Classical Musicians React: 4MINUTE 'Hate' vs 'Crazy'

For the 73rd video of this series, classical music majors react to 4MINUTE’s ‘Hate’ MV vs ‘Crazy’ MV!
DEAR CLAMUS GOING TO KCON LA!!!!
if you want to see me there…at a panel…talking about myself, my channel, and my reactor friends…
Just make sure to mention ‘ReacttotheK’ when filling out this form ; ) docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FA...
THANK YOU AND I LOVE YOU AND I WILL HOPEFULLY SEE YOU THERE
also a clamu did let me know Skrillex produced Hate and I didn't know that when we filmed reactions so I didn't tell the reactors BUT I just told them in our group chat so we're good now.
ok back to the usual description info:
~Channel instagram: @reacttothek_official
~Support us on patreon and get extra access to videos you’ll never see on YT: / reacttothek
~Full Reaction Schedule:
docs.google.com/document/d/1u...
~THE FULL LIST OF MVs TO-BE REACTED TO: • Playlist
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Video editing by Umu
Thumbnail credit goes to Nozomi Murayama (insta: @nonchanyuzuru)
Subs done by Ash & Umu
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(PD) Umu:
Instagram and twitter: @_emcha_
KZbin (Kpop covers): EMCHA
Tumblrs: / kpop-instrumental-covers
/ omg-horns
/ bangtan-fanart
/ funny-vixx
(kpop, mamamoo, bts, vixx) Amino app: Umu @ ReacttotheK
(channel manager & assistant editor) Eric:
Twitter: @ricekangaroo
(Assist. filmer) Ash:
Instagram: @ashhfong
Snapchat: @ashleyfong457
Henry:
instagram: @zappa_yes_floyd_genesis
Twitter: @henry_carpender
Yunyi:
Tumblrs: / classic-jenny
/ beijingboi
Facebook: / classicjennycomics
Peyton:
Instagram and Twitter: @pjohnzzz
Jarod:
Instagram: @JVLPhotographic
and @Jarod_lau
Davis:
Instagram: @davisherndon9664
Kevin:
Twitter: @nerdymusicks
KZbin: nerdymusicks
Gwen:
Instagram and Twitter: @gwenpakerr
KZbin: Gwen Paker
Hugo:
Instagram: @hugohumbility
Shimon:
Instagram: @shimonohi
Ben:
Instagram: @ben.j.l.kronk
Naoki:
Instagram: @naokitoyomura
Lindsey:
Instagram and twitter: @lamusicstudio
tumblrs: / punk-popsicle
/ double-horn
Fiona:
twitter: @fiona_stout
Insta: @fionaastout
Emiel:
Fb: Emiel De Jaegher
Insta: @trumpetoats
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
*DISCLAIMER: I do not own any of the songs or videos being reacted to in this video. All credits to the companies that own them.
Also, none of us are PROFESSIONAL musicians. So if you come here for a strict breakdown/analysis of the music, you won’t be getting that.This is strictly my conservatory musician friends taking time in their schedule to watch kpop for fun, and throw in any musical comments that come into their mind! Also please do not complain about any "boring" reactions...some of the musicians have blank faces since they are concentrating so deeply on analyzing the music.

[@ReacttotheK]

yoo guys idk whether y’all are going to KCON LA or not but…if you want to see me there…at a panel…talking about myself, my channel, and my reactor friends… Just make sure to mention ‘ReacttotheK’ when filling out this form ; ) docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSc8rBuramsEsyzKpEpBym_gcK-0v-xSRU5tEezSE-PFaE9vEg/viewform THANKSSS Love, Umu

[@Michaela445]

ReacttotheK WHY AM I FROM A FAR FLUNG COUNTRY 😭

[@emirjaloudpangandaman7926]

ReacttotheK please react to blackpink as if it is your last. please

[@sanisinaga5192]

ReacttotheK react to sistar, wjsn or monsta x please 😭

[@rebelgami]

thank you so much♡ I'm 4Nia from Brazil hahhahhahha Love U☆♡

[@johnraymond9512]

ReacttotheK are you going to vlog when you go??

[@ShemaraFontes]

"they are dressed like they are about to fuck you up on the side of the street" *LMAO*

[@bencapps219]

Shemara Fontes "In a soft K-Pop way of course."

