Classical Vocalists React: IU 'Dear Name' [Fantastic Duo] (Part 2)

[@cookiecan1140]

Their VARIED opinions n thoughts on who was better just PROVES that at the end of the day music is subjective on what one prioritizes as “good singing” :-)))))

[@GiantLittleDino]

steph foo Amen!!! At the end of the day these are opinions. While they might have similar opinions for basic vocal technique, stylistic choices like vibrato, breathiness, and emotion all producing varied opinions.

[@cookiecan1140]

Cale Albracht EXACTLY :-) 👏🏻👏🏻

[@downthispath6538]

Also notice how each pair has similarities in opinion? If that ain't humans being the usual social animals, opinions changing based on who they're currently with, idk what is.

[@juliall255]

steph foo No they agree on good singing they just disagree on the APPROACH to good singing

[@ivanjonahcarpio2138]

It's very interesting how each pair had different preferences and have their own opinions against other's favorites. Anyway, I think IU did not chose taekwondo girl because she'd not blend with her well compared with the guys.

[@hasaneatif9386]

Ivan Jonah Carpio yeah rhat's why she chose the security guy as he can blend well with her voice where as the chef can't as he sings high and the dentist can't too esp for the song she is singing in the final he fits her and she chose the dentist for this round as she felt it was a shame he didn't do well on 1st round so she gave him another chance

[@lurinzoo]

The TK girl has somewhat of a same tone as iu. If they sang togehter, it would feel lat

[@lovely0804]

This show isn't to CHOOSE who sing the best it's to choose who will fit your voice and song in DUET... lol overpowering each other voice is stupid

[@downthispath6538]

I feel like if she explained this to them before they started reacting, they'd react different. This isn't about who sings better, it's about who can complement the voice of the singer who fucking WROTE the song and is personal to her.

[@mythrin]

Well overpowering is kinda the nature of Westerners...

[@keely203]

This is one of my favourite songs of hers and it was written by her for the Sewol Ferry incident. That's what makes it so emotional of a song. I wish that would have been mentioned at the beginning of the video so they can actually try to understand the video better

[@wooden_girl]

neocity true

[@cristinalopez5554]

Yes

[@simandianamarieg.2216]

at the full show IU explain why she chose those three guys.. and she needs to pick the one who will compliment her voice, because its Fantastic Duo..

[@julynightowl7413]

DM Siman IKR?!! I think they need to be informed about that.

[@navibyul]

DM Siman UP!!!

[@cristinalopez5554]

👌

[@gatiTLH]

Ohhh that makes so much sense...wish the reactors would know before hand

[@Sil-wx6ln]

There was also the fact that the singers usually picks the final song ahead (like before the show starts) while choosing which people to choose or eliminate

[@taeminislove]

I really wish you gave them context on the song's meaning/lyrics so they understood why the singing technique was like that cause Dear Name is literally one of the most emotional and sad songs IU's made. :(

[@user-ij5lu9ph2p]

Agree

[@fluffymoonbunny]

IMO the 'whisper singing' is to portray sadness in their voice. Like when you're really emotional you get breathless and it's harder to get words out so you talk in a 'whisper' way

[@AegyoKpop913]

Fluffy MoonBunny iu always tends to sing in a breathy way though, it’s styles she seems to like so...

[@user-ij5lu9ph2p]

yeah esp since the song is about something so sad and hard to talk about...in case yall didnt know it's about the sewol ferry incident, it's a tribute to the victims

[@ainrsttt]

That's because IU sings mostly ballads. Her breathy way makes it smoother. But if you listen to Red Shoes, she's not. And yeah, she probably like that breathy sound. If you want to compare, Ailee also use that technique when singing sad part but she knows proper technique as well. Ailee is just not the ballad type of singer.

[@rainbows5232]

no its not, and they whisper happy songs as well

[@Qwerky396]

the song was written in memory of the sewol ferry incident so in a way it’s the only appropriate way to singh this song

[@Sensationalhehe]

The rage at the beginning 😂

[@tomhannah3825]

I am there with that rage!!!! No fucking way should she have picked the guys and discarded the great girls! IF IU was just looking for singers that would complement HER, she shouldn't have even given the girls a chance! NO!!!! This is bullshit, I'm registering a complaint, and I'm out of here!!! Fuck no! Bye!

[@takoyakai7211]

Tom Hannah It’s part of the show so you can’t blame IU on it. The singers competing were chosen by the writers, IU basically did what she was supposed to do and picked someone who she thought would be suitable to sing with her in the last round.

[@tomhannah3825]

Ok, whatever. Maybe the tv producers wanted... Wait, I don't care what they wanted. I heard better singing from some of the women, who were immediately discarded, so I feel discarded too. And Umu, I trust you to give us what we need to know to enjoy the show. You not telling us that it's NOT about who sings better, is easier for you, but you lost me. Bye.

