Consti-tuition Ep. 06: Anti-defection

[@dryuvrajsambhy3774]

Good info for me that I did'nt care for decades- and now I am over 70. Good job done by you- Enjoyed.

[@SwapnaNaik1]

If a MP, MLA changes party we shouldn't mind kicking him out. But other than that off course they should be f*ckin allowed to vote on their own!

[@WorldToMe]

Swapna Naik ofcourse, i dont know how can this be a thing. The only work of a representative is to represent its people and if he/she can't even vote on behalf of his people then how he is a representative.

[@asifansari5004]

Great initiative, Any day democracy.

[@vikasv3718]

Love this episode. We need u

[@Digital_gyan1]

You Newslaundry Team is doing great job. Unfortunately I can give only one subscribe . Keep it up.

[@mahlawat12]

Waiting for this shit from so long. Love this series. Best series on Internet for knowledge that's what net is for. I feel really bad to see few views and likes on this video. 😔. Shitty peoples.

[@syedmaqsood5929]

it was really informative and enjoyable to watch! surprisingly didnt get bored all the way long...looking forward to next videos. Great job guyz, keep it up!

[@kaizoku4life]

Thank you very much..

[@nitipriyam9695]

Good show

[@mruss0613]

Love this show. Keep it up, guys! Hopefully with more awareness, we will also question some of these laws & practices that might have been pushed through in another time but have no place in today's India.

[@MrMurtaza5252]

Bro like literally the best content....excellent sense of humour

[@mohammedsaeed355]

Shit! I am early. According to constitution, it's mandatory to comment

[@goelshubhamshub]

Great work . Finally something for the new generation to move ahead of #Be GoT me kya hua Be!

[@syedmaqsood5929]

well, anti-defection law can be appreciated if its amended in some specific terms... It shouldn't be the responsibility of political party leaders to make their MPs vote, but the speaker should be given some power to make sure that the MPs are present and each Mp must be bound to give his/her opinion for the bill independent of what their respective leaders think about it! Voting must be made mandatory, but the favor in which a MP wants to vote shouldn't be narrated by their leader!

[@VishalVerma-wn4by]

you should be on netflix. by that way more people will know about this fantastic series,thus about their consititution.

[@luvkch]

super interpretation of the super obvious that we don't see🙏👍

[@HemantKChitale]

The best one so far !

[@varma11235]

Regarding subscription ... I live outside India and like to pay only through pay pal (your current payment walls are not working in europe and I dont like to use credit cards for any subscriptions ).... i know paypal takes more money from you but if you can pass on that costs to willing subscribers.... I will be more than happy to bear that extra costs (lot of websites already doing this ...offering same services with multiple options to pay .. direct bank transfer being cheapest to paypal being costliest= ...... Another great way to monetise this is that put your audio visual content for sale in youtube where we can buy individual episodes when ever I want..

[@3393ani]

I am a subscriber since long but not able to avail episodes after wo 6th

[@VeryProudIndian]

I m interested in your episodes but English seems to me difficult to understand. Please can you recoerd all these episodes in Hindi too....... Thanks

[@runn..]

Great work guys

[@berserker2302]

Anti-defection is necessary because, MPs should have to trust their party in certain issues. There can be differences between people of the party but they should resolve them before they put it on the table of parliament.

[@mountaincrush75]

wow sir great work 👍🏻👍🏻😊😊

[@gautamkenway8343]

watching this baked is helpful yeah funny too

[@RD-ku8to]

Udhar Banks haircut le rahe hain, aur yahan Meghnad. 😂

[@BTECE_FARIZ]

Great intro

[@israr6778]

Bad is better than worst. Anti- defection is bad but situation without it would have been worst.

[@WorldToMe]

CR7 can't we work on electing sincere and dedicated people to represent us? That would be better.

[@israr6778]

Simnan Urooj It seems difficult considering widespread illiteracy and lack of awareness about electorals in our country.

[@rockybalboa1465]

Awesome 🤘

[@subratadas950]

awshm work dudes.... keep it up

[@kumarsuryan7753]

Btw awesome video and series gentlemen!

[@aravindvadde2941]

Ofcourse order, without order there would be no democracy except chaos

[@876hari]

Aravind Vadde I think his point was that level of order and synchroneity demands a price , which is true democracy. We can't have both

[@aravindvadde2941]

Hari Krishnan oh thanks for that, I would go with order , it would give more vision to our country, but at one point of time again a revolution will takes place if the order goes out of the hand , obviously it will because it's our politicians who think parliament is a longue don't they?.

[@himanshudixit3625]

good content

[@BivashRath]

Great research and script. A stronger presentation would be better. 🖖

[@adv.tanmaymalikOfficial]

Love you

[@amul9538]

i am dissappointd by very less views for this episodes.... people are definitely ignorant !! #antidefection

[@vigneshhuman]

Do we get access from "Disruptors plan"?

[@newslaundry]

Yes. Vignesh. All subscription levels will get access to next episodes of Consti-tuition. :)

[@blissfulsounds1111]

we vote whom we want And the MP and MLA's vote whom they are told to. Nahi. humare democracy me namak nahi hai

[@iambhupindersingharora]

I wish you can make this show in Hindi!!

[@prashikdongare6362]

After a haircut From meghna to meghnand

[@mon1507]

Wow....

