Chase and Melia React to 비투비(BTOB)의 킬링보이스를 라이브로! | Killing Voice

[@ilhoonsquad]

btob being called proper is the funniest thing to me. truly unhinged is what they are

[@cassie7thomson]

I know, I thought it was funny them calling them "proper" - they only look that way here, they are bonkers at times lol

[@bees0la276]

I guess the succeeded in fooling people, because if we know one thing about BTOB and it’s that they are unhinged 😂

[@sevenbelledays7800]

That's exactly what I thought 😂😂😂😂

[@MELODY_LABYU]

This is true. I kind of giggled a bit when they say.. proper. The word proper and btob would just.. repelled🤣

[@loric5855]

They are a talented hot mess! I'm totally here for it.

[@changsubber]

btob went from being a band, acapella group, acrobatic group to a dance group. they literally got everything. they even compose and produce their own music and is literally the funniest group out there U NEEEED TO WATCH MOREEE

[@pocky11stick]

They tried everything but still so fckn underrated 😢

[@half_plastic2367]

They started as a dance group, so your order is a bit messed up 😂😂

[@Cherrryyyymelo]

​@@pocky11stick international yes but not in sk.. they're second famous after bts... and have huge fandom

[@jasmineyejiapsa2267]

@@half_plastic2367 i think what she meant is the pre debut era, it’s right that they were supposed to debut as a band, then they train to be an acapella, acrobatic, but in the end they debuted as a dance group. cmiiw 😊

[@Portiayuu]

@@pocky11stick To be fair, they aren't as underrated as you'd think. You can only apply underrated to them internationally but tbh they are still more well known internationally than some groups out there. But in Korea? girl, they're the second most popular group especially during their prime. Even when Yoo Jae Suk who is like the national mc of Korea was asked who is his favorite group. He says it's btob and they have also sang their songs twice during their concerts on running man which is a big thing because running man is one of the biggest variety shows in Korea. Btob's song missing you was also the 3rd longest charted song in melon after 2 bts songs. And even though they don't have as much attention now compared to when they were at their peak. It's still really impressive for them to get such results and support for a group who has been in the industry for 10 years, went on hiatus for 3-4 years, lost one of the key members. But they're still very much relevant. I wouldn't be surprised if they'll get another missing you type of success in the future since a lot of Koreas still know them even the younger ones.

[@Sarah_2505]

The reason why they seemed a little bit out of tune is because dingo edited their voices. BTOB were so loud that their voice were getting into eachothers mics. And that's why dingo edited it. Alot of adlibs weren't clear because of the same reason too. Dingo actually gave a statement regarding it too because melodies (fandom name) pointed it out

[@td8446]

This needs to be up up up! as a lot of people don't know this fact!

[@l3lugu]

Really? I'm not even a melody but when I saw the mics I thought they seemed too close to each other for the level of "noise" these guys can make, their voices can be so big and loud I'd have thought their mics would be placed further apart or the show would have taken proper precautions because it's really well known these guys have very powerful lungs

[@benetampi]

Well melody is the best too. LOL, they even notice what common people dont.

[@sarahkeilany7583]

Actually.. what I believe is that the pitch the boys are using are exactly what was needed and directed for the specific songs... it is to the liking of the director or producer.... isnt it? I am saying this because I remember watching their behind the scenes (if that is what it's called😅)

[@키오-c6t]

어쩐지 평소보다 안맞는 느낌, 편곡도 갑자기 들어가는 느낌이 강해서 아쉬웠는데.. 일반인 친구도 이거 보고 비투비 관심있고 하이어도 좋아해서 좀 아쉬웠어요 ㅜㅜ 특히 괜찮아요는 젤 좋아하던.. 화음 오지는 곡인데 ㅜㅠㅠㅠ

[@changsubber]

actually if there were any weird out of tune parts, fans actually complained to dingo (the one who made the killing voice video) about the same thing that they were editing their adlibs and voices slightly. dingo apologised and said that it was because btob was so loud their voices overlapped each other’s mics so that’s why 😭😭

[@letter131]

yup, dingo said it sounded like 12 people were singing, so they had to edit it

[@tasyacamila9882]

Hey, is there any source about what you said? Thanks.

[@kynanzweekez872]

Omg! You are right! There are added adlibs. I was hearing someone on the higher harmony being off in one of the songs but it didn't make sense because no one was doing it when I was looking at their lips. Now that I see your comment, it makes sense.

[@honeybee_241]

@@tasyacamila9882 I heard the source is from the dingo audio director's tweet

[@donnysky12]

This!! Lol

[@칼세도니]

Dingo's editor informed that they had to edit BTOB's voices because their voices were so loud that it sounded like 12 of them were singing together.

[@ngaszeng129]

I think that did them bad on the harmony part of Pray/I'll be Your Man. Damn I was waiting to hear our 4 big vocal belting and 2 rapper aggressively rapping 😢

[@aroundus4088]

"you cant have low note and high note, you need to pick one" LOLOLOL hyunsik really really impressive! He has very wide vocal range and he knows it lol

[@flafri]

now that I watched this entire thing, I can comment that you are actually very right about them being "trained": Changsub (orange collar guy), Hyunsik (white shirt & tie guy) and Eunkwang (dark blue sweater guy) studied Practical Music in college (changsub and hyunsik with a crazy acceptance rate of a cutthroat 3000:5 ratio at their year), and Changsub and Eunkwang are both musical theatre actors. On top of that, Hyunsik and Minhyuk (far left rapper with the cool speaking voice) compose and write most of BTOB songs, so they're really the whole package! One thing you're wrong about is about them being proper tho; they're probably the most loud and funny kpop group out there and they're not afraid to appear silly or dumb in any circumstances🤣🤣

[@Shutthemos]

Yook Sung-jae also won first place as a vocalist in "Fantastic Duo" and also won first place in "Duet Song Festival.He was praised for being the perfect vocalist on "King of Mask Singer" kzbin.info/www/bejne/rHKaq4yIfZVqY7s

[@mypaceskz9949]

Just to add, Hyunsik (the one in white shirt and tie) is actually taking his graduate degree in music as well.

