ChatGPT DESTROYS Quran ONLY Muslims

[@TheBobbysPerspective]

☕Buy Bobby A Coffee: www.buymeacoffee.com/bobbyristo

[@glitch504sans9]

Is it as good as v60

[@Arkan-Al-Islam-5]

This ignorance to ask ChatGPT because it only gives Google source info which can be googled and not from scholars. Trusting it is a misguidance. Also, a hadith was written in prophet s.a.w time there are much evidence to it. I don't understand why even ask a robot so called ai who search internet and find the closest answer and find it trust worthy. Why not believe in the bible then, because the source is the same anonymous author like chatGPT. This is ignorance. Please use your brain. May Allah guide people to the Quran, Sunnah and the way of the selef. The saved sect in islam. Amin

[@anyq_CS]

what quran tafseer/commentary are you using right now? just asking.

[@Leon-jp7ch]

Qur'an explains everything in detail? Yes it literally says EVERYTHING? But you know we need hadith?? There were so many contradictions and so confusing. No Qur'an does not give detailed explanations when they depend on thousands of hadith books. Hadith is all human product

[@عبداللطيفمزوز]

Give glad tiding to the believers

[@B.Abdennour]

My grandmother passed away today in Mecca while performing Umrah May Allah have mercy on her

[@190mohammedyasin6]

Ameen

[@Sohailhhh1993]

Ameen

[@thetruth6992]

آمین

[@HabibiDubaiKittyAbdulBenjoh]

Ameen

[@shi06749]

Allahu Akbar! What a wonderful way to seal one's life. May Allah grant us all such a wonderful end.

[@mohamed.albaghdady]

My brother Bobby, I really thank you from the bottom of my heart for the work you do in this series and others... which benefit Muslims and non-Muslims... May God keep us and you steadfast.

[@TheologyWithLogic]

I've launched a new Islamic channel with a unique approach to Islamic teachings. I have also created videos discussing my attempts to prove the existence of God. In'Sha'Allah, you will like it. Thank you!

[@bazd313]

Subhanallah even robots are sending peace and blessings to our beloved prophet.

[@charlievaughan1308]

@bazd313 WHAT PLANET ARE YOU ON?? Its a machine incapable of thinking on its own. It is not self aware. Incapable of critical thinking. It is not a PERSON. It is an LLM ie a large language model. It merely regurgitated what it says on the Internet. Wake up if you don't want to.make.a laughing stock of Islam.

[@TheologyWithLogic]

I've started a new Islamic channel that offers a fresh perspective on Islamic teachings. I've also made videos where I explore and try to prove God's existence. In'Sha'Allah, you'll enjoy it. Jazak'Allah!

[@AYHAYRUAASI]

proud to be ummati of MUHAMMAD (saw) ❤

[@gaxxaroth7539]

Are you trying to write the prophets name in a weird way?

[@AYHAYRUAASI]

@@gaxxaroth7539 🙌

[@syedbaqir2687]

if u r ummati, what or who is eligible to lead muslims to sarat al mustaqeem according to Allah not sahabas based on surah fateha that u read every day

[@esx9346]

@@syedbaqir2687 la 3ala9a

[@AYHAYRUAASI]

@@syedbaqir2687 ALLAH

[@PalestineBookCafe]

People dont claim the quran is sufficient; the quran states that quran is sufficient

[@ismailbinabu1968]

Assalam everyone. Allah says in the Quran is complete and fully details. In this respect ChatGPT failed.

[@ggunitttt]

He doesn’t realise chatgpt is programmed by shaitan and his pets so it won’t give real info. They put ifs and buts to Allah’s verses.

[@TheQuranist]

Wa aleik al salaam, Bobby is from the decepters and ChatGPT gives mainstream answers. The web has mostly pro Hadithism content so it prioritises those contents and arguments in its arguments. All the arguments given by CHATGPT is easily debunkable.

[@Sohailhhh1993]

Chatgpt is like, Brother asked a very good question 🤓

[@MohammedKhan-y3i]

Let me repeat brother's question.

[@teamcali9212]

​@MohammedKhan-y3i "hope to answer your question" lol

[@AbbyUploadsALoT]

​@@teamcali9212 TeamCali9212 LOL

[@TheologyWithLogic]

I've started a new channel which presents Islamic teachings with a unique twist. I have also created videos where I tried to prove the existence of God. In'Sha'Allah, you'll appreciate the content. Jazak'Allah!

[@pasha_72_91]

Chatgpt is an advanced search and consolidator of available information only, hence why all the answers are the same as what we are told to just accept and never question or challenge logically.

[@friendlyhealth7467]

Even if one which is not advanced comes still you will not accept because it's not your eyes that are blind rather the heart 😂

[@TheAdrianSmith]

Well said mate

[@TheologyWithLogic]

I've started a fresh Islamic channel with an innovative take on Islamic education. Additionally, I've developed videos where I delve into proving God's existence. In'Sha'Allah, it will be meaningful to you. Thank you!

[@mjunikiobya]

WoW!. Bobby you did a great Job in this episode. Indeed you asked relevant questions

[@TheologyWithLogic]

I've launched a new channel where I explore Islamic teachings in a unique way. I have also crafted videos in which I seek to demonstrate the existence of God. In'Sha'Allah, it will resonate with you. Thank you!

[@kenkaneki9138]

The thing the distinguishes the Islamic civilization from other civilization is the science of Hadith. No civilization has put such effort or anything close to preserve their tradition, its what makes Islamic civilization unique.

[@wolfking4879]

Guess you forgot the Jews

[@effjoo]

what about the hadith that says the Earth is held up on a the back of the bull? Hadiths are false. Hadiths brought Islam to the dark ages.

[@Ali_Mekrani]

thats because other civilization are not so stupid to make hear/say science. Omar r.a. sad koran is sufficient for us. Malik ibn anas when people came to him with hadith he sad we don't take hadith as guides !

[@wolfking4879]

@@Ali_Mekrani[45:6] These are GOD's revelations that we recite to you truthfully. In which Hadith other than GOD and His revelations do they believe? [45:7] Woe to every fabricator, guilty. [45:8] The one who hears GOD's revelations recited to him, then insists arrogantly on his way, as if he never heard them. Promise him a painful retribution. [45:9] When he learns anything about our revelations, he mocks them. These have incurred a shameful retribution. [45:10] Awaiting them is Gehenna. Their earnings will not help them, nor the idols they had set up beside GOD. They have incurred a terrible retribution. [45:11] This is a beacon, and those who disbelieve in these revelations of their Lord have incurred condemnation and a painful retribution.

[@ridhuan2335]

Muslims learned from what happened to the jews and the christians. I think the jews would be like a "Hadith only muslims" and the christians would be "a Quran only muslims".. Hadith only muslims - Practice / follow blindly and depends too much on the community for daily practice / cultural muslims. definitely will corrupt practices over time following whoever is more influential. Quran only muslims - practice doesnt really matter, what matters is the intentions. As long as verses can be interpreted as such, they will do as such. most likely have no unified way to practice. follow whatever quran interpretation that suit their own understanding/desires. Holy spirit is born here, thats basically what it is doing. it does give much freedom tho

[@MCD0DE]

Needed to watch this! Great video and answered all of my questions/doubts.

[@cciid]

Why don't you give it its due justice and hear the arguments from the other side rather than from a robot?

[@MCD0DE]

@@cciid I have and all of the arguments/points that were brought up by Hadith rejectors were answered in this video.

[@TheologyWithLogic]

I've created a new channel offering a unique take on Islamic teachings. I've created videos where I present arguments for God's existence. In'Sha'Allah, it will be to your liking. Jazak'Allah!

