Charlemagne (Part 1/2) 📜 The Rise

[@HistoryMarche]

🚩 The first 1,000 people to use this link will get a 1 month free trial of Skillshare: skl.sh/historymarche12201

[@Human.Being23]

Yaaayyy!

[@KiranSingh-zr8jr]

Love your videos

[@emmanuelfernandez04]

Any updates on Hannibal?

[@generichomosapien4666]

darn

[@saratmodugu2721]

The avar khanate still had Slavic vassals at the borders of the khazars and as far as north Poland. You map is wrong

[@Mr_M_History]

The quality of your maps is insane. Makes a huge difference in gaining a detailed understanding!

[@onetwothreefourfive12345]

So true

[@ramichahin2]

its a lie to call roman catholicism ''The True Christian Faith'' because the romans paganised The True Faith beyond recognition.

[@aSm8full]

and the lack of jokes are a great plus too as they kind of break the immersion imho

[@DenUitvreter]

Indeed, even the Netherlands shore line and inner waters, which have changed a lot over the centuries, are period correct.

[@iowastate358]

A racist that didn't open his land to Muslims and Africans

[@kaspernielsen9149]

I love geography and I admire your sense of detail in these maps. e.g the Netherlands have their actual correct size for the time, and not the reclaimed area they have now. maybe people miss these small details, but when u see them done right it is oh so satisfying to look at. :)

[@HistoryMarche]

Glad you noticed. Thank you for the nice words.

[@Matthew10950]

@@HistoryMarche I can only hear any reply or posted comment from HistoryMarche in the narrators voice. I know it isn't right, but I can't help it!

[@HistoryMarche]

@@Matthew10950 The commander ordered the men to drink a cup of milk and then to charge forward! As the two armies clashed they began tickling each other to death. Many men fell, but it was a lot of fun and a lot of laughter!

[@Matthew10950]

@@HistoryMarche lol, undoubtedly a quote from the upcoming series "Hugh Hefner, and the siege of the Playboy Mansion"

[@dingliedangliedoodle9261]

Liam Neeson and his "very particular set of skills" caught me offguard lmao

[@Michael_______]

Made me laugh. I love that very much.

[@iowastate358]

A true racist that didn't open up the land to mass Muslim and African migration 😭

[@iowastate358]

No LGBTQ++ community 😭

[@andrewharper3165]

@@iowastate358 take that nonsense somewhere else, you're ruining an otherwise brilliant channel with your narrow minded blinkered self.

[@BStial223]

@@iowastate358 what African immigration are you talking about ? Learn your 8th century history, because you are talking bs

[@metalpsyche82]

The partition in chapters and the quotes of historians really give an edge to your videos

[@andersonolb1793]

One of my favorite medieval characters. Not only by his influence and important role in medieval history, but for all he achieved during his lifetime. I can't wait for the next episode of the series, and congratulations to HistoryMarche for another great production.

[@joachimverbruggen6062]

Yes but the much important groundwork was laid by his father Pepin, I don't think you can't talk about charlemagne and dismiss Pepin so easy.

[@andersonolb1793]

@@joachimverbruggen6062 You're right my friend. Pepin set the basis from which the carolingian dinasty could grow its influence throughout most of Europe, especially the close ties established with Church, from which they gained the necessary legitimicy to rule.

[@MikhailTabigay]

One of Napoleon Bonaparte’s heroes

[@Nomadicenjoyerplus]

Others are Julius Caesar, Hannibal Barca, Alexander the Great, Nader Shah though 🤨

[@ru4582]

Literally every European monarch after Charlemagne were in some way trying to replicate his career.

[@angelostriandos6659]

That is why even Napoleon went to the Pope for his coronation. Legitimacy is always the question.

[@MikhailTabigay]

@@ru4582 yeah, and Charlemagne wasn’t the first man in Europe to conquer different lands?

[@AlexC-ou4ju]

@@MikhailTabigay Rome?

[@nervachadikus]

Me: This day can't be better HistoryMarche: Hey there

[@mihkeltroost8769]

for real I have been waiting for a video about Charlemagne for a loong time

[@edishasora5200]

For real! It just their viewers isnt as massive as KnG. I think HM need to work on their thumbnail more. The content are way way better than the thumbnail. It could be more tempting to click. Hope HM team see this and working more on the thumbnail

[@nervachadikus]

@@edishasora5200 True, I will remember the animation from the fall of the west for the rest of my life

[@CelticSaint]

Bad day for me. Diagnosed with an inoperable cancer. I have 6 months at most. But I'll be watching these videos to my last breath.

