Creality S1 Plus Has all the right features - Let's compare it to PRUSA I3

The new printer from Creality comes with a 300mm x 300mm x 300mm print volume, it assembles in 30 minutes, has Firmware Bed Leveling with a touch sensor, filament runout detection and it's easy to use. Best of all it works right out of the box. No upgrades or modifications needed. To everyone who thinks Prusa is still dominant: Have you see what Creality is doing?
Check out my detailed review of the Prusa I3 Mk3s: • Why Does Nobody Speak ...
Mihai Designs Extrusion Explanation: • What I've learned abou...

[@FayezButts]

My work just got a bunch of S1PLUSs and they're quite impressive. That said, I did notice that there is another PTFE tube going down into the hotend and butting up against the nozzle.

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

Yeah. I got that detail wrong. Thank you for the correction. Creality does sell an all-metal version if you want to print high temperature plastics. PTFE lined hotends are quite good up to 260°C. It's Teflon like your non-stick frying pan. Molten plastic doesn't stick so you get fewer nozzle jams. All metal need to be made with high quality standards. Polished bore so that there isn't texture for molten filament to stick to it. Also high temperature non-stick coatings are beneficial. This is a lot more expensive and doesn't provide benefit if you are only going to print with PLA, ABS, TPU, and PETG.

[@ByronChou17]

I’d love to hear your thoughts on the bambu lab printers!

[@NathanBuildsRobots]

0:26 I'm still using an iPhone 6 because I recently broke my other phone. It gets the job done!

[@ame7165]

I've owned a mk3 from preorder and just got a mk3s+ and have thousands of hours between them. bone stock. I recently got an ender 3 s1 pro, which is one model up from the one you have, and I even added sonic pad (runs klipper), got input shaping and pressure advance tuned, and I still disagree with virtually everything you said. I don't remember the last failed print I had on the prusas. my ender has had many. the pros: it's way more quiet than my bambu carbon x1, but a hair louder (thanks to fans) than my prusas. (not sure if pro differs much from the plus). the motion system is more quiet thanks to the wheels on gantry motion system, but the prusa comes with noctua for the heat brake, so fan-wise, it wins. print quality-wise, stock for stock the ender s1 pro wins slightly, but with a caveat. smooth surfaces looked better, like the bow of benchy, but considering default speeds are like less than half of the prusas, I'd hope so. the actual caveat is that when you print a calibration cube, you see it has bulging edges and really badly needs pressure advance. klipper fixed that, but after adding klipper it loses the price advantage. (if you got at full price like I did, I think it was about $550 + $160 for klipper, so $710). out of the box, with bulging corners like that, it's not a great choice for practical parts with engineering tolerances for fit. the prusa's calibration cube out of the box is a thing of beauty. also, the prusa starts printing so much faster. the bed leveling is way better with pinda. the ender is still faster than my bambu at bed leveling, but the prusa smokes it. with the prusas, I do what most prusa owners do. start a print, and after the first layer, use the menu to crank speed to 200%. it just works and gets very respectable print times with virtually no difference in quality. doing this, it absolutely runs circles around the ender. even after klipper I can't get it to beat the stock prusa. I can get faster prints out of it but the print quality suffers greatly. the prusa's name brand parts (especially the hot end) just perform better at speed than the enders. I imagine the pro does even better as I think I remember the plus and base s1 don't get the all metal sprite extruder like my pro variant. it was worth getting and tinkering with, but it just isn't reliable enough to replace one of my prusas. talk to anyone who went the other way around, from an ender to a prusa, and you'll hear their praises about getting fed up with constantly tinkering with the printers for various failure reasons, then finally just getting a printer that works every time with no drama with the prusa. also slightly unrelated, but I've had my carbon x1 with AMS for a few weeks now and I still haven't sold my prusas for several reasons. it's slightly tempting, as when it DOES print right, it prints VERY quickly with VERY solid quality. the prusa's quality benchy still beats both the carbon x1 and ender 3 s1 (even on klipper), but the carbon x1 can get VERY close while printing at 2-4x the speed of the prusa, so it gets a pass. the $700 p1p is tempting as I don't even use the lidar now, but being forced to have a lower quality cameras kind of sucks, so who knows. they're so loud that I think for that reason alone, I won't sell both prusas. maybe one of them, but for now, at least one will stay as my printer when I need to be near the printers.

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

1) You sure are throwing around a lot of claims. My cousin's third uncle says he saw your office and you don't have a Ender 3 S1 or a Bambu Labs printer to actually compare to your Prusa. 2) Why are you conflating things by bringing in the sonic pad? You don't need it. I showed the two printers out of the box. The Creality printed better even without the sonic pad. 3) Now you are just listing small defects and lots of other confusing variables in an effort to make the Prusa sound superior. What you are doing is called bullsh!tt!ng. 4) You said "talk to anyone who went the other way around, from an ender to a prusa" those guys don't exist. That's why I have a job on KZbin. I am the guy who has both and I disagree with your assessment. What kind of guy buys all these printers like you say you have? Are you another KZbinr who gets sent these things for free. I know SERIOUS 3D printer hobbyists and they are all selling their Prusas to buy the Bambu Labs printer. See, they don't actually make money from their print farm attempts so they can't justify purchasing all these printers. How does your wife feel about all this wasted money you spend? Your entire comment sounds like a guy who works in the Prusa marketing department who is trying desperately to put out every fire at once. You are trying to use this single comment to disparage all possible competitors to the Prusa. The Bambu Labs printer and the Creality have almost nothing in common EXCEPT that they are both threats to Prusa sales. Why you would see it necessary to disparage both...you are sus.

[@No0o0o0o0o0]

@@DesignPrototypeTest This dude is on something, The only thing a prusa has in common with a Bambulab is that that use electricity to run. There is no comparison, for the price The X1 stomps the prusa.

[@tadhgd350]

@@No0o0o0o0o0 nah x1 stomps in terms of speed. Reliability not so much. I have both a prusa, an x1 and a fully tuned voron trident and In terms of quality the x1 is a bit behind the prusa and the voron is miles ahead. Speed wise voron crushes the bambu but the bambu decimates the prusa. Reliability, the prusa blows both out of the water and the voron is noticeably more reliable than the x1. Longevity wise, idk bout the voron and x1 but the prusa has 25000 hours on it

[@dt08jh8]

Creality has a legit licence for trinamic drivers. Trinamic even has the Creality logo on their offical website.

[@videoviewer2008]

My GF has an iPhone 8. Works pretty well still.

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

Yes, and the Prusa I3 Mk.3 "works pretty well still." I should have said in the video "Who do you know is still buying an iPhone 8 in 2022" If anyone already has a Prusa I3 Mk.3 keep using it until it no longer works and you can't fix it. It prints just fine. No need to replace it, but for goodness sake don't recommend that anyone purchase a new one when there are now options like the Creality available.

[@sculptaware4548]

@Design Prototype Test this should be pinned as the top comment should shut up a lot of the fan boys you are unbiased in this review and this comment hits it on the nail if you have a MK3 great glad you're happy with it but don't recommend it in todays market as there is now cheaper and better alternatives.

[@videoviewer2008]

@@DesignPrototypeTest that's definitely a fair distinction between continue to use vs buy new now at full original MSRP.

[@paul-begley]

@@DesignPrototypeTest I absolutely 100% agree with this type of advice. Prusa's are great. I love mine (and my Ender pro and e3d bigbox), but would I buy the same Prusa today at the same price (or more) with no improvement over my 3+ year old original, when there are so many other as good/better and cheaper alternatives? No.

[@jstro-hobbytech]

@@DesignPrototypeTest In all your insanity, double quotes that cannot be argued with. Ps. Add thank you and memberships

[@Bennett_Lab]

I have the S1 Plus. Combined it with the Creality Sonic Pad for Klipper. Absolutely a beast now. I did not like the the TouchPad that came with printer layout terrible. Klipper pad and using web interface is much better. Great video

[@ame7165]

agree, printing from cure is VERY convenient. it made me go back and add octoprint to my prusas haha

[@bernardosilva7306]

Yep, almost all printers use Marlin which you can exchange gcode because it’s standardized. Klipper supports the same gcode also. Prusa has a proprietary gcode which is dumb :(

[@clutch2827]

Never thought Prusa was worth the price. My #1 printer is the Artillery Sidewinder X2 for around 250 dollars shipped.

[@zero00tolerance]

I have seen print quality from the Sidewinder X1 and X2 it's amazing out of the box took less than 10 minutes to setup as oppose to the Prusa Mk3 kit which can take up to 6 -10 hours build time. Only an idiot would think Prusa is a better choice in term of price and print quality.