[@Mohmohguh]

Shemara Fontes ahahahah XD

[@krizziaperilla4735]

"I'm crazy about Crazy. But I didn't hate Hate." 😂😂😂 Damn it, Lindsay!

[@virginiojeon5546]

Kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk

[@watierahman6832]

She suppose to say I crazy about hate but i don't hate crazy 😂😂

[@laramiaizz]

@@watierahman6832 no, if you say you don't hate any song, it means that you don't really like it but you can tolerate it..which is not what she meant..

[@randomarmy7123]

@@watierahman6832 well literally the girl at 13:50 said it but yeah she hate crazy lol

[@itzclvhere]

4 minute disbandment was the most saddest thing in the world for me.

[@noraxo4654]

Hoseok'sManiManiMani IsLife I agree💔

[@duamandrade]

I discovered them the other day and then I saw all the comments i was like WHAT D: why did they disband?

[@ImaZaphod]

i'm still not over it but also 2ne1 both groups :(

[@strmpunchpridt.4217]

Same 😭

[@Myhalamanz]

There's people dying, kim..

[@kurlykpopfan8111]

I love how they appreciate the uniqueness of the drop in "Hate". Most people were unsatisfied, but they liked how different it was. They reacted similarly to how I did 😊💕

[@arikasandemore6221]

Seventeen & BTS are my lifeu I actually know only these two songs so far but I like Hate even more :D

[@miabarron4102]

Seventeen & BTS are my lifeu I love how this song drops

[@muhamadzahier8401]

Seventeen & BTS are my lifeu me too..when i first heard the song i was like "meh..."and then Boom "WTFFF is thissss...i love it😍"

[@ggia4258]

Skrillex did a great job with it :)

[@sinistermusicdestiny6768]

The HATE drop is the best drop. And THAT is how you react to it.

[@vijayendrawairokpam4914]

SinisterMusicDestiny it had to be since Skrillex made it.

[@Jvzz_]

really?? skrillex? damn i had no idea

[@t1m3fl0w]

And second sound like Boss Mode by Knife Party :D

[@virginiojeon5546]

YESSSSSS

[@artoriasoftheabyss1575]

And people love shitting on Skrillex because "he doesn't make real music" And here you have Classical Musicians admiring different forms of music. Edm + Kpop= Unstoppable

[@Becca11389]

honestly Crazy is one of the best k-pop songs of all time

[@nojolie]

RogueARK25 i totally agree!!

[@pamelagot7730]

RogueARK25 agree

[@nojolie]

Honestly I think its THE best

[@lych3e]

It's iconic

[@jhonmichaelberina8960]

I was like.. what's wrong with knetz? It's a bop song..

[@AmberSweetPea]

It's ironic they seemed to all like/appreciate Hate more, when a big reason why they broke up was because Hate couldn't match Crazy's success. I always thought Hate was underrated........it was a brilliant piece of work, and while I disagree with their opinions on Crazy(that song is dope af and I'll listen to it any fucking where, any fucking time!), I love how that one duo acknowledged the awesomeness of Hate!

[@whydoineedaname11]

@@Zedvais 4Minute said they would disband is Hate didn't do well by whatever standard Cube set. They made it clear their contract renewal depended on Hate's success.

[@ketphish]

Amber Sweet Pea! :3 the fact that i always prefer hate more than crazy since the first time i listen to it

[@CrowsRevenge1]

They may have won more shows with Crazy but they were still trending downwards. If you look at their sales, Crazy was still a good ways from there best selling albums and was part of an overall sales decline. The fact that Hate flopped was just the final nail in the coffin. For Cube, it made much more business sense to try investing in a new group and keeping Hyuna on board than trying to renegotiate with what was on paper, a past the prime group. There is a reason almost every KPOP group, especially GG, tend to break up after the contract expiration.

[@J2Jaholic]

Back then most people criticized Hate for sounding similar to Crazy. I really liked Hate when it came out and would jam to it almost everyday but I do remember K-netizen was not having it.

[@imgroot6831]

imagine if this song is released now instead

[@imaangy]

Lmao "it's a slow paced break up song"

[@YasMean]

soooo I just realized I have a very specific style of K-pop I like and ... all my favorite girl groups are gone. this album was so damn good.

