Ranking The Purest Kindest Noblest Acts In Red Dead Redemption 2

[@whereismybanana1712]

Arthur Morgan is a simple man. He yells "VAMOS!" to the German family.

[@IvanIsYda_]

underrated XD

[@bonniemacfarlane6709]

Like a Karen saying gracias in an Chinese restaurant

[@SD_yessir]

Well, this was 1899 and Spanish (and a bit of French) was the only major neighboring language to English in America, so I suppose it's not too surprising that Arthur went with the only other language he's even remotely familiar with. Still pretty funny, though.

[@yessir6427]

@@SD_yessir wasn't there german speaking communities in the northern states?

[@suspicioustumbleweed4760]

@@yessir6427 New Hanover

[@joelbeltran4437]

Can we take a moment to appreciate Charles for being the moral compass our boy Arthur needed

[@graceelathrop6371]

We stan Charles

[@lordodium3872]

Yes

[@sartajsandhu2282]

Dont forget the good Sister and Rains Fall

[@sketchflix6425]

❤🍻

[@reileyscoyote7976]

That is exactly what I was thinking

[@Und3adRob]

It was a nice touch that they included the German family again

[@Rokaishi]

Und3ad Rob :')

[@stephcupid2161]

"How did they come up with dem word" say Arthur

[@lewisofthehoood]

I was like “Oh my god it’s the Germans from chapter 3”

[@OzarkTheGothBitch.]

Ja

[@fx6794]

@@OzarkTheGothBitch. lool Deutscher?

[@spookyboi1433]

I love how at 14:07 you can see and hear in the background that there’s someone being kidnapped and the scene just continues lmao

[@Aleesh1881]

Bad sides of open worlds

[@joshabbley4179]

that made my night

[@Rainierbro26]

random encounter basically

[@skylerisbesty5712]

I know right lmao

[@mutenroshie]

Oh my god I'm dying here XD

[@gabrielsanchez2123]

When he saw that kid: he saw Isaac. Isaac and Arthur's girl were killed for 10 dolars. He had enogh.

[@nabber2002]

Never thought about that but it makes sense now that I think about it

[@thefern8847]

Yeah i see that now but didn't you do the debt collecting mission before Arthur talk about his son

[@fishfashfosh]

It’s a big clear cut when her husband’s name was literally Arthur. I think rockstar also implied that the dead Arthur also signifies the end of the old Arthur Morgan, making him a new man with a different outlook of the world

[@millimeter2008]

Your english had enough too I guess.

[@gabyyyyyyyyy]

​@@millimeter2008 rude, not everyone speaks this stupid language

[@kongassets]

Love that youre doin a debt mission and theres a a girl getting kidnapped in the background

[@noxedout9218]

Well she was being taken somewhere. She'd already been kidnapped.

[@isramubashar1227]

I remember riding to the house, but as I was about to start the debt collect, I stopped to go save the kidnapped woman I think that's the first one I actually saved

[@mansbestcomrade6315]

14:00 i know the whole meaning of this scene its pretty obvious for some, but for those who don't know Arthur's wife and child were killed for a few dollars, the husband of mrs. Londonderry was named Arthur too so you get the point

[@TheTrueFawaz]

man's best comrade yeah i knew the meaning as well but its like arthur seeing an alternative version if what woulda happen if HE was the one who was killed instead of them

[@riotrecker8978]

Wow I never understood that I should have noticed that cause I know he’s story but that’s kinda sad

[@bonniemacfarlane6709]

It wasn't his wife it was a fling

[@johnnyvargas5450]

Anyone else wonder what happend to mrs.Londonderry and her son after Arthur encounter with them

[@sketchflix6425]

I never thought of it... Now it burns deep.

[@IvanIsYda_]

1:55 one of Charles' best moments, calling Arthur out on his self-depricating bs

[@canadiangirl2207]

Arthur knows when Charles is scolding him he knows he f up

[@wasabi5338]

Charles believed in him even if Arthur cant believe in himself.

