Circumcision - Khatnay Ki Sharai Haisiyat - Javed Ahmed Ghamidi

Circumcision - Khatnay Ki Sharai Haisiyat - Javed Ahmad Ghamidi
ختنے کی شرعی حیثیت
Is Circumcision Compulsory in Islam?
🔴 SUBSCRIBE 🔔: kzbin.info?s...
▶ About Javed Ahmed Ghamidi:
Javed Ahmed Ghamidi is a Pakistani Muslim theologian, a Quran scholar, and an educationist. Mr. Ghamidi is a student of Maulana Amin Ahsan Islahi and Maulana Abul A’la Maududi. Mr. Ghamidi has authored several books, including the bestseller ‘Meezan’, in which he presents a comprehensive treatise on the entire content of Islam. Mr. Ghamidi is a researcher and a critical thinker who has challenged many aspects of the traditional Muslim schools of thought on the basis of evidence from Quran and sunnah.
▶ About Ghamidi Center Of Islamic Learning:
"Ghamidi Center of Islamic Learning", an initiative of Al-Mawrid US, is established with a single purpose, to educate people of all ages about moral, ethical, and humane values as taught in Islam. Our aim is to separate history and culture from Islam and teach it in its purest form as a field of knowledge and not enforce it as a creed. We base our instruction method on argument and logic and encourage healthy criticism. An institute where traditional and historical knowledge can be understood as well as challenged with reason.
▶ DONATIONS: www.ghamidi.org/donate/
▶ CONNECT with us:
◼ WEBSITE: www.ghamidi.org
◼ FACEBOOK: / ghamidicil
◼ KZbin: / ghamidicil
#GCIL #JavedAhmedGhamidi #QnAGhamidi #AlMawridUS

[@GG-ft1bf]

GG (Great Ghamidi). Teacher of teachers. Hero of heroes. Ocean of knowledge. The best philosopher, theologian, educationist, researcher, critical thinker, Mujaddid-e-Islam. Love you Ustad-e-Mohtaram.

[@nkhan6429]

I like the way Ghamidi saab explains any subject matter with that calm, and soothing voice. Not everyone holds this quality to explain a subject without them yelling it.

[@amtunnisa5200]

دین فطرت کے مطابق دینی مسائل کا بہترین حل بیان کرتے ہیں۔ اللہ تعالیٰ صحت وسلامتی عطاء فرمائے آمین۔

[@shehzad9863]

حسن صاحب آپ سے گزارش ہے کہ ایک پروگرام سینٹ پال کی شخصیت پر بھی کریں جس میں اسکی مسیحی مذہب کے اندر ہونے والی تبدیلیوں کے ارتقاء پر روشنی ڈالی گئی ہو۔ شکریہ

[@mubeenbutt8914]

Theek kaha bhai

[@mohammadharisfahim6614]

St. Paul or rather devil Paul destroyed the real law of Jesus. And replaced it with a skewed ideology.

[@raanimughal8405]

G sir bilkul hmen b intzar rhega..

[@hadiglass243]

سادہ اور آسان الفاظ کے ساتھ نہایت عمدہ طریقے سے عام آدمی کی سمجھ سے مطابقت رکھتا ہوا جواب دیا گیا ھے ۔۔۔ ❤

[@shivanimakker7618]

The video would be so elusive because of the language barrier.. Thanks for making it accessible, Faizan. Great translation 👍

[@faizanrashid8209]

Thank you for your comments.

[@sameer-111]

I was waiting since a long time for Ghamidi sahab to talk on this topic. Searched a lot about his videos on circumcision and couldn't find any. And here we are.

