Voice Teachers React to Melomance Killing Voice 멜로망스(MeloMance)의 킬링보이스를 라이브로!

[@yoon-jounghur1161]

He is famous with singing amazing without effort, he said that his aunty was a classical music singer, and learned the way singing from her without frown. ❤️

[@ayoayo1044]

He looks and sounds like a Disney prince. Someone needs to cast him asap

[@hero4963]

Melomance is vocal legend in South Korea btw so yeah he's awesome and extremely talented and they're so humble

[@jwo122]

he's good but not considered a legend. maybe in about 10 more years at least.

[@thecynic_]

not even close to be legend. doesnt mean hes bad at all, but its all about if one can handle technique and expressing various emotions at the same time. hes not quite there yet.

[@홍-n5y]

멜로망스는 아직 레전드가 아니다. 그가 레전드가 되기에는 레전드이고, 연차가 높은 선배가수이 한국에 너무나도 많다

[@씨익-q8z]

레전드는 아니에요 ㅎㅎ

[@Ldzvjjvb78ct9]

일반적으론 그렇게 생각하진 않지만 갠적으론 보컬레전드라 생각함. 내가 아는 한 이런 식으로 편하게 고음 부르는 사람 없거든. 염소바이브레이션, 가성, 소몰이창법 싫어하는 내 기준엔 최고 보컬.

[@ELI4347]

Even if you don’t understand the Korean language is just a pleasure do your ears to listen to this guys voice

[@wys4434]

I like to recommend group Forestella to you guys!! Forestella is a 4 member group full of charms. Each member has their unique sounds but with their effort their harmony sounds very astonishing! Bohemian Rhapsody,Time in a bottle and Scarborough Fair and Champions are my best picks so far( my personal opinion). This group is form in the competition called Phantom Singer program and since then they been singing together. I am certain you folks would fall in love for this group!! Thank you!

[@ritat7788]

Yes....Forestella please. Scarborough Fair, Hijo de la Luna, Parla piu piano, Bohemian Rhapsody

[@EKSO-El]

Omg yes they should

[@arialien7854]

Please I want them to listen to them sing Scarborough Fair and Hijo De La Luna!!!

[@anau5649]

Totally understand you. He sings so easily all the time and so nice to hear his voice :)

[@erikac2720]

I love melomance, his voice is amazing, and this duo voice + piano is so perfect.

[@zopuii6876]

He is one of the best vocalist in the industry but underrated. 'Gift' 30:26 will always be one of my favourite song... Damn! he is sooo good ..

[@galenkerrick3133]

His voice is amazing, and you two are a delight to watch. Thank you for exposing me to singers I probably would not have known otherwise :)

[@ChaseandMelia]

Thank you! We're finding this singer for the first time ourselves as well! Thanks for being on this journey with us!

[@yootoobsamantha]

Gift is truly a masterpiece. It's so good, it makes me wanna cry.

[@grueg]

Please react to Taeyeon's Killing Voice performance! :) She is very versatile and a highly respected vocalist in Korea and is also my favorite singer. I don't know anything about singing but I like your analyses, so I would be very interested in knowing what you think of her. I would love to see a reaction to Ailee's Killing Voice performance as well.

[@jumanahksa4527]

About his pronouncing I'm not korean and I can understand each word he said he is pronouncing all the values so clearly so person still learning korean can understand his lyrics easily 👌👌💘

[@rebeccabeebe1]

I love seeing people discovering MeloMance they have to be my favorite non Idol K artist... I listen to them daily Kim Min-Seok is so freaking talented and Jeong Donghwan (pianist) is brilliant as well.. suggestions I hope you could look at Gaho he is also very talented

[@liama9862]

Just to let you know, they just released a new mini album and actually performed the entire thing on their channel in one go! It has beautiful live instrumental and is genuinely so gorgeous to watch. The pianist also sings with Kim in one of the songs!

[@lam1995522]

Omg, I love your reaction!! It is also my first time listening to Melomance - such an amazing singer. Thank you so so much!!

[@lookingforbooks]

Gift is one of my favourite songs. It always hits the spot and his singing is always full of emotion

[@SueLee-y2h]

OMG. I loooooove how effortlessly he hits high notes with such a peaceful look. Amazingly great singer!

