Maqbool & Joji: How to adapt Macbeth

FACEBOOK: / cinemawali-92278671791...
INSTAGRAM: / thecinemawali
TWITTER: / paromabose

[@Cinemawali]

Yes, I watched Mandaar. I talk about it here: kzbin.infoLqn_TDNFk6I?si=Y4JBc65Set-_TxVi

[@Noproblem396]

Is Cinemawali the only great desi yt film creator left alive to make an essay interesting in this overcrowded space?✨

[@cinephilebuddy464]

Filmkopath, Cinema musings , Long live cinema , suave critic are some other equally good active creaters .

[@Noproblem396]

​@@cinephilebuddy464if not the only one, among the very few greats indeed🫡

[@myhalikabasher1125]

yes but u shd also try watching the swadlle

[@h.hholmes.492]

​@@myhalikabasher1125 swaddle chutiya hai mere khayal se, they point out the most obvious things in the movie jo main bhi bol skta tha but i am glad i dont have yt channel

[@h.hholmes.492]

But it could also mean they are the most unpretentious movies pr bolne wale(idk the word)

[@swordofdurga]

Maqbool is an all-time classic. Joji is good on its own. You should watch the movie 'Kaliyattom' which is an adaption of Othello - and in which Suresh Gopi the MP from Thrissur and a current Minister of State of the current Govt. won the 'Bharat' national award for best actor.

[@aavi.]

Stumbled across the kumbalangi nights video, and then this one. These two videos are only what took me to subscribe❤ great analysis and amazing presentation.. keep on going man

[@abhnav97]

Very well written and well made video. Kudos to cinemawali!

[@sauravsingh9177]

I loved Maqbool more...its a masterpiece filled with masters of acting. Even Fahaad would choose his beloved actor Irfan's Maqbool.❤

[@sagishkumar4632]

Even before joji.. there is irakal movie by KG George

[@lastmanstanding1733]

Nice one. Joji has lot of similarities with the Malayalam classic Irakal (1985) too.

[@RachaelWill]

Idk how i was unaware of this amazing channel for so long. 🤩

[@infinitedestination485]

You must see a bengali web series named maandar, another adaptation of Macbeth

[@rohitmali2057]

I love the way you pin point specifics & the different perspectives , character arc so clearly. I haven't watched Maqbool yet, nor Macbeth but JOJI I saw..but I felt both versions are super!!❤

[@RachaelWill]

Jali was such a slow pace killer. 😊

[@ankitghosh1988]

I had seen joji without realising it was an adaptation of Macbeth even though I loved it. Amazing commentary love your channel

[@roka5947]

There's this another Very interesting adaptation of macbeth named Mandar in bengali which is based on the shadowy underbelly of bengal based in a quiet seaside mofusil of Bengal

[@Cinemawali]

I discuss Mandaar here: kzbin.infoLqn_TDNFk6I?feature=share I didn't personally like it so didn't include it in this video.

[@debikaroy9946]

There is also a masterpiece in Bengali. " Mandar"

[@vijendersahu3678]

Just WOW….Waiting since i watched the acting analysis on Irrfan through your eyes from The Namesake and it is great. Please make more videos on Irrfan’s acting analysis or something new. Great to see you really…thank you very much for this🤝🙏🏻

[@nileshsharma6265]

Wish you a million subscribers 😊 too good

[@jayanthannamboothiri239]

Joji is but Irakal (1985) for dummies, completely stripped of is subtext, complexity and nuanced political commentary. It is known that Fahad Faasil had asked for the remake rights to Irakal, but the director of the original film, KG George refused starting that it needs no reiteration. The makers later claimed inspiration from Macbeth to evade the fact that they did go ahead and shoot their remake anyway, right down to even recreating some of the frames in the original film. Watch the 1985 film and you can see for yourself if it's closer to Irakal or Macbeth.

[@gayatrim3826]

They basically took the story of Macbeth and the soul of Irakal and made a good fusion. But of course it ended up as an inferior version of Irakal. And that's not a diss at Joji, it's just a testament to how good Irakal was.