[@ibrahimmujahed8000]

From personal experience, the more guidance i get from the lord, the closer and more obvious it becomes that i am following the prophet PBUH automatically, in things i've never seen hadiths on or mention of how the prophet PBUH, i would be directly heading to his example. It's truly surreal how extraordnary he was PBUH. and i can without shadow of a doubt, say everything he did and said was not performed from his nafs or to benefit himself, instead, it was absolutly guidance from our lord SWT. The more pious you become, the more clear how Prophet PBUH was deep down and truly is the messenger of Allah SWT, and how he as a creation was beyond extraordnary, and how he is made as a benefit to ALL Humanity. PBUH. I can easily say, how impossible it is to reach his knowledge, strength, honesty and reliability as he was beyond humanity in creation PBUH. and its extremly obvious that Allah SWT gave him the guidance and made him PBUH as perfect of an example for everyone to follow. And the Prophet PBUH, deserves all the praise the lord SWT required us to direct to our prophet in our prayers and more. Anyone who rejects the prophet PBUH is clearly not following islam, and Allah SWT knows, sees, percieves and hears everything including within everyone. Thats were you're , consiounciousness, fear and focus should be on, not if there was corruption in the passing down of the message. "And when it is said to them, 'Do not cause corruption on the earth,' they say, 'We are but reformers.' Unquestionably, it is they who are the corrupters, but they perceive it not." (Surah Al-Baqarah, 2:11-12) and those are explicity refer to hypocrites (munafiqoon)

[@user25895]

Assalaam 'Alaykum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuhu. Maashaa'Allah what an inspiring post. Jazaa'kallah Khair (may Allah reward you with Khair). Aameen 🤲 and may your Lord and Creator be pleased with you and your deeds.

[@TheAdrianSmith]

Apart from surah 22:12-12 , nothing you said is from the Quran

[@zebmohammad3776]

What you wrote is exactly what the Quran proponents say. The prophet followed what Allah SWT revealed to him, the Quran. He would be severely punished by Allah if he did not convey exactly what Allah revealed.

[@awwalever3232]

Narrated Abdullah ibn Amr ibn al-'As: I used to write everything which I heard from the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ). I intended (by it) to memorise it. The Quraysh prohibited me saying: Do you write everything that you hear from him while the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) is a human being: he speaks in anger and pleasure? So I stopped writing, and mentioned it to the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ). He signalled with his finger to him mouth and said: Write, by Him in Whose hand my soul lies, only right comes out from it. Grade: Sahih Sunan Abi Dawud 3647

[@wolfking4879]

@@awwalever3232 🤢🤮

[@Ali_Mekrani]

Koran 66:1 O Prophet, why do you prohibit what Allāh has made lawful for you, seeking the approval of your wives? And Allāh is Forgiving and Merciful. يَـٰٓأَيُّهَا ٱلنَّبِىُّ لِمَ تُحَرِّمُ مَآ أَحَلَّ ٱللَّهُ لَكَ ۖ تَبْتَغِى مَرْضَاتَ أَزْوَٰجِكَ ۚ وَٱللَّهُ غَفُورٌۭ رَّحِيمٌۭ

[@awwalever3232]

@@Ali_Mekrani القرآن الكريم سورة آل عمران الآية إثنان وثلاثون {قل أطيعوا الله والرسول فإن تولوا فإن الله لا يحب الكافرين} سورة النساء الآية ثمانون {من يطع الرسول فقد أطاع الله ومن تولى فما أرسلناك عليهم حفيظا} Quran 3:32 Say, "Obey Allah and the Messenger." But if they turn away - then indeed, Allah does not like the disbelievers. Quran 4:80 He who obeys the Messenger has obeyed Allah; but those who turn away - We have not sent you over them as a guardian. Do not mislead people by placing a verse out of its context. The verse that you mentioned only speaks about something that the Messenger, peace be upon him, did to himself and not to the believers, that even mean if there is anything Allah will revealed verse, unless Allah doesn't know ? Allah knows everything, glory to Him. The evidence for the obligation to obey the Messenger in the Holy Qur’an is very abundant.

[@KilifiKorner]

Maybe pick up a QUR'AN and read it again. While you're at it, take a few English classes.

[@wolfking4879]

@@awwalever3232 obeying the messenger is obeying the message he was sent to deliver by the Sender, God Almighty... The message being in the Quran.

[@ahamadhamidi6048]

My brother Bobby, what you do is so so so....Grate... makes more clear to understan Al Quran and Hadis..Thank you..

[@TheologyWithLogic]

I've created a new Islamic channel with a distinct approach to sharing Islamic teachings. I've created videos on topics aimed at proving that God exists. In'Sha'Allah, you'll find it engaging. Thank you!

[@kb4432]

Say, "Obey Allah and the Messenger." But if they turn away - then indeed, Allah does not like the disbelievers." Quran - Imran:32 This verse is mentions obeying both Allah and the Prophet. How can you obey the prophet without learning what he said through the Hadeeth?

[@cesalci]

definitely bro,quran With proofs and the scriptures. And We sent down to you the Reminder to reveal to the people what was sent to them, and perhaps they will think. He says, "To explain what was sent to them. Without explanation, everyone interprets the verses in their own way." There is also a very serious threat to hadith deniers. and quran and they want to make a distinction between God and His messengers, and they say, "We acknowledge some and reject some!", and they desire to take a path in-between. Allah further says that they are the disbelievers.

[@AbuHurraira-bn9mo]

what has obey the messenger got to do with hadith?

[@AbuHurraira-bn9mo]

@@cesalci what has obey the messenger got to do with hadith?

[@Letgoit2]

@@AbuHurraira-bn9mo The Hadith gives the commands and teachings of the prophet.

[@AbuHurraira-bn9mo]

@@Letgoit2 the Talmud also gives commands and teachings. just like the previous religions that abandoned the Torah and follow the talmud the rabbi wrote, so hadithist have abandoned the Quran for hadith that the sheikhs and imams wrote. the Quran even speaks about those who abandoned the Quran, and claim the Quran has been abrogated by hadith

[@kb4432]

"And whatever the Messenger has given you - take; and what he has forbidden you - refrain from. And fear Allah; indeed, Allah is severe in penalty." Quran Al-hashr 7 Here the verse specifically refers to what the prophet forbids, the quran is not from the prophet it is from Allah and so this verse is about the prophets own words

[@cesalci]

definitely bro,quran With proofs and the scriptures. And We sent down to you the Reminder to reveal to the people what was sent to them, and perhaps they will think. He says, "To explain what was sent to them. Without explanation, everyone interprets the verses in their own way." There is also a very serious threat to hadith deniers. and quran and they want to make a distinction between God and His messengers, and they say, "We acknowledge some and reject some!", and they desire to take a path in-between. Allah further says that they are the disbelievers.

[@AbuHurraira-bn9mo]

So you are claiming the prophet Muhammed didn't give Muslims the Quran ? if the prophet Muhammed gave people hadith book then why were they not collected in the same manner as the Quran? why is every hadith told to single person or couple, instead to the whole community like it was with the Quran

[@afifadanish7868]

The previous verse gives the context, it referring to giving and taking spoils of war, so it’s not what you assumed. Now when you see this verse being used to argue it shows your ignorance or arrogance.

[@virtualwanderer]

​@@afifadanish7868you're missing the context. If Allah says he has the authority to distribute the spoils, it means he is the only one with the wisdom to carry out Allah's command. This is why Allah mentions obeying and following the messenger over 50 times in the quran. This is just 1 instance of 50.

[@user25895]

​@@afifadanish7868Okay what about this verse? Surah An-Nisa 4:59: "O you who have believed, obey Allah and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you. And if you disagree over anything, refer it to Allah and the Messenger if you should believe in Allah and the Last Day. That is the best [way] and the best in result." This verse is for all time because Allah says "O you who have believed", that's all Muslims. So first we obey Allah, then the Prophet SAW (how? Yes, Hadiths) and those in authority like the 'ulama, scholars, Imams/sheikhs. And when we don't know something then refer not only to Allah, it says AND the messenger (how? Again, hadiths). And read further why.