[@geovannyguzman8721]

Hey I’m looking to buy that exact printer soon, do you have any problems with the bed adhesion from what I see it has a non removable bed so I would probably buy a removable PEI coated bed plate. Also I know it has silent steeper motor, but what are the fans like? Are they creality level loud?

[@clutch2827]

@@geovannyguzman8721 I've used a mirror bed and gluestick for years so I am a little biased but I think the x2 bed does not adhere as well. I was thinking about just clipping a pei sheet to it instead of doing the magnetic thing to reduce weight but it's probably fine with the magnetic backing. This thing is quiet as a mouse. When it is on and idle, no fans are running. When it is printing, you can barely hear it. Print a few add on's like rubber feet, and the z axis stabilizers and this thing excellent even though stock is great too. Look up 3d printed props video on youtube. He has a decent coupon code. That's how I got mine.

[@usrenmae]

With the release of the sv06 I am lost why people still look at prusa. An amazing clone for under 300

[@ame7165]

name brand parts and top quality service. there's a reason why every print farm uses prusas. sure, they can get 2-3x more prints from creality or sovol, but they end up spending way more time tweaking and fixing and repairing and replacing. there are several KZbin videos where people tired other brands and switched to prusa and they praise the hell out of it as they went from constant issues to a whole farm that just hums along. the original i3 design came out just about 11 years ago. it has received very subtle and slow updates, but to the places where it counts, and that's what has gotten it to be so polished. and considering they print their printers from their own print arm, of their own printers, they get thousands of personal testing hours to help them identify weak points and such. you can tell, as the printer looks basic, but the performance and reliability you get out of it is super impressive. also, even if you can get a printer that performs 90% as well for cheaper, another thing people forget about is noise. the prusa is VERY quiet, even without using silent mode. it comes with real Japanese linear bearings and a name brand noctua fan. and the silent stepper drivers. in silent mode, it's so quiet it's crazy. I did preorder the sv06, as I'm just curious and couldn't resist for the Black Friday pre order price of $230 and for the record, I have an ender s1 pro with sonic pad (klipper), and a bambu carbon x1 with AMS. both are cool in their own ways, but haven't provoked me to sell my prusas yet. the bambu comes close, but it's super loud, stilll isn't as reliable, and quality lacks behind the prusa a tiny bit, but that doesn't matter when you need the speed, as the quality is very close.

[@101stsurvivor]

Because you're paying for more than just the printer. You're paying for the support which is some of the best in the consumer printing industry, you're paying for much higher quality parts, you're paying for continued research and development, you're paying for the printables website to remain ad free and you're paying for a company to pay their employees a living wage.

[@ame7165]

@@101stsurvivor exactly

[@calebphelps7030]

The sv06 is a hot pile of garbage

[@billkaroly]

I'm loving my Ender 3 S1 Pro. I installed a 3rd party firmware called "professional firmware" which is way better than the stock. I had to downgrade the touchscreen to the Ender 3 V2 screen which uses a wheel. Nathan Builds Robots has a modder board you should look at. I bought a second Sprite assembly for swapping out nozzles. I have plans

[@krazybonnie5523]

I disagree with the touchscreen being better than a click wheel + lcd display, i always prefer a tactile interface to a non tactile one (plus a lcd will work with klipper if u ever feel the need to upgrade) I do agree that the creality is generally better than the prusa for the price, but for prusa money, a corexy is def the way to go rn

[@cosminjuverdeanu3671]

Well an 1990 Mercedes in 2023 it's a Mercedes. 500$ it's not a good price for half of a printer (1steper z, stupid drivers, etc). You are comparing 🍏 with 🥜 in 2022. I don't have an i3 but I've just build one from dyi mentality that i3mk3 has born with it. Creality...nice printers... Just build your own and it's much better.

[@g.s.3389]

I have a nearly original CR10, the first one that came out. I have just added during time an all metal hot-end and auto bed leveling, then I moved to klipper (with an old RPI I had around) and since I got rid of the spring the quality became amazing, I am so happy that I hope it will last for ever. during all these years I found that I used the 30x30 bed 10% of the time, but it helped me a lot to have such a larger bed. I think that 2525cm bed is too small, at least for me, I still think that the sweet spot is 30x30. another thing I doon't get is why do they still use springs when they have auto bed leveling... I got a huge improvement in quality when I got rid of them... my 2 cents....

[@ArtillaVeq]

What kind of bed leveling you have in your CR-10? There is no need for replacing mainboard?

[@g.s.3389]

@@ArtillaVeq no, no need to replace mainboard. I have added bl-touch because I wanted to get rid of the knobs that are under the bed. getting rid of the knobs and springs is where you get improved quality the most.

[@ame7165]

ender extruder assembly is smaller, but saying it wins is funny. even on klipper, it can't touch the prusa in speed (while maintaining performance). we're comparing their new sprite extruder to a name brand e3d hot end, name brand bond tech gears, higher torque extruder motor, and name brand noctua heat brake fan. and the stock part cooling fan works fine. centrifugal fans have good static pressure, and being that close to the bed, it cools just fine, even printing virtually everything at 200% speed like most prusa mk3 users do. and apparently someone skipped statistic class if they think the setup routine is showmanship. it's an inductive sensor. they're noisy. to get the most accurate measurement, you want the most powerful reading, and you get that by being perfectly centered to the read locations. you don't get that by checking it once. you test it from many directions, many times, and take an average to get a nice solid answer. maybe some kalman filter for good measure. and you complain about setting up the pinda height, but the instructions literally tell you to mount it one zip tie distance from the bed while the nozzle is at perfect printing height. I got it first try. read the manual! and you keep mocking the "it just works" thing, but I've had my mk3 (non-s, non-s+) from preorder and have thousands of hours on it, and I've never tightened a single crew or belt. not one damn thing. six years, still the calibration done on day one. still prints perfectly. that's "it just works". and the lengthly pined calibration is why it can mesh level the bed in like 1/3 the time other prints like the ender takes, and nail it every time. 1st layer is one of the single most important things in 3d printing for success and reliability. prusa knows where to put their time and effort.

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

So do you consider it your job to sow the seeds of doubt. Nothing you are saying is concrete. Your entire game is just to make things seem less clear cut. Both extruders clearly print without issue up the maximum speed that the printers can be run at. You are just trying to pick off each win of the Creality one by one and make them seem like they aren't wins. You are a propogandist. Why do you behave this way? Are you being paid, or is this just a hobby for you? Are you some new sort of troll? You aren't here for the LOLs you are here for the manipulations?

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

Seriously though. Stop trying to manipulate the internet. Let the printers speak for themselves. Tell Josef to make a competitive printer which is competitively priced instead of forcefully selling us on his 5 year old overpriced inferior machine.

[@ame7165]

@@DesignPrototypeTest propagandist? oh man, you're about to motivate me to make a video in direct reply to your clown ass. where do i even start? first, none of these printers would exist without Josef's contributions to 3d printing. i built my first 3d printer just about 11 years ago and it was a reprap mendel i3. i bought prusa's pcb bed heater. slapped on a sheet of glass with binder clips and layered kapton tape on the surface. frame was A frame with threaded rods from the hardware store and joints were abs printed by my friend on his printer, in the spirit of reprap. brains? arduino mega and some drivers on 0.1 pitch headers on a shield. generic chinese steppers. while clowns like you have this hilarious hate for prusa, they never realize what he's done to consumer 3d printing. he could've done what bre pettis did and sell out and go private. nope. makeebot, and therefore stratasis, acquiring thingiverse, then changing for EULA to say they own all objects uploaded to it, motivated him to create what's how called printables. he made a great fork of slic3r. opened it to all printers and includes profiles for competing printers and filaments. leaves it completely open source. called bambu out on it when they based their slicer on prusa slicer but didn't contribute back per license. (they complied) he standardized flexible magnetic build plates. and PEI surfaces. and mesh bed leveling. and the use of silent microstepper drivers. filament runout sensor. power panic recovery. and remember, the mk3 had all of this six years ago. everyone is playing catch-up. and he didn't hoard any of this. it's all open. also, garbage in, garbage out, filament quality was not consistent, so he bought equipment and started making his own. it was game changing, and we can thank him for forcing the market to shift, and most filaments improved since. even a lot of cheaper ones list their tolerances how. he doesn't wait for the industry to change. if he sees the need, and opportunity, he leads with change he will go down in the history books for being one of the biggest players in bringing turn-key consumer 3d printers to our homes. some idiots always get stuck on the wrong side of history, so i'm not surprised that your responses were personal attacks with no data to back your blind rebuttals. i speak from experience. pointing a camera at your printer and uploading it to youtube doesn't automatically mean you know what you're talking about. by the way, you've already shown that you don't know what you're talking about multiple times in this video alone. you said you doubt anybody would run klipper against that oem marlin board. ha, you mean the oem board that runs a 32 bit SoC? the one that people directly flash klipper onto? and even more hilarious, CREALITY themselves do what you claim doubt that nobody would do. the sonic pad. runs klipper. still uses the oem board to drive the kinematics. i could go on and on but why bother? you're like the rest of the clowns coming out of the woodwork that got into 3d printing late and have no idea about Josef carrying the industry to where it's at today. the bambu fanboys are the worst if it, but apparently ones without bambu's like you exist too. morons. claiming print farms don't make money as a way to try to discredit their printer choice. get a clue

[@Bot_Brad]

Hello Sir. I have had a 3nder3 for a while but am still very much a noob. Can you please make a video where you take a ender3 and upgrade it to print like a Prusia. I live in Huntsville Al.