[@aafichaudhry560]

Teri dunya sanwar gayee

[@zahmed7]

Dear Honorable Ghamdi sb..u are a learned individual and cognitively well equipped to entertain queries of variant nature, but in this particular topic it could had been a better reply to simple mention in response to the question that" I donot know the answer' ..only ALLAH is all knowing...circumcision is not proved a legal act from Quran or Sunnah , it is a major surgery of sensitive nerve endings which has greater other purposes such as enhancing intimacy pleasure, providing stamina, contributes in control of late droplets, allows natural lubrication during intimacy, allowing vigor in multiple attempts in a short period to consecutively conduct intercourse. and various other benefits..it is only that we are in conflict with QURAN while observing this faulty practice (circumcision) whilst it is prohibited in HOLY QURAN to edit the 'KHALQ' design of ALLAH....kind regards Sir

[@immadmalik7632]

Thanks a ton, Faizan for another brilliant translation. Ghamdi sb's sophisticated urdu could only have its full effect with such an excellent translation. More power to you.

[@faizanrashid8209]

Thank you so much.

[@mohammadsabirkhan1560]

I don't have any problem understanding his Urdu (which is actually pure Urdu).

[@NaushadAli-ft4cb]

Sir Assalam Alaikum. Sir you have answered all the questions very very correctly. Zajak Allah khair.

[@MrSyedbasit]

The guiding light of our time… Allah ustaaz ko salamat rakhay ❤️ lots of love from Srinagar Kashmir IOK

[@inamkohli8545]

bhut behtareen ....Allah Talah apse khush rahe..

[@shamnabi2501]

سینیٹ پال اور مسیحی تاریخ کے جائزہ پر پروگرام ضرور کریں

[@muhammadshafeeq5663]

Jazak Allah

[@zamanpeykar3474]

Masha Allah

[@ranaali501]

kindly aqeeqa k mutaliq bui tafeel say bata dain boht c ahadees main aqiqa milta hay jb k sir ek hadees hay jis main lafz haqooq ko pasand nahe fermata gaya kindly sent any book reference or details answer

[@muhammadabdullahfaheem7668]

Jazakallah khair

[@sadiqhussain157]

جزاک اللہ واہ

[@zamanpeykar3474]

Jakakallah

[@asadkhanniazi7613]

buhat khoob ustad g♥️

[@yousafkhalid4870]

Very good knowledge thanks

[@saleemkhan12]

Excellent explanation

[@syedhassan233]

جزاک اللہ

[@z.aadvertiser5206]

سبحان اللہ

[@asififtekhar1411]

Clear and concise

[@mohammadharisfahim6614]

Nice explanation

[@zafaraliindher4083]

Great fan of ghamidi sahb

[@aijazkhan4766]

Yes please one or 2 programs on Saint Paul with respect to Religion

[@aafichaudhry560]

I m Muslim n believe Muhammad pbuh as last prophet. Big fan of ghamdi sb but no straight answer and imagine where millions of Muslims are living without food even clean drinking water, how concern we are for khatna. Subhan Allah, masha Allah we recite

[@fjscan]

As I understood: Khatnah is a strongly recommended practice that ensures easy maintenance of bodily cleanliness. Therefore, in certain circumstances, if it becomes a formidable task, it can be deferred. However, it is a 'procedure' carried out since ancient times hence, there can be only limited periods when it becomes impractical to carry out. The practice can be resumed as soon as the normalcy returns. Millions of Muslims are in a deprived situation mainly because they themselves have decided to act in a way to perpetuate the situation.

[@zubaair]

Millions don't have food,, so we should not keep ourselves clean?? How they are related?

[@adma7298]

Millions don't have food and water, it doesn't mean they should start doing shirk, stop praying. They should follow the commandants who much they can. life is test, and everyone have different question paper according which everyone will be evaluated.

[@rashidshaikh1873]

Ek subhanallah, mashallah bolna shuru karta hai , to phir dusre bhi shuru kar dete hain.Does our thoughts and lifestyle makes us happy and prosperous?!No! Then why shouldn't we change our thoughts and lifestyle to make us happy and prosperous?.If we will not change our thoughts and lifestyle then still we will go down and at that time these so called scholars etc will not come to help you, to feed you.

