Crash Test Compilation | 8 Luxury SUV 2024

[@LeistungDrehmoment]

For right comparison, X3 --> X5 Q5 --> Q7 XC60 ->> XC90 All models need to be in same class

[@배석진-e9s]

전기차는 폭발의 위험이 있어서 실험을 안했다지?

[@B345T1N355Official]

All the models that were tested were about the same size though. I think the RX and GLE were classified as mid-size crossover SUVs and the Q7 and XC90 were both full-size models as they have a 3rd row and could seat people more comfortably, although the XT6, Aviator, and MDX come by default with a 3rd row. The X5 is also notably heavier than the RX.

[@chad_rs]

@@B345T1N355Official they’re all midsize.

[@nbreuer2029]

@@B345T1N355Official The GLE also has a third row. Just the X3 and the XC60 are Compact-SUVs.

[@CosminAndreiConstantin]

@@B345T1N355Official GLE can’t be mid-size.

[@shunt8084]

What are the general differences between ratings? Hard for my layman’s eye to distinguish.

[@nectt]

Probably there are sensors in dummies that measures the energy of impact. But to eye, you can see dummies jumping less and hitting their heads less in the safer ones.

[@baybae92]

The updated test really focuses on rear passengers, whereas the old one didn't at all. Keep an eye out for "submarining," which is the passenger slipping under the lapbelt, thus potentially causing greater injury to the torso/internally.

[@jasonvitagen]

The test shows how well can the car absorb impact so as to reduce chest injuries on rear dummy, notice the pressure sensor on the torso, while at the same time maintain the rigidity of the car structure so as not to injure the occupants inside.

[@pandumiharja6769]

i'm not even surprised volvo is the first one with good ratings 😅

[@graysonalexander1071]

I have the XC60 and i love it 😊👌

[@Bailbruke]

What’s the demerits of having the XC60? Just wanna now

[@youngmanchake]

Nearly Chinese car...😊

[@graysonalexander1071]

@@youngmanchakeWhat is not chinese today? 🙈

[@youngmanchake]

@graysonalexander1071 better not in cars. Cars are not like toys or stuffs.

[@DwayneHicksCpl]

@@youngmanchakeSwedish built though.

[@dylanofficial456]

4:33 GREAT JOB VOLVO! My mom has a 2019 XC90 and I feel immortal in that car.

[@mocnywklikaniu]

@@dylanofficial456 Świetny test, szkoda, że Volvo powinno konkurować z Q7 i BMW X7 i Mercedesem a nie z Q5, X3 i GLE 😂😂😂

[@pavelfilatov9513]

Your mom earns quite a bit. What does she do for a living, if it's not a secret?

[@kasiak1288]

@@mocnywklikaniu to było Volvo xc60

[@feg3akatrey144]

Excellent video, much appreciated. It would be valuable to have some quick notes/comments shown for why a certain rating was given. Perhaps arrows superimposed on the video stills to indicate issues, like a wheel intrusion into footwell, etc., as most point reductions are not easily discerned. Thanks, 🙏

[@djplonghead5403]

Mostly back seat restraints. They didn’t keep the rear occupant in the seat.

[@lesliegerlach-eb2th]

Love my Lincoln Aviator. Happy to see it received the highest rating!!

[@fp5495]

Were you one of the lucky ones that didn't experience the onslaught of recalls the Aviator/Explorer had, and continue to?

[@pacmanc8103]

@@fp5495Right - unlike many of the vehicles in this test. I’d take my chances in the Lincoln over the others.

[@paul756uk2]

There's a reason you don't see those (or any American car) in Europe. Even the Alabama built Mercedes SUV's have poor panel alignment.

[@Lucyhays24]

Aviator owner here and have yet to be disappointed. It’s an incredibly smooth ride and just feels safe and comfortable. It would be hard to switch now

[@Lucyhays24]

I was one of the lucky ones because I waited until the kinks were out. It’s noted the aviator relaunch wasn’t the best, but they made it right for sure. 🇺🇸

[@navistormrage5057]

If u have GLE than bmw needs x5 , audi q7 and volvo xc90 to make this test fair ....btw i think Volvo xc 90 is the only car or suv in the world with 0 deaths since its launch

[@winrarwin754]

actually 0 deaths in America, i have seen some deaths and one video was horrific the volvo xc90 packed and it was said than the lady who was driving was more than 190km/h and hit a big tree

[@navistormrage5057]

@@winrarwin754 190 omg well thats too fast even for xc90

[@ginvt]

奔驰GL死亡率也是0，并没有什么意义

[@maxnixon7800]

@@winrarwin754 190 km when they use speed limit in their cars 180 km?