[@simandianamarieg.2216]

at the full show IU explain why she chose those three guys..

[@stillfangirlingtoday1468]

That was me watching this show as well, lol.

[@sarah13pink]

Tbh i got a little upset when they said that IU would be last place? I don't know anything about singing....but there is a reason why she is the country's most loved and respected artist. Since we know she did not get famous for her dancing or her visuals...she made her mark purely through talent and her emotion driven singing. Her "breathy" technique is what makes her songs intimate and absolutely breathtaking to listen to. Different countries have different preferences, we just need to listen with an open heart.

[@bluishviolett]

Classical singers are (most of them) too "strict" at their knowledge. Sometimes I feel sad thinking about how some of the guests can't feel the song and the passion because they're "searching" for mistakes or "seeing" from the "classical thecnic side of the window"

[@ivanjonahcarpio2138]

To be honest, she's not at her best at this episode and I personally did not like the approach on the notes she hit at the start but that does not make me a lessee fan. Her blending with the contestants were good but the classical vocalists were too busy analyzing the contestants' capability that they ignore IU's skills at blending with these three guys at the same song.

[@rey-wi8jk]

you shouldve stopped at "i dont know anything about singing" bc just bc someone is the nation's lil sister doesnt mean theyre incredibly great at singing technique wise. people just love iu's voice color and her songs but her technique isn't all that special. obviously people have different preferences ( on the vocal color ) but at the end of the day what really matters is the technique someone sings since that could fuck up ur vocal chords if ur doing it wrong

[@sarah13pink]

키라 kira i agree with what you said..i don't think popularity equals talent. It was also insightful for me to listen to the reactors talk about technical things and who they would have choosen. I just wish they would have worded themselves better instead of saying IU would be last place. As a viewer and admirer of IU since many years i just thought that was unnecessary.

[@defective622]

The thing is, she IS incredibly great singing technique wise. I'm sure you'll be able to find a "vocal coach reacts to iu" or something on KZbin. She is literally known as one of the best female singers in South Korea, if not the best. I don't think you can achieve that by just having a unique vocal color. She has an amazingly powerful voice, maybe not seen in this video, but again, just KZbin it. IU has been singing for years without having problems with her voice and she has been trained professionally, I don't think you need to worry.

[@nattie2822]

Tbh, the blonde girl was being so rude when she was saying that IU would be last place. I get that she has proper training but it's just a bit disrespectful when IU is so much more than her technique. She basically produced and wrote her whole entire album and has an amazing tone. She is such a legend in South Korea.

[@JE-sf5ky]

Yeah, it was heartbreaking, more so for people who are her fans and adore her.😢

[@ronaldamores7291]

Stop following this hilarious reaction video, respect to those who are good enough. Not those who are pretending pros. hehe

[@dlanyerdale]

Yah it is kinda rude. I thought the blonde girl is kind and all but wtf that comment of her should have just been cut rude ass shit

[@joshualegaspi9206]

ikr!!! ive watched so many of these peoples videos and she has NOTHING positive to say at all

[@feministfascist]

also why she be chewing like that this aint an asmr channel

[@jjptrash9160]

i wish they were reminded about the real purpose of the show tho, 'to find who best fits the artist for a duo'. maybe in that way, they could have related their critiquing to the purpose of why IU picked them and the rest of the story.

[@jinae7019]

It's annoying how stylized singing can't be considered as acceptable singing. Like ok the technique isn't good, but if it fits with the song and the mood, shouldn't it be fine??

[@sarah13pink]

Elaine Le Agreed. The performance was so emotional and beautiful..i don't understand the over analysis...did we just forget that these are normal everyday people that are singing with heart, they are not trained singers.

[@spress15]

Sarah Ahmed - Yes, they are not trained singers, and I agree should not be judged as if they were. But as you can see there isn't agreement even among these reactors. Each reactor had their own criteria, some may prefer a more beautiful tonal quality, others may prefer the emotional quality. We each have preferences, just as IU has her preferences when she decides who she likes the best. 😊

[@LINDSEYLWLW]

This is CLASSICAL vocalist reacts. They aren’t saying that stylized singing isn’t “acceptable” it just doesn’t make any sense from their perspectives as classically- trained vocalists

[@jinae7019]

Lindsey W I understand that they're criticizing the singers from a classical approach, but I would honestly prefer to see them criticize the singer after taking into consideration the style of the song as well. I have a friend who is also classically trained and she loves criticizing singers, but when it comes to different styles like RnB for example, she often won't criticize their singing simply because she knows that they're going for a style more suited to the genre.

