Classical Musicians React: Jimin 'Lie'

For the 50th reaction video of season 2 of this series, classical music majors react to Jimin's 'Lie' lyric video.
SO SORRY FOR THE BAD QUALITY! I had to make some changes after deleting the original project so I had to download from my original YT upload, which lowered the quality :')
Thanks to Twitter ARMY's and RM's VAPP video (www.vlive.tv/vi...) reflecting back on the WINGS album, I was able to write up and read short intros to each solo song before the reactors watched the videos. For our solo song marathon, I encouraged the reactors to pay 50% attention to the music and 50% to lyrics...except for Suga's solo where I asked them to pay most attention to his lyrics.
Watch ashleygold25's Begin lyric video here: • BTS Jimin - 'Lie' [Han...
She also kindly gave me permission to use her thumbnails too!
Follow her on tumblr:
/ suminga / jiyonggie
/ oppalester
People have been saying that they always miss the text when I name the new people in the video, so i'll just name em here:
dude sitting next to Hugo: James, vocalist
lady sitting next to Peyton: Charlotte, oboist
If you want to watch the rest of our solo song reactions NOW, pledge $1 to our patreon and you'll gain access to them! / reacttothek
To see what other BTS songs we'll be reacting to, check out the links below.
~Reaction Schedule:
docs.google.co...
~ Complete to-react list:
• Playlist
~ Will not react to list: • Will not be reacting to
---------------------
Send us things!
P.O. BOX 14933
ROCHESTER, NY 14614-1119
~Channel instagram: @reacttothek_official
~ Channel twitter: @reacttothek
~ Channel tumblr: / reacttothek
~ Channel Facebook: / reacttothek
~Support us on Patreon and get extra access to videos you’ll never see on YT: / reacttothek
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Video editing by Umu
Eng subs done by Ash (insta: @ashhfong)
Intro design by Alex Chen (website: www.acchen.com/)
Thumbnail credit goes to Nozomi Murayama (insta: @nonchanyuzuru)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(PD) Umu:
Instagram: @_emcha_
/ omg-horns
/ bangtan-fanart
/ funny-vixx
(kpop, mamamoo, bts, vixx) Amino app: Umu @ ReacttotheK
(channel manager) Eric:
Twitter: @ricekangaroo
Olivia:
Insta: @oliviaagalante
Twitter: @OliviaGalante
Aaron:
Insta: @aaronlee753
Henry:
instagram: @zappa_yes_floyd_genesis
Twitter: @henry_carpender
Peyton:
Instagram and Twitter: @pjohnzzz
Tumblr: / pjohnzzz
Charlotte:
Instagram: charmander_97
Her cat’s instagram: monty_le_chat_noir
Jarod:
Instagram: @JVLPhotographic
and @Jarod_lau
Katie:
Instagram: @katieknudsvig
Kevin:
Twitter: @nerdymusicks
KZbin: nerdymusicks
Hugo:
Instagram: @hugohumbility
Naoki:
Instagram: @naokitoyomura
Lindsey:
Instagram and twitter: @lamusicstudio
tumblrs: / punk-popsicle
/ double-horn
Fiona:
twitter: @fiona_stout
Insta: @fionaastout
Emiel:
Fb: Emiel De Jaegher
Insta: @trumpetoats
(Isaac & Stephen & James N/A)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
*DISCLAIMER: I do not own any of the songs or videos being reacted to in this video. All credits to the companies that own them.
Also, none of us are PROFESSIONAL musicians. So if you come here for a strict breakdown/analysis of the music, you won’t be getting that. This is strictly my conservatory musician friends taking time in their schedule to watch kpop for fun, and throw in any musical comments that come into their mind! Also please do not complain about any "boring" reactions...some of the musicians have blank faces since they are concentrating so deeply on analyzing the music. On top of that, if you think that they aren't commenting enough on the music, it's because /nothing/ is happening IN the music to comment on. It may be a great song/bop/huge hit that they're listening to, but that does not mean there are actual complicated musical things happening that they'd be able to talk about.

[@btsgotmelikeyah8487]

"Why would he put that in major?" "Well maybe the major is a lie in and of itself" THAT GUYS FACE IM CRYING

[@hipeople9856]

Can I just say, your profile picture is perfect right now

[@jam1602]

@@hipeople9856 I agree

[@imxn1000]

Omgggg ur pfp is life n name ahhahaa

[@namjoonsbigtoe1774]

I just scrolled down when this comment popped up and he started saying that

[@sonjadarby1158]

Yeah, dude's face totally said "MIND. BLOWN."

[@bone7885]

"It's BTS, 95% of the time it may be really really emotional" "This is BTS and BTS expressively does that on purpose because they are melodramatic AF" *It's so true that it hurts*

[@thevilonesfr]

MsDeerie they are melodramatic and that's why we are so dramatic

[@mauryn1009]

Thevilone sfr very true

[@leikyuu]

tO be honeSt

[@knifefght]

OOOFF The truth hurts

[@shreyamaji4441]

MsDeerie this was my favourite line

[@vs_miley]

“It’s sounds like a funky Beethoven” 😂👌

[@miaamoo1860]

Congrats I was your 200th like

[@sansshiber5060]

Lmao I gotta show jimins song "lie" to my music teacher

[@Ray-bd5gb]

​@@sansshiber5060did you show it to them?

[@riverfragments]

"This is bts. They're melodramatic AF. They do it on purpose." Major mood

[@joannasunjo5630]

major mood... pun detected..pun appreciated.