[@YaqoobNohriHD]

❤️

[@Hazara26]

Please, give me any reference and prove when Mohd and his companions did circumcision?

[@khalidismail8843]

غامدی صاحب سے گزارش ہے کہ اسان اردو استعمال کریں کیونکہ اتنی مشکل اردو اب کون سمجھ سکتا ہے۔

[@hiraakbar1407]

❤️ for this black dress

[@tzd269]

So iska matlab Nabi Ibraheem khaleel se pahle ke Jitne Nabi aaye unko nafs ke Tazkiye ke liye Allah ne unke khatne ka khayal nahi kiya.... Ya phir Ibraheem se pahle ke ambiya Ibraheem nabi se kam pakiza the....?

[@rashidshaikh1873]

Sirf ek hi baat yaad rakho.Kudrat ne loose skin kisi khas maksad ke liye di hai.Jab hum usko kat kar nikal denge to kya hoga?! "Kisi achhe surgeon /doctor se pata karo.Indian sub continent ke musalmano ka sabse zyada nuksaan agar kisi cheez ne kiya hai to vo hai khatna!!. Ye bilavajah is ko glorify karke batate hain.Abhi kuch waqt pehle Sudan jo ke ek Muslim mulk hai usne vahan " lady khatna " ko legally ban kar diya hai.Lekin hum to duniya mein sab se aklmand log hain.Hum purani baton ko kaise chhor sakte hain?!!

[@ibrahimmd4369]

I request you to program on Islam and caste by javed ahmad ghamidi

[@anjumf8224]

السلام علیکم ورحمتہ اللہ و برکاتہ ،جیسے ختنہ کا وضاحت کی ہے، میرا سوال لڑکیوں کے سر کے بال اتارنے کے بارے میں بھی وضاحت کریں، انڈو پاک کے علاوہ عام طور سے مسلم معاشرے نہیں جانتے، عرب میں بھی لوگ ناواقف ہیں، البتہ غلام یعنی لڑکے کے بارے میں تو حدیث سے ملتا ہے، صل اللہ علیہ والہ وسلم نے حسن و حسین کے اتارے، ضرور آگاہ کریں.

[@sarfrazsae9226]

Socially man keeps his opinion according to what he learn from the society so others (woman) give up some space for their relief. So, a man take two positions from it's point of interest which showed up as a hot position and a normal (to be in normal he still need to be protected in his opinion which is extra mass to keep him calm down) while in hot position he is out and too sensitive to get a space.

[@muhammadshoaib76200]

Hazrat Ghamidi shb public dealing krty hen Pakistan main?? Agr krty hen tu plzz bta den m inn say mulaqat krna chahta hon aur seekhna chahta hn ❤️❤️

[@saqibhafeez5927]

Plz subtítule english ( bhot dificult alfaz hain ) 🙏

[@mohamedejaz9570]

غامدی صاحب جامعہ الندوہ کی تارپخ بتائیے گا۔ شکریہ

[@mohdabduljaleel01]

1 purification o body 2 puriication o food 3purification character 4 prurification of rituals

[@daymoon195]

غامدی صاحب آپ جیسے اہل علم سے ایس جہالت کی باتوں کی توقع نہیں تھی۔ ختنہ کا حکم اللہ کی کتاب میں کہیں نہیں ہے۔

[@xenium535]

آپ نے جتنی چیزیں گنوائی ھیں وہ سب بڑھتی رہتی ھیں جیسے بغل کے بال وغیرہ ۔ جبکہ ختنے والی جلد مردوں کے ساتھ آتی ھے وقت کے ساتھ بڑھتی بھی نہیں ھے۔

[@tanveermughal3935]

03:22

[@smshafique9873]

An expert doctor may explain this phenomenon 🙏

[@muhammadfawwadkhan1014]

شعوری طہارت ختنہ سے کس طرح حاصل ھوتی ہے کیونکے جس بچے کی ختنہ ھوتی ھے اس کے پاس شعور نہیں ہوتا ہے۔؟

