Nostalgia Critic fangirling over Mary Poppins until now

[@Steventhe2nd]

yeah, doug loved Mary Poppins, and i loved the movie too, it's a timeless classic

[@Sugaprincess2500]

yes2 allponies it’s actually adorable tbh

[@theashennathancroft7271]

he fangirled over it in Disneycember for 10 minutes

[@Steventhe2nd]

@@theashennathancroft7271 cause it's like i said, he loved that movie, it was one of his favorite disney movie period

[@mqfii8992]

Poppins being his first crush doesn't help it either

[@d-manthecaptain1382]

Aw, yes. My favorite Disney character, "Lion King"

[@chupacadabra5161]

I thought I was the only one who was bothered by that.

[@CourtJesterVA]

Yeah, I'll admit, that made my eye twitch.

[@p0nk889]

Brov what was that?!

[@bubbleshock14]

Well he is a lion and he is a king so is it really incorrect?

[@LadyOnikara]

Since Disney owns Muppets too, I like "Frog Captain" in one of their movies.

[@jamesmoyner7499]

38:08 Doug you love the original Mary Poppins so why didn’t you realize that by Michael giving his tuppence to his father he gave his love to him who then passed it on to Mr. Dawes Sr. who truly was in need of it. As being a cold heartless banker as Bert described earlier with the line “They make cages in all sizes; bank sizes some of them.”

[@GirlofCulture]

Tamara is a lovely Mary Poppins ❤️ "Money means nothing without caring" Great line Doug 👏🏻

[@Celicagame13]

And “caring”

[@AgentVamp]

caring*

[@AgentVamp]

Tamara

[@_Chiaroscuro_]

Yeah She Is lovely

[@stephenknizek2651]

I was hoping Nostalgia Chick would come back for a cameo. Oh well.

[@mariaer9692]

I'm actually pretty impressed with your Mary Poppins impersonations!

[@fartymctits5701]

It's his lack of testosterone and self respect.

[@KristinaXenophobia]

Amazing right? Tamara is literally becoming a show stopper in every new episode. Tamara for a role in a blockbuster!!!

[@gooeymon8146]

@Dead Pool How is she annoying?

[@gianrecana9858]

@I Love Halloween i have to agree with @Guisadotron with this. what makes her annoying?

[@dannys8014]

LIN: "And the queen of the nation made a royal proclamation" CAST: "He's just Non-Stop!"

[@wrybreadspread]

13:25 "Recycled plot points...unimaginative story...rushed script" ...sounds like Rise Of Skywalker

[@eyesack2007]

Or as I call it Episode IX: Disney’s Burning Applebee’s Dumpster

[@olleselin]

Totally

[@RedMoonbow4921]

Sounds like all of disney today. They are running out of ideas or don't know how to tell them properly. They purposely pissed George Lucas off I think 🤔 🤔 🤔

[@wrybreadspread]

@@tristanhartup4936 Both my parents grew up in the Great Depression. Poverty and unemployment like we can't imagine. They were married for 70 years. Dad passed away just a few years ago, Mom on New Year's Day of this year. Their lives are worthier than your comment. But it's the darndest thing about Christmas...I want to treat everyone like Ebenezer Scrooge does after he stops being an SOB. I believe in the Pyramid Of Argument...that means to treat people rationally and not behave like a prick. So...if you're up for it, let's talk...discuss. Did you like the flick? What was good about it?

[@dylansharp8471]

@@RedMoonbow4921 Not true.

[@Angie-ji7be]

I'm living for every single Endgame and Pennywise reference in this review

[@AndreNitroX]

Original Disney movies Dissemble

[@renbehesi9162]

@@AndreNitroX thank u for that lol

[@chiefrief2940]

NC said it himself: topical.

[@sandraskender1388]

And home alone 2 refrence

[@Foxy02016]

Angie Hmmm, that is Brittans

[@90sgrungechick5]

Tamara as Mary Poppins is my new favorite thing.

[@angrypredator2704]

BOOBS 😛

[@ThaloniusPFunk]

@@angrypredator2704 you spug pidelwap

[@OlaftheGreat]

She's practically perfect in every way!

[@averymerrick]

Emily Blunt knew she could never live up to Julie Andrews' Mary, so rather than try to emulate that Mary, *she based her interpretation of Mary off Rosalind Russell's sharp-witted journalist character from His Girl Friday and the more stern and vain nanny found in P.L. Travers' original book.*

[@acjnse8258]

Cool

[@beatthegreat7020]

Mary Poppins would be terrifying if she was evil. The nanny who killed Gaunter O'dimm and Nyrolethotep.