[@corydsnell]

I purchased the S1 Plus instead of springing for a Prusa. After weeks of calibration tests and tweaking settings I found that I was outside of the timeframe I had to return it. I just assembled my Prusa last weekend and haven't touched the S1 since. Maybe I'm just unlucky and got a crap one but the Prusa has surpassed my expectations.

[@6581punk]

The Prusa is a workhorse, reliable and has been refined for years. These other brands start from scratch every time and want you to keep buying a new model instead of upgrading what you have.

[@CartaIV]

Wanna sell it? Lol

[@kamilolszewitz2935]

relax. Prusa will be gone soon, Bambu will do the job ;)

[@MaxFenix8k]

Really glad see you still doing great videos, fan boys just defend the brand because they spend so much in garbage if they don't defends it they will feel like idiots spending that much money in really outdated technology, keep doing videos like this, Good luck!

[@6581punk]

Nothing outdated about the Prusa. There's printing companies using those 24/7 with minimal downtime. It's open source, you can get or print parts. Where's the 5 filament loader for the Creality? Where's the upgrade path?

[@MisterkeTube]

WTH ... The S1 *IS* running Marlin and running Klipper on it is easy and if you get Creality's Klipper box with screen (forgive me for not knowing the name by heart), you get a Klipperized printer in such a easy way that only a printer with Klipper pre-installed might be easier. So, honestly your Duet-fetish is similar to the Prusa-fetish you are cursing others over ... And again, I'm no S1 fan, but you should not bash it with incorrect statements.

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

>Duet-fetish is similar to the Prusa-fetish Except that Duet do all the hard work themselves to progress the hobby and then deliver a product which is actually superior instead of the Prusa which as I demonstrated in this video only pretends to be superior. Oh, and Prusa doesn't develop ANYTHING themselves. Litereally every feature on a Prusa is an idea which was proven and brought to Prusa by someone else and then adapted/tweaked by Prusa and removing the original creator the Prusa name gets slapped on the feature. Afterwards anyone else to tries to use the feature gets accused of copying Prusa and the "community" mobs them with hate for daring to trespass on Prusa's turf. EVEN THOUGH PRUSA IS OPEN SOURCE!

[@SeerWS]

I had the i3 mk3s+ and bought an Ender 3 S1 Pro. I then bought another. The S1 is my printer of choice and I'll keep buying more of them. It's just better all around.

[@Rolman3D]

I got into 3D printing about 3 years ago just before the COVID crisis. I bought an Ender 3 and it has out preformed the Prusa I3 since. Having worked on building an I3 I laughed when I heard 9 hours to build the i3, my Ender 3 took about 1-2 hours to assemble and that’s with no experience with using an 3D printer before. Since then I’ve upgraded my Ender 3 to have a CR touch and touch screen, it’s outperformed my brothers CR 10 and friends i3 since. When setting up the “smart sensor” on the i3 you have to very carefully tighten the screws that hold it in place on the printer at a specific height, otherwise the printer doesn’t work. When using the i3 myself and the group of younger children working on the printer encountered errors that stopped us printing for about 5 days vs my Ender 3’s easy setup. I’ve printed helmets and Cosplay armour on my Ender 3 with ease and my friends with their 2 prusa i3s can’t print anything better than a “batterang” from the Batman Dark Knight. I recently discovered how to have the best quality print profiles on my brothers CR 10 whilst having the fastest time without sacrificing quality. I took 2 day long prints (48 hours on Cura) down to just 13-15 hours. He’s never seem such high quality on his printer and speed. Now I can’t wait to get myself an Ender 3 S1 Plus you’ve sold it to me from this video and I’ve never seen a video by you before. As a manufacturing engineer I instantly understood all of the points that you made and found some very interesting. Thank you for being so informative.

[@tactiti0n]

You sound like a savvy individual. Its no suprise you've managed to make good use of your tools. Others don't have your innate abilities lol.

[@spartan3299]

Still using the Ender 3 Pro with genuine BLTouch, Duet 2 FW for fear of messing with success. I finally changed to a Mosquito all metal hot end but kept the stock heater block so as to continue using your Air duct, Nice upgrade. A whambam3d flex bed covered in PEX, which works w/ petg, pla, abs, LW-pla. For flexible filament I still use the proprietary Cetus3D Mk2 that still prints beautifully onto blue tape. I'm done with CUrA and only held on because printing single layer rc planes with LWPLA dictated using CURA settings uo to now. Started with PrusaSlicer which seems to work well on stock ender settings, but will now try SuperSlicer. Enjoy your candid reviews and tolerated the intro with minimal cringe hehee.

[@burnout.c]

Hmmm… different from my experience. The Ender 3 S1 was my first printer and I learned a lot from it because I did way too much tinkering in past year. Now it runs Klipper and can print with quite incredible speed. However, I almost have to tune the settings for each model I created to achieve a good enough quality. I find this frustrating, as it could not “just work”. This is especially a problem if one aims to print for profit. Plus, the bed leveling mechanism is very unreliable. You could see people proposing all kinds of solutions in Facebook groups. That was why I ended up buying a Prusa MK3S+ to see how good it is, since people running print farms appraise its consistency. For me, it was day and night. Although it looks like a dinosaur, it is old tech, the movements are relatively loud, and it cannot hit the top speed of a Klipper machine (you lose some useful features if you go Klipper on MK3 and it’s a bit more complicated to install Klipper than more modern machines, so I’ll assume you won’t do it), the print quality seem to me surreal at first. No, I didn’t get that obvious artifacts on the surface like on your video. And the consistency is as good as what I heard. Now I rarely have to tinker print settings. I can press print, walk away and it won’t fail.

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

We don't know who you are. You could be working for the Prusa marketing department. Your entire comment is a testimonial contradicting what I have documented on camera. If you want us to take you seriously make a video proving your words. I'm sure Prusa would be happy to retweet it and blow up your channel. What's adds to the sus factor of your comment is the single upvote. Most other comments don't have that. Looks like you used your alternate account to upvote your own comment. Everything you said just seems to be manipulation without substance.

[@burnout.c]

Nah… I’m just sharing my experience and I have no will to make sure everyone take my words seriously. Just like I won’t 100% believe anyone’s content. It’s more like “okay, someone had that situation”. People can do their own DD and make their own decision.

[@tadhgd350]

@@burnout.c dude don’t bother arguing with DPT every time he sees positive things about prusa it’s “prusa marketing team” and whenever he sees negative comments he encourages them as they “prove his point”

[@Marcos-tj8nk]

DPT lives in his own spy movie where he is saving the world from Dr. Prusa and his infiltrated agent like YOU. What a teenager

[@billkaroly]

I added a linear rail kit from Amazon to my Ender 3S1 Pro.

[@georg6876]

Fwiw out of all four people I know who own a printer (five including myself), none of us has a Prusa Machine and we all unanimously agree that the Prusa is a pretty "meh" machine.

[@scottmahoney8528]

sorry, didn't finish the entire video. I've had a prusa for 3 years now and never experienced any of the "FAULTS" you pointed out. I would have respected a fair comparison but you're obviously just bashing the prusa for whatever reason...

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

And yet another KZbinr has experienced the same and also it's all over the forums as "inconsistent extrusion" You're probably right though. The godhead Prusa can do no wrong. Everything with that name is perfect and beyond reproach.