[@DragovianMythiX]

Take cover, the Yemeni sisters (bots) are striking again!

[@Savagecat2503]

Pahahahahaha 😂

[@umarzz8892]

😂

[@kotarohardrockbontot1924]

Hahaha be carefull 😂

[@Kobenoz]

I'm your brother from Indonesia, please ignore my sister from Yemen...

[@Savagecat2503]

@@Kobenoz pahahahahahahaha

[@daniallegacy]

ImamGPT = BukhariGPT

[@TheAdrianSmith]

well said

[@kb4432]

"He who obeys the Messenger has obeyed Allah; but those who turn away - We have not sent you over them as a guardian." Quran - Nisa 80 Another verse mentioning both Allah and the Prophet. And this time note that it says if you obey the prophet THEN you have obeyed Allah. So obeying the prophet is is a separate action that is then equated to following the Creator.

[@cesalci]

definitely bro,quran With proofs and the scriptures. And We sent down to you the Reminder to reveal to the people what was sent to them, and perhaps they will think. He says, "To explain what was sent to them. Without explanation, everyone interprets the verses in their own way." There is also a very serious threat to hadith deniers. and quran and they want to make a distinction between God and His messengers, and they say, "We acknowledge some and reject some!", and they desire to take a path in-between. Allah further says that they are the disbelievers.

[@AbuHurraira-bn9mo]

what has obey the messenger got to do with hadith?

[@DafiLogs]

hahaha, yall ALWAYS play like this, the word is MESSENGER, but NAHH, just put PROPHET instead, NOT A BIG DEAL!!?? Really?? 🤣No question yall are really confused

[@rajababy2009]

@@AbuHurraira-bn9mo because Companions can follow the Prophet as they lived with him But we cant so later generation needed hadith compilation

[@TheDragonshadow1231]

That is true

[@abdulelah9726]

Your questions were amazing, and clover ❤

[@sHuRuLuNi]

Why is the Ummah in this horrible state? This is why: "And the messenger will say, “O my Lord, my people had abandoned this Qur’ān.” - Qur'an, 25:30 Keep relying on other than the Book of God ...

[@TheAdrianSmith]

Well said brother

[@ramazz]

May God guide us to straight path free from any form of shirk

[@aaronaaa9264]

now this is perfect from now on I will use only the Quran even Chat GPT is telling the truth no matter how you try to dress it

[@johnonah5178]

I think bobby is actually quran only lol in no way did chatgpt "destroy" that position but he doesn't want to be attacked by sheep

[@ramazz]

@@johnonah5178 i hope

[@hm-7456]

[150- Indeed, those who disbelieve in Allāh and His messengers and wish to discriminate between Allāh and His messengers and say, "We believe in some and disbelieve in others," and wish to adopt a way in between - 151- Those are the disbelievers, truly. And We have prepared for the disbelievers a humiliating punishment. 152- But they who believe in Allāh and His messengers and do not discriminate between any of them - to those He is going to give their rewards. And ever is Allāh Forgiving and Merciful. ] Surah-an-Nisa

[@Wasy-k3f]

Salaam Aliakum waramotullah wabarakatuh, brother Bobby , jazakallah khayran 🙏❤️

[@SI00000]

Which is worse? To reject all except the Quran or to raise something else above the Quran?

[@numara585]

The Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) was not just a messenger but also a role model and an ideal to be emulated. If people were left to worship God according to their own whims and personal interpretations of the Quran, everyone would have their own unique religion. God knows human nature; people will not adhere to a single uniform method of worship. Their understanding may evolve, and they may stray from the right path. The noble Prophet was not a "delivery man"-God chose Muhammad (peace be upon him) because he was at the highest levels of humanity in knowledge, morals, and actions; his teachings had a significant impact on us. Why do we accept the saying of Umar ibn al-Khattab, Hercules, or the revelations to Pharaoh without objection, while we question and protest the words of the great Messenger? Secondly, we do a disservice to the scholars who collected hadith, as if their goal was corruption. On the contrary, imagine if all the false or fabricated hadith, which number in the thousands, had reached us; our situation would be one of complete chaos. Instead, we should appreciate the efforts of the hadith collectors for sifting the false from the authentic, providing us with the life and sayings of the greatest of God's creation. Yes, there are hadith that are difficult or controversial, but we cannot undermine this great prophetic heritage just because some hadith do not align with our desires.

[@truepath99]

We have sent you O Prophet only as a mercy for the whole world. 21:107

[@friendlyhealth7467]

They are desires which are disturbing people they just don't want to believe and practice

[@TheAdrianSmith]

The Quran is not a religious book. Also God told Muhammad to follow the milat of Ibrahim. Do you follow it?

[@muhammadnuralhafiz]

yes he just a delivery man

[@muhammadnuralhafiz]

@@truepath99 read following verse

[@bobstevenson9015]

There is one sahih Hadith that is worth being challenged though I feel, and that is that of adultery. In the Quran it says that those that commit adultery and fornication, should be punished with 100 lashes. Yet the Hadith says that only implies for non married couples, and that a married person that is adulterous should be stoned to death. I have trouble coming to terms that such an important distinguish would be omitted by the Almighty, especially as the Quran itself clearly states that nothing has been neglected in it and that it is clear. While many Hadiths make sense, such as how to pray, this one I find to contradict the Quran and that scholars seems to have instead adopted a jewish punishment.

[@TheGreatLakeRuler]

Cook . Allah himself says follow the Quran in his prophet. Without Hadith how would you know how to perform Hajj or how to pray?

[@TheAdrianSmith]

Define hajj and salat form the Quran

[@MrT-gh5ch]

Thank you brother Bobby. We should be cautious of these movements and research their motives and origins (not just their arguments) as they seem stark.

[@moshameem99]

Gold and silk The prohibition for Muslim men to wear gold and silk originates from the hadith. Nowhere in the Quran does God forbid this.

[@TheologyWithLogic]

I've launched a new Islamic channel with a unique approach to Islamic teachings. I have also created videos discussing my attempts to prove the existence of God. In'Sha'Allah, you will like it. Thank you!

[@zingo6999]

7:32 Absolutely destroys their point

[@madmax5756]

Only quraan came for humanity not hadith

[@rezanoorkhan5916]

Excellent work Bobby!

[@TheologyWithLogic]

A new channel has been launched, offering a distinctive approach to Islamic teachings. I've also made videos aiming to substantiate the existence of God. In'Sha'Allah, you will find it valuable. Jazak'Allah!

[@عبدالله-ن6ه2ص]

These are books recommended by Dr. Sami Amiri, professor of comparative religion, for non-Muslims: 1. The First and Final Commandment, by Laurence B. Brown 2. The Divine Reality: God, Islam & The Mirage Of Atheism, by Hamza Andreas Tzortzis 3. The Qur'an: An Eternal Challenge, by Muhammad Abdullah Draz 4. Islam Between East and West, by Alija 'Ali Izetbegovic 5. Muhammad: Man and Prophet, by Adil Salahi 6. What Did Jesus Really Say?, Mish'al ibn Abdullah 7. The Bible, The Quran and Science, Maurice Bucaille 8. Women in Islam, AbdulRahman Bin Abdulkarim Al-Sheha 9. What Is Islam, by Jamaal Zarabozo

[@mamoudakla9217]

Salam brother, you do a great job. Super video, very interesting 👍

[@vortexvampire]

بارك الله فيكم... اللهم اغفر لوالدينا و ارحمهما و اجمعنا معهما في الفردوس الأعلى مع الأنبياء و الشهداء و الصالحين و جميع موتى المسلمين.. اللهم احقن دماء المسلمين و انصرهم على من عاداهم.. رب إني مسني الضر و أنت أرحم الراحمين... لا إله إلا أنت سبحانك إني كنت من الظالمين..... ............. . .. .