[@Gretaisworking]

you know that you can have emotional singing without sacrificing technique... that's why it makes trained singers frustrated. it shouldnt be one or the other

[@ivberryyy4808]

That moment in the middle of reaction. They're already picking the cook and saying they'll be pissed if IU wouldn't pick the cook. I'm seriously laughing so hard... because you can now see what will be the outcome and as espected. AHAHHAHAHAHAHAHHAHA.

[@BorisSo-0-0]

Please give some respect！！！What do you mean IU deserves the last place. IU is one of the most famous singer in Korea. Even if you're dissatisfied her choice. You still can't curse her like that. If you watch the whole episode. She has explained the reason why she didn't chose the cook. Because their timbre are not similar. It's not just a singing technique competition. Technique is important but whether their timbre can be blend in is more important

[@MedinaAicah]

I feel like umu(?) should’ve explained better what the concept of the show was. They are not suppose to choose which one is the greatest singer out of five but to choose which one compliments their voice. That is why it’s called Fantastic Duo. Also, I think it’s better if they knew the back story of the song so they’ll understand the content better

[@cheesymac3121]

Also the song is one she made and one that's really important to her I kind of wish that was mentioned but maybe this was recorded before you started doing the song/artist intro

[@downthispath6538]

Should have also mentioned what the show is about like it's fucking called FANTASTIC DUO for a reason. It's not choosing the best singer, it's choosing who she thinks best complements her voice so they can sing in the final round. Like... dude. I'm pretty upset that this wasn't explained to them.

[@cutietaetae.]

People should like this comment more so it can be shown at the top alont with @downthispath's comment.

[@amberhurtado3692]

They don’t really need an explanation of the song to objectively critique it from a classical vocalist standpoint. While I get while some fans may want this, using the breathy vocal tone isn’t the only way to express such emotions. Maybe lyrics would have been good but this isn’t the regular reactors videos so they do it differently.

[@jessicanguyen754]

It’s “fantastic duo” not “fantastic vocal” tho’ 😂 just sayin’

[@jioh8091]

TOTALLY AGREE. there is a lot of good singer, but this show for the "FANTASTIC DUO" with Singer's fan.

[@oreb]

Breathy singing doesn't always mean it's well supported. Singing should involve the whole body, and when you sing with just your throat by producing a "breathy" soft sound, you don't have that. We're used to that style of singing because it sounds nice in pop music where you're recording and have a mic. Whispery singing is kind of like a cookie; it's sweet and delicious, but not always good for you. Without proper technique and support to produce a soft volume in a healthy way, you could damage your throat. Obligatory: it's all personal preference based off what kind of singing/tone/color/style you enjoy. This is just my opinion coming from years of chorus + my personal taste. Enjoy the music everyone!

[@koshira1977]

Lol I love the vocalists reacting to competitions!!! It's so fun especially since I haven't seen them, so I can guess along too! I hope there will be more vocalists react to singing competitions like this show!!!! Thank you for always making content!

[@user-ju6vr7ug9i]

They are busy chatting among themselves than actually reacting to it n when it comes to iu's voice it doesn't sound like whispering it sounds beautiful..

[@kawaiibunnbunn]

0:07 - 0:20 LMAO. I know some ppl are triggered by his rage, but I just find it hilarious. 😂👌👏

[@snsdlyrics162]

same hahah it's funny

[@andreamarie685]

I have been a fan of IU for years. She is definitely not a great vocalist but she truly is a good singer. Fantastic Duo is a program where the artist picks the contestant who will join him/her in the last round. Thus, the one that the artist will pick may or may not be the best vocalist among the contestant. Most of the artist picks the person they can duet with. If you'll watch the video, you'll know the reason why she pick the security guard, it's because he and IU can blend together and create synergy. I agree that technically, the cook is the best among the three but this is Fantastic Duo, not a competition among vocalists. The cook has a powerful voice that may drown IU's voice, hence the choice as both the guard and IU has this whispery sound. IU is a singer-songwriter, she knows what she is good at and she probably knows her weakness. She is most suited with jazz that's why her Modern Times Album was truly exceptional. By the way, the song in this round, "Dear Name", is co-written by IU, it has a beautiful lyrics and is rumored to be dedicated to the victims of the Sewol Ferry incident where many people/youth drowned and died. Hence, the song is somewhat saying that there name will not be forgotten. I also agree that the taekwondo girl is technically good. She is even technically good than IU. But again, this is a program where the singer chooses who she can create a good synergy. IU is a singer who can touch your heart, especially with her lyrics and her emotions. Again, she's technically not a good vocalist but she will always be a great singer in my opinion. I love her writings and compositions. 😊 All else considered, I love the reactions. As classically trained vocalist, I did expect the reactors to react on what they know and what they are good at, thus, classical training. The reactors did well on that area. 😊

[@aznfangrl612]

It's funny the opera singer chick hates on stylized singing a lot. Like shes very like only proper technique and singing always. Breathy singing tends to set the mood

[@TheTappss]

aznfangrl612 umm, they're supposed to analyse the vocalists critically, and that's what they're all doing. Breathy technique isn't really good for the voice in the long run, even though it might sound awesome. I think that's why she points it out..