[@Moon-hr2xh]

Yas Mean You should check out Jimin Park - Take Me Home MOLA - Chillin

[@blackjack2ne143]

Yas Mean Same 😭💙❤ Act7 😍👌perfect

[@stefanodirella2076]

Damn true, same here. And male groups too. Probably because they are more edgy? I don't know

[@azegagyoureanoldman9603]

What about f(x),snsd and red velvet?

[@stefanodirella2076]

Fortunately they are still active, and Blackpink too. Pheeew

[@ladychang2790]

My favourite thing is when collectively the whole squad gets so hype and into the music. It's not often that everyone will all like a song/type of music and tbh I didn't expect y'all to love 4Minute as much as you did. I've been waiting for this reaction for MONTHS and so into the fact that everyone was so into it. Also always appreciating how attentive you guys are in remembering other Kpop songs you've reacted to and tings

[@DCPetterson]

That is good but it sucks that women are ALWAYS judged by how sexual they are. These kids either like of hate girl groups and girl songs exclusively on their own personal feelings on if a group is too sexy or not too sexy or not sexy enough or not the correct type of sexy. No mention of dancing. No mention of the rapping. When asked about the singing the response was either idk good? or wasn't really listening lol. It's just sad imho

[@ReacttotheK]

DCPetterson no one's perfect my friend. it's hard to pay attention to MV/singing/instrumentals/melodic content all at once.

[@tobyvanbaast3800]

the best reaction video sofar

[@nikitakashyap1979]

I wish Korea had appreciated 4M more. Especially Hate since it was an awesome song.

[@quinn6895]

😢💔

[@minatozakisanachewie5924]

Koreans are more into cute they dont like that much this kind of songs specially the lyrics i think they are more on positive/cheerful songs

[@mizzymsp]

@@minatozakisanachewie5924 don’t lie they ate up crazy and fuckin ADORED 2NE1 and bigbang

[@user-xr5ms4vf3z]

@@minatozakisanachewie5924 Ok. You are saying all the 'Nonsense.' :) Btw 4M is considered as a legendary group in Kpop so far.

[@michaelanthony4356]

@@minatozakisanachewie5924agree.. thats why Twice is very popular.

[@analuiza5792]

it really upsets me that hate did badly in korea and after its release 4minute disbanded, that's my favorite song from them

[@shinco193]

Me toooo

[@minecrraftunicorn]

"nothing like a fine woman in a big ass sweater"

[@mistertadakichi]

Andrea ˊᗜˋ WISDOM

[@marcelafranklin2429]

Andrea ˊᗜˋ accurate

[@CandyNunu]

I yelled 'PREACH!' at the computer

[@steph7809]

I agree

[@MUVAMILK]

i was like same

[@FromGroundUp1]

Correct me if I'm wrong but I remember 4minute's song "Hate" was produced or co-produced by Skrillex. Thus the Skrillex-y vibe to the song.

[@4minutesleft544]

FromGroundUp1 yup! 😊

[@KatStawp]

Jepp, It WAS!!!

[@Dennis2001ify]

same with crazy right?

[@rosietales]

Nakawala Simwanza no it was just hate

[@shatteredshards8549]

I kept waiting for Umu to tell them, especially when they made the Skrillex joke.

[@user-fx3bn7fx4n]

이 분들 되게 박자 바뀌고 조 바뀌고 이런 거 좋아하시는구낰ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ꺄아아아ㅏ 하고 반응하는 거 너무 웃기고 귀여워ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@londontadpole5064]

4minute and 2NE1 were the only bad ass kpop group but now they are all gone. I was 4nia for 8years, and strugglinh to dream of my girls are bringing me new teasers.............. miss 4minute.

[@mazlinmazlan6023]

😭🙏

[@luthientinuviel101]

yes i miss them too

[@mehzz864]

No worries there is a group called CLC with a badass concept. Since they are in the same company as 4Minute (used to be) the similarities are noticable.

[@veelite264]

@@mehzz864 yeah, clc is my last resort now since i lost 2ne1 and 4 minute

[@kb-ih7ni]

mehzz Though no one can fill the 4M and 2NE1 holes in kpop, CLC came close when they finally came back with Goblin hahaha

[@nct666]

Hate was produced by Skrillex, probably why she heard a Scary Monsters and Nice Sprites sample

[@t1m3fl0w]

Skrillex

[@danibarnayha]

Lindsey: This is how you do a hype song! IKKKKRRRR

[@ARMYsince2015]

'They're dressed like they would actually f*ck you up on the side of the street, but like in that really soft kpop way.' - Peyton 2017 This shit had me dying because it's so accurate for so many kpop groups 😂 😂 I love you guys. Umu, thank you for making this possible. P.S. Kevin, I totally agree with you about this being better than Boombayah (No hate on BP).