[@sixteenskies]

adding too! minhyuk actually also studied musical theater in college 😊 prolly why he’s so good at narrating and putting in so many different emotions when he raps!

[@wndthomas]

I love BTOB not only for their amazing performances but for the fact that they broke the KPOP mode for every idol having to appear amazing and without fault, perfect. They showed everyone that in fact everyone is human everyone has flaws and you can still be amazing ❤ they make me smile at the worst times and that is not an easy thing for people to do ❤️

[@yjas8904]

​@@wndthomasthe real entertainer indeed. more importantly they truly enjoy performing and entertaining other people. maybe that's why they got to this point despite being underrated for a few years after debuting

[@Miraiwhitelock]

Never expected btob and the word 'proper' in one sentence together 😂😂 don't get fooled, they're one of the craziest kpop groups.

[@eva1585]

Hearing that made me audibly snort-laugh

[@paeawg7967]

me too ..I laugh to the max ahha they are loud and funny.they don't care how dumb they look like..they just want to have fun performing😂

[@andhiniretno3886]

im really loving the attention hyunsik has gotten thru killing voice. he is insane. this guy got insane range, tone, technic on top of that he got bachelor and masters degree in practical music, plays every musical instruments (he got credited for playing almost every instruments on his solo album), knows how to compose and arrange. literally a musical genius

[@yjas8904]

wow idk he also played most instruments in his solo album. I really like his album a lot

[@sliracha]

out of the other vocalists, hyunsik really got the most stable vocal. like I've never heard that man's voice cracked

[@Semiria5]

and not to mention he's BTOB's Main Dancer. insanity

[@dudu8925]

as someone who love singer kyungsoo, i also love hyunsik. they have some similarities in term of their technique. no doubt they were in a same band back in high school:)))

[@erikac2720]

Hyunsik not only has this crazy voice range, but also plays so many instruments and produces BTOB songs using his own recorded samples. He just didnt left anything for others. He does everything!

[@izzahizzati6184]

Absolutely right.. He took everything including my heart ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@mirraarrim3155]

Father of Music for Btob no doubt💙 음악의 아버지

[@jakajan3187]

Can even rap and is the main dancer-

[@MythicalMacaron]

hyunsik's phone is btob's treasure since he keeps samples there hahaha

[@huhyunjingf]

It's cool that you made Men's Choir because they were originally trained to be an acapella group. They even trained a lot with the Boyz II Men songs, which you compared at the beginning of the video. Changsub (orange collar) has range indeed. His is wild and this video, although very good, does not show everything he is really capable of. For you to have an idea at the age of 15, long before his debut he had already won a singing competition. He trained to be part of an acapella, band and then finally kpop group idol. He had vocal nodules, his throat wasn't in the best condition and he kind of had to learn to sing again. He is a musical actor, and was in a military band during the military mandate period. All this made him absorb a lot. He has a lot of vocal knowledge. I think his voice is the most adaptable precisely because he has experienced almost everything and has overcome obstacles the most. That's why he's my favorite voice. He has a very beautiful vocal color and sings like an angel. Whenever I see vocal techs reacting to BTOB they praise Changsub's vocal control, and it's something I've started to notice when listening to him. It's amazing. It's interesting that you said that the best falsettos come from baritones because Sungjae (white shirt with blue lines) is also considered a baritone, but he has some falsettos that make no sense how good he is. Like, in the song When It Rains, there's a high note in the background that everyone swore was Eunkwang until they sang it live and we found out it was Sungjae. It was mind blowing, and also not because it's BTOB after all. I was really happy when you praised Sungjae at the end because he definitely has the most emotionally charged voice in the group, and that makes listening to him so beautiful. He makes people want to cry when he sings. You guys mentioned DK, and he did a musical with Eunkwang (guy in the blue navy sweater). By the way, Eunkwang is considered one of the best vocalists in kpop. Like, he can do so much more. Masked Singer? Won all. Sing in soprano? No problem. High notes? It's his house. This guy is simply incomparable. All this praise for Hyunsik (all white shirt ty) makes my heart swell with happiness. Everyone in BTOB loves music. 100%. Their motto is to sell emotion, not albums. But Hyunsik is made of music. There is no way to describe his passion in words. He's just made of music. This guy grew up with music. His father is one of the best folk singers in South Korea, so he grew up with music. He can play so many instruments. He knows how to do so much. For you to have an idea, 90% of the songs in this video were all his composition and production. He has an amazing solo project called Rendez Vousz. It's full of stuff about the universe, the galaxy, and that smart stuff because he's smart too (of course he is, what isn't he?). But it's also very beautiful, kind, poetic and romantic because that's what Hyunsik is all about. He even did a free concert on the street for the fans because he just loves music and he loves sharing it with us. He is the most genuine and passionate guy I know. BTOB is a group with 11 years of experience. Sadly, one of the few old groups that survived and is still active. In this kpop world where all eyes are on what's new, they've managed to stick together and keep making music. So much so that in Korea they aren't even considered just kpop idols anymore, but artists (it's a whole cultural thing, but y'all get the idea) This video is just a little taste of what BTOB is really capable of. Everyone can sings. Minhyuk (the one in the light blue shirt) is the group's rapper by choice, as he also knows how to sing beautifully. His voice is very melodic and smooth. And yes, his speaking voice is really beautiful, so much so that he is a presenter on a radio station. Peniel (the last one) could barely speak Korean well, and look how he is today. He never stopped challenging himself and still overcomes obstacles today. And the results of this is his evolution, which if you knew it, you would be moved. Although the few times he sang, I always thought his voice was beautiful. Ilhoon (former member, forever loved) was simply one of the best rappers in Korea and yet, even jokingly, he sang like no one else. They are the complete package. Recognized as the kindest, most genuine, most talented, funniest, most crackheads people in the industry, and that's not even me saying it, it's everyone who worked/lived with them. There's always a new report/story of what good people they are, fun to be around, respectful, comfortable to talk to. This comes from staff, tv show producers, other idols and even regular people who only met them once. I am very proud to be their fan. Thank you so much for the video and the time you took to react to it. Killing Voice is something we've wanted for a long time for the boys, but it's nowhere near what they're actually capable of. They have so much more and I would be very happy if you take this journey. It doesn't have to be on video, just in your personal, feeling the voices as passionate music listeners. Their songs are known for being sentimental to the extreme, deep and meaningful. Thanks for being so kind, respectful and for all the technical information that put into words the meaning of the group's talent. 🤗❤️ Sorry for the giant comment and if there are any grammar mistakes (English is not my native language)