[@cuteotaku1997]

Yes breathy singing can sound nice to some people, it's a preference. It shouldn't be used when ones vocal techniques aren't developed, it's a stylistic choice meant to be used by experienced singers. ^^

[@ashablue78]

TheTappss yeah but every genre has a different kind is singing. There’s a reason why R&B singers don’t sing like Classical singers. There are definitely some things in technique that are universal, but some are made for stylistic choices

[@TheTappss]

Asha Blue yes, I definitely agree that they are stylistic choices made by the singer, but my point is that the whole series (in my understanding) is about these guests analysing proper technique in singing (not classical). And, in the past, they've appreciated singers with good support and clarity in voice. A few singers in this performance video don't have those skills which are necessary for you to be called a good vocalist (not artist, performer, singer), and that's why they are pointing it out. I thought that their job was to analyse the singer's techniques irrespective of the genre that's being sung (I know it's impossible to not consider the genre, but I think basic techniques of breathing, intonation, articulation is used in all genres of music). And, I think they're doing a decent job...

[@rententobi3852]

TheTappss the thing wrong with that is that breathy voice is legit the style of the song. Other of her songs are different.

[@ainrsttt]

Well well... I love IU above anyone else in the music industry. She's queen in my heart. I love her, genuinely. BUT, in that song, she does use that "breathing technique" a lot. It goes with the flow of the song. If you want to hear proper technique, listen to other songs who don't have this ultra-sad vibe. In Dear Name, at the end, when the song climaxes, you can clearly hear her voice using proper technique. What I love about her is that she's actually able to change her voice depending on the vibe of the song/moment. Best exemple is Dear Name : You want all that technique, powerful and strong vocals ? Last chorus of Dear Name. If you want something very emotionnal, expressing deep sadness, weakness, that's the main vibe of the song. If you listen to Ending Scene, she uses this breathy technique as the song is really sad, expression almost despair. She even makes her voice crack at a particular moment in the song to express how heart broken she is. IU is not only a good and strong vocalist, but she is also good at conveying emotions. And also, most vocalist tend to restrain their abilites on this show (because otherwise you're considered as rude to show off in front of amateurs). So people should also take that in consideration.

[@lpadgett23]

this. so much this. It’s decisions she’s making depending on the need of the song and of the performance/space she’s in.

[@Ilog-bf3vm]

So many pressed people in the comments just because their fave isn't getting praised to high heavens. What I love about this channel is that they never pander to the "fans", and remain true to their opinions. This is what I watch this channel for, and I hope they never change. Fightingggg!!!

[@yuratchkaplisetskys3063]

Exactly! This channel is all about musicians reacting and critiquing the performances they're shown. It's obvious that the singers performing are lacking in technique, so it's no surprise that the musicians comment on that. I don't think all the pressed people understand that they can still like an artist and their singing even if their technique isn't great.

[@AegyoKpop913]

Yes!

[@lpadgett23]

But the guys at least, they were just complaining for like half the episode? They were barely even paying attention for lots of it

[@kamabokogonpachiro142]

i hope kevin would react to this . he's more open . these reactors nah like seriously i cried listening to this and im not even korean . they're not even paid attention to the harmony . this collab was so beautiful .

[@katrinaleebaldwin4660]

For the love of God and all those wearing headphones please do not let her eat whatever he is eating again while filming. All that smacking, slurping, and crunching ain't necessary.

[@aliciadelemus938]

Estoy de acuerdo. Encuentro de muy mala educación que esté comiendo mientras graban la reacción.

[@juliall255]

Katrina LeeBaldwin She can do whatever the fuck she wants.

[@isaaccastro4846]

IU knows their audience......so clever my girl. Dear name such a pretty song it always hit me in the feelings

[@cloudy762]

Tbh, I accept slander because i mean everyone has different opinions and you're allowed to express them. But the one song I can not stand anyone talking shit about is Dear Name. The context, the lyrics and the way she delivers the emotions go straight to your soul. I'm sure they didn't have lyrics or know the context, but I do think for this song....that was really needed.

[@tarikbensalem8523]

Iu is a queen you need to react to her modern times album and her “a flower bookmark album”

[@jamesrawlins735]

Jihyo Twice •o• They reacted to Red Shoes

[@bushyhs7942]

ok but they were being so rude wtf

[@juliall255]

Cuteness Overload Get over it. I love IU too but these are their opinions as classical vocalists and they can say what they like due to the accurate studying they've done

[@yvonne6374]

I also thought so but they have a point.

[@ramilitoa.magadiajr5474]

Yeah right..