[@edishasora5200]

@@nervachadikus yea it was lit. For me its battle of Ain Jalut, Mongol defeated near jerussalem. Feels like watching a movie. The narration and the struggle it was spot on

[@hashirmuhammad4731]

I am still PATIENTLY awaiting the Hannibal series so please HistoryMarche make my wish come true

[@drlca6601]

bruh we just got Charlemagne, this is a victory... patience

[@bahaataleb7725]

they already did it

[@53yearsago56]

@@bahaataleb7725he never covered the battle of Zama so I hope they will continue the series.

[@midoelshafaey8026]

R u kidding me !? It’s their biggest series .. they already did it

[@ElderGod4]

@@midoelshafaey8026 nah its just started

[@fergusmallon1337]

Clean, concise, Informative. This is the best video on Charlemagne. He laid the groundwork for modern Europe.

[@NR-rv8rz]

At 13:58 it states that the Pope believes he has implicit superiority over the emperor. But this is not the case. The understanding was that the Pope had supremacy over spiritual matters and the Emperor had supremacy over earthly matters. That is why, if I am not mistaken, the Emperor kneels before the Pope to be crowned but after he is crowned the Pope bows to him.

[@nathanscarlett4772]

Interesting, I did not know this. Thank you.

[@justinian-the-great]

Ah Charlemagne, truly the greatest medieval European ruler.......well, at least bedsides us TRUE Romans.

[@sijanshamsulalam4243]

Very rare of you praising the barbarians of the west my liege.

[@nonnayerbusiness7704]

Too bad you left your own empire an over-extended, bankrupt and depopulated shadow of its former self.

[@chrissantos1012]

You’re not even Roman bro

[@justinian-the-great]

@@sijanshamsulalam4243 Well, the credit should be given where it is due. Sure, Charlemagne is a barbarian and a wicked one (he stole the one and all title of the Roman Emperor), but there was never a greater barbarian in the medieval Europe.....that is, as much "great" as barbarians can achieve greatness.

[@justinian-the-great]

@@nonnayerbusiness7704 Or perhaps famine, dozens of dammed earthquakes and, you know, a FRICKING SECOND WORST PANDEMIC OF PLAGUE IN THE ENTIRE HISTORY did that, huh? Also, I didn't really left my Empire bankrupt, since I managed to recover the economy in 550's, so I don't know from whom you heard that story of bankruptcy? At least my Empire existed for another 9 centuries, while Charlemagne's fell apart just 29 years after his death.

[@cidmatrix9643]

The maps just keep getting mappier. Love it!

[@jeffagain7516]

Thanks very much once again HistoryMarche for an outstanding vid! Just wanted to take a moment to mention that I am extremely happy to see your use of some of the most noteworthy paintings history has provided us, no more so than that of The Coronation of Charlemagne, at the T.S. 8:50 mark. I once saw a film that explained in great detail (forgive me, I forget the name of it) why the great artists drew what they drew. In essence, every person in these frescoes are there for a reason and in fact their individual gestures, expressions, actions, dress, etc has strong reason for being the way they are in the painting. An absolutely fascinating revelation to me back then and I've since tried to discover the hidden meanings portrayed in all the great artworks, since. Folks may wish to do the same, as it reveals FAR MORE to a painting than we ever actually imagined!

[@HistoryMarche]

Thank you so much for the positive feedback. Truly appreciated!

[@Austin_Schulz]

Leo III is actually considered a saint in the Catholic Church, probably for being one of the most based dudes of the Middle Ages.

[@rmp7400]

@Austin Based dudes?

[@oboroth51]

Papist schismatic🤢

[@younes2415]

He was truly great, to put into perspective, all of West Europe was broken in pieces, no unity but all of that changed with his hard work!!

[@thhseeking]

And then fell apart gain after his death.

[@younes2415]

@@thhseeking he left a basis for a state in Germany and France, to put into perspective again, there was no unity in what we call France now or Germany, he unified these towns and their economies.