[@tadhgd350]

@@DesignPrototypeTest every direct drive printer has inconsistent extrusion. It’s difficult to circumvent

[@toalan]

Rod and bearings are much superior to v rollers, POM Z nuts are much superior to brass Z nuts. Prusa has z motors with integrated threaded rod, that together with the POM nuts mitigate z banding issues. On the Creality printed spire under harsh light, you can see z banding in your video. Pusa does have more surface artifacts than most other modern printers using modern stepper motor drivers. The creality machine has a bed probe that makes physical contact with the print surface and that is much superior to the non contact probe used by Prusa. Edit: The prusa metal frame in the zy plane, that used to be a positive as other mendel style printers used acrylic or wood, now I wish it was standard aluminium extrusions so that I could bolt a proper spool holder or other things to it securely without drilling and tapping the frame. The calibration aspect of the mk3, not talking about the first layer calibration, is typically run once after the machine has been fully assembled. On my geniune Mk3s, it passed calibration without problems. On my clone Mk3s I got a very specific error, I forget the exact error, when I went to check I saw there was an error on my part and I fixed it and the calibration completed successfully. Without the calibration I would have eventually caught the error myself but still it was cool that even on a clone mk3s the calibration caught the error.

[@buzzbbird]

Not a bad comment since you're talking about your personal experience and what you learned from it. Your first sentence however is untrue in the absolute sense of untrue. Not only are they not much better they're not measurably better nor visibly better in the final product.

[@protogenius]

​@@buzzbbirdI agree, I've managed a lab with many different machines, and own 9 of my own machines, only one of my personal machines has rod and bearing and that's my original i3 prusa, I had to stop using it when the rods got scarred up from dust and started to bind. (It was old and not worth fixing) After a decade of experience I'll take the V rail and wheel set up every time hands down, it's also a great place to hide the drive belts which is an excellent design feature instead of the belts just free floating and vibrating like a guitar string causing them to eventually wear out or go out of calibration.

[@836dmar]

I’m using an iPhone 8. If you upgrade just because they tell you you can, I have some Florida swamp land to sell you. It’s almost as silly as hanging on to a Prusa mk3 printer!

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

Okay, but would you tell somebody to buy an iPhone 8 today if it cost twice as much as the newest model?

[@836dmar]

@@DesignPrototypeTest I guess I don't understand. The Ender 3 v2 is now $199 but I'm looking into the S1 Pro. I guess I need to watch the rest of the video but this stuff falls out of relevancy faster than the iphone 8! Incidentally, I would indeed suggest the iphone 8 due to the enhanced tracking and recognition features of subsequent models. I've thought every iteration was great but they will quit supporting them to get you to keep moving along with the program.

[@hobbyrob313]

family bought a Printer Ender 3 S1 Pro. ( VERY NICE machine! ) they are beginners, but they are very happy with it. they manage pretty well for a bunch of newcomers to 3D printing. I myself have 2 self-build Prusa i3 (not a buy Prusa) but really self-build*DIY* with M5 Z axis threads. (still works fine!) Healthy and Friendly Greetings from the Netherlands! Rob

[@shokdj1]

Still using an iPhone 7 lol not really worried about a new phone. But that being said I got my daughter an iPhone 14 and that’s way more advanced.

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

You exhibit good decision making.

[@shokdj1]

@@DesignPrototypeTest nah

[@chrisdixonstudios]

You had me until "Global warming" in Europe, LMAO 😂. Speed is directly proportional to quality of extruder heat, if frames and steppers are equall..speed matters unless you have farm space. BTW, thanks for inspiring me to learn parametric modeling and the meaning of ten thousand iterations.. God bless.

[@tek9058]

why is anyone buying printers on wheels nowdays? they are inferior and a constant issue

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

Ha! What are you on about? Think of the delrin wheels like tires on your car. You don't see any cars with metal rims riding on the pavement. The softer material gives a nicer ride and eliminates slop/wiggle in the movement system. Unlike the Prusa linear bearings, you don't have to keep grease on the movement system when using delrin wheels. Grease which can easily get on your hands and clothes when interfacing with the printer. It's true that if you over tighten the eccentric nut tensioning system on the wheels they will degrade from being under too much pressure. So adjust your printer correctly and you will have these superior movement system at your disposal.

[@ashvanes484]

I have an Ender 3 8 bit old school and it runs near 24/7 printing petg with a microswiss all metal hotend, the metal extruder, capricorn tube. yeah it took me some time to get right but now it's just a dead steady beast. Also have an Ender 3 S1 Pro running Klipper, and an Ender 5 Pro w Klipper. These are all very good machines. I don't get the hate.

[@buzzbbird]

I want to see the S1 vs Neptune 3 Pro vs Vyper in a side by side. Do you have those 3 printers? For the money, and on paper it looks like they might finish according to their respective prices. I know the Vyper is not a direct drive, but the extended arm for the geared extruder and shortened Bowden setup might just be as capable as anything on this side of Ninjaflex.

[@andrec230]

Hey, thanks for help us to open our eyes

[@gitss7367]

I see all kinds of print farms on youtube featuring all kinds of printers. The majority of them have few if any Prusa's. When watching videos to try to glean information from all sources I see the Prusa farms making odd assumptions about upkeep on roller wheel machines that seem off. Watched one last night and the take away was "I have 20 Prusa's because I don't want to adjust all my wheels every week". Approaching 3 years of using home 3d printers and I get so little useful info from Prusa featured videos. I use original Ender 3 Pro upgraded over the years to half the price of a Prusa kit printing 95% in ABS consumables for out small business or replacement parts for machines we use I designed. Still on the original belts, motors, and wheels and I have replaced 2 fans and just had a cable go bad. I think i have to had adjust my eccentric nuts 3 or 4 times and tighten my belts 2-3 times. I am happy I didn't buy into the Prusa hype back then. To be honest it wasn't the cost that stopped me it was the PEtG printed parts and the damn zip ties in key areas that combined with printing ABS in an enclosure that exceeded my comfortable risk level.

[@baljazz]

When I was researching to buy my first 3d printer I figured out real quick that prusa was an over priced ridiculous scam. This was 3 years ago. Makes absolutely no sense but so much sense at the Sametime as there is always an apple brand for every product.

[@Dashitishere22]

If only this video had been out before I bought a Prusa. Sure it works but I could have gotten 2 other printers for the price of this one and be printing twice as fast. I personally do not recommend Prusa's to people.

[@brezovprut4431]

Dude, Prusa is more than fair. You shouldn't only compare hardware, but printer sustainability. You pay them for: 1) upgradeability 2) 24/7 customer support 3) firmware updates 4) Awesome slicer For DIY thinkers cheap hardware is go-to option, but if you want reliable workhorse MK3 sits just in the sweet spot between "iPhone of 3D printers" - Ultimaker and chinese printers that will be outdated with new models in just few next years.

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

1)WHAT? Prusa goes out of the way to discourage you from changing or modifying the base printer. Even the upgrade path to add a Raspberry Pi 0 is in shambles The claim conflicts with your second point because if you modify your Prusa you will lose customer support. Also, the Creality is better for upgrading. Put a Duet with RRF into the S1 and you still have spent less time and money than it cost you to buy+assemble the Mk.3 2)I guess. I'm getting a lot of comments from folks telling me they had terrible experiences with the Prusa support department. There are a couple in the comments for this video. 3)I guess. Creality does updates too. Prusa's are probably more polished. But then again Prusa is running an 8 bit controller and imprecise click wheel. How much can you really update it? 4)You can use Prusa Slicer for the Creality printers too. Prusa slicer is a fork of Slic3r. Super Slicer is a fork of Prusa Slicer. So, basically I was using Prusa slicer in the video to run the S1. >Ultimaker and chinese printers that will be outdated with new models in just few next years. EXACTLY! The current Chinese printer here makes the Prusa outdated. Imagine how far behind Prusa will be "in just few next years." Prusa better release the XL soon or they won't exist as a company "in just few next years."

[@brezovprut4431]

@@DesignPrototypeTest I never said Prusa is ideal, but (MK3 and MINI) are just FAIR for extra what you pay. Obviously their constant rise and development speaks for it self. 1) Not everyone wants to use RPI, Duet, or modify at all, i assume 70% of Prusa customers are ones that don't want to modify anything on the printer. 3) Some people (like me) don't personally care about 8bit controller, and just likes oldschool click-wheel. 4) EXACTLY, chinese company use R&D from hardworking companies and Open source contributors to earn money without any money engagement. Prusa is paying 40 developers constantly working on just PrusaSlicer. (I think we should respect and support that) My MK3 is not outdated, but my 6 years old CR10 is definitely.

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

4) You were saying Prusa Slicer is superior and that is a reason to buy an I3 Mk.3. Now you want to talk about Chinese companies using open source and not contributing. These are totally different topics. I think you are grasping at straws because you are an idealogue who can't let go of your adoration for Prusa despite compelling contrary evidence. Release preconceptions from your mind and judge the thing impartially. Don't go searching for logical justifications to support your feeling that a Prusa is the best.