[@richardhague801]

a reminder that young people learning something, always think they're experts. i'm sure the narrow-mindedness is such an influence on your own creativity

[@minak6169]

Richard Hague These people have actually been trained. They're literally studying music in college.

[@richardhague801]

these people are actually 'being' trained - they are 'in the process' of studying music and they will continue to learn long after their formal education finishes. learning the best way to draw a straight line doesn't make you appreciate art, learning the correct ratio of ingredient in a recipe doesn't make you appreciate a taste. these guys argue that professionals who make artistic decisions are wrong (not specifically in this video but throughout this whole series) just because they're learning one discipline in an educational environment. In my experience (and I've been connected to the music industry in my country for nearly 2 decades) professionals tend to raise up their fellow artists rather than criticize their work. judging IU's artistic choice of who is best to compliment her in a duo as wrong, and even going so far as to say IU would have been in last place for vocal ability is immature and rude and a prime example of how ignorant some of these 'students' are.

[@minak6169]

Richard Hague The series really isn't that deep. It's only a KZbin channel which they do for fun and clearly they have a lot of support to do so. The entire concept of this channel is to give their unfiltered views rather than sugarcoat to pander to the audience. If you want a reaction channel like that then there are plenty out there that would suit your tastes. As a fan of IU I find no issue with them saying any of this as they are entitled to their opinion, whether or not they've finished their education.

[@richardhague801]

yes ofc they're entitled to their opinion, i'm just pointing out that it's from young music students some of whom believe they're experts which is a what this channel plays off of. The whole premise of this channel is that they're students of a prestigious music school viewing the pop music of another culture and compared to other reaction channels this is deeper than most. Plenty of these reactors recognise and point out the things that set kpop apart. They're amazed at the different approaches producers have to music from the west and they praise creativity and ability ...and then there are those that don't. Those that offer insights into what makes kpop unique are the reason I'm here, I don't need to be shepherded off to other channels thanks.

[@NaraKwonPoD]

mina k nice job ignoring the entire argument you started. true talent.

[@hobi-hoejung5505]

This is just proof that everyone has different opinions of what a good singer is. Hahaha. Kinda didn't find it cool how spiteful they were being when IU didn't pick who they want but understandble. I get that way too MOST of the time with singing-comps. And I know that IU is a straight hippie and she finds the diamond in the rough. ☺

[@hobi-hoejung5505]

Overall, she's looking for the one who can pair and match her voice. Not necessarily the one with the BEST voice, it's not that kind of comp. The one with the best voice for HER voice. Lol. 'Fantastic Duo' guys.

[@juliall255]

Hobi-Hoe Jung They never said she wasnt a good singer it was her APPROACH they differed on.

[@hobi-hoejung5505]

@@juliall255 they did remark on her singing and it was out of spite, or it better have been because no one says IU isn't a good singer. She's an exceptional singer.

[@juliall255]

ONE person did and she did say later on that IU has a ''gorgeous'' voice. It was out of annoyance really that is shared with most of us on how IU ditched taekwondo girl, who freaking slayed. But I get IU's reasoning for it. People are allowed to get annoyed. I love IU but I could understand the girl's comment. I actually like her opinion because she comments on the technique of each of the voices too and she does hate the breathy style singers do sure, but she gave a justified and technical reason for it. She said her preference is when IU actually closes her vocal chords from air so she can actually hear her sing. Its not like she just slagged IU throughout. Everyone was frustrated here because we're all human after all so its hard to stay neutral. IU is my bae but I still think they had some rational arguments here and it all comes down to preference. IU is surprising to me bcz i prefer more alto- singers like Lee Hi and Taeyeon but I still love IU who may not have the same range as them but she can still hold her own cause her songs allow her unqiue voice to shine even more than theirs do sometimes. Compared to Twice's video, this is pretty constructive. Although I understand their reaction Twice - who I dont hate but Im not really a fan of bcz I dont like excessive aegyo. Another reason as to why i like IU so much bcz she hates being forced to be excessively cute too. She doesnt have to be though, she;'s naturally adorable Please dont hate on them cause I think they did what this video is supposed to be about. Bearing in mind, they are not biased too cause they are into the kpop fandom world which is better.

[@juliall255]

If anything its Umu's fault for not telling ALL of them that IU had an intention to lose bcz she didnt want to be there in the first place

[@selenalimon3622]

I tend to enjoy the reactions from this channel but the way some of the people disrespected IU made me upset.

[@lilaznyume]

Is anyone else annoyed? I can't stand it when people talk with their mouth full when they are eating.

[@ramilitoa.magadiajr5474]

Their just giving their opinion but no one knows what the video is all about..

[@maddie-lo3dj]

Annie Nguyen omg right

[@tanyavu5689]

People, please look at the title of the video. It’s “classical vocalists react”. It is supposed to be about K-pop vocal performances through the eyes of classical vocalists. So please don’t hate the reactors even though you disagree with their opinions.