[@whyiamafs]

Yondu: "I'M MARY POPPINS, Y'ALL!" Mary Poppins 2.0: I'm Thanos, y'all...

[@alyssabaney9921]

Qu33nof0z your comment deserves more likes.

[@GhazMazMSM]

Mary poppins 2.0: I’m yondu, Y,ALL.

[@whyiamafs]

@@alyssabaney9921 Thank you :)

[@PunakiviAddikti]

Oh shit, you're right.

[@NotAHandle22]

2017-2018, when Yondu was a better Mary Poppins than Mary Poppins

[@jsb8261]

The Adult Banks Children: "That magic we experienced as kids didn't actually happen." *Mary Poppins comes down having not aged a day* The Adult Banks Children: "..."

[@croweman6515]

If what I've heard about Walt Disney himself is true, I really think he'd be so disappointed in what his corporation has become, and that his name is associated with it. And I DAMN sure know Pamela Travers is rolling in her grave at what her life's work has become with modern Disney. R.I.P. original ideas and actual talent...

[@dylansharp8471]

"R.I.P. original ideas and actual talent..." No actually. Those are still around.

[@mcm730]

To be fair, Pamela Travers hated the first movie too, lolz

[@malikpierre-louis3343]

​@@dylansharp8471Not anymore in 2024.

[@bobbysyblik68]

11:20 I could've sworn she asked about Burr "Last I remember he shot me". "Oh dear."

[@CabinetofThorns]

To quote another good “version” of Mary Poppins (aka Nanny McPhee): When you need me, but do not want me, I must stay. When you want me, but do not need me, I must go. Interestingly enough, supposedly Nanny McPhee was closer to what the author had originally envisioned Mary Poppins to be like...

[@zachmanf.7479]

I'm glad I'm not the only one who remembers Nanny McPhee. I hope the critic does a review of it at some point.

[@SteveCarras]

Hey, those old as I am (59 as of next month!) will recall "Nanny and the Professor" Released/Produced by 20th CENTURY FOX(Owned by Disney! Well, NOW it is) starring Disney icon Hayley Mills's older sis, Juliet (who appeared in Disney's OWN THE OTHER SISTER>>)

[@morgangobin9985]

Let me just say that Tamara plays a practically perfect Mary Poppins...and Aiyanna plays a practically perfect villain!

[@victoriamartines5030]

Or Mary Pop-ups if you will.

[@JakNekon]

@@victoriamartines5030 Yes, yes I think I will...

[@HeilRay]

Facts

[@Blitzo8390]

Morgan Gobin Aiyanna kind of reminds me of Dolores Umbridge from Harry Potter

[@BJAlexThe4th]

11:28 "He's high isn't he?" "Everyday" I take it "as a kite" was too obvious a pun for this point in the movie?

[@missb2052]

I’m here because it’s Dick Van Dyke’s bday (97), and 37:42 sums him up perfectly. 🎉🎉🎉

[@gradygal81]

We love dick van dyke! Still awesome!

[@victoriaware664]

“Disney: We used to be good at this.” So accurate😂

[@kirinbobarcana]

True

[@crocuslament9680]

Hi, Disney? I know you'll never read this, but there are hundreds of fairy tales that haven't been adapted yet. Can you make movies about those? I like your movies about fairy tales. They're nice and pretty and they make me feel good and most of the better movies you've made recently have been about fairy tales. Like Frozen! Frozen was okay, I guess. But there are hundreds more fairy tales you could adapt into stories, so you would literally never run out. Please. I don't think you're as good at this as you think you are.

[@H.E.M.95]

Mad Mar yes, that’s what I was thinking. There are enough 1001 night stories, the brothers grimm, ... . Come on disney.

[@kylemorello4787]

They are still good at this! They're just making films that aren't. I can name just as many amazing films, attractions and tv shows that are just as good if not better than they're ogs! I'm sorry, I'm just sick of modern coal overshadowing modern gems.