[@Billswiftgti]

No unity after him either. False achievements, false emperor.

[@groundzero5708]

@@Billswiftgti only a fool like you will think like this

[@vladtarniceru394]

Great video and great editing! Just something I would love to have: the current year should always be displayed in the top-left side of the screen (it would be very nice to see how the years pass by as I observe the teritorial changes) and also to have the current age of each character displayed near/inside their flag. Anyways, thanks again for the great work & content, I learn a lot from it!

[@GabrielBelmont4727]

One of the best channels. So detailed and vivid. The quality is bombastic. Thanks for making these amazing videos!

[@ryanrogers9457]

The illustrations are so good!

[@HistoryMarche]

Thank you sir.

[@zacjie1551]

😀

[@jezm7828]

The character details are very challenging.

[@zacjie1551]

@@jezm7828 :}

[@arabian9372]

Oh how long have i wated! This is the kind of channels that deserve the most support in KZbin, not the silly ones, thank you 🌹

[@AeneasGemini]

what's wrong with silly channels? Plenty of room for both to be appreciated!

[@arabian9372]

@@AeneasGemini hungry for argument much? watch jake paul and the likes of him, if there is room for them in your time, but not mine dear aeneas, not mine

[@talleyhoe846]

I wish superb content like this was available when I was studying history. Brings it to life thereby greatly facilitating comprehension and retention.

[@ArabianRazumZar]

Charlemagne was one of the most influential figures in Christianity can’t wait for part 2 Will there be a battle ?

[@kolerick]

well, there are few that documented further than the result... the one that would be documented would be a defeat, in Ronceveau...

[@almightydummy]

true, every European colonizers execute natives that worships other Gods. Good old days.

[@zahirhussain5913]

What did Charlemagne ? Destroying the places of worship was also used as an alternative method of conversion when peaceful means of persuasion ( preaching , miracles , etc. ) or social factors ( rewards , etc. ) seemed insufficient ". ARTICLE : Christian Attitude towards Pagan Monuments in Late Antiquity and Their Legacy in Later Byzantine Centuries page - 49 AUTHOR : Helen Saradi - Mendelovici SOURCE : Dumbarton Oaks Papers , Vol. 44 ( 1990 ) , pp. 47-61

[@zahirhussain5913]

Christianity spread by sword: Charlemagne conducted his first campaign against Saxons in 772 AD .His forces advanced rapidly to the castle of Eresburg and destroyed the major Saxon shrine called the " Irminsul " The Royal Frankish Annals for 772 triumphantly claimed that huge amounts of treasure , consisting of gold and silver had fallen into Charlemagne's hands , plunder that may have been pagan sacrificial offerings ; this booty also seemed to fire the enthusiasm of the king's retinue for waging war . BOOK : CHARLEMAGNE . Author : Johannes Fried . Translated by Peter Lewis . Edition 2016 page - 99 .

[@zahirhussain5913]

Under Charlemagne rule : " Many people died in infancy , some in maturity and others in old age " . " Many of the poor found themselves forced by sheer poverty to kill their infant offspring , above all , girls . Many other babies were exposed and left to die- archetypes for the fairy tale of Hansel and Gretel . It was just a fact of life then that some times people found it impossible to feed their children . People lived in their respective world's , rich or poor , sated or hungry , and not a few of them in desperate need . " BOOK : CHARLEMAGNE . Author : Johannes Fried . Translated by Peter Lewis . Edition 2016 page - 57 .

[@Remiball1221]

One of the best presentation I’ve ever seen , amazing narration guys. Show off!!!!!!

[@LewisPulsipher]

I've not studied Charlemagne's military campaigns specifically, but my understanding was that he conquered by superior numbers, logistics, and organization, not by big battles. A BIG battle was a chancy affair, and he wisely avoided them most of the time. E.g. he caused the Avars to disappear from history, without any big battle.

[@Dave_Sisson]

I've always wondered what race / linguistic group the Avars belonged to. Were they Germanic, Magyar, Turkic, Slavic or something else?

[@faramund9865]

C is pronounced K in Odoacer. And the A is 'soft' like in the word 'bar'. And the emphasis is, as always in Germanic words, on the first letter. >O

[@ragingsage3973]

I really wish that the 769 AD start date would be on CK3 but oh well.

