China attacks Filipino ship with Telegraph reporter on board

Nicola Smith, The Telegraph’s Asia Correspondent, was onboard a Philippine coast guard ship accompanying fishermen near the disputed Scarborough Shoal in the South China Sea on Tuesday when her ship was attacked by the Chinese coast guard.
#china #philippines #dispute
Read more here: www.telegraph.co.uk/world-new...
Subscribe to The Telegraph with our special offer: just £1 for 3 months. Start your free trial now:
www.telegraph.co.uk/customer/...
Get the latest headlines: www.telegraph.co.uk/
Telegraph.co.uk and / telegraphtv are websites of The Telegraph, the UK's best-selling quality daily newspaper providing news and analysis on UK and world events, business, sport, lifestyle and culture.

[@hanice88]

Why reporters are not in the American universities? Is it because the US police uses really gun instead of water cannon?

[@user-sm2xn5zu8c]

犹太人惹不起

[@blexie5042]

Freedom speech except jewels.

[@mikeyL-os5cf]

hahaha

[@mikhailchanovich]

Because they want to show what people here want to see 😎

[@user-gm9ni9df9e]

這些記者真是嘴臭，滿口髒話😜😜😜😜😜😜😜😜😜😜😜😜😜😜

[@goyasolidar]

China has some nerve accusing the Philippines of provocation when they're the ones instigating these encounters.

[@ck-bs2ms]

Philippines has some nerve accusing China of provocation when they are the one doing the provocation

[@rafaelwabinga5917]

​@@ck-bs2ms brainless

[@skjor1989]

@@ck-bs2ms bot

[@kaagapay_nyo]

​@@ck-bs2ms China only a squatter in Philippine waters. Unclos Rulling is legally binding in international laws.

[@goyasolidar]

@@ck-bs2ms That's not how reality works.

[@kenchan8099]

Jesus, it just happens that loads of reporters on that boat. What a coincidence.

[@EDon933]

Its not a coincidence, cause every PCG and BFAR are getting harrased by the CCG. Whether with media or not in it 🙂 It just shows how CCG do not restraint in their actions 🙂 whether with civilians or not

[@user-qi4uh6if5o]

JESUS is Lord. Please refrain from using His name in vain.

[@terry1708]

​@@user-qi4uh6if5osome people believe he is God, not all the human.

[@hylimm]

It’s just like a Thai water festival! lol

[@abaez7484]

Loads? Where? I only see one

[@patsokssokari5974]

What's the reporter doing there exactly? Did she go all the way out to sea just for a bath?

[@foreverhere824]

she was dry and eagered for some water

[@stevencher9968]

lt's called optics for narrative to build on

[@lawi_ilwa]

To document/ gather evidence for the world to see. Duh

[@asocenagaming5761]

where's your brain exactly? what does a reporter do? u dumb

[@benibky6281]

yes.. it's true that they came to bathe China bathed the people on the Philippine ship very well, and journalists also reported China's provocations, and defended the Philippines. reporters are paid handsomely by their employers..😂

[@renesrparco8479]

The thieves of the sea and land grabbers justifying their presence in a place that doesn't belong to them

[@craigcman6738]

Bullcrap. Chinese never owned this land and they are invading other's territories.

[@hastingz9948]

just since when Philippines owned that place?

[@monum2398]

Isreal -do u say land grabber 😂😂😂😂😂

[@glm8245]

​@@hastingz9948it's near in Palawan and miles far away in mainland China look at it in the map

[@jorgepilapil3407]

@@hastingz9948 Ask The Hague.

[@dep4025]

WoW..Free ship cleaning service by China to Philippines 😨

[@handyman77-iw9vr]

ban tiktok first..then all goods coming from china..

[@albertm.santos6403]

True and agree and plus free bully unlimited and for life time bully for life. Nasaan na yun laban pilipinas? Nasaan na yun philippine navy at AFP? tatlong ahensya ng gobyerno useless po! sayang ang aming mga taxes at pina pa sweldo sa mga ito pcg, afp ay philippine navy. Lahat sila tulog sa pancitan wlang ka moral moral ang mga ito at nilagay sa kahihiyaan ang bansa at mga pilipino na nag papa sahod sa kanila at nag papalamon sa pamilya nila. 2024 na parang 1950's parin bangka parin meron tayo nasaan na ang mga bilyunes na pera ng taong bayan peso at $ nasaan na sinced atlist 100 years?

[@user-gj6hn1eo4f]

yes...always.

[@Hav180]

Water canon is hitting the boat's radar system so destroying property.

[@jianyang6281]

@@Hav180 make a stronger radar.

[@kimannepark4709]

This is truly despicable. How dare a squatter fire water cannons on the homeowner?

[@robertsteele474]

The garden needed watering.

[@Kyo_Tears]

知道中业岛是谁的吗？

[@czuskitcariaso2876]

China can't feed their own people so they steal resources from other countries.

[@jonzkiecopy4267]

@@Kyo_Tears 中国历史，中国制造

[@user-du4cx4or8s]

why not

[@dengmao6330]

I have to ask, Where is American, the Dad of Philippine?