[@kyrrasaoy4599]

please know that i adore your whole comment. thank you for introducing btob to them this way.

[@warinch99]

Thank you💙

[@Piyo-yl2ro]

U just write an essay about BTOB 🤣🤣🤣

[@maliii266]

You wrote this beautifully! I’m so proud to be Melody💙

[@suriyanisamad]

Wow!full essei 1🫡

[@haetchocho3454]

From left to right: Minhyuk, Sungjae, Eunkwang, Hyunsik, Changsub, and Peniel BTOB, all of them are vocalists😂

[@shenvi]

BTOB is honestly the only group with 10/10 vocals and 10/10 rapping. Their entire group is so talented! WATCH SOME LIVE PERFORMANCES PLEASEEEE!

[@blairbass2232]

Lol! SB19 says hi! they write, compose and produce their music...choreograph their dance, creative director of their MV and lastly they made their own label... they did everything from scratch! a very versatile group! RnB, ballad, pop, rap, hiphop, rock, and even Country...they can do it!

[@1marieleathem]

This is not true. They are not the only ones. There is so much talent in KPOP and many of the groups write and produce and contribute to choreography. It's pretty common. It's ok for many to be excellent.

[@shenvi]

@@1marieleathem Well that's your opinion. I think I have the right to have my own opinion. I agree that there are so many talented groups, but I don't think you have the right to tell me that my opinion isn't true.

[@1marieleathem]

@@shenvi It didn't sound like an opinion, it sounded like you thought you were stating a fact. You're entitled to your opinion, of course. There is a huge amount of talent in KPOP and there are outstanding rappers, vocalists, producers, composers, lyricists in many, many groups and I guess, whoever your favorite group is will seem like 'the best".

[@qiqiprobablyforgot]

@@blairbass2232 excuse me?! Btob also writes their own songs

[@tarotmonica]

Melia you are on POINT that they sounds “trained”! Vocalists, 4 guys in the middle all graduated with vocal/practical music degree in uni and tie guy, hyunsik and orange collar, changsub graduated top tier vocalist uni. That school’s entrance was so competitive that admission ratio was 3000:5. So yea these guys are more “properly” trained haha

[@hazreenhamidon5977]

50:55 I thought no one would mentioned Sungjae (2nd to the left).. When I watched the killing voice (before this reaction), Sungjae’s voice left me the biggest impact. Like I noticed him more than other members. So proud of Sungjae ♡

[@piratepoppers7042]

exactly, i LOVE sungjae's voice

[@joycb5129]

Sungjae doesnt get much attention when singing along his hyungs because the other 3 are just more advanced in their techniques. Sungjae on the other hand gives me or makes me feel so much emotions in his singing which is why I love listening to him. He’s my favorite person in kpop!!! Whenever he sings solo...It makes me want to cry!!!

[@sjywd1817]

trueee he left me big impression after killing voice vid esp 2nd confession part its soooo addicting. plus im a casual fan of them so i didnt really noticed his voice before so its surprise me that he is soo good at singing ❤❤❤

[@akiraamamiya6008]

His voice captivated me when I watched Master in the House,now I'm a fullblown Melody lol

[@symone_angel0762]

@Joy CB totally agree, when people ask me who's my bias in BTOB, everytime i say its Sungjae, their reaction will be, ahh bcoz of the face...and i'll be like, Nooo, its his voice...there's just something in Sungjae's voice that makes me feel emotional in so many ways..

[@shalsadillar3997]

Finally Hyunsik’s voice being praised 😭 I love his voice so much.. he can sing both low and high note, arrange music, writing lyrics, play piano and guitar. Gosh He’s so dreamy 😭

[@junkyuseum]

29:22 & 50:56 Other vocal coaches barely notices Sungjae, so big thanks to you, guys! For seeing and acknowledging how great he is too. 🤧 Sometimes, because his hyungs are so excellent, he’s rarely praised for his singing which is unfortunate.

[@azemelo3426]

During an episode of OOTB's Jeongwaja, one of the students said that the professor always shows videos of BTOB as an example to resonance

[@sa_yanchifuyu]

Sorry which ep is it?

[@azemelo3426]

@@sa_yanchifuyu Episode 22

[@peekabbyu]

BTOB is one of the KINGS of live performances. I super love them.

[@sliracha]

this is the first time ive heard people call btob proper😭💀💀 anyway yall need to see more of them, live stages and everything. they have one of the best vocal in kpop rn

[@hoppipollaedits5116]

I love that Hyunsik is getting well-deserved compliments because of Killing Voice. A lot of people know Eunkwang is a monster in terms of vocal techniques (I do think this performance only showcased very little of what he can do so please react to his Immortal Songs stage singing “That Man”). Changsub has always been the instant favorite of newer fans bc of the quality of his voice. So that leaves Hyunsik’s insane vocal range and precision and Sungjae’s beautiful, emotional tone being less known among newer or non-fans. So thank you! All of them are different yet all incredible.