[@mikeaaron8506]

truly smartest verification,and very useful jazakkallah khair

[@IdrisoFilms]

The only KZbinr i forgive making clickbait titles. JazakhAllahu khair akhi

[@TheBobbysPerspective]

But it's not clickbait at all.

[@U.019]

​@@TheBobbysPerspectiveyour title should be Chatgpt destroyed Quranists! Not Quran

[@m0racle]

@@U.019but the word Quranist would sound like they are people who are extremely expert on Quranic subjects, which they clearly are not.

[@U.019]

@@m0racle then I think hadith rejectors is more appropriate

[@zingo6999]

@@U.019Which hadith rejectors?🤔🧐

[@Chiimu864]

No Book is fully understood without its Teacher. Islam is for all - the literate and the illiterate. Follow and Love your Teacher and you will be fine iA. If Imam Bukhari or Muslim (May Allah have Mercy on them) claimed something wrong intentionally - they will be held responsible on The Day. We follow for the love of our Prophet SAW and may Allah accept this from us as his Ummah and make us amongst his followers on The Day of Judgement

[@blackcatmuezza9338]

As a former hadith rejector myself, all I ask of the sincere ones among the hadith rejectors is to not stop with the few cherry picked Quran verses quoted by professional Quranists but to sincerely take it upon themselves to study the entire Quran and ponder over its verses. I have no doubt that when they do that, the Quran itself will direct them to hadiths of Prophet Muhammad(PBUH). Only then, they will be able to reconcile they verses they quote with other verses like 33:21, 4:59, 3:164 etc. Take your time, check your ego and desire to be always right at the door, and ask Allah to guide you in your journey to the truth. Just to be clear, I don't regret going Quran alone for those few years bcz it did force me to focus on our primary source of guidance, The Holy Quran, which every Muslim should do. The only regret I have is arguing with limited knowledge and trying to convince others to accept my views like I see other hadith rejectors doing. May Allah forgive me if I did end up misleading anyone out there. Ameen.

[@kb4432]

Ameen. May Allah forgive you. You got lost but You came back to the truth of Islam because you were always sincere. Keep warning, InshaAllah through you, more will come back to the truth.

[@Quranhadith360]

[Surah Āli-ʿImrān: 164] Indeed Allâh conferred a great favour on the believers when He sent among them a Messenger (Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم) from among themselves, reciting unto them His Verses (the Qur’ân), and purifying them (from sins by their following him), and instructing them (in) the Book (the Qur’ân) and Al-Hikmah [the wisdom and the Sunnah of the Prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم (i.e. his legal ways, statements, acts of worship)], while before that they had been in manifest error. [Surah Al-Baqarah: 151] Similarly (to complete My Blessings on you), We have sent among you a Messenger (Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم) of your own, reciting to you Our Verses (the Qur’ân) and purifying you, and teaching you the Book (the Qur’ân) and the Hikmah (i.e. Sunnah, Islâmic laws and Fiqh - jurisprudence), and teaching you that which you used not to know. - Al-Hilali & Khan

[@blackcatmuezza9338]

@@kb4432 InshaAllah. That is why I post on this topic everywhere so Allah will see my efforts and forgive me for spreading misinformation in the past out of sheer ignorance. There is nothing I can do to re-educate the ones I may have negatively influenced years ago...I live with that regret everyday of my life... but at least Allah is giving me the chance to warn others who are currently being misled. Thre is much truth to the saying, "a little information is a dangerous thing".

[@tuning6924]

@@Quranhadith360So you say Hikmah is outside of Qur’an? What if I show you the Hikmah from the Qur’an itself? Will you believe?

[@kb4432]

@@blackcatmuezza9338You have nothing to fear. Allah is the Most Merciful. The Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) said: “The one who repents from sin is like the one who did not sin.” Narrated by Ibn Maajah (4250); classed as saheeh by al-Albaani in Saheeh Ibn Maajah.

[@user-if9pp4vg7g]

Thing is following someone's example and essentially worshipping what people think he said are two different things. People treat hadith as if its the Quran and cannot be refuted.

[@johnhill6794]

Relying on AI to give us guidance is ridiculous. The Quran was revealed in arabic to those who think. It requires a deep understanding of the arabic language to understand the Quran. The islamic world will never be united without refering back to the Quran.

[@CaptainS159]

Ai with Quranic Arabic . Does it exist?

[@supermario1460]

... and the Sunna

[@AR-yr5ov]

Sunnis don't dispute that. But Quranists do dispute the validity of Hadith. You're tip-toeing around that. Are you a hadith rejector?

[@blackcatmuezza9338]

True. We can only be united if we refer back to the Quran and the way Prophet Muhammad(PBUH) interpreted its commandments. Otherwise everyone will interpret its verses based on their own whims and desires which will split us up even further.

[@HajjiJesus]

​@blackcatmuezza9338 Imagine this simple example. Imagine if Billionaires say we only pay cents because there is no definition of how much it shoukd be paid in Quran, or a child stealing a candy would cause them losing their hands, etc. Hadith is mercy and to give the people on how best to follow the Quran, i.e Prophet's way.

[@Nour_Islam204]

MashaAllah brother, I support you!

[@asimjabbar8445]

In Quran 33(Al Ahzaab) verse 21. Allah says that you have an excellent/beautiful example (to follow) in the shape of Prophet's life (as a role model). So we Muslims are ordered by God to try to follow the path of the prophet. Apart from broader aspects and guidance, Quran doesn't teach in detail how to carry out your day to day tasks. Whole Islamic jurisprudence, way of life, offering prayers, seeking Allah's help through Dua, conducting business, treating people, minute details of rights and obligations, even the guide lines for conducting warfare, charity everything is extracting from Sunnah and Hadith. What imam wears and how he delivers his lecture etc all are copied as the Prophet did and was subsequently done and taught by his companions. Hadith is mostly the detailed explanation of the Quran and the events that occured during that time period.

[@asimjabbar8445]

In Quran Allah says that your adopted sons/daughters or parents are not the actual real son/daughters. there's difference between them and your begotten offsprings. But Hadith elaborates that and how it was proven by the Prophet's family situation. Prophet Muhammad's life is special in a way that he had been through vast variety of situations. Like his life before being Prophet, his trade and business ethics, he lived under the pagan Govt, then conducting Hijra, his tribe and followers Faced insulation/boycott. How he forged alliances in Madina, he assumed the roles of a military general, head of state, imam, conducting diplomacy, judicial system, economic system. His life encompasses almost all the fields of life. His own family matters are presented as the role model to be taught and jurisprudence.

[@mirali3405]

Bobby, You are learning as a new Muslim and spreading Islam and uninformed Muslims and non-Muslims are also learning. May Allah bless you.

[@zilenium007]

People shound understand that Quran is majestic word, the King speech. The king's speech usually use concise wording not detailed. The detail is given to the messenger. Hadith rejector will also needs detailed in their aplications of the Quran. this detail has only two options. (1) they relay on their (their leaders) understanding (2) relay on prophetic example and teaching in hadith. any sincere muslim would take the 2nd.

[@TheAdrianSmith]

Seriously, you are contradicting yourself

[@Thehanifapath]

Quran defines shirk as associating authority with Allah. On who's authority are these scholars working? There are plenty of "sahi" Bukhari that are fake because of their blatant contradiction and innovations on the Quran.

