Everything Wrong With The Punisher In 15 Minutes Or Less

Once upon a time, there were two Punisher movies, and neither was very good. These are the sins of one of them.
Remember, no movie is without sin! Which movie's sins should we expose next?!
Tweet us: / cinemasins
Tumble us: / cinema-sins
Podcast: / cinemasins
Call us: 405-459-7466
Reddit with us: / cinemasins
Jeremy's book now available: theablesbook.com Merch: teespring.com/stores/cinemasi...

[@danielcossey9118]

In all honesty, I gotta call bullshit on some of those sins.

[@Boss-ec4if]

+Clay Tankard a lot of his sins are bullshit, but its funny as fuck so who cares.

[@danielcossey9118]

+Boss eh, most I found funny, but some where just stretching it too much and too obvious

[@sum0panduhhh118]

+Clay Tankard Your right dude this video is extra salty. Funny.. with just a dash of salt.

[@ethan5354]

+Clay Tankard This isn't a serious video, they're all bs comedy sins

[@liampezzano]

Jeremy still isn't over BVS, I can only imagine what Civil War is going to be like

[@thedondon911911]

The movie had problems but still was amazing. The fact that the punisher actually PUNISHED his victims , think about it. He stole his money , made him kill his best friend and wife , killed both of his sons , took out his henchman , THAN dragged him through a parking lot on fire. THATS fucking punishment and was enjoyable to see on screen. The punisher in the comics would've just shot Howard Saint in the face point blank. This version was a lot smarter and actually punished him

[@ocarinaplaya]

*then.

[@moviemetalhead]

It was very Greek Tragedy of him which was what was cool about this telling of The Punisher. I agree.

[@damageYT666]

+thedondon911911 For the record, this draws heavily on an actual comic book series, written by the legendary Garth Ennis, where a lot of the events and characters featured appear (including Harry Heck, The Russian, Bumpo etc). The Punisher "punishing" people is definitely a feature , it may not be in keeping with the more traditional "kill 'em all" mantra of the other series (like "Punisher Max" which inspired the other movie, also written by Ennis) but it's still part of the character. I liked this movie a lot too.

[@thedondon911911]

***** exactly, like the popsicle torture method was in the comics, i even have the issue, the film had problems but i still found it amazing

[@sinxincarnate]

+damageYT Garth Ennis does a great series for avatar press called "war stories".

[@kingoffuzziethieves]

"roll cred--they're actually rolling credits. Excellent." *Sins it anyways*

[@LRP3102]

Honestly that should be a sin removal

[@HabibHasan110]

@@LRP3102 Agreed

[@VegetaLF7]

The whole movie was the punishment. Castle didn't just outright kill Saint, he wanted to take everything from him the way Saint took everything from Castle. He specifically set up things to make Saint's life fall apart, shown at the end after the quickdraw. "Made you kill your best friend. Made you kill your wife. Now I've killed you".

[@konstellashon1364]

@@user-im6bn2cg2s considering that this is the start of his vigilante life, and that it was personal with Saint. Every criminal after he can be quick & efficient.

[@rubix4195]

"Not vengeance. Punishment."

[@KianoUyMOOP]

It would have been a riot if Frank outed Quentin as a fanook from the get-go and in desperation, he explains to Howard that the blood-pressure medications he's taking f**ked with his head which is why he's attracted to other men. Oh, and he has a vindictive brother-in-law who has the tendency to remind others that he spent 20 years in the can.

[@rashido_grey]

"They are actually rolling credits" I feel like that should have been one sin removal...

[@zachariahdearing9611]

+Colin Healy Agreed.

[@sandman83nl]

+1

[@rashido_grey]

I don't think he's ever sinned a movie that rolled credits when it actually says the name and rolls credits.

[@MicJaguar]

+Slave2thedrago No they dont get a sin removed because thats something they should already have done without asking in every movie. So no sin removed for doing what they were supposed to. Sin removal I believe is for really awesome scenes or moments.

[@MicJaguar]

+Slave2thedrago True that.

[@matheustran8009]

The Russian Waldo is easy to find because in mother Russia, Waldo finds you

[@ryanscottnix]

This comment is a hidden gem.

[@xanderellem3646]

lol

[@Corgifunni]

it doesnt technically explain it but i wont complain this is a pretty good joke

[@victor882100]

Gold

[@Haaklong]

Such an Australian name.

[@dante340]

To its defense, the popsicle torture is meant to be more of a psychological torture than a physical one.

[@omega1maestro]

It's also taken directly from the comics. I don't know what this numbnuts is talking about.

[@afterdinnercreations936]

It was like he was pranking someone at the family-picnic... too soon?

[@thegrandslamgamer3129]

Also, that torture scene is ripped straight out of the War Zone comics

[@GodmanGoddard]

I just found out that Thomas Jane ACTUALLY stabbed Kevin Nash so his lack of reacting was the real reaction

[@Ixidora]

Absolutely, my favorite bit of trivia about this movie is that moment.

[@marekstruhar5574]

wait seriously?

[@Ixidora]

@@marekstruhar5574 the prop guy was distracted talking to a girl and forgot to swap the real knife for the prop knife before the scene

[@marekstruhar5574]

@@Ixidora holy shit thats brutal

[@Ixidora]

@@marekstruhar5574 unfortunately I can't remember the big guys name but he used to do work for the WWE and he's used to acting like injuries don't affect him. The man is a freaking legend IMHO.