[@PreenNiie]

Love your comment, especially, when you mentioned about Eunkwang. This might be the reason why he was chosen to be “ main vocal” position and the leader during their debut. By the way, BTOB can prove that they are 7 vocal ( as Eunkwang said, all of vocal positions in BTOB ; Eunkwang, Changsub, Hyunsikand Sungjae are main vocalist, not only him) I’m so proud of being a Melody! 🩵💙✨

[@jruth4557]

Oh it was actually Hyunsik who first catched my attention. His voice and his smile😊 But I do agree with you🥰🥰

[@johns80schick]

I was a fan of changsub for about the first week I listened to them. Then I noticed Hyunsik and his amazing vocals and never looked back lol. Just him in front of a paino with his soulful voice is all you need. I love his solo music too. I listen to him everyday. I think Changsub is easy to like, he has a fun personality and a beautiful singing voice. But don't sleep on Hyunsik, especially the opening to his song swimming. wow great smooth sound.

[@ayaka0077]

For me, it’s completely the opposite: at first I noticed Hyunsik, but then something went wrong. I've been liking Changsub's vocals lately😅

[@johns80schick]

How could you leave Hyunsik lol@@ayaka0077

[@rxchelxx9944]

They are one of the best vocals groups in kpop, there hasn’t really been a boy group to outsing them

[@letter131]

Firstly, thanks so much for the reaction Chase and Melia. Secondly, our fandom is called 'Melody' ^^ nice to meet you. We may be a bit small to other fandoms, but we are extremely tight and as a long-lasting fandom in the industry for 10 years, we are verrrrry open and one of the chillest warmest fandoms. I'm a young fan who joined just this year, so I have been welcomed by many mature fans so I can say this confidently. So, please be open about comments, of course as long as it isn't harmful ^ v ^ //. In fact, we love when vocally focused channels do BTOB as our group is so talented, but we can't keep up with their skills. We flock to vocal coach channels, cus they catch out the more skill aspects, rather than our commentary which is usually, 'DAMN HIS HIGH NOTES ARE SO HOT'. Keep talking about their vocals, textures and all that professionalism PLS LOL So really haha you guys don't have to keep reassuring us by saying you aren't criticising them. In the kpop industry, Mamamoo and BTOB go hand in hand in vocals, so that's the kind of stuff you could expect. Except BTOB is a bit more vocal focused, teeny bit less dance in terms of discography. Thank you so much for this reaction Chase and Melia! Have a good, warm day.

[@kyrrasaoy4599]

oh my good gods, i resonate with this whole comment. i'm kinda 3 years into this btob rabbit hole and, seriously, once i see a vocal teacher or professional singer react to them, i learn smth every time. like the other day, i learned about the texture they add their voices in order to match the genre. now, i learned about the vowel placement and, holy hell, i've been listening at Beautiful Pain for a long time but i only learned about the many ways changsub pulled his section off in this video. while all this time, all i know and think and say is that btob sings so greatly. hahaha

[@letter131]

​@@kyrrasaoy4599from the reactor Katriinka???? AHAHAH CUS ACTUALLY I LEARNT THE SAME THING, I feel like by the time we've become 5 year melodies, we could practically sing opera...in theory only of course

[@shielafontanilla5257]

This comment really hit what I wanted to say. Mamamoo and BTOB

[@SleepingLittleHedgehog]

also most melodies and melodude i know like mamamoo too 😆😆

[@alexawoo1594]

@letter131 Wellcome to the most caring and beautiful fandome, as you said we are a bit small but we love our crazy guys 💖💖 From a Melody since the moment I saw their debut teasers 🫶🥰

[@Yung_Guac1]

The guy in the white shirt and black tie (Hyunsik) can quite literally do anything.. He can play all sorts of instruments, sing high and low notes, and he writes and composes most of BTOB songs. The members call him the Father of Music.

[@TheAwkRobot1997]

Hyunsik, the guy in the white shirt and tie, is such a musical genius and I’m so happy for all the praise he got in this video. He is the son of a very popular 80s folk singer, he composes and produces the majority of the music BTOB releases, and his vocal range is just absolutely insane. He has an amazing live performance with his father, that is just phenomenal, I hope you can listen to. I do hope you can react to more from BTOB in the future- I promise you will not be disappointed. 💙💙💙💙💙💙💙

[@angelie912]

We always hear that word 'resonance' from BTOB too. I think they always aim for that from their graduate school. Hyunsik (necktie) is a Monster when it comes to range. Changsub(orange collar) is a CEO of a music(performing arts) school. Both of them are from Howon university. Changsub is a musical actor as well as Eunkwang(navy blue). He's a director of Cube entertainment and has been trained in classical music. Sungjae (blue lined sweater) is an actor and I think he got his singing style from old singers and is a baritone just like Hyunsik. He sings like a dolphin sometimes in his adlibs. The rapper on the left, Minhyuk, also sings but I guess he gave all singing parts for this vid to the vocal line. His voice is rough and tough when rapping but he has very sweet singing voice. I always listen to his song 'Goodnight' to sleep. The rapper on the right, Peniel, can also sing. His voice when rapping and singing is very cheerful and very youthful. There is another rapper, Ilhoon. He's no more in the group so you might be confused if you see 7 of them. His raps calmly. They named his style lazy rap. Sometimes his rap is like a sjngsong manner (I don't know if I'm right) All of the songs you heard was written, composed and even arranged by them. So mostly their parts are tailored for them.

[@danitx_]

For me they have the best vocals in the kpop industry. They are crazy singers… it’s impossible not to love them 🥰

[@brionyfakatou1620]

And aside from their god tier musical talent they are just good, likable people.

