Can You Beat Red Dead Redemption 2 With Only Throwables?

What's up guys! In today's video, I'll be seeing if I Can Beat Red Dead Redemption 2 With Only Throwables. Will I be able to do it? Let's find out.
TIMESTAMPS:
0:00 - Intro
0:34 - Chapter 1
3:44 - Chapter 2
8:58 - Chapter 3
15:00 - Chapter 4
19:32 - Chapter 5
22:23 - Chapter 6
26:50 - Outro
Music used in this video:
• Old Western Music & Co...
• Western Background Mus...
#canyoubeat #rdr2 #reddeadredemption2 #rdr #reddeadredemption #throwables

[@CJHaven]

If you enjoyed the video make sure to like and subscribe!

[@arunabhrakshit]

I actually never used throwables at all during my first playthrough, i didnt know you got health points by throwable kills. I might try this next time. And as always quality content, my friend!

[@CJHaven]

Yeah, I also used little to no throwables in my first playthrough haha. It was a pretty fun challenge, definitely a lot harder than the shotgun one but still. Thanks for watching!

[@theretrodude2010]

​@@CJHaven what Cornwall owns the trolley company in Saint Denis the wagon the train tho oil factory and probably a lot more

[@17PAT17]

I always tossed a stick of dynamite in the middle of the KKK rallies I came across

[@burpboy-]

so ur telling me that throwables have lifesteal? this is nuts

[@user-mu7yd2us8i]

How did you finish the mission the kings son?

[@Dylanlemieux22]

One of the only creators to fit the game in under 30 minutes

[@CJHaven]

Yeah! I was gonna include the epilogue but I decided to just release it as it's own video (it's most likely coming out this Wednesday). Thanks for watching!

[@Halogamething]

Well a gun is technically “throwing” bullets at enemies.

[@CJHaven]

It seems like you’ve found a loophole…

[@thisisnotachannel]

Nope... they are primed and fired... Totally different.

[@Halogamething]

@@thisisnotachannel let me believe

[@gekko9367]

Yet another banger! If you continue to put this much time and effort into each video I'm sure you'll be getting a way bigger audience in no time

[@CJHaven]

Thanks for the support! Hopefully that happens someday 👍

[@mandodo]

Dear CJ, You can't understant how hyped i'm for this. another Magic piece of MP4 content 🦕 Thank u for uploading. This makes my days better than usual :]

[@CJHaven]

I'm glad I'm able to make your day better with my videos! Also, sorry for the delay, KZbin took FOREVER to process the video... Nontheless, thanks for watching even if I'm a little late lol 👍

[@lilnuggit1088]

Man your content is amazing I’m proud of the work you have done for us man I’m happy for you good job

[@CJHaven]

Thank you so much! 😀

[@lilnuggit1088]

@@CJHaven no problem man your content make my day thanks

[@JammyGit]

You should have explored and picked up all of the free tomahawks in the game as soon as you got to Horseshoe Overlook. It would have helped before unlocking the Emerald Ranch fence 👍

[@CJHaven]

I didn't even know there were secret tomahawks lol. Thanks for the info!

[@JammyGit]

@@CJHaven No probs mate. There are also a load of throwing knives at the O'Driscolls camp in Cumberland Forest, I think it's called Six Point Cabin. That way you don't need the fence quite so badly.

[@13lueBomber]

Nothing like driving the coach off the cliff. Classic. 👌🏼 awesome RDR2 creators, I’ll be looking forward to the next!

[@CJHaven]

Thanks! There’s nothing quite like it. Speaking of my newest video, I actually just released it yesterday! Here’s the link kzbin.info/www/bejne/mKPIgKN9jKybpZo

[@rjgforex]

lol I loved when you drove the stage coach off the cliff with the women!!! too funny

[@CJHaven]

Thanks for watching!

[@Mohawk_Productions]

Yea that part turned me on……..oh………I meant

[@PrestonDaw]

I know this video came out months ago but when you just drive the wagon off the cliff at 4:18 just kills me 😂

[@CJHaven]

Definitely one of the best parts 😅

[@petere.9138]

For those scenes like the casino manager who takes you to the safe, you absolutely shouldn’t count those as a negative. If R* is setting the parameters of that task in such a way you can’t use one, then there’s nothing you can do. If you had the ability to swap, sure.

[@CJHaven]

I mean that makes sense. I'll definitely take that into mind when I start my next Can You Beat RDR2 video, thanks!

[@AlmostHunter]

Congrats on 2k!