[@laurenmiller149]

"It's BTS. It's 95% of the time really really really emotional." Hugo preaching truths lol

[@xBlueEyedGoldilocks]

THE ACCURACY THO

[@seewhaticcurious1]

"because they're melodramatic af"

[@knjjah2776]

“and that’s what makes them great”

[@jiminiecrickets3677]

It’s tru tho😂😂😂

[@leezap9358]

Lauren Miller TRUE I CDY WVERYTIME I HEAR THE VOCAL LINES VOICES

[@cozybunny7548]

"His voice is so pure" His dancing says otherwise (;

[@mymochiarmy9316]

Park Jimin 😂😂 jimin can be angel and devil at the same time 😅

[@michylol]

I LITERALLY THOUGHT THE SAME THING-

[@dory1489]

( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)

[@soccerfan5845]

Park Jimin I’m so PURE.

[@SwissLotus]

"Nae pi ttam nunmul nae majimak chumeul da gajyeoga ga" *shoulder expose*

[@malvonos]

"I'm sorry, what?" All of us when we first listened to this

[@chmchmmine5582]

Facts ㅋㅋㅋ 😅🙃

[@dominikig69]

While i was watching i was like: "GUYS BE QUIET SO I CAN HEAR THE MUSIC"

[@nancyjennifer9477]

Yeah, me too

[@dominikig69]

@@nancyjennifer9477 At least im not alone ;')

[@nathanielcooper4288]

Same

[@nataliecarralero1461]

Same. Then my sister said just listen to the actual song.😂

[@dazaisbakugoswaifu8688]

Sameee

[@chachacha8862]

"I'mnot even gay but I would totally bear children for that man"

[@cass8446]

Fujoshi Chan *AND I CANT EVEN BEAR CHILDREN*

[@jindoratheexplorer3678]

Fujoshi Chan Sameeee bitch!

[@ozlemdr6076]

I love when Jimin turned men into gay 😂

[@jamais_vu3]

Omg ikr

[@canweget1ksubswithoutanyvi608]

I hate kids when they use their excuse of being younger to escape from other things

[@snisa92]

I dont know music but I kinda understand when one guy said, "No, no one's doing that on purpose, of course not but you have to remember... this is BTS. Everything is on purpose." Right guy got SHOOK. LOL. PREACH.

[@DD-fh6gy]

yesss i love it too! for others it might be just a coincidence but BTS have been constantly doing this kind of stuffs that there are just too many coincidences for it to be /just/ a coincidence!

[@cinfygfs3376]

Everything is a hint to another hint to uncover the purpose uncover the plot

[@AngelaSealana]

👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

[@sammi3145]

ahh yes Jimin he be collecting men like trophies

[@minpamela2541]

Once you Jim-in you can't Jim-out😈

[@dory1489]

He's collecting men the same way I used to collect pretty rocks when I was little 😂

[@mya4212]

He collecting men like Pokemon’s on Pokemon go

[@phoenixwing5133]

Did you see my bag? It's hella trophies and it's hella thick 👀

[@fushiie9583]

LMAO IM WHEEZING

[@JJ-ii4cw]

I love listening to people who actually technically understand music and composition comment on songs, it's so fascinating and gives a whole new perspective. It's so easy to just listen and not think about the effort, creativity or thoughtful planning that went into creating the piece and leading you on an emotional journey - this really brings you back into each sound, voice or movement and makes you appreciate the music on a different level.

[@hobi_sunshine4033]

L Dango THANK YOU it needed to be said

[@zoe2.089]

Exactlyyyy yess

[@dinaros4146]

Yessss

[@1marieleathem]

Ditto!

[@MK-eh5bk]

well said

[@katelynlittleton4510]

Jimin even thought this wasn't good enough. He kept rewriting this song. He'd be so happy to know how they felt about it. How we feel about it

[@flohwalzer]

𝘵𝘩𝘪𝘴 𝘴𝘰𝘯𝘨 𝘪𝘴 𝘱𝘦𝘳𝘧𝘦𝘤𝘵, 𝘩𝘦 𝘪𝘴 𝘱𝘦𝘳𝘧𝘦𝘤𝘵, 𝘦𝘷𝘦𝘳𝘺𝘵𝘩𝘪𝘯𝘨 𝘢𝘣𝘰𝘶𝘵 𝘩𝘪𝘮 𝘪𝘴 𝘱𝘦𝘳𝘧𝘦𝘤𝘵

[@katelynlittleton4510]

@@flohwalzer Yes!

[@thelifeofise]

If I could meet him one day, I would say how much happiness he brought into my life. I'll tell him that he doesn't have to change himself nor his thoughts about anything. Everything about him is perfect, and forever will be..

[@ninaeureekaylloizuy5393]

Thats true, and is also sad :(

[@sofiahs8057]

@@thelifeofise me too :´) he is perfect.

[@doyoulikemessi3129]

If classical musicians didn't react to lie we would not have known there was a lie in the music itself and that just made me so amazed to BTS once again

[@nighttimedaydreams7181]

do you like messi ? trueee like that made me appreciate the song more

[@sulimar957]

YAS I WAS LOOKING FOR THIS COMMENT I AGREE 10000%

[@neetu_1322]

do you like messi ? So true..

[@ryleigh7830]

yes!!

[@yuelizeuwu7575]

I still don't get what was that lie in the song that they were talking about?????