[@snflwrchan8019]

the reason why iu chose the dentist was because she also thought that his performance in good day lacked but saw his potential so she wanted to hear more from him. the taekwondo girl would overpower iu's voice thats why she wasnt picked.

[@PheelingCool]

I'm pretty triggered with how narrow minded most of their opinions are.

[@juliall255]

PheelGood Inc No you're triggered with how they arent sucking up to your fave. Suck it up. They are trained vocalists, we are not. Technically we are the narrowminded ones due to our absence of training, knowledge etc

[@LK-xk4nh]

@@juliall255 look, being a trained vocal doesn't give you the right to be rude. I'm a trained vocal and a vocal teacher but I'm not going to insult people, just give constructive criticism. And it has nothing to do with sucking up to anyone's fave.

[@ramilitoa.magadiajr5474]

Yeah...

[@lalrinpuiiralte3712]

Whats so great about hitting high notes all the time. I would not even feel like listening to that for a whole 10 mins. But IU definitely 365 days a year .

[@julynightowl7413]

I dont like how they reacted in this so imma leave. Didnt finish the reaction and just watched again the original. They talked too much about technicalities in singing. I get it, we are watching classical musicians react but I think their opinions are way out of line. Id prefer an artist who connects her emotions w the audience than an artist who perfectly knows about singing but w no sincerity.

[@AegyoKpop913]

4th prince So that’s completely subjective, I respect your opinion, but this is classical vocalists react, which means they are trained... it was obvious they would point out their techniques

[@meomeomeo7917]

Bless all the IU vids and the reactions we've been waiting a whole year!!! Can't wait for the "dlwlrma" and "PSAU" next week! Really enjoy these episodes but I wish you had shown them IU's "Love Alone" performance, it was my favorite :(

[@greenygrass7932]

yasss 'love alone' performance on fantastic duo was superb

[@YourName-yt9pe]

This is criticism not a reaction. 😂

[@fluffymoonbunny]

*👑Queen IU👑* The drama tho 😂

[@ibelieveinyourgalaxy]

Lol I felt their rage when IU did that as well.

[@myfairyjinani1602]

I am so sorry but can she finish her snack first then reacting or just eat later after reacting,,?? I miss the old Reactor’s,,😪😪😪

[@hr6439]

Lol she is one of the old reactors

[@JessJalepeno]

Yeah, the way she was eating and talking was pissing me off the entire video. Ugh

[@amberhurtado3692]

She’s doing this out of her own free time y’all, they’re supposed to talk about their opinions through the video. Let them live a little 🙄

[@clairesouppie8812]

I just wanna say the point of this show is to find which voice suits IU's voice the most, NOT who sings the best. I know her voice might not be too powerful and sometimes be criticized as well. Everyone has different opinions, which makes you guys distinct from other reactors. But for me, i'd prefer listen to her moderate but deeply emotional voice rather than powerful but emotionless one.

[@hyunjoon.watterson]

Sohyang- MonaLisa, Lean on Me, bridge over troubled water

[@30pokerface30]

They're missing the point of the show!!! It's Fantastic Duo!!! IU is looking for the best one to compliment with her singing. And the song..... it's supposed to be emotional and IU's style is intimate and perfect for that. They don't know anything I'm upset :/

[@purpleworld08]

I have a whole ass music degree and everyone but the guys in the red and green shirts were decent. Y’all are pretentious and rude af. This is why no one fucks with vocalist. They should know how the dynamics of this works and IU isn’t going in because she is listening. Dude. Get off your high horse.

[@kenchedaroy]

just saw this video, and I was like...duh? do you even know the context of the song? the show? I mean yeah, you're more on the technicality of the singing part, but I guess singing is not all about technicalities...your reactions just show how different IU is compared to other singers. She's a great singer. She sings with her heart.

[@rizzaaaa]

I'VE BEEN READY FOR THIS SINCE LAST YEAR!!! IU AND HER FANBOYS, SLAY! NO MATTER WHAT THEY SAY. 💜💜💜 p.s. Not a fan of this reaction at all to be honest because they seemed harsh towards non-classically trained performers/fans, but to each their own.

[@VeryMuchConfused]

I must say the three guys being chosen was he biggest plot twist ive ever seen

[@イト奈々絵]

This video is my favorite one out of all reaction videos these people have made so far. Hugo and Jeremy were so funny hahahahahaha and honestly I TOTALLY relate to their feeling LMAOOOOOOOO

[@FlavioNoNavio]

i LOVE how each pair of reactors has a completely different opinion on who should have been picked lmao

[@mythrin]

IU's lyrics are a huge part of what makes her music good, not just her vocals.