[@CJHaven]

Thanks dude! Next is 3k 💪

[@izekio7076]

"he seemed nice" amazing! Also great video but I can't stop laughing at it

[@CJHaven]

I'm glad I was able to make you laugh! My next video should be dropping next week so stay tuned...

[@BasedGrandmasKitchen]

Shared with all my friends! I just found your channel and based off the production value I guessed you had 100k-1m subs but I just saw you only have 2k! you are criminally underrated like it should be a crime how underrated you are.

[@CJHaven]

Thanks man! I appreciate the support! I'll be making a lot more Red Dead content so stay tuned...

[@splaty2231]

bro did jimmy Brooke’s dirty💀

[@CJHaven]

You gotta do what you gotta do!

[@wyvernsden3385]

I always have fun when the girls are singing, but running them off the cliff was pretty funny.

[@letsplay2bros679]

Amazing video! So glad to see another RDR2 video. Keep up the good work and you will be massive!

[@CJHaven]

Thanks, I'm glad you liked it! I'm actually going to be doing a lot more Red Dead content so stay tuned...

[@thejuhlerofdk]

You must the first person I have come across that doesn't like the three women singing in the back of the wagon on the way to Valentine.. I think it's super neat and cute. Also if you go slow enough, you can hear one of them mess up and they all start giggling.

[@Saint_Foggy]

4:02 u don’t know how many times I intentionally failed that mission by destroying the wagon

[@CJHaven]

Same dude, same 😂 It's very relieving not gonna lie...

[@loganhall8326]

1. Quality video 2. Replied to every comment and just great channel interaction. Definitely earned a subscriber

[@CJHaven]

Thanks man, I’m glad you liked it! Yeah, I love keeping up with all the people who watch my videos. Thanks for subscribing 👍

[@TheEfficientWay]

Extremely extremely great job by the way your commentary and how you summed up the story, is what kept me entertained can’t wait till you reach 100 K I believe in you💪

[@CJHaven]

Thanks man! I appreciate your kinds words! I’ll get there someday 💪

[@lancebrotherton7589]

I feel like I've found a channel before it becomes a number 1 channel

[@CJHaven]

Maybe... 👀

[@FirstLovexLateSpring]

"we came across one of our gang members, micah bell. he seems like a pretty nice guy." 💀💀

[@StarShow777]

I just noticed why did your Dutch keep the sheriff’s badge all the way until chapter 6? Maybe he was the rat. Bro was working for the law the entire time 💀💀

[@CJHaven]

I just noticed that!!! That's pretty funny not gonna lie lol

[@Robyn2208]

Bro called our money guy "Stross"

[@CJHaven]

😂

[@Robyn2208]

@@CJHaven Damm actually got a reply, neat video

[@CJHaven]

Thanks dude! I'm glad you liked it.

[@BrownTrout1238]

You can definitely hear the confidence boost you had between then and now.

[@CJHaven]

Are you saying that I sound more confident in this video than I do in my newer videos, or the opposite? I definitely can tell that there's a difference.

[@laars2233]

Dude your so fucking underrated. I laughed my ass off!

[@CJHaven]

Thanks man! I'm glad I was able to make you laugh 😅

[@secluee]

love ur vibe cj keep it up bro!

[@CJHaven]

Thanks dude! More to come…

[@ianmierek7647]

"He seems like a pretty nice guy" if only

[@CJHaven]

😔

[@17PAT17]

When you drove the wagon off the cliff for some peace and quiet I died hahaha

[@CJHaven]

Definitely one of the best parts of the video 🤣

[@sword0115]

16:55 is too true

[@CJHaven]

It's the sad truth...

[@kuvxwbmas62]

I think if they added the stone hatchet from gta into red dead (I the meant same mechanics) a melee only challenge would probably be possible

[@CJHaven]

I think I'm actually going do that for my next Can You Beat RDR2 video. Hopefully it wont be super hard but I'm thinking it's going to be...

[@Prettydecentdog]

Actually you don't have to use your knife in the bear hunting mission in Dead eye if you put your stick to the left right front or back impress x you can dive out of the way of the bear and it won't tackle you

[@CJHaven]

Good to know!

[@acompletelynormalhuman6392]

21:03 honestly I was expecting him to say "Hotchkiss revolving Canon"

[@CJHaven]

I really should've not gonna lie haha.

[@lexinicole4317]

The KZbin algorithm finally doing its job and recommending amazing small channels with quality content. Thanks for the video! Problem with all RDR2 Challenges is R* loves to lock you into forced gameplay, but hey, that isn’t your fault. I appreciate seeing you try the run anyway lol!

