Cheap VS Pro - Car Trolley Jacks - At The Wheel

[@oo0Spyder0oo]

At 3:47 the reason the jack is tilting is because it wasn't able to slide as the lift went up, these jacks have good stability only if they can keep centered at the jack point, your crumbly driveway blocked those wheels from moving forward. Otherwise, while smaller, it could have done the job quite satisfactorily.

[@protoman247]

also he shouldn't be putting his fingers under there 😨😨😨

[@ChillToMusic87]

​@@protoman247 He's an amateur.

[@yueru33]

Agreed. If I don't see the wheels moving forward I release it and start again. It helps to point the rear castors forward so they don't fight the jack's intention of moving forward. However I disagree with you there because the expensive jacks tend to have much bigger wheels that tend to work better on rough surfaces, whereas the smaller wheels of the cheap jacks tend to dig in to the surface. Thos big front wheels on expensive jacks are worth the premium alone.

[@MMR20]

2 years later and the car lifting kit with the trolley jacks and wheel chocks he mentioned costing around £70 is £110 now.

[@skinnyniggawidfatbelly7212]

Currently on sale for £59 on halford

[@Halfy1990]

If I'm honest I own the Halfords jack and still use it 6 years later (providing you service it) yes it's small and it's a slog to pump but aslong as you're using jack stands for any major work these jacks can be used for anything within it's weight limit. I even used it to drop an engine to change the clutch so there is seriously nothing wrong. The draper is obviously significantly better.

[@pauljeffers6835]

Today I bought the Halfords 2 tonne low profile trolley jack, used it tonight to change the pads on my car and I must admit I was quite happy with it. It seemed a lot sturdier than the wee one you used. Thought it was a bargain at £55, I just couldn't justify buying anything more expensive as I wouldn't use it often enough

[@jonathanwebb8307]

The small one is good enough and will do almost any job provided it will fit under your car. The small one is also handy if you don't have much storage space. The larger one is much nicer to use. I have the best of both worlds, I paid for the cheaper one but if I have a big job I pinch my brothers larger one ! NB , I never jack up under sills, Always under a heavy duty suspension part or an outrigger designated as a jacking point. On some cars such as the Toyota IQ the sill seam will bend which in turn moves the wing out of place. I found this out when I let a "professional" fit new tyres.

[@cameronwetzel6227]

Well informed and presented video. As a tech nerd and "budding" car guru I'm excited to see more from this channel and other channel!

[@AtTheWheel]

Thank you! I've got lots more to come, both tech and cars!

[@TekkenBones]

Having used that exact 2 tonne halfords jack for some 14 years+ I will say that it is proven to be very good quality. The difference in price between the two jacks in this video is substantial and you really need to be working on vehicles a lot to justify purchasing the bigger one in my opinion (or if your vehicle is 1500kg+). With the rise in popularity of all these Crossovers and SUVs however, that halfords jack wont cut it (that has a lift height of 38cm). If you have something like a KIA sportage you will need a jack that lifts much higher.

[@BlueStreak706]

Good review! Very to the point and not confused rambling. You’ll go far with the channel if you keep putting out contents.

[@Kellett30005]

I already know this is going to be my channel subscription of the year! I highly rate your TechteamGB content, so will no doubt love this channel just as much! Can't believe I accidentally stumbled across it!

[@elliot438bcfcVTEC]

I've got the same Halfords which must be about 30 years old and is still fine after years of abuse, it's done engine changes, clutch jobs etc. Yes it's a bit wobbly but it doesn't owe me a penny. However I have had more recent Halfords jack's which haven't lasted at all. They do currently have a low profile version which I'm happy with the quality so I'm going to pick me one up, currently only £41.99

[@fqlynx]

I'd disagree that for the occasional user the Halfords or equivalent cheap jack is a good choice. I've been using the Halfords Jack's for decades and originally this was because the more advanced jacks were really pricey. But the cheap jacks tire you out more, creak, and are not as stable as the more advanced ones. That additional time and effort takes a toll on the more extensive jobs, especially where you may need to lower and raise the car multiple times. The narrow wheels on the cheaper jacks will also indent softer surfaces like tarmac. The aluminium heavy duty ones with the large roller front wheel, rubber protector and some with a locking mechanism, will put less pressure on your back, save you time and will help you get the job done a lot more comfortably.

[@Tyro207]

Great video 👍. In terms of storage can you remove handles from the pro jacks?

[@ryleymclean313]

Yes, most brands have detachable handles. Sometimes they are held in place by the universal joint at the end of the rod or if it uses another mechanism it’s secured using 2 bolts

[@luckyshotjpg]

The 2 Tonne Halfords one is disconcerting in use. I've used it for a number of years and am constantly worried when jacking a car up that something is gonna fail on it due to the creaks and groans it makes, even on a 1.5 tonne car. Recently got the 3 tonne which isn't that much more but seems a whole lot more stable to use.

[@noginnog]

Enjoyed the informative video, thanks.

[@ysfdesign]

I think its a bit unfair calling the little orange jack "the Halfords one" since Halfords also have jacks very similar to the Draper in this video. Minor comment but enjoyed the video nonetheless.

[@one-off3264]

I wish I hadn't bothered buying a cheap Jack, exactly the same issue with the back wheels lifting up of the floor, didn't feel very stable was quite unnerving. Even for the most basic tasks just invest in a proper one it will last so much longer, will pay for itself after one or two services, false economy getting a junk one...

[@yeager6882]

Did you say, "change your breaks once a year"?!?!

[@iserved8840]

Skip the cheaper ones, it only takes one time for things to go WRONG!🤔

[@hakimghelab5922]

AMAIZNG VIDEO !

[@jr5389]

Splash OOOT 👍🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿😎

[@somebloke5565]

Which? Neither. For £50-60 buy a proper used Hi-lift Epco or Bradbury on eBay. Measure them, and pop a new set of seals in there for £15, see it blow that Draper trash into the weeds. And do this for another 40-50 years. A Bradbury 586 if you can get one. The Halfrauds item is only good - if cheap is all you'll ever need. Epco or Bradbury is for life. What do these young kids know eh?

[@coolissimo69]

the halfords not good for the rear or the car.

[@NoMoreCandies]

Hahah the automatic translator is ridiculously wrong.God

[@MrLibbyloulou]

Buy a decent jack plus axle stands, if not, when your lay in your hospital bed, you will have plenty of time to refl ect.....you now have no money coming in.....your kids are distressed, your boss needs you back in.....will you ever be back to normal....? unlikely..........................never mind, at least you saved 200 quid....YOU ARE GETTING UNDER A 1 TONNE PLUS LUMP OF METAL...make sure your safe for your family, don't be selfish.....

[@cubey]

What a stupid video. "let's compare a dirt cheap tool of one style to a very expensive tool of another style and see which is better" 🙄

[@ryleymclean313]

I’m my opinion the video makes it’s points. Multiple times the author states you should really use the more professional jack in a more professional circumstance like if you are a career mechanic. The video makes a good comparison since the main thing it’s really comparing is bang for your buck.