[@MikiCab1]

Cannot agree with you more. I was an original wait list MK3 owner and Prusa was an excellent printer back then and still and excellent printer now. All these years later Prusa support still supports me. Twice early on had parts issues and they shipped replacement parts that I received within a week after opening a service call.

[@MikiCab1]

@@DesignPrototypeTest You don't lose customer support if you upgrade your Prusa Printer. I know because I have upgraded mine and they still respond to me. They maybe not be able to help the particular upgrade but they support the rest of it. I bought my Prusa MK3 the 3rd day it was on sale and was on the wait list. I have never dealt with better support of a product and I have been in product support for 30 years.

[@bobbinferbears]

I, for one, would love to see you design a split part cooling fan duct for the sprite extruder. I am very interested in that

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

As you wish. I'm working on it now.

[@NathanBuildsRobots]

@@DesignPrototypeTest I’ve got a start on one, the f3D is on my Patreon if you want to take some inspiration

[@billkaroly]

There are some good 5015 part cooling options for the Sprite.

[@joaovictoredgardodasilva2221]

I saw that you commented on the difference in size and mass of the bed and how it affects the acceleration and jerk parameters. But I believe this comparison is not fair, as the S1 plus is a large format printer. It would be fairer for the comparison to be made using the S1 Pro or the normal S1, as they have a bed size close to the Prusa I3 MK3.

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

I was giving the S1 Plus credit for having the larger print volume so it's only fair to speak about the drawback that comes with that larger format. BTW, I would call 100-150mm beds "Small format" 200-350mm beds "Medium Format and 400-600mm "Large format. I don't think the S1 Plus qualifies as large format. But that's just my opinion.

[@Spartyo]

Can you check out the Sovol SV-06? I got it for $229 and have had a great experience.

[@TheJacklwilliams]

I had to pause, 39 seconds in, as a career technologist and lifelong NUT about all things engineering and tech? I’ve got an 8 plus and? There’s not a ssingle sign yet I need to replace it. It’s for consuming, ebooks, web content, etc… and? It still does a fine job. Paid cash for it and yeah, when the time comes for me to get a new one, I’ll pay cash for that. Finance a phone? Seriously? That said, I’ve an Anet A8 Plus (go ahead, make fun of me, I deserve it) that taught me how to print, at 279.00. Just got a Sovol SV05, same price, ten times the goodies. I have to admit man. I want an MK3. Prusa needs to evolve for certain, yet it’s widely known those little devils are workhorses made with reliable tech that kick out what’s STILL the standard of quality. Joe, if your here reading (LOL, like you aren’t busy with a million other things), I want an MK3 I just can’t afford it! ;-) Anyway /end rant. Carry on! Edited to add: Great opening! Subscribed!!!

[@greliusz]

I pointed out what you said wrong: Prusa parts are made of ABS. not PETG. As you say he is 5 years old and it is true. 5 years warranty and support from this company, they are confirmed by people. Creality where? The warranty is just a piece of paper. My CR10SPRoV2 printer damaged the thermistor and shows the temperature incorrectly, and despite not moving it, I complained and the company does not respond. It doesnt work in EU countries. That's right, it's 8 bit, but it uses 100 percent more power than 32 bit printers. It prints flawlessly and has a dozen confirmed filament profiles that you don't have to fiddle with to set up. You're right that it was 5 years, but look at it honestly, they've only just caught up to Prusa level. For 5 years Creality has been pushing people cheap printers like the Ender 3, I remember they said it was better than Prusa and it wasn't true. A marketing scam. But what about the fact that the S1 Pro has just come out ... I'd rather you talk about Bambu Lab X1 Carbon or P1P because they can be compared to Prusa. Creality in my eyes is a joke and scammers. If the Prusa mini version, I would prefer Kingroon KP3S Pro, Ender 2 Pro is also a joke and a dump. I have noticed that Creality bribes Yootubers like Chep who favor and despite other printers dont reviews. Anyway, I don't favor Prusy, because I have Voron 2.4 350 and as I wrote, I had a CR10SProV2, it was my first printer that disappointed me quite a bit. I have friends who have a Prusy farm. And when I look at the Ender farm, I think they come out the same, because people have to spend on mods to get to the level of Prusa. And you know what's best, I see the comparison. Prusa had less breakdowns than Enders. If something broke, they got it for free. Creality no, you would have to order and pay.

[@MikiCab1]

The original Prusa MK3 is not the same printer as what they are selling now. It has been upgraded many times and is as modern a system as you can find at that price point. I bought my Prusa MK3 3 days after they launched and was on the wait list. Since then they have introduced many upgrades that were up-gradable on existing instruments. Not all companies will do that. When you buy a Prusa MK3s now it is like buying a Iphone 14 not an iphone 8. Your logic is all wrong. Just because Prusa is not coming out with a new model number every year does not mean they have not been improving their printers. SW/FW/HW are constantly being upgraded and they push those upgrades out into the existing market free of charge. At most I have had to print a few parts to do the upgrades. Don't know why you constantly been hating on Prusa. You should be happy for them because all these companies are advancing home printing. Guys at work have Enders and we are all happy with our printers.

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

Hey quick question: Whatever happened to the filament motion detection system in the I3? How come it's now just a simple filament detection switch? If Prusa is constantly upgrading why did they quietly stop selling that feature?

[@MikiCab1]

@@DesignPrototypeTest It didn't work consistently. The simple switch works much better. I had the motion sensor switch and it didn't work on certain colors of filament well. I believe black and clear filament is have a problem with. I have been an engineer for 30 years and been on dozens of new product launches and I can tell you the new wiz bang things sometimes do not work as designed and the old tried and true tech is what we fall back on. I worked with sensors in the computer chip industry and we had issues with LED and reflected and refracted sensor detection when you have to sense everything under the sun. A simple contact switch is more reliable in those cases.

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

I agree with this last comment you've made. You do sound like a knowledgeable engineer. Yet you stand behind your first comment where you defend the Prusa in a dogmatic way. It is possible for a company to "get it right" with a design and that design can stay viable for many years but Prusa does not fit that description. The reason Prusa is viable is because it has been endlessly massaged into functionality. Fundamentally there are many erroneous design decisions which JP made. He has stubbornly refused to abandon these. He wisely abandoned the filament motion sensor. Why has he not yet abandoned the direct drive mechanism when it clearly leads to the "inconsistent extrusion" problem? You see, the Mk.3 is as antiquated as an iPhone 8. You don't buy a model number you buy all of the upgrades that come along with the new model. When referring to a model you are referencing the long list of improvements that are too numerous and complicated to mention in conversation. The I3 Mk.3 is still called that because there are no such improvements. Please be an honest engineer and admit that the Prusa I3 Mk.3 is no longer viable and only continues to sell well because of the popularity contest and continued manipulation of the online environment by "the community." It is marketing and not actual substance that convinces the ignorant consumers to waste their money on a printer which they believe is superior but which is actually no better than average compared to Chinese printers which cost half the price.

[@MikiCab1]

@@DesignPrototypeTest Not a knowledgeable engineer just a knuckle dragger who carried a tool box for 20 years before I went into Tech Support and New Product Development for my last ten years and got to see how sausage was designed. Secret of sausage is when you design rats into the mix don't be surprised when you end up with rat sausage. Marketing runs most companies so engineers design stuff to be just good enough and move onto the next project. I will give the extruder could be better designed for easier access and but some people in the community have designed better extruders if I want to upgrade, and I have done some minor community upgrades, but that would be for easier access for cleaning and clearing jams. Extrusion seems consistent for me and they have done several SW/FW upgrades over the years to improve it. The Nextruder on the XL looks awesome. Everyone in the community is hoping they release it for the MK3s. Honestly Prusa has a loyal customer base because they stand behind their product. MK3s costs $799 and you can buy an ender 3 for $150 or less on sale. Out of everyone in my office they all 3 of them own enders and I own a Prusa and our company has Several commercial grade printers for prototyping. Prusa has a loyal base because they support their products. They have sent me 2 parts under warranty and have supported me for free since I bought the printer. Not many companies will do that. If I buy a second printer, no reason to buy one at this point but if I did, I would consider buying a Prusa. I gotta cut this short but I say buy what you think you can afford and what you think is best. Ender's are good printer and so are Prusa but I enjoy the Prusa community and company support.

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

You seem an honest man. I appreciate that. As you said "but I enjoy the Prusa community and company support." it's an emotional thing, and I'm not trying to make people feel bad for their purchase decisions. Please enjoy your printer. I'm trying to prevent those who don't know already from wasting money. Let's stop recommending I3 Mk.3 to anyone anymore. There are less expensive options that are just as easy to use and make the same quality of prints.