[@GiuseppeGaetanoSabatelli]

Should have removed a sin for that roll credits. Since that's sort of the entire point of that trope. XD

[@kasane1337]

+Joseph DiSalvo He didn't add a sin though, so that's something.

[@GiuseppeGaetanoSabatelli]

***** He dinged from 161->162...lol had to double check since you said that.

[@kasane1337]

Joseph DiSalvo I don't get how I read that wrong two times in a row.

[@csgrambauer5852]

That's exactly what I said too when he gave it a sin.

[@0_0gaming13]

I was thinking that exact thing

[@Valkanna.Nublet]

Missed the chance for "In soviet Russia Waldo finds you"

[@MrPrince105]

+Valkanna .Nublet lol

[@tremassicotte3172]

+Valkanna .Nublet nice

[@McPhisto]

+Valkanna .Nublet Excellent.

[@MicJaguar]

lol. Thats exactly what was thinking. Har de har harrrr!

[@ginganinja84]

You win the Internet for the day 😂😂

[@joshsteele5701]

Thomas Jane crushed that role. The movie was pretty decent.

[@SuperColonel91]

He's my favorite as the Punisher

[@whobitmyname]

If only he had an R rating to work with.

[@SuperColonel91]

@@whobitmyname The movie rated R

[@TheTribalGymBro]

Bernthal is the best punisher though

[@enesgokturksahin463]

@@TheTribalGymBro yeah but Netflix Punisher is shit though

[@mogarcia9755]

The only thing wrong that there wasn't a sequel

[@Chief_5]

Mo Garcia I’m still waiting 🐍

[@ch33zybreadtrellie4]

War zone. I thought that was the sequel but went straight to DVD. This movie was better, but that movie was in right direction of how violent the punisher comics really is.

[@coolcat6303]

Yeah that was a real shame. He’s a terrific actor & I was really looking forward to him reprising this awesome role. Here’s a quote that I found from a 2007 email, that Jane wrote, on why it never happened: "I'm writing to tell you that I regretfully and painfully had to pull out of [Punisher 2]. I can't tell you how completely broken up I am about it… Punisher fans are already fighting an uphill battle as it is. And I've always felt a responsibility to fight that fight for them and with them so that Frank Castle gets the treatment he deserves. "What I won't do is spend months of my life sweating over a movie that I just don't believe in. I've always loved the Marvel guys, and wish them well. Meanwhile, I'll continue to search for a film that one day might stand with all those films that the fans have asked me to watch."

[@heartless604]

@@tintinthereporter4391 you mean the Jack Daniels advert?

[@spaceracer23]

"The was Punisher Warzo.." "I SAID THERE WASNT A SEQUEL!!!"

[@TheNobleScoundrel]

The Popsicle "torture" scene is a direct reference to a popular scene in the Punisher comics.

[@garganrose]

TheNobleScoundrel I can’t believe more Punisher fans don’t know that.

[@MudflapNichols]

I scanned the comments specifically to see if someone mentioned that. TheNobleScoundrel is on it! 😀

[@wlthomas67]

It's also used in BDSM...don't ask.

[@silverblade357]

The whole point of the scene was that Frank wanted to interrogate and then recruit the perpetually mistreated henchman. Burning him with the torch would not inspire much more loyalty to him than the Saints.

[@peebay3515]

@@garganrose I literally knew what it was the second I saw the guy hanging and the meat. It's literally an almost shot for shot remake of it. Well as much as a shot for shot could be from a comic book but yeah.

[@richardtorruellas2370]

As an overweight Italian guy I can assure you I and many others will be eating while cooking. And yes we usually order a pizza and cook pasta.

[@JaceCavacini]

Meh. Meal prep can take a lot of time. Not noodles, granted, like in this movie... But I might eat while cooking sometimes just because I may have started that meal prep with a very empty stomach. Effort is harder when really hungry. Doesn’t mean I just eat again immediately after finishing the meal prep. It might be for a later meal. I’m part Italian and that has nothing to do with it. Not overweight.

[@darthwhatever9959]

As a non-overweight, non-Italian, non-guy I can also confirm that eating while cooking is an almost daily thing for me. )) Never tried pizza with pasta though. Shame on me. Now I want to try it. To think of it..my last pizza was more than 7 years ago. Now I want it even more.

[@chrisallie2224]

Must have smoked a ounce of pot

[@glenncordova4027]

Wow. I must be Italian! 😃

[@wlthomas67]

"They managed to shoot the salad but not the salad bowl." LOL

[@robertmorris8997]

Should take a sin off for the otherworldly marksmanship.

[@phydeux]

A truly skilled shooter can hit the inside of the rim, have the bullet sling around, and come out the other side. And that's complete bullshit too.

[@keepironman14]

It looks like a wooden bowl, so it's possible the bullet did hit the bowl, but if it's wood it could punch a hole

[@mattmccormick4565]

Can’t hate on a movie as good as this one... classic, one of my favs

[@pauljarvis446]

I prefer the original.

[@dmoney96761]

Definitely a classic to real punisher fans

[@ZinoAmare]

It's sinful that they changed actors.

[@michaelpacinus242]

I prefer good movies

[@ChristophBrinkmann]

Good movies don't have shooting victims fly back like they got hit with a wrecking ball.

[@ahikernamedgq]

I actually really enjoyed that movie. And, I like Thomas Jane. I wish we saw him more.

[@ryanscottnix]

Likewise!

[@FerRguez94]

same!