[@upgrademix6791]

Pag tapos na election us gagalaw na yan

[@EDon933]

It should be "Where are the Americans" dumb head 😂 not is

[@Monkey88888]

Mid east to protect their father and arrest their students at home😂

[@larspatriksson4744]

In the same place that the dad of Ukraine, Iraq, Afghanistan, Vietnam, and South Korea went.

[@IanBriones408]

Russia ask the same question look how they mess up in ukraine..

[@justnickos]

Hello World, That is China!

[@SpyFromMarsZeus]

Firing water cannon? That is surprising civilized considering how Israel treat Palestinians.

[@larsv6144]

@@SpyFromMarsZeusstop deflecting bot.

[@rodyrickolarte9600]

China is idiot

[@shirokusanagi5291]

@@SpyFromMarsZeus another bot

[@hl1234561]

welcome to china sea area

[@markv1974]

This is inside the Philippine eez.

[@rodyrickolarte9600]

Yes

[@60secondsDiary]

​@@One_For_AllWheres your title of sea

[@peng6447]

This is the sea area of China.

[@erwin734]

Prove it?

[@hokroeger]

That vessel has only a single purpose for this trip: invade China's sovereignty, and provoke the Chinese. That's why they took reporters and photographers on board, and nothing else.

[@CarlosNieves-ok7sp]

dapat sabihan ang ibang reporters ng buong mundo huwag sabihin ang "south china sea" kong ito naman ay nasa loob ng "West Phils Sea....."

[@catalinoruben2665]

Tama ka. Wps

[@marcusaurelius2061]

The PH is not claiming anything. In 2016, the Permanent Court of Arbitration ruled in favor of the Philippines against China's claims in the South China Sea. The tribunal found that China's nine-dash line claim had no legal basis under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS).

[@chensong7719]

What kind of pheasant court is illegal and has no jurisdiction

[@Dept246]

2016 Hague ruled in favor of the Philippines 200 miles EEZ which is fishing and oil rights but did not rule who owns the islands in the South China Seas.

[@kuruchi91]

​@@chensong7719paid troll

[@vladoarboleda7831]

@@chensong7719 i though chinese people are smart, and yet they cant even comprehend simple geography

[@Nxde-cl3gg]

The chinese government only got interested in WPS when they discovered that there's a good source of oil in that area. This was during former president abnoy aquino's term.

[@StevenKeery]

Boycott Chinese goods and services. Appeasement toward aggressors does not work.

[@anakborneo8276]

Hahaha why don't u set a example first...go live in a cave 😂

[@akbarmohammed4eva]

says the idiot on his Made in China phone.

[@subtitelingyou]

EUROPEAN COLONIZERS.

[@hkfoo3333]

Good make sure the check your panties. Make sure they are not made in China.

[@dasvarder1842]

How about throwing your phone away now idiot

[@wrhytz]

That is an assault!

[@davosam1968]

[@HealTheWorld898MV]

Yeap been so long they doing it again and again

[@ck-bs2ms]

Us is always assaulting

[@dragondescendant1]

Rightfully so. Shouldn't trespass into Chinese waters.

[@hl1234561]

是的，就是攻击，又如何？美国呢

[@gerryboymojud7227]

How did China can say that that is their territory when there is no island to say so. They made artificial islands which destroyed the corals. It is ocean and if its ocean the EEZ of each country should be respected. In this case the Philippines island shore which is inside the 200 nautical miles from the sea belongs to them and also China have its EEZ but what the did is they extended it to x10 claiming other boundaries and clearly a definition of being greedy!

[@dennisroque8584]

Yo men it's called Greediness!?

[@luburan1973]

this is no different from piracy and should be treated as piracy.

[@gyokyo]

Pooh crazy mad 🤡🤡🤡

[@johnsonpillay7099]

Pooh mad dog.

[@Iamtwohundredtwentyfive]

Poor pooh

[@rollyty.3822]

Takke😂

[@RepublicofKorea00]

기분이 나아질 수만 있다면 맹세하고 세게 꾸짖으십시오. 하지만 아무것도 바꿀 수는 없습니다. 몇 마디 맹세하고 화를 내지 마십시오.😅😅

[@pennycandyys]

‘Crazy’ being the operative word.

[@TanjiroKamado_905]

That ship is not a civilian coast guard seeing the 125mm cannon at the bow, that is a gray ship.

[@762459]

If i'm not mistaken majority of ChingChong Coast Guard Ships are hand me downs from the ChingChong Navy.

[@Featherface01]

Even Chinese fishing vessels are military.

[@paulsteaven]

That is a former Type 056 corvette of PLA-Navy transferred to the China Coast Guard.

[@user-ce8my5xb3v]

well according to their military structure, their coast guard is under their PLA NAVY so technically this is a grey ship painted white :)

[@maxmustermann19203]

coast guard ships has cannons

[@loneranger114]

China is too Benign and Kind to the Philippines

[@veronicao.7661]

How so? 🤔

[@heartdeph4444]

China is the criminal Pirate of the sea

[@reydalupan8460]

because they want to grab everything from the Philippines

[@yuezou7391]

​@@veronicao.7661just assume what happen if USA in CHINESE position?