[@AmarYasser-v5g]

Whitout hadith who can we pray ? Even in hadith the Prophet SAW tell you how you should prostern

[@TheAdrianSmith]

It’s described in the Quran The Quran mentions remembering Allah in the morning and evening in several places: Surah Al-A'raf 7:205: "And remember your Lord within yourself in humility and in fear without being apparent in speech - in the mornings and the evenings. And do not be among the heedless". Surah Al-Kahf 28: "And patiently stick with those who call upon their Lord morning and evening, seeking His pleasure". Surah Al-Ahzab 43: "And glorify His praises morning and in the evening". Surah Ali 'Imran 33:41-42: "Believers, remember Allah often and glorify Him morning and evening". Surah Al-Baqarah 152: "Remember Me; I will remember you. And thank Me, and never be ungrateful

[@Thehanifapath]

Are you aware that the hadiths do not have an explanation of one salat cycle, yet the Quran does. It also tells us the exact time to pray, and even when amd how to break our fast. Allah is concise with his message because he wants to keep it simple

[@redvoice896]

La ilaha ill-Allah ☝🏻❤️🌹

[@shaikino]

Proof of Divine Authorship [4:82] Why do they not study the Quran carefully? If it were from other than GOD, they would have found in it numerous contradictions.* [10:39] Indeed, they have rejected this without studying and examining it, and before understanding it. Thus did those before them disbelieve. Therefore, note the consequences for the transgressors. [34:44] We did not give them any other books to study, nor did we send to them before you another warner. Study the Quran [47:24] Why do they not study the Quran carefully? Do they have locks on their minds? [39:29] GOD cites the example of a man who deals with disputing partners (Hadith), compared to a man who deals with only one consistent source (Quran). Are they the same? Praise be to GOD; most of them do not know. Muhammad Forbidden from Issuing Any Religious Teachings [69:44] Had he uttered any other teachings. [69:45] We would have punished him. [69:46] We would have stopped the revelations to him. [69:47] None of you could have helped him. [69:48] This is a reminder for the righteous. [69:49] We know; some of you are rejectors.

[@CommentsProbablyDeleted]

Qur'an's message is best understood through the lense of the Prophet Muhammad's life in the Hadith.

[@AbuHurraira-bn9mo]

hadith is not the lens of the prophet . even hadith scholars admit that hadith are not direct quotes from prophet but the words of the people who spread these hadith

[@CommentsProbablyDeleted]

@@AbuHurraira-bn9mo I stand corrected.

[@shamailsiddiqui1403]

so allah wont teach u quran? isnt allah sufficent for u???

[@TheAdrianSmith]

@@shamailsiddiqui1403well said brother

[@zebmohammad3776]

Seriously? Why do even need any other book while Allah address all the humans in the Quran? The prophet was not even allowed to move his tongue before the revelation. His job was to convey Allah's message and nothing else. Quran says so. Read the Quran please. Hidaya is in the Quran, for muttaqeen.

[@ysfkrwn7095]

For you who are still in doubt whether hadiths are necessary. Do remember the last sermon of our Prophet SAW at the mount of Arafat: "O People! No Prophet or apostle will come after me and no new faith will be born. Reason well, therefore O People! and understand words that I convey to you. I leave behind me two things, the Quran and the Sunnah and if you follow these you will never go astray. All those who listen to me shall pass on my words to others and those to others again; and may the last ones understand my words better than those who listen to me directly."

[@ibrahimmuhammad1323]

Proud to be a Muslim and the detail questions and answers should also put forward to Christianity to see whether it will pass the test please...

[@DMMreasons]

How did the Hadith rejectors know that the prophet ordered his companions to write down the Quran without reading that from a Hadith? This question alone debunks every claim that Hadith rejectors make.

[@TheAdrianSmith]

Why don’t you ask God?

[@Abdul-l5p]

Quran alone is not Hadith rejection because God already says the Quran is the best of Hadith ﴾39:23 ﴿ GOD has revealed the best Hadith

[@DMMreasons]

@Abdul-l5p So where in the Quran did Allah order the companions to write down the Quran?

[@Abdul-l5p]

@@DMMreasons First do you agree that the Quran is the best of Hadith? Because you called us hadith rejectors without knowing the Quran is the Hadith.

[@DMMreasons]

@Abdul-l5p Bro, why is it difficult for you to answer a simple question?

[@SAMEERSHAIKH-pb3fe]

May Allah bless you and sunnah of prophet Muhammad peace be upon him warm our heart's ❤❤❤

[@Yusufhusein-k1]

The initial prohibition of writing down Hadith by the Prophet was to prevent the mixing of Hadith with the Quran, as the Quran was still being revealed at that time [1] [2]. The fear was that if Hadith were written down, there could be confusion and potential competition between the two sources [4]. This prohibition was also intended to ensure that the Quran remained the primary source of guidance [1]. However, despite the prohibition, some companions of the Prophet still wrote and memorized Hadith. It was only later, during the caliphate of Umar bin Abdul Aziz, that the official collection of Hadith began.

[@Cobra_Khan]

Can you provide an authentic source where the Prophet ﷺ prohibits writing down Hadith?

[@Yusufhusein-k1]

@@Cobra_Khan Abu Sa'id Khudri reported that Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said: Do not take down anything from me, and he who took down anything from me except the Qur'an, he should efface that and narrate from me, for there is no harm in it and he who attributed any falsehood to me-and Hammam said: I think he also said:" deliberately" -he should in fact find his abode in the Hell-Fire. حَدَّثَنَا هَدَّابُ بْنُ خَالِدٍ الأَزْدِيُّ، حَدَّثَنَا هَمَّامٌ، عَنْ زَيْدِ بْنِ أَسْلَمَ، عَنْ عَطَاءِ بْنِ يَسَارٍ، عَنْ أَبِي سَعِيدٍ الْخُدْرِيِّ، أَنَّ رَسُولَ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم قَالَ ‏ "‏ لاَ تَكْتُبُوا عَنِّي وَمَنْ كَتَبَ عَنِّي غَيْرَ الْقُرْآنِ فَلْيَمْحُهُ وَحَدِّثُوا عَنِّي وَلاَ حَرَجَ وَمَنْ كَذَبَ عَلَىَّ - قَالَ هَمَّامٌ أَحْسِبُهُ قَالَ - مُتَعَمِّدًا فَلْيَتَبَوَّأْ مَقْعَدَهُ مِنَ النَّارِ ‏"‏ ‏.

[@Yusufhusein-k1]

@@Cobra_Khan Allah knows best

[@jazzjazz7627]

@@Yusufhusein-k1 The Prophet (peace be upon him) initially prohibited the writung of Hadith but later permitted it. Ask chatGPT about it

[@Cobra_Khan]

@@Yusufhusein-k1 This is a Hadith

[@Crazyneo2917]

Awesome video. Let's say quran only muslims came into a world where there is no hadith no knowledge about prophets or their life. Will they be able to establish a proper form of Islamic life like we have now? I believe it would be extremely hard without all the teaching of prophet Muhammad SAW. And reading only quran and trying to live as a true Muslim would be like reading the user manual of a car and starting to drive the car into a busy highway for the first time. I am assuming all this on my basic knowledge, i could be wrong. I personally would follow quran and use hadith to guide me when i don't understand the quanic verses. I can't imagine a world where quran only existed without our beloved prophet. He is our teacher and without his example we are sheeps without a shepherd. Long lost to the wolves.

[@TheAdrianSmith]

You sound like most Christians

[@salehathezigns]

Jazakallahu khairan brother for this amazing video

[@edinsemsovic4453]

How the example of the prophète means to follow books someday else wrote the books he never saw ore approved

[@commentofthis]

Hadith rejectors are in fact rejecting Quran's commandment to actually follow the Prophet's example, it's mind boggling..🗿

[@fabians1028]

But how do you know what is true of his actions or just an invention by some muslim king

[@abedonly]

Does Allah tabaraka wa taala, preserve the Hadith?