[@marveldcfanboy5127]

+FerRguez94 when was this made?

[@Purify94]

+Civil_ War 2004

[@FerRguez94]

Purify I think there was a remake in 2008 but it was awful in my opinion

[@jparbiter1972]

Shouldn't a sin have been removed for them rolling credits when they were suppoused to?

[@peejay4606]

I actually liked this version of the Punisher.

[@anonymousanton8418]

Same, pretty spot on from the comics well a scene or three.

[@Ogrematic]

@@anonymousanton8418 The popsicle.

[@thehobbyist7275]

What I like about Berthanal's portrayal more is how more human he appears. Yes, the common complaint he cries too much is there, but his best performance will always be in season 2 of Daredevil. He's far more black and white, the tone is grittier, and to be honest, the prison fight scene is THE best way to make Punisher a brutal and intimidating threat. "I don't want to fuck with that guy," I thought to myself. What really hurts the older version of Punisher isn't really the Punisher, but the rest of the characters and the plot of this movie. Sure, you can say that the older movies pioneered the Netflix show, but the Netflix show has side characters and villains that shine just as much as the respective Punishers. Ben Barnes made Jigsaw awesome- despite the more disfigured his face should've been. Hell, Lewis Wilson was a terrifying villain because of the severity of his PTSD and he isn't really a mainvillain in the Punisher's gallery! Because the other characters evenly share the load with Jon and that the Punisher feels more human, I think Netflix is better than this movie or anything later

[@Ogrematic]

@@thehobbyist7275 I liked war zone, but jigsaw and his brother were too cartooney, as were the parkour guys. I liked Wayne Knight as Micro, he was perfect. I just don't like when they change the main storyline, like the Thomas Jane movie. Dirty Laundry was cool. But the comic will always be better. Jim Lee's War Journal made me a fan. Still my favorite comic, cuz of the depth of his internal arc written out in his journal.

[@thehobbyist7275]

@@Ogrematic Is that you agreeing or disagreeing? I'm genuinely curious. Quite honestly, I read Punisher Max before I've read War Journals... I enjoyed the former more if you ask me. Garth Ennis transformed Punisher for me. This iteration makes me understand the character of Frank Castle more. I practice stopmotion and hope to get a channel going with superheroes and what not. The comics are the source material I want to use for the most part. Some characters I use MCU iterations, the DCAU or the comics (pre-crisis or post depending on my narratives' direction) . I also want my characters to have their origin stories be the central heartbeat for a character's action. Yes, Batman's dead parents have been repeatedly beaten into our heads, but what about his actions because of his beliefs? The Punisher lives in a black and white world: you commit a crime, you die. If you don't, you live. It's that simple with no discrimination. But what are some real world/philosophical consequences to this thought process? Daredevil's moral code conflicts this and his actions have rewards and consequences. If Punisher was a villain instead of an anti-hero, he would've probably worked better than the Hand for Daredevil Season 2. Idk, but conflict that has no clear answer draws me in. It puts in a situation where you don't really cheer for any one person.

[@g-mancollections5264]

This movie deserves at least 20 sins removed for its badass soundtrack...

[@ChristophBrinkmann]

Nope lol

[@g-mancollections5264]

​@@ChristophBrinkmann if that's how you feel, then you're a silly goose...how about that?

[@DarthAzabrush]

Frank's preternatural resilience is hinted in the scuba scene with his son. Hinting that an 8 year old can hold his breath longer than a Navy seal hints that the Castles have some serious genetic abnormality if not an outright mutation.

[@Smeeshie2001]

It's because the Punisher made a deal with Satan.

[@DarthAzabrush]

Smeeshie2001 That's Ghost Rider isn't it?

[@Smeeshie2001]

Ian Warner In Born, and other MAX issues, (Comics) they imply that Punisher made a deal with Death/Satan. Or, you could re-interpret it, arguing that he must've gone insane, and that voice was the result of his 2 conflicting ideologies: "I want to meet my family" and "I want to stay in Vietnam and murder forever", with his insanity/doubt of whether or not he could return to society being represented by the latter

[@WexMajor82]

The speech baloons in Punisher Born are those of Death. He made a pact with Death to make the war continue forever. Death sealed the deal, telling him that he will lose something. When he returns home from 'Nam and sees his family, he nows what the price is. Death then removes this knowledge from his mind.

[@Smeeshie2001]

WexMajor82 That's implied, but never confirmed. Remember, MAX Punisher comics are supposed to be grounded in reality. Not saying it's impossible, just saying we don't know that for sure.

[@Yceb0x]

"Overweight Italian guy is now eating pizza while making pasta. This may actually be racist." Nah that's just John Pinette on a typical day

[@crimsonvampyre602]

*was John Pinnette

[@Yceb0x]

:( ... yep, *was

[@existenceisrelative]

I would say "Nay Nay", but it would just make me sad.

[@arkanjoteixeira]

Yeah, R.I.P :( Great comedian

[@jamesrelich8210]

I would've added a "John Pinette isn't losing his cherub-like demeanor in this scene. *ding*"

[@dannytheginus7899]

In the EMS profession we put our ears next to the nose and mouth and look at the chest for breathing when we check for vital signs

[@LS-to6el]

dannytheginus That’s right One sin removed

[@ethancrytzer5809]

Tbh i thought Frank said something under his breath to the paramedic

[@mccarthy5825]

You and your colleagues and all EMS personnel are angels without wings. Much love to all you heroes.