[@issaclarke3449]

The standard S1 is my first printer and it took me just over an hour set up and start first print. I was being extra careful to not mess anything up, so I see how it could be faster.

[@dbtest117]

I also think there was some research done by some bloke on youtube on cooling ducts where open cooling works better than to much restricted area with "clever" cooling ducts.

[@erkisala8436]

Its like comparing apple 8 to the latest version of 2022. But still I love the innovation and standardisation that the Prusa company does in the field of 3d printing. It was Prusas flagship years ago and it made other companies improve their products. Prusa has always had great support vs no support (unless you can talk chinese). I enjoy Prusas website, challenges etc that they host.

[@erkisala8436]

There is nothing bad in buying newest Ender or the newest Prusa. I think that both printers need maintenance in some point and tweaking to find the right print settings. And can`t deny that people like brands and enjoy them. A Scoda is not a BMW but both are cars that you can use for driving. An older BMW is still more expensive than a new Scoda. The same anology is with Lego and cheap copy bricks from china - you can make builds with both of them, but everybody likes the genuine article more and is ready to pay 4x times more over Chinese copies.

[@-Gunnarsson-]

I really like the looks of a pruisa. But I think its crappy he doesnt offer all metal parts. I would buy one if there was.

[@catalinalb1722]

Hello, what about the Bamboo X1 compared with the Voron 2.4?

[@jakeharms1386]

Looks great, but v-wheels for the y axis, and non-replaceable stepper drivers seems ridiculous for the price of the S1 Plus

[@Smedleydog1]

I'm still running my Ender 3 v2. I have mods like the Micro Swiss direct drive kit with a BL touch, although I'm still running the stock hot end and heat sink with a Slice Engineering heat break, a Red Squirrel fan shroud with a 40x40x20 cooling fan and a 5015 blower for the part cooing. 80mm fans cooling the mainboard and power supply. I put silicone springs on the bed adjusters and a heat shield on the bottom of the bed. I never have to manually level the bed. Printed a handle for the bed and extended feet to raise it up to get more air to the electronics. I extended it to 400mm on the Z with dual motors and screws. I'm running the Jyers UI firmware on the mainboard and display. The printer is almost completely silent. The print quality is just as good as a Prusa, the print area is larger and I have less than $400 invested with all the mods.

[@grampafpv8013]

well i have both printer as you do and the prusa is so much better just wait until you sprite extruder jams its a pain to fix and when you get filament sipping only to find the filament wore out the extruder gears so people if you want a new 3d printer theses are not a good choice a prusa mini is a better choice or a tronxy crux 1 or a prusa clone is better.

[@RandomProjectswithSam]

haha love the video sign-out algorithm voiceover!

[@AJayTheStageArtist]

Not Prusa Fans all along ..Prusa expensive and old fashion tech 😅

[@bernardosilva7306]

Klipper is already fully compatible with the Ender 3 stock board (for a while actually).

[@hanspolders1688]

I still have an iphone 8 and it prints just fine, don't see the need to buy an other phone if the current one is just printing fine.

[@lexzbuddy]

We just bought an Ender 3 S1 Plus, it has a faulty SD card slot. The UK vendor and Creality are dragging their heals with replacement. Absolutely terrible support. So we haven't managed to print a thing and nobody is willing to replace it or supply a new main board.

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

If it doesn't work there are avenues to getting your money back. Consumer protection laws exist. It's not that hard. Why are you here complaining on a Random KZbinr's video about a problem between you and the vendor? Are you being a Karen? Are you attempting to shill for Prusa by damaging Creality's reputation online.

[@cgwworldministries83]

Check out the sovol sv06, it is a prusa clone for $260. Please look into it!

[@MarcelRobitaille]

You've seemed pretty anti "china" in past videos. Why the change? I'm not saying it's good or bad, just asking. I don't own a prusa and I don't like prusa as a person or as a company.

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

I'm still anti-cloning-China. Also like any reasonable human being who grew up in a democracy I am anti Authoritarian Government and anti-slave/child labor. Why is it a team sport to you? I can't love two things? I can't criticize both Chinese copy-cats and Prusa?

[@MarcelRobitaille]

@@DesignPrototypeTest I was really just curious. I didn't see the nuance of it, but now I do. Thank you for explaining. That makes sense.

[@KerleyExpress]

so which one was the best i gave over 500 for my s1plus

[@snax_4820]

I will continue using my Prusa even it if would be from the fifties. Never had any serious issues: it works, works, works ....

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

Yeah. If it ain't broke don't fix it! But for God's sick don't buy another one in 2024 or tell anybody else that they should get one. There are much better options if you're buying today.

[@Jopakilo]

So glad you know the difference between HK and CHINA

[@sighyawn54]

why would the fan turn on if its not even hot, or is that the fan for the power supply

[@johnjenson670]

Great review. Thank you.

[@LisaHarsh]

With the Bambu X1C and now P1P why anyone would buy a Prusa is beyond me. I have the X1C is incredible and compared to the fully built Prusa the price is not much greater. The P1P is less than the kit and no real set up. The Sovol and Enders are getting so good as well. Meanwhile their attempt at making a tool changer keeps being pushed back.

[@Majkl9102]

it bougles my mind, how you can think this was good review with equal condition, "enders fan boy". Disclaimer first: I do NOT own any of Prusa's printer. I have experience with heavy modded Ender 3 (out of box, it was not able print anything decent). After I watched both your bad videos on MK3 printer, I will buy one. Second: If anybody want to see unbiased review, check for example this one: kzbin.info/www/bejne/oHTOeot-nsp7oqc Third: calling everybody who disagree with you as "Prusa Fan boys" is really bad argumentation foul which is mostly used by populist politicians and dictators. This is showing how you playing on feelings not on logic. Which is what you should do if you want to do proper comparison. Four: From your video, both printers fail in print that needle :D and to be honest ender needle was more uglier, because it was not only top of needle. then you give second print without showing any setting and speed on ender, but you did not print same with same setting on MK3... how you can then compare anything? and its many thing which is just showing your video is made to harm MK3 without real data, or logic, basically your are just Ender fan boy. :D your argument. But last point: most of things which you are point up on ender s1 pro (printer from fall 2022) are already on MK3s+ (printer from spring 2021), logicaly, ender is newer printer in that case it should be better, but most of upgrades/news in ender s1 pro are already default on mk3s+ for years. :D To be clear I do NOT say "MK3S+ is better", I'm saying it is sad to buy new printer for not so cheap as well and have similar quality as much older printer. And biggest joke on you, in both videos you was forced to do second print, to "proof a quality" of ender's printers :D that is saying much about MK3S+ stability

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

>first: I do NOT own any of Prusa's printer I'll just quote Shakespeare here: "The lady doth protest too much, methinks" As if some claim not to own a product is proof that you are unbiased and are not here to serve Prusa's interests. >in both videos you was forced to do second print Why sir, whatever do you mean both videos? I've made many videos. Surely someone like yourself who is unbiased and has no agenda to support Prusa would have seen all my videos that feature other printers. You wouldn't have any special interest in Prusa printers to the point where you are fixated on the two videos I made comparing the Prusa I3 Mk.3. to Chinese printers. So, which European country are you from? Czech Republic or Germany?

[@Majkl9102]

​@@DesignPrototypeTest basically you proof my point where everybody who does not agree with you is Prusa fan, without any further information or with any hint of presumption of innocence. That is why I commented your video, not to support ender or MK3, but point out your not professional behavior. Everyone is entitled to an opinion, and if you disagree with it, there should be an open discussion here. But your attitude only promotes segregation and certainly not healthy discussion. Hobby should connect but your attitude is going again. I found your videos because I want to buy a new 3D printer. And I'm not just thinking about MK3, I'm looking at everything that's currently available that's at least partially decent. And unfortunately, cheap does not mean good. I already learned that with Ender 3. And before I buy anything, I do deep research and especially look for people with a different opinion than the mainstream. And yes I found your video when I was looking how is standing MK3 in 2023, but that does not mean I came here as "white king to protect Prusa research pride". But your video has nothing to do with an objective or valuable opinion, you draw attention to some shortcomings but you are not willing to take into account a real comparison, history and other circumstances that belong to the product. Your position is purely based on hatred without supporting anything with valid arguments. But what I'm trying to do, I can say anything, but it's not up to me to prove to you that I'm something or not, it's up to you to be open to criticism and other opinions as an influencer. But no matter what I say, I will still be a secret agent of the Prussian cult for you. What a stupid approach. The world is not black and white.

[@donfykes5226]

I loved my so much I bought another one...Thank You

[@hasagreenlaser4229]

This is biased and honestly, I'm a bit dissapointed with the content given how it's suppossed to be a fair comparison.