[@Emma-ky7ck]

Omg i've been waiting for this reaction ever since the killing voice dropped!! Our BTOB are the best vocal oriented group in kpop

[@SIJ-mz8rt]

so true! and other idols should learn from them, always singing LIVE, unlike those that even singing ballad or acoustic either lip-syncing or mr is louder than their voice lol

[@downthispath6538]

23:20 - here's my take on this, kpop idols are "trained" singers in that they learn to sing when they enter a company as trainees. even if they're not good singers, they are taught to sing and can carry a tune. however, there are "born" singers in that they just can sing and training when they enter a company just enhances that talent. some groups have 1 or 2 born singers and the rest are trained, but BtoB has 5/6 born singers. That's exceptionally high! And their songs reflect that.

[@MoMoon1920]

This is literally the The first time I've heard BTOB and I'm completely blown away like they're so talented TOO talented and I love the mix of pop r&b jazz that they have so Spotify here I come 🏃🏾‍♀️🏃🏾‍♀️🏃🏾‍♀️🏃🏾‍♀️

[@basickbaekhyun]

I feel like eunkwang (the guy in dark blue sweater in middle) is more a showman than actually having to work hard while singing; when seeing him sing while doing something else (so not focused on performing), he also has the prettiest stable voice without all the stuff around it :)

[@basickbaekhyun]

though I definitely agree changseob (orange collar guy) and Hyunsik (tie guy) are more effortless hahaha

[@mariondaim4491]

*Shinee *Btob *Beast/Highlight are known to be 3 of the most beautiful vocals groupes

[@ww_o8457]

THIS GROUP WILL NEVER DISAPPOINT YOU! SO, GOOD DECISION TO HAVE REACTION! 🙌💯

[@mel352]

For Hyunsik (tie guy), his voice is almost like a machine made sound. This is what always comes to my mind when I hear how perfectly and flawlessly clean his notes are. It’s almost like he has no weaknesses it’s insane

[@keykth4040]

You guys actually reviewed one of the members here in a previous video where he performed “love poem”. He’s the leader of BTOB and as much as he could just do himself, he likes to give bigger parts to the others as he likes to let them shine instead of him to allow them to really show what they can do since we know what Eunkwang can already do (if you’ve watched his solo performances and competitive performances you’ll know)

[@ark2129]

Hello Chase and Melina, I’m so excited for your reaction to BtoB! Wow so glad you took to liking Hyunsik and Changsub (and really just all of them) but fun fact: Hyunsik (tie and white shirt) and Changsub (orange collared sweater) were both trained by two Big Mama singers 😊 and I have to agree, they are really great and versatile!! Also Melodies correct me if I’m wrong, but while recording the killing voice, the audio director tweeted that all mics (not just the ones each person was singing into) kept picking up on other voices and their harmonizing moments so the sound overlapped so much that it sounded like 12 people singing instead of 6; some of the audio was cut out/lowered as a result. The whole group is so so impressive 💙💙 thank you for your reaction to them!

[@hazilab]

Finally!!! Super love BTOB! The guy with the white shirt and tie is Hyunsik, called the father of BTOB's music, who produced most of the BTOB music. Hyunsik was influenced by his father (a folk singer) and was exposed to a wide range of music from an early age. His family had a habit of listening to the whole album from start to finish, not just one song at a time. Hyunsik was first attracted by Stevie Wonder's music. He has been fascinated by Stevie Wonder's music ever since. He even sang Stevie Wonder's "Lately" for his university entrance exam (Practical Music) and of coz became a student of Howon University (Howon only accepted five out of 3000 applicants into the Practical Music major. Changsub, the guy in the sweater with orange stripes, and Hyunsik were the only two male accepted). Apart from Stevie Wonder, he says that whenever he hears a song by Donny Hathaway, he feels a sense of soulfulness, e.g. A Song for you. He also likes James Ingram, George Michael, Damien Rice...etc There is a Hyunsik's LIVE compilation in 8 minutes video mainly the cuts from his LIVE singing in his program "Hyunsik's Late Night Studio". kzbin.info/www/bejne/bWSUpn2vr8SfkJo

[@supernazu4546]

This is the group that I have waited for since the beginning of Killing Voice!

[@Jamari6]

I've been waiting for a BTOB reaction for ages. Glad you finally delivered. Hyunsik is the one you guys like the most. He's the son of a famous Korean singer.. You could say music runs in his blood.

[@K엘리-h3d]

영어로 듣는 비투비 찬사 너무 행복하다 하

[@smbfor1769]

I really really like Sungjae's voice(the second guy from the left). Like you said, his voice definitely has a rock ballad vibe and It’s true that his singing style requires a lot of effort. And I really love it because there's a emotion and rawness that only he can give. Anyway, I always appreciate your killing voice reaction and great vocal analysis!! Thank you so much for reacting them😊

[@mrs_rover]

i can see how they're presenting a "proper" image in this video, but that's probably the last word i'd use to describe this insane group of men

[@lecturaslunares926]

Fun fact: Hyunsik and Changsub studied Practical music in college and one of their teachers was one of the ladies from Bigmama (I believe it was Shin Yeona)

[@carat143svt]

the guy in orange is changsub.. he is one of idol with the most unique voice.. he also does musicals..the guy in navy blue is eunkwang the leader. you've seen him once.. in their kingdom stage. they sang love poem the one with tie is hyunsik their producer..and you will be shocked with their vocal range..

[@zzangst_limji962]

all i can say to your reactions is "YES!!! THAT IS BTOB'S FATHER OF MUSIC, IM HYUNSIK RIGHT THERE!!!!!!!!!!"