[@rubix4195]

I thought it was something they did since *Victorian* times (possibly before) because Dr. Watson often did that to check if the victim was dead or not so I am not sure what the Cinema "Sin" is about

[@UseWallow]

4:21 the gunshot in the windshield makes a smiley face lol

[@XXXINC]

The only thing REALLY wrong with this movie is that it didn't get a sequel. Thomas Jane is the best Frank Castle/Punisher ever and they have should have built a trilogy around him.

[@moviemetalhead]

It was supposed to happen but never got off the ground because of because of studio politics and creative differences between Thomas Jane and Johnathan Hensleigh (the director).

[@filmfanaticx4212]

Even though it's a different actor, Punisher: War Zone is the official sequel to this movie, even if some would like to forget it's existence.

[@pissedhulk7794]

agreed

[@Justin-rd5bh]

Same I loved Thomas Jane as the punisher

[@nadiadribrats7239]

+FilmFanaticX but in War Zone he had a daughter, and in the Thomas Jane one he had a son.

[@timothylewis2527]

If, during his "Everything Wrong with Batman V Superman" video doesn't end with "The bell is rung. It can not be unrung. Ding, ding, ding, ding, ding, ding" with a sin for every "ding", I will lose all faith in humanity.

[@oddballskull1941]

You sir are an ARTIST!. I love every part of your sentence.

[@StephySon]

+Timothy Lewis U know to be honest while there is an essay long list of problems I had with BvS i didn't completely hate it and I still have hope for the majority of the DCCU, I have faith in Suicide Squad and Wonder Woman (And Alfred XD) That being said I can't wait to see Jeremy Sin the ever living shot out of that film as well as Zootopia, Kung Fu Panda 3, Deadpool, and Civil War ^^

[@StephySon]

TheSquishyCat Putting aside the Dark Knight trilogy which is its own greatness, most of DCs film success has lied in there animated films which are dark and nitty gritty. But in terms of live action, Marvel is king currently but only time will tell if DC can catch up. I too and mega excited for Suicide Squad and I sure hope they don't let me down. But to be honest even I for months now have had this shaking feeling that SS would be the better film over BvS.

[@timothylewis2527]

StephySon truth be told, I'm a huge comics geek and, despite it flaws, I really enjoyed BvS. I know a lot of people had problems with it but that's fine. I can laugh with them, too!

[@StephySon]

Timothy Lewis As did I ^^

[@TheCrackedFirebird]

You asked what the Punisher's super power is? He's a pissed off US Marine.

[@LRP3102]

Literally everyone who has met even one Marine: ‘nuff said

[@TheCrackedFirebird]

@@LRP3102 being one, I can confirm your statement as fact.

[@andrewblanchard2398]

SEMPER FI

[@rubix4195]

He's a pissed of US Marine that says his declaration of intent is 1) If you want peace, prepare for war. (2) He died with his murdered family (3) To pursue natural justice, it's not vengeance - it's punishment. I am sorry but for most villains - super or otherwise - they would think this is not a guy they want to mess with.

[@jamesliggins891]

'MURICA

[@ChristopherJ0884]

13:15 "Don't do this" "Come on Quentin he is well into the middle of doing this" 🤣

[@OldManTheseDays]

The popsicle torture scene is right out of the comics. But I'm sure about a thousand people have noted that.

[@Blasted2Oblivion]

only about 400.

[@TheKamilkrawczak]

Literally taken from pages.

[@TonySylvesterOhio]

War zone # 1 to be exact

[@AnchisesGamer]

That shit was hilarious watching it

[@gregbethscheider5912]

@@AnchisesGamer yes yes that scene was hilarious

[@TheWheelsHaveEyes73]

Shell of his comic book self? The popsicle interrogation scene is taken almost panel for panel from The Punisher: War Zone #1. Learn ya shit fam

[@thejamman4070]

SHODANFreeman I thought it was awesome and kinda funny.

[@MonadRimsire]

I haven't seen this movie, or read the comic. But that part with the popsical, and the guy eating it afterwards, made me laugh xP

[@jasonrhodes10000]

Pretty much the whole movie was taken from a Punisher comic story line. The narrator would have shit himself if Frank had killed the Russian comic book style by burning his face with a hot pizza, knocking him down and smothering him with Mr. Bumpo.

[@link8440]

Jason Rhodes Really? What drugs does a writer have to be on.

[@uglyguy2519]

This movie picked a lot of unexpected stuff from the comics, like the popsicle torture, the Russian (quite accurate fight as well), Mr Bumpo, Joan, the piercing guy (Sparkles or something like that, right?) being interrogated while having his piercings pulled one by one but still not snitching Frank... What startles me is how they picked the silliest characters they could find in Punisher comics and did them justice but couldn't pick a single villain. I guess Jigsaw could've been too hardcore for what this movie was aiming at (thanks again, dumb Warzone movie), but it's not like he was the only Punisher villain they could use to kill his family. Feels like they only created a new character because John Travolta signed up for it.

[@OrevShalom]

We YELLED at the screen when Punishers wife ran from that good hiding spot for the truck😂🤣😂🤣😂

[@chriswilko18]

The only real sin is Thomas Jane didn't appear in more. Though the Dirty Laundry short was masterful.

[@benabramowitz18]

X-Men Apocalypse is coming out soon, but you've already sinned all the X-Men movies. What are you gonna sin then when it comes out? I'm hoping for The Usual Suspects, since Bryan Singer's the director.

