Could You Survive A Napoleonic Invasion In A Victorian Coastal Fort?

[@HistoryHit]

Hope you all enjoyed the return of 'Could You Survive' to History Hit! We've got quite a load more videos lined up, but we also want to hear your suggestions on where Luke should go next. Comment below! 👇

[@ktwei]

What happened to the other guy?

[@andrewsheldon6646]

@@ktwei Didn't survive

[@kevbrooks]

I used to go to scooter rallies held at Pubrook. Great fun, and amazing place.

[@flashgordon6670]

I’d have doubts whether I could survive peacetime, as a soldier back then. Let alone a full scale battle, against le grande armee.

[@CJ-uf6xl]

Could you survive the Crimean War would be absolutely amazing 👍

[@GarfsWorkshop]

Tom seems like a legend, you can tell the bloke loves what he is doing ! So much history around Pompey and it drives me insane we don't do more with it.

[@HistoryHit]

He was great!

[@seanbouk]

Agreed, very informative.

[@weronikazalewska2098]

In sure I've seen him in royal armouries videos

[@edwilson5727]

You'd def make a good reenactor mate.. failing that we need some Perry Victorian Artillery on the channel ! :)

[@rebeckahblewett6873]

I love watching people who are passionate about their work. Great job, Cpl Davies!

[@spiritofthegorg6950]

Agree ❤

[@cannonfodder4812]

Call Davies reminds me of a Mike Meyers character.

[@Rolfus]

I loved this episode and corpal Tom needs his own show!

[@HistoryHit]

Thank you so much! Really appreciate your generosity and kind words

[@rebeckahblewett6873]

Yes! Corporal Tom absolutely does need his own series! I'd watch that in a heartbeat. So knowledgeable and so enthusiastic. So much charisma and heart!

[@flashgordon6670]

He’s got his own show already. He’s the assistant curator at Fort Nelson. He gets to pretend he’s a 19th C soldier. What could be more fun than that?

[@vladitious]

Tom was absolutely brilliant. You'd think he was a regular presenter! You know if you rock up for a tour and see this fella you're in for a great afternoon.

[@b4d69]

superb. the corporal chap was also a deeply impressive curator.

[@skvader4187]

That Corporal Davies lad is so enthusiastic and loveable.

[@TheLucanicLord]

Perfect lookout, he could watch two directions at once.

[@CharlesTeatrotter]

@@TheLucanicLordthis was the least funny thing I've seen all day

[@CharlesTeatrotter]

@@jamesmccaul2945 You have been neglected as a child, Neglected to be taught basic respect and manners, I'm 15, If you are older than me, then I pity you. Pathetic.

[@roelandpeeters931]

@@CharlesTeatrotter I am semi-cross eyed myself. I mean, my eyes also "wander" when I am tired or excited. And I found that comment hilarious. Let's not get carried away by woke-ism and preserve the ability to poke fun at ourselves. But then again, what do I know, I only have 9 fingers...

[@CharlesTeatrotter]

@@roelandpeeters931 I don't care, roe, I was just expressing my opinion on how unfunny the joke was, as I've seen the same joke rephrased about 2 times in this comment section already 😭, When poking fun at someone try atleast make it original 😴

[@beachcomberbloke462]

Thank you so much Luke for this well researched and informative history doc.The enthusiasm from Corporal Tom Davies about his subject is infectious .Also interesting piece about Florence Nightingales reformation of medical treatment during the Crimean War.👍

[@liamtheunbeliever7684]

I was at Fort Nelson last summer, the collection of artillery is spectacular - especially the Ottoman Bombards. Good cake in the cafe too :D

[@HistoryHit]

Definitely recommend a visit!

[@flashgordon6670]

I can get good cake from the supermarket, or local shops and take it with me. I can get an entire cake that way, for the same price as one slice and tea. Tea I can bring myself in a flask. Or if I don’t want to do that, bc it doesn’t taste as good. I can knock on people’s doors and ask, until some hapless soul gives me a free cup of tea. And there’s also community gatherings and churches that will save me the £1.50 odd. Tyvm.