[@williamtheconqueror7807]

Mhm.

[@niccolocaramori7288]

Play CK2 then or use a mod

[@TheMops14]

Don't worry, you'll get it in a DLC for 20$. That's Paradox for you.

[@impaugjuldivmax]

@@TheMops14 20$ just for maps, without skins of units

[@mariano98ify]

@@TheMops14 and not problem for me if the content of the expansions or vanilla game is good. What it is your problem? do you prefer that paradox focus in release sequels each X years???

[@jeffreese1828]

I read a book on Charlemagne , once , I think by Lamb , his accomplishments were absolutely phenomenal . Great vid , thanks !

[@kylebell7879]

You’re way better than KingsAndGenerals ❤

[@dawarrior95]

Thank you History Marche for doing what you do. My favorite History Channel on the tube. You may not release videos at the rate that the other channels do, but the ones you do release are of the upmost quality. It only gets better and better, to the point of being cinematic. You are doing heavenly work for us history nerds. Thank you.

[@ThisisBarris]

Brilliant video Mago! Can't wait for part 2.

[@HistoryMarche]

Coming soon!

[@arandomwalk]

You have inspired me to create a video! Will be coming out soon. No self promo, just appreciation to y’all

[@KHK001]

Did not expect video this soon! Thank u HM

[@luukkievit8892]

Man, John Julius Norwich could write very well. Extremely rich description that explains the concepts very clearly and concise. Simultaneously it is written as if it is a narration.

[@CivilWarWeekByWeek]

So glad for this story

[@Countinzeroeseveridai]

always a pleasure

[@unclesam5230]

Charlemagne is one of the greatest statesmen of middle age Europe who restored a portion of the Western Roman Empire.

[@alvarojaviervargasuriza2340]

I'm really greatful for the making of these videos, thank you.

[@charlemagne6644]

The spread of Christianity, was not just for a Cultural Unity. In the Cloisters, they could form a new Educated Upper Class. Reading and Writing helps alot for gaining Knowlege of all Kinds.

[@Leptospirosi]

Except the most ancient cloisters which started hosting valuable books, were built by the Lombard in Italy and by the Visigoth in southern France, both of which, by the VIII were fully converted to Catholic Christianity. Most of the new monastry came from Ireland to the mainlad, on which Charles had little to do with. Fact is that spreading of Christianity had little to do with Charles politics except to enforce control. As all of Germany was already catholic christian, the only "spread" Charles did of Christianity was over Saxony, a very small part of Germany, using faith as a tool to submit the tribes he had not completely genocided or deported.

[@krzkam7792]

love those videos

[@trentondamm194]

Once I saw empress Irene and the Byzantine Empire I cant stop watching this!! and can you guys please do the rise and battles of basil II or the rain of Empress Irene !:)

[@ΘΕΟΦΑΝΩΚΟΜΝΗΝΟΣ]

Basil the Hellenic sator!

[@trentondamm194]

@@ΘΕΟΦΑΝΩΚΟΜΝΗΝΟΣ More like Basil the Bulgar Slayer!

[@jonathancummings6400]

Had they had this sort of presentation of his greatness, they wouldn't have balked at embracing him and joining him to restore the Roman Empire in it's full ancient glory.

[@MrGordonSims]

The commercial at the beginning is one of the most engaging I’ve seen. Very well presented sales pitch. Also, these videos are incredibly well done.

[@evilinside6327]

It's the first time I learn about Charlemagne. Impressive individual.

[@papazataklaattiranimam]

The Abbasid caliphate reached its apogee under his rule, which was characterized by relative peace, prosperity, and unity of the Islamic community. Corresponded with and sent a diplomatic mission to the Holy Roman Emperor, Charlemagne, opening a period of technological and economic exchange with the West. Established a hostel for Christian pilgrims in Jerusalem. Set up the first hospital and observatory in Baghdad, which served as models for later rulers.

[@shahsaud2625]

Well, medieval Islamic world was way better. It's now that the Muslim world is a mess

[@ru4582]

@@shahsaud2625 industrialization definitely brought many more sources of division into the Muslim world than the previous millennia. The abbasids didn’t have to deal with imperialism and weird borders and had a relatively united caliphate under their governance. Hell, they had an actual caliphate to work with, whereas the position has been vacant nowadays ever since the dissolution of the Ottomans.