[@bryanc1984]

+Benjamin Abramowitz Deadpool

[@bordje123]

I dont think he does proper critically acclaimed films, such as Usual Suspects. Just dumb, comic book, sci fi and fantasy stuff because it typically has loads of stuff to poke fun in it. Something like the Usual Suspects is so good it will only be like a 2 minute video.

[@SDFRiver]

+Bordje You mean like Die Hard?

[@Gemnist98]

They've actually done three Best Picture winners before, only one (American Beauty) of which was more of a "silly movie". Usual Suspects would be a good choice. The only drama movies I wouldn't sin are those based on true stories/scenarios, like Saving Private Ryan and 12 Years a Slave, although one of the Best Pictures (Titanic) still fits under that criteria.

[@AcetylsaliciIique]

+Bordje You think there aren't stuff to make fun of in """""""""serious""""""""" movies ? You're fooling yourself.

[@SavageBalls]

I actually really fucking loved this movie. But none the less, no movie is without sin.

[@MEH-tv7re]

This was my first introduction to the punisher and to me, Thomas Jane will always be the character.

[@prometheusunbound7628]

"Cypress Hill, I'm looking in your direction." Thank you, CinemaSins, for the constant "Simpsons" references.

[@superman8109]

at 4:21 the bullet holes in the truck windshield make a near perfect smiley face.

[@jbuenaventura7647]

because it's just after 4:20.. get it?

[@KoRnFoReVeR23]

In Soviet Russia Waldo finds you! ;D

[@MasterChief117Aisha]

Yaas!

[@MasterChief117Aisha]

+gmk 9411 Oh you know, the usual. Eating Pancakes and threatening to break people's legs. Same old same old. xD

[@MasterChief117Aisha]

+gmk 9411 ;-;

[@hunting_hound8252]

I love how Jeremy further proves he's never been regarded as cool enough to go to fun parties, because he says that an entire bottle of whiskey or rum will kill a large man like Frank castle.

[@JDJoshofficial]

Too much alcohol will kill anyone, no matter their size bro

[@HumungusO_o]

@@JDJoshofficial surely not

[@desolane900]

Russian Waldo wasn't on drugs but he was genuinely stabbed on screen and that reaction is genuine lmao

[@demitriuscovington370]

Oh, he's wrapped up in something. And "Your mother's gone, she took the train. Solid Gold

[@nightdemon78]

Daredevil the show realllllly makes all these movies look like shit.

[@BubblesZap]

+House of Hammer Quite. This is why I only trust Marvel when it comes to Marvel. Fox had some good x-men (and Deadpool) and sony had some good spider-man, but generally Marvel studios does the best.

[@1000JayStunna]

+Jkop you mean Disney studios

[@SageVallant]

+Jkop If you think Fox had anything to do with the Deadpool film actually being good, you haven't seen Wolverine Origins. :D

[@pwners4u]

+Jkop this is made by marvel lol so was blade 3 yet people hate both of them a lot so what is your point about fox and sony when they have nothing to do with this movie

[@ca20mn]

+pwners4u marvel disney studios did not make these all marvel properties have that marvel intro this was made by lionsgate and blade was new line cinema

[@PatrickOCnMD]

I love both Thomas Jane and Bernthal as The Punisher. Just 2 different versions of the same general character. Both were played excellently by both actors. I am just sorry Netflix axed the recent Punisher series. Will really miss it.

[@KevinDelgado-ho7vz]

“Roll cred- they are actually rolling credits. Excellent” i laughed way to hard at that 😂

[@masteroftheassassins]

Here's another sin: I actually like this movie

[@CryingZombie666]

+masteroftheassassins hi

[@gazerkentrell2459]

+StygianTraveler141 Creep

[@VeryPeeved]

that line is a massive cliche in the comments section for this series *ding*

[@dRoy8364]

+masteroftheassassins Worthless whining is worthless. *ding*

[@iamclough3385]

I still love it.

[@jasofisc]

Your problem with the interrogation scene not being like the comic is actually strait from the comic.

[@israelicrane5132]

Straight.

[@RainyDayBlue8]

+IsraeliCrane str8

[@NanBan9er69]

The bit where the medic checks Castles pulse and “listens” is actually to check and see if he’s breathing. By placing your head where the medic does you can clearly see if the patients chest is moving up and down. In those kind of hectic conditions and circumstances where there is a lot going on and there is danger present it’s an efficiently quick way to see if your patient is breathing and / or has a pulse.

[@Rurik_Luci]

I love watching all the fact fiend fans screaming about how that wasn't a fake knife that Kevin Nash was actually stabbed.

[@blairpenny1526]

Bro..I was just looking for the first person to mention it. I saw the same video and had to see that scene knowing he actually got stabbed and that is the actual shot in the movie.

[@wowser4life]

The thing with the popsicle is because your mind can easily be tricked to think that cold is heat, so when he felt the popsicle hit him his mind assumed it was the blowtorch and that's why he got scared.

[@jordanzlotolow8254]

jagvillinte göradet and he burned fat to make him smell his flesh burning

[@ysmahelyfilho9998]

Damn right. But the opposite is also true (sometimes, i guess) as a guy once held a burning lid against my back and it felt like a cold hand.

[@adambedard8641]

Thank you Dr. Good Humor

[@FireheartIndustries]

"call me... The Punisher" "Roll credi...they are ACTUALLY rolling credits. Excellent!" This part made me laugh more than any other part of this video!