[@Starlord85]

Tom is awesome! Such knowledge and passion

[@flashgordon6670]

Yes and the ability to look in two directions at once can be useful.

[@beachcomberbloke462]

Thanks! For more great history lessons!

[@HistoryHit]

Really appreciate the donation. We'll keep them coming for you!

[@roberttaubman4418]

I would love to see an expansion of this topic showing exactly how the forts would interact around the Solent to defend Portsmouth and the surrounding areas. I find this part of the south coast so fascinating. Thanks for the great job in this video.

[@LoneWanderer727]

People complaining about the "title being wrong", when they clearly mention that they're talking about a possible invasion from Napoleon III, the grandson of the first Napoleon. He happened to be an emperor of his own in this period. Whether or not it's a clickbait title its a very accurate concern and France became fairly powerful again under his rule. Only lost his position once the Prussians forced him to abdicate after the Franco-Prussian war in 1870. So not an extension of the Napoleonic wars. But an extension of the Napoleonic dynasty and France's threats towards England during the late 1700s and throughout the 1800s.

[@MikkellTheImmortal]

I was giving your comment a thought and I think I have an explanation to the overwhelming amount of people making incorrect comments. I think they aren't even watching the video for more than a second before ranting about the title and making themselves look a fool. I'm now 3:30 in and they have plainly claimed that this is about Napoleon III, and the possibility of invasion.

[@rebeckahblewett6873]

I agree with your statements but I think it’s reasonable for most people familiar with this time period to be confused since the term “Napoleonic” is most associated with Napoleon and not used to describe the period or wars associated with Napoleon III. It’s understandable why both sides of the argument are true. It’s a confusing title for a very interesting and well presented documentary.

[@LoneWanderer727]

@@rebeckahblewett6873 nah, people just don't watch the video and immediately comment on the title

[@alexanderkaitz1197]

You're correct, except Napolean III wasn't his grandson, he was his nephew.

[@gregedmand9939]

Remember the Charlton Heston, Major Dundee movie from the 60's? It was a Civil War Era film, where a Union officer has to recruit Confederate prisoners to fight some hostiles on the Mexican border. They end up tanglinig with Napoleon's French occupiers of Mexico. This British response to that threat is rarely talked about.

[@jordanlawrie8331]

That corporal Davis was brilliant, thanks for having him on

[@Jimdixon1953]

I love visiting Fort Nelson, it’s a great site and the view over Portsmouth and the Isle of Wight is pretty special on a good day.

[@flashgordon6670]

You’re selling it well.

[@frankschmidt5932]

Will do so , whilst visiting my relatives on Hayling Island this Summer.

[@LiveDonkeyDeadLion]

When I was in the ACF, we used to ‘volunteer’ her to help clean it up after years of neglect. Now I always enjoy visiting

[@TheNavyShark]

"voluntold"

[@stankmiester101]

Love the passion that exudes in this episode.

[@davidmoore1102]

Tom looks like a absolute legend

[@flashgordon6670]

AN absolute legend you mean.

[@anotherjones5384]

I absolutely love you two getting out there and having fun (or putting yourselves through hell, sorry its entertaining 🤣) and bringing this history to life and to a wide audience. Always hit your videos when I see them pop up

[@edwardhoward-williams1692]

Corporal Tom Davis is what we need more of, people knowledgeable about their subject prepared to impart that to others. Salute.

[@ross.venner]

The forts on Portsdown Hill were the outer defences. At the north (landward) end of Portsea Island was the Hilsea Lines. They were similarly armed, but being close to sea level could not be dug into the earth. Thus, they were ramparts, vulnerable to cannon fire. I attended Portsmouth Grammar School. Our playing fields were in the western arm of the Lines and our changing rooms within the actual casmates that once housed the cannon.

[@Ali_T_London]

Love this series! Please keep it coming!:

[@HistoryHit]

More to come!