[@StarwayBunny]

I'm glad someone can acknowledge Arthur's flaws.

[@XxTheJimsterxX]

Roger Clark’s delivery of “I’m sorry, ma’am” gets me every time. It’s so damn genuine 15:33

[@Bonified369]

Playing High Honor was great in this game. When it came time to absolve the debt of that woman's husband and I saw the remorse in Arthur's eyes and it felt so powerful. Like he saw he was on the brink of starting another family down the checkered path he sent the Downes family on and couldn't bring himself to do that to another person, let alone another family. When he said "I'm sorry, ma'am. I really am." I knew he really was. Seeing him throw Strauss out of the camp after that, hearing Arthur call him a disgrace, not for sending him after the already poor and destitute, but because after some time he saw genuinely good people being steamrolled by him at Strauss's behest; I think in that situation I would've gutted Strauss. Maybe that makes high honor Arthur a better man than me but it sure as hell makes him one of the best characters I've ever seen.

[@leighgillen7615]

I didnt read that like not any of that so can you explain it to me in a short version thats easy to understand? Basically just pretend im dumb

[@Bonified369]

@@leighgillen7615 a high honor playthrough felt like a better story because low honor feels like "I'm gonna be a dick for funsies."

[@CaptnCrunch247]

@@leighgillen7615 - Are you really THAT lazy?!

[@en3525]

I think arthur went too hard on strauss, he was shady af but lending money is legit. It was of arthur impetus to be an asshole and intimidate people like that

[@Sol_Official]

@@en3525 Kicking him out also inadvertently might have saved him because of the things that happened later on. He still dies when he gets captured by Pinkertons, but he refused to talk, showing that he still cared for them even though he got kicked out.

[@exosluckyone]

WHEN CHARLOTTE KISSED HIS CHEEK AND HE GOT ALL SHY I SOBBED. MOANIN MARY COULD NEVER

[@strangelucy5627]

👏👏👏👏👏

[@bonniemacfarlane6709]

A round of applause for this legendary speaker of FACTS

[@TheWickedLep]

I think it's cuz Arthur knows he didn't deserve it but it felt good to receive a genuine gesture of gratitude

[@vermilion6667]

OoO OrRtHuUr...

[@jin_cotl]

MOAJING WHAT WIRHJFEBJE 💀

[@trailersparks]

The way he hugs the woman in the caves gets me, man. When you play him honorably he’s got so much depth and heart, it killed me to lose him in the end

[@davidschneider9145]

I only ever played high honor but I know the low honor ending from KZbin. And I‘ve got to say, seeing Arthur get shot like a dog hurts a lot more if you only ever knew him as a good man at heart

[@lv.30boss65]

notice how at the first chapters arthur was like “yea yea come on let’s get it over with” whenever he would help someone but then in last chapters like in 12:00 he REALLY wants to help people

[@matthewdoss195]

That's because he had tb in the later game and he knew he was gonna die soon and wanted to make a good last impression on the world around him

[@hyperbolicraider4848]

I like pears and also how that Sister lady gave him advice that he should help people in need cuz it always made him happy.

[@fishfashfosh]

@@matthewdoss195 I don’t think that’s the take. The common regrets of a dying man is usually when they realises how short and precious life is and all the past actions tends to become clear. I think it’s less so about Arthur wanting to make an impression as I think he doesn’t care about things like that. He wanted to spend his last moments saving people from the mistakes of his own past, like believing and fighting for the wrong things and for the wrong reasons. He saves John because John reflected his life when he was younger; having a family, a loved one but blinded by loyalty. Saving Edith and her son because they lived in a life where both are working in horrible jobs that could kill them etc

[@Madasylum04]

I wish he is in heaven after all he has been through

[@joshstone5376]

Well for me imo you can see around like 3:25 he realizes what people do when you do good if you get what I’m saying and this is like chapter 4-5 I don’t remember

[@BeefNuggetStew]

I love how Arthur does hand gestures as if he knows that not everybody speaks English and at least tries to get his point across

[@generalvan6449]

Be Rootin Be Tootin By god be Shootin But most importantly Be Kind

[@ari1758]

Wise words to live by

[@HuffdrewPaint]

11:00 "You n' me is all we need." No kidding, the two of them could have occupied Blackwater by themselves. Good lord.