[@wrhytz]

@@yuezou7391 👈pink

[@ragnarokws2670]

China too mercy, if was U.S , PH ship already sink due to real canon hole

[@Nxde-cl3gg]

If they do that, U.S. will be a threat to other countries. Attacking a ship just to steal others property is illegal. Other countries will unite to fight U.S. and same goes to china. This shows claiming a property without legal right is a crime, if U.S. or china do that to Philippines, this is a threat that they can also do this to other countries.

[@teslab8903]

Speak proper English what your saying doesn’t make sense ‼️

[@ragnarokws2670]

@@teslab8903 Sorry English not my first language and i dont gave a fck about it 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@Robert-wj1so]

Yeah, is west ,the ph ship have already sink

[@ranwu1168]

@@Nxde-cl3gg以色列怎么敢那样做？

[@AmazingDiaries]

*The world should be aware to this*

[@snakeph]

China, the devil in disguise. The propagator of war in the middle east and ukraine.

[@felixthecat2786]

That would complicate their denial

[@kimeli]

The world is aware, they just dont care

[@haniahannslew4108]

Yup aware of Phil illegally entering China’s territory

[@SpacenaZ]

The world is aware, but they keep eating bullcrap propaganda from china

[@baader999]

Nobody asks why the journalist are on board? Maybe tourist or maybe to document the provocation?

[@haiducburrowes6812]

invited by Philippine government to report whats happening

[@deathbyathousandcats]

Journalists are now allowed to be on board to document china's bullying

[@zenden9]

They provoke other and expect no reaction. These thieves orchestrate all these dirty tricks.

[@Meow-il2ux]

@@zenden9yeah okay chinese, the world knows china’s atrocities

[@wionporky9937]

The Philippines are playing victims with reporting crew on board and kept on provoking the Chinese. I will not be "surprised" if one of the reporter or crew is wash off to the sea or being thrown out. The Philippines in their "Illusions" thought that US will trigger their treaty and get involve. 😂😅😂😅

[@gilvega4060]

Very disturbing. Patience is temporary like any other things on earth. The truth and righteousness prevail.

[@user-ki4ps1eo3o]

中业岛还台湾

[@ddngai]

Before the 1970s, the Philippines had no territorial claims to the area on maps published by the Philippines

[@krazykatz-hl8bf]

Yes, we do. It's called the Velarde map and it was published in 1734 vs the 9-dash line which was published in 1947.

[@gtaraya]

Freedom is not free... IT'S A BUSINESS!

[@koblongata]

Let us all build artificial islands like China does!

[@gtaraya]

@@koblongata what’s stopping us?

[@sanimgurung87]

how convenient of sky and telegraph journos to be there at the same time :)

[@DW-op7ly]

Timeline of the South China Sea dispute * It has been claimed by the People's Republic of China on the argument that since 200 BCE Chinese fishermen have used the Spratly islands * Naval forces of the Liu Song dynasty (420-479 CE) patrolled the Paracel and Spratly islands.[5] In the Tang dynasty (618-907 CE), the islands were placed under the administration and authority of the Qiongzhou Prefecture (now Hainan Province).[5] The Chinese administration of the South China Sea continued into the Song dynasty (960-1279 CE).[5] * Archaeologists have found Chinese made potteries porcelains and other historical relics from the Southern dynasties (420-589 CE), the Sui dynasty (581-619 CE), the Tang dynasty, the Song dynasty, the Yuan dynasty (1271-1368 CE), the Ming dynasty (1368-1644 CE) and later eras up to modern times on the South China Sea islands.[5] 1876 - China makes its earliest documented claim to the Paracel Islands[citation needed] 1883 - When the Spratlys and Paracels were surveyed by Germany in 1883, China issued protests. 1887 - In the 19th century, Europeans found that Chinese fishermen from Hainan annually visited the Spratly islands for part of the year, while in 1877 it was the British who launched the first modern legal claims to the Spratlys 1902 - China sends naval forces on inspection tours of the Paracel Islands to preempt French claims.[28] Scholar François-Xavier Bonnet argued that per Chinese records, these expeditions never occurred and were backdated during the 1970s.[29][30] 1907 - China sends another naval force, this time to plan for resource exploitation.[28] 1911 - The newly formed Republic of China, successor state to the Qing dynasty, moves administration of the Paracel Islands to Hainan,[28] which would not become a separate Chinese province until 1988. 1946 - The R.O.C. established garrisons on both Woody (now Yongxing / 永兴) Island in the Paracels and Taiping Island in the Spratlys. France protested. The French tried but failed to dislodge Chinese nationalist troops from Yongxing Island/Woody Island (the only habitable island in the Paracels), but were able to establish a small camp on Pattle (now Shanhu / 珊瑚) Island in the southwestern part of the archipelago.[37][38][39] The Republic of China drew up The Southern China Sea Islands Location Map, marking the national boundaries in the sea with 11 lines, two of which were later removed, showing the U-shaped claim on the entire South China Sea, and showing the Spratly and Paracels in Chinese territory, in 1947.[28] The Americans reminded the Philippines at its independence in 1946 that the Spratlys was not Philippine territory, both to not anger Chiang Kai-shek in China and because the Spratlys were not part of the Philippines per the 1898 treaty Spain signed with America.[38] 1950 - After the Chinese nationalists were driven from Hainan by the People's Liberation Army (PLA), they withdrew their garrisons in both the Paracels and Spratlys to Taiwan. 1969 - A UN sponsored research team discovers oil under the sea floor of the island group. 1970 - China occupies Amphitrite Group of the Paracel Islands * In 1596, the Spanish Colonial Government declared that each island in the Kalayaan Islands, now known as the Spratly Islands, had Barangay or Barrio status. 1971 - Philippines announces claim to islands adjacent to its territory in the Spratlys, which they named Kalayaan, which was formally incorporated into Palawan Province in 1972. The Philippines President Marcos announced the claims after Taiwanese troops attacked and shot at a Philippine fishing boat on Itu Aba.[ Wikipedia

