Comparing Pat McGrath Labs Moonlit Seduction Against The Rest Of The Motherships

[@MartinaLily]

Hello Friends! I hope you find this helpful. I tried to just really focus on showing the comparisons and not give too much of my opinion in this one as I wanted this to be more of an aid as to whether or not the palette would bring something to your collection. I hope you like it 💗

[@lolaphearse3688]

I absolutely LOVE how beat up ,used and loved your palettes are! I’m way to precious with my makeup and need to really just revel in the beauty and use everything,to honour it’s actual purpose and function. Thanks for all the hard work that went into this comparison!

[@MartinaLily]

Thank you Lola! 💗💗💗

[@stefaniemezigian414]

This is some very thorough swatching! I love looking at all of the Motherships together. They’re like little boxes full of jewels. Thank you for the comparisons!

[@vevans3391]

I just got a screenshot of all the palettes swatched together for future reference. Never seen anyone do this. Thank you!!

[@MartinaLily]

You’re welcome, glad it was helpful ☺️💗

[@brookezab7290]

Yessss! Happy Friday indeed. Love your work 🥳 💃🏻

[@MartinaLily]

You're quick girl!! Thank you 💗💗💗

[@brookezab7290]

@@MartinaLily this was so great!!! I especially loved the swatch photo comparisons of all then at once. Took a big old screenshot of that - what do I need it for? I don’t know. But I need it. P.S. RIP your arm lol

[@alexandreaturcot8921]

You are an Encyclopedia of Pat McGrath! I really appreciate how much work, effort and knowledge you bring to all your videos! Thank you!

[@MartinaLily]

Aw thank you so much! 💗💗💗

[@karensnailstudio7171]

Yay so excited for this!!!! 😍😍😍

[@MartinaLily]

Woo hoo! Thanks Karen! 💗💗💗

[@s.clairegreen9577]

Hi Martina, this process of comparing each to similar was FANTASTIC for educating those of us that are just beginning our PML collections, awesome. To someone who is trying to pick which one i want to add next, but the shades seem so 'same same', this really helps me see how different they are. Excellent content, thank you!!!

[@MartinaLily]

So glad it was helpful! Thank you lovely 💗💗

[@lubazak636]

This is very helpful!!! Thank You. The best shade comparisons of Pat McGrath I have ever seen. I have all the others, so will be picking the Motheship X, but will wait for crazy sale.

[@MartinaLily]

Ohh amazing, im so glad you enjoyed it! 💗💗💗

[@Nina-gf8zr]

Thank you so much! I imagine filming videos like this can get a little tedious but that is such a help for us! Also, who am I kidding, of course I am getting this… Already wondering what next year‘s MS will look like…😄

[@MartinaLily]

Hahhaa I'm wondering what next years will be too! And this years holiday palette. And you're welcome. I actually like filming these don't worry. It's fun to play with all the shadows 💗💗💗

[@Nina-gf8zr]

@@MartinaLily oh yeah, the holiday palette ❤️💜💙!!

[@thedylangirl]

The GUCCI just arrived! 🙌🏼 it’s better than I expected!

[@MartinaLily]

Oh really??? What would you compare the formula too? 💗💗

[@thedylangirl]

@@MartinaLily 🤔 hmmmmm…they’re so much creamier than the first palette. So far I’ve just applied them with my fingers because the texture is so nice. They sort of feel like the Chantecaille single shadows in the glass pots. No skipping and not the powdery texture of the first palette. Again, they’ve gone for a vintage/retro experience and that’s going over some heads. It reminds me of some amazing shadows my mom had when I was little. They nailed vintage. 🙌🏼 The blues were especially gorgeous, lasted hours, and I had zero fallout or transfer; I have very hooded, oily lids. I’ve not yet used any primer. I’m curious to compare with the new PMG mattes, as these are also special mattes.

[@emilycrowell4524]

Oh girl! Yes! I am here for this! 🎉

[@melina_m_makeup]

What an awesome comparison video! I love the new formula but prefer her baked shades for that extra sparkle! But I still dnt have it to compare in person yet. Thank you so much for taking your time to do these videos! I'm sure very similar looks can be made within one's collection without having to break the bank. I guess I'm not rushing to get it just yet nor an I feeling FOMO yet because I have so many of her palettes and that new Sextacy shade is almost an exact dupe of Devinah's Messier shade!! I wanna say Beauty and the Frizz swatched them and they were basically identical and I have the one from Devinah so if anyone is just wanting that special shade try shopping Devinah Cosmetics. She has so many of those super shifty glittery multichromes! I will get the new Mothership tho as soon as Sephora launches it so I can use my Rouge $100 rewards credit n save some money. 😉 thanks again for all ur hard wrk!! Great video!

