Commander Testing Guide [Why KP ratio can be misleading] Rise of Kingdoms

[@davidw.5185]

At the start of 2024 I had two archer marches. I have none today. Frankly, they are too slow. They are almost always the last to make contact in your field swarm. They wrap too far and get out of position for their speed, they can't escape. My total result improved dramatically when I moved away from archers.

[@everAU2]

What did u do with the gear?

[@user-ez7cx5ro3r]

The wrap is a real problem

[@yuriys5642]

I think it’s possible to capture Philip’s buff impact in reports “theoretically”. If you can fight in very similar fight over many reports with him and without him, you can take stock of overall trade of your 5 matches with and without him, that is total kills to sevs ratio and power ratio. The most realistic way I guess to do this would be to take out from city march with him and without him every other time you go out into any field fighting and then somehow separate reports from both situations (with/ without Philip) into two groups (feature doesn’t exist), that way you have reports split more event across different field situations and if you have a big enough number, I would assume it would produce a decent representation of his overall impact

[@Andi_Lie]

Bro, i run 5 marches Nev Joan, Ragnar Scipio, Liu Alex, Huo Arthur and ZL Hermann. Is it worth to replace Hermann to Philip?

[@Busdriver3092]

@@Andi_Lie no. ZL/Hermann is better

[@terminator6505]

For lc/alex what’s better wedge or arch I have all 4 legendary inscriptions

[@Busdriver3092]

@@terminator6505 arch. But if you have 4 legendary I’d just run that on Ragnar.

[@yuriys5642]

I will say if you get swarmed on the way back it’s part of the game and it will probably happen given way your KD/ you fight. It probably is influenced/ reflects by how slow the march is. I think overall it gives good picture how you specially do with the marches with your playstyle. There were some people that were just cheeseburgering marches for majority of their kill points when Herold came out, and reports will make it look like the best march in the game, and it probably is for their play style. There are many kingdoms and players which refresh marches once they get under 50% and many big kingdoms and players where they play them until dead (Leo would be a lot more useful). I think the context in terms of situation in kvk (underdog or not) and play style are important, but overall results you get from report manager represents the performance of your marches under those conditions fairly accurately

[@ElTurco01]

Why no Liu WW

[@Busdriver3092]

@@ElTurco01 I got 50 GH in and decided to skip him because I think LC/Alex is better and WW wouldn’t be a good long term investment

[@fabiogravano2115]

If you tank and sad face every time LC/Alex or Philip is not that great

[@ramos_pinho117]

With any pair

[@xDread]

That's not how you play LC + Alex/Phillip. LC/Alex is meant to engage and quickly disengage before enough rage is generated for anyone to fire their active skill. You win many short trades with LC's expertise and LC & Alex's on hit effects