[@Ser3nityRain]

Hi, super late to the party. But I feel like "caught in a lie" is in major because major is usually associated with happiness, and the lie is him pretending to be happy with himself. Welcome to my ted talk.

[@rachelarubin1026]

Also the whole piece is in minor and you subconciously expect a minor in the chorus but then the major comes so it kinda doesnt fit but it's definately on purpose because it's pretending to be happy.

[@berna5444]

oh wow sis what a comment

[@northbelle2317]

Oof, I - 😲😲

[@m3lom4nia_]

..... holy sHIT-

[@miyamin93]

HOLY SHIT what a comment

[@mahumkhan7724]

Friend: classical musicians are old people Me: shows friend this video Friend: ............ Jimin: caught in a lie~

[@rachelarubin1026]

Old people? Why would they think so about us? 😭😭😭

[@nnthrssrt8435]

@@rachelarubin1026 not a professional. but im a teenager and i have friends who think that too. it's because they usually hear 'boring' music from them and musicians who have been performing for a long time, perfecting their art. they don't see it as art but as a job which only old people like

[@momokomonzur7057]

V poTAEto and that’s on prejudice

[@flowerpetals0161]

oH so I'm old now okAy 😤😭😭😭

[@LaughingInTiny]

How sad for that friend...

[@o1_99k]

“Fudge i’m not even gay but i would totally bear children for that man and i can’t even bear children!” LMFAOOO I LIVE

[@TashmitG]

Ann the best example of Jimin effect 😂😂😂

[@King-cv4rc]

That was the best reaction 😂😂😂 I felt the same way and I'm straight as an arrow.

[@christian7978]

I read this as he said it and it made it 1000% funnier

[@fizzaahmed1949]

The girl next to him said how she was gonna word vomit when it ended up being him fanboying like other guys becoming gay for Jimin

[@shotabdi4868]

everyone gay for jimin

[@nina655]

James:"Why would he put that major?" Hugo:"I duh know" James:"You think he's suffering....? *mumbles* " Hugo:"Well the major might be a lie in itself" James: *mindblown* I was shooketh too lmao

[@relaxingsatisfying2628]

mi ki what’s that mean? Im confused

[@everyyxy8425]

"just like cake"

[@mypropicisnotjiminlookleft1581]

Why isnt this top comment Im relating so hard

[@alkalinebase]

He was Jungshook!

[@na-mib.2298]

*IM YOUR 1.2K LIKE!!!!! OMFG IM DEAD AND HONORED!*

[@krishnavasquez598]

1:20 omg is yoongi predebut 😂💕

[@eden_noodle1941]

Omg.... I hate u 😂😂

[@carolinegaskins470]

Omg lmaooooo

[@chiimmin2427]

You deserve more likes... Luv it hahaha

[@nochujk4956]

KKKKKKK

[@lyricshelper2042]

Emily Gurl 😯 That’s actually what I said before I clicked on the comment 😂

[@chlrie4676]

"it's BTS, its 95% of the time really really really emotional" Me: **looks over to The Truth Untold**

[@taesfeetpics2807]

Me: *looks over to Mic Drop*

[@oyshirahman897]

@@taesfeetpics2807 lol!!😂

[@oyshirahman897]

Me : Looks over to *house of cards*

[@army4chair345]

Me: looks at dark and wild outro

[@alleypush2737]

Me: looks at Anpanman

[@justkidding223]

3:42 "well the major could be a lie in and of itself" Hugo already a BTS theory expert

[@CAMI9023]

justkidding223 and James is the live representation of our fandom. Literally.

[@4maybeso]

Lie is legendary

[@belovedarmy97]

4maybeso le'jin'dary

[@4maybeso]

Beloved Army Liegendary 😱

[@ren-zy9qp]

Liejindary. *Boom*

[@e2kyoi]

These comments perfectly define my thought process

[@tsyoongibear8798]

YOU MEAN leJINdary okay ill leave

[@soph7066]

the girl in the yellow shirt putting in the second earbud is ME

[@nthlns]

"I'm not even gay, but I would totally bear children for that man, I was like wow I just wanted him to take me right now, sorry" I'M DYING LMAO, literally everyone is so gay for Jimin

[@siffatchhabra9376]

What minute?

[@nthlns]

@@siffatchhabra9376 8:36

[@regelio]

Nathália Nogueira, lmao you’ve seen it after like a year 😭😂🤡

[@fateenzulaikhabintimohdriz6110]

"Because they are melodramatic AF." "and that's why they're great." BIG FAT MOOD

[@whaomarina9115]

Watching this after BTS burn the stage, where Jimin cried because he thinks he struggle with singing... NO JIMINIE LOOK AT THAT

[@jmine4758]

It's Marina yeah,,, jimin must know it

[@Carmellx]

can we just tag bts here? so jimin can see this and be encouraged

[@manikta]

like CHIMCHIM LOOK WHAT U DO TO PEOPLE!!!

[@jaysellwood6308]

It's Marina same his vocie is peRf

[@aconfusedmf8580]

It's Marina SAME SNXKCMC

[@pianoplayz3306]

"His voice is so pure." *Thinks about blood sweat and tears.* *Thinks about Bapsae* *Thinks about the choreo for Lie* *Thinks about No More Dream abs* *Thinks about Bulletproof Pt. 2* *Thinks about all the times Jimin has flirted with Cameras/Camera people* *Thinks about all the times Jimin has flirted with Hosts on T.V. shows* *Thinks about that one time Jimin was on the Tonight show with Jimmy Fallon, and started twerking while saying he was shy* Yeah... I don't think he's that pure... His duality is unmatched.