[@jayshreejha1308]

Love ur work

[@CinemaSatsang]

nice coincidence! we also made a video on the same topic! we added throne of blood to the list!

[@Nyssa-yi3ev]

There is so much to learn about yourself in these stories.

[@vinitvsankhe]

Maqbool was a masterpiece. ❤

[@vm1059]

Wow like I dont have words man thank you really

[@trashpanda12300]

Beautifully explained

[@philrose7024]

I loved both movies

[@sreekanthmenon5900]

Unbelievable! How did you do this😮? This is a great effort. Really loved your work!

[@dooba7]

i just found the best channel on film yt

[@anulayanu1923]

Great analysis

[@dalysaviour6971]

Joji... ❤

[@rituraj8070]

wish you all the success

[@yashkumarjha5082]

Great work girl

[@naavoor]

Well understood and written

[@rose888warfaze]

Thank you

[@adutta8]

I would recommend bengali movie Mandar as another brilliant attempt.

[@richaprasad6737]

All your videos are really good.

[@Cinemawali]

Thanks Richa! ❤

[@charukeshprasad7857]

BINCY IS THE SECOND BROTHER'S WIFE, JOJI IS THE YOUNGEST.

[@cinemasucker6446]

YOOOOOOOOO THISSS ISSS EPIC

[@Luke__antony]

JOJI 😈

[@vm1059]

how can I thank you for this

[@Cinemawali]

Just like and subscribe. 😉😁

[@vm1059]

@@Cinemawali yessss obviously

[@vishalvyas5721]

Maqbool any day I love. But Joji threatens me to snatch what I love. Tough Tough. Cant choose one over another.

[@CinemaSatsang]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/hWannZWKeJd2rKs (discussion on throne of blood-an adaptation of Macbeth by Kurosawa!)

[@dogicoin2101]

Please upload more videos

[@neo-noiranathubronthan6045]

A few recommendations : Ee.Ma.Yau (Available with subtitles on YT) Thazhvaram(1990), Anantaram (Monologue, 1987 - remastered print available on YT) Kodiyettam(1978 - remastered print Available on YT) Mattoral (1988) Bhoothakannadi (The Magnifying Lens, 1997) Irakal (1985 - The 'Joji' from the Malayalam Golden era) Iruvar (Tamil - 1997) If any of these movies inspire you, please do consider making video essays.

[@susmitasengupta3918]

❤❤❤❤❤

[@REY-jt5ex]

Make this type of video on Othello or hamlet ....there's also Bollywood movies like omkara and haider are there!

[@Cinemawali]

You can watch my video about Haider here: kzbin.info/www/bejne/p4HdlJyhlJynq8Usi=TcwWwXkAlsH4bcww

[@anu0271]

Damn

[@Noproblem396]

There aren't very many yt creators that get me to click asap when I get a notif!💥😆

[@krishnakant5544]

Same bro same

[@bokyarao873]

Subscribed.

[@h.hholmes.492]

Yeh yeh yeh yeh yhe yhe yhei

[@wanderfolk]

Yar apne woh mandaar ke bare me kya kaha tha livestream me woh part bhi is vdo me daal deti to acha perspective milta.. i mean what you shouldn't do with Shakespeare type

[@Cinemawali]

Agreed, but criticism livestream pe hi thik hai. Videos are for appreciation. 😊

[@wanderfolk]

@@Cinemawali yaa but you see one can't be without the other and don't you think that the criticism inspires the best than the appreciation. To understand remember this line - aag ke liye pani ka darr bana rehna chahiye. Santulan

[@pratikgautam1617]

Is macbeth magneto??!

[@kanencrypted6315]

Gangs of Wasseypur?

[@vinodmathad]

I appreciate you copying the format of Cinema Beyond Entertainment. You did start narrating slowly like Vineet Masram in the beginning, however you soon lost it and started pacing. All the best for the next one.

[@aaliyaakhtar3207]

Your videos are very engaging and interesting throughout. Thank you for making them. Wish you the best! 🫶🏼