[@CJHaven]

I'm glad you liked it! Yeah, RDR2 is very strict when it comes to its missions which got pretty annoying at some parts... Nonetheless, it was a pretty fun challenge! Thanks for watching 👍

[@Mohawk_Productions]

The KZbin algorithm seems to have days when it’s working and days when it’s not. But this is a sick sick channel and loving it. Dudes going to hit 10k at some point As a small channel myself I enjoy watching others so I can get tips and just enjoy content

[@CJHaven]

@@Mohawk_Productions Thanks man! I appreciate the kind words 😁

[@Mohawk_Productions]

@@CJHaven No worries friend

[@jaythatguyyouknow5135]

You spoke I’ll of Saint Lenny and now you must be haunted by the ghost of Author until you pour out a handle of whiskey on the bridge in Strawberry while riding Eagle Flys horse.

[@CJHaven]

NO 😫

[@jaythatguyyouknow5135]

@@CJHaven I don’t make the rules, just help enforce them. I left a gift under your pillow for Arthur to find.

[@CJHaven]

@@jaythatguyyouknow5135 I wonder what it could be… I’ll guess I’ll have to find out for myself.

[@TheLastBeanCan]

If you get a tomahawk before the hosea mission with bear you can equip it can kill it

[@CJHaven]

Really?! I wish I would’ve known this before I made this video lol.

[@TheLastBeanCan]

Yeah my friend found it out and skinned the bear before the end of the mission and hosea was rambling about how bear

[@ThyFemurbreaker]

"He seems like a nice guy." 10+ hours later, "Micah's a bad guy?"

[@CJHaven]

Shocking 😱

[@ThyFemurbreaker]

A shocker indeed.

[@noahlopezgaming3114]

Arthur was actually looking at the sunrise at the end.🤓😬

[@user-nb5wk2zr7n]

This guy is awesome. He reminds me of Dante ravioli and Dante’s friend rocombasco

[@CJHaven]

Thanks! I haven’t watched Dante ravioli in a while but he seems like a pretty cool guy!

[@stormwinther4319]

really great video, although you should work on your delivery in some cases. keep up the hard work and you'll be a big creator in no time

[@CJHaven]

I'm glad you enjoyed the video! Also, thanks for the feedback, there's always room for improvement 👍 A new video should be dropping next week so stay tuned...

[@adammcbride725]

Micah the rat such a nice guy

[@elliotgrondahl870]

at the misson when you watch colm oldriscoll hang you can pick up the rifle fast and pucnch him asleep

[@CJHaven]

Really?! I’m gonna have to try that out!!!

[@Compvr8]

I love ur comedy bro got me dying laughing I’m sending this vid to all my friends keep up the good work my man

[@CJHaven]

Thanks man! I appreciate the support 😁 I have a new RDR2 video coming out soon so stay tuned!

[@Compvr8]

@@CJHaven Les goo

[@damienthetexasian6827]

Sadie, Charles and Emmet Granger pull off a Quickdraw with throwing knives, why cant Arthur?!

[@CJHaven]

I know right?! Life isn't fair...

[@angelus-sx8tf]

The second time he used a gun was a cut scene and he had no other option

[@Polish710]

I can't imagine how hard this would be keep up the good work man👍

[@CJHaven]

It was definitely VERY hard so I appreciate it!

[@thisisnotachannel]

Long as you have the HOMING TOMOHWAK? Sure can... long as you don't count the parts where you're literally forced to use firearms... which you definitely shouldn't count. Hosea, Shawn, Lenny, and all the others? If those places do indeed exist in the RDR2 universe? Then they went to HELL, no doubt. And ummm... "impressively" is a very common word in our language.

[@gameingbong0]

I haven’t finished the video yet but it really good so far, you earned a sub

[@CJHaven]

I'm glad you're enjoying the video! Thanks for the sub 👍

[@nucleartopics2040]

you commentate rdr2 so well, loving the videos

[@CJHaven]

Thanks! I appreciate the kind words 😃

[@tthejs6333]

Top tier content keep it up man!!!

[@CJHaven]

Thanks, I appreciate it! A new video should be dropping next week so stay tuned...

[@MYSTERYGAMING723]

In chapter 3 when he shoots the sheriff the shotgun is the weapon that he uses

[@flckrs]

Your channels gonna blow up bro I needa start me one like this lol

[@CJHaven]

Thanks dude! I hope so 😁 If you do end up making a channel like mine, I’ll definitely check it out!