[@momijiwalker7913]

Author said "Vamos" to German family. that's funny.

[@lilben4184]

Oh Author

[@benrussell-gough1201]

9:28 - If this weren't a pre-scripted scene, this is the moment when Arthur should have blown Micah's brains all over the wall and saved everyone a lot of pain and heartbreak later on.

[@IvanIsYda_]

if there was more freedom of choice I would have let Dutch and Sadie go on ahead and volunteer Micah with me to salvage things, then when they leave, strapped him to a post of the burning house, and tell Dutch Micah ran in to get more supplies before the house collapsed and pray that the boss buys it

[@IvanIsYda_]

@dudeguy true true😔

[@gigantor6519]

Or allow Sadie to knife him.

[@MohammedMahdi8005]

Arthur gave like 50 to 100 dollars to poor people and it was enough to give them new and happy lives. But the fucking 15k dollars in his satchel wasn't enough to give the whole gang of probably just 20 to 25 people a new life. Was Dutch planning to go to Tahiti or fucking buy the whole place

[@amartyabiswas4972]

That's probably the best thing I've heard in a while.

[@danielmu22]

100 dollars was a lot of money back then, Cornelius Van der Bilt started his empire with a borrow of 100 dollars.

[@IvanIsYda_]

"You live a good life, you hear?" And she did ;-; she fulfilled Arthur's wish for her and she found a good man and started a family ;-;

[@splashnskillz37]

1:55 damn Charles knows

[@NoshirDalal]

That was one of the first scenes I ever did on this game. Good times. =)

[@seva7500]

@@NoshirDalalit’s Charles himself. Wow.

[@therealsirdj5934]

You can feel that high honor is the way the game was meant to be played. It's what brought me some of the best moments I had in any video game. By far my favorite moment was the dialog between Arthur and sister Calderon at the train station. Honestly her "take a gamble that love exists and do a loving act" line hit me back when I first heared it, and it stuck with me ever since. I think it's a reminder not just Arthur but everyone needs from time to time that there is love out there as long as you're ready to accept it

[@MuthukrishnanBellie]

The 15yr old edgelords that love low honor plays are gonna get offended

[@therealsirdj5934]

@@MuthukrishnanBellie oh no, I'm sorry 😂

[@capitcha]

u are supposed to play low honor until you get TB. then arthur changes and goes high honor

[@nctsgrass]

​​@@capitcha not really. It's difficult to get significantly low honour unless you stay away from all actions that give you high honour (donating in camp, doing chores, not do stranger missions) and consistently kill & rob people, antagonise everyone. But when you do that... the game makes u sit with Mary Beth, tilly & Karen as arthur talks about how he doesn't feel good about his actions. I'm trying to get a low honour playthrough but even by killing most of van horn i hardly got to the red. Arthur would def rob coaches, trains, loot bodies & gun down gangs and not care to help strangers but in the mission where u take sadie out he says they don't go after people making an honest living. So canonically, arthur would never attack a town. He hated doing that while getting Micah out of strawberry. And canonically, he would donate to the camp, which gives u honour boost. So I'd say arthur starts off with a bit red to neutral honour, and keeps building it up till chapter 6, rather than him suddenly become a whole new person when he gets TB diagnosis. TL;DR : you aren't "supposed" to play with low honour. But of course you play however you desire. If you want to be full red and feel it fits, you do you, but I don't think that's canon to Arthur.

[@ainhat.]

@@nctsgrassSame. This is so well put.