[@RaffaelPallus]

The freedom is depend on Israel....look at US, all freedom is depends on Israel government

[@jchernz9038]

Di sana tayo mabubully kung di naging kurap ang gobyerno.

[@simplyjesse3212]

Ganyan talaga grabi si Digong walang kamalay ang mga Pilipino na pinapasok nya ang china sa Pilipinas at gawin itong probinsya ng china,sa 13 trillion na inutang na sa china,may regalo pa ang china sa kanya, eskwelahan na nkapangalan sa Ina nya,tapos Ang nagmamay Ari daw ay yong friend nya na chines,dto naman sa Pilipinas yong mga Pera na nakulimbat nya as Gobyerno inilagay na sa religion ni Quiboloy para di mahalata pero corparasyon pala nila yan.😢😢😢

[@skjor1989]

bobo ampota

[@eddieboeing777]

Tanga! Pinagsasabi mo. Ano'ng koneksyon ng corruption sa bullying.

[@graezemxavier6228]

👌✅

[@melvinpili5534]

@@graezemxavier6228 pls. elaborate..

[@Wbliss]

These reporters just happened to be tourists or sport fishing in the SCS & incidently discovered that China was being very aggressive towards the poor & innocent Filipinos out there , fishing peacefully but being victimized for no reason by the big bad Chinese naval forces. Omg, this scenario was so bad & the rest of the world should condemn China for violating the international law of the seas in SCS, according to those western reporters who so happened to be witnessing such aggressive behaviour of the Chinese forces out there. Oh boy, what a field day for those gringo reporters, who risked their lives , defending those poor innocent Filipinos at sea.! Btw, could someone pass on some Kleenex tissues for me, pls.? I’m so choked up with such pain.!

[@tomnguyen3372]

Where are US news outlets? Only the telegraph, sky news

[@birdsnature6421]

Why don’t they report Palestine

[@ronnoble2440]

It’s time to stand up to the bullying Chinese.

[@gtaraya]

just stand up... like slim shady?

[@snakeph]

@@gtarayagrow up dude

[@user-vo3fv2er9q]

Stand up or always be bullied.

[@hl1234561]

所以你要如何？叫美国人？美国在哪？

[@ck-bs2ms]

And what? Be American slaves?

[@giancarlocajitayamato334]

The result of gentleman agreement

[@user-gp5id6ix9u]

Matagal na sila jan wla pang duterte time😂

[@bucanic560]

​​@@user-gp5id6ix9u isa ka pang duwag na duterte minions

[@rj-lc8pe]

​@@user-gp5id6ix9uHuwag mo ng ipagtangol ang gagong iniidilo. 👹

[@giancarlocajitayamato334]

@@user-gp5id6ix9u mas pinadami nya. Kasi wala syang pakialam sa national interest natin

[@annabelleabella4311]

Grabe nanlumo ako sa binoto kong Presidente halos pinamigay n ang WPS sa China...the weakest PRESIDENT I VOTED..FPRRD.

[@bajdgh]

Thanks for the update!

[@goodluck2-oe4qz]

Despite the economic recession, I no longer depend on Government Grants since I acquire $86,400 weekly profits

[@roxanneslp]

trading under proper guidance remains the best way to succeed in today's crypto market

[@yft2623]

Imagine your own coast guard ship gets attacked and your response is just to cry about it

[@njoy177]

Communists never understand weaker power

[@Grionlam]

But freedom always there for the oil😂

[@nemanjaljubicic5282]

​@@Grionlamgreat comment

[@njoy177]

@@Grionlam nine dash line itself is bogus and forgery, China was never a naval going in ancient days. All of a sudden they devised evidence of past claims. Truth is that ancient China was confined within limits of great Wall, and their claim to Philippines sea is illegal.

[@user_uif_ghg_wer_das]

weak and power don't belong together.

[@neililagan5289]

That is the Godless Pooh.

[@danielbandiola1411]

This is an act of War.

[@regorflora7915]

Come on it's just water.

[@richellek.4152]

True, chinese make initiative to start a war. Once phil fight back its possible. We dont know what are the other weapon chinese brought inside their ship, aside from water canon

[@jianyang6281]

@@regorflora7915 we might add some pee into the water, but still not act of war.