[@victoriaware664]

Kyle Morello I totally respect your opinion, I just consider myself an old soul and kind of a purist when it comes to films haha! Some remakes might be good, or continuations like the movie Christopher Robin, but I think if the original was received well in its time or perfect the way it was, it doesn’t need a remake(and Disney is definitely not the only franchise doing this). I had a long conversation with my friend about this and we agreed that there are some Disney remakes or continuations that are worth doing, such as two of my favorites The Hunchback of Notre Dame and the Great Mouse Detective. Some of their new movies have been good like Moana, but quite recently I just don’t think they hold a candle to the originals.

[@kattyallialchemy5025]

I just love how is Critic fangirling when Tamara Poppins appeared XD

[@viansalozano328]

The most wholesome thing you'll see all day!!

[@camerontofu5798]

"SHE SAID SPIT SPOT!!!"

[@mqfii8992]

@@viansalozano328 In the Disneycember of Mary Poppins, Doug said this Is his favorite Disney Live Action and that Poppins was his first crush. So it's obvious that NC would fanboy all over her.

[@TMP2064]

I love Tamara's Poppins voice!

[@StefWriter]

Same! lol

[@Niamh2060]

*I'm still feeding the birds, just with my lifeless corpse...* - Birdlady 😂

[@manbehindtheslaughter]

4:55 My name is Patrick Stamos. You killed my childhood role model. Prepare to be nostalgia criticed.

[@moviemaniac9034]

Mary: "Oh, how is dear old Bert?" Jack: "Travellin' the world, he is, off to parts unknown." Critic #1: "He's high, isn't he?" Critic #2: "As a kite." He could've easily made that joke.

[@biomassregional6vlogstv]

I really wish he did

[@TheQuashingoftheTub]

Not gonna as I was reading this comment my brain had to do a mental backspace because I thought I somehow missed this joke Thank you for clarifying I'm not -as- insane.

[@daytonapeanut]

Is anyone else going to mention just how amazing Tamara looks in her Mary Poppins outfit?

[@SnifyWisper]

Normally I don't give a shit about makeup but even I feel they went above and beyond for the Mary Poppins outfit. The makeup department was on point for this review.

[@Celicagame13]

Leonida Tuck Aiyanna looks way better

[@UnprofessionalProfessor]

And with that, a new fetish was born.

[@Zulfburht]

You mean her busy, or makeup?

[@emptypocket1905]

Bust* your welcome

[@emilyfrancalangia516]

I'm surprised he didn't bring up "Saving Mr. Banks"

[@thenarnianhufflepuff6077]

I love saving mr banks

[@iamthemeguyhere]

“We tell them what they want.” I never would have expected such a disgusting true line about what Disney has become from a - very well written, but not well executed - critic channel.

[@shadow_shine3578]

I'm kinda scared that this is true...

[@dylansharp8471]

It is NOT true.

[@springbonnie5249]

​@@dylansharp8471 yes, it is

[@Goremaid]

Critic squeeing over Tamara-Mary Poppins is the most wholesome thing

[@MrDalek2150]

Tamary Poppins.

[@pandoravex4791]

I giggled the whole time.

[@h193013]

Goremaid It’s like watching a little kid at Disney

[@thejohnhopkinscompany9599]

WE OWN STAR WARS! Actually felt pretty sinister.

[@TheRezro]

That was the point..

[@LakeInTheDarkProductions]

Ha!

[@Marinealver]

spot on 4:29 is really everything wrong with Disney now a days

[@tomnorton4277]

Well Star Wars has been raped and destroyed by Dicksney. George Lucas kept it going for 40 years. Dicksney killed it in 4 but they're still parading its corpse around to squeeze every last cent out of gullible morons.

[@Sonichero151]

@@tomnorton4277 jar jar Binks and Jake lloyd was from Lucas..... Never forget this

[@pem1974]

Doug I definitely see your point. However if Hollywood is so hellbent on remakes instead of originality, then I find a remake disguised as a sequel a bit easier to swallow because at least they're not asking you to forget what came first. Also I don't know if you can even call this a remake because *nobody* bonks their head on the top of a fireplace It ain't Mary Poppins until someone does that! 🤣

[@louise6093]

21:00 when Lin started singing I immediatley wondered what was the directing of that. Rob Marshall: Okay, Lin, just sing how you'd normally sing except you have to have random flashbacks to Hamilton. Oh yeah and the irony of Lin in this film is funny. Think of it, a man that wrote the songs to a musical against the oppression of the British colonizers landing the role of a British guy. It may not be funny for you but sure of a heck of a lot funny to me.