[@emilycrowell4524]

How do you rack up $100 with points at Sephora? I’m rouge for the first time and I’ve seen people say this but I need to know how!

[@melina_m_makeup]

@@emilycrowell4524 you have to save 2500 points. Look for when u purchase and points are 4x or 5x value or sometime more. Just sign up for emails for those offers. Also I never use my points for the 100 point little samples, I just keep saving. Once u have all your 2500 points you can go to your rewards and purchase the $100 rewards card with your points. I have noticed they are usually available around 10 AM Central std time on Tues or Thursdays

[@lisadukes6471]

Yup Pat McGrath Labs is Something Else and idk but i believe She Repeats certain Shades because in Her Eyes They Flow Together 🛐🕊

[@charlenejensen3559]

I loved this so much. It was amazing seeing all the different Pat shades swatched beside one another. Thank you for two incredible videos on the new Moonlit Seduction Mothership. ❤

[@MartinaLily]

Thank you so much Charlene! 💗💗💗

[@carinekubelec9531]

That was a lot of work, thanks a lot it was amazing 🤗

[@catgandini]

I've been waiting for this one!!!

[@vaniacalveri9002]

Great job Martina! ❤️

[@teresak9543]

It is a beautiful palette and it is clear from the one pic you did with all the palettes compared that this one is unique and I would love to have it, but my question is, is it too shiny for older people? I know older people can wear anything younger people can, but there is a point where it doesn’t look as good on older skin as it does on younger skin. You did a fantastic job as usual!

[@lolyasbel3440]

👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻‼️ I'm new to your channel and it's the best thing I've seen‼️dedication and love in what you do. excellent work. congratulations and blessing🙌🏻🤗‼️

[@MartinaLily]

Aw thank you so so much!! 💗💗💗

[@estefaniarodriguezadalid3386]

Hi Martina!. Great vídeo, amazing! You are like the PML special shadows...so special and dedicated! Thank you for your excellent job, maybe the new pallette will be my first mothership...,😁😁. Kisses from Barcelona, Spain.😘😘🥰

[@MartinaLily]

Aw thank you so so much! That is so kind 💗💗💗

[@zusamy20]

Thank you 😀 I was searching for this

[@donnareed73]

Great video I don’t think I’ve ever seen anyone show all the mothership palettes together like that I paused just to look at them. I’ve never been glitter crazed so I can appreciate this palette for not having so much glitter but being so shiny at the same time. This was fun to watch

[@yulianagonzalez2428]

I know right!!

[@MartinaLily]

Thanks Donna! I'm glad you found it helpful. I like seeing them all next to each other so you can see them all laid out. Makes me realize what I want from future ones too haha 💗💗💗

[@curatedbycristina7923]

This was so helpful, thank you!

[@Spiralyne]

Girl, I totally slid out of watching make-up channels (at least it's been beneficial for my wallet lol 🤣), and now that I'm here I realize how much I've missed you talking about palettes, Pat-palettes above all🥰! I'm glad you didn't let other people's opinions of the Moonlit Seduction color your review video and that you went with your own honest opinion there. Happy to see you like it so much, I still don't have it, and not the Celestial Nirvana either yet. I've now been trying to decide what palette to buy next overall, and thanks to your review vid of Natasha Denona's retro glam, I crossed that one out (Thank you 😄!). Excited to check out your 2022 palette ranking video next 😘

[@MartinaLily]

Aw thank you so much Lina! I totally understand the break on your wallet haha Oh yeah, Retro Glam is just ok, also I don't recommend Nirvana unless you love color. Obvs I do recommend this one tho hahaha 💗💗💗

[@Spiralyne]

@@MartinaLily Oh I love color, so I'm sure I'll buy it at some point in time, perhaps not just now! Many of us have missed those mattes of different colors than pink and brown from Pat, so in a way I think she has listened to her fans which is honorable. Will of course check out your review one more time before I buy

[@abbracia]

Thank you for all the hard work! This video has been very helpful for me.