[@WaheedKhan-ig1fg]

Ghamidi sb, please comment Jis bachay ka kia jatha hai us se tho pocha bhi nai jatha jab k app koran bhi un ke shok se on ko ifz karanay ke haq main hain

[@chachapaki123]

to jab bacha bara ho jay to tab khud karwa lay jab shaoor aa jay , waysay shaoori taharat sub cheezoon kay baray main kahi thi jaysay hair etc

[@rehanmajid2115]

Assalamualaikum bhai apka buhat axah sawal hy lkn m apko clear karta chalon k Ghamdhi sahab ne jo shaori taharat ka zikr kia hy wo baat fard ka zaati shaor numaya nhi karti blky wo baat insaano ka shaori taharat ko numaya karti hy masllan .bachay k sar k baal katy jaty hyn tu bachay se pocha nhi jata blky insaan khodh fesla karty hyn....k kab bachey ko badan ki taharat ki zarorat hy ..or kab nihlaana kab nijasat se taharat ki taraf lana hy .... Hope you understand brother....👋👍❤️

[@Zainimrankhan7]

@muhammad fawad Khan Until you are adult decision are made by parents. So if a child needs operation parents sign the consent form. So legal shaoor is used by parents. This rule applies in all the countries.

[@jinmanzur4749]

@@Zainimrankhan7 in law too.consent of the minor is invalid. For any act if a minor gives his or consent it is not validated only by substantiating it with the consent of the guardian or parents

[@zahmed7]

Dear Honorable Ghamdi sb..u are a learned individual and cognitively well equipped to entertain queries of variant nature, but in this particular topic it could had been a better reply to simple mention in response to the question that" I donot know the answer' ..only ALLAH is all knowing...circumcision is not proved a legal act from Quran or Sunnah , it is a major surgery of sensitive nerve endings which has greater other purposes such as enhancing intimacy pleasure, providing stamina, contributes in control of late droplets, allows natural lubrication during intimacy, allowing vigor in multiple attempts in a short period to consecutively conduct intercourse. and various other benefits..it is only that we are in conflict with QURAN while observing this faulty practice (circumcision) whilst it is prohibited in HOLY QURAN to edit the 'KHALQ' design of ALLAH....kind regards Sir.

[@champ1007]

Please use common Urdu and few words to keep viewers engaged.

[@fjscan]

Would we ask all scholars to use the layman language, Stephen Hawkings, Ibn-e-Khuldun, Plato? We need to learn a few words and terms to learn from the wizards. Regards

[@youngcoder4721]

ghalazat lerkion main zyda jama hoti hai phr lerkion ka khatnay kuin hoty? Islam main lerkion ka khatny hoty thy liken Hindustan main lerkion ka khatun ko kabhi musalman badshahon ny allow nae kia.

[@sadaqat-ULLAH]

I was thinking about circumcision from long time and I came to the conclusion its because of the evolution of human body from homosapian and all those previous species of hairy humans. To keep them warm and safe in all weathers they needed body hairs, gradually when the evolved to humans their skin started losing hair and lastly some remained in armpits and down there. It left to civilised humans to clean. Similarly the forseskin on penis is the remnant of evolution which humans have been told to cut and clean. I think it makes sense. It's my observations.

[@DrAneesAhmad]

I am not convinced. The Penis is itself weak, without bone and unprotected in open A foreskin is nature's protected provision for the frontage of delicate penis. The circumcision was invented by man for sexual pleasures. And Quran Shareef doesn't support it.