[@huggybear441]

Except, it was declared by the Philippines China has every right to defend its territory.

[@kimnoaz]

@@huggybear441 Nope. China is far away from its territory

[@me8874]

Be safe 🙏🕊😢

[@helloooafrica9460]

The PH is not claiming anything. In 2016, the Permanent Court of Arbitration ruled in favor of the Philippines against China's claims in the South China Sea. The tribunal found that China's nine-dash line claim had no legal basis under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS). - ctto

[@donbuteh9903]

Those ships are Frigate ships turned CCG.. 😅😅

[@Chickenworm9394]

Yep, China is just that powerful

[@user-qm8sc1jr9u]

@@Chickenworm9394 hahahah your pathetic boast cant even get into blue water hahahaha loser

[@wrhytz]

@@Chickenworm9394 👈 pink

[@deruiz1478]

@@Chickenworm9394 powerful but stupid, operating a Frigate just to fire a water cannon lol, imagine all the money they are burning

[@peaceloverespect]

@@Chickenworm9394 hahahahaha

[@user-jl9fl1sp7s]

Ito ang peace talk na gusto ng karamihan..nganga lang kayo..laban tayo ng patas

[@jayvee8502]

Sa digmaan walang patas na labana n.

[@WANDERINGMAN82]

Asa pa mga Pinoy mananalo sa gyera. MagML na lang kayo 😂

[@jchernz9038]

Baka naman yan ang bunga ng corruption sa Bansa.

[@rodcabas]

Iyan ang bunga ng ambisyon ng china na manakop ng mga bansa kaya saan pat hahantong ito sa gyera... kaya chill lang mga bombers ng US nalalapit na ang gulo.

[@jm97117]

Lumalaban po ang PCG diplomatically, hindi ba obvious na inieexpose na yung CCG sa international media at pumapanig na saatin ang international community. Walang ganyan sa panahon ni duterte na "tahimik" lang.

[@journeymanX]

maybe the reporter lady can ask the filipino coast guards why they don't retaliate? the rest of the nation would like to know

[@lineanoves6650]

There are 3 types of Filipinos in this issue: The ones that know That ones that don't The ones who prefer stupidity

[@DelbertTheFifth]

Because it's dumb, And would be met with reactions from the international community that would likely result in the Philippines losing support of other countries. Aside from that, The Philippines pledged to follow international law, Which makes them respected by other countries. The Philippines also has a Defense pact or mutual defense treaty with the United States, If the Philippines attacks china first using ammunitions, The usa won't be able to help through the treaty.

[@caryandrae9952]

cause then they can sell the narrative of "china being a bullly" and let america justify militarising philippines more to "protect" philippines.

[@kevinrich5222]

@@DelbertTheFifth Fool, no matter what happens, the US won't help the Philippines. The other side is China, not Syria. Will the United States fight a nuclear war with China over the lives of a few Filipinos? NO

[@mboxphil9906]

First of all this move of Ph is within concensus command of US and Ph government, PCG is commanded not to fight back, it is move to further gain support from international community and expose china modern day imperialism and terrorism, many countries like bhutan, nepal myanmar have quietly conceded their territory to china while it seems vietnam and malaysia have also kowtowed to china and put aside their claim in promise of loan aka debt trap, its seems only PH has the integrity and bravery fight back and to uphold what is right but doing it in calculative way with guidance of other superpowers like US, Japan and France

[@ancientweeb5984]

Probably the first shower a telegraph reporter has had in years, that's kind of china to give them

[@kenchan8099]

And they have sky news reporters on that boat, too. What a boat.

[@maxmustermann19203]

the sun reporters and writers having no showers since the pandemic would greatly benefit from that free shower

[@user-ce5vd2qv7y]

What I learned from this video 1. China is being generous for not firing live ammo 2. Philippine ship are made out of duct tapes 3. Karen's hair got wet and she is very upset

[@KSmifune]

They aren't generous. Firing an ammo would trigger US-Japan-Philippines trilateral agreement. China is using gray zone tactic to not bring the US and Japan into the conflict. Philippines has more allies while China is pretty much alone also they made a lot of enemies. They can only rely on NK who's military is complete too reliant on nukes for defense and has no much for Japan or SK military. Also China can't even touch Guam or retaliate against the US as it will invoke the NATO's article 5.

[@SpiritShinobi]

Daily reminder It's called the West Philippine Sea 🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭

[@anakborneo8276]

No such sea 😂

[@elfilibusterible]

@@anakborneo8276 China is fake from head to toe. From cellphones, to houses, to food, to seas, to cultures. It's a fake country with fake people with fake attitudes and fake personalities.

[@nemanjaljubicic5282]

But it belongs to China clearly

[@hastingz9948]

nope! couldn't find it anywhere in the map !

[@xuyangbao9837]

When it’s called South China Sea, the tiny country Philippine didn’t even exist.