[@pebblesshado]

Volvo driver: "Did you feel something?"

[@fp5495]

Volvo: They're Boxy, but They're Good.

[@Uberkeko.]

I don't feel my wallet due to maintenance costs

[@pe7893]

don't exaggerate .....

[@petterlarsson7257]

they absolutely freaking felt that

[@thomasmathew1212]

I didn't see anything special with volvo🤔

[@spyridon8765]

Well done BMW Mercedes-Benz and Volvo . Disappointed Audi

[@Xzizia92]

I saw a video like this of an A4 sedan (the older model, ca 2012). Man the whole dashboard came flying towards the front seats, crazy!

[@Mo_Hamd72]

Horrible cars - high repair cost, high price and high chance of not surviving. That sums it up.

[@Nickker4]

need an audi q7 test...

[@navarrouk3487]

Lexus disappointed.

[@drk_blood]

This is harder to watch than drop testing expensive smartphones 😂

[@boyguapito1]

I was surprised by the ratings of the Lexus RX., the BMW X3 and the Lincoln Aviator. I didn’t think the Lexus would be rated anything below Acceptable. And the Aviator, rated Good?! Very impressive!

[@anastasioslastiotis503]

The testing company can be biased in favor of the European cars.

[@tylermacconnell217]

The Aviator is based upon the Ford Explorer, which is used for police work. That may play some role in its safety.

[@jim5017]

Interesting video but remember that human body internal organs can only survive limited speed deceleration without damage.

[@MrEtn1es]

We can see here why crashes are so lethal, even if we have top safety measurements in place. Look at the side windows, they rip apart from the sheer force of stoppage. You can imagine how lightweight that specific component is and how much placement is in place when it rips apart. Rear passenger is injured 100% of the time when front crash happens. Neck overextends so much.

[@kevinn1158]

This is my wife when she sees a sale. 😂

[@xmindk]

😄😄😄

[@SM-1010]

Volvo and Mercedes has always been my favorite when it comes to safety

[@mikelliteras397]

One reason I drive an Aviator but also because it’s the best riding suv out of all of these, unless you like a brick ride and hard seats. I drove all of these, other than the Cadillac, and the Lincoln was just more of a luxury car the way it drives and the stereo. 4 years with no issues is just a bonus.

[@Packer1290]

I agree. I have the MKX which is the previous Gen before the Aviator. Love the seats. I had driven a VW previously and the seats were so hard I still don't think my back has recovered.

[@DENGAMIESTELEWGW]

So what is totoya doing in this test?

[@iandavies1893]

Volvo and Mercedes have always been at the forefront of crash safety and still are. There were some pretty disappointing results in their but, that's SUV's for you.

[@egorboroda1099]

Да и Форд тоже. А вот Тойота почему-то сейчас низкие показатели(((

[@brettweltz8135]

Yeah, except Mercedes has an unseen amount of repairs that are required outside of maintenance items. High amount of technology equals high amount of probable fixes and repairs lower technology, lower probability of fixes and repairs

[@ahmedalwalid8726]

Lexus still better that mercedes

[@navarrouk3487]

Lexus, disappointed.

[@ahmedalwalid8726]

@@navarrouk3487 lexus is so underrated mate you should try both

[@edwardlaw797]

On my 8th Subaru Outback XT, almost had an xc90 but the truck suspension (wife flew in air middle of back seat during test drive 😅) and Corolla noise level threw me off… Volvo addressing those next year can’t wait!!!