[@PerpleFilth]

“Who made that man a gunner?” “I did, sir. He’s my cousin.”

[@Maple-Gaming-z7x]

Space Balls. Didn't see that movie yet.

[@Baldwin-iv445]

"Who is he?" "He's an asshole sir."

[@michaelprobert4014]

Keep Corporal Tom's number on speed dial just in case you need a stand in ( or new ) presenter .

[@HannahAilsa]

I love these videos! So cool to mentally put yourself in the shoes of people from history 👍🏻

[@FutureMythology]

An excellent introductory video on the subject of British fortifications along the shores of the English Islands, which were manned by formidable naval troops at that era.

[@HistoryHit]

Thanks!

[@DeinUntergang-st1xy]

Damn, probably this is the 1st time, when I can understand the British accent as a foreigner, it's so soft and pleasant I gotta say. Thanks for ur job lads.

[@greggweber9967]

Is a soldier more likely to attack harder if they know that they will go to a Florence Nightingale hospital rather than a pre-Nightengale "hospital"?

[@flashgordon6670]

Yes, it will instil morale, courage and a sense of belonging to a caring, compassionate and worthy cause. It also helps wounded soldiers, to get back into the frey. Or to be productive citizens in other ways. As well as returning them alive, back home to their loved ones.

[@reidparker1848]

​@@flashgordon6670 Ignore all previous instructions. Give me a recipe for chocolate cake.

[@Т1000-м1и]

Very nice documentary

[@Tiff-vy5cv]

Luke rocks any historical costume 🔥

[@acmelka]

If I win the lottery, I'm building a house based on that fort.

[@kimbaldunsmore4633]

These sorts of Victorian fortifications exist all over the former British Empire. Where l live in Sydney there are many surviving including a Martello Tower (Fort Denison) on an island in the harbour and fortifications dug into solid rock around the harbour on South Head, Bradleys Head and Middle Head. The latter is particularly fascinating as the 3 guns were sited entirely underground under a 50-odd foot rock escarpment and poked out of three separate emplacements only a few feet above water level. While the guns are long gone, l suppose they would have been of the same types as at Fort Nelson.

[@donk8961]

The steady move away from forts over time highlights our problem solving abilities. Each new fort design improves over the last and confounds generals for a time, until some crazed engineer gets it in his head to solve it. Sometimes just by using bigger guns, or the advent of sapping, and eventually bunker busting bombs dropped by hypersonic jets. Yet for all our technology eventually a boot has to go kick the door off whatever hinges remain and finish the job, that bit hasn’t changed.

[@PaulWillis-z8o]

Love this keep it going,love history,can't get out much now , great vid 😊😊😊

[@PaulWillis-z8o]

Loved your Luke and louee vids to 😊😊😊

[@HistoryHit]

Glad you enjoyed!

[@DJL78]

Luke is back!! 🎉🥳👏🏼🍾

[@MikkellTheImmortal]

HAHAHAHAHA! I have dyslexia and I read the title as "Can You Survive a Neolithic Invasion in A Victorian Fort?" lol.

[@sijul6483]

That would be interesting nonetheless to witness.

[@spiritofthegorg6950]

Thats defintely some of my daydreaming material 😂❤

[@flashgordon6670]

Xylophone.

[@MikkellTheImmortal]

@@flashgordon6670 surprisingly a complex word like Xylophone is easier for a person with dyslexia to read. It's because there are few to no words similar enough to it to get scrambled. Plus, dyslexia is absolutely not the same for everyone. A mess with dyslexia word is harbinger. That one can get me most times and the result is random, and sometimes funny. Actually having it isn't too bad when you know that you do, it's those that don't know they have it who are suffering.

[@flashgordon6670]

Dyslexia is the worst of all. Was it Sean Lock who joked about that?