[@srijayasalim3608]

"It is like the booty is crawling at you" LOL BEST COMMENT EVER

[@Untitled-bf4ez]

Queens of Kpop, miss them a lot😭😭

[@shellycarter1691]

same, love that they reacted to it, still makes me sad.

[@MiltonLeite10]

I can't see this and don't fell bad :'(

[@gumdeo]

😢

[@kimebina2586]

"That was too much ass" Me: " Do u not AMERICA?"

[@babykitti3]

Yeah that was what confused the crap out of me like... have u seen any of the western artists mv or what?!?! XD

[@dairymilkz95]

Maybe he was comparing to all the other K-Pop MVs they've seen. This would definitely be a ton of ass XD

[@kimebina2586]

dairymilk95 maybe lol..ig... *cough cough JAY PARK MOMMAE* 😂😅

[@babykitti3]

Kim Ebina LOL but most fans consider jay parks stuff to be more american and westernized music than kpop songs to begin with 😂😂

[@TonalliGb]

Thought the same thing haha

[@KatStawp]

"They're not trying to be feminine at all..." She's talking about one of Korea's current sex symbols xD (I like that.)

[@luthientinuviel101]

Hyuna has a sexy concept yeah

[@tolerance711]

so late but i read this exactly when she was saying that omigooo XD

[@qraee]

LMfao I SNORTED WHEN SHE SAID THAT

[@fenty2331]

an introvert with taste sameee

[@tmaqvdxdba]

When they released Crazy and Hate, I thought they would make it really big. Like, finally, I could find mature and addictive songs that I can throw my mood on a swing and turn it into a roller coaster. The day I learned about their disbandment, I was literally sad for days :(

[@basicsince5620]

Me too. I’ve liked them since high school, but I really loved this new sound. I happy to see Hate loved like this because it didn’t seem like many liked it.

[@kookie2910]

Me too

[@tabloharuxx693]

7:20 "this is nothing like K-pop that I have ever seen" oooooh boy you sure have not seen everything

[@2ne1queens89]

Makes me miss 4minute 😭😭

[@kimiya1509]

2NE1 QUEENS SAME AND I LOVE YOUR NAME

[@kalinaxiong2763]

2NE1 QUEENS same

[@Navy_ShiningGold]

Hate가 한국에서는 진짜 저평가된 노래인데.. 처음 나왔을때 별로라고 그랬는데 다른 나라 사람들이 이렇게 좋다고 해주고 심지어 전문적으로 공부하는 사람들이 좋다고 하니 되게 신기하고 뭔가 뿌듯.

[@thecookie390]

"there's nothing like a fine woman in a big ass sweater" 😂😂😂

[@JessBreen]

Ooo would love to see un-edited reactions of these ones

[@lockey13yuuya86]

If you are one of the patreon donators, you could watch i advance and full reactions. I'm not a donator though, sadly I can't watch unedited reactions of them either.

[@flylightlvia2181]

That's gonna be cool

[@JessBreen]

LocKey13 YuuYA The unedited reactions go in order by upload date, so they are only up to BTS Prologue (with the one exception of Ailee) so unless there is another exception, this unedited reaction won't be up for a while.

[@ericgruber]

The phrygian lick in the chorus of Hate (and also boombayah) is in the mode known as phrygian dominant. It's actually the mixture of what both Yunyi and Kevin say in the video: It's the ionian mode (natural minor scale) with a flat II and a raised/major III. A lot of eastern music is based on this mode, as well as some spanish flamenco. For some examples, you can check Lecuona's classical guitar standard Malagueña, Dick Dale's turn on Misirlou, some of the soloing in Megadeth's Holy Wars and, in K-POP, I think most of the songs with a heavier eastern feel are based on phryigian dominant rather than standard phryigian, such as, again, Boombayah, 2ne1's I am the best, Yezi's Anck-su-namun, and so forth. Hope it helps you guys. And thanks so much for the videos. It's helping me a lot with understanding music theory.