[@edwardlaw797]

Also had an Audi q7 on the garage for 1 day, returned it because my trifield emf meter was off the scale inside the Audi! Germans have strong you know what?😅

[@yankeepapa3572]

How did the Merc get a good rating when the "kid's" hand flew out and smash it's hand against the C pillar of the window? View 5:35 of video

[@Hernsama]

Bc he is waving “Hi, im ok.” That’s why

[@ginvt]

应该是传感器的数据，但是无从知晓

[@Lwaves123]

Um cus there is wires inside the dummies that show how good is the safety on a car and how injured the dummy was

[@Spirit-vlad]

They aren't sharing the date from the sensors so yes they could bs people

[@Mario-R-3232]

You cant compare, eg a GLE Mercedes with a X3 BMW, it's totally unfair. Try an X5 instead and see how things will change.

[@b1r2y3n]

@@Mario-R-3232 they are not compared to each other. The standards of the tests are independent of the vehicles. Poor is poor not matter the group they are in. They just happen to be in the same video.

[@ct529a1]

Volvo and mercedes is good things, but the price not in same class

[@casmatori]

They must have changed the criteria of the test then? A few years ago, all of these would have been best picks.

[@brettweltz8135]

That’s because now they’re focusing more on the rear passengers whereas in the older test, they did not do that

[@Whywhywhyw-c5l]

they are getting more and more stringent

[@kylieraynor3846]

That start part is me in any video game that has car crash physics

[@samharkode]

That is why I ride volvo xc60 in Germany !

[@ВаняРыбаков-б7б]

Ну вот,что и следовало доказать...,Вольво лидеры как ни крути,браво Вольво!!!

[@ginvt]

现在的Volvo 和过去不能相提并论。

[@mikelliteras397]

When does the Judge Dredd foam come out

[@mustafaköse-i5i]

Bu bilgi yanlış.Volvo hala çok güvenli araç üretiyor.Ancak eskiden olduğu gibi şimdi de ülkemizde tercih edilmiyor.Çünkü biz parçası neredeyse markette bile bulunabilen yan sanayii yedek parçaları yaygın ve ucuz olan tenekeleri tercih etmeye devam ediyoruz

[@GKHAN-y9x]

Birisi böyle bir sorundan bahsetti bana. Aşağıdaki alıntıya bak. Volvo'nun masrafı çok. 2017 yılından beri xc90 kullanıyorum aracın kullanımı ve konforu malzeme kalitesi gayet güzel ancak şu ana kadar özellikle şehir dışına çıktığımda muhakkak problem çıktı Direksiyon titremesi hiç bir zaman kesilmedi Servis her seferinde deneme yanılma çözümüyle ön takımda bir parça değiştirdi ancak bir türlü problem geçmedi ve araç 80 bin km geldi Yine şehir dışına çıktım aracın yağ eksildiğini uyarısını aldım ve altına yağ akıttığını gördüm Ankara’da servise gittim aracın bloğunun çatladığını tüm turboların öldüğünü şarj motorunun bittiğini şanzımanda seloneit valfimidir nedir kilitlendiğini parça değişemeyeceğini komple şanzıman değişmesi gerektiğini ve daha anlatamadığım bir sürü parça değişmesi gerektiğini söyledi Neden olmuş olabileceğini sorduğumda xc90 larda bu problemlerin olabildiğini şans deyip çıktılar Ayrıca düzenli resmî servisine km dolmadan düzenli servise götürdüğüm halde ve önceki servislerimde hiç bir uyarı çukmadığı halde 400 bin TL Ye zor kurtuldum Araç sıfır km oldu dediler teselli ettiler Volvo imajına yakışmayan bir aracım var Satmak istesem çok zarar ediyorum Ancak almak isteyenlerin iyi araştırıp servislere gidip xc90 ların motorlarının yerlerde darmadağan olduğunu kontrol etsinler öyle karar vermesini arzu ederim Bir daha asla Volvo almam

[@ДмитрийБрель-у4ы]

Как по мне ,все авто прошли на отлично. Есть параметры которые нужны,для тестов и учета оценок,но ни как не влияющие на безопасность.

[@DSMR-bo1so]

whats the difference between good and acceptable?

[@trendwaveworld]

💎 Each item showcased oozes elegance and sophistication. The attention to detail is unparalleled, making it a true embodiment of luxury.