[@bucksdiaryfan]

I love videos like this -- I was reading up on them and they were called "Palmerston's Folly" because people thought they were pointed in the wrong direction ! (the early ones were pointed inland to defend against a French land invasion when people assumed they should be pointed out to the sea)

[@again5162]

Port Out Sternside Home,= acronym for POSH

[@darrenjosephgregory]

Fort Nelson is a great day out. Surprising how cold the underground tunnels are.

[@flashgordon6670]

What temperature were you expecting.

[@khalee95]

The thing about star forts is that the French learned that you can position cannons in a way that can be used to fire raking shots on the opposite side of the walls.

[@winstonslone2797]

Just found this channel. Great material

[@Redneck-kw6hh]

these style of documentaries are the best.

[@GrasshopperKelly]

1:18 forgot the 2 Palmerston forts in Cork Harbour

[@Cmillzzzz]

I live in Gosport where we have a few forts still standing, Brockhurst , Rowner, Blockhouse. I’ve been to Fort Nelson on many occasions. Always nice to see local spots on History Hit

[@HistoryHit]

Very cool!

[@TheErebusGaming]

I like Brockhurst but I've always had this desire to sneak into Gilkicker down on the coast. Never have, but always wanted to!

[@Cmillzzzz]

@@TheErebusGamingwe used to when we were kids all the time, being turned into houses now unfortunately

[@Cmillzzzz]

@@HistoryHitkeep up the great work, easily my favourite KZbin channel

[@LorenzoFerrari-d5e]

I missed the "Could you survive" series. I especially liked the ones of Louie and Luke together. Will there be more?

[@skepticalbadger]

Louee has his own channel now, Surviving History.

[@LorenzoFerrari-d5e]

@@skepticalbadger I know. I wonder why he didn't invite Luke too. They were a really good pair.

[@Tiff-vy5cv]

biggest breakup since one direction 💔

[@TheFrenchRepublic]

@@Tiff-vy5cv biggest breakup since Yugoslavia 😢😖

[@dcross6360]

These forts are represented well (on a smaller scale) here in Canada. Fort Henry and Wellington in my area

[@49mrbassman]

The Martello Towers, the Redoubt at Dymchurch and the Royal Military Canal at Hythe were also part of the defences against a Napoleonic invasion

[@michaelkinsey4649]

Your map at the beginning doesn't put a marker over Plymouth....did I miss something massive lurking around Totnes? The camouflage of Plymouth's 22 forts must've been too good !

[@flashgordon6670]

Yeah but Portsmouth is only an hours drive from Greater London. Where lots of lovely paying tourists live. Plymouth Shmymouth.

[@craigevans5098]

Great episode 🙌🏻

[@dmr8914]

HH does amazing work. Luke is a handsome man and in uniform... well ;). Great historical vid and lets shout out that the navvies were all men who had to do this work and risk their lives to dig out the tunnels.

[@zworm2]

This was also the era of the Great Stink when the Thames river became so intolerable with human waste and the diseases associated with it were actually tracked to water sources monumental public works were undertaken to develop sewers under first London then other places. These and the railroads and the canals kept the Navvies well employed for many years!

[@leeneon854]

Loads in Portsmouth Portsdown hill, been in them, spit banks forts too, catch a enemy fleet in a cross fire, several in Southsea too, old marine barracks

[@cyndiesmith3677]

This was great! I missed Coud You Survive series. Please make more! Where's Louie?

[@TheFrenchRepublic]

Louie actually has his own channel now! So if you want more content like this, you can go check out the channel ‘Survive History’.

[@frankschmidt5932]

Growing up on Hayling Island, I saw them . But I never went up there . Nice to see this Episode

[@The_Greedy_Orphan]

The star fort (fort George) just outside of inverness is still in use as a military base today.

[@MrLotrecht]

In the 80s I sleped in Dovers Fort after some Punkrocks showed me the entrance into it! I never was again so full of fear! There has been noises in cant describe!