[@rissstyles2408]

Im starting to love melomance and yeaa minseok's vocal Is AMAZING

[@max-lee]

I love Melomance. Started saw one the guy from i can see your voice show.

[@mmj1327]

Yeah. Felt like just last day seeing him in I Can See Your Voice. But it’s actually been years. Glad he’s finally had his moment.

[@max-lee]

@@mmj1327 yup. heard his voice again when the song gift came out. saw the face, and i was like 'i know that guy!' im glad for him.

[@saymyname7553]

Thank you !!! Love this reaction so much

[@marouajallout3733]

This man have a unique voice 😮

[@gfndceqmavhor354]

Oh.. Finally you listen to some real vocalist...Melomace owns one of the mellow voice in music industry...sweet and mellow.. Love listen to his vocal When i am having coffee break.. But i still awaiting for your reaction of Ha Hyun Woo...from Dingo Killing Voice He indeed is an irreplaceable LEGEND male vocalist..who can sing me all different genres like his own music..

[@lkc4808]

멜로망스 노래 좋쳐... 특히 하드락 발라드 좋아하는 사람들에게는... 보컬이 참 감미롭게 들립니다~

[@mackenziehendrix7755]

I love you guys and your reactions. Thank you sooo much for another great reaction!

[@FelixSuen]

I am a classical trained tenor and Kim Min-Seok (the singer of Melomance) is my favourite too. He delivered everything with ease - a clean sound and a good variety of tones. There are some auto correct in the recordings but he has very good intonation singing live always. As far as I know they are trainnd in uni in a contemporary music production department. I believe there are lots of good teachers and talents there in S.Korea.

[@FelixSuen]

*and your reactions reminds me the first time hearing him. His singing inspired me singing in operas and art songs too. Thanks for telling the world about him and welcome to the fandom! Haha

[@colleenmargarethurd1211]

You will discover so much more amazing gifting in the Melomance couple ... both pianist and singer. A perfect duo. 👍👏

[@TheLilacStar]

I wish MeloMance would watch this video!

[@claudiaswenson8895]

I loved this reaction video! Melomance is amazing. Try listening to Seo Eunkwan from BtoB. His range is ridiculous. He was also in Killing Voice. He also goes by Silver light. He was in the show Immortal Songs where he sang "That Man" in its original female key, and he event went higher. Korea has amazing singers.

[@firdhausismail2206]

"I guess we're fan" hahaaha. Omg i love it. I became his fan when the first time i heard his ost song from Business Proposal called Love, Maybe. After that I'm looking for his other song. Maybe you should react to Yoo Hwe Seung from N.Flying too. Super powerful voice.

[@subtleswaggermk]

I really love that you guys react to MeloMance Killing Voice! The first video I watched at your channel is the reaction to his and Wheein’s video because I fell in love with him there too and I’ve been following him since. He (Kim Minseok) and his friend (Jung Donghwan; pianist) are from the same university where Minseok studied vocal and Donghwan studied piano (or classical music, cmiiw). Then they form this duo, MeloMance. Kim Minseok said himself that he is obsessed with singing EFFORTLESSLY with minimum expression. His family is genetically singing geniuses with his aunt as vocal teacher or something, his lil brother is a musical actor. Donghwan is also a genius producer and he is one of the most sought out pianist in South Korea. They are soooo talented, and I’m happy that they got the spotlight they deserve!🥰

[@keykth4040]

I have their albums and yeah, long road trips with their music make these trips take less time somehow. They put you to sleep while still keeping you on your toes. It’s interesting

[@gregs1646]

A few months late, but I might as well comment. You're correct, Melomance is a duo of the vocalist Kim MinSeok and pianist Jung DongHwan. Yeah, it is all this kind of really nice vibe.

[@tenywajimowen1002]

They are a folk duo from south korea ( vocal and piano) who are alumni that graduated from south korea within the same school.

[@nicolelgarq]

I love Melomance. He is fantastic. You should see 10cm and Feel Kim. Korea has many good singers. Thanks for the video. 💜

[@HyesongKim-d9o]

In korea, his nickname is Simmons kim,,,,😁 (because he sings sooooooo comfortably like Simmons bed,,)

[@winterso8589]

Ya'll are hilarious 😂 enjoyed ur enthusiasm. Didnt know about Kim from MeloMance but thanks to u guys i'll catch them from now!

