Thank you all for such a memorable year @Pies Footy family! If you want to further support the channel, consider joining the 'Champ Pie' membership which will set you back $5 a month - kzbin.info/door/I2TswI5baxbRfA23nKakSwjoin
@arlohealy61502 ай бұрын
You left out though Dayne Beams to Brisbane for Pick 5 (De Goey and the steak knife Crisp)
@PiesFooty2 ай бұрын
My bad hahaha yikes!
@arlohealy61502 ай бұрын
All good. Your doing a great job with your channel
@PiesFooty2 ай бұрын
@@arlohealy6150 thanks Arlo! Did you get to go the game on the weekend? Or are you interstate based?
@arlohealy61502 ай бұрын
I am Melbourne based and go every game I am close to 50 years of age so this digital world is all new to me but I like many am knee deep in the love for the club. I have a knowledge of a lot of history of the club so if you need any suggestions or bits and pieces to help your channel feel free to to reach out - keep following your dreams and goals with the channel
@Magpie_Mark922 ай бұрын
They ripped us off back a few years later
@Comatosedpeanut2 ай бұрын
Jimmy clement. What a star.
@MJK24072 ай бұрын
That Jamie Elliott goal after the siren was on my birthday! Very special present as a pies fan that despises essendon
@TheLaughingMagpie2 ай бұрын
1 Jack Crisp 2 Jamie Elliott 3 Bobby Hill 4 Darcy Cameron 5 Jeremy Howe 6 Travis Varcoe 7 Tom Mitchell 8 Jordan Roughead 9 Patrick Lipinski 10 Levi Greenwood
@kelstra19972 ай бұрын
I pretty much agree with your list Laughing, particularly Jack Crisp and Darcy Cameron.
@Comatosedpeanut2 ай бұрын
James clement was vice captain of Collingwood and won two best and fairests as a defender and was a two time all Australian I believe. He’s without a doubt better than half the players on this list.
@TheLaughingMagpie2 ай бұрын
@@Comatosedpeanut we gave up pick 8 for him
@Comatosedpeanut2 ай бұрын
@@TheLaughingMagpie we did but we also got Brodie holland. Both played over 100 games for the pies. We gave up pick 25 for geeenwood, who was good, but not half the player clement was. Clement was also a better player than Daniel Motlop who was pick 8 in that draft.
@AndrewDyson-u2u23 сағат бұрын
Varcoe was next level useless and spent most of the game running around doing effectively nothing
@iiWiLlIaMsOn2 ай бұрын
It’s been said multiple times in the comments already but I got to #2 and said to myself “By process of elimination Jack Crisp is #1” and was surprised to see he wasn’t on this list
@PiesFooty2 ай бұрын
Total mistake on my behalf!
@arlohealy61502 ай бұрын
Great job. Dereck Hine has had a lot more hits than misses
@chunkyau36142 ай бұрын
Hoskin-Elliott's another one that pies fans have loved, having a great 2024 season as well.
@TheLaughingMagpie2 ай бұрын
@@chunkyau3614 he is and he is but what we gave up ended up being Noah Balta, not really a steal in hindsight
@Comatosedpeanut2 ай бұрын
@@TheLaughingMagpiewe wouldn’t have picked up balta with that pick anyway.
@marnuscoreyempanadaslooseb6760Ай бұрын
Tom Mitchell should be top 5 and higher than Bobby Hill. One of the very best exponents ever at what he does. Collingwood doesn’t win without Mitchell in 2023, made all the more evident considering how poor the Pies midfield was this year with him injured. Don’t think it was necessary for my Hawks to get rid of Titch, would be a lot more confident going into this Friday’s night elimination final with Tom Mitchell in our side.
@kevsmagpies13062 ай бұрын
Great video mate I remember Anthony Rocca I’ve seen him kick four goals in 2002 grand final and kicking big goals I love him
@PiesFooty2 ай бұрын
@@kevsmagpies1306 thanks Kev you legend!