[@akmalraja8326]

السلام علیکم استاذ محترم سر مونچھیں، زیر ناف اور بغلوں کے بال وقت کے ساتھ آتے اور بڑھتے ہیں جبکہ ختنہ میں معاملہ ایسا نہیں اور بعض فکر کے لوگ اس کو خلاف قرآن یعنی اللّٰہ کی بناںٔی ہوںٔی ساخت کو تبدیل کر دینے کے مترادف سمجھتے ہیں اور سورت النسا کی آیت سے استدلال کرتے ہے ان کو گمراہ کرکے چھوڑون گا ، ان کو آرزوؤں کے جال میں پھنساؤں گا ، ان کو سجھاؤں گا تو وہ چوپایوں کے کان کاٹیں گے اور ان کو سجھاؤں گا تو وہ خدا کی بنائی ہوئی ساخت کو بگاڑیں گے اور جو اللہ کے سوا شیطان کو اپنا کارساز بنائے تو وہ کھلی ہوئی نامرادی میں پڑا ۔ سورتہ النسا 119

[@mir491]

Circums is sunna

[@waqarkhanvlogs]

Mr. Hassan please let us know Ghamidi sbs opinion about khatna in countries where its legally banned. How to perform khatna in these countries? Government in these countries treat khatna as child abuse. Thank you

[@Rehan_khan60]

Khatana is not Allah's Order, not in Quran. you dont have to do it. Allah's orders are in the Quran ...anything from out side is not part of religion Islam.

[@mohammadzaki3274]

Where does it happen?

[@LondonerUK64]

Travel for 2 weeks holidays to nearest country or find a Muslim doc who can do privately

[@fjscan]

At the time of posting, I am the fourth person replying to your comment but I am unable to see the rest of the three comments. I tried unhiding them but they are unreadable? Can you view them?

[@smshafique9873]

@@Rehan_khan60 Muslims are also required to follow Hzt.Mohammad SAW.

[@everrightneverwrong7044]

Mere sawal ka bhi jawab dijye Yahoodi namaz padhte hain per Christian kyu nahi padhte?

[@fjscan]

Answered, in this talk (6:52 onward). St Paul gradually made all Divine laws (shari'ah) 'not applicable' for the modern day Christians.

[@everrightneverwrong7044]

@@fjscan thanks sir and who are you ?

[@LifeInNoMansLand]

In some western countries it is believed that its a barbaric act on children. Let them grow up and if they decide to circumcise then its their choice but taking that choice away from children is not fair. When they grow up and dont want to be circumcised then they cannot reverse the process. Can muslim males wait til they are 18 and then decide to get circumcised if the parents want to give their children this option? And in any case it is not an obligation but highly recommended? What is the view of Ghamidi center on that? Please clarify.

[@shahanjahan2368]

One would surely need to get an anesthesia procedure done before cutting off the foreskin, if he wishes to do it after he turns 18. It is very painful. Our parents deceive us into believing that it is a random checkup, which helps us gather the courage. Unimaginable to do it in consciousness, when we are adults, and we know the doctor saab is going to roast the foreskin...aaghhh🥶🥶

[@s.v.hussain435]

Bill Clinton is running a campaign for circumcision to be safe from AIDs. In usa every child born in a hospital is circumcised.

[@zubaair]

Vaccination, training, education also seem barbaric to children,, just ask any kid..

[@rashidshaikh1873]

Khatna makes a beautiful organ ugly.( thin, short,bent/ curved etc) reduce sexual pleasure and is the main cause of " excessive divorce" among the Muslims of Indian subcontinent and as such not desirable.(2) The need for doing surgery arise only in cases where the skin of the penis is not moving forward or backward and such cases are very very rare, one in thousands!. As such doing surgery in all cases in a routine way is not correct.( Recently,Sudan which is a Muslim country has done commendable job by banning khatne in their country.)

[@ghulammohiuddin6356]

سینٹ پال نے تحریف کی۔

[@johnnyenglish1264]

Ghamidi sir, your Urdu is very difficult to understand. Please use simple words. It's a humble request.

[@bigcatt859]

A simple question : How does he look like the prophet Muhammad ﷺ who is supposed to be a model for muslims? He is just a swimmer in the big ocean of Islam . Nobody remembers such swimmers for long . Don't distance yourselves from the roots of islam because of Mr Ghamdi's words .