[@zacharyrodgers693]

You are probably not gonna see this but I think you should try to beat rdr2 with only a cattleman revolver

[@CJHaven]

Thanks for the idea! I'll definitely take it into consideration 👍

[@ZacZactherock]

He seems like a nice guy lol😂😂

[@diss_dkb]

I laughed out loud so many times during this video

[@CJHaven]

That makes me so happy! I’m glad I was able to make you laugh 👍

[@zenzei2847]

HOWDOES HE NOT HAVE MORE SUBS THHIS IS THE BEST VIDEO OF MY LIFE

[@CJHaven]

Thanks man! I appreciate it 👍

[@user-zr6cm6hm6h]

You said that you cannot use guns to kill or DAMAGE your foes in anyway. Hitting someone with a gun is damaging them. You failed the challenge. Bty nice video, love it.

[@AussieFerret1]

Did you make a discord account yet ( also another Great video)

[@CJHaven]

Thanks man! No, I haven't made one yet, I'm waiting until I get a lot more subscribers so I would get a good amount of people to join.

[@cookieman42069]

I have a question about how how you got through the charles hunting mission in the first chapter, since you dont have a throwable nor can punch or kick deers.

[@CJHaven]

You actually can punch and kick deer. You just need to be quick enough..

[@Satiredbastard]

Another great video 📹 keep it up! 💯

[@CJHaven]

Thanks! I'll be doing a lot more Red Dead content so stay tuned...

[@vengeance6850]

0:41 “he seems like a nice guy” 😢

[@CJHaven]

Little did we know...

[@Sopranos990]

Please make more rdr2 videos challenges like this

[@CJHaven]

I actually have another one coming out either this Wednesday or next Wednesday so stay tuned!

[@Sopranos990]

@@CJHaven I just looked at your channel and you make good content for a small KZbinr, I expected hundreds of video and a few million/thousand subscribers but after seeing how small you were in comparison to these other rdr2/challenge KZbinrs I’m subbing. You really work hard but get no subscribers but loads of views. I hope you get big you earned a sub my friend Edit: I just realised I have seen your shotgun challenge and rope bridge short and I remember thinking “this guy is good at making videos” anyways I thought I would mention that (I also fell asleep to your videos 😅 not in a bad way though it was late and I was sleepy)

[@CJHaven]

Thanks dude! I appreciate the kind words. I spend a lot of time perfecting my videos so it's awesome to see that people enjoy them. Yeah, 10,000 subscribers is my goal for the end of the year so hopefully we can do it! Lol, that's awesome. I got a couple of other comments saying that they watched my shotgun video. I've been pretty busy recently which is why I haven't been able to upload anything besides shorts. After today I should be able to get back into the swing of things! Stay tuned...

[@Sopranos990]

@@CJHaven yeah that video blew up with i believe 230k views, the algorithm blessed you but I wish they viewers subscribed as you put out more effort and work than most KZbinrs with loads of subscribers. I hope one day you become big and blow up as a content creator as you deserve more subscriber ps than some people with millions

[@Sopranos990]

@@CJHaven I hope you reach that goal by the end of this month. Good look on your goal though

[@dagobahstudios3662]

Charles liked that

[@ProMeader98]

You got my like just for the red dead online joke 😂

[@CJHaven]

Thanks man! I'm glad I was able to make you laugh. A new video should be dropping next week so stay tuned...

[@goodie2goodie1]

Swear youtube is listening to me, I literally talked-about this with a friend.

[@CJHaven]

You did?! That’s crazy lol.

[@sirdumb4sure305]

The guy holding bill hostage in Rhodes can be spared if you shoot the gun

[@CJHaven]

The game automatically gave me a shotgun so I sadly couldn't... I could've just restarted the mission but I was already so far ahead so I decided not to.

[@Mr.gunslinger1]

0:40 well that is you first mistake

[@CJHaven]

I should've known...

[@Mr.gunslinger1]

😂😂

[@anthonymccole5389]

18:35 Hosea dies 🕊🕊🕊

[@CJHaven]

R.I.P 🫡

[@BoysGeeloor-fi6gc]

John wick ah video

[@exvxty]

Its me again and lets just say this vid was a banger (its still loading I have bad internet lol)

[@CJHaven]

Thanks man! I hope you like it/I'm glad you liked it 👍

[@Kondricts]

When you go hunting for the bear with Hosea, you can jump to just get hit by the bear, then it leaves you alone :). Take 1 of the score

[@CJHaven]

Oh really?! Thanks for the tip! I wish I would’ve known that when I was making the video 😅

[@tristanthurlow2633]

Anything throwable if you think about it, the guns throw bullets out of their chambers

[@CJHaven]

Good point… 🤔

[@archiestanfield9733]

Video idea?: if not already then maybe try and beat RDR2 with just a bow

[@CJHaven]

That’s not a bad idea… I may have to do that eventually. I’m currently making a MASSIVE red dead video, but after that I’ll definitely do it if most of you guys would like me to of course 👍

[@anwarbojorges]

I made my Arthur part Assassin so throwing knives and the bow were my weapons on stealth and in general

[@CJHaven]

That's awesome!

