Cinemare Sins: Everything Wrong With Forever Filly

[@nessesaryschoolthing]

Even weirder than Winona not aging is that the Cake twins go through like 5 Christmases together and are still somehow infants until the time skip.

[@Thinginator]

To be fair, the Cake twins are eventually shown without diapers, so some kind of progress is implied.

[@hannahlamagna]

@@Thinginator true

[@foxanard]

It seems that ponies age like elves...

[@zuzoscorner]

or how flurry a baby after three. well okay she act more toddler in Flurry of emotons os eh nvm

[@chelseal5550]

@@foxanardHonestly, my headcanon is that ponies can’t die of old age and only die from diseases, accidents, pretty much anything but old age. It would really explain the finale. Plus, they were like middle aged in the finale so they probably do age slower. Also, I think dragons age even slower because Spike has been a baby dragon since Twilight was a foal. And when Twilight was like I’m guessing 1,000 years old in the finale, he still looked pretty young

[@novalightfim]

Sadly the iconic Ponyville Liquor Store is going out of business since its supplier Sweet Apple Acres switched from producing cider to juice.

[@caffeinatedpossum]

I thought it was because Berry Punch broke in and stole everything? Then again she was never arrested for it...

[@jaanhavi0_0]

Lmaoo good one

[@McBean1331]

Yup.

[@gracekim1998]

@@caffeinatedpossum I forgot that happened

[@LannyArtist]

NOOO

[@CookieFonster]

i love the running gag of iconic ponyville locations that have totally always been there too much

[@LeafRazorStorm]

1:27 The "You are good" was for Sweetie Belle predicting Zipporwhill's arrival so accurately that she opened the door the second Zipporwhill was about to open it herself. The real sin is that she's wasting her psychic abilities on cheap gags when that's Pinkie Pie's shtick.

[@dashietheytpproductions2521]

A real waste of pinkie’s powers will be her dragging a pony from out of literal nowhere which means she has trans-dimensional powers

[@nessesaryschoolthing]

"Bananas are so very, very slippery!" "Maybe if you live in a cartoon world, Rarity." Clearly Littleshy hasn't seen the iconic vine where the guy tests whether a banana peel is slippery like it is in the cartoons. Spoilers: they are

[@Oshroth]

Mythbusters also tested banana peels and they came to the conclusion that they are not very slippery and slipping on one requires a smooth enough surface but walking on one on a normal surface doesn't have much effect.

[@82dorrin]

@@Oshroth They're not very slippery if you step down hard on them.

[@JoePCool14]

This was one of your funniest episodes yet. I can't wait to visit the Iconic™ Ponyville liquor store, hope I don't get shot!

[@MadmanWthABox]

Wait a minute, how did you come at six days ago? This video was released 30 minutes ago?

[@Fluffy-Rose1993]

@@MadmanWthABox Patreon early views.

[@gracekim1998]

@@Fluffy-Rose1993don’t worry after a while you get used to the repetition questions😅

[@augustday9483]

On the topic of the Cutie Mark Crusaders growing up, I always wondered why they didn't update their models to the "teenager" form we see sometimes. In the last couple seasons it started getting kinda weird that the CMC still look like fillies, despite years having past in-universe and in real life.

[@Robohead-z6z]

I wonder why they didn’t use the the tot pony design for the younger ponies.

[@pemanilnoob]

Marketing.

[@SkiggsMoDiggs]

It seems like the show was hesitant to depict teenagers until they couldn't avoid it anymore (The Perfect Pear) so they likely didn't have models ready, and even then the CMCs would lose their relatability to the young girl audience it was targeting so they were never going to do it. But it would've been really cool

[@nicknackpaddywacks]

Your edit of Rarity shoving Zipporwhill ALL the way out of the window and hitting the ground made me double over 😭😭😭

[@StudioMEGA_]

I'm forever trapped in this franchise...help me

[@JordanOlling]

Hmm... no. You're stuck here.

[@nessesaryschoolthing]

There was something we used to say about "a ride" and how you couldn't get off it for some reason, how did it go...?

[@augustday9483]

The ride never ends.

[@nessesaryschoolthing]

@@augustday9483 That's the one

[@albatross1688]

Just watch a bit of G5 and you will be cured. It did wonders for me and my Pony obsession. Then again, my KZbin feed still reminds me semi-regularly why I used to be in love with MLP, so...maybe I am still hooked.