[@kyrrasaoy4599]

and "YES!!! WE DON'T KNOW HOW HE MANAGES TO SING LIKE THAT AND AT THE SAME TIME BE KINDA OUT OF THE RADAR SO YES!!! PLEASE LISTEN TO HIM MORE!!! thank you!" hahaha

[@riosw]

Minhyuk covering Ilhoon's part 😭 Peniel also covering his part 😭

[@Laura-gi9nv]

how good it would've been if he was also in the video, hearing his melodic rap 😭😭😭

[@junkyuseum]

23:55 Fun fact, they’re not just trained in the company to be even better singers. They also attended prestigious universities to study music and performing.

[@craashhsye]

Hyunsik's vocal range is just crazy 😞🤚

[@HarryLim-x1v]

Thank you very much for your reaction! I laughed so hard at “they look proper” 😭 BTOB is literally one of the biggest crackheads in KPOP. They’re known as “Beagle Idol” because of their crazy antics 😂 8:58 - “Who do you think my favorite is?” “Is or was?” This is literally us fans,, “Melody” (cause BTOB stands for Born to BEAT and EVERY BEAT NEEDS A MELODY to make music), our fave depends on who updates that day 😂 We just love them all equally 😂 The guy in dark blue navy sweater (Eunkwang) is the DESIGNATED main vocal. The guy in orange collar (Changsub) is the DESIGNATED lead vocal. The guy in white shirt with a tie (Hyunsik) is a SUB VOCAL The guy in blue collar (Sungjae) is a SUB SUB VOCAL. But Eunkwang said that they are all main vocal material so they consider themselves as ALL main vocalists 💙 Minhyuk (the one at the very left) is the LEAD RAPPER but he also sings in other songs ☺️ Peniel (the one on the very right) is also a rapper but he also sings. BTOB members are all vocalists and rappers 💙 51:18 - “they were just like BAM one after the other” BTOB has a lot of this type of adlibs btw. I think they just love doing it. Us, fans, even say that it’s not a BTOB song unless the 4 vocalists are in a vocal battle 😂 I love killing voice but I’m kind of disappointed at how the video came out to be. Cause I have been watching BTOB singing without mics and without background music and I know that they couldve done better than what came out. I thought it was only me who noticed it but other Melodies did too. And we were right, a Dingo representative said that because BTOB’s voices are too powerful, their voices overlap each others’ mics which made it sound like there are more than 6 people singing, that’s why they had to tone down the adlibs. It was actually evident since there have been times wherein the vocalists were still opening their mouths (singing) but we can’t hear their voices anymore. But I’m still very thankful to Dingo cause a lot of non-koreans have finally seen how great BTOB are. (BTOB are very well-known in Korea) Fun fact: BTOB is a self-produced group, more than half of the songs they sang in Killing Voice are produced by either Hyunsik or Minhyuk. I can’t wait to watch more BTOB reactions from the both of you 💙 Since you would like to know more about BTOB, I think watching/reacting to a guide will be the best at helping you. Personally, I like this guide the best hihi ☺️ kzbin.info/www/bejne/o5CkfZmrbJier6c Thank you very much again! I think it’s evident how happy I am with your reaction because my comment is very long 😂

[@flafri]

can't believe i was just thinking like 30 minutes ago how much I needed you guys to react to this, so thank you so much!!!! hope you keep checking out some btob stuff, they have some of the best vocals in kpop!

[@kiak2971]

Changsub is one my favorite singers, he has such a beautifil voice. But they are all good, the kings of vocals. So not one bad opinion, we fans know what they all can do.

[@heyjk096]

I remember reading somewhere that Dingo had to edit the audio a lot because Btob were overlapping in each other’s mics (which is why it sounds odd in places and I think they also cut out adlibs too)

[@aliyahracman4279]

you'll be surprised that hyunsik, the one in white shirt with tie also produces their songs and plays so many instruments. LITERALLY AN ALL ROUNDER!!

[@Shutthemos]

Yook Sung-jae also won first place as a vocalist in "Fantastic Duo" and also won first place in "Duet Song Festival.He was praised for being the perfect vocalist on "King of Mask Singer" Every time he participated in a vocal contest, he made a big splash.He has a sweet voice and a special ability to excite people. kzbin.info/www/bejne/rHKaq4yIfZVqY7s

[@jaehalu6035]

Sungjae definitely deserved that last minute recognition

[@cyyymaaa]

BTOB is one of the best vocalists in kpop industry

[@HarharVivi_KBS]

The leader of BTOB Eunkwang (the one in Navy blue jumper) is the same person in your “Love Poem” react video in the middle.

[@raricheta]

I always love watching people react to Hyunsik's normal talking voice for the first time after only hearing him sing lol Thanks for reacting to BTOB, guys! Really enjoyed it and hope you will listen to more of their songs

[@eirelavenna]

The rude guy with amazing range at 31:44 is the composer and vocal director of THAT song - Im Hyunsik

[@zeeminimee]

Others have mentioned Hyunsik (guy with tie) and Changsub (sweater with orange lining) are Howon graduates - one of of the most sought after universities in Korea for Practical Music - who got in through a very tight competition of 3000:1. Just want to add in that Hyunsik recently finished his Masters too! He took his Masters in Practical Music and has this philosophy that there is no end to studying music and always wants to learn more and refine his knowledge and skills. Lately, he mentioned he's been doing a self-study of arranging music. Very similar to Eunkwang (guy with dark blue vest) who also has this philosophy of there is no end in studying and practising singing. Till this day, even though they are already 11 years into their debut, the members of BTOB are still continuously in practice rooms practising their skills - vocals / dance / rap / instruments / composing / producing etc. This is on top of them having such likeable and great personalities and group dynamics too. Hope you enjoy falling into the rabbit hole!

[@g1rld1nner]

hyunsik is my bias because he’s multitalented. thank you for crediting him.