[@Ice_wolf2k]

Colms hanging moment

[@CJHaven]

😂

[@criminalmind27]

very cool vidro with a touch of humour :) keep it up

[@CJHaven]

Thanks dude! I appreciate it. A new video should be dropping in the next week or so, so stay tuned 👍

[@definitelynotaskinwalker]

Bullets are basically being thrown at your enemies

[@alfiewarbuton5676]

Im proud to say i beat the game with only the basic weapons you get in chapter 1 without cleaning them. I forgot you could purchase guns and i thought i had to find them

[@CJHaven]

That’s pretty funny lol. Thanks for watching!

[@alfiewarbuton5676]

@@CJHavenlol love you bro keep up the good work ❤

[@pavlenikolic69420]

Amazing video

[@CJHaven]

Thanks!

[@krazycanon]

Great video man keep it up!!

[@CJHaven]

Thanks! I put a lot of work into this video so I'm glad you guys like it.

[@marioinfiniti4025]

Its s-o sad that Arthur died bc they spend lots off time on his model but atleast John didnt die

[@CJHaven]

Yeah… R.I.P

[@annamorrissey8518]

In chapter 2 try shooting the guard who had john hostage in the leg technically you wouldn't be killing them

[@CJHaven]

Thanks for the tip!

[@R_Null]

Well Lenny atleast made it on the train

[@CJHaven]

Yup.

[@humanwow5848]

22:02 this one made me laugh

[@RyanDavis-om2ve]

14:55 I love these jokes

[@CJHaven]

I’m glad!

[@RyanDavis-om2ve]

@@CJHaven keep them up

[@SneakyDiggler]

You should do some rdr2 online stuff too

[@CJHaven]

I was actually thinking of making a Red Dead Online video in the future… stay tuned!

[@jakecrady1505]

not the horse shitting right in the camera 9:37

[@CJHaven]

😅

[@FANTA6441]

0:53 1:07 1:50 2:39 3:31 me explaining chapter 1 of rdr2 to my little brother

[@CJHaven]

Straight to the point… I like it!

[@skull....]

When you use you fist to "kill" your enemy it just knocks them out so you never kill anyone with a blunt weapon

[@CJHaven]

Yeah, unless you keep stomping on their head... Who would ever do that though? 🤔

[@randomyoutubeuser3918]

That must be pretty hard.

[@CJHaven]

Some parts were easy, most were hard. Especially that STUPID hot air balloon part…

[@deadlegs187]

Bret riverboat.... Knife man.

[@CJHaven]

What's a Bret riverboat?

[@talenouderkirk4675]

What kind of horse were you using

[@CJHaven]

I do believe that it’s the pre-order bonus horse.

[@fuklnord]

Bro said when you lasso people off their horse they die for SOME reason💀

[@CJHaven]

😅

[@Rdr2maniac]

Ranking my fav chapters 8. Epilogue pt1 7. Epilogue pt2 6. Chapter 5 5. Chapter 3 4. Chapter 1 3. Chapter 6 2. Chapter 4 1. Chapter 2

[@CJHaven]

Pretty similar to mine!

[@Rdr2maniac]

Nice! I know some people hate chapter 1 but I genuinely think it's really good. It's almost magical, the fact that your introduced to the gang members. And considering I never have snow in my country, I like it even more lol

[@dais3151]

the hate towards molly oshea 💔

[@CJHaven]

Deserved to be honest.

[@crimsongamer1226]

Good video but where was the hunting mission in chapter 1

[@CJHaven]

The entire mission consisted of me running around and kicking deer so I decided to cut it out of the video lol. Nonetheless, I’m glad you enjoyed the video!

[@Ponnes]

The first two kills can be avoided by disarming both the men with your deadeye

[@CJHaven]

Oh, really?! I wish I knew that beforehand lol. Thanks for the tip 👍

[@eliqueen4845]

You can use your gun can as a bashing weapon

[@CJHaven]

No, that was an accident but I decided not to count it since I technically didn’t shoot anybody. I’ll make sure to be more careful next time 👍