[@TheSkaterskool]

The cuss counter deserves 10 likes xD

[@secondculs]

ikr xD

[@lchow95]

I'm living for the drama 😂😂😂

[@LINDSEYLWLW]

Y’all this is CLASSICAL vocalists reacts, not “random listener who gives uneducated opinions on singing”.

[@yuratchkaplisetskys3063]

LOUDER FOR THE PEOPLE IN THE BACK 👏👏👏👏

[@pedrofelipemedice]

yes, and they are classical musicians reacting. Technically, IU voice has POOR technique. its a fact. it's not like they do not like her ar all (by the way, they've analyzed her mvs before that day)

[@bellota_miau]

I think that the auditions videos that the 3 man send also made her choose them. Watch that video and you'll understand.

[@francesberrios8250]

This reaction had me in stitches. Everyone was so invested in their choices.

[@deandamendozanormaangelica2666]

OMG, I NEEED THE PART 3 !! RIGHT NOW

[@MineHacksPvP]

She's experienced enough to be able to sing stylistically.

[@yuratchkaplisetskys3063]

She really isn't. IU still has issues in properly supporting her notes, instead constantly opting for a breathy unsupported sound. This is not good for her voice and can damage it in the long run. Sure, it sounds nice but her technique is still poor.

[@amys6987]

I will say... the final duet between iu and the winner really is beautiful. Hopefully they enjoy it!

[@helloitscindybby]

I didn't finish this video... I am very disappointed how rude they were. Honestly I really love this channel, but seeing them being rude and all makes me not want to keep and update with this anymore...

[@TeddyGom91]

show them the short duet the guard and IU did before the elimination round started.. :D

[@Qwerky396]

2:08 when you realize that this song was written for the sewol ferry incident...

[@cheesymac3121]

You should show them videos of IU's actual performances 😍😍

[@spress15]

IU's performances in this Fantastic Duo program? Or IU's music videos? Because they have already reacted to a lot of her MVs.

[@hanng1242]

1. The security guard sort of looks like Eric Nam. 2. Why did the camera cut to Psy? Is he a special guest judge or something? 1A. EDIT- nevermind. I guess that basketball player was there too. 3. Does this video demonstrate that "good singing" is completely subjective? How can none of these groups of classically-trained vocalists trained at the same school agree with each other?

[@a.teotico]

Psy is IU's competitor on that show.

[@hanng1242]

Annie Teotico Ah. I guess that explains his outfit.

[@takoyakai7211]

Han Ng Since this is a competition, IU was going against Psy, that’s why he is there xD and also the “basket ball guy” aka Seo Jang Hoon was there as part of Psy’s supportive team. And the way from I see it, the different pairs of reactors weren’t looking at the video in the same mind set lol. One pair were focused on stage presence, another focused on solely the voices, and a pair that looks at who’s going to get chosen for the last round.

[@hanng1242]

[KTP] Aoi I can't seem to remember his name. Cricket forever!

[@tomhannah3825]

[KTP] Aoi What?? That's way more complicated than I thought. I feel misled. I thought it was all about the voices.

[@katiarios7706]

Could you please react to Fantastic Duo whit the singer Lee Moon Sae it will be amazing or Lee Sun Hee pleaseeee

[@bluishviolett]

Lee Moon Sae's performances are the bests

[@anastasyavie6236]

right, Lee Moon Sae and Lee Sun Hee or even Yoon Book Hee ftw!

[@marialujancaruso7532]

*stares right into the camera* can you believe this guy LMAOOO

[@SUJUdNPP]

I don't know what technique is supposed to be wrong or right. She sings this song in many different way i think by the mood or music arrangement like in the Melon Music Award she sang it emotionally but powerful which is different from this stage. If you have time I would like you guy to check it out. Anyway I still like how she sing because I can feel what she wants to express to the audience. Ps. Thank you for making this content. I still like to watch it ^ ^

[@SnowCrasher]

Please be aware that Fantastic Duo is not about picking the person who sings the best, but the person the main singer wants to duet with the most. The voice has to mesh well with the singer and also their performance/vibe/emotion should be in tune with each other. They only have very little time to practice once they are picked, so it has to be someone that can also handle the last minute arrangement. Also, they tend to pick the one that would fit the final song the most. They could sing the first two songs perfectly, but might not be suitable for the final duet song.

[@joeypow2043]

This probably is the funniest and most fun videos I’ve watched from react to the k :)

[@Anessanevaeh]

In my opinion the REAL definition of a musician is someone who loves all types of music/genres IU is very talented and I wish you gave them a little more context about the song ”dear name” because the meaning behind it is beautiful.