[@renatotumala5842]

Grabe itong mga instik wala naman tayong magawa sobrang pang aapi sa atin

[@markieinacay5831]

Meron, dami Chinese national dito sa Pinas, pwde umpisahan don🙄

[@vivi-kh9lp]

​@@markieinacay5831你猜猜有多少菲律宾人在中国？😂

[@jeffreytrinidad1629]

iyakin talaga mga chinese kapag natalo sila 😂

[@vivi-kh9lp]

​@@jeffreytrinidad1629在哭的是菲律宾人😂老实种香蕉🍌🐵

[@vivi-kh9lp]

​@@jeffreytrinidad1629菲律宾一直在哭😂

[@jaysondgreat8171]

this is an issue of geo politics, America militarizing the the region.

[@debatetv5794]

don't be naive, China is claiming the whole SCS based on their BS historical fishing grounds. claiming the whole SCS is enough to start a global conflict even without america.

[@danger26102]

Chinese coast guard: Philippine Coast Guard didn’t inform us Telegraph news reporter was on board

[@augustorivera6055]

A foreign correspondence will attest to that behavior. The eyewitness of Chinese aggression.

[@robertsteele474]

The foreign corespondent is all wet.

[@user-ss9nk1qu4q]

and？

[@AmazingDiaries]

*BOYCOT CHINA*

[@eegt628]

thats not gonna work idiot

[@dragondescendant1]

Nuke Manila.

[@kentdwigth410]

Nuke shanghai​@@dragondescendant1

[@rickycastorlabrada2986]

Sadly we cant

[@zerdanlousanvictores3517]

@@kentdwigth410 wag shanghai favorit ko yan lalo nat may ketchup.. NUKE BEIJING NAN DUN C POOOH!!!

[@forkborking7]

wow amazing they had all of those reporters on board and they happened to encounter the chinese coast guard. must just be a coincidence!

[@scarlettlee5009]

Deliberately taking international media reporters to touch porcelain😂

[@richardmacanas]

Where is the ironclad?

[@Jportin]

busy in their TIKTOK.

[@lumri2002]

It could be just an idea to boost politics.

[@alvinseah5423]

It's in the Bidet.

[@JohnChen9920]

That rusted wreck and eye soaring Sierra Madre is on the shore

[@pedrapgwilym1341]

Looks like the Philippine Navy took a bunch of lady reporters on board to see the Chinese firing water at them. Sky News had a woman on board too and Deutsche Welle in English. Still worth emphasising China's agression in the South China Sea - which despite its name is not a Chinese lake and should never be allowed to become so.

[@dinopiccio4144]

They were on board a Philippine Coast Guard vessel and not the Philippine Navy. China is definitely bullying the Philippines by firing those water cannons to unilaterally claim the whole West Philippine Sea. Since when can a country claim an entire sea as their own? Mind boggling! China's behavior is beyond reason. If China can't win legally their claims in court they resort to force.

[@dennisng7961]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/hmKtgYKtd8qKeaM

[@xzwang619]

Every time there is a Chinese coast Guard operation, Western journalists happen to be on a Philippine boat

[@aquasport3078]

Where ever the US got involved, where the conflict starts.

[@lawi_ilwa]

bullshit

[@robertsteele474]

@@lawi_ilwaStick with your war games, Incel.

[@phuchong5267]

But the US will not the one who start it first

[@robertsteele474]

@@phuchong5267 It is a US habit to start wars. Why would they stop now?

[@omzoilerau4404]

This is within Philippines EEZ and China claims it as their territorial waters. Just imagine the things that they can do if they fully control the area.

[@anakborneo8276]

Cry harder 😂

[@ko1993]

According to 1943 Cairo Declaration and 1945 Potsdam Declaration, Japan agreed to return Taiwan, Penghu Islands and islands that occupied by Japan during World War II in South China Sea to China. In fact all Islands in South China Sea belong to China. Since 1970’s Vietnam, Phillipines illegally occupied some islands in South China Sea. They must be returned to China.

[@joshcyz]

There is always a western journalist on the filipino ship.

[@eric6769]

all Western reporters reporters happened to the on the same ship, funny?

[@Xidigong_nyo_trydor]

we're tired of fighting because we can't do it no matter how much equipment we have, it's heartbreaking we're being bullied in our territory

[@lvjinbin28]

Sino-Japanese Peace Treaty Article 2 It is recognized under Treaty of Peace with Japan signed at the city of San Francisco, Japan has renounced all right, title and claim to Taiwan and Penghu as well as Spratly Islands and Paracel Islands. Your territory?? who Japan didn't sign such treaty with Philippines?

[@leopalis5053]

Mas maganda ang batang quiapo panuidin keysa ganito

[@lineanoves6650]

Eh di doon ka.

[@eddieboeing777]

hahaha! ba't ka kc nandito. hindi naman pilitan ang panoorin ang video na 'to. wala ka rin naman magagawa kung ayaw namin sa batang quiapo.

[@lonm2m]

Mahihirap lang nanonood ng bq

[@leopalis5053]

Ah ok mahirap lang kami, bagoong lagi ulam namin Heheheerr

[@ZyrexShorts129]

tanga

[@arthurchen8162]

Where is American and Japanese?

[@argellie]

Chinese CCP minions😂

[@thegodsss-if4bp]

In 1971, Taiwan withdrew from Thitu Island to escape the typhoon and the Philippines took the opportunity to occupy the island.