[@heyiyay]

Can you pretty please do CLC Hobgoblin vs Blackdress? 😏

[@hatershate7066]

Riza Ruiz they won't react to black dress

[@biteass953]

Riza Atraje Vocal:Black dress Dance:black dress Rap:Hobgoblin Visual:Black Dress

[@riceboy922]

포미닛만의 컨셉 진짜그시대에 독특하면서 좋았는데 뭔가 대중들에게 인기끌기에 항상조금씩모자랐다고해야되나? 항상 뭔가아쉬웠음ㅠ 제발잘되기를 진짜 바랬었는데 결국 해체해서 너무 아쉬웠다는 특히 포미닛은 현아만떴지만 메보가진짜 아쉬움 . . 보컬,피지컬 다되는캔데 진짜

[@vicky2525diva]

Oh shit I'm hella early! So sad that they disbanded though, CRAZY was played on repeat.

[@ShionHiponVT]

Moment when the song they liked flopped in Korea.

[@quwandathornton]

For REAL!? WOW.

[@Nhaunderstood]

RagdollAngelcat BTS yes it is flopped, apparently because it's weird. Once again, good music left underappreciated :(

[@pandabear9613]

a lot of the kpop songs that do well for American audiences don't actually appeal to the Korean masses and end up flopping

[@kyrrahlee788]

like really? these are my two fave songs...

[@ndbee-ha1466]

yup, korean doesn't really like this type of song.(they tend to cute girlish concept). and, these two songs are loved by international fan, but not korean. just like the song by clc called 'hobgoblin'. it doesn't do well in korea. -sorry for my bad english

[@mariannejackyloubaysa3174]

"thats how u make a hype sing. u dont make it hype the whole time" love it cuz it def. says it all!!! slay 4minute 2019 and we still miss u

[@kookie2910]

Now 2021 and i miss them soooooooo much

[@ikacapren5824]

This is the pride of 2nd generation of kpop😍

[@frances3266]

2nd generation was on another level. They brought new things on the game. Sadly tho theyre all gone. Is there gg from 2nd gen whos still there?

[@hafifihafiz7405]

@@frances3266 apink

[@joohyunthebabiest8203]

Frances snsd

[@fitriahardono9661]

"that was too much ass" watch jay park's mommae-

[@grimrhiper496]

all hail kingbin, mongbin, tigerbin & king of youth . Too truthful

[@nadiraali6109]

them being shocked at this makes me really want to see them react to jay park mommae or steller vibrato lol

[@sararojas9779]

Nadira Ali word on stellar I was thinking about that too

[@elfstarlight]

Nadira Ali they would be so shook by stellar but hopefully they understand that they are underrated LEGENDS

[@EliiVelez]

I think they're going to lose their shit at Vibrato

[@daddykronk9593]

The drop in HATE is so... funky, nasty, dirty, like something you’d just bust down to. And I love it. I’ve always been a fan of beats like that. I’ve replayed it so many times

[@pxmens9430]

I will be forever bitter that 4MINUTE's disbandment relied on Hate's success in Korea since Koreans don't seem to like strong girl crush concepts unless there's a hint of cuteness to it. -.- Also, I love the fact that all of you appreciated the beat drop in Hate. There was such a strong hate/love relationship for not only the fandom, but everyone else who listened to it.

[@multifandom5598]

"This is perfect" said every Kpop fan ever.

[@mr.alpaca382]

I FREAKING LOVE HENRY SO MUCH LIKE SRSLY "tOo mUCh aSs, sTOp" "They didn't just drop it, they AAAAAAH!"

[@bosgotnojams]

I remember back when Hate released I was so freaking hyped because it was just so freaking good that I would play it loud on repeat but didn't have anyone I know who appreciated it as much as I did. :(

[@UwU-lm9or]

this brought back memories from being a fan of kpop during 2nd gen which i totally felt lmaooo but hey at least more people are intrested though in kpop :D

[@erinbailey7940]

“There’s nothing like a fine woman in a big ass sweater” 😂😂 why is that line so iconic

[@dumxx]

Actually, Crazy was all the rage in shops and eateries here in my country when it first came out. You heard it everywhere. I guess it's difference in culture. Yay 4minute!! I was looking forward to this reaction. P.S. I freaked out when Boy Meets Evil played at the end... it's just one treat after another. :)

[@beepboop4833]

Which country is that?