[@Drog007]

The movie had issues for sure, but no more than most superhero adaptations of the era, and Jane absolutely embodies the role. I'd love to see him put on the trenchcoat again.

[@gotu2dieter]

You have like 4 or 5 actual "sins" and the rest is either comic accurate or else made sense for that time

[@KiingLewis]

he has said multiple times it doesn't matter if it is in a book or whatever he judges on the movie alone

[@RabblesTheBinx]

"Comic-accurate" and "sinful" aren't mutually exclusive terms.

[@MrShadowcast]

This movie was awesome back in the day. Still is! Sins forgiven.

[@_guitarjun_]

To be fair, this punisher movie is way better than the other one

[@apmm4209]

Great movie Thomas jane was amazing!

[@SpeezyOTB]

Sometimes I just re-watch your videos because they’re so funny. You’re one of my favorite KZbin channels. You should do punisher war zone, inspector gadget and inspector gadget two I can only imagine what you would come up with. In all seriousness, keep up the amazing work.

[@sporkwitch]

Near the start "checking pulse requires hands and ears," he actually did it right. You check the pulse with your fingers, while putting your ear near their mouth to listen/feel for breathing, and look down the chest to look for breathing. It's exactly how I was taught to check when I was in the military.

[@Goldenmaster94]

+SporkTV It's a first aid thing, what he did wrong is that Franks face was facing side, ergo the paramedic was poorly placed and couldn't have felt his breath

[@sporkwitch]

Phillip Bathory I get that, but the specific criticism was still wrong. That's my point. He went through the motions right, as you're taught to do, he just didn't actually position himself right.

[@HazardSJ]

Kevin Nash (The Russian), actually did get stabbed in that scene, with a real knife. He said the shock of the stab was lessened by the adrenaline rushing through him. That face Thomas Jane makes, is pure fear that he might have killed an actor.

[@travisdicken5947]

Blind Kumiho the real shocker isn’t that Kevin got stabbed, it’s that he didn’t blow out both of his quads walking up the stairs to Frank’s apartment.

[@adrianwagner8319]

Oh shit whattt? I didn't know that, thats cool. Thanks bruh for that info, like the Punisher more now haha

[@gdroff]

Seriously?

[@MrJoshcc600]

I don't believe that for a second

[@nrdsgtbck101]

@@MrJoshcc600 Its true, he accidentally stabbed Nash during the fight scene.

[@abyssous24]

Omg, I've never laughed so hard in my life !!! Thanks for the upload, i love this channel.

[@thomasferrell6346]

I love how "everything wrong" video when he literally called a chevy blazer a jeep.. oh the irony 🤣🤣

[@DistortedAudio2001]

*Sacha Baron Cohen. Sorry. I had to.

[@jamesanderson8765]

.....DING!

[@FriENTlyFire]

that's not a jeep (ding)

[@shortyof99t.42]

Blaizer not a jeep

[@BobMinelli]

So beautifully done.....i must have giggled 12 times....TWELVE, can you believe it?! 🌱

[@prisonmike4971]

11:09 That stab is actually legit- prop master forgot to switch out the dulled blade with the retractable one and Nash didn't even flinch.

[@SinHurr]

You know what doesn't suck? Daredevil's Castle. He's fucking amazing.

[@jabarhenv5933]

amen

[@Kostyurik]

+hksin11186 wrong

[@iankopeski2831]

+hksin11186 ONE BATCH, TWO BATCH, PENNY AND DIME

[@jakeboos9860]

+Константин Лозовой Said nobody

[@Kostyurik]

Jake Boos I said. I am person

[@EatWave]

You might as well cover the Dolph Lundgren version of the Punisher next just to complete the set.

[@tinyj4520]

!

[@shawniebeans8382]

I second that !!

[@Discosaturn]

+EatWave I think the biggest sin to Dolph Lundgren's Punisher is that he didn't wear that iconic skull symbol on his shirt.

[@rihardsrozans6920]

+Disco Saturn Loves To Do Subtitled Comedies and Other Things 24/7 That and that stupid knife throwing.

[@TheTaintedWisdom]

+EatWave That would still leave out Punisher: Warzone from 2008

[@bobbydown1606]

The "I just want my kids back" part near the end is perfect lol

[@Nicodemus1991]

You take the pulse with your fingers, you try to hear the breath or the heartbeat, you try to see if the chest elevates. If there Is negative response to all of those signals then RCP. 30:2 , which means you press the chest 30 times and then you insuflate 2 times(hard enough to elevate the chest).

[@ryan_edmond]

"Roll Credi-- they are actually rolling credits. Excellent." sins them anyways

[@WhiteMonteSS]

Lol I loved that bit

[@egeerdem8272]

btw that stabbing was real that big guy didnt feel anything and continued the scene

[@PhatGirlLuvr68Comix]

+Ege Erdem Big Daddy Cool doesn't feel pain.

[@TJ52359]

+Ege Erdem he Felt it, but the the take was short enough he held it together until they yelled 'cut'

[@beilmandulin]

+PhatGirlLuva68-ThelastOG except for his quads

[@PhatGirlLuvr68Comix]

beilmandulin LOL! True...

[@norbertoszi6812]

Because He is Kevin motherfucking Nash.

[@corndog2475]

The interrogation scene with the torch is actually straight out of the comics.

[@ztm454]

Ah yes the Jeep "Chevy s10 Blazer" how could I forget about that model

[@Power5]

It was clearly a Jeep S10 Explorer.