[@janaabdulnaser6661]

Remember when he said if he win he will show us the bottom of hid body

[@jadzia1071]

I don't think you understand what a pure voice is. They aren't talking about his personality.

[@arunaerintikova40]

Что вы знаете о чистоте и чистоте исполнения особенно.

[@arunaerintikova40]

@@jadzia1071 Личность Чимина также чиста.

[@misakixxchan]

8:35 pretty nice description of anyone seeing jimin for the first time lbr here 😂

[@WaFaTrans]

*tell Bang PD-nim to tell P-DOG to tell namjoon to tell taehyung to tell hoseok to tell jin to tell yoongi to tell jungkook to tell JIMIN TO WATCH THIS VIDEO TO KNOW HOW BEAUTIFUL & UNIQUE PEOPLE THINK HIS VOICE IS. WHICH IS FACTS*

[@ClaudiaNkeji]

비FF Best comment goes to *You* fam👏👏

[@anac8166]

비FF yes just yes

[@chewingpeppers]

YES PLEASE

[@graciesgingerbread_house7815]

YASSS THATS RIGHT JIMIN IS A FUCKING ANGEL THAT NEEDS MORE ATTENTION AND HIS VOICE IS BEAUTIFUL AND I WANNA CRY AND HES BEAUTIFUL OMGGG

[@crown_the_empirelopez2159]

비FF. YES

[@Marta-gj8rd]

I never realised that the switch from a minor to a major might have been purposely done to give more strenght to the meaning/ to be presented as a lie itself. That is genius. Thank you for opening my eyes.

[@kissmeontheribs]

I've been asking for a whole vid what is major and minor thing they're talking here, mind to explain? 😅😅

[@Max-ed6wt]

kissmeon theribs musically speaking there are majors and minors it is something quite hard to explain if you had no previous musical training. It is when the music have a specific sharp or flat.

[@Marta-gj8rd]

Omg I just came back to this and it has 200 likes wtf how did this-

[@Marta-gj8rd]

kissmeon theribs To people with no musical experience, the easiest thing to put it is: majors sound happy and minors sound sad (that's the easiest way of recognizing a minor from a major and vice versa), but obviously there is more to it

[@LPOnePiece30]

Can I ask if I understood correctly that the Major presents the lie because the happy part aka. the major is a lie? Like he sings in Major and the statement is that his happiness (which is symbolized by the major) is a lie?

[@amber-bx8rz]

i honestly can't believe that lie is a real song like it's such a masterpiece that i can't even put it into words. i'm not exaggerating this in any way; i've listened to it on repeat for more than a week with it being the only song i listened to (and i literally mean only) and i still haven't gotten tired of it at all. it's so mind bogglingly perfect and amazing and i'm honestly struggling to type this because i know that no matter what i say, my love for this song cannot be properly expressed. every time i listened to lie, it feels like falling in love over and over. i don't know exactly what it is but something about it is so extremely perfect in every way.

[@kristin123a]

It is really a masterpiece unlike anything else. And the lyrics? So simple, effective and meaningful. Nothing is unnecessary. Jimin really has a way with lyrics that way. If he wasn't so hard on himself and his work and learned to just not give a f about the result every time, I think he would've written and released plenty of songs by now.

[@arunaerintikova40]

Я вас поняла и тоже так думаю. Вы выразили то, что я не могла.

[@M__se]

“His voice is SO pure” Oh honey, u haven’t seen his dancing yet. 😏

[@iva-marimiskulin1787]

as a musician i think this is one of the most clever harmonically written songs, that major catches ur attention u know

[@rachelarubin1026]

Yes, totally agree. The harmony is somewhat classical and a bit Beethoven-like i would say, it's really dark and intense and the major in the chorus gives a different context.

[@Jha0601]

True. My all time fav will be Bohemian Rhapsody then this song comes a close second, its a fricking masterpiece.

[@amayalaanan7529]

We have the same pp

[@KarlaGizzleTomlinson]

I can't believe jimin created this masterpiece i am so impressed that he put everything into the song, the whole song omg

[@maze7438]

Ikr!! So proud of baby Jimin

[@shineinstars]

IM SO PROUD

[@maze7438]

@lmao lil haters mfs 😒

[@shasha9421]

n that's why I always looking forward for jimin to did a new song like this by himself cuz yeah he rarely do it... but when he did it.... the song is sooooo BOOM! even a word "masterpiece" can't describe how good it is

[@sheilahanindra3316]

He did?

[@juice-5853]

Jimin is so amazing and this song is such a masterpiece. And when coupled with Jimin’s incredible vocal techniques, emotions and the breathtaking performance, it’s just so perfect !

[@maciemauk3003]

Scrolling my phone: Sees Jimin: Clicks video: Let's go!! Edit: Thanks for the likes!

[@anirtak5141]

Macie Mauk same!!! 🙋🏻‍♀️

[@ptd92]

"Fudge, I'm not even gay but I would totally bear children for that man. And I can't even bear children" oh god Jarod is me

[@selix3506]

Pao THAT WAS SO FKING ON POINT 🤣🤣

[@1DheyMofo]

Jimin himself should see this. He needs to know he is very talented despite the worries he have with his own singing ability.