[@undramaticfanofworld9862]

I wanna know which country it is too... My country doesn't even know Kpop at all!

[@SyndicateGila]

Hate produced by Skrillex

[@SyndicateGila]

Ahhh just read the description

[@ReacttotheK]

;D

[@SyndicateGila]

Sorrryyyyyyyyy

[@CottidaeSEA]

It's quite cool how he found the link even without being told that.

[@amanacer3088]

I'm 😭 I was just getting into Kpop so many of the girl groups were so cutesy then I found 4MINUTE and was like yes I love them literally the next day they announced they were disbanding.

[@Jam-cp6qp]

7:23 Henry: This is nothing like kpop that I have ever seen. Meanwhile me Me:This kind of concept turn me to a kpop fan HAHAHAHAHA Im obsessed of 2ne1 and Bigbang just saying

[@Angel-jc6mw]

HAHAHAHA same!

[@hallo9062]

"this is so awesome! what the hell?" EXACTLY GIRL

[@stanloona.pussies]

See 4minute in the Title starts crying i miss them sooooooo much 🤧❤️👏🏻

[@lilttiger]

both of these songs are some of my favorites ever omggggg

[@hanjisung7967]

“but i like it more than boombayah for sure” agreed.

[@Moon-hr2xh]

Jihyun - Will be in a kbs drama called "Best Delivery Man" Airing soon. Gayoon- In a movie "Drug Lord/King" will be released Next year Jiyoon- Wil have a comeback at 20th July and will have a 2 concerts in Japan Hyuna- Wil have a comeback soon, and performing in festival's with triple H Sohyun- Doing activities with fans and friends such as camping or festival's Please support these 5 queens and give the unconditional love.

[@MrBabylonandon]

Jiyoon has 4 songs on the Web. Solo's - I Do, and Magnet Collab with Samuel Seo - Cliche OST - Taken. She is a featured artist on another song on that same OST.

[@Moon-hr2xh]

MrBabylonandon I know I'm saying their current schedules

[@inmars2222]

MI what company jiyoon?

[@MrBabylonandon]

Wanting to make sure folks know about her singles - especially TAKEN as it just came out - pretty good tune.

[@Moon-hr2xh]

mrs nobody 8888 jiyoon is in JS E&M entertainment. That company is filled with actors and actresses. She is the first singer in the company

[@labyrinthdrmr]

2NE1 disbanded (my ultimate bias group 😥), 4Minute disbanded, WHERE ARE MY BADASS FEMALE KPOP GROUPS?!?! I WANT THEM BACK! It feels so good seeing you guys appreciate them! PS. Please, PLEASE have them react to 2NE1 live performances! PLEASE!

[@parkbomsteponme]

Multifandom Dreamer I feel the same way. 2NE1 and 4Minute are my favourite groups because of the girl crush, bad ass concepts that they had and both groups are so talented.

[@IAM-yj6xr]

Now we have the next generation version of them (BLACKPINK & CLC)

[@labyrinthdrmr]

No Jam Bros got no Jams CLC, with HyunA's help, are really doing 4Minute's concept justice. However, I can't claim the same for BLACKPINK - they aren't even trying to do it after all. The raw energy and charisma of 2NE1 is too hard to recreate

[@moonlitgalaxy5940]

Multifandom Dreamer i mean there's dreamcatcher but they're more k-rock

[@queenlin]

Multifandom Dreamer SAMMEE

[@sownflix3804]

This is the one that cube wasted? YES.

[@ciethelight8266]

Shoutout to Yunyi for saying “black culture inspired” yes girl 😂

[@LauKungPow]

I didn't expect the gang to enjoy Hate as much as they did. I'm pleasantly surprised. Also Peyton's fucking hilarious EDIT: wait, Umu, you didn't tell them that Skrillex actuallu made Hate?

[@goldenj-hope4472]

Nope.. I waited for that intense part shifted to the dope ass beat. Their reaction was F*CKING PERFECT

[@buyan-erdenebatbaatar1513]

LauKungPow has

[@itsfnansyahmi4212]

React to pepe vs hobgoblin from clc peasee!! 😍

[@maddy5827]

ItsFnan syahmi oh shit YES

[@bres1809]

Noooo. Do a No Oh Oh vs Hobgoblin vs Where Are You?