[@CyberWarezz05]

4:58 that actually brings up some pretty interesting points, such as: 1-is that supposed to be a metaphor for the fact that even though you're specialized in something, sometimes you still need help from others? 2-that because she is a filly, despite having 3 paws as a cutie mark, she still doesn't have enough experience with pets, therefore this being more as a matter of experience instead of a "cutie mark talent"? 3-the creators butchering their own concepts and ideas?

[@AnachronisticALLOS2401]

2:38 No lie, one day at the end of school, the last bell had just rung, and as my class was leaving, just outside the room a girl had slipped on a banana peel, and her friends caught her. I legit saw that once.

[@gracekim1998]

Whoa 😮

[@FuzzyStripetail]

Not to beat a dead horse, but Rarity convincing that "retired" ice cream shop owner to return to the apparently always there Ponyville Ice Cream shop just to serve Sweetie Belle a sundae was a Sunday that was slipperier than any cartoon banana peel.

[@TheCommenterDragon]

"Forever Filly" is one of my favorite Rarity and CMC episodes! I know Rarity and Sweetie Belle are sisters, But to me personally the way Rarity was crying in the beginning of the episode felt like the same way a mother would cry over missing her child, But that's just how I see it but would anyone else probably not. And it was good to see Zipporwhill again since she first appeared in "Filli Vanilli" As for Sweetie Belle I admire how much she's grown as a character in the series, It may be hard for siblings to do what they used to do but it's still possible for them to find new things to do together. Speaking of which I always loved the part where they did the photo shoot Sweetie Belle looked absolutely adorable in that sheep costume!

[@Lpsdingo.allyson]

"The Iconic Ponyville Volcano" is such a classic sight.

[@SonicJrandSarah]

So Sweetie Belle's favorite part of a puppet show is when Celestia talks like a robot.

[@lucidfangirl1030]

What clip is Celestia from?

[@juvairia12345]

​@@lucidfangirl1030I think that clip is from the episode called “Horse Play” yk the one in which Twilight was putting up a play and made Celestia the star of the show and everyone started freaking out

[@MarsNotPlanet]

This series will never die

[@IdiotamSpielen]

actually it will. In exactly 6 years from now... or maybe 7 years if he's doing "Rainbow Road Trip", the animated shorts and "Friendship is forever"

[@JeffUni]

@@IdiotamSpielen U just had to ruin the mood🤦🏾

[@LannyArtist]

@@IdiotamSpielenshut

[@oscargonzalez3599]

@@LannyArtist Wait guys....let him cook.

[@IdiotamSpielen]

@@JeffUni what mood? There was no "mood" to ruin here. This wasn't some elaborate joke that necessitated a suspension of disbelief. It was merely a fallacy...

[@Butterflygirl659]

3:04 Sweetie bell is actually destruction to dig in🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣that just made my day. every time there is a villain he/she says heir gonna destroy the main characters instead of kill so he is actually right lol

[@FanSeitz]

5:30 perfect use of Celestia acting.

[@TobbyMLP]

The iconic Ponyville Liquor Store is my favorite location within all of Equestria!

[@Mirthful_Panda]

0:43 (cries in Marshmallow) 😂

[@nicholasnguyen5181]

Sweetie Belle’s so adorable when she’s acting like a filly again. Awwww!

[@TheEternalSamurai]

Cannot get enough of cinamare sins! Gr8 job as always LittleShy

[@jmmj1311]

1:00 maybe that's the mountain from the episode Dragonshy?

[@pinkprincess6136]

This episode is funny I love it and I loved the part when you showed the part of Celestia trying to pretend to act she was talking to Twilight in the episode horse play.

[@kirbyshowstheworld]

I remember watching you as a kid and seeing you still do this kind of videos makes my day. Keep up the great work!

[@bandicootsauce4569]

I love the idea of Rarity performing necromancy just to get ice cream. I may even have to write a fanfic to that effect. Lol!

[@rexyemperor]

Well as always Littleshy you did a wonderful job with this Cinemare Sins episode! The liquor store joke was very nice but I mean, if you are not american, cider is alcohol so technically Sweet Apple Acres is THE liquor store of Ponyville. Jokes aside continue the wonderful work! /)

[@archtansterpg4246]

1:06 I think AB was asking about this particular slab in comparison to any others that Chip Cutter may have worked with (like, "each slab is asking to be turned into something different" or something), so AB's articulation of that line makes sense to me. I dunno.