[@ryanchristian3977]

“Blessed are those who hunger and thirst for righteousness.” RIP Arthur Morgan

[@DBSRBLX]

you cold have given the slaves the money from the register and you get extra honor from that

[@SD_yessir]

Damn, really? I actually didn't know that. I guess I just assumed Brother Dorkins had them covered. Probably cause I also try to refrain from taking from registers, due to the honor hits lol

[@crapporoniandchezze8338]

R* is very good at portraying that good people exist in bad places. I think one of the best examples of this is in GTA 5 when you're playing as Franklin, some of the dialogue he has with other gang members is genuinely pretty sweet.

[@AluminumFusion22]

His interactions with Jimmy are pretty wholesome too. Jimmy is at his core a good kid but is very misguided and desperate for companionship and Franklin becomes something similar to a surrogate brother to him. Their hang-out interactions are pretty funny and wholesome.

[@micahfarrell7402]

Take the captives over to the register after freeing them and it gives you the option to give them the money this gives you extra honor and reminds you to take care of the poor

[@heyodi3092]

12:02 the way he runs in and hugs her 😭😍

[@abhijaman4792]

"A noble spirit embiggens the smallest man." - Jebediah Springfield

[@JMR_2028]

I mean what do you expect, it’s Arthur Morgan!

[@terrimoran4428]

Mary Beth is the nicest person in this game. She’s so kind! She listened to Arthur and danced with him. She was always so sweet!

[@JafoTHEgreat]

Mrs. Adler, RIDE WITH ME! Chokes me up with emotion every time.

[@proneczarniecki2833]

I love seeing how kind Charles towards other folks not related to his gang he joins way early on in the stories lore before the Red Dead Redemption 2 game starts

[@wizardmanmarcos]

Honestly I wish that in the epilogue where you play as John Marston I wish there was another kind of mission that involved with the German family. Still with a strong German accent their English has improved quite a lot since 1899. Now in 1907 John meets these folks for the first time helping them. Andreas saying John reminds him of a feller that saved him a while back giving physical appearances. Even saying how he tried to help him after finding him passed out from his tuberculosis. This will then turn into the cutscenes of the old gang member reunions. Like the Charles Smith reunion there’s 4 different outcomes of when Arthur (low honer) saved John vs Arthur (high honer) saved John along with the same with Arthur going back for the money. “Arthur wasn’t a good man. But when his time was coming to an end, he searched for righteousness. “You and I must of have something in common partner. Arthur saved the both of us. He may not’ve shown it but deeped down inside...he truly was great man and gave everything to what mattered to him most”.

[@DeadhunterThe]

You know what might have been interesting? If during Arthur's last ride with high honor if German voices were heard saying, "You are a great man. A great man. We are blessed to have met you." and "Thanks a lot. From the bottom of my heart." in English. Like Arthur's heart now understands what they were all saying in their emotional gratitude.

[@thelilhedgehog6855]

Arthur yelling Vamos Vamos to Germans is so humorous to me

[@smoker5989]

Not as much as the "To the bar SEÑOR" segment in the riverboat.

[@MyViolador]

That im sorry maam . Arthurs face breaks my heart

[@thebestmc3912]

When Arthur said “vamos“ to the German family,i laughed so hard But when the Germans said “you saved us when we need saving,and now we can’t save you“,that breaks my heart

[@polter_z]

I love how Arthur went from 😠 to 😳 when Andreas pulled the gold bar from under the wagon 3:40

[@driptitan5853]

it’s cool that the last time we see the german family they spoke better english than before

[@joshuahughes5761]

Number 9 if Arthur had TB then he would’ve helped them straight away I reckon

[@TheTimbs_]

Arthur: *dying* Horse: Yo, what’s wrong with you bro? You good?

[@ketomine.]

It's great that the reverse of the Downes family, whom Arthur tore apart, the German family, whom he brought back together (both involving the fathers of the family) helps him near the end.

[@Skrimpinboss]

@ 9:00 you can loot the register and give the money to the two men before you lead them to the monk, it’s pretty neat if you ask me.