[@scrambler4148]

@@Power5 nah its a 2 door so it's a jeep s10 bronco II

[@nthgth]

@@scrambler4148 maybe it's a Jeep S10 Navajo LX

[@TheWheelsHaveEyes73]

Also, it isn't "convenient" that Frank is at a family reunion when they go after his family...they go after his family BECAUSE he's at a family reunion

[@jrgenaarvik7671]

I have NEVER had a family reunion like that in my life. I don't even know anyone who has had one of those. Even if i did there is a 0% chance of everyone being able to make it. Point being that the fact the he even has one of those at all is a sin.

[@Draukagrissah]

Literally had one of those a couple months ago. There were even twice that many people there. I do have a big family, but still. There's so much shit Jeremy didn't even go over in this I'm surprised this made the short list for actual sins, because it isn't one.

[@jrgenaarvik7671]

And not a single person in your extended familien was absent?

[@Draukagrissah]

Jørgen Aarvik Well sure, but it never said in the movie that every single living blood relative that exists on the planet was there at the Castle reunion. When talking about something like it's assumed that most of the immediate family makes it, and as much of the extended family as possible. Which is not outside the bounds of believability in the slightest.

[@megatronbee]

we have one of those on almost every holiday

[@FinalFlameProductions]

The Popsicle scene is taken directly from the Punisher comics, so it does fit his character. 'Cinema Sins' as usual making big mistakes while laughing at others for slipping up.

[@heartlandranchtv4943]

+Final Flame Productions Just because it was in the comic series doesn't mean that it makes any more sense. Comics are full of flaws as well.

[@FinalFlameProductions]

+HeartlandRanchTV The video suggests that it isn't something the Punisher would do based on the comics. That is flat out wrong.

[@heartlandranchtv4943]

Final Flame Productions The sin was that there was no explanation of how he would know about shit like that. Just saying that 'it was in the comics' doesn't excuse the lack of exposition in the film. It's also important to keep in mind that 99.9% of movie-goers don't read the comics.

[@willmeng4251]

Okay I know this video is 6 years old, but many of the sins were explained and/or validated in the movie if you pay attention. I’ll list them: 1:16: it becomes obvious seconds after he’s referring to Mickey 1:29: the scene cuts directly to Mickey being kicked, it is implied this has been going on for a while 1:42: the real reason is seconds later when Howard says Mickey’s father gave his life for him, Quentin is just acting tough 2:05: they’re literally moving out, don’t think they care 3:07: Yes, how is this a sin? 3:11: the only reason they’re killing his whole family and not just Frank is because they were told he was at a family reunion, which is what gave Olivia the idea to do it 5:37: yes he’s been away with Candalario (sorry don’t know how to spell it) recovering from the multiple gunshot wounds for quite some time. When he returns to Tampa, he says it’s been 5 months since his family was killed 6:51: Frank needs Mickey to help him, he knows he is insignificant through his dealings with him while undercover. There would be no value in him actually harming him 7:12: we’re just making everything a sin now 7:32: this is the point in the video I decided to make this comment. Mickey told Frank that Howard has FIRST tee time 5 days a week. So it would be logical to assume he put it on the first green. No one else would’ve come up to it yet. Only thing I would say could be a sin is he would’ve had to do it between the time the groundskeeper set the pin and Howard teed off. Okay I’m done now, not going to do the whole video.

[@willmeng4251]

Okay no I’m not 9:44: he’s parking there for the sole purpose of getting the ticket!!

[@CamaroAmx]

Sin 163: they call it a Jeep but it’s actually an Chevy S10 Blazer.

[@LadyOnikara]

*hits Bing* Oh, there really was a Blazer version of the S-10! I just have a regular Chevy S-10 pickup. She's fun (but the CD player is being a royal asshole).

[@CamaroAmx]

@@LadyOnikara I had 2, a 91 2 door 4x4 5-speed and a 95 4-door 2wd. Was going to v8 swap the 95 but a knee injury forced me to sell it.

[@bastardman7998]

This movie could have been so good...

[@bastardman7998]

I agree it's good but it had the potential to be a lot better

[@Maxphyte]

While I personally like this movie, it is still a movie that does as much wrong as it does good. From what I have heard and read, a lot of the problems stemmed from budgeting issues

[@Freshtony15]

+jake rowland it was better than the second one they came out with.. however the netflix series will put them all to shame!

[@MyHazey]

it wasnt too bad considering the 1st punisher Dolph Lundgren did. THAT is what he should have sinned. It would have been to long though.

[@gustav901]

+Maxphyte I expected as much with all the lack of blood.

[@dorn284]

20 sins to CinemaSins for not including a "In Soviet Russia, Waldo finds YOU!" joke.

[@Dr.Gaming98]

I thought he would’ve removed a sin for them actually rolling credits

[@theauthorii1751]

Kevin Nash getting legitimately stabbed on screen because the prop guy was trying to get laid is 100% worth a sin removal

[@OtakuHub506]

Deadpool is now out on dvd. Dare i say more..... DOOO IT!!!!

[@ryanfreeman5333]

ah

[@Wes-qw3fk]

Yes please do deadpool.

[@azeemtravadi6128]

+Wes Hebner DO EET

[@stopmotionmaniac8237]

what are you waiting for.... do it.... DOOOO ITTTT!!!!!!

[@70astralaxe]

JUST DO IT!!!

[@alexman378]

The interrogation with the Popsicle is straight out of the comics. Plus, when you want an informant, they will be less likely to turn on you if you spare them after tricking them into thinking you burned them.