[@Artur_M.]

If I'm not mistaken, they sent a living elephant in this mission, as one of the gifts.

[@shaynebiggs8831]

You guys and kings and generals are the best I've found.thank you

[@f.e.gviper1601]

This is very convenient I’m taking AP ero this year and we had to learn the time period of 750 to 1450 over the summer.

[@faizananjum36]

The best Channel for War History and is never biased, great job. Do make a Documentary about Ghazva Khandak !

[@zaidbayaty3865]

Great work 👏 👍 I would like to suggest a series to cover the second crusade both the Eastern and western parts which not yet covered by any historical channel

[@markfiedler9415]

Thanks for doing a Charlemagne video! I feel like despite how influential his reign was I know comparatively little about it and the broader geopolitics and culture of the period.

[@xenotypos]

It wasn't the "holy" roman empire yet, it was just called the roman empire. The HRE is an entity that is indeed derived from Charlemagne's empire, but noticeably different as well, and not just in name. The HRE as we know it will be created later, in a more germanic-centric context.

[@wy2041]

Actually that would be the germanic Holy Roman Empire, not the same thing as the Holy Roman Empire

[@johnnyboy3410]

the actual Holy Roman Empire is the one Otto The Great created i guess but it wasn’t called Holy until Fredreich Barbossa one of the greatest if not greatest Holy Roman emperors, he was the one who named it holy

[@sebe2255]

I would say a more German context. The Frankish Empire definitely had a Germanic character, given that the Franks themselves were and still are Germanic.

[@xenotypos]

@@sebe2255 It doesn't have much to do with the differences between the Carolingian empire and the HRE. But since you're mentioning it, I'd argue that the early Franks didn't that much to do with the later Franks. During Charlemagne time, "frank" had been a term designing the people in a lot of places including modern day France for centuries. And there are a lot of Germanic ancestry in the northern half of France. French itself was influenced by germanic dialects even if it's a latin language.

[@sebe2255]

@@xenotypos Not really. Frank became a general term to refer to people from western Europe because of the success of the Frankish Empire. Other cultures labeling a very broad region of western europe as Frankish has little relevance to determining who the Franks were ath that point. When you say early Franks were little like later Franks, that is true and untrue. In the sense that later Franks were more organized christians, they were little like early Franks. But they still spoke their language and continued many cultural practices. Of course over hundreds of years cultures change, but that applies to every culture, and in that way, no culture is like it was 1000 years ago. Neither Franks, nor French of Germans or anyone beyond those regions. As for the Germanic heritage in northern France, of course there is some, but it is limited to the very north and the Alsace. And not all of them are Frankish in nature, the Alsace for one is/was Allemanic.

[@onetwothreefourfive12345]

Another fantastic vid from one of my top 3 history channels :)

[@zhugeliang2121]

Thank you for providing us with more valuable videos translated into Arabic💜

[@HistoryMarche]

My pleasure 😊 Arabic subtitles added.

[@zhugeliang2121]

@@HistoryMarche We have benefited a lot from the history of your channel and I hope all your historical videos are from all over the world Chinese and European to translate into Arabic

[@darkovia111]

Charlamagne is an ancestor of mine. I have a ton of nobility in my family lines and i can trace both of my parents lines at least as far back as Charlamagne and further. Its actually really cool seeing how far back it goes on charts.

[@rosshugecaulk]

That's like any Asian guy saying he's related to Gengis Khan lmao

[@historyforyou3327]

Don't forget to share the interaction of Charlemagne with Muslim sultan Haroon Al Rasheed

[@wyattforbess7504]

Best channel ever, I swear

[@JawsOfHistory]

I find it equally fascinating that the title Magnus - Charlemagne comes from "Carolus Magnus" in Latin, "Charles the Great" - has survived since antiquity (i.e. Pompeius Magnus, Caesar's rival in the Roman civil war) as I found it disappointing that Charlemagne wasn't just a really cool name.

[@FatGouf]

Just call him Charlie the Great.

[@Nielsly]

Karl the Great sounds less impressive than Charlemagne

[@BillGreenAZ]

Whenever I see the name Charlemagne, I try to think of it as "Charles the Magnificent" since it shares the root of that word.