[@jacksonhodge4638]

14:05 damn that sucks. Woman being kidnapped in the midst of a cutscene during a noble acts video. Feels almost poetic.

[@morningstarlink]

If you played rdr2 as a bad Arthur, then you're playing the game wrong

[@morganv.9325]

I wish Charlotte became a legitimate potential romance for Arthur

[@KevinNarwhal002]

A man doesn’t know what kind of person they are till the very end

[@zhengwenyu1587]

The world could use more High Honor Arthurs and Mary Beths

[@DaiKaijyuu]

Family: *speaks German* Arthur: I don't speak Taco Bell!

[@FresnoCA93727]

When you rescue the slaves in the cellar, you can take the money in the register and actually give it to them. Then you can take them to the Brother Dorkins.

[@oryan4395]

I never had Arthur remove his black hat. After playing the first red dead I loved that hat so seeing it again in this game I couldn't let him wear anything else

[@zooweemama911]

Arthur is a certified gentleman

[@MrKrossix]

Yup, Mary-Beth purest member of the gang. That seems about right :)

[@travismeta3727]

7:38 Harold MacDougal reference :)

[@skylerisbesty5712]

The person getting kidnapped was hilarious also the person in the game getting kidnapped was funny aswell

[@hlyph.istaken.bastards]

"i know I ruined your life, I suffer for it every day" one of those lines that guts me

[@warrr_machine]

5:26 I had the law already aiming at me during this cutscene. It was an all out shootout after.

[@caominhpham7135]

Just 3 superative adjectives are not enough for his kindness

[@colbymiller440]

When you’re freeing the people from being sold into slavery you can give them the money from the register

[@KiwiSpartan01]

"We're bad men, but we're not them. We'll keep you safe until you figure out what you want to do" Professionals have standards

[@WalshieYT1]

This was awesome! You should do the toughest characters ranked!

[@coolnsolid198]

ok i will put it on the list

[@bluscout6440]

Arthur thinking of being a nice person: Takes a huge stack of cash

[@vice_o1443]

3:33 Vamos😂

[@JamSome]

Events like these always makes me wonder what's the point of having bad honour in the game

[@La-hora-del-terror]

I think it's better having bad honor at the beggining but after Guarma is time to be good, i think it feels better with the story instead of being good since the beggining

[@ferchrist770]

9:00 you can give money from the cash register to the slaves and you will earn honor

[@anonxo4914]

14:09 someone getting kidnapped 😂.

[@lukesmith5816]

😆😆😆😆

[@justacasualplayer3603]

Omg lol

[@sircrimsonwolf7492]

It’s a shame Dutchman, completely insane in the end. He may not have been a good man, but he definitely wasn’t an evil man not at first anyway, which makes the brotherly relationship between him and Arthur more heartbreaking as the story continues renegade Arthur doesn’t have quite the same taste full story as the high honor/good guy Arthur which has a very inspirational and heartwarming story, even if it ends in tragedy, but if you think about it, it is somewhat fitting, considering the previous red dead had a similar ending. Perhaps one day we might get a red dead with a good ending, or the protagonist survives unlikely, considering the franchise seems to be stagnated or dead.

[@heyodi3092]

The fact that Micah burned Sadie’s house down 😡😡😡

[@pleatus9919]

Arthur, Charles, Sadie,john,and the rest of the innocent member would've been a nice fit for a new gang no killing no lying

[@abderrahimsaidi1945]

Hahahahahaha 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 . The only thing that Arthur make me laugh , is when he told the German family to get out from the land by saying " Vamos " in Spanish to get out , once he needs to tell the " Schnell" in German language to move out . 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@rat341]

2:14 kindest noblest acts you say LMAO

[@Alex-tj2tg]

You want me lie down for you? Arthur: sure

[@totallynottherealgojo748]

Arthur saying "Vamos" is the funniest thing

[@souhridhrachakraborty6001]

I wish i could forget everything about this game and experience it again from the start

[@lotter5371]

What about the time Charles tossed Micah off his chair to the ground?