[@johanagaleano7356]

always coming back to watch this reaction😭

[@imaloser8010]

Can you pls react to Forestella? they are a korean crossover group with talented singers, also they did a lot of good covers. (sorry my english isn’t very good)

[@meemo8864]

I want my viola playing to sound like his voice 😭 his voice is so perfecf

[@DavaAlhamda]

i love chase & melia reaction, it makes me really appriciate all aspect of the vocals , it makes me learn a lot of things about voices and vocal , with just their reaction , btw i love melomance too because of them and ofcourse because the melomance its just as spectaculer as the fact it is, love it

[@SuperKMao]

Can we give his piano playing partner some love too? :)

[@ChaseandMelia]

That would have been good manners for us to acknowledge the amazing piano playing! We were too amazed, we had stars in our eyes!

[@SuperKMao]

@@ChaseandMelia I didn't mean to imply you guys were being rude! Love the channel, keep it up!

[@jowr2000]

What a voice! And so effortless

[@Moo19850730]

Congrats on becoming parents!! Love your reaction videos. Thank you so much!

[@mjwith4cats873]

It’d be much better with subtitles 😢 Your professional analysis makes me understand how he sings and enjoy the video more

[@gitanovianty]

Thank you so much for this video, this is made my day. Can't wait for part 2 and other Melomance reaction videos.

[@musamusa]

Despite the slightly nasal sound, his voice has a lot of control. If it's not too much to ask, could you guys react to Ha Hyun Woo's killing voice too? He's one of the best Korean singers with a wide vocal range. I'd love to hear your technical comments on him! Love from Argentina.

[@jjlettucs8119]

Best singer minseok 민석이 최고💕💕

[@elichyrr403]

I feel like you guys will also like Golden’s (aka G.Soul) killing voice, he is my favorite singer , his voice is amazing .

[@PersonWithStupid37]

His is routinely on my playlist. It is that good.

[@thththth937]

이 영상 시청하는 여러분 멜로망스를 '맞이 할 준비를 해~~~~~~' 김민석 정동환 사랑합니다

[@boygood3239]

요새는 악기도 유튭에 나와서 노래를 하네ㅎ

[@Dilara-js7ek]

Melomance is really an astoundingly talented vocalist! If you are looking for someone who in my eyes has a similar level of technique I would strongly recommend you react to Song Sohee - Tearful Duman River. She sings in a traditional korean style, that is quite different to anything we have in the west. The emotion of the character portrayed in this performance always moves me to tears. Every time. I recommend to quickly check out the comments of the performance before watching as there is a short explanation of the history and story of the song. Always love and appreciate you perspectives!

[@emilychung9216]

Would love to see both of your reaction to Park Hyo Shin's Wildflower and Forestella covering this epic piece of Queen's Bohemian Rhapsody to start off. Great job! See you two soon👍🏼👍🏼💜💜

[@erikoenglish1651]

23:00 OMG 😂 you guys face. I love it. Thank you 💕

[@user-xl3qc5ip3m]

Melomance Rediscovery... After seeing you guys reaction, I want to listen to Melomance music...

[@ChaseandMelia]

After DOING this reaction, I want to listen to Melomance!

[@cheerfullynotes]

Thank you so much for this reaction video, I will gladly join your melomance fandom…. another melomance fan here… So happy that someone talks about and appreciates them… Here are little things I know about melomance. . Melomance is a duo, the one who sang named Kim Minseok and the other one who played piano named Jeong Donghwan. They were colleague best friend, both studied at Seoul Institute of Arts, Minseok majored in vocal while Donghwan majored in jazz piano. They decided to create melomance and debut in 2015 with a self-produced album titled Sentimental. They wrote, composed, arranged, and recorded their songs by themselves. That time they did not yet join a label and they promoted themselves by doing gigs here and there, maybe that's why they considered as indie musician. Melomance is a combination of melodramatic and romance. That’s the concept of their music, so you could find a lot of songs that mellow and romantic that also carried a classic vibe… and because Donghwan background is jazz you could also find songs with swing and jazzy feeling. About Minseok singing background… he already studied vocal since school age, and his aunt is a classical vocalist and lector (if I'm not mistaken). Naul and Park Hyosin are Minseok role models.. he studied a lot by watching their videos, so you might interested to check their songs too… their famous song is Memory of The Wind by Naul and Wild Flower by Park Hyosin.