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

You speak as if it's a forgone conclusion. You are making an accusation that I am biased. An accusation is not the same as the truth. Prusa is for losers.

[@Q3Coricoco]

I've printing with one in my farm, and I can confirm that machine is a beast. 5 months printing 24/7 no problem at all, quality like the first day. Awesome printer. For the heatbreak the one the machine have is the same the ender 3 s1 has, that heatbreak has teflon inside, they got a pro kit you can buy with a bimaterial heatbreak, that works way better.

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

I should have dug into it deeper before declaring that "all metal" The thing is for PLA PETG ABS and TPU the PTFE liner is superior. Friction free and it's not possible for molten plastic to bond to it. Even a very smooth bore all metal really needs a coating to match the non-stick performance. Most Chinese manufactured throat parts don't have all that smooth of a bore. I think CNC kitchen did a video about bore smoothness.

[@Q3Coricoco]

@@DesignPrototypeTest yes maybe is s better solution for some materials, but also needs more changes of that piece trough time. E3d V6 uses that type of heatbreak with a thin channel between both sides, and works fine with all the materials

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

E3d has very good quality control. A very smooth bore in the throat and a top secret coating. A Chinese all metal hotend is not nearly so trustworthy. A part which is so difficult too verify for the end consumer should only be purchased from a reputable brand. Slice engineering makes an amazing product in this regard. Much better than E3D.

[@Lion_McLionhead]

The sprite extruder is $90 so the lion kingdom is sticking with its obsolete $40 direct drive. Wonder what the weight difference is.

[@SteveM0732]

I use a first gen iPhone SE. Should I get the Prusa because I like Atmel and old tech or should I get the Creality because I'm cheap? If you guessed cheap then you are right. I paid $138 (shipped) to get a refurbished Ender 3 Pro. The included filament printed a great 3D benchy then then next day was crackling and popping from absorbed moisture and I had to dry the filament to get it to print well again. The 1kg spool of Creality branded PLA does not have this problem so I don't think it is from the same source as the sample, which is a good thing.

[@3dtechnologies153]

Good to see you making videos still.

[@lvguerrero01]

Thank you for the review but, I will also add the BAD quality of customer service. The printer is a little pricey for a similar in this range. Good features, even though some of then don't work "out of the gate" with this new touch screen printer. Ex: pause at height or pause to change filament in the middle of print. Then you have to use your messenger app to send a message and wait one day. Just to find out your message is not answer correctly or worse yet.... just ignored. If you are savvy, don't need customer support, and have a couple hundred dollars extra. This is the printer for you!

[@johowohoj]

I still have an iPhone 8, but I don’t have a Prusa… nor any other 3d printer actually, I’d by one now but I just recently broke the glass front and back on my iPhone 8 so I guess apple probably gonna get my money…

[@fakumadda1632]

I thought you got the Prusa from a friend. You said it was just sitting in his basement.

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

Yes. That is right. He still hasn't taken it back. He doesn't even use the one he has that he built himself. He is into table top gaming and doesn't do any FDM printing anymore. He is mostly printing miniatures for painting. He might trade me the Prusa for a large format printer so he can print cosplay helmets.

[@jamescahill2192]

It’s out of mainland China shenzen is the city

[@WarBorn313]

I’m still using my iPhone 8. And I think it’s better then all the ones after it.

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

That's actually pretty cool. If he bought a Prusa 5 years ago and it's working for you, you should continue to use that one as well. The quality of Prince you will get out of all of the better machines is a barely noticeable difference. But I'm sure you're not telling anyone to buy an iPhone 8 in the year 2023. Especially if the iPhone 8 cost more than the current version. Neither should you tell them to buy a Prusa which costs more than the new printers that do a better job.

[@workingTchr]

I messed up and got the Ender 3 Max (not the S1 Plus) and added on the Creality hotend and auto level sensor. I never could get it to work (as a set) and had to return it. The good news was that right after that the Bambu came out. Had I got this one, I'd probably be using Ender instead of Bambu today.

[@jeraldstraub3194]

Prusa wins in multicolor printing. If creality would release multicolor support it would be viable.

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

No. Bambu lab wins in multi-color printing.

[@jeraldstraub3194]

@@DesignPrototypeTest For a price twice that of a prusa or creality. It should.

[@ianmcleod8898]

Apples and apples are not compared here. 8 years difference in age? Of coarse there will be upgrades on a newer printer. My Prusa is a work horse and yes it needs repair some times, so does anything that is your go to printer.

[@MrMoxyspirit]

Great review......so good I bought the s1+ today. I found it for $399 @ Microcenter in Columbus, Ohio

[@gigifrana940]

Than why I still use the prusa?🤔

[@AdrianoCasemiro]

The non pro moniker of this one has a ptffd tube in the hotend and I don't like it. Switching to an all metal hotend would allow me to print up to 300C safely?

[@dmcarpman]

Prusa it may well have it's backing but as far as i am concerned it is well over priced. i now have 2 printers a Tronxy x5sa Pro and a Voxelab x2 out of the box the X2 was spot on and great prints from it every time. the Tronxy X5sa Pro well it has it's problems i got this at half price even at a full price i still got 2 for less than a Prusa. over the past week i have the X5sa now sorted with updates from Tronxy and it now works great prints every time it was a fault with software that is now sorted. would i go and put klipper etc on these no as i do not see the point.

[@yeroca]

I'm pretty sure Creality is based in Shenzhen China, which is quite close to Hong Kong geographically, but isn't in that special economic zone.

[@OmerMeshy]

I print with my prusa over 2 years and no fixes where needed! Prusa is steel better than creality 🤷🏻

[@FilesCohnRacers]

Any way you could make a video upgrading it to Klipper! we all own the Creality S1 Plus. not a big fan of the Prusa, specially knowing it comes from mr Prusa. thanks for the great videos

[@Fejszi]

While I will probably be classed as a Prusa fanboy, its kinda far from the truth, I don't agree with the pushing of "made by Josef" on everything, I don't agree with their descision of not making a 12 volt version of the einsy to support the MK2 with the reason: TMC2130s aren't stable on 12 volts. But there are a few problems with the "issues" you keep coming up with: PETG suffers from heat deformation: yes after around 80 degrees it can deform but its unlikely (its also far away from the bed to not be a problem). 8-bit MCUs and the screen, I have to agree with Thomas Sanladerer on this: I don't interact with the printer to need anything more advanced that we have. I start a print, load and unload filament, I don't need a fancy touch screen to do these basic things. (also setting Z height or steps/mm is hell on touchscreens) 32 bit mainboards are just for cost saving, what can the ender do that the Prusa can't with that 32bit chip? Nothing. While speeds could be quicker I don't think the average user needs 500mm+ speeds, if you need that build a Voron. I value upgradeability far more than something being great out of the box but the manufacturer just leaves it to rot after they release a new version... I also can't stand your hatred towards the spirit of RepRap... I don't get why its so great to have sheet metal everywhere.... I simply don't. Sure make a stiff frame but I don't get the whole "Ew it has 3D printed parts" argument... - a former ender owner