[@Nielsly]

@@BillGreenAZ magnificent comes from magnificentior “great in deeds”, from magnificus, from magnus + facere “to act great”, magne comes from just magnus “(the) great/big”. So Karl the Great, in the same row as Alexander and Peter, not in the same row as Suleiman.

[@BillGreenAZ]

@@Nielsly So Charlemagne means "large Charles" and not "magnificent Charles"?

[@sparrowman]

This is brilliant quality. Only epic history is it's equal.

[@resileaf9501]

Good new style of video! It's good to vary the content to include non-battle videos too. Looking forward to part 2!

[@HistoryMarche]

Glad you enjoyed!

[@adamdrake6750]

Your voice is perfect for these videos

[@DeardropsRiho]

Let's shed the blood of the Saxon men!

[@nightrunner3701]

They were pagans… For the ignorant morons out there… Even IF the pagans were not raiding civilized lands, they were always fighting each other, so inevitably 1 if the various groups will try to get help from the civilization closest. Providing ample reason for conquest.

[@dittmannrudolfrohr2149]

@@nightrunner3701 "Pagan" is an exonym.

[@AlphaSections]

@@nightrunner3701 I thoughts exactly!

[@ramiromen6595]

It's insane that we never had a proper series about Charlemagne in any of the big channels..... Until know! Thanks HM!

[@kolerick]

I guess the lack of accurate battles recounts is the problem... we know of the results and maybe 1 "good" recount that was defeat because of the "comments" that come with the song of Rolland, but most of his known/recorded work was "political" and that isn't what youtuber believe the most interesting for their viewers... so there are a few series about him, but on "indies" channels... need to specifically search it

[@KiranSingh-zr8jr]

Sad how his empire fractured just after his death.

[@AlexC-ou4ju]

it lasted at least trough his son Louis the Pious, who ruled for 27 years, it wasn't quite alexander and the diadochi

[@nervachadikus]

@@AlexC-ou4ju Yeah but Louis barely held it together and by the end of his reign his sons were tearing the empire apart for the second time

[@prs_81]

Charlie got the mil stats high but didn't do enough cul tech to reach past gavelkind. A newbie mistake if you ask me

[@DarkKing009]

I said it once and I'll say it again. I like it knowing it will be great before seeing the video!

[@Awesomewithaz]

Last time I was this early Charlemagne wasn't even Emperor yet.

[@konstandinostsintaris8445]

I missed history march videos. I thought the channel was slowly and sadly dying but this great video proved that is still rising

[@zacjie1551]

Subscribed😁

[@HistoryMarche]

Welcome to the channel.

[@zacjie1551]

@@HistoryMarcheThanks

[@wolfbeastdevil]

It has been so intriguging to understand the ways of the past leaders and their principles of ther governence which brought greatness to its people and their lands

[@inuuteqstotts9639]

Thank you! Keep it up HistoryMarche!

[@chasemurraychristopherdola7108]

Just saying but I would love to see a video on the 778 battle of Roncevaux pass and I am interested in this battle because even though it was a defeat for charlemagne the battle saw the death of a Frankish military leader named Roland and his death elevated him and the members of charlemagnes court aka the paladins into legend becoming the quintessential role model for knights and greatly influencing the code of chivalry in the Middle Ages aka the dark ages and this battle is recounted in the 11 century The song of Roland which is the oldest surviving major work of French literature.

[@rafiullahqazi7731]

I only love your voice when you are explaining. In other videos I hardly watched it because there was a different voice but you're one has magic Mashallah (protect you from evil eyes).

OH YES, this oughta be delightful

[@thhseeking]

Betty!!

[@TwinIonEngines]

I learn more from you guys than any history book, please keep up the fantastic work! (And soothing voice work)

[@youvebeengreeked]

Charlemagne and Irene could have literally just declared the Western and Eastern Roman Empires respectively. This makes me mad af 😂😅

[@Hades_Orkos]

Honestly pretty ridiculous

[@laonch6073]

No? He missed so much land from the actual "Western Roman Empire" that it's almost ridiculous... Don't forget literally illirya, the rest of Spain, England, and well, Africa

[@youvebeengreeked]

@@laonch6073 I meant more in status rather than physical boundaries.