[@vs33618]

Our legislators are elected on a party ticket. For example, in Tamilnadu, people voted for Jayalalithaa's AIADMK, not to any random Tom Dick and Harry. When you are elected because of the party you belong to (otherwise there should be no party symbol in the EVM), obviously the party has a role to play in deciding how legislations are voted upon. Imagine 543 people, each demanding their share of the pie when voting on an issue. For example an MP in South India doesn't care/know about the requirements of the North East. So why would that MP vote favourably to a bill helping that region? Anti-defection law is necessary for effective governance. It is ridiculous to put it as a fight between democracy and Fascism. It is more like a fight between disruption and development.

[@RushilNagda]

I think the debate about anti defection boils down to what we believe an MPs duty is. If the MPs primary responsibility is to his or her constituency then it is not justifiable to have an anti-defection law. An MP should simply vote according to the benefits a bill grants his or her constituents. The GST for example was not beneficial to producer states like MH or TN. And BJP MPs from these regions should have voted against it (or faced the electoral consequence). But if an MPs duty is the development of the nation at large then it does make some sense to favour a less disruptive process and delegate the debate one level lower to within parties, with parties as a whole voting as a block. The presence of an anti-defection law, but with greater representation from regional parties (like the AIADMK) makes for the ideal balance for now. Less horse trading combined with better representation. Coalition governments might just be more democratic in this sense.

[@nadeemghadiyali7458]

I request for Mr J Mehta to be made the finance and the commerce Minister undoubtedly he will bring bring back the TaleSpin economy to health if not ahead of America at least we can put behind China in doing Global Business

[@chetana9802]

5:24 thanks for the new password Meghnand 16:06 that must have the initial intent in 1980s when it was passed right?

[@samiullahk7223]

Kankhajura hearing aid. 😂

[@isha-7304]

Underrated joke.

[@RhishiJ]

Where are your hairs? I hate to see you like this 😂... Nice episode

[@nishantkumar-gb1xw]

assassins vs templars!!!!!

[@thecasualobserver9875]

I thought it was an episode on anti defecation.

[@logiccool]

np buddies. I can live without subscribing NL.

[@rohitanand14]

for a second i thought its anti-defaecation :D

[@sakthikumaran6654]

i think u guys missed one important clause or loophole of anti defection law.....that is if a group of legislative members (i think more than 8) except the leader of party defect to their opposition party the this law is not applicable!! since majority of the members have oppinion fifferent from their leader they can defect to rival party without their membership disqualified!! example?? arunachal pradesh recently became a BJP state after its large no of ruling congress party members jointly joined BJP party!! so simple BJP won the state without even election!!

[@nadeemrangrez01]

make in hindi

[@poojachhachhiya1574]

Hindi me nhi aata kya?

[@CrosswireHunter]

Noooooooooo ... where is your beautiful curly hair????

[@kumarsuryan7753]

Anti defecation laws should be passed to stop MPs shitting on our constitution..

[@bhaskarsharma824]

You guys don't understand that you're catering just a small section of audience with English as the language. Where is good explanatory content in Hindi? The country needs THAT.

[@JatinGuptanow]

You explain it well but don't be so rude to Govt

[@thevikas5743]

But if you are asked to vote by the button? who knows which button I pressed? Or is it also required to be not-secret? But yes, it is really the shittiest law which destroys the diversity which we have. congis!!!

[@utkarsh96aware]

Order completely! We cannot afford to get rid of Anti-defection currently. It will turn our ministers from Policy-makers to the managers of MPs.

[@akmisraji]

Utkarsh Gaur But, ministers are NOT policy makers, MPs are. That's the whole point. Ministers, just "execute" the policies (made by parliament/MPs) 😀

[@utkarsh96aware]

Abhilash Misra That's also true vaise, But Afterall the bills are usually introudced by the government and they are approved by the parliament. If the anti-defection goes, any govt. which comes in power will feel it's very difficult for it to implement it's vision for the country.

[@akmisraji]

Utkarsh Gaur The solution to that isn't anti-defection law but Strong "Anti-Corruption" law, which, btw, has already been passed(albeit, weak) still the Govt didn't implement it. And so that the Govt/Democracy doesn't get reduced to a handful few, anti-defection has to go.

[@utkarsh96aware]

Abhilash Misra A law won't make any difference you know that. There would still be deals between MPs and Govt. then. I think we are not ready to get rid of anti-defection abhi

[@WorldToMe]

Our ministers are our MPs. We have to Choose our MP carefully and for that educating voters is the necessity.

[@subratadas950]

modi vs rahul gandhi

[@nishantjain1112]

Can you please not start the show with namak wala joke? It's very lame.

[@johnjosef.s7620]

WTF do Hindi version bhakt for understand u R videos 😂😃😂

[@sulit584]

Democracy sucks :(

[@logiccool]

Start Preparing for IFS,IAS, etc. once u will be selected then we can discuss whether Indian Democracy Sucks or not. I bet u will never say this again.

[@jastejsingh1931]

You guys have started behaving like Ambanis. Reliance introduced Jio saying that for getting free internet/sim, reliance phone must be bought and when some people bought phones then reliance started distributing free sims. You must deliver 10 episodes free as you implicitly promised in the beginning.

[@nakulgote]

And that is why, friends, don't vote for your MP, vote for the party he/she represents. #Modi2019

[@WorldToMe]

Nakul Gote seriously thats what u got from the episode?

[@biplobbiswas3323]

Ha ha ha :)

[@whatstrendingfolks6825]

Bhak sala, kaheka subscription be. Aeee. Sala paisa kauri h na aur ee sab maaatha kharaab kaaarle hai,,maaa ki aankh.