[@pamelalamim11]

Changsub (orange guy) is a vocal monster really! The one with blue sweater (eunkwang) is the one at love poem cover from a program that you reacted, he’s the middle guy who guided the performance, is the leader of BTOB and is also a vocal killer, BTOB rocks at vocals

[@vanshikakumar6105]

You should watch some live of BTOB, especially some of their performances from Kingdom

[@Chelsea-cs9uz]

what you said about hyunsik about how he makes you love singing and makes you want to sing made my heart so happy i always say changsub's voice literally makes me want to keep living life so i FELT that comment haha). like i need you guys to dive deeper cause this doesn't even cover half of how amazing they are as artists and people.

[@mel012dy]

Thank you for reacting and listening to them 🙏 If you guys continue this journey of getting know them 😂 I'll be ready for every ride 💙

[@mariayohanna5277]

The guy in orange (Chang Sub) and the guy in navy sweater (Seo Eunkwang) are also musical singers. And please don't underestimate him (the guy in navy sweater), as the leader of the group, he is also known as 1 of the best vocalists in kpop.. he can also sing in soprano

[@freedomdive1881]

*Eunkwang

[@batool2000rox]

His name's eunkwang, seungkwan is from seventeen ^^

[@keykth4040]

They’re the whole package. Composers, vocalists, rappers, and amazing people to hang out with.

[@LufiYuwanaMursita]

One satisfying reaction for BTOB! Thank you so much for your appreciation for BTOB. They have everything about vocals. The word "clean" is the most suitable, right?

[@mariellabanzon7018]

BTOB (Born to Beat) composed of 7 people (4 vocals and 3 rappers) but something happen to other member. The other member whose gone now in the group is Ilhoon. His a rapper and producer. His now doing fine with his life. This year 2023, Btob is celebrating their 11th anniversary. These kpop group is called a "King of Ballad" in Kpop world because of their voices and the song and melody of it. These groups are all rounded (vocalist, rapper and dancers). MELODY is the name of their fanbase. Eunkwang (dark blue sweater guy) - leader and oldest member of the group. Main vocalist of the band, entertainer, musical theater actor and songwriter. Minhyuk ( the sky blue shirt w/ tie guy) - second oldest member, visual of the group, producer, composer and songwriter and rapper of the band Changsub (Orange collar guy) - third oldest member, musical theater actor, lead vocalist of the band Hyunsik ( white shirt w/ tie guy) - lead vocalist, songwriter, producer and composer of the band. Member of KOMCA (Korean Music Copyright Association. Peniel (the gray sweater guy) - foreign member (chicago), singer, rapper, and songwriter of the band. Sungjae (white shirt w/ black collar guy)- the maknae (youngest member), actor. songwriter and lead vocal of the band. Ilhoon (former member)- producer, composer, songwriter, rapper and singer of the band. As a melody thank you for doing a reaction video for their killing voice. Please watch and react for more live songs of BTOB!!!! Saranghamniida!!!!

[@ferlopezz07]

fun fact: eunkwang (the one in the blue sweater) is the guy who was singing in the middle in love poem, the song you previously analyzed

[@feb-sep]

As you are vocal teachers, I was wondering why it take so long for you guys to check out BTOB while watching this video. Thank you for reacting to BTOB. I love this video. 🩵🩵🩵

[@antoinette2957]

OMG. I've been waiting for sooo long for you to react to BTOB!!!! ❤❤❤ Melia saying they're prim and proper. Oh boy. hahaha! Editing to help you know more about these amazing boys. BtoB means Born to Beat and they debuted in 2012. from left to right Minhyuk - rapper but he can sing really well too Sungjae - youngest; sub-vocalist Eunkwang - leader; main vocalist Hyunsik - lead vocalist; writes most of their songs Changsub - lead vocalist; my fave ❤ Peniel - rapper; Chicago boy lol

[@monaegielove885]

I laughed when she said they were proper cause they are such goofballs 😂😂

[@Kezi_Carat]

ME TOOO I KEEP GOING BACK TO THEIR CHANNEL TO MAKE SURE 😅❤❤❤❤

[@Emma-ky7ck]

i genuinely laughd so hard at that comment, i haven't seen idols who care less about their idol image, i love those goofballs

[@cindih78]

BtoB said there are 4 main vocalists in their group, they don’t consider one better than the other and they all bring something different to the group’s music.

[@keykth4040]

Crazy and funny fact: the Dingo audio director shared a message that the volume of their singing was adjusted because their voices were too powerful that each vocalist's voice was captured by other vocalists' microphones. Voices were overlapped making it feel like 12+ people were singing together. Therefore some of the harmony and adlib were taken away, so it probably sounded different from normal BTOB's live. But of course, the original LIVE was very good. And yeah, the “clean” singing compared to other groups was also caused by the reverb having to be taken away since they’re such strong singers. Leaving reverb would just wash over to each others mics and ruin their sound

[@erikac2720]

Tks for reacting to them. They indeed are the best vocal group in Kpop. So many people compare them to boys II men. For this killing voice the post production had to do some adjustments bcs their adlibs were caught by the others mics, so who havent seen them live yet, doesnt really know how their live vocals are even more amazing than what we saw. One of the things in my bucket list is to see them live and be amazed by them. Those who saw them live said that no video give them justice😢.

[@KainZC]

I just love surveying around seeing new peoppe react to their killing voice video, learn and falling in love with their singing, they are a very unique group even in kpop imo

[@finnahaujanirsta7873]

BTOB is the best vocal group in Kpop.

[@rupertblaine]

I have been watching BTOB on the side and this killing voice just made me fall in love with them🥰🤟🏽

[@michinnunapaen]

hyunsik (the guy with tie) is super underrated!!! not a pro but i could hear his beautiful range since i became a melody, so happy pros are appreciating hyunsik for all his talents❤ also, he wrote most of these hits!!!