[@khrangrok]

Sorry, but the ear is used to detect breath while the eyes are used to look for fall and rise of chest while taking a pulse. My wife is a medic and she would disown me if I failed to know this. It is basically a medic multi-tasking however, The ear was no where close to where it could have detected or felt breath so there is a sin on proximity. Keep up the good work. Love this entire series.

[@morganstuart8798]

I can believe that Russian Waldo doesn't feel that, it's Kevin Nash, with all the Solmas he's done, I'm surprised if he feels anything.

[@awesomejosh9683]

You missed a sin, Franks tombstone said 1968 but his FBI paperwork said he was born in 1972

[@MrJoshcc600]

These days he is more nitpicky then the old days when he would point out actual plot holes and such

[@dp-r9856]

The Punisher’s wife overcorrecting the vehicle is forgivable, in my eyes, since she was BEING SHOT AT. I would not expect myself to make perfect reactions in a fast paced, life or death situation.

[@Wangitup]

Plus the sudden change in the vehicle physics trying to do that turn on flat tires.

[@theveryworstluck1894]

Plus she's a woman driver.

[@SILVER_QT]

@@theveryworstluck1894 Does it like fill you with manly pride to shit on women lol

[@theveryworstluck1894]

@@SILVER_QT Does it make your butt hurt when you can't take a joke?

[@SILVER_QT]

@@theveryworstluck1894 lmao wheres the joke

[@michaelploskina1681]

The popsicle torture seeing is directly from the comic books

[@synnastyrkuhr]

The popsicle/blowtorch scene was a scene in whichever comic book I read it in that gave me a surprised chuckle.

[@thelonelywolf88]

Regardless of how many sins it gets, this has been a favorite of mine for many years

[@greymajickjedi]

It fucking rules as a movie. But as he says; no movie is without sin.

[@CaribbeanLounger]

Do you live in a windowless room illuminated only by a 14" television, a BetaMax VCR, a copy of this movie, and a copy of a Jane Fonda workout tape? Because that would be the ONLY sensible reason that it would be ANYONE'S favorite movie.

[@GuitarManSDJ]

Wow, man. Not only is everyone entitled to their own opinion, and everyone's perspective is unique, as well as completely valid in relation to their understanding and experiences, but you went out of your way to attack someone for once admitting they love a film that they even admit isn't perfect. Eleven months before your comment, mind you. I think you might need to take a breath, a chill pill or whatever gets you to calm down, and consider the fact that your opinion is technically only as official or correct as anyone else's, then read up on how empathy and interpersonal communication skills can help you. That is, if you're humble enough to accept that your egocentric views are nothing more than that.

[@jonathanbethards3689]

u know this is the internet right? and not only the internet, but the comments section, c'mon man.

[@brennanmccarty3771]

You right

[@chrisjimenez2192]

I like this Punisher film more than the '89 or '08 ones

[@PhatGirlLuvr68Comix]

Daaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaamn!! Instant sub.

[@GameThruz]

+Shione Cooper I second that.

[@yungslyme4341]

+PhatGirlLuva68-ThelastOG cuz of her profile pic wow

[@protoflux5953]

I suddenly have the desire to go motorboating...

[@GameThruz]

OMG I didn't even notice that. Microsoft really needs to sort out scaling for larger 1080p displays.

[@superdutyzack]

1.Netflix The Punisher 2017 2.The Punisher 2004 3.Punisher: War Zone 2008 4. The Punisher 1989

[@iamciril]

This movie is the whole reason I drink Wild Turkey 101 straight from the bottle.

[@TurkIsAwesome]

9:42 out of context, he purposely parks there to get a ticket in the wife's car. which is part of his plan to get the crime boss to think that his 2nd in command is banging his wife, which ends up working. so its not a sin.

[@cadetrenew]

lsmail Abi Yup. Don't see how he missed that extremely important part of the plot

[@marshallh8215]

They probably dont have time to closley watch the movie

[@dirpyturtle69]

Marshall H they watch the movie several times

[@CaribbeanLounger]

"Don't see how it matters that he missed that part because it was 3-seconds of a completely stupid movie." I fixed it for you.

[@hulkslayer626]

Doesn't he say that? I thought he sinned it, because even though he had to park there to get the ticket to lend credibility to the frame up, he still parked in a handicapped spot lol Pretty sure that's what he said...

[@stefanli6700]

The roll credits should have been a sin reduction!

[@rolandgold4988]

For me John Pinnete made this movie. His stand up was also amazing god rest his soul.

[@boiledcrap]

Personally, I don't like how the son shot Frank at point blank but missed his vitals. I'm all for 'the hero surviving the odds', but if you are a criminal and you miss at point blank you should just turn yourself in. Hell it took him a minute to figure out he was holding a Claymore!

[@Kyle-bu3og]

also, the popsicle interrogation thing IS from the comic books.

[@Japheth19]

The fight between Punisher and the Russian is in my top five "superhero vs villain" movie fight scenes.

[@Mikki-Moo]

That pulse check is pretty spot on though. Fingers for pulse, one ear at the mouth to listen for breathing and the eyes looking to the chest to see if it moves

[@wavemaster4891]

I love the fact that Kevin Nash (the russian) actually got stabbed for real. Didn't break character realized after the take was over. Then just asked for glue, glued the wound shut and finished filming. The cast freaked out but not him lol.

[@ufoufo2788]

"this guy is on all the drugs" no he's just russian