[@commentofthis]

@@fabians1028 do you even know what "bid'ah" means..?

[@fabians1028]

@@commentofthis no I did not know now I know - and what is your logical statement on this? If we use this over centuries we are again on the same point as Christians ;) stay near to the core don't you agree?

[@blackcatmuezza9338]

@@abedonly Allah knows the future. If Prophet's sunnah could not be preserved after his passing, we would not find so many Quran references on obeying the messenger, following his example, and taking our disagreements to him for resolution. Why would Allah want to confuse future generations of Muslims by telling them to do things of which He knew they would have no knowledge?

[@moshameem99]

How to pray” argument Hadithers will inevitably tell you that the hadith are necessary for Islamic law because it explains how to pray. What these people don’t realize is that • No one learns how to pray by reading the hadith. Instead, they learn from other people like their parents. • The hadith does not clearly explain how to pray. Considering that prayer is a daily ritual, the fact that the hadith doesn’t say much about how to pray should make you question the authenticity of the hadith in general. • Even if the hadith did clearly explain how to pray, then since the hadith books were not written until ~200 years after Muhammad’s death, then for 2 centuries after Muhammad died, no one could pray because the hadith books had not been written yet. It is illogical to believe that people could not pray for 200 years because they were waiting for Bukhari to write his hadith book. It is reasonable to believe that God did not provide step-by-step instructions on how to pray in the Quran because God knew that people at first would learn by following Muhammad and then after Muhammad died, people would learn from their communities, e.g. when they pray at mosques on Friday. In actuality, knowledge of how to pray is passed down from one generation to another, not from reading through thousands of hadith trying to figure it out like some huge jigsaw puzzle.

[@rodjaibmanaleseg2264]

The Noble Qur'an and prophetic traditions ( sunnah preserved by the hadiths) are both revelations from the Divine (Allah). They complement one another.

[@nasarkhan3648]

Very intresting video one video enough for information for non muslim and new muslim

[@mshaz452]

If someone claims to follow the Qur'an alone and decides to "simply prostrate," it would lead to countless variations of what that prostration looks like. Without the Prophet’s guidance, each person would interpret the Qur'an differently, leading to division and chaos. This applies not just to prostration but to all commands in the Qur'an. The Qur'an itself makes clear that Allah doesn't just send the message; He sends a prophet to show how to follow it. Countless exaples in the quran where prophets calling people to the straight path and then guiding them. The Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) was chosen to be a living example, demonstrating the correct way to practice Islam. The Qur'an tells us: "Indeed, in the Messenger of Allah, you have a good example..." (33:21). "And whatever the Messenger has given you, take it..." (59:7). Saying that the Qur'an is enough ignores the purpose of the Prophet’s mission. Without the Sunnah, the unity of Islam would collapse into endless personal interpretations, defeating the very order that Islam provides.

[@TheAdrianSmith]

Here is my humble advice to you , go back and study the Quran with care.

[@silent_dators]

@@TheAdrianSmith here is my humble request to you go and read seerat and hadees and quran

[@silent_dators]

@@TheAdrianSmith we dont say that hadees is first the primary major book is quran what hadees match with it accept it

[@TheAdrianSmith]

@@silent_datorsTell me , who is the first hadith rejector?

[@silent_dators]

@@TheAdrianSmith you

[@charkueyteow04]

If books are enough to teach students, why do we need teachers in schools?

[@InspoDesigno]

the early muslims relied upon hadith (literally reports), i.e. the sayings+actions of prophet Muhammad peace be upon him.

[@AbuHurraira-bn9mo]

since you were not there your opinions about what the early Muslims relied up on is worthless. from hadith itself we can see that Umar was against hadith being spread

[@khendrix]

@@AbuHurraira-bn9mohe didn’t have to be there lol what a garbage response may Allah guide you

[@AbuHurraira-bn9mo]

@@khendrix clearly you're to ignorant to understand why its worthless opinion for someone on youtube who was not a witness to make claims about early muslims

[@AbuHurraira-bn9mo]

@@khendrix its haram for hadithist to use reason. may Allah guide you

[@khendrix]

@@AbuHurraira-bn9mo yes because we don’t have books of Hadith or any information on the prophet ﷺ the Sahaba or the Salaf, we can only have a opinion if we lived 1400 years ago again u make no sense none of us were alive back then so why don’t everybody just never speak about Islam ever again?? Low IQ comment

[@ElementsofIslam]

May Allah Reward you in duniya and aakhirah brother Bobby

[@Sami-pd5kc]

Are you being serious that ChatGpt could have a say about such a topic? Please tell me why I am as a Muslim be given the burden to authenticate Hadiths and the chain of narrators who I didn’t meet and could never meet? Some might say this is a job of specialized scholars who vet Hadiths text and narrators credibility and trustworthiness but Even if all narrators were 100% well intentioned they’re humans after all and subjects to memory lapses or misunderstanding issues. The same thing applies to the content of the Hadith, we have Hadiths that their content is ridiculous but they get a pass because of their “strong”chain of narration. The idea that Hadiths are narrated by multiple companions with separate chain of narration is very small if it even exists at all. The vast majority of Hadiths are solitary with a single chain of narration and scholars differ on who is trustworthy and who is liar or forgetful and thus not trustworthy. Additionally I don’t want to be a sheep and just follow so called Hadith scholars in something that they can never perfect because it can’t be devoid of biases, guesses and mistakes. If our beloved Prophet ﷺ believed Hadiths were Wahi like the Quran, like some misguided people claim, he would have commanded the companions to write them down and proof read them like the case with the Quran. Actually the Prophet did the opposite and commanded his companions not to write anything other than the Quran and erase anything that they did. The companions obeyed RasulAllah ﷺ and didn’t write down anything other than the Quran but hundreds of years later came Bukhari and knowingly or unknowingly disobeyed. The thing that angers me the most is people saying Hadith is the same as the Quran being revealed and thus it is Wahi blah blah blah. Quran was written AND PROOF READ by the Prophet ﷺ himself during his lifetime. How dare are you to compare the Hadiths to the Quran when the Hadiths narrators relied on memory alone and wasn’t proof read by the Prophet ﷺ himself for errors or misunderstandings. Now some will say without Hadiths you would not know how to pray or fast blah blah blah. These people keep parroting this nonsense without even thinking it through. Please answer me why the Islamic nation would need Bukhai Hadiths or any Hadiths to remember to pray or fast or to do any act of worship? The Ummah learned how to do all acts of worship from RasulAllah ﷺ and they kept doing it like it is from his lifetime ﷺ to this day. We didn’t stop doing all acts of worship in order to seek assistance from Bukhari to remind us how to do it. The acts and methods of worship is what defines the Sunnah of our beloved prophet ﷺ and Hadiths are not the Sunnah but people knowingly or not keep using both terms synonymously when they are not synonymous at all. The Sunnah transmitted to us by practice and passed through generations unchanged because the acts of worahip is the prophetic application of the Quranic commandments and therefore it is preserved by Allah like Allah ﷻ promised to preserve his book. Finally if the so called scholars didn’t place the Hadiths in the same sacred place as the Quran and regard them as complementary, which BTW is a hidden acknowledgment that Quran is not a complete book, I am sure nobody would have been angry or against the Hadiths as a historical resource no more or less than that. Claiming that Hadiths as equal to the Quran is actually no different than associating partners with Allah ﷻ. Allah ﷻ knows best.

[@thetruthandthebestexplanat6686]

45:6 ends any debate: 45:6 These are the messages of Allah, which We recite to you with truth. In what announcement will they then believe after Allah and His signs?

[@luckyluke8576]

To ensure the consistency and unity in whorship across the muslim community. Therefore we need hadith. In fact, the authenticity of hadith exceeds the holy books of other religions.