[@laonch6073]

@@youvebeengreeked even status wise, it wasn't an empire like the WRE used to be, he didn't start any process of Romanisation (or Frankisation) (I mean, not many empires did that though). Status wise was just a big chunk of land, without a centralised or consolidated power. What then makes it similar or comparable to what the WRE was?

[@aurelian2668]

@@laonch6073 Yeah like in comparison was the franks even really roman? They did not have roman culture instead have a mixed one.

[@alien-vx2bj]

i have a big problem with chanel. i saw all the videos in just few days,some of them twice. the problem is that the upload rate is toooo low. love the quality of this videos. keep it up mate.

[@rashisti]

I gladly pay homage to the algorithm on behalf of HistoryMarche!

[@dillonblair6491]

I've been wanting a carolingian empire documentary for a while now 😳

[@الوليدبنمحمد-ذ5ذ]

He is the Father of All europeans and Father of Cross and Christianity

[@tapsaforss9504]

Steps to greatness 1. Grind 2. Rise 3. Fame Thats what my boi Charlemagne did💪

[@myheadisaverydarkplace7842]

Charlemagne like "Hey Saxons you aren't ready for me yet but your kids gonna love it".

[@stevo271]

FINALLY! Finally someone started Charlemagne in proper!

[@clementl.9566]

One might say that Charlemagne was the founding father of the german monarchy even though some may argue that Otto the first was the actual one, however, Charlemagne was definitely not the founding father of France since we had numerous rulers before him, starting with Clovis who is regarded as the founding father of the french monarchy by french historians and the French people.

[@DeutschlandMapping]

Well some French nationalist argue that the Frankish Empire and the Kingdom of France were the same with East Francia becoming independent from the Empire rather then the Empire splitting up into East and West.

[@katsuieshibata7493]

@@DeutschlandMapping From Hugh Capet to Phillip Augustus, all the kings titled themselves "King of Franks". Would you consider them Frankish or "French".

[@DeutschlandMapping]

@@katsuieshibata7493 Charlemagne held the title of "Roman Emperor". Was he Roman? No.

[@katsuieshibata7493]

@@DeutschlandMapping So they were not Franks, then they were French? What makes Hugh Capet French and his predecessors not?

[@skiteufr]

@@katsuieshibata7493 the Franks of Hugh Capet and the French from Philip Augustus are the same people. Only the name has been changed or modernised. The territory called Kingdom of the Franks and the people called France at the beginning of the reign of Philip are exactly the same than those at the end of his reign

[@deamonomic]

What makes a country/civilization great? Is it the monuments they erect? Is it the strength of their army and military victories? Is it scientific progress? In my mind, the true judge of how good a civilization is, is how well they can care for their people.

[@Dornan77802]

Of course, the “Holy Roman Empire” would get divided eventually like all other pretenders to the Roman legacy. With a style of Emperor selection being just as bad as the “Byzantine” way of selecting an Emperor.

[@raigarmullerson4838]

One great documentary after another. Love the videos and cheers from Estonia

[@AlexC-ou4ju]

Long live Charlemagne King of the Franks, father of modern Europe! Patron of the arts and education! May his vision and memory endure!

[@ΘΕΟΦΑΝΩΚΟΜΝΗΝΟΣ]

Fun fact: Even do the Byzantines were the heirs of the Roman Empire, they didin't have the administrative traditions nor the customs of the Ancient Romans, while the Holy Roman Empire shared tons of traditions with the Ancient Roman culture and customs. Irene of Athens got to be a "Basilissa Satora" thanks to the Hellenistic customs and administrative practices of the Byzantines yet a women in the throne was seign as wholy wrong by the ancient Romans and Holy Romans.

[@sauronmordor7494]

a ok

[@ΘΕΟΦΑΝΩΚΟΜΝΗΝΟΣ]

@Marcelo Henrique Soares da Silva Until 476 maybe. Afterwards the Byzantines were deeply Hellenized.

[@sauronmordor7494]

@Marcelo Henrique Soares da Silva ;o

[@bobbyjoe1111]

Best History Channel damn

[@KiranSingh-zr8jr]

When "Holy Roman empire" was actually an "empire".