[@fp5495]

Okay, AI bot

[@pacmanc8103]

@@fp5495Wow, I can see from your other comments you bring a lot to conversations.🥱

[@Dood1es]

Say goodbye to the kids hand on the GLE. Good?

[@serenan920]

Swedis cars: Saab and Volvo, have a holistic view to safety...

[@pacmanc8103]

@@serenan920😂😂😂 Are Saabs even produced anymore?

[@ProXcaliber]

They open the window for the crash test, meaning if it weren't open, that likely would not have happened.

[@doobedi]

Still going to pick the Lexus!

[@Mark-eu6mc]

Keep er under 40 then

[@navarrouk3487]

Disappointing.

[@scottysvensson]

Volvo is the best premium car ☺️

[@avdp9095]

Most unreliable brand around😢😢😢

[@Charlie1776_]

Too much movement, risk of secondary collisions.

[@scottysvensson]

@Charlie1776_ it is not a german car, so dont worry about 2nd collision 😃

[@chbreet]

You correct, but In any country that temperature not exceed 40c° , come to middle east and see what's happening here , and also see how big failure are our retailers services after sale for parts and maintenance pricing.

[@serenan920]

By a long way..Bought first Volvo...Far better built than any German, Japanese or Korean car

[@crazyone1067]

Cannot believe most of these vehicles received a Marginal Rating on the Moderate Overlap test.

[@navarrouk3487]

They’re too big, too heavy. SUVs are not survivable cars!

[@rgen28]

Do they fix them afterwards 😂

[@Amgregory-CRNA]

So basically all of them will Stephen hawking our kids in the back …that’s great

[@brianklamer3328]

Don't like Lincoln's but the Aviator surprised me with it's crash results.

[@9fiveb180]

Why was the Lincoln's front driver's side wheel locked up for so many yards before impact? That seems sketchy.

[@papaniiampah1801]

Almighty Lexus “marginal” the almighty reliable, I’d rather be safe with a Volvo,bmw n Mercedes rather than focus on reliability with a Lexus. SAFETY FIRST! Life is important

[@MrMartinHolden]

Watch it again. Lexus was almost untouched. Front mask barely touched. It was even better than Volvo. Watch it carefully, mate. Watch and compare. To me Lexus has been the safest in this test.

[@Vanguard.I]

@@MrMartinHoldenyes while the driver was protected very well, the rear passenger wasn’t sadly

[@navarrouk3487]

Who can save you on the hard shoulder?😂

[@Wasabi9111]

It’s sad GM doesn’t make safer cars. I wonder if they intentionally decide to cheap out on safety.

[@Mark-eu6mc]

Just safety? I almost feel sorry for people who choose to drive government motors.

[@pacmanc8103]

@@Mark-eu6mc2 comments on this channel and you’ve already distinguished yourself!😂

[@Mark-eu6mc]

@@pacmanc8103 gasp! An opinion 😉

[@pacmanc8103]

@@Mark-eu6mc An opinion? Where’s the opinion?😮

[@Mark-eu6mc]

@@pacmanc8103 oh it’s that GM sucks in case that flew over you lol

[@DwayneHicksCpl]

Interesting how the more safe cars bounce more after impact.

[@taeizofyne]

IS THE LITTLE GIRL IN THE BACK BEING DRAMATIC

[@madmanday]

I have hard time to understand which suv is the safest and reliable. I don’t have money problems. Could someone send me which is the strongest and reliable suv for my new family to buy? Thank you

[@edgarmendoza9912]

XC90 recharge

[@kylee1515]

Where has Genesis gone????

[@Whywhywhyw-c5l]

it is not luxury

[@djplonghead5403]

Glad to see GM still knows how to give people a danger box

[@pijushmazumder4006]

What was the speed of these Suv's conducting the test?

[@dwanray4521]

Acura the best

[@boahneelassmal]

it would've been more than just helpful if the reasons for the rating had been given as well.... why does a car where the kid's head is snagged by the airbag and severely stretched forward/down better rated than the car where that doesn't happen.

[@casselroze9621]

Lexus, Lincoln, Volvo, Audi, Mercedes ❤️‍🔥😮‍💨

[@panrichard9739]

some cars' seatbelt don't even hold the passengers tightly on the seat.