[@MartinaLily]

Thank you! 💗💗💗

[@tirshasmith5999]

All Pat content, all Martina. I’m here for it. 😘 Thank you for this my lovely

[@yulianagonzalez2428]

Absolutely helpful video that’s why I subscribe to your channel for this comparison videos and I being learning a lot from you😘😘😘

[@MartinaLily]

Thank you so much Yuliana! 💗💗💗

[@BethaneyLilly]

Excellent breakdown of shades! I also appreciate each mothership for what it is I love how she keeps evolving & improving the formulas. I’m someone who works from several palettes to get the look I want, however I find with the motherships I don’t necessarily find I have to, they are exceptionally curated and each one really does have its own “personality” …lol

[@dubsbeautydiary]

Super helpful! Very in depth. I love it. I’m falling more and more in love with the new palette.

[@mintkandi22]

Thank you for the swatches! I missed the sale for the Moonlit Seduction palette so I won't get the discount. I'm going to get this palette! It's gorgeous! When I get it, it will be my fifth Mothership palette!

[@loreniarangel3027]

SOOO helpful!! Thanks this video is amazing

[@MartinaLily]

I’m so glad! Thank you 💗💗💗

[@kathleenkaffeine8696]

this is an amazing reference video thank you so so much!

[@julianaaoki327]

Wonderful video, loved your comparisons!

[@EmilysMakeupBag1]

This was so helpful!!

[@MartinaLily]

Thanks lovely! 💗💗💗

[@LisaF_]

This was so helpful! Thank you for doing all of these!!

[@MartinaLily]

You're so welcome! 💗💗💗

[@ct7531]

Great video, thanks.

[@tianiortiz8529]

Thank you! I’m a collector as well but I just wait for them to go on sale.

[@sayura93]

I'm really curious how the douchrome special shade compares to the duochrome one in Celestial Odyssey. I know that one isn't as glittery and not a special shade, but the shift seems very similar.

[@MartinaLily]

Ohh hmm the Sextasy shade with the brown duochrome in Odyssey? I did swatch that one but I think I compared it to the bronze shade cos they seemed similar to me. But I may have the wrong shade completely sorry 💗💗💗

[@michellemakeuptutorials]

this video is truly top notch helpful thank you so much! even though I own them all now, I still don't know them as well as you do :D thank you for taking the time to do this and for doing it so very well!

[@MartinaLily]

Thank you so much, I'm so glad it was helpful 💗💗💗

[@peuruaisheiche]

Wow this is so detailed! Thank you so much 😍

[@MsBNoodle]

That platinum one literally is the moon

[@cynthialees2760]

It’s definitely one I will be picking up!

[@lisadukes6471]

If i get any Else probably the duo blushes but I'm good on PML lol 🛐🕊

[@WyDesch]

So helpful--thank you!

[@ShellySims1988]

Loved the video ❤️ do you think you could possibly do a dupe video for the sextacy shade? I think "Sacrab" from the Tiny Marvels palette might be a dupe although different formulas of course. Maybe if you have any other indie brand shades that might be similar.

[@rabbiroz3806]

Between the two Bridgerton Palettes, both of the two plum and brown shades (not the Taupe) are exact dupes. I purchased the new Mothership and I enjoy it, but mostly because of the Taupe and the Platinum shades. I’ve used the special shades as well. I truly wish she didn’t keep putting those two shades in every palette. This one could have easily been done without them. Very disappointing.

[@erinstettner1]

I was 100% certain this would immediately be your favorite palette from PM.

[@MartinaLily]

Completely! The color story is amazing 💗💗💗

[@MsBNoodle]

Yaaaaay thank you! You're a superstar

[@MartinaLily]

Aw thank you lovely! 💗💗💗

[@LocMaiden]

🖤

[@jenniferd5477]

Omg 😱 Bridgeton mattes are the same as moonlit !!!

[@MartinaLily]

Yeah pretty much lol 💗💗💗

[@chantalmeijer8491]

Hi, I love your video's in dept about all the shadows. I was wondering have you ever swatched a mothership in store? I swatched it last weekend for the first time and I didn't like it. It didn't feel creamy of smooth at all. I swatched divine rose 1 en huetopian dream. Could it be cause they are always open in store and all lot of people swatching it? Or does it feel the same when you order a new one. Now I really don't know if I want one or not🫣

[@MartinaLily]

Hi Chantal, oh thank you so much 😊 Oh yeah I personally don't find eyeshadow palette swatching stores super helpful cos of how many people have swatched them. When you get them new they are lovely. The special shades dont always feel super creamy tho I will say that more almost sandy like cos of the glitter in them