[@kaseypayne173]

Please react to Aileen’s killing voice or her version of “Everyone” on immortal song

[@smbfor1769]

WOW His techniques are crazy and I really love your analysis

[@allthesips]

Thank you for adding technical tidbits on how to sing some of his phrases! Like the double chin method lol

[@mjsillagaya5660]

Loved your reaction to Melomance! Your next killing Voice should be Urban zakapa, please!

[@YUNJINWOO]

His strength is his gentle expression when he raises his high notes.

[@eternaleez]

this is my favorite reaction of the channel. i comeback every now and then because your reactions are so funny and i can never get tired of hearing him sing. thank you guys

[@azeef4926]

I cannot believe this was a year ago. I watched it the first time the day you uploaded it and many more times after. Time really flies.

[@kurious_kuromi]

even though ballad is not my preferred genre of music, i can always appreciate a few really amazing singers and melomance is definitely one of them. if they happen to pass by on a show i'm watching or even on the yt algorithm (like this video did) i won't hesitate to watch and listen bc they're amazing. the pianist dong hwan doesn't get much spotlight but he is also amazing and well known in the industry as he worked as a session musician for many shows and artists. i love how they can do their own stuff and come back together to make amazing music as melomance.

[@Universalmaa]

You guys should definitely react to So Hyang "Arirang" or "I will Always love You", you guys will cry in seconds.

[@miorandmior]

Exploded into the korean music industry via his appearance on i can see your voice korea (you should watch that episode 😊). He has a unique sound, which may or may not be conventionally delivered. He hardly opens his mouth 😊. Korean Singers like him completely underrated though in a world of music more and more enamored with visuals (blackpink, bts etc etc). Balladeers like him were bigger in the 80s,90s (legends today) but barely gets noticed today.

[@fromnaras]

I love this video! You guys actually know the artists on Dingo which is awesome. Will be tuning in from now on!!!

[@jiwoonjang1833]

still waiting more reaction video to Melomance!!

[@marie-francemazoue8387]

Les chanteurs coréens ont des voix magnifiques Bing bang The Rose BTS MELOMANCE ETC.... cherchez et vous trouverez des trésors have à good day 🇨🇵

[@danahkopsida]

Thank you for the interesting video! Joining in with people recommending IU's killing voice!!

[@alondragarza2217]

Please react to jannabi😭😭 they also have a killing voice, them and paul kim

[@Moo19850730]

His aunt is a classical vocalist and he learned singing from her before he joined the college

[@bkbk9825]

i would love to hear his speaking voice. what beautiful tone and control.

[@usermcw222]

Hi, began watching your videos today, enjoying very much, thanks. On the comment 31:20, the singer sounds that way (rather not clear) because the pronunciation is not "Mae" but actually "Hae " in Korean. He is trying to pronounce "Hae" but the final consonant of the previous word is "M" is affecting the next word "Hae" 😊 Hope you find interesting.

[@joshuavang4396]

You guys talked about one-breath phrases and a good one that I always look out for is in Park Hyo Shin's Wildflower. It's the phrase that leads up to and past the peak high note in the song.

[@kimstephanietrinh3923]

Love your reaction

[@이나미-y1b]

27:30 I first saw Kim Min-seok frown while singing. Thank you for your reactions.

[@망고스틴킴]

Hi, Melomance's music genre is known as "Ballad" in South Korea, which is not in any way the classical "ballad" from the middle ages; it is more of a genre that is mostly emotional--usually sentimental or romantic. Sentimental ballad would be a quite fit explanation for the genre Korean Ballad, while the "sentimental" part is not necessarily essential, as romantic songs can be upbeat/boppy sometimes.

[@망고스틴킴]

but yeah, they can be explained as indie folk too

[@이나단-y9e]

I hardly make a comment; but do it because not sure where to ask! Please react to Si Kyung Sung, killing voice as well. I love you guys reaction to Melomance. It’s so detailed❤

[@cassupreme7165]

GIFT !!!! still one of the best songs ever

[@ChaseandMelia]

ohh!! Getting this request a lot!