[@f35alightning]

Man where is Genesis

[@GordonDavis-j8q]

Not a true luxury vehicle. Only pretending to be in their marketing.

[@spaghetti9067]

interesting that the cars with pre tensioners did the best the major of the low ratings are bc of submarining of the seatbelt so if they add pre tensioners it should bring them to a good rating

[@Allen-wk5sc]

為何不研發在前座椅後方安裝氣囊，連動後座的重量感應器，當後座有人時打開氣囊，減少後座乘客頸部甩動的傷害。

[@bmwhigh1]

1.) Cost 2.) Ford use to make inflatable seatbelts for the F-150 limited prior to 2021 I believe. Not sure if they ever really took off though

[@Foof0811]

3) front seat can move, making the air bag either useless or dangerous in many cases 4) baby seat in back seat with infant could make air bag lethal

[@prokomi1208]

Try a crash test with the Audi Q7 4L. Then you understand what a safe car is. 😉

[@sakinah7442]

@@prokomi1208 I was hit from behind by a semi truck, and I only bounced forward and had minimal damage to the rear.

[@빨간닭-s9u]

Why GLE instead of GLC?

[@ginvt]

Why GLC instead of GLE ?😂

[@კახაგურული-რ6ტ]

🇺🇸🇬🇪🇺🇸🇬🇪🇺🇸🇬🇪 როგორც ყოველთვის ღმერთი ფარავდეს ამერიკას საუკუნიდან საუკუნამდე ამინ ძან შორეა ჩემგან ამერიკა მაგრამ ყველაზე უფრო მომეწონა კადილაკი.

[@MyViewToronto]

The kid in the GLE is toast and it gets a good rating???

[@dylanofficial456]

Oh and once again Volvo infamous for the lights and hooks flying out of the headliner when the side airbag goes off

[@pavelfilatov9513]

No matter how safe a car is, public transport will always be the safest.

[@navarrouk3487]

Really?

[@pavelfilatov9513]

​@@navarrouk3487yes, look at the statistics of the percentage of accidents in private and public transport, in all countries of the non-3rd world and even in some countries of Latin America the percentage of accidents in public transport will be significantly lower.

[@spinnetti]

No context! WHY were they rated how they were?

[@badenbaden166]

Tell me someone how ratings it’s work?

[@ProXcaliber]

In simple terms, watch how many G forces are put on the test dummies. An easy way to notice this is by seeing how much they move around during impact. If you notice, as the ratings get higher the test dummies move around a lot less, especially the one in the rear.

[@lakshdeepbharti7311]

@YouCarTV Proud of Indian car companies ( Tata and Mahindra) could have given tough compitition to these cars

[@pajtim9079]

That Lexus got scrambled quite deep

[@fabianely8]

Volvo 4 ever ❤

[@Max-S01]

Different classes of cars. Mercedes should be a GLC model. Lincoln has a Nautilus model. And this turns out to be a not entirely correct comparison.

[@USandNL]

Not really sure where your classifications come from. Totally different from all other test results done by government and insurance companies!

[@cristiandumitrana6510]

After many videos watching with crash car testing , the best car is RAZVANI SUV TANC WITH ALL RESPECT FOR TRUTH AND KNOWLEDGE

[@Dmitri84reg96]

1. Почему разные классы? 2. Во всех авто все выживут. Что хорошо. 3. Вольво отработала лучше всех, есть ощущение запаса прочности. Переднее колесо не ушло от геометрии сильно.

[@chaseperryman]

Mercedes 💪

[@nikitasimakovs7268]

And volvo 😊

[@prabhunavalgund7664]

Volvo = safety

[@julyseven808]

👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

[@mohammedqayyum1140]

very surprised by lincoln

[@RealKevGotEm]

Lexus gets a crappy rating 😂 that’s how you know they’re not 1 for safety

[@serenan920]

Lexus are pants now...can't make brakes, either. Would not drive one for free

[@ProXcaliber]

In my opinion, they also look super outdated, especially in the interior.

[@titibluesg]

Why they do not use same car s size GLE , X3 (should have use x5)

[@juro603]

BMW and Volvo TOP !

[@tonysea9724]

The merc gets good 'cause the kid gets to wave for help through the back window...