[@AlexiSonic]

Tamara makes such a great Mary Poppins I was genuinely sad that she was Thanos snapped in the beginning. Like, seriously you made me care for a parody of a character taken out of context of its original universe for the entertainement value of an analysis video. I'm blown away by that feat.

[@questworldiangreenknight7455]

AlexiSonic LOL 😂

[@kylemorello4787]

Kinda reminds me of South Park's portrayal of Winnie the Pooh in Banned In China. A perfectly in character portrayal of a timeless Disney character that it's genuinely heartbreaking when they get killed as a metaphor for Disney's mistakes.

[@clancydowrca]

The ending is good though!

[@danielshimoda9246]

Shes not going to fuck you bro.

[@goldenbone8288]

@@danielshimoda9246 lol what? Where did that come from

[@pokeguyzilla5597]

Sees Mary Poppins fly in. Me: She's Mary Poppins, y'all!

[@firenze6424]

I wish yondu was the star of this movie

[@pokeguyzilla5597]

@@firenze6424 We ALL wish Yondu was the star of this movie. It's just human nature.

[@Devilman6066]

"Child eating tree, you'll have no more bones in your branches!" That was a good laugh. Omg.

[@questworldiangreenknight7455]

😂🤣

[@ella-strator2107]

Boy no.1 was actually my childhood friend. We met up last year and I shared ur opinion with him, and you can bet he had A LOT of character in his reaction. He karate kicked a piñata.

[@ghostnebula8805]

That is a funny image.

[@LegendPurpleDragon152]

What I wouldn’t give to be a fly on the wall for THAT conversation 😂. I take it he disagreed with Doug’s assessment?

[@lynfabros]

Psychiatrist: Don't worry Mary Poppins isn't real she can't hurt you Mary poppins: (sticks her hand in the room) *S N A P P Y S N A P*

[@pastelhotmess9299]

*screams*

[@LordWyatt]

*Fades away*

[@mr.eazilymctriggered9369]

*S P I T S P O T*

[@codysonic1]

*loads shotgun with malicious intent*

[@rexosaurus3610]

*marry poppins provides a slap just hard enough that you remember it*

[@tackey8632]

"You have no idea what kids want! "We're Disney. We *tell* them what they want." ...Wow. Just..j-just....I...[incoherent stammering] ...That. Was awesome.

[@Sonichero151]

Doug is twisting that Knife Deep.................. Disney won't feel it..... but we see how deep it's going and frankly it's terrifying and awesome...

[@kanati1133]

@Anthony Castello Productions If they do make a second one I want something similar to the original idea of nick making a big amusement park for predators and ditching the collars that have to wear. Like a underground spot for predators and nick has to hide it from judy That's just about it, if it's just some sorry ass shit I'll riot

[@tomascaldon1332]

@@kanati1133 I just think that Disney should finally make something original again. Y'now, not a remake, not a sequel, an original idea. I live in hope.

[@Ze_eT]

@@tomascaldon1332 Disney is kinda what happened to Pixar (plus Google, but that is something different). Some of the creators still try to be creative but they get silenced because that's not what the big crowd wants/not as easy to do as the formula, and why should they care? They got the brand recognition already. They at most care if it is something new to show how great it is to start a franchise/Disney+ (High School Musical: The Musical: The Series). I'm not saying that the franchises/Disney+ will suck after they tried establishing they won't, but I am also not saying Disney cares enough. As for Pixar, they are still trying original stuff, some being good and some absolute garbage like A Good Dinosaur, and alot of sequels, some being okay and (Atleast for me, many think the following movie is good) some absolute garbage like Toy Story 4. TL;DR Disney gone corporate.

[@channelsunnamed1202]

No!!! It was evil!!! EVIL!!!!!!!!!

[@JDXC666]

Normally I find the skits to be hit-or-miss, but the one at the start with the two Mary's was absolute GOLD.

[@claresaguban3471]

Mary Poppins 2.0 became Thanos when she snaps Mary Poppins away. :(

[@notentirelyanon6902]

Damn. I was more emotionally invested in the first 6 minutes of this than I was in the entirety of Mary Poppins Returns.

[@andylagger551]

Rob & Maria DeHoff Yep...a dude talking to a camera is more of an entertainment than a Disney movie, you know they messed up

[@Goremaid]

Seriously! Tamara's awesome and tough but in a comforting way, Aiyanna was scary and Critic needs a hug

[@andylagger551]

Goremaid True, I like the role she’s playing, not quite Marry Poppins, but more like her own character. A sassy 60’s woman who always know better than you, she’s also charmingly chubby.

