Commander Game - Muldrotha, BeamTown Bullies, Captain Nghathrod, Edgar Markov - EDH Format

[@estefanalbarran7889]

That Beamtown bullies deck had me stop and look for info. This is the type of commander I like. I might build it

[@brandyourfan9244]

Great match guys. The end was a little anticlimactic, but it was still cool to see. Keep up the great work!

[@maxahlse8522]

Got randomly recommend to your channel and I must say: keep it up! Nice and easy to follow gameplay, really liked the arrows indicating attacks and the triggers on card text! Some constructive criticism might be that you can keep the played cards on screen until the the next one is played. Makes it a bit easier to follow for less entrenched players. Subscribed!

[@mostlycasualcommander]

Welcome aboard!

[@bend5963]

Never seen that loop before. Good game!

[@TripsAhoy]

Happy Sunday!!! Say hello to Meatball for me!

[@mibbzx1493]

That was a good play around eater of days because your life was going to be miserable for 2 turns 🤣

[@nilshaukeholtfester9198]

Didn't knew the combo with kayas ghostform😍 thanks

[@ryanalexanderkovacs]

Comboooooooo. Great game guys!

[@jessesandburg]

I thought Teferi's protection doesn't phase the player out just the permanents? Meaning you can really dodge the eater of days? I'm probably wrong.

[@mostlycasualcommander]

Hello there! Tef’s protection gives protection from everything to the casting player, so beamtown could no longer target BK with its ability

[@MadHashashin]

Problem is the "Target" in Bullies' ability. If it was "Chosen player" it probably would resolve, since it's not a targeting ability.

[@MRProtector124]

He could have activated beamtown bullies before his untap step couldn’t he!

[@donnext4008]

nice work

[@mostlycasualcommander]

Thanks!

[@natsukisubaru1732]

Markov deck list says it was updated 11 months ago but this video is 5 months old? Would building that deck now be considered outdated too old or is it still good?

[@PaulusCunctator]

A couple thoughts, correct me if I'm wrong because I'm still new: At 4:50, you couldn't steal the Chasm Skulker because Captivating Vampire (and the associated token) are still summoning sick until the beginning of your turn, right? At 6:30 before phasing out with Teferi, you could've tapped to snag another creature before you were going to phase out until your next start phase anyways, right? If you took the Beamtown Bullies, would that have messed with the resolution of their ability since you'd no longer be the Bullies' opponent? Loved the game, I'd really enjoy seeing more Edgar in particular, they're just something so satisfyingly honest about swinging big vampires at the enemy's face.

[@digitalk1llraymon448]

So the wording on the abilities is what you gotta look for to answer this. For the Captivating Vampire the wording on the card say "Tap five untapped vampires you control" tapping those 5 is the cost of the ability when its on the stack. If he had the "Tap" symbol on his text, then you would be correct, because he has to tap as an additional cost to tapping the 5 vampires. Once it's on the stack, youre tapping him as a requirement for paying for said ability. For the Bullies, Once the ability is on the stack, it belongs to whoever activated the ability, not the creature. This means that even if they take your creature in response. in the stack the ability still says "Target opponent". However IF the card said "The controler of (X card's) opponent" meaning that whoever CONTROLLED the card at the moment of resolution would not be the opponent as you stated initially.

[@fwop7436]

@@digitalk1llraymon448 damn, what a great answer!

[@karsmatt]

im a little confused about the combo at the end, id love if someoen could explain. muldrotha only lets you play 1 card of every permanent type per turn right? so why can you infinitely play the kayas ghostform and that mana artifact? also, why did that damage the opponents? was it cause of sir konrad? if anyone knows id be v happy to hear

[@GeneralGlitter55]

I think its something that makes them mil out

[@bearclash48]

I thought that with muldrotha you can only cast each permanent type once per turn?

[@beefsupreme5563]

It’s a new muldrotha every time so other than lands you get new instances of her ability.

[@mostlycasualcommander]

Hello there! So, that’s correct, however, when muldrotha dies and then is brought back to the battlefield, muldrotha doesn’t see the cards previously cast by muldrotha before dying. It sort of “forgets” what was cast using its ability each time it returns to the battlefield. Therefore it works. But yes if muldrotha wasn’t dying repeatedly, it can only cast one card of each type.

[@bearclash48]

@@mostlycasualcommander ah i got it. Thanks!

[@Foetoid2k6]

You guys play spelltable?

[@dakotarumery8425]

Where did hunter get the playmat?

[@mostlycasualcommander]

www.inkedgaming.com/products/mushrooms-playmat?variant=40317889446088 🥳

[@dakotarumery8425]

Thank you and my son loves your videos

[@nemesist-type4294]

So who chooses the creature for beamtown the opponent or the controller

[@asheketchupp206]

The controller

[@Aeleus123]

You shouldn't of been able to respond after seeing what he used with beamtown. You should of responded before the resolution of the ability.

[@mostlycasualcommander]

Hello there! Beamtown bullies says to target a player as well as a card in your graveyard. Do both of those things happen at the same time then? Would love clarity on that. Thanks!

[@Belena711]

@@mostlycasualcommander You played it correctly. The ability is activated, goes onto the stack with both the player AND the creature targeted, and you can respond before it resolves. Fun game, btw. :) I've been subscribed for a long time, but I don't comment much - I'll change that to help boost those stats. 👍

[@FFMajorEMT17]

Infinite combo wins have got to be the lamest part of this game…

[@arcroy7]

Craterhoof/Triumph of the Hordes every game then.

[@tfdrago]

No matter the table, edgar deck ends always as captivating vampire.deck, so boring.

[@MadHashashin]

If you're like me and you don't have it, it's different haha Killed a fella with Immerstrum Predator comboed with Blade of The Bloodchief. Swinging for about 21 dmg