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

3D printed parts are inferior. They are not isotropic in strength characteristics and they are made out of plastic. They get the job done. But the whole appeal of Prusa is that it is the best printer. Not the "gets the job done" printer. People have a visceral emotional feeling for their Prusa because they feel like they own a winning piece of excellence with the I3 Mk.3. This emotion is misplaced because clearly it is not the winning printer. It is the "gets the job done" printer. I've never denied the advantages of the Prusa. It is a very well polished turd. But fundamentally it is made of excrement. At least they got rid of the zip ties but before they did that there were SO MANY guys here on my channel attacking me just like you are saying "So what. Zip ties are fine." Next they will get rid of structural 3D printed components and you won't be here apologizing to me for sending me so much hate. For downvoting my videos even though I'm right. Go watch the PrusaXL video and you will see no 3D printed structural components. I'm already right, but again you won't apologize for the damage you do to me. You *feel* right because there are a lot of Prusa fanboys who have got your back, but just because there is a mob doesn't mean you have truth and justice on your side. RE: 8 Bit electronics Did you know that the antiquated 8-bit tech is actually more expensive and harder to source. This is why the base model Ender 3 now comes with 32 Bit electronics. Creality is actually saving money upgrading from the old 2560 8-bit chips. You say you don't mind the old tech because you don't need anything more advanced. Back in the 1940s, the first computers were physical mechanical machines. No electronics. There is a calculator the size of a room in a museum somewhere. Why don't you get one of those and throw away your cell-phone with the calculator. It would be the same arguement you and Tom are making. It get's the job done crunching numbers. You don't need the new tech. You went on to justify that the i3 Mk.3 "gets the job done" in other ways as well which is fine EXCEPT that the Prusa costs at least twice as much as a printer from China that similarly "get the job done." Why pay more money for antiquated tech when the new tech is more user friendly and costs less? If you own a Prusa keep using it. I'm not trying to make people feel bad for their purchase decisions. Please enjoy your printer. I'm trying to prevent those who don't know already from wasting money. Let's stop recommending I3 Mk.3 to anyone anymore. There are less expensive options that are just as easy to use and make the same quality of prints. Can I ask you a favor. Will you please stop making me the bad guy? I'm not. I'm just making honest criticisms. I do have a negative mindset regarding JP and by extension his company. He/it is advantaged by nefarious behavior. I am justified in my judgement. It's possible to think badly of something and be right. Not biased. You don't seem to care about Prusa, and yet you still desperately want me to be your enemy. WHY? You say "I also can't stand your hatred towards the spirit of RepRap" This is an ABSOLUTE fabrication and if you watch my videos it is demonstrably false. Everything else you have said is reasonably fair in the context of a debate. This strongly worded sentence is your trespass. This propaganda is your cheating manipulative motivation revealed. I insist that you justify this claim or apologize for the offense. Define the spirit of RepRap and then find examples of me violating that spirit with "hatred" or issue an apology. You won't do it. Your ilk of trolls/fanboys/bots/sockpuppets/whatever-you-are never apologizes. You go on being wrong and making the world a worse place confidently because you are supported by a groupthink mob of the similarly wrongheaded. Shame on you.

[@Fejszi]

@@DesignPrototypeTest first of all, the fact that I said 32 bit boards are just for cost saving just went around your head… second, in my opinion the spirit of Reprap is that you have a machine that can make most of its parts for itself, and can create useful things for its owner. Your argument of: we NEED sheet metal and injection molded parts everywhere is against that idea IMO… Your argument that of: you should get rid of your phone and use a calculator is: this argument went around your head also. I’ve said that not everything needs a touchscreen and 32bit, sure ditch the 8 bit platform, but I don’t think everything needs to be Touchscreens, I the LCD of the mini would be a nice replacement, but still, the end of it all. I don’t need a touchscreen in my dishwasher, because I use it like my printer: I don’t sit next to it or watch Netflix on it, I just use it for 2-3 minutes then forget about it… (I also think that most printers should be like this)

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

I don't see a justification or an apology for your statement that I hate the spirit of reprap. I'll give you one more chance before I ban your avatar.

[@Fejszi]

@@DesignPrototypeTest i justified your hatred towards the spirit or RepRap: a RepRap is a machine that can make most of its own parts and can make useful things for its owner. You continusly attacking 3D printed parts and encouraging designs that aren’t self replicating in any way is IMO a hatred towards the core spirit of the movement. Also, I just want to remind you that in a previous video you dissed the MK3 for having 3D printed parts, while also promoting Voron…

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

I wouldn't say that I have hatred (nothing so extreme) but as I said, 3D printed structural parts are undeniably suboptimal. I don't think you understand what "the spirit" of a thing means. It is the underlying philosophy or moral motivation that begets the thing. The spirit of reprap is akin to that of open source or right-to-repair. It's about democratizing access to the technology so that it does not get monopolistically controlled enriching a single company while the rest of us languish without the ability to 3D print. The mechanical implementation of reprap (as defined by a single man named Adrian Boyer) involves self-replicating printers using 3D printed structural parts. This was conceived at a time, years ago, when recursion was a popular fad among academics and programmers. There is no deep meaning or ideology to recursion. It's popular like a joke or a curiosity. Recursion is NOT the spirit of reprap. Unless Adrian Bowyer he wants to chime in and tell me I'm wrong.

[@tybca_04_alexjohnson28]

could u review a printer named pixel 3d s1 i intent to buy it but there is no review or anything regarding this printer

[@MisterkeTube]

Ok, who are you and what did you do to the actual DPT guy? Being positive about Chinese Creality? Ok, the Prusa complaints are still there (but actually tuned down to actually acceptable complaints and comparisons). So, I'll drop my semi-sarcasm now and congratulate you for jumping over your own shadow and creating content again instead of plain nagging. Personally I'm not sold to the S1, but mostly because I disagree with it getting the Ender name, which I would have reserved for the ultimate cost-optimization while retaining functionality, not something with bling like extrusion that are flat on one side and hence missing the v-grooves I want to attach stuff to. And that Creality still finds it acceptable to have PTFE upto the nozzle is a big no-no to me. Then again, I'm no fan of Prusa either (but won't tell others not to be).

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

You lampoon me without any self awareness. It doesn't occur to you that perhaps I behave the way that I do in reaction the mob that I face. Perhaps it is not a reflection on me or my character but on the insanity of my opponents.

[@MisterkeTube]

@@DesignPrototypeTest I won't give up hope... Irrespective of the reasons, I hope also future videos will be content again rather than just mindless bashing. I think many agree that a Prusa is outdated by now, but unlike Apple with the iPhones, Prusa has not crippled this old hardware with new software forced on you and hence it's still as good as it was years ago. Is that good enough? I agree that it is not, but that everyone needs to decide for himself. And for many Chinese products your remarks on just being clones or not innovating do hold, but I feel being able to cut costs while keeping acceptable quality also is a form of innovation and companies like Bambu Labs show that not every Chinese company is a clone-factory. So, I'll just reiterate my congratulations for again producing some technical analysis rather than senseless rants - regardless of the reasons behind it.

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

You don't sound like my enemies. But it sounds like you don't believe they exist either. I think you have a mind of your own. I like that.

[@MisterkeTube]

@@DesignPrototypeTest I do think you are slightly paranoia and that your way to express your opinion about some topics might be counterproductive in hitting some fanboys' cords causing them to resonate. Well, counterproductive might not be the right word. The resulting flamewars will likely attract KZbin viewers to the videos like moths, but I personally get annoyed by them and would prefer seeing again more on ex. creating the ideal high-temp printer. Having your critical but factual look on ex. the upcoming HevOrt extruder (sorry for not knowing the name by heart, I think it's ExtrudOrt or something) and VzBot Goliath hotend would make me so much more happy than another Prusa-bash. That was the type of content I landed on your channel for, but this has been replaced too much by criticism on printers that are anyway outdated. Sure, that might get more views, but I doubt that will last in the long run.

[@TheOfficialDarkICE]

@@MisterkeTube He's a simp for ccp companies everytime he gets something for free. He didn't got that from prusa so now he's mad :(

[@ZURAD]

I'm always in favor of using POM over metal when you can. For 3D printers the loads are so low that I would often prefer polymer for motion components given their cost/lifetime.

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

Exactly! That analogy I came up with in the video of the wheel being like a tire is very apt. You don't see cars driving around on metal wheels without tires. Like you said because there are no loads why not reap the benefits of having a tire?

[@ZURAD]

​@@DesignPrototypeTest One thing I would like to see more of is the investigation of polymer as a motion component. I believe the Bambu uses polymer on their CF rods. Have wanted for a while to run Igus polymer on a 3D printer. The lifecycle and loads claimed are out of this world. Potentially you could ditch the wheels entirely and run directly on the 2020 extrusions.

[@AccessAccess]

A actually hate that damn knob. Sometimes pressing the knob also changes the selection. I have one of the original CR-10 (not even a CR-10S) from back in the days and had nothing but problems with it -- some of which are difficult to impossible to fix. Though I am glad to see other companies getting it right because with more competition we get more choices and better machines in the end.

[@technodruid]

... does your electricity come from gasoline?

[@DesignPrototypeTest]

A significant portion of electricity generated around the world is done by burning natural gas.

[@jstro-hobbytech]

Creality are a no questions asked with sending parts if you show them a pic. Nathanbuildsrobots does his own custom adapter boards Matt. He's a young mechanical engineer but he's learning quick. Great humor like you as well. He also has a few different versions of part cooling that keeps evolving. I know him and he's like minded.

[@vactirio]

Is the Ender 3 S1 Plus compatible with the "Creality3D Sprite Extruder Pro Kit"????

[@TonyStark-ik9em]

Nice that you touched a "holy cow", please do the same for Vorons to see how they are holding up.

[@sighyawn54]

i wish the CR10s had a chassy like the ender 3 s1 because it actually has extra space for a mosfet or anything else

[@timhoover1416]

Thanks for the good comparison review. Any chance you can get your hands on the Flying Bear Reborn 2? That is a very compelling printer for the money. Only thing it would be nice to have is an upgraded control board to run Klipper.