[@heroe480]

And Holy

[@JuTakii]

@UCDvp9RkhpTl45oWatdqbB0g why are you being so rude about it, just summarize it yourself or say nothing. No need to be so cross.

[@Mma-basement-215]

Charlemagne the great !!!

[@d1a9m9i1lare]

Is it true he had 500 or 5000 Germanic warriors beheaded because they won't submit to Christianity?

[@isakhanofbengal5936]

How sad

[@jackparker8602]

Yes. It's called the Massacre of Verden. And they were all Saxon nobles.

[@assyrianempire4341]

Pagans killed Christians…Christians killed pagans 🤷‍♂️ thats history

[@asgeer5351]

Yes.

[@BrunoOLucido]

As it should, they are raiders barbarians

[@robbabcock_]

Great video! I can't wait for the next installment.

[@zhugeliang2121]

Charlemange was the first Frenchman to unite most of Europe under his rule.

[@AeneasGemini]

To be fair, he did better than the second one

[@freewal]

@@AeneasGemini England was not interfering in French/Frankish affairs back then. They were too Weaks. Charlemagne reign is a golden age for Europe. Like Napoleon.

[@TheKingmanIII]

Charlemagne was not French. He has little in common with the French and his relationship to them is as a man who ruled over them from a foreign Germanic elite.

[@freewal]

@@TheKingmanIII French people is historically a mix of Latin and Germanic people …

[@TheKingmanIII]

@@freewal No, the French are a mix of Celtic, Latin and in northern France some Germanic influences. Charlemagne was extracted from a Frankish elite which was purely Germanic, which makes him significantly more closely related to Germans, Anglo-Saxons and other Germanic groups than to the French.

[@dontbemad8894]

Thank you for making such great videos on historic battles.

[@msaley6033]

"The Holy Roman Empire was neither holy, nor Roman, nor an empire"

[@robertgrochowski687]

100% truth.

[@anantawibawa5315]

yeah i agree with that

[@BrunoOLucido]

It as, did you watched the video?

[@crzypopemonkey]

Sacrifice has been made to the algorithm! Been subbed already, but liked and commented. I appreciate your content, such high quality!

[@illuminousarc75]

Charlemagne's France: Rule over 8 countries in today times The Roman Empire: Pathetic

[@HoH]

This was great - Fantastic artwork, maps & such smooth editing (and of course Charlemagne's story is spectacular 😜)

[@HistoryMarche]

Thank you! 😄

[@user-gt7hl3nz1n]

Living for the day when a "historical" video calls the Empire Roman and not Byzantine.

[@canadious6933]

@Drake Hashimoto (MV) I second your opinion. However one question I would like to put out there for anyone who would like to clarify. But since the Byzantium is the Eastern Roman Empire, why did they have an issue with a new Emperor in the west? Since before the fall of west rome, there was 2 emperors already. I get that the pope was trying to delegitimize the East but if they remembered their own history, Constantinople was always the "second" part of rome.

[@maxion5109]

@Drake Hashimoto (MV) yes this seems to be an ongoing argument. I dont mind the label since the ERE at that point was quite a different beast from the previous years of classical urban society around the mediterranean, at least culturally. There was a lot of draining of what was Roman or non-Christian during Justinians reforms in the 6th century, the closing of the Academy of Athens and the end of the so called "Second Sophistic". After that a new kind of identity was created for society in the east which i think with some justification can be called Byzantine.

[@maxion5109]

@@canadious6933 but it became the "New Rome" after the WRE fell. So there is always just one "Rome". But it's true there were two emperors and before that the Tetrarchy after Diocletians reform with a senior and junior emperor in both west and east. I assume this is about an issue that there could only be one Christian emperor after Constantine the Great but im not entirely sure. Well Charlemagne was probably viewed as an imposter by the Byzantines as this Frankish strongman could not claim any direct line as they could in the east

[@swaythegod5812]

Greeks aren’t Roman Constantinople isn’t Rome They spoke Greek not Roman Latin

[@daegudiva]

A most excellent video! Well done

[@denniscleary7580]

My wife is actually a distant descendant of Charlemagne

[@makahmed7130]

Does your wife have younger sister ?

[@shahsaud2625]

@@makahmed7130 Jesus man

[@kaldirdimgobegi]

Wtf

[@nikola4962]

I enjoyed this so much, magnificent work