[@youngnsweett]

THE CHARLOTTE LITTLE KISSSSSS OH MY GOD MY OVARIES EXPLODED

[@SlashmanG]

It killed me when Arthur yelled “Vamos” to a bunch of Germans

[@SlipYoke6081x]

Of course the first one is Mary Beth

[@daviddoesthings8931]

Arthur is so much taller than Charles, in the #9 cutscene.

[@simp-johnson]

When you save the slaves at Saint Denis and open the cash register, Arthur will give the money to the slaves. I've never knew that until I play the game again

[@caleb_güero]

I remember I was heading more south/southwest and came across a girl whom was hogtied on the side of the road and accidentally cut her throat because I pressed the wrong button. I was so horrified I reloaded my game and still cant forget it years later.

[@sadieadler5535]

Arthur Morgan would be the perfect boyfriend and husband

[@huethebest2694]

#1 should have been when arthur stalled for john so he and his family could get away

[@Wanted_wont31]

The fact there’s someone being kidnapped right behind Arthur on number 2 is pretty funny

[@joshuasuarez3297]

So we just aren’t gonna talk about the lady getting kidnapped in the background💀

[@lewisjohnston7077]

By the Murfree Broad

[@nutterr2149]

Anybody else when they play through the story again try too play as arthur as a cruel outlaw but then everytime i end up playing like arthur towards the end 😂

[@norakiyote1642]

happens every time! lol.

[@exosluckyone]

12:52 her face always get me 😭

[@gerardwayseyelash]

Now I don't feel bad for laughing 💀

[@exosluckyone]

@@gerardwayseyelash ive been wondering if that was intentional or not but no one ever mentions it 💀💀

[@jonhni19]

The only dislike on this video is from Micah

[@Bananapeelz098]

14:06 -14:10 that poor lady in the background. This could have been another wholesome scene buut...*Cutscene* 🤣🤣

[@uriahedwards]

Charlotte kisses Arthur Me: No. Germs.

[@skollandhati9961]

One thing I really like about the honor system for Arthur is when Arthur is low honor he’s like Dutch but when Arthur is high honor he’s like Hosa.

[@lazzy0dog]

3:47 when i sell that i was like. "what a nice guy"

[@trailersparks]

We had the same leopard Appaloosa… I named her Domino and wept like a baby when she died 🥲

[@thelorddarthvader7264]

It really sucks that covid got Mr. Morgan in the end.

[@DoomShepherd]

Fortunately a vaccine for TB was developed in 1921, and there were no Q-tards back then, so now infection is super rare and mortality is almost nonexistent.

[@zaneharoldson2293]

I never released Arthur repeats line Rains Fall’s line to the Downes family about being killed for pride. He has indeed seen it kill too many folk.

[@Truthstilldoesit]

13:42 her eyes are so damn blue

[@tenji8084]

*Arthur saying Vamos to a German family will never not be funny to me*

[@Ranger-ze8by]

The women getting kidnapped in the background of a really touching scene 😅

[@phantom_prince4037]

I never played the based RDR2 story only the online with some friends but one day I thought “ why not give it a try see what’s it like….. man from the very get go I felt something different with this game like each session I had with this game felt like a day or two ( I had only a most an 1 hour of game time to play) I adored Arthur from the get go and did my best to keep him steady like sleep at a reasonable time, eat healthy food , drink less and smoke less ( albeit it’s a personal choice of mine) try to do high honor really early. Take care Arthur the best I can. When all the major events occurred in the game and then the scene when he finds out about his TB I felt like I was losing a friend, I lost a lot of people in my life and considering I did my best to care for Arthur, I knew there’s nothing much left to do but “ do a loving act” as the sister said and it felt like I was reliving some past mistakes that I endured in my life and just… this is one of the few if not only 1-2 games that made me emotionally invested in it through and through.

[@dismayingmist7868]

I feel like Charles is the only one who can put Arthur in his place , I like playing as high honor kinda going for low honor Since Arthur can be funny sometimes