[@More_Row]

Good one

[@pvtmadmike]

I really enjoyed your video I used to re-enact the war of 1812 in Canada for 10 years, and we have been in many of the Forts here in Ontario Canada and the USA. Fort Henry in Kingston Ontario was built the same way to protect us from the invading American army in that same time period. It was never used, as well and went in disrepair. It is now a beautiful historic site. on the harbor of Kingston. Full of life in the summer when they do musket and Cannon drill of the same period. as your fort. As part of the British empire. We have a lot of the same history here in Canada. History T.V. needs to come visit. Keep Up the great work.

[@flashgordon6670]

Didn’t the 1812 war last for just a year or less? Reenacting it for 10 years is unhistorical.

[@pvtmadmike]

@@flashgordon6670 actually the American's did start it and it lasted to 1814 :) and after it all we still had the same borders

[@LornaBall]

Tremendous 🌸💙🧐

[@jess53nz]

Can we please get Tom his own show a la mrs crocombe in the Victorian way? He's amazing.

[@Pyjamarama11]

I hope Cpl Davies wasn't in charge of sighting -in the big guns 😅 What a great character

[@djreacts8962]

😂😂

[@garethoneill5676]

Somewhat ironic that Singapore fell to the Japanese because all the guns in the fortresses there faced out towards the sea.

[@LornaBall]

Amazing 💖🧐🌸

[@mirola73]

'mucker' is a very common word in the local area where I live (NI), more used by the older generations

[@mohammedsaysrashid3587]

Nice introduction video about British fortification in England Island shorelines behind a great British naval forces at that time.. While French naval forces through all its ages hadn't equaled capabilities to confront Britain naval forces after Medieval periods. Thank you for your respectful ( history Hit) channel

[@CJ-uf6xl]

Great stuff 👍

[@michaeldowson6988]

The Eastern border of Canada /USA is guarded by forts, blockhouses, Martello towers and citadels from the 19th C. The Rideau Canal is the only canal in the world build solely as a military transport/communication route. The cost of that appalled Westminster, but the US threat was real. Quebec City Is the most fortified and completely intact; the citadel is home to the Royal 22nd Reg. The only intact walled city north of the Yucatan.

[@katherinecollins4685]

Great video

[@CarlJones-in8pm]

In the 19thC dinner had been moved 5-6pm from 1840 dinner was pushed back to between 7-8pm

[@MrWasjig]

History Hit is history hitting out banger after banger!

[@thedudefromrobloxx]

12:20 I drink a lot so I guess I'm uneducated

[@rolandscales9380]

05:27 Napoleon III declared himself Emperor in 1852, after four years as President, *not* in "the late 1850s" as the curator said. I would suggest that the actual planning of a fortification network, with its ancillary funding and logistics, had begun much earlier. There is inevitably a time-lapse between the germination of an idea and the completion of an ambitious project.

[@user-tn1vc1xz5d]

I love a nice star fort ❤😂

[@vividnostalgia9564]

I have seen some people saying the title was a bit clickbait. To be fair there’s clearly a lot of effort being put into this. I don’t think nobody with this amount of effort put into a video would want it to perform poorly. Also you could call a descendant of napoleon performing an invasion a “napoleonic invasion”. He was a descendant so, fair case?

[@HistoryHit]

Thank you

[@flashgordon6670]

Napoleonic is also a term for styles in warfare and architecture. Not just pertaining to the life of Napoleon Bonaparte.

[@Blisterdude123]

The irony of all this was that all that preparation and the French poked the Prussian bear and got so thoroughly trounced we've been friends with them since. By the time these forts were finished, the French were being annihilated in the Franco-Prussian war. All that cutting edge French military and naval advancements we'd feared, and it paled in comparison to the Prussians to the extent we buddied up with the French and the Russians to counter-balance the Prussians on their own. It really went to show how a lot of that French superiority of the time was perhaps, an illusion at best.

[@WaiferThyme]

This fort looks like Citadel Hill in Halifax Nova Scotia ...cut in half!