[@ItsShanzyy]

Bobby I'm here after a year... You are my favourite but i was struggling in life so i didn't watch anything! Now im watching every video one by one Insha Allah💙💙💙

[@AR-yr5ov]

Hadith rejectors are the saddest people on earth. Imagine finding the truth and then not being able to absorb the entire thing. So you never fulfill any of the duties imposed upon you. They don't even pray 5 prayers. LMAO. Very sad.

[@AbuHurraira-bn9mo]

Umar the second khalif was one of those "sad a hadith rejector" and threatened to beat abu huraira for spreading hadith

[@AR-yr5ov]

@@AbuHurraira-bn9mo He never "beat" him, he reprimanded him and shoved him, but that was for a very specific hadith. Umar RA was not against hadith. Where is your proof that he was against all Hadith? Also how many prayers in a day and how many rakaat in each prayer?

[@khendrix]

@@AR-yr5ovdon’t argue with him Akhi he’s going back and forth with everybody in the comments he’s clearly a troll, may Allah keep us firm on the Quran & Sunnah

[@AbuHurraira-bn9mo]

@@AR-yr5ov Umar forbade abu huraira to spread any hadith, not just 1. and abu huraira himself admitted that he only felt free to spread hadith after Umar passed

[@AbuHurraira-bn9mo]

@@AR-yr5ov how many rakaat in each prayer comes from Fiqh not hadith. imam abu hanifa was also against hadith and based his Fiqh on Quran

[@adamdost1876]

Ask your GOD, ChatGPT, what does God say in the Quran regarding Hadith other THAN QURAN. ASK IT SHOULD MUSLIMS FOLLOW ANY HADITH OTHER THAN QURAN WHICH GOD’s HADITH. THEN YOU WILL SEE EVEN CHATGPT WILL DESTROY YOUR HADITH BOOKS AND HADITH WORSHIPPERS.

[@sevenseven31]

How do you use your computer, i.e. the computer, without reading its teaching book? It seems that GPT chat is an answer to your questions that you were asking previously regarding the benefit of the noble Prophet’s hadith, but you were very strict and strict in your questions, and now try the same standards on Christianity and Judaism. And compare by yourself

[@tounsi_m7ashesh]

Why are you comparing God's book to a man made device that limitation is humanly also you can understand your computer through trial and error so it's not really a good analogy

[@sevenseven31]

@@tounsi_m7ashesh To bring understanding closer, it is as clear as the sun

[@Abdulaziz-kw]

Jazak Allah Khair Brother .

[@belkassem06]

Masha Allah. ChatGPT just admitted the Quran is the real source to rely on. The quran is ENOUGH. I am a proud Quranist.

[@blackcatmuezza9338]

Can you tell me, based only on Quran, why only Isa ibn Mariam(A.S) is given the title of Al-Masih by Allah? Its important enough to have been mentioned multiple times in the Quran. So what does this title mean and what is its role according to the Quran? Speaking of Isa(A.S) how do you....again, without using contextual support from any hadith(report) outside of Quran....reconcile Quran verse 4:157 with verse 19:33. How and when will Jesus die(19:33) when 4:157 says he was saved from crucifixion and raised up alive to Allah?

[@commentofthis]

@@blackcatmuezza9338 they completely disregard the fact that even the Quran told us to follow the examples of the Prophet, the irony..😆

[@malofficialyt4268]

so how do you pray?or you pray just as you like?where did you get your Quran from?is it the companions who transmit or who?

[@TheAdrianSmith]

@@blackcatmuezza9338 Jesus died , he was not taken up alive and he is certainly not coming back. Plus he was not born miraculously, he had a father .

[@blackcatmuezza9338]

@@TheAdrianSmith LOL, finally your true colors are showing. You're not only anti-hadith but also anti Quran. You say Jesus died. Quran disagrees(4:157-158). You say he's not coming back. Quran gives him the title of Messiah and indicates his eventual death(19:33) which means he is coming back to fulfill another role given to him by Allah before dying like all humans. You say he was not born miraculously but had a father. Quran says otherwise.(Quran 19:20-21). I think its time to stop taking you seriously. However I do want to ask some other more sincere Quranist, what does "Masih", the title given to Isa(A.S), mean? Remember, you cannot use the explanation of that title and role provided by hadith. Use only Quran explanation in your answer. Thank you in advance.

[@shaikino]

How did the previous prophets before Muhammad recite Shahada?

[@WiseWisdom94]

Allah promised us guidance ( hudan) Our guidance from God is the Quran alone.

[@alhassangangu4357]

It is reported that Saydinaa Abu Bakr RA had 50 ahadith he wrote down but destroyed them before he passed away.

[@sHuRuLuNi]

A letter written to the Caliph Abd Al Malik (r.685-705) has the following passage about Muslims just a few decades after the Prophet a.s: "They abandoned the judgement of their Lord and took hadiths for their religion; and they claim that they have obtained knowledge other than from Qur'an." "They believed in a book which was not from God, written by the hands of men; they then attributed it to the Messenger of God."

[@mot7-7xein10]

Great video Bobby 👍👍

[@shaikino]

Quran: Fully Detailed* [6:114] Shall I seek other than GOD as a source of law, when He has revealed to you this book fully detailed?* Those who received the scripture recognize that it has been revealed from your Lord, truthfully. You shall not harbor any doubt. *6:113-115 Upholding any source beside the Quran reflects disbelief in the Quran

[@silent_dators]

it says sources of law what do you take source of law?

[@KEVIN_ELIX]

Bosnia and Herzegovina, Bosniaks follow only Quran no hadith and way of life since Bogumil (10 century Bogumil took Jesus second to God and not as Jesus god, pray 5 times, did not have saints or icons) Quran is to be studied not just read by each individual.

[@zingo6999]

Where’s 5 salats in Quran? Only 3 was mentioned

[@paperplanes1015]

"There has certainly been for you in the Messenger of Allah an excellent pattern for anyone whose hope is in Allah and the Last Day and [who ] remembers Allah often " Quran 33:21 " Hold firmly to the rope of Allah all together and do not become divided. And remember the favor of Allah upon you - when you were enemies and He brought your hearts together and you became, by His favor, brothers. And you were on the edge of a pit of the Fire, and He saved you from it .Thus does Allah make clear to you His verses that you may be guided. " Quran 3:103

[@TheIslamicGamer]

Im Ex Quranist, I denied Hadith because I was trying to rebel from Allah, but I didn't want to accept that I was doing so, So I blamed the hadith (the only matter I could point my finger at in this perfect religion). But now I realise that all of them cannot possibly be wrong. But it was my ego speaking. I thought I'm better than others, Lord forgive me!❤😢

[@sirajsid7760]

It is common sense to believe that scholars were genuine to collect, verify its sources, scrutinize, validate and finally add but not blindly.

[@TheIslamicGamer]

@@sirajsid7760 true brother

[@Kannadipaarvai]

can you please share what exactly changed your perspective ?

[@Ali_Mekrani]

You say it yourself (the only matter I could point my finger at in this perfect religion) Of course not all of them are wrong we don't say that. if i read a hadith were the prophet say's: you have to be good for your nabour NO PROBLEM, the koran say's the same.

[@TheIslamicGamer]

@@Kannadipaarvai actually I was sitting one day and racking my brain in hadith rejection philosophy... I was fed up with such tiredness and desparately asked Allah to guide me and show me a sign if I am on the wrong path and I was immediately shown a sign without a millisecond delay... But I thought it was a fluke and so, I asked for another sign and got another sign in a millisecond... Then I prostated and cried...the sign was a very rare occurrence but I don't wanna discuss it. And then I researched further into it and found it to be absurd and misleading

[@Faadielg]

Great video, clears up a lot of misconceptions, I only hope it allows Quranists to have a better idea of the function of Hadith and that it is not an affront to the Quran's guidance but allows them to practice Islam from the final message as practiced by it's messenger not from a vague inclination of simply prostrating being enough. Hadith are categorised well enough and base Islamic practices are pretty much universal and don't contradict the Quran.