[@serendiclipses6851]

Preferably with subtitles bc Pepe’s lyrics are a TREAT 👌🏼

[@Mangotropolis]

How did I miss this one? Well anyway, watching in 2019 I was waiting for a while for you guys to react to this and I was nooooot disappointed. I expected these reactions and I'm so delighted. Love you all!

[@jisooyalove4842]

Now I miss 4minutes a LOT! 🥲

[@gabrielavianna272]

4minute volume up vs watcha doin' today!!!! Pleasee

[@lulux8078]

Yes please!

[@cubestanlight970]

Gabi YESS ❤

[@gayatrimantra_]

Yes please

[@MADJESTIC5]

yes please :)

[@zigzagzane5329]

volume up vs what's your name? would be better imo

[@cchh1]

Two songs really captured me and introduced me to Kpop. BTS's Dope and 4Minute's Hate, but Hate was the first to get me to listen to a kpop song repetitively. I mean South Korea blasted 4Minutes music over the border to North Korea. 4Minute is iconic! 🙌🏽

[@cubestanlight970]

CHL. The North Korea thing Is that true? 😅

[@j134679]

CUBE stan yes they regularly do it. Other popular kpop songs are used in their playlist too

[@Moon-hr2xh]

CUBE stan They blasted HuH which literally the whole point of the song is saying "We will do what we want!" "You can't stop me"

[@cubestanlight970]

MI Like for real? Didn't they take any action?

[@cchh1]

CUBE stan no SK is pretty used to NK's hostile behavior (like decades worth of threats) plus at the time I think SK and NK have a type of "keep the peace" type of treaty, I think they still do. Where they agree not to attack one another or risk full fledge counterattacks. SK is at the greater threat to NK than the US but NK knows if they attack SK the US will come to their aide because of ally agreements.

[@stayuwutr1247]

OHHH came back here again to enjoy, 4 Minute was my bias group back in the days when they were still active

[@bulletproofdiamondwinstar9470]

This is the best reaction I've seen from this channel. I actually LOLed and had to go back to rewatch parts of the reaction!

[@dreajp]

I heard that they said if it didn't do well, they would disband but tbh, I don't see how this wasn't good enough.

[@honeybees160]

it did huge internationally, but in korea it was kinda a flop but korea is where it really matters so

[@Moon-hr2xh]

jessi it charted really well in korea but it wasn't promoted properly

[@rania4751]

Luscious Angel they weren't winning on music shows also

[@MiyusRibbons]

considering this isn't actually their final song that isn't at all true

[@mimsie496]

MiyusRibbons it was though

[@livlaughloveanime]

I did not expect them to love 4minute this much wow but I'm so glad they did. Also didn't Skrillex produce Hate?

[@rileyboo8615]

He did produce it

[@hptruefan]

Okay they HAVE TO react to Hyuna's Roll Deep now plEASE

[@afriend5107]

Their songs would have broke everything if it came in these days.

[@kookie2910]

Oh yeah

[@d1a2r3k4]

😩 I miss 4 minute so much. I honestly feel like they left such a big hole in the industry... They went out so strong which makes it so hard to let them go...even now in 2021😭.

[@RM-dd3yq]

So miss them😢 Any 4nia here?

[@cubestanlight970]

devid lio 😭😭

[@luxenlu8496]

Me! I Still miss them

[@liz_fm]

devid lio Me!!!! I miss them so much

[@queenkimhyuna4minute4niaa-47]

devid lio I do

[@broidk8910]

devid lio support Ji Yoon and Hyun A in their solo careers

[@thomasfrintzos8404]

They were true Queens and so huge internationally. So sad Koreans didn't follow them.

[@tannakota1846]

IK!!!! They were so fantastic and different and badass... it frustrates me so much sometimes how a lot of Korean culture doesn't really care for anything that isn't cutesy when it comes to female artists. They miss so many great things bc of it. 😔

[@inquisitvem6723]

my fav female kpop group of all time....kpop fans will regret years from now by not supporting them...especially koreans.

[@thomasfrintzos8404]

They were my fav too. Cube should focus on their international career. I hope for a reunion in the future :)

[@royvelvet7994]

Just found this channel and videos in the start of 2023. Where I've been.. Thank you, it's amazing!