[@jungkooksbeautifulvoice7326]

Taetae we should send this to bts on twitter

[@ikarifka2790]

Send this *ASAP*

[@user-qr2yp3hq5f]

ikr it’s so sad that he’d cry after the concert thinking he was bad :(

[@alejandratrevino1583]

I wish Jimin could see this and realise that everything he does is just perfect and amazing 💓

[@Sunset553]

It’s so hard to survive shame.

[@FaceByJimin]

This reaction will forever be iconic

[@elisahaizler]

Jimin: breaths Every single man on the planet: I’m not even gay but I would totally bear children for this man and I can’t even bear children!

[@mikaela5607]

The truth

[@superiorkims5294]

Omg

[@animusic4161]

SAME

[@RayneBreena]

*But where is the lie*

[@rryuh]

*I love seeing people praising jimin's vocals because that boy deserves all the love in this world!! He needs to realise everyone including their moms LOVES his beautiful voice.. His voice is truly one of a kind, it can touch one's heart.* *Hope one day, jimin can love and see himself as we do..* I love this reaction video so much

[@milagrosmalpartida2127]

jimin stan must protect!!! ( ò0ó)/

[@snisa92]

jimin stan his voice is really unique and beautiful. Hope he finally realized it.

[@pebble8978]

True! ❤

[@honeybutterpotatochips]

yess! HE'S A TOTAL FLUFF it hurts seeing him cry every time he thinks me made something wrong while singing when he really made a great job 😭

[@yourlocaldyke]

Me too. Jimin is so hard on himself and seeing that makes my heart hurt ❤

[@hm.3831]

"I feel like this is gonna be really really really really emotional." "It's BTS. It's 95% of the time going to be really really really emotional." 😂😂

[@SalamanderMagic]

As someone who's not well versed in music theory, it's amazing to me how easily they pick up on the minor to major change and it's significance- something which totally went over my head.

[@rryuh]

*I just can't imagine this song will give us the same vibe if jimin isn't the one doing it. Like no one can pull this off except him, his vocals makes this song even more of a masterpiece. And just to mention, he also wrote this whole song, just wow.* *The overall production, vocals, the lyrics, everything is just perfect.* *also if you watched Jimin's live performance it seems like he was controlling the song. I recommend everyone to watch it!* *_Not only his voice is beautiful and pure, Jimin's musicality and the way he executes every song is also mesmerizing_*

[@salangsaejj4722]

jimin stan Hello there mate 🙈😂 i agree with you btw nice name

[@redsadventures6651]

Very well said

[@ElspethGordie]

"This is the sickest kpop song ever" literally my reaction upon 1st hearing this. Also is my favorite solo song on the YNWA album. I also caught the major note so I feel cool now lol.

[@brianajewel]

Zombii Pie this song and stigma were my fav lol

[@ElspethGordie]

brianajewel Stigma is amazing, especially when Tae hits the high note.

[@vanessaives40]

"This is the sickest kpop song ever" - my reaction when I saw the teaser/short movie xd

[@realist4418]

lie is a confusingly interesting song. i mean, the first time i heard it, i was hooked as soon as they smacked me in the face with that major. I'm not quite fond of the way jimin handles his voice, but am really fond of his tone all the same

[@cyphervjk]

it's fair to say that lie made me a bts fan. before i was kinda unsure about stanning them, but this song... man, i'm not even a musician in any way, but when that note changed into major i was like "hold the f up! what just happened???". and jimin's vocals... this song is truly a masterpiece. so happy these guys have finally reacted to it.

[@EnglishSubOPMs]

8:09 this is how every straight man reactor in youtube and in real life ends up loving jimin... "everyone loves jimin" is definitely a fact.

[@ARMYBLINK-zs1qh]

The thing i love most about this song is that it's hauntingly beautiful, but also sad, and even a little seductive. it's got so many moods to it, and it has a really good meaning behind the lyrics too.

[@kierakhov5777]

There are two types of people that i cherish. 1. Those who react to the meaning/lyrics of BTS songs 2. Those who react to the music/tone of BTS songs

[@kakik6519]

But I think BTS join the two. The melody always fit to the lyric and also the dance. That's why I love them

[@dv7703]

Someone needs to add korean subtitles and then send this to bighit so Jimin can finally see how amazing his vocals are!!! EDIT- Considering this is my second time commenting on youtube, im amazed at the number of likes!!! JUNGSHOOK! O.O

[@CarlaSantos-le5tv]

D c Excellent idea!!!!!

[@dinunanayakkara1682]

D c ikr

[@camio888]

Jimin has to see this!!!!!!

[@itagalicod3430]

Someone tweet to Sugafull so that she can translate and send to BigHit

[@SwagTutorialsJB]

pls do it this!

[@lepcha2442]

One of Jimin's Masterpiece "Lie💜 It's Aug 2021 But I'm still here for the best reaction video I have ever seen they honestly appreciated about the Jimin vocal, the song itself & every detail on🥺🙏 Our Fallen Angel's voice is so pure & beautiful🐥🖤

[@Genidias97]

Jimin created a Masterpiece a song like this will never come in kpop or pop in general since 1.The song sounds Amazing with good instrumental arrangements 2.The composition period that major was seriously so thoughtful 3.So much of thoughts is put into this song lot of details in the music composition area we can tell Jimin worked day and night as he said he wanted it to be perfect (and it came out to be perfect) 4.The lyrics are wonderfully written by Jimin and Co 5.His pure voice and emotions he delivers through the lyrics 6.The choreo O-o It's a complete Masterpiece best kpop song easily Periodt

[@HKFern]

This coming out after this week's burn the stage fits so well, I hope Jimin sees this in some way.