[@kaka09876543210]

the only quranist that I legit understand and respect is revert. majority born muslim quranist that I see is either racist or hate specific person.

[@cciid]

A number of sahih hadith contradict Quran and themselves though...

[@Faadielg]

@@cciid Yeah so as the Quran states use your intelligence and you ignore those, that's if they really do contradict the Quran and it's not your lack of understanding.

[@imranhaji265]

Hi bobby me from indian occupied kashmir Please make reaction videos on Dr Zakir naik videos Moreover love u keep it up 🤍☝️

[@afifadanish7868]

24:01 trust but not infallible and divinely preserved, as gpt mentioned earlier.

[@sHuRuLuNi]

So, in addition to Bukhari & Co, you now have another Lord besides Allah - ChatGPT! Well done! "These are the verses of Allāh which We recite to you in truth. Then, in which HADITH, after Allāh and His verses, will they believe?" - Qur'an, 45:6

[@nooralnoor]

your a champ bro, well fucking said, the quran is sufficient enough!!!! allah has said so, and thats all we need

[@tuning6924]

Surah Al-Ankabut 51, ”Is it not enough for them that We have sent down to you the Book, ˹which is˺ recited to them. Surely in this ˹Quran˺ is a mercy and reminder for people who believe.” ”For people who BELIEVE” so if you follow any other book than Qur’an then you are not included in this verse. Salam

[@farazdaqchamal6417]

🚨🚨🚨🚨 Salam, Boby, I've been following you for a while and I like very much your logic and way of thinking. Regarding this subject, there are so much more material in arabic going in the way of Qoranists, by the way there are several types of qoranist some who are 0% suna, others keeping just the practical and not scriptural (Hadeeths). As an arabic born muslim I can tell you that the subject is much more complex to be treated in an hour or a day and the claim that the Hadeeths have harmed the Islam and Muslims through history more than it served it is a question that has to be seriously asked and deeply studied. I didn't answer definitively this question but at this point my answer is rather yes. Please take your time to study this point and I hope that you will be one of the non arabic Muslims who will guide the non Arab Muslims in this very critical topic. For information, this topic has started to be well discussed even that the qoranis are criticized and sometimes more than that.

[@TheAdrianSmith]

You are the one following the Satan footsteps, God rejects all hadiths except the Quran.

[@muslimresponse103]

Alhamdulillah for the Quran and sunnah. there is only 1 islam!

[@TheAdrianSmith]

FYI there is no sunnah of the prophet, only the sunnah of God in the Quran. Wake up before it’s too late

[@muslimresponse103]

@@TheAdrianSmith you are not a Muslim.

[@TheAdrianSmith]

@@muslimresponse103 According to you , not according to the Quran

[@muslimresponse103]

@@TheAdrianSmith lol I have debated too many of you and the Quran always wins against your false ideology! i have no time for any more of you! we will see on Judgement Day!

[@muslimresponse103]

@@TheAdrianSmith you have never even read the Quran.

[@alhassangangu4357]

Sura 6 verse 38 isn’t talking about this Qur’an but Lawh Mahfouz according to mufassirun

[@jesus_isamuslim]

Allah promises to protect the Quran from any change or distortion. In Surah Al-Hijr (15:9), He says: "Indeed, We have sent down the Quran, and surely We will guard it." 🌟📖 This verse is clear proof that Allah Himself has taken the responsibility to preserve the Quran. Throughout history, the Quran has been carefully transmitted unchanged. 📜 The practice of hifz-memorizing the Quran-by millions of people further ensures its protection. 👳‍♂️🧕📚 Old manuscripts, identical to today's Quran, also testify to its preservation. 📝☝️

[@edinsemsovic4453]

Good example in the prophète how he believed and followed the Qur’an

[@sameerhassan2912]

Quran does not teach how to pray, by this logic, following quran only means you won't know how to pray🤣

[@sHuRuLuNi]

Qur'an DOES teach you how to pray: Stand, recite the Qur'an, bow and prostrate while praising your Lord. And that is ALL you need to know.

[@sameerhassan2912]

@@sHuRuLuNi yes I get that but not the exact steps

[@sHuRuLuNi]

​@@sameerhassan2912 But that is the point: The hadith have turned Prayer into a ridiculous fixed set of "rules", like if you raise your index finger, or move it side by side in Tashshahud - that is bad -- you have to "wiggle" the finger! And then EVERYBODY wiggles the finger and make this into a MUST. But it is not a must, it is OOMPLETELY IRRELEVANT. God explicitly says that he has not made the religion DIFFICULT for us --- but when you then realy on hadith it becomes sooo dofficult, so ridiculous with so many details and prescriptions that it actually TURNS PEOPLE AWAY from religion! Imagine in Ramadan praying Terawih -- I go to pray and then we pray Isha+Terawih+Witr --- that is 33 (!!!) rakaah --- and we pray all that in like 20 minutes!! Imagine how stupid and ridiculous this becomes! THe imam is SPEEDRACING the recitation, it all becomes incoherent mumbo-jumbo --- people get tired and cannot wait for the prayer to finally be over. See how this makes the religion unattractive, difficult --- the complete opposite of what God said in His Book. The point of Prayer is not "1000 rules" but the point is PIETY and your REMEMBRANCE of God. This is exactly why God DID NOT mentione every intricate detail - because those details are NOT THE POINT of prayer. He simply told to praise and remember God by standing in prayer, reciting His Verses, to bow and prostrate in HUMBLENESS to Him while praising Him. That is the whole idea of the prayer - to bring you closer to God.

[@tounsi_m7ashesh]

​@@sameerhassan2912"the quran is missing because it doesn't have the steps in the ahadiths" isn't a very compelling argument if God didn't specify the exact steps that means it's safe to assume that those steps are irrelevant for example if i tell you to go from france to germany that is a complete statement how you get there is up to you

[@tounsi_m7ashesh]

​@@sHuRuLuNithat is a very good point we do view everything through a halal haram lens but that when taken too far would make the religion rudementary for example if say "is choosing strawberry over a grape halal" you'd say I'm a moron and rightfully so

[@abedonly]

Let's start, is there a Hadith of prophet Mohammad pbuh clearly saying not to write his words? Are there sahih Hadith that contracted the Quran? Does Allah preserve the Hadith as Allah preserves the Quran? If a human did not write Hadith how would we have got it? Can Allah actually rely on humans to write Hadith to give the world his religion

[@rodzitazainal19]

Interesting to note that Chat GPT is looking at religion at realistic way, ie. religion must make sense.

[@chamstrabelsi5540]

brother i m a student in hadith , chatgpt have some responces are not true

[@Shawon-l6r]

Hadith is Elaborations, explanations, qualifications of the Prophet Muhammad SAW, Q4:59"O believers! obey Allah and obey the Messenger"Q4:80 Whoever obeys the Messenger has truly obeyed Allah. Quran 4:59 "Should you disagree on anything, refer it to Allah and His Messenger". @Shawon: The Qur’an is the word of Allah’’ and the Hadith is the word of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him )❤️Following hadith is sunnah for us (we are one Ummah)❤️

[@madmax5756]

Quraan is only came down for humanity, hadith is a people's saying which could be wrong. Quran us enough for hidayaa

[@modernphilosophersafrica8088]

Apparently, two distinctive set of teachings entities must be established in the scholars and muslims, for example:: the prophetic teachings and words that explain the Qur'an must be one set of teachings or text; secondly, the prophetic teachings and words that explain the way the prayers and life must be. Actually, in that way, all the disputes will be verified by the divine inspirations from Allah. (End of quotation).