[@zubaair]

Where is the question??

[@nomi374]

Bahi zara b app ki English nhi samaj ayi,urdu main byan ki jye

[@ALone1982]

ختنے کا اگر دین سے کوئ تعلق ھوتا تو لازمی قران میں ذکر ھوتا۔ یہ آل ابراھیم کی رسم لگتی ھے جیسے داڑھی رکھنا یا سر پر پگڑی وغیرہ رکھنا۔

[@tanveermughal3935]

ختنہ عملی نوعیت کا حکم ہے۔ اس کا قران میں بیان نہ ہونا کوئی عجب نہیں۔ یہ سنت کے ذریعے ہم تک پہنچا ہے۔

[@ALone1982]

@@tanveermughal3935 تو پھر یہ فرض نہ ھوا بلکہ سنت، یعنی افضل ھے لازمی نہیں۔

[@ahmadashraf5952]

@@ALone1982 کس نے کہا کہ یہ فرض ہے.. ختنہ سنت ہے.. اگر کوئ کافر نو مسلم بنتا ہے تو اس کو ختنہ کروانے کی ضرورت نہیں ہے..نو مسلم کے لئے ضروری نہیں کہ وہ ختنہ کرے.

[@arishsaeed1947]

What fetish do u have with pen. Picking and then putting it back. 10 times in 1 question, it’s irritating. Pls don’t do it.

[@mohsinbutt8890]

تو گویا آپ سنتے کم اور دیکھتے زیادہ ہیں

[@pascalwager4544]

Please don't ridicule people based on condition they might have. OCD, tourettes, ticks, there are many conditions not under control of the people. You think, it is irritating - you know who would be more irritated by it then you would be the person suffering from it!

[@SyedAli-yc1bd]

Allah subhanahu wa taala alazeem did not command His Rasool anything like that, therefore, ختان is not mentioned in alQuraan. However, history witnesses that it was invented by Firoun and imposed on both Egyptians and Hebrews alike. Christians did not adopt it but due to the influence of Bani-Israel in Arab it was declared a sunnah. St. Paul was invented to misguide people from the right path. May Allah guide you upon your request and stop you from spreading satanism.

[@DrAneesAhmad]

This is thoughtful and correct educated reply

[@rajahindustani6174]

یہودی کے طریقے کو سنت بتا رہے ہو اور بائبل سے مثالیں پیش کرتے ہو قران سے ثابت کریں

[@dilkushpanshe7233]

آپ کو کس نے کہا ہے کہ مسیحیوں نے ختنہ رد کر دیا ہے

[@kalimmalik1514]

Lol. Still stuck at circumcision.

[@psingh8018]

They were created by Allah that is religion , why created when not required that is science subject . Is that a genuine explanation by ghamidi? Common man it is purely running away from the fact.

[@Hidayah_Guidance]

phir nahate q ho pshab aur stool bathroom me q karne jate ho

[@saadfaridi8031]

Ghamdi صاحب کے پاس زائد کھال کا کوئی جواب نہیں ، وہ جواب سے مطمن نہیں کرسکے،

[@snacknadeem8587]

Kia bakwaas hay, اگر یہ اتنا اھم ہوتا تو قران میں اس کاحکم ضرور ہوتا۔۔ اس کا حکم صرف یہودیوں کی کتاب میں ہے جس کو مسلم بھی فالو کرتے ہیں ، ولن ترضی عنک الیھود حتی تتبع ملتھم۔۔ والی مصداق ہے یہ

[@shehzad9863]

حسن صاحب آپ سے گزارش ہے کہ ایک پروگرام سینٹ پال کی شخصیت پر بھی کریں جس میں اسکی مسیحی مذہب کے اندر ہونے والی تبدیلیوں کے ارتقاء پر روشنی ڈالی گئی ہو۔ شکریہ

[@dmxauthordmxauthor5298]

❤