[@phuchong5267]

In 1974, during the Vietnam War. The Chinese took the opportunity to attack and occupy the Paracel Islands from South Vietnam while they were losing the war. Stop hypocrite

[@iguezz3121]

Respecting international law, such as UNCLOS, and rejecting disputed claims are crucial for preventing conflicts in the South China Sea, especially as many countries are increasing their defense budgets. Diplomacy and cooperation based on these principles offer the best chance for peace and stability in the region amidst growing concerns about military buildup.

[@gabegabe1]

Imagine a 'telegraph reporter' in action with the perfect timing. This is a really great planned report. Ano bang gustong ipakita ng mga kababayan natin?

[@Chickenworm9394]

Not just the Telegraph reporter, Sky News reporter happened to be onboard too. What a coincidence

[@x-creator4460]

I was wondering why a Telegraph reporter is on board in the first place ?...

[@user-sr5zc4vv4f]

我认为他们应该准备好在那里，只是为了挑衅，否则我无法弄清楚这些记者在那里做什么，只是为了制造新闻

[@asocenagaming5761]

why not?

[@Ashley1278_memasik]

So they can witness the real story . To inform the world how greedy is China .

[@user-hb9rp4is2y]

why not? its called tranparency

[@lvjinbin28]

for propaganda

[@gerry991]

China is like a your neighbor who claims your backyard 😆

[@anakborneo8276]

Nope it belongs to china 😂

[@lanky_j7701]

​@@anakborneo8276no, never was..

[@elfilibusterible]

@@anakborneo8276 Nope, it's inside the Philippine Economic Zone. It's not even part of the South China Sea. None of it belongs to China. The Chinese vessels shouldn't even be there in the first place.

[@joelturley4847]

​@@anakborneo8276Rumbly Tumberly Chasing a Bee 🐝🍯 Winnie the Pooh 😂😂😂

[@GhostLGNDClashRoyale]

It's Chinas backyard Amerikanski have nothing to do there

[@manofwar1305]

Great coverage

[@rickace132]

What's the Philippines and US going to do about it?

[@avetsuper6272]

hahahah good question ..why us always has to be asked ?????

[@pimohbusiness]

China: " invoke ur mutual defense treaty. . come on its exciting" :3

[@user-hb9rp4is2y]

soon allied forces will give what china want

[@fugak-han0072]

US is such a cowardly military

[@user-gc7pd6jl8j]

@@fugak-han0072 For the United States, the Philippines is not even a chess piece. It can only be used to disgust China and can be discarded at any time when it is no longer needed.

[@edgarmorales4138]

to our govt.what now?where is the shoulder to shoulder excercise.are we going to file for a nonsense diplonatic protest?pls we need to act accordingly.

[@MyNameIsJoyce]

The late President NoyNoy Aquino already took this to international court and the tribunal ruled in our favor in 2016, even naming it the West Philippine Sea. The traitor President Duts did not acknowledge it and he became China's puppet. The current President BBM is fighting for what's ours. Good to see an Aquino and a Marcos on the same side in this issue.

[@robertsteele474]

It is all water under the bridge.

[@forgettohaveaname2954]

A loud voice not necessarily speaks the truth, it is not who is boarding the ship which proves the ship is in the right place

[@erniequion]

To the World, please help Philippines from China's bullying tactics.

[@Kariktan214]

Tulungan din dapat natin sarili natin. Wala man lang tayo magawa.😢

[@Jimmyli0426]

Where is your American dad?😂

[@anakborneo8276]

Loool it's just a free water bath chill 😂

[@snakeph]

@@Jimmyli0426where are your devil friends?

[@shinchanfan3681]

Why South Korea didn't help Philippines..😂😂

[@MandeeeMoreee]

It show the video how weak and coward the Phil. Coastguard/Army..👎👎👎

[@user-jw9op8eq6q]

😡

[@rickybelen_fyakap]

Hindi nman nag iisip ang mga nag susupply ng mas safe na vessel gagamitin nila alam na nila how many times na, parang gusto lagi pinag mukha katatawan at kawawa

[@yugo6262]

The new definition of gentlemen......💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀

[@arnelblancaflor2787]

Oh my god.... That's how really determined those Chinese people on the west Philippine sea EEZ..... Imagine the fisherman who are in small boats.. 😮😮😮😮😮

[@user-lu4nq6hr1k]

Walang magawa ang PCG. There is no means to retaliate. Weak Coast Guard.

[@skylark2583]

Ignorant

[@lineanoves6650]

So ano solution mo?

[@jmexchannel3441]

@@lineanoves6650 water cannon din tapatan ng water cannon.

[@ChristianEraMonsanto]

War

[@joeldelgado8558]

Tirahin rin ng water cannon yan ang solusyon.

[@johnnyq4260]

LMAO, the reporter went on board looking for this to begin with.

[@Kafarmer10]

Greed...

[@davidthomas126]

telegraph has REPORTERS??? No way jose😅

[@Masterbuten333]

the heat and this report what a dangerous mix.

[@Qiushishuo]

Supply fishman with coast guard but load of foreign journalists. What a drama.