@kelstra19972 ай бұрын
Let's not forget the last one he kicked that was called a behind. Luke Power admits it was a goal.
@kelstra19972 ай бұрын
Another great effort Anthony - as I often say, I don't know how you find the time. Having said that, I don't know how Jack Crisp isn't in there. I would actually have him at No. 1. They paid nothing for him really and he used to be referred as 'steak knives' - just a deal sweetener. I'm not sure that the Pies would have won the Grand Final without him and let's remember he's played God only knows how many games in a row.
@PiesFooty2 ай бұрын
Totally mistake on my end re Jack crisp!! Easily number 1 just ahead of Elliot.
@hijaudragon2 ай бұрын
Great video but we traded for Rocca in 1996.
@PiesFooty2 ай бұрын
Damn how did I miss that 😅😅
@gwhwheheheh2 ай бұрын
Well now you’ve gone and done one of the wort trades of all time trading a 1st round pick for Lachie schultz
@toddmillar40412 ай бұрын
Two first rounders for Trelor
@tommyandrewd2 ай бұрын
Could be wishful thinking I feel Schultz will after another pre season at the Pies have a better year in 2025.
@Comatosedpeanut2 ай бұрын
@@tommyandrewdstill won’t be worth a top ten pick
@clumeroo2 ай бұрын
Dont underestimate what the father son rule has done to keep the pies relevant over the years
@alandoherty13322 ай бұрын
What about Luke Ball? Good video👍🔥👍😎
@PiesFooty2 ай бұрын
He was picked up in the national draft after his contract ended with the saints!
@zsjh68592 ай бұрын
People forget the GIANTS tried everything to keep Bobby Hill, didn’t trade him the first time he asked out…
@GinoMunari2 ай бұрын
Seriously? How do you leave out Jack Crisp?? Would be top 3 or 5. How good have his finals performances been?
@PiesFooty2 ай бұрын
He is unreal. I completely forgot about him!!
@Magpie_Mark922 ай бұрын
We could've stolen Stevie J in 2006 for pick 30 but the stupid club doctor talked them out of it
@thedoc19772 ай бұрын
Bobby hill kicked 4 goals in the grand final not 5
@BlueWinter222 ай бұрын
Jack crisp #1 cmon!! Mr.Steak Knives not even a mention. Hard to take a video like this seriously
@PiesFooty2 ай бұрын
Complete mistake on my end
@denisjeux10202 ай бұрын
Billy elliot was pre listed by gold coast not GWS
@PiesFooty2 ай бұрын
Wrong
@denisjeux10202 ай бұрын
@PiesFooty are you sure didn't he come pre-listed with Andrew krakouer from the suns for more picks
@lucasm83202 ай бұрын
The steak knife is surely at 1.
@PiesFooty2 ай бұрын
Yeah missed him somehow 😅
@arlohealy61502 ай бұрын
Another good trade was Tarrant to Fremantle for pick 8 (Ben Reid) and Paul Medhurst
@PiesFooty2 ай бұрын
Very true! That’s a good ROI
@toddmillar40412 ай бұрын
I was looking to see if Medhurst was mentioned. Had all the ability but no consistency at Freo but hardened up at the pies, tackled better was a lot less flashy but a lot more consistent. One of the best deliverers inside 50, mastered the across the body 45 degree kick
@daicosdemis2 ай бұрын
I can only assume you don't remember much of J Clement, he was the best of the lot, would have him at 1.
@PiesFooty2 ай бұрын
I must admit. I’m 97 born so was hard to get a gage!
@toddmillar40412 ай бұрын
That's a good call
@Comatosedpeanut2 ай бұрын
Think we traded a top ten pick for James clement but he was a gun for us.
@toddmillar40412 ай бұрын
@Comatosedpeanut close it was pick 8 for Celement and Holland. If you count games and BnF votes you would take that from pick 8 every day of the week
@thegoochinc53592 ай бұрын
Ah Jack Crisp?
@PiesFooty2 ай бұрын
@@thegoochinc5359 I know I know haha my bad I malfunctioned lmao