[@Hannah-jj3ik]

[@wakeshimutanemahazunakunam819]

My heart grew when she called gayoon a Queen❤

[@ArrenHidalgo]

I just love how they liked it. I'm a 4nia ever since and they were the one who introduced me KPOP so I'm really proud of them! ♡♡♡

[@lulupain18]

Watching them get all hyped and enjoying the songs got me emotional since we will never get a 4minute song again. 😢

[@makhnolelong177]

I just discovered this channel via this video. The angle of classical musician is very interesting. The professional side is another good thing. Great job

[@xena4780]

THIS IS AMAZING!! I WAS SITTING AT THE DINING ROOM TABLE WATCHING THIS AND MY BROTHER SEES MY SCREEN AND ASKS WHICH ON IM WATCHING AND I SAID "THE 4MINUTE ONE" AND HE'S LIKE "OH WE'RE WATCHING THE SAME ONE" AHHH

[@moonlitgalaxy5940]

Xena THATS SO COOL!!!!'

[@iollankmurphy4496]

they'd probably love CLC hobgoblin

[@bres1809]

No Oh Oh vs Hobgoblin vs Where Are You? Pleasee

[@beatrixtsukino2581]

oh my moon yassss

[@MitreyK]

A P M AND "BLACK DRESS"

[@raimukoyoasu6636]

The HATE Drop is fuckin' mind-blowing, No one saw it coming. Man, that's literally my reaction first time listening to it.

[@sheiskate_]

React to 4MINUTE'S Volume Up and Mirror pleeeease! 4minute throwback would be great. hihi

[@sheiskate_]

And some live performance of Aileeeee! Hihi esp her performance/rendition of "Love that is too painful is not love" . And omg! SISTAR's I LIKE THAT and ALONE :))))

[@es.teh57]

70 views with 124 likes, youtube cant handle the epicness of 4minute XD

[@Gabzstopper]

Pretty sure skrillex produced hate, hence why I guess it's an appealing hype song

[@pil99]

Im still fcking sad hate wasnt successful enough for them to stay as a group

[@erikarios459]

YESSSSS

[@joshernandez4955]

This group is one of my favorite groups

[@nouranhalim180]

I'm in love with both songs ..this so dope

[@whalieneffect]

I'VE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS. I want to cry. I miss 4minute so much they will always be my forever ultimate girl group always a 4nia. and saying that Hate is one of your favourites thank you

[@vegasslawyer1921]

They should react to Hyuna’s songs,too.

[@IHMyself]

These two songs always give me chills, lol.

[@farah_felice]

I still love going back to this reaction video because it’s pretty epic

[@nicetisdale]

I really need to see u guys react to btob!!!!!

[@morganmackie6752]

nicê yessss!! I'll Be Your Man would be so good for them to react to!!

[@muftiahanifa7198]

I'll be your man is interesting

[@nicetisdale]

I'll be your man and movie!!! or it's okay, or way back home too,, Idk so many good songs

[@peace7642]

nicê the four way harmony is great

[@serenaso869]

YES

[@kk6836]

4minute is such an authenthic kpop girlgroup that slayed in every kind of genres...i loves the strong & girl crush👊👊👊👌❤

[@lenadehnhardt7494]

Oh god my emotional range while watching this was so crazy haha. I really got goosebumps everytime they liked the so g and tge beat dropped bcs i was like YEAH GET IT GURLS I'M SO PROUD OF YOU and then I remembered that they're disbanded and started to cry actual tears

[@Minecraftgiraffe12]

this is why 4minute are my favourite

[@kimberlylipton971]

The last time I was this early, 4minute hadn't disbanded...

[@syasol]

Yoomi Yoonicorn let's not remind ourselves

[@jeonnie5271]

I JUST LOVE THEIR REACTION OMG THAT SHOOK SCENES THO SO SATISFYING LOL

[@carlavincent7405]

You know the shit is good when Peyton starts doing sounds. Like you know it. Love this man.

[@caroccp1673]

I never get tired of this reaction.

[@madhattergodess]

Still awesome 2years later

[@ginareverseganosis119]

I think I'd like them to react to Troublemaker lol especially the MV Now (original ver) and Trouble Maker

[@csoniah4432]

" censored " make them react to kpop 18+ videos 😂😂

[@zoejohn5026]

Caroline like eureka by Zico

[@pedroalres588]

I love this reaction so much, specially the Hate one