[@luzmanhizrian3601]

Thankyou for giving some ❤️ to melomance

[@mmj1327]

I’m not really a big fan of MeloMance. I can only tell a few that I know about him. I saw him the one singing from beginning in I Can See Your Voice 2015 as a “Naul voice a like” I think. It means he had a voice like a famous singer called Naul. And in I Can See Your Voice, there’s a few others that come there as “Naul Series of Voice a like” every year I think until they stop coming just a few years back and those who came as Naul Series hits high notes like a piece of cake. Lol. But there’s also people who said his high note voice more like 10cm band who also appears in Killing Voice. I’m not sure tho I am no professional to say any of that. But whatever it is I’m glad he who I see in I Can See Your Voice have become more big today.

[@danaecandance]

that the first time you go so much back you can clearly see the facination ahahah

[@UCERybQik2FJrTMZ8Kr-c6_w]

So glad to watch you guys listen to Melomance For more then 30 years i didnt like singers using falsetto or too much heady voices becuz i thought its not good to listen But he has power and resonance. Its not unpleasant sound, its so good to listen and mordern. In korea if we remind a singer who is great, we dont think about him but hes very unique and one of great singer Thanks a lot for reaction from Big Sohyang fan

[@Jouda5923]

Where is the emotion ? Well it's in the fact that u don't understand a word but still feel like crying! He's voice is sooo magical, its like he takes u to another world when he's singing!! So beautiful Insane duo . Oh n make sure to watch a drama where they sing the ost for nd u'll sure cry ur eyes out !!!!

[@hasnanadila3419]

I really recommend you to react day6! Especially Young K, the bassist. He has super wide range and great controol, kinda effortless too. Their songs are great too!

[@이연우-o3d7i]

지금 까지 리액션 중 최고 찬사 이군요~~~^^*

[@encikk444]

"Gift" are the song that made me to know them and also made me to become their big fans! Ever since then, when they releasing a new song or sing for a drama OST I would be super excited... I have heard almost all of their songs... They are the best👍👍👍 My favourite song from them are Tale

[@animo144000]

I love melomance ..They are my favorite musicions and Thank u ur reaction video

[@hero4963]

I love seeing you guys react to killing voice and listen your great comments check out IU killing voice

[@junl6748]

Now that I'm old, my voice has become cloudy. Singers, listen to their songs when you were young. And there are many high-class singers in Korea because they have to manage high economics in a small country.

[@TheRedMasqueradeMask]

He's the only male korean singer that I notice with his effortlessness in singing. He sing like he's breathing.

[@꺅-ch]

Welcome to MELOMANCEworld! I recommend playing videos of Jeong Donghwan who is the pianist of Melomance. His piano is also so goooood👍👍👍 Thank you for your reaction video!

[@lcactus6257]

Please react to Taeyeon’s killing voice. She’s amazing!!!

[@AyuLestari-zr4pb]

hopefully you'll be able to check Ben in dingo too. she's absolutelly has that beautifull voice and unique too

[@algrina04]

Me immediately going to Tiktok to follow you there and see the challenge!!!

[@cindypandini1149]

Just found you!! Yay!! Melomance is one of my favourite Korean duos...PLEASE PLEASE check out Kim Feel singing Damien Rice's Delicate and The Blower's Daughter....and so much more. His voice is life changing. Peace Love and Light from Beautiful British Columbia.

[@mayusbff]

Please react to the Sunwoo Jungah Killing voice. She's a great and versatile singer!

[@aharya4940]

Hi, I have been following your channel for over a year now and I just love your explanations, analysis and reactions! So firstly, thank you for doing this, I've learned a lot from it, you guys are amazing!! Secondly, I would very much like to see more BTS performances around here, preferably live stages. I'm a big fan of their art and to see you reacting and teaching things through their performances is just amazing. Thank you again and again!

[@callmemisspizza1665]

You better react to ailee's killing voice it was amazing the way she jumps from song to song effortlessly, I wanna know your thoughts about her she has a powerful voice

[@DOREENBOGLE]

I love Melomance, Yang Da Ill sounds similar, great voices that really gets to my soul.

[@aequil]

I hope you can react to Taeyeon Killing Voice as it is one of the best Killing Voice performances