[@PrincessMalka_]

Rarity: *cries because Sweetie Belle yelled at her* Rarity and Sweetie Belle back in season 2:

[@82dorrin]

Now we need the iconic Ponyville adult book store. Oh, wait. That was Twilight's old house. The Golden Oaks "Library" which totally _wasn't_ an adult book store.

[@SmokeTheHorsehog]

The sad thing is, most of the pets got sidelined and never got an episode having to do with them outside of a few scenes, unless their name was Angel Bunny.

[@Whats_that_its_Phlow]

"The best way to stop things falling through the cracks is pretend there are no cracks at all"😂

[@robbys5236]

Ponyville: Where you never know what's gonna be added next.

[@theAstarrr]

1:42 rhyming reminds me of TV shows that do that aimed for kids. (Like the seasons of Thomas with boring writing)

[@ShaDHP23]

This episode made me cry the first time I saw it

[@timwoods2852]

I completely forgot about this episode. Probably because I knew what the conclusion was when the problem was introduced. I was honestly thinking the B-plot with the dog was going to go somewhere, but then they revealed that it was the same lesson twice, and my brain shut off.

[@Werefangx]

1:06 Apple bloom looks scared to give em the hammer and chisel 😂

[@bettyacheampong5412]

0:33 the best sin ever in my opinion hands down.

[@leighilynn]

I love it when old lines for sins come back

[@whatthehelldoiputhere]

I found this series again recently and I still love it although I don't watch my little pony anymore. I'm gonna be sad once you cover all the episodes.

[@isaiahkoch1673]

That thumbnail is so cute though 😊

[@karineraad3631]

I noticed another sin: at 20:10 of the episode, the stick in Rarity's mane magically grows so that it can be a decent size for the dog

[@TheSimba86]

if only there was a pony that could talk to animals that could help them out

[@loganchristensen9820]

This has quickly become my favorite parody series 👌😂

[@cronchytoast]

i find it strange how applebloom and scootaloo think that tiny pink toy, which is about the size of two pebbles, would even fit in the dog's mouth. he would probably choke on it if he tried to play with it and nopony seemed to notice.

[@3fatkid]

4:18 Sounds like Apple Bloom said Azumarill XD

[@82dorrin]

Another of those episodes where a member of the Mane Six seems to stupidly regress in their character.

[@shiningroses1789]

I always look forward to these episodes

[@njivwathomassilavwe2056]

Cries in marshmallow is so accurate 😂

[@mayowhishes]

About the volcano, didn't discord spawn one sometime and flutters told him no ? I think he snuck it back in

[@JasonScotchmer]

The audio outtake clip at the end (5:28) is: My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic, "Horse Play" (season 8, episode 7; Discovery Family, 28th April 2018)

[@bitsandbytesboy]

Dude, I used to watch these videos as a kid, your voice bought back so many memories. Thanks for still making these, king! 💖💖

[@mywaterco0lerromance]

“the iconic ponyville liquor store” made me laugh more then it probably should’ve

[@AnneKerthieJeanDedieu]

5:25 lol😂

[@ShizuruNakatsu]

Oh wow. Just a couple of days ago, I was thinking of looking up an "Everything wrong with" mlp series, but I ended up not searching for it. Then today, this gets randomly recommended. I might just go back to the start and watch in order :o

[@BetamaxFlippy]

"We watch in reverence as Narcissus is being turned to a flower" "A flower!?"

[@rainbowdashthefirst]

Ive been watching this series since 2013 ❤ i look forward to it every first of the month!

[@Tanukitime37]

Hehe another great one Littleshy! So funny 😂

[@kitty_gutzz]

It’s so nice to watch these videos after watching the scripting streams!

[@Larsen_illustrations]

Can't that little girl talk to dogs? I mean fluttershy can talk to animals with her talent, why can't the girl do the same?

[@jazspidwtv1002]

it has been a long time since I enjoyed your newly released episodes

[@loukasmekens4691]

One of the best things on KZbin

[@realOmegasMovie]

A pony falling out of the treehouse. Was pretty funny. 🤣great editing. Always looking forward to your videos.

[@mochastar3362]

No joke, the part that made me laugh out loud was Celestia's appearance. Great editing.