[@marie418mmbs]

So where are the US and other countries who pledged to support and help?

[@chokzfernan2635]

its an attack...it could danger human life onboard...and could destroy govt property...

[@JohnChen9920]

and it could take 10 to 15 years to get a replacement ship or none.

[@chokzfernan2635]

@@JohnChen9920 none at all

[@robertsteele474]

Perhaps the Philippines should make boats that are waterproof?

[@Pinnian]

No one can stop Philippine from turning into the second Ukraine..

[@fernandojabola7083]

The West Philippine Sea is within the 200 nautical miles exclusive economic zone of the Philippines. china has no jurisdiction in the WPS, they are the intruder and a troublemaker in the West Philippine Sea and in all over the world.

[@zedz8748]

South China Sea😊

[@easyislander]

For sure those islands are part of the Philippines.

[@user-oe9tg5hl7x]

@@easyislanderFor sure the Philippine is part of china

[@lvjinbin28]

Sino-Japanese Peace Treaty Article 2 It is recognized under Treaty of Peace with Japan signed at the city of San Francisco, Japan has renounced all right, title and claim to Taiwan and Penghu as well as Spratly Islands and Paracel Islands. Win WWIII to rewrite WWII order, not talk.

[@k-sk4ph]

二战时菲律宾是美国殖民地，80年过去了菲律宾还是美国殖民地，当狗是不是很好？

[@teofilosagarino2459]

ganito ba tayo palaging confrontation? Ano mangyari sa dulo nito, kapayapaan ba?

[@ShinewayLam]

All viewers and commenters please first understand why China expels the Philippine ship? Why are they just water cannons but not real weapons?

[@nikkalee6544]

What? The ridiculous reason on why they're inside exclusive economic zone of the Philippines? Their ridiculous reason why they're in West Philippine Sea? Not real weapon since it'll be against the law? Even what they're doing now is against the law of the sea.

[@Heilviceivar]

Attacked?? They got a bit wet....at sea!

[@mengstv.7943]

They cant harass taiwan and japan.

[@KanuniSuleyman4857]

Taiwan is their backyard, Japan is an American colony so both are incapable of direct confrontation with China otherwise Taipei and Tokyo will be flattened before they even invade 😂😂

[@soumyamukherjee4312]

Flattening a country just like that is not that easy as u think. Yes America sometimes get intimidated by China due to Joe has no spine but if the Americans start retaliating with force then china won't bark for long. Also India is with them as well the only country that china don't want to engage in a combat other than America

[@lvjinbin28]

nope, China will harass every American allies.

[@bruneilange4161]

It's time that Philippines takes action.. Protesting does not work.

[@nravis1]

Water canons are a symbol of honour given to mightier powers...!

[@chfa2001]

中國海警為泥濘不堪的菲律賓船隻免費清洗，這個畫面真是暖心

[@Waterfromthesky29]

Winnie the pooh

[@Dcream6]

bo lan tiao

[@user-dw6dr2on6o]

@@Waterfromthesky29 Better than your family of corrupt criminals

[@RichMidasPapa]

China didn't attack Philjppine vessles. They are providing free ship washing service as sincere welcome for guests visisting Chinese territroy😊.

[@cesarvivarjr8471]

😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@GneissAlucard]

Free washing service with a water that is 10x Pacquiao punch

[@Critique633]

Try to use some nerve cells and read real and legit news about UNCLOS. It was not even China’s territory in the first place. 😂

[@dreamer-vk3xt]

Imagine if it was India. They will make a no gun agreement and we would've witnessed the world's biggest water canon battles

[@Rockieoo]

Philippines: American master, I am very obedient. I am the best dog.

[@Observer82]

This is still not an attack?crazy....

[@Morunic777]

The Philippines can go whine and protest about it all day but if they don't take military action against an enemy who's deaf to all legal means then it's all for naught.

[@user-kw7ti5dt4k]

欢迎菲律宾采取军事行动，不来是我孙子

[@virtueschan]

Military action means war. That's a heavy consequence

[@AchwaqKhalid]

Well as a Starter: Stop calling it the *-South China Sea-* ❌

[@zedz8748]

it is South China Sea

[@zedz8748]

South China Sea

[@qv1548]

South China Sea. Oh I call it again.

[@lvjinbin28]

Just like Greece was the winner after the Balkan War, WWI, and WWII, so Greece can control 97% of the islands and EEZ in the Aegean Sea, but Turkey can only control 3% of the islands in the Aegean Sea, If Turkey wants to change the post-war order, win the next world war. so West and Soviet let ROC, Not American Philippines or French Vietnam to control SCS after Japan left 1946, coz Southeast Asians and colonial troops surrendered to Japs in 1942, but KMT/CCP resisted fascist until 1945, PRC inherited same claim from ROC after 1949, that's why both Beijing and Taiwan claims same islands in South China Sea today, so win WWIII to rewrite WWII order, get your trophy not by talk

[@bixiachen7080]

South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea South China Sea

[@JovinelBolivar]

Too much!!! 😡😤😠

[@tinnn_1029]

It sad to see this, god protect our country to the greediness evil enemy. Parusahan nyo sila sa iyong mga kamay.