[@kirakiryu1020]

Rob & Maria DeHoff MPR was, indeed . . . “Stupidcrapafuckarifficexpiabullshit.” Nostalgia Critic, Batman & Robin review.

[@gamewiz720]

@@kirakiryu1020 He used that same line on his Facebook page!

[@joelyap2538]

Wait, three kids and with a set up for a deceased mother, they could have explored so many different things with just the children's personalities alone. Like the oldest could be the only one that is most affected by the mother, making them go through their role as the oldest child who needs to take an initiative. The middle child could have a relationship problem with the father and is socially awkward, and finally the youngest could be overly dependant on the father. Done. Three simple distinct personalities that could tie into how the story can progress.

[@voidjockey82]

Was that...creativity? What a rare sight these days.

[@joelyap2538]

@@voidjockey82 What's creativity? Can I eat it? XD

[@ezelfrancisco1349]

That would require thought and creativity. That is not allowed here

[@soygato2722]

Joel Yap YOU BELONG TO DISNEY NOW!

[@alex_geronimo]

Что говоришь?)

[@Zoe-ge5id]

on a side note "Saving Mr.Banks" utterly destroyed my emotions. That movie is waaaaaay too relatable for me... left me sobbing for days.

[@gradygal81]

I remember watching this in the theater and just thinking “this is wrong” then a couple days later I just remember yelling “Mary poppins shouldn’t have Mr O’Hare from the Lorax as a villain!!!!”

[@shadowthesavagehedgehog4296]

Mary Poppins 2.0: I am inevitable. Nostalgia Critic: And I....Am....Nostalgia Critic. *Snaps*

[@jasongill7590]

Is no one else feeling a bit weird that Critic spoiled the ending of Avengers: Endgame.

[@randalgraves6979]

Are we forgetting Michael Rooker 🤨

[@isaacandluxo5463]

He remembers it and she won’t forget it

[@questworldiangreenknight7455]

shadow_the savage boss I’d love to see Nostalgia Critic in the mcu😂😂😂

[@Loopyboy447]

And I.....remember it....so you don’t have to.....

[@ahmede.]

Who knew Mary Poppins 2.0 was an undercover thanos?

[@kikioliveer]

Yeah, and she can make the gauntlet invisible 😂

[@ForkJuuga]

Reality can be whatever I want it to be.

[@iceymacchiato6360]

Spoilers!! Gotta look out for the next marvel × disney movie if it ever comes to life

[@GlassesnMouthplates]

And Yondu was meant to be the original Mary Poppins.

[@aurahoneydew9607]

It's like into the spiderverse anyone can be a Thanos. With Infinity Gauntlet level powers anything is possible.

[@sweetie9569]

34:42 Subtitles : Mad Chick I'm Brad. That perfect mistake 👌

[@PENGUINGIRL1210]

Mary Poppins was my favorite movie as a kid. I even dressed up as her for Halloween. My mom made my costume for me.

[@aitipsea3909]

"Hmm, that is Britain's ass" Nice reference

[@alexjewett7455]

To what

[@aitipsea3909]

@@alexjewett7455 Avengers End game "That is America's ass"

[@90sNostalgiaNerd]

I understood that reference.

[@incanticle699]

@@aitipsea3909 they didn't call it *END* game for nothing. ;)

[@dementedcreations8971]

I actually fell on the floor

[@nightmareeclipse8383]

Poppins 2.0: the power of my snappy fingers Original Mary poppins: on your left

[@theartistdemon3757]

Lin: I AM NOT THROWING AWAY MY SH- Disney: we want you for our mary Poppins reboot Lin: i- wha- why? Disney: cause you're popular and well...we need a popular actor to make our movie better Lin:....i am throwing away my shot Disney: ah do that with a British accents *-we own you now-* Lin: ugh... *in British accent* i am throwing away my shot

[@crashtefano]

I genuinely loved Mary Poppins Returns. It's not like it is anything new, but it's the best use of Disney Nostalgia I have seen in one of these recent movies. By far. I felt happy while watching this one, like I was taking a trip to an old time and revisiting some old friends I had not met in a long time. But in a sequel instead of another remake of the same story. I swear this is way superior to those many cash-grab remakes of Disney classic that I watch just once for the sake of nostalgia and then I'm like: "Nope! Back to the originals and never watching these live action remakes again." I don't know if I can make you see the difference, but I can feel it.