[@xzyzyx02]

a lot of things in this video are true. eunkwang is known for his ability to sing with very proper technique (especially for classic singing), and he always singing forwardly (idk how to say that, but ig he ever talk abt this in knowing brother before). changsub is known for his excellent half-air-half-voice singing ability. i think noone in kpop industry can sing as good as him with that technique. i'm not surprised u fall in love with changsub, he already stole everybody's heart with that voice😂 even my bias is him. hyunsik definitely the widest vocal range singer. and i am so happy bcs u guys also praised sungjae. bcs not a lot of ppl praised his vocal enough, eventho he's a good baritone. i just kinda surprised how u guys didnt choke by their silliness a long the video🤣

[@hohoho3256]

That's why I am proud to be a Melody (their fans' name). I am sooo proud of them. Every time people analyze their vocals, I will be sooooooo happy. I am so glad you found them!!! BTOB has a loooooot of great performances. We never have enough~

[@len5278]

Hyunsik the guy in white with a tie composed most of BTOB songs.. he is good also in playing his musical instruments,he is indeed talented ❤

[@remixedv]

BTOB is a vocal group I appreciate. Talented singers/producers/instrumentalists. Love Hyunsik vocal tone... that throat... the resonance... he's one of those singers who can caress you like a black hole and then elevate you to the sun. Talented group of men.

[@Kezi_Carat]

I've been waiting for this video ever since dingo released the btob killing voice 😭😭😭😭 thank u guysss

[@eunhyukiee]

i love how hyunsik got a really proper appreciation here. i mean when we mentioned about btob's vocal, we always think about eunkwang or changsub automatically. but through killing voice, they really give the spotlight to hyunsik so he shine so good here. but not forget to mention, btob's vocal is always strong and impactful. all of them literally give different color to the group and i love all the combination 💙

[@changsubber]

PLEASE WATHC MORE OF THEIR LIVE STAGES TOO!!!

[@mondaze4fun467]

The guy on the left in blue, Huta (Minhyuk) has a great speaking voice too! He hosts a radio show too and interview K-pop groups on the show. Love his voice 🎤🎵❤

[@Emma-ky7ck]

They are Pentagon's older brothers and teached and helped them in a lot of things, you already reacted to Jinho getsemanhae's, and it's clear that the two groups know how to sing and enjoy it... They are awesome. Also, both groups usually participate in musicals, they are incredible diverse artists

[@laishatrejo34]

Omggg I wish pentagon would do a killing voice 🥺

[@Emma-ky7ck]

frrrr their songs are great, and their live performances amazing!!! i know they'll love hui's voice as much as they did love jinho's@@laishatrejo34

[@christina8101]

They have a member who left so many parts are changed. Btob are the best. I knew exactly who ya'll would like lol. Btw they are the biggest crackheads in kpop. Seventeen takes second in that lol love them all.

[@ayrishchinmae3613]

The four member at the center actually is train vocal trainers,the light blue shirt,he can sing...you should watch his solo performance and to know they better you should watch their solo each

[@josefinasotes796]

The way Sungjae breaks into Finale: Our Concert's chorus makes me tear up, it's so epic and emotional, I love it❤

[@blueheart7797]

BTOB is the best vocalist in Kpop😊😊 I love your reaction to our boy's and yes they are unique very talented

[@NagataYuki5]

Left to right: * Minhyuk - Lead rapper, lead dancer, vocalist and "visual" ("the prettiest/sexy/etc") * Sungjae - Vocalist and youngest * Eunkwang - Leader, MAIN vocalist, and the theatre pro 😻 * Hyunsik - Main dancer, lead vocalist, also a theatre pro 😻 * Chansub - lead vocalist, goofball, also a theatre lead man * Peniel - Lead rapper, vocalist ** If you want to check out more of Eunkwang (dark blue sweater), you should look for his duet with his mother, Hwang Soon-Ok (in the tv show "Immortal song") *** Im Hyunshik, the one with the resonance and vocal range of the Gods 😅, he is son of Im Jihoon, and has also talent with several instruments besides his voice...

[@woonghao]

BTOB VOCAL KINGS

[@arinanepaa]

Oh my gooodddd!!! I couldn't be happier right now!! Chase+Melia+BTOB+kiling voice is like a dream come true. Thanks for watching and recording your reaction and comments 🥰🥰🥰

[@kaylinlewis8413]

I’ve been waiting for this video. BTOB are one of the most talented groups out there. I adore them and your reaction videos are everything!

[@lilshmet4167]

So basically for the harmony of the song "I'll be your man" that sounded out of tune, the main melody was edited out🥲 I don't know why Dingo edited out so many of their harmonies in this Killing Voice, but it made some of them sound off when I know they sang them almost perfectly (because they did these harmonies many other times flawlessly) So I recommend you guys to watch a live performance of "I'll be your man" because that harmony is actually one of my favorites, and I also recommend you watch just other vocal videos of them that are less edited!!

[@yasminmanser3961]

This was so good! So excited to see you react to more BTOB in the future! Their talent is endless! 🥰

[@muzikhead007]

BTOB is not only a talented group, but a group with such great chemistry and hilarious on to. Not just with each other but with others they interact with. It’s infectious!!❤

[@hudahaven3099]

that guy with the amazing vocal range. His name is Im Hyunsik and.. wait till you guys know that he also produces and composes most of their songs AND plays a lot of instruments like the guitar, piano, ukulele etc. Yeah... ALL that talent in one person. 😂A literal musical genius

[@vee6224]

BTOB just another talented guy next to another talented guy. They're full packages of talented entertainers. They can have all the things they want and they mastered it on they're on way. I love them since forever. They're one of the reason I can't leave kpop, cause I need to see album& hear their masterpiece every singel time they dropped an album.