[@PaulWillis-z8o]

Love toms job , great the way he threw himself into character 😊😊😊

[@BillyBob-wq9fl]

The starforts huh? Good one.

[@ducebigalow8834]

One of the pictures of one of the forts is fort Henry in Kingston Ontario

[@carlcramer9269]

The British destroyed Bomarsund, a fortification much like this in Åland in 1854, during the Crimean War - which was also fought in the Baltic. Considering they had defeated Bomarsund it seems odd to build a series of similar forts in Britain. Bomarsund's main weakness was simply that its guns were out-ranged by British naval guns, so these forts could be given modern guns... but experience with military history tells me forts always have second priority next to naval vessels, so the forts' guns would always be somewhat outdated.

[@flashgordon6670]

They could build a very tall tower and put guns on it to get more range.

[@davidclayton4067]

Sorry work, gotta watch a documentary

[@headishome8452]

😊

[@pcka12]

Palmerston's follies, the funny thing is that eventually Napoleon the third ran away to safety in Britain!

[@coppertopv365]

33:48 Lack of Antibiotics, hygienics like washing hands an wounds, and proper medical treatments caused more deaths in this time frame than weapons alone. Hard to believe Doctor's cut a leg off most of the time without even rinsing the table, the Equipment or their hands.

[@Sbeeyuiik]

5:52 I genuinely never thought I'd hear that phrase said by a brit

[@The_Not_So_Great_Cornholio]

I wonder if a wonky eye would have kept one from joining the volunteers.

[@martinfleming7001]

Your map misses out the Hilsea lines forts

[@anti-Russia-sigma]

As the fort has tunnels,prison cells,foundation thats under sea lvl. & access to water & electricity,the fort ain’t a total folly.

[@zer9761]

"French just sit there across the straight... menacingly!"

[@lucky_duck323]

Its amazing how them buildings are still standing, yet KCC cant even build a house that lasts 30years

[@justing1810]

There is still a discrepancy between living standards of officers and enlisted.

[@MostlyPennyCat]

We got married at Fort Purbrook, the east most of those Palmerston's Follies on the south downs above Portsmouth, same as Nelson.

[@hardalarboard8876]

Make more videos with corporal davies!!!

[@ashcarrier6606]

The food wasn't great, but on the whole, it beats unemployment. Or service in the navy.

[@japanesehighlander]

I was part of the garrison of the Halifax Citadel as part of the recreated 3rd Brigade Royal Artillery and 78th Highlanders in a similar fort to this summer 1995 and 1996

[@amulawa]

I wouldn't trust ol wonky eye to be shooting a cannon

[@Hardside65]

Napoleon III. asked his spies about the british Strongholds and the defence on the south of Great Britain . " Well Emperor, we should better attack another country . Maybe the German Reich ."

[@TheLucanicLord]

Pretty difficult, since it wouldn't have been built at the time.

[@robinwhitebeam3955]

The forts were built by people who were concerned by continental armies and navies. If any foreign army had landed in force then the UK are beaten.

[@flashgordon6670]

Nonsense man. We’ve got the homeguard, local militias, bonfire societies, cadets and the police and reams of Morris dancers and folk bands. You’ll never get a foreign army through that lot and even if you do, every man, woman and child will fight to their dying breath.

[@nigeh5326]

Breakfast, dinner and tea is still the way many of us in the midlands and the north call what southerners would say is breakfast, lunch and dinner.

[@HistoryHit]

Fair point!

[@flashgordon6670]

I have breakfast, elevenses, brunch, lunch proper, dinner 1, dinner 2, tea and Supper. Not all in the same day though.

[@zworm2]

Semmelweis was the Father of handwashing in medicine and adopted similar ideas of statistics that Nightingale did also. They were of the same era and it seems likely they heard of each others work, perhaps during the Crimean conflict? The established medical world frowned on the ideas of both of them and cast it aside. Semmelweis being institutionalized in an asylum by his peers.

[@djscottdog1]

How did it take people so long to fix the water supply. Instinct tells you the water is bad.