[@catherinecifer664]

"We're Disney, WE tell children what they want" THIS IS GOLD! XD

[@CardboardBoxGod]

“HEYA GEORGIE!” That Pennywise joke was too good lol 11:10 for replay value xD

[@LupineShadowOmega]

Pennywise vs Mary Poppins, I'm so down for that...

[@LupineShadowOmega]

@FearlessAstridHofferson yep, so Autumn court fae vs Spring court. Both are terrifying inhuman monsters that feed off humanity, you just might survive one of them. XD

[@LupineShadowOmega]

@FearlessAstridHofferson indeed.

[@jamesgriffin7962]

I can’t wait for IT Chapter 3 vs Mary Poppins

[@-ZeroRed-]

19:36 THIS! I am really sick and tired of every single Disney movie being cgi now because it's cheaper to do. I miss these lovingly crafted masterpieces so much because they had far more heart in them and you could feel the artists in them. I don't think they have to do it every movie they make but every other movie they should go back to, well, actually being Walt Disney pictures :(

[@malecrose6282]

"Hey, Mary Poppins 2.HO..." Best pun ever!!!

[@rnspurgn3015]

"She was from the 60s. Children have no interest in seeing anything from an age with no cell phones." Me: Hold my age appropriate beverage Edit: Replies are extremely toxic, view at your own risk

[@silverpslm]

How many modern day pop songs use segments of popular 60s and earlier songs or memorable quotes?

[@3N3MYKN1GHT]

@@silverpslm How many popular 60's things borrow from the 20's-30's or earlier, about the same.

[@onisfury8264]

Children nowadays have no interest in seeing or listening to anything from the 20s 30s 40s 50s 60s 70s 80s 90s early 2000s.

[@quarreneverett4767]

@@onisfury8264 we are living in the early 2000s

[@onisfury8264]

@@quarreneverett4767 I'm talking about the stuff from like 2003 and 5

[@MM-xn6tn]

The scene in Guardians 2 of Yondu saying, "I'm Mary Poppins, y'all!" was more faithful to the original than this high budget horseshit.

[@Megaproductions302]

M M you got that right.

[@thebossrayden]

It wasn't but ok.

[@Alondro77]

I would have bought Yondu as Mary Poppins... XD

[@tsukishiro70]

I love Tamara's accent in this video. And she is the spitting image of the real Mary Poppins too. I am well impressed.

[@klimmr]

39:33 Best line in the entire MCU behind Avengers Assemble and I ... am ... Iron Man.

[@AforAwesome3604]

As a Hamilton fan, I found it hilarious when he said “the Lin Manuel Miranda Song” and preceded to sing “Hamilton Hamilton Hamilton Hamilton”😂😂😂

[@evilted]

TheKoolStarIsWeird yeeeesss

[@barrythechopper]

When the original Mary Poppins looks in the mirror and her reflection speaks its fun and whimsical. When the reboot one does it, it's creepy and off-putting...that's some Oculus shit going on.

[@edwardtjbrown2193]

Well, somone has to be given a spoonful of sugar...

[@Ibhenriksen]

In reality, both movie were oculus. Still the first one holds up better for me.

[@AJ-cq5pw]

Well, if we’re gonna get technical the actual Mary Poppins from the books was never fun or whimsical.

[@DigiRangerScott]

It’s s very obvious sequel

[@SaucerheadTharp]

The villain bugged me when I saw this at the theater, especially at the end...because the head banker found his happy place or whatever in the original. Here they just shafted him.

[@SupermarketSweep777]

10:13 I saw Oliver and Company referenced, but Jenny's mom wasn't dead. Jenny's parents were away on a business trip. She even says "Mom and dad just said I could keep him." when she was talking to Georgette after she met Oliver.

[@ocbday]

"Honey badger dont give a shit" Caught me off guard, now ive got tears in my eyes 😂

[@PikaLink91]

Critic: You have no idea what children want! Mary 2.0: We are Disney, we TELL them what they want. OMG that hit hard!! ...because it's true

[@HolyKhaaaaan]

Not in my home, will that be the case. Hungarian Folk Tales, classic Disney, and 90s PBS tapes! Who needs anything more?