[@nikkilags3528]

tigerbalm this is wat I actually thought after seeing this

[@jungkooksbeautifulvoice7326]

tigerbalm we should send this to bts on twitter!!

[@pommefrite8693]

I don't know, saying he should see this puts the need of reevaluation on him when it's at least just as much on the fans. Granted, the idol/fan relationship unhealthiness goes both ways, but in this case, it's also a product of expectations. "They're so amazing they can sing and dance at the same times and kill these high notes and perform for hours etc", no, they're not >that< good, and all these unrealistic expectations of irrational fans seeing perfect beings is part of what creates this unexetricable pressure which then can contribute to the kind of "impostor syndrome" Jimin seems to feel and the song can be interpreted being about.

[@zoelenoble330]

wow, i've never seen someone talking about that, but its so true thanks for saying this. are you french btw? ^^

[@HKFern]

Pomme Frite I don't think I had that thought of 'he must know he's perfect' in mind, I just thought it'd be good for him to see a more constructive compliment so that he knows his song is musically complex n good in that way. I kinda see what you mean though. For me I believe that Jimin still has a lot of room to improve, like you said, he's not an absolute perfect performer, but I think he shouldn't stress himself so much, or at least don't just put his self-worth into his performance, which is a difficult thing to not do, cuz as a performer there's that responsibility to do well. I thought this evaluation of his song would be an encouragement to him cuz it has more substance that the standard 'omg he's perfect' comments.

[@LazyAceDia]

You could also say that the switch to major represents the realization that he has been lying to himself. It's like a sudden moment of clarity, followed by the dark realization that he doesn't know how to escape, despite recognizing the issue.

[@inezleeya]

Lazy Ace Dia OMG I KNOW YOU 😂 I LOVE YOUR VIDEOS😍

[@LazyAceDia]

I edit videos on this channel now! But I might start making more of my own in the future

[@inezleeya]

Lazy Ace Dia Looking forward to them 😁😁

[@Girlo98]

Lazy Ace Dia I was thinking the exact same thing. Genius!

[@misscrankypantss]

So amazing, this is a true masterpiece! 😢❤

[@brigidruberson2917]

This is my favorite BTS song. I heard the story, heard the song, then I saw the dance performance and just sobbed for like half an hour. 10/10

[@dowonunsimidi9493]

Hes a good vocalist,a good dancer,hes good at dancing,hes purrfect wth

[@fersepulveda455]

7:18 she is the hardest person to sorprise and what she said? "Cause his vocals are beautiful, first of all" HE NEEDS TO KNOW WE ALL AGREE

[@allforbts3711]

I really do hope Jimin sees this and realize how beautiful his voice is.

[@LittleBabywriter]

Does anyone know if they are going to react to serendipity?

[@spanishstay7669]

Hi there! I am a classical musician myself and I love your Channel. Just one thing, the Spanish guitar part after the intro is a reference of a classical piece, the Spanish Dance nº1 from "La Vida Breve" by Manuel de Falla, one of the most celebrated neoclassical and nationalist Spanish composer!!!!!!

[@LRwer]

"he wrote it thinking about his past" me: NO NO NO, THIS WAS HIS PRESENNNNNTT. THAT'S WHY HE WROTE IT LIKE 100 TIMESSSSSS.

[@michikocheng4414]

'His voice is so pure'

[@periodtpooh5132]

@IISaltQueenII me: *dies*

[@auroraks6207]

* *is ded* *

[@wdzcix]

Shah Study bUt tHe qUeSTioN iS... iS hE??!!

[@chips6264]

1000th LIKE

[@hopevang6810]

Im seeing all these comments omg you guys are amazing you've made my day

[@johanaester6606]

Unfortunately JIMIN is a hard-to-died PERFECTIONIST. It's hard for him to accept praises. I hope he watch this video.

[@AndikaAndika-zg5pf]

Johana Ester sad but its true

[@aaaaa2839]

Them: "third... second dundundun *fancy language* " Me: "hold on what?"

[@ma.anjelicachan3351]

Back in 2024 this is still the best reaction and appreciation I have ever watched on the Wings album

[@jungkooksbeautifulvoice7326]

This song is seriously a masterpiece ♡

[@codmouse13]

this album is a whole masterpiece

[@sehunscartier667]

Ikr, I dont know much about Bts but this song is so good I like the boy’s voice

[@kG-ep7wj]

sehun's manager well if u like this song u should listen to their album wings

[@leifuertes306]

sehun's manager If you like his voice you should also listen to Serendipity. And if you want, you could also check out the group's other songs 😀

[@DD-fh6gy]

not only the song but the performance is pure art. jimin is a god send gift

[@lhsmmrvb]

" It's BTS. It's 95 % of the time it may be really really emotional " TRUE.

[@wintergarden2875]

yeah, and we're really emotional while listening Bangtan's member voice omg

[@yeontaniswatchingyou5092]

Jarod: *"I was like wow...I just wanted him to take me right now"* Guys, Jimin got another one.

[@megha8130]

When they said, 'the major comes only when he says "caught in a lie" so it's a lie itself'. I am like W-H-A-T!!!!!!!!!!????????? WHAT? When you see it all and think BTS is the best, their music in a theory and like technical way is crazy too. Like what?