[@johnwoka9272]

Okay the black guy and his partner were hilarious i love them:))))) i enjoyed this

[@Dramalandkimchi]

Lol...the outrage

[@Gretaisworking]

they are totally justified for being angry. i honestly think a part of her didnt want to be outshone by the taekwondo girl

[@downthispath6538]

Because that's the point of the show? Lmao. This show is called fantastic Duo. It's to pick someone who can blend well with the singer's voice because at the end of the show, they will compete with the other guest singer and his chosen contestant. They are not justified for being angry. It's Umu's fault for not giving context. This isn't to choose the best contestant, it's to choose the one who will best complement the singer's voice so they can win over the other singer-contestant pair.

[@KreaTiefpunkt]

"He just went to falsetto on the most important note!!!" Literally me every time I expect a powerful belt and instead get a weak falsetto.

[@dots_com1386]

Have you done the Taeyang Fantastic Duo, or is it on your list? The final performance is epic!

[@stillfangirlingtoday1468]

Please let them react to IU Dear Name Melon Awards performance, that is so touching!

[@lostgirl1409]

Isn't it funny that each pair had their own ideas which were exactly the opposite of what the other pairs said 😅

[@CindyCherrywood]

A suggestion for new video idea, if you could have them react to their stage performances! I suggest showing them stage mixes so they can appreciate the choreography while the outfits are changed.

[@CindyCherrywood]

This is one I suggest from dreamcatcher. It's flawlessly transitioned. kzbin.info/www/bejne/gKTEkGaOhLOqhq8

[@ravensebastian3746]

I Also think that the Dentist Guy doesnt Deserved to be in The Final 3 But I didnt like How You said all those words to him while he was Singing Dude That Man Can sing but the problem Was Not In him Its probably The song Choice Of IU doesnt really Fit in everyones Range Like Him I definetly Think The Dentist guy has a Baritone range But The Song Requires A Tenor range for It to be sing Completly Clean thats why The Guys didnt sound The best in here

[@ayoitsbellee]

Good techniques and voice isn't enough to make people listen to music. Hope you know that. I understand that you are a musician but, hey, you should know that when you sing without emotion, no one or less people will listen to you. I also don't understand why you are being harsh on her? She's not in her good shape when she attended this show and FYI, the show and PSY, convinced her a lot of times just to be on the show, she's not IU for nothing. The comment is very rude, this is a reaction video, but it's below the belt. Hearing those curse words, make me think if you are really a musician or just some kind of dude who unintentionally heard a kpop song then throw some shitty word, cause they don't understand the song. S

[@fluffymoonbunny]

Loving the saltiness 😂😂😂

[@SkyTessaPrincess]

please react to kyuhyun on vocalists react !

[@gaslight_gatekeep_girlboss3732]

I feel like their opinions got swayed immediately because of their previous picks. The comments weren’t as constructive but rather dissy with no respect to other singing styles. Breathy vocals is not a sign of vocal weakness but rather a tool to show emotions. I came here for the usual educational classical music input but rather just felt uncomfortable from the close-minded comments. Super disappointed.

[@johnkim9556]

Not sure where I can put requests, but any chance can you compare older stuff like Brown Eyes With Coffee or Already One Year versus For You?

[@twentysevenand]

I thought the dentist had the most interesting color out of the 5 from the beginning, so I understand what that one reactor was talking about. Also, thank you, Umu, for correcting and always saying tae kwon do instead of karate. I felt like it was really respectful of you to do that.

[@sarxh]

i cant find part 3:(

[@JayHanju]

3:15 .. I'm disappointed with this guy ... do u guys not realize that they *Are Not PROFESSIONALY TRAINED?!?!?* ..... 😐😐😑

[@thedoorofhaikyuu8234]

I love how everyone has so many different opinions

[@DemonPoo]

The incredibly negative blonde woman shovelling food into her mouth is the reason I will stop watching this channel.

[@DemonPoo]

And she is speaking with food in her mouth. Why is she not edited out? Ugh

[@joshualegaspi9206]

exactly, every video i see her in, she has nothing nice to say

[@sankalpdatal3039]

all of the guys talks over the security guy part so naturally.

[@minak6169]

6:13 I think I died laughing

[@LCe110]

I love these competitions!

[@huangcjz]

Re: cheek-bones - James has the most vertiginous cheek-bones that I have ever had the privilege of witnessing. He's just so handsome and intense! Also, lol at none of them agreeing on their opinions of the singers.

[@JessiEche]

Hugo’s cuss count was 17 but Umu added her own to make it 18 lol

[@Sandra-et4tw]

9:50 aint that the truth "coughPRODUCE101x2coughANDLIKELY48coughcough*

[@sc-wq2tu]

honestly, kpop stans... can't hear criticism from people who understand what it is to have a good singing technique that they go berserk. breathiness in singing isn't good for your throat/vocal chords so even if it's stylistic and for emotional purposes it's still damaging and hello! these are classical vocalists who are judging vocal skills and in the end they have an opinion and different preferences but above all they're classically trained and have a pretty good idea of what they're talking about