[@So1]

It was fun watching the stream of u making this, i hope u do them more, great video btw ^w^ Also thanks for implanting that celestia scene into my head

[@darkyboode3239]

I love the photoshoot of Rarity and Sweetie Belle with their mouths covered in ice cream at the end of this episode, it’s really cute.

[@criticalaorta]

It’s a good day when Littleshy posts cinemare sins

[@cian.o]

Its almost my birthday, so I consider this an early gift.

[@tanandalynch9441]

Applebloom eas impressed by sweitebell knowing exactly when Zipperwhil showed up

[@purehyper124]

The thought of Rarity gasping the hole time is too funny.

[@NachoCheeseDorito-Kun]

1:01 I feel like the sin shouldn't be that there is a giant mountain near Ponyville, but that it hasn't been mentioned since Season 1 Episode 7.

[@PygmentSplat]

Canterlot has nothing when its competition is all the iconic and mysteriously-convenient-for-the-plot tourist scenes!

[@NitroIndigo]

Rarity paid for the ice cream with a green rupee, which is only worth 1.

[@2goodsharks]

To be fair that wasn't a lot of ice cream.

[@Wissle]

I really feel Rarity in this though. It's scary as heck how time flies

[@oceansolstice608]

I did the math and it will be exactly 6 more years of these sins videos

[@AidanWR]

What are you talking about? The iconic Ponyville Liquor store has been there for centuries

[@RebekahSmithChildofGod7]

We're back!!!

[@ajshiro3957]

An episode about siblings. Always loved those. But one sin i must forever place is Rarity's voice. Where did that come from? Their parents don't sound anything like that. In fact, the parents sound like Manehattenites. Unless... Rarity picked it up in school, or she lets out her real voice secretly.

[@Zachruff]

0:25 is it just me or does she have no neck here

[@LannyArtist]

Just you

[@Enchantlingus]

Welcome to Ponyville. There's Sugarcube Corner, there used to be a library there, you have Rarity's Boutique, and of course, the iconic PONYVILLE VOLCANO. Edit: Forgot ice cream shop

[@TheMovieAndCartoonFan]

Sweetie Belle as a sheep. That just killed me right there.

[@shinyskeleton5257]

Can't wait for you to do "Frenemies" even though that's gonna take a few years lol

[@windygleam9821]

The true meaning of retirement...Yeah that was terrifying

[@kresentia5733]

That was SUCH a good episode of yours!!! I've never commented on your videos but this truly deserves a comment!

[@jonathanchan7896]

Ah, the second of the trifecta of the “CMCs Growing Up” episodes. Try and guess which are Applebloom’s and Scootaloo’s.

[@shane5326]

Zipporwhill's finger feather predicted my reaction to Season 8.

[@ChicagoMel23]

It wasn’t that bad

[@Fictionboy16]

I'm sure someone has waited forever for you to get to this filly...

[@theffects9545]

Happy 200k

[@FanOfMostEverything]

Ponyville warps itself to fit the plot... I mean, Discord's current hobby. Silly me, it's Equestria's railroads that grow to reach the plot.

[@fony8198]

The fact about the dog shocked me.

[@TheAllSeeingEye2468]

I really liked this ep

[@eatatjoe]

The sudden and unusual appearance of things like the ice cream shop and the removal of the liquor store irritates me.

[@watergirl929]

0:41 Rarity’s yellow mucus. That would mean she’s sick. Your mucus is only yellow when you have a cold, flu, or other illness.

[@ScorpSteed]

2:37 I mean, have you ever unknowingly stepped on a banana peel?

[@gamerninjask6746]

I like the "iconic ponyville locations" bits/parts (idk :/) They are funny

[@windygleam9821]

I haven't seen one meme about Scootdog yet considering that many chicken memes there are

[@autumbreeze1129]

The idea of Rarity gasping the whole scene between the B plot before coming back to her and Sweetie Belle is not only hilarious, but I can easily believe it since it's Rarity 😂 Scootapup memes not happy is odd, now that you mention. I mean, there WAS that fanfic about her becoming Dash’s *dog* after getting her Cutie Mark, but that was written before the CMC got their marks and... is honestly a kinda uncomfortable fanfic anyway, given we now know Scootaloo DOES have family

[@rain_124]

i just realized there won't be infinite CinemareSins

[@nialvessal]

5:05 "Why, the taxes, of course."

[@joi_mg21]

I want the iconic Ponyville liquor store in my playset 😔