[@btsjiminface]

I disagree with the theory that the lie is the major chord. I think it's more that the minor key is a metaphor for the lie, and the minor key triplets are like a web of lie(s), and the major key note symbolizes Jimin successfully extracting himself from the lie for a half second, but then submerges back into the web of the lie that he's caught in.

[@beige_ricaforte]

After watching Burn the Stage last day... i just hope Jimin knew his vocal is amazing 💜💜

[@doublesey]

Beige Ricaforte, true

[@ANDSTONE100]

That's normal, most vocalists think their vocals aren't all that despite their actual skill level.

[@ilbwfy1550]

Beige Ricaforte He knows now. It was a year ago. Then Serendipity happened. He loves himself more. He believes in himself more. He healed. He is good.

[@snisa92]

rosalie • yeahh serendipity show how much he has improved. And he seem much more confident and happier. I think he already got vocal lesson.

[@beige_ricaforte]

rosalie • I sometimes forgot that it was last year 😅

[@jamaeeey]

" His voice is so pure, like it is so pure " AN ANGEL 😭❤

[@pinkpanda9439]

back for my monthly watch because i just love seeing people be amazed by jimin and the masterpiece that is lie

[@rbsmmm]

Again I’ll say Jimin is the bts differentiator- he makes bts above other groups - his unique voice tone and dance style, and this song exemplifies this !!!

[@arunaerintikova40]

Без Чимина БТС были бы другие.

[@DecarlaOutar]

I totally agree..I've said that he is key. Me going back to this song 2 yrs after becoming army💜

[@dayflyni6442]

I'm proud of our mochi

[@ParkJimin-eu3pd]

Echo ikr..Our Mochi R Awesome

[@KIMTAEHYUNG-ho7us]

Echo me too

[@jaysellwood6308]

Echo me too

[@vipwei23]

yes!!! BTS yes!!!!!!

[@goldilocks_372]

Sooo proud 💖👑💐

[@saramin4798]

After watching this reaction just make me so proud of Jimin!!!!!No wonder Lie is the most successful solo song out of BTS WINGS albums. The compose, the lyrics and the vocal all combined together so well."The major, is a lie" just show how delicate this song has been arranged. I'm so glad that Jimin is such a talented man.

[@sqdazai6674]

true.. Lies was the 1st solo song from BTS that make me download & listen repeatedly after the 1st listening..

[@marshalltoby6994]

i always go back to this channel when reacting to bts because i love the input and pure amazement lmao

[@nanananananananana00]

one of my absolute favorites from bts, holds a lot of meaning and it doesn’t hurt that it’s absolutely beautiful

[@user-wg7or1ox3y]

You guys must see this song’s live with the jimin’s incredible dance!!

[@lamiamech1066]

김레이 right!! They would flip

[@offthehook1001]

I thought I couldn't like this song, or Jimin, any more. Until I saw the incredible live choreography.

[@lmf221]

I have been waiting for this for months! Also, I really hope that Jimin see's this because I know he gets so insecure and the amount of informed praise in this is wonderful.

[@heelrunner]

Lauren Freeman meeeee tooooooooooo. So wonderful.

[@aradg9796]

I hope he watches this and hopefully there is korean subs.

[@katiaferreira4370]

Lauren Freeman it’s so sad that he has insecurities in his great talents.I mean he is ABSOLUTELY superb as an artist! Honestly he has all my respect and this is no exaggeration!

[@imululo]

I don't know his social media but you could send it to him, I'm sure he's gonna love it.

[@jungkooksbeautifulvoice7326]

Lauren Freeman we should send this to bts on twitter!!

[@nickiii26]

Practicamente armaron la teoría de Lie solo escuchando la música, dios eso fué magnífico, realmente entienden el lenguaje de la música :')

[@lavvi7045]

Creo que si hubieran visto junto con la coreografía se vuelve una locura 🤭

[@nickiii26]

@@lavvi7045 Qué cosas mas hubieran conectado, es una gran idea, ahora estoy intrigada 😅

[@lavvi7045]

@@nickiii26 hazlo para que no te quedes con la duda 😉🙃

[@eusabellellego4332]

I keep on re-watching this reaction because I knew that this song is a great song the moment I heard it. I'm not even musically trained! I just love listening great music. 10 out of 10 indeed.

[@eeseom]

kinda didn't know what the hell they were talking about.. but one thing is for sure. JIMIN IS LEGENDARY AND DESERVES ALL OF THE LOVE

[@bestie9744]

milky peach lol same tho

[@simism9717]

milky peach same

[@Pedley143]

I can relate lmao

[@ilargia_]

Jimin MUST see this! His voice is so beautiful but he is such a perfectionist he is never satisfied with his work, this would give him the confirm f his talent and would probably help him becoming less critical of himself. Lie is truly a masterpiece from the touching lyrics to the clever composition and the choreography as well perfectly suits Jimin’s extraordinary talent of delivering emotions with his dance. Thank you for acknowledging all of this.

[@kayg7438]

Seriously

[@chantreajeffery9078]

Somebody get him to watch this

[@auroraharts5819]

How can they even think while listening to Jimin sing? I’m hypnotized & mesmerized every time he opens his mouth!