[@TheRezro]

@@HolyKhaaaaan Who don't have those tapes? You hipsters are aware that many young people see old movies, only because they see remake in cinema first? It isn't a theory, it is a fact.

[@PatZalatoris]

Honestly, disney shouldve just left mary poppins alone, it was and still is a perfect movie. And one of the things I hate is when people take a show or movie and do what people like NC call a requel, a reboot and a sequel at the same time, for me you can only have one or the other, not have a character from the first film be older having us think it's a sequel, but then redo scenes play by play as if it's a complete reboot of the first film, it confuses people

[@Valhobino]

Marvel:”infinity war is the most ambitious crossover in existence.” 42:18 The awesome channel:

[@BugsyFoga]

Can we all just agree it was awesome to finally to see 2d Animation in a Disney film again .😁👌

[@Roadent1241]

Nathaniel Foga That was the only good bit of this film. And I loved the original.

[@JoshF183]

you are everywhere wtf...

[@Sorcerer-SMC]

Exactly

[@mysticalkeyblade759]

Why did Disney stop two dimension animation?

[@gerawallstar3487]

@@mysticalkeyblade759 Because Winnie the Pooh bombed in 2011, and their CGI films were making more money than that film, and The Princess and the Frog.

[@manicalman597]

Old: I’m Marry Poppins Ya’ll! New: Oh Hell Naw!

[@TheLastBabyMan]

New: No, fuck this, i'm done. I am so done.

[@questworldiangreenknight7455]

I love how Critic gets excited when Mary Poppins arrives!😂😂😂😂

[@ot7biasedmashups]

I just watched Marry Poppins Returns and like most the people here I have strong nostalgia connected to the original movie. So I was kinda scared to watch the reboot, after all I didn't know if they'd just try to make it modern. When the movie started and we got to "Can you imagine that" I felt my heart sink because I absolutely LOVE the 2D animation in the original. It's just super unique and totally holds up for me. So I thought all the magical parts were probably gonna be animated like that but Emily Blunt did such a great job as Mary Poppins and the songs had me bawling in nostalgia so I kept going. When the villain arc got stronger I really felt put off. I hadn't seen the original in a while but something didn't feel right about the fact that there was a villain. I remember having the original movie as a save zone as a child, this didn't make sense. And even though I've finished the movie and will totally re-watch it a lot, I definitely feel like it was unnecessary af. It takes me out of the Mary Poppins feel (just like some of the modern stunts and as I said CGI). I'm personally really glad that they kind of hit a lot of the same notes from the original. I think it's great if you already have established nostalgia with Mary Poppins! It definitely hits harder when you're a teenager or adult watching it. I also really love the songs.

[@ghostling170]

when you see lin manuel in anything other than hamilton “I know him.”

[@SessVlogs]

A Mage of Void who is also a hufflepuff That’s that...little guy who spoke to me.

[@autismrobotrixvcghva1999]

@@SessVlogs All those years ago, what was it? '85? That poor man, they're gonna eat him alive!

[@autismrobotrixvcghva1999]

@GirlGeek next to Washington, they all look small

[@tomsparrow1823]

All alone, across the sea, when your people say they hate you! Don't come crawling back to me

[@blackandbluemadness7965]

Dadadayada dadadadadayada dadadadadadada

[@TheJulioToboso]

I’m surprised you didn’t mention how standardly grey it looks. Saturation level to the minimum, while obviously recorded colourfully

[@misseli1]

Julio Toboso García, That's such a great description of what many recent movies look like. The staff obviously put a lot of effort into making the costumes and sets look vibrant and colorful, but then when it comes to the editing room they end up draining much of the life and color from the movie. Have you seen the video essay "Why do Marvel's Movies Look Kind of Ugly" by Patrick Willems? He talks about how following the switch from film cameras to digital cameras, a lot of movies have become pretty dull to look at.

[@ZorotheGallade]

It's just so clashing with the complexity of the environment and special effects. They managed to make CGI, something usually used to make grand and imaginative things, feel bland and tasteless

[@KhadaJhin04]

They think it will give them a professional look when all it does is mute everything, I am far more likely to sleep through one of these movies and it usually indicates that there is no grabbing storyline

[@thechaossociety7453]

It is great Britain

[@obiwankenobi9141]

I also thought the Angela Lansbury cameo at the end was clearly reserved for Julie Andrews, but she wasn’t available, so they got ms Lansbury, but mrs Lovett in a Mary Poppins movie is hilarious.