[@jchill5229]

The test dummy in the back keeps frantically raising its arm demanding no more I think. Not so dumb after all.

[@dylanofficial456]

5:45 what is that

[@joerg-peter]

Man sollte schon Autos gleicher Fahrzeuggröße wählen, nimmt man einen Mercedes GLE, müsste es bei BMW ein X5 oder X6 sein, sonst ist es unfair.

[@4673962]

Looks to me the Lexus was by far the worst. See how it twisted the dummies head around. Toyota sure has been blowing it these last few years in many different categories.

[@헬리-o1s]

XC90과 X5, 카이앤이 보고 싶은데~

[@user-jw4nz8km2x]

And now there is Kia EV9 from the "poor mans brand" getting same ratings or topping all of them in certain areas. Scoring full 5 stars and in side impact getting maximum ratings.

[@monseratmarchant2327]

Audi Q5

[@gaylekimbal7777]

Why no infiniti tested?

[@kane5282]

Hand picked models to show unfair results. Good to see ppl in comments recognized that

[@andrewdubose9968]

Bias? They did the XT5, RX, Q5, the GLC (edit: GLE), X3, aviator, XC60, RDX, Aviator. That’s a totally reasonable set of cars to evaluate. Infiniti, Genesis, Range Rover, Porsche, and EV makers were not present, but if you think it was biased, what would you have included? That said, I would like to know more about the actual scoring methodology. Also worth noting that in absolute terms, they’re all very safe. I didn’t see passenger cell intrusions or compromise in any of the three cars. We just constantly raise the bar. Although it is worth mentioning that the XC 60 was introduced in 2017, so it’s competing with a newer cohort.

[@jonathanmoore4288]

Why the added music? It's inappropriate.

[@WFRULTIM]

audi q5 like anti infantry mine, dropping very small plastic details in every direction, even people near can be injured

[@Toshiaomaxwell]

My heart is beating fast bcos of new car crashing

[@meawchiyaphum5855]

I heard that They crash 1 car everyday at volvo for safety test

[@F35Nerd]

2024 and cars are still performing poorly...but lets keep adding screens into the car, rather than putting that money towards making the car safer

[@fernandovergara3119]

Cuando pagar seguro

[@chanderran]

How about Citroen

[@MBG141]

Not sold in the US Market.

[@pacmanc8103]

@@MBG141And given away in most other markets.

[@sangilhan4416]

Lincoln and Ford are the best.

[@fp5495]

For the most recalls in North America in 2023? Yes, not doubt, Lincoln and Ford are the best. Agreed.

[@pacmanc8103]

⁠@@fp5495Ah ‘most’ and ‘best’ are two different adjectives. The best for the most….hmmm.

[@merseyrailer7780]

The best at being the worst, obviously. After all, they are built in the USA.

[@pacmanc8103]

@@merseyrailer7780 Troll😛

[@davidd1692]

How did cadillac do poor but acura marginal

[@dphotography8]

Did you watch the video..? Cadillac did poor because it literally crumbled😂not surprised. Acura was acceptable and if you can’t see why then keep driving your Hyundai

[@fp5495]

@@dphotography8 What a dumb answer. No, it was actually mind-numbingly dumb.

[@pacmanc8103]

@@fp5495Mind-numbingly? Really?

[@michaelrice6729]

So what is it based by,when most of the cars look the same atthe end of the test. I didn't think the Caddilac looked worse than a lot of the others. Can u tell us what the rati gs are based on. Surely not by what the vehicles look like

[@frankieb7405]

@davidd1692 yeah didn’t make sense to me either

[@Charlie1776_]

Why only 40mph?

[@MeirCohen.kingbibi]

Because that is the Average speed for most cars.

[@OzkanOzel_USA]

It is mostly deadly after 50 mph

[@ProXcaliber]

Because that is the average speed for cars, and usually anything much higher than that is pretty deadly, no matter how safe the car is. I believe above 60 MPH, you are basically playing a game of chance.

[@EndtoEnd1517]

Good to see london in the list

[@costisordorin5785]

Volvo …👍😉

[@GordonDavis-j8q]

Missing jaguar suvs.