[@laishachan8059]

His voice is like an angel I love Park Jimin

[@cassandraday3687]

"50 Shades of BTS" wow I'm triggered😂😂

[@v-nikiforov8725]

house of cards

[@Naz-zayn]

Expensive girl

[@chimrm6447]

Singularity

[@olasmulska7812]

trouble

[@TheGoldenChildJai]

@@v-nikiforov8725 Remember they just released "House of BTS"

[@neenad6409]

I know that you guys a classical musician and you don't really visualise the music in your mind the way a dancer might do, but please take a note that jimin is a dancer through and through so his approach in writing music/lyrics is different as he wanted to emphasize the way he move along the beats too.. It is actually amazing how difference a music can be with a choreography in mind.. Fiona has described that this beat makes you feel like being pulled in and Payton gestures raising his hand during 'Caught in a Lie' line and it was exactly how Jimin danced this song.. and I am sure none of you had actually seen him performed this live.. it is mindblowing how some moves can be transferred through the music like a different formnof telepathy or smtg ajsjsnsjs idk how to describe this better..

[@DD-fh6gy]

thank u for describing this. i tend to forget that BTS always take into account coreography when writing and areanging music and damn this is beautiful, i'm not a dancer so i'm not aware of these stuffs but man why am i suddenly tearing up. usually i just watch jimin's live performance for his techniques, now that u mentioned about layers and emotions, my respect grows ten-fold for jimin, bts and the people working behind. what an amazing team.

[@leifuertes306]

This is such a great comment. Thanks for mentioning it. True respect for Park Jimin in every aspect of his artistry.

[@dannydd6734]

Profesionales lo dicen, "sus voces son hermosas" y agradables Y tu niña meca diciendo que no cantan ajá

[@jeoncielmin5536]

Concuerdo

[@uwu-km3wf]

Literalmente Estoy totalmente de acuerdo contigo

[@nthlns]

This video is simply amazing. Their reactions are so priceless, I love the sincerity of their compliments and how they enjoy literally every second of the song. I really wanted Jimin to watch this video, imagine how happy he would be with these comments

[@masquenmanifest]

50 shades of BTS oooooooohhhh..... lol every reaction of BTS that I watch from you guys makes me want to fly across the world to Korea to show this to the members and producers and entire staff at BigHit

[@ElisabettaCoppi]

lmao same this one is the best so far I cried for laughing ♥

[@andreasol9899]

bts music is great

[@redlady4]

Seriously, someone needs to show this to Jimin though it probably won't help since his issues are largely in his head.

[@masquenmanifest]

now I want them to react to Outro Her, Serendipity and Pied Piper and ynwa. Also I watched the rest of the solo reactions through Patreon cause I couldn't wait and I'm glad I did...it only gets better all the way till Awake. Especially loved First Love reaction

[@masquenmanifest]

redlady4 I know it's been breaking my heart watching him on Burn the stage

[@amandarae5337]

I really like that note about how the line "Caught in a lie" is the only part played in a Major key and the rest of the song in Minor. I've never picked that up. It's as they mentioned, that "it's a lie in itself."

[@LPOnePiece30]

Amanda Rae does that mean that the happiness that is represented by the major is a lie? or did I misunderstand?

[@bubbles-.-9090]

I don't understand :/

[@fmaxorcist]

@@LPOnePiece30 Not exactly. The whole song is in a minor key except for that line. As some background knowledge, major and minor keys are differentiated based on the 3rd scale degree (third note) of the scale. In a minor key, the third note is a half step lower than that of the major scale. So you can tell if a song is in a major or minor based on that one note. So, the whole song uses the notes of the minor scale until he sings "lie". He uses the 3rd scale degree of the major scale, not the minor. So the key signature is a "lie" because the minor key is suddenly turned major for that one note. Hope that makes some sense, Im sorry if I confused you more orz

[@Wishphoenix1]

Anyone else have no clue what that music technobabble ment? But still enjoyed watching and listening to them enjoying BTS? ✋✋✋✋✋

[@thefriend14]

i still come back to watch this ep solely for the guy in the blue t-shirts explanation bc accurate

[@chaesmic9425]

i love classical musicians who actually know what they’re talking about complimenting and praising jimin’s vocals & the song so much. and the fact that all of them literally fell in love with it and couldn’t stop talking about it and praising it means so much. i’m so thankful that they’re actually complimenting the producing and everything, thank you.

[@mypropicisnotjiminlookleft1581]

Yassss im keeping this video in one of my playlist cause YES

[@mselenoalose]

This is literally the song that got me into Kpop. This is the song that made me realize that not everyone who speaks Korean is a bubbly, brightly colored, high ptiched person singing about partying and love. This is a song that I connected to emotionally before I even looked at the lyrics. This is why I love Park Jimin. THANK YOU FOR REACTING TO THIS

[@mariamh4401]

ME TOOO

[@isabellaa.8225]

SAME IT GOT ME INTO KPOP i played this religiously everyday before exploring other songs

[@elirude4422]

I feel like the only people that appreciate ALL music in every way are other artists/musicians.

[@majofigueroapjm]

El chabon de lo último refleja lo que siento cuando escucho a mi jimin. Es mi espíritu animal.

[@annavickers7752]

I WANT JIMIN TO SEE THIS SO BAD OMG

[@fnina2207]

He probably will see it

[@natibb1166]

“well played bts, well played...” WHY IS THIS ME EVERY COMEBACK

[@aylinitzel.]

I think the fact that they made the key and meter reflective of the lyrics’ meaning, really goes to show how much time and care Jimin put into creating this song. “Lie” is absolutely beautiful, and I truly hope Jimin is proud of what he’s created.