Classic figure skate sharpening fails

The skate's previous owner claims that it is impossible that the blades could be defective because they have always been sharpened at a well-known figure skating shop. His / her claim is probably based on the general belief that skate shops are sharpening professionals rather than on facts and know-how.
I would claim that the blades are more or less ruined by poor sharpening. Unlike the previous owner, my claim is based on measurements and literature, not belief.
www.iceskateolo...
www.iceskateolo...
www.iceskateolo...
www.iceskateolo...
Which one do you think is closer to the truth?