Critique of Modi - Professor Vaidyanathan (Part 6 of 6)

[@s.sarkar83]

True observations by Prof Vaidyanathan. Totally agree with him. The Hindu Charter Bill must be passed by Govt in the 2nd term

[@favouriteworld3702]

@H P ha ha ha lul gandu liberals Wht happen gand phat gayi aab

[@favouriteworld3702]

@H P everything done wht bjp promise

[@ajitbantia]

I love watching Prof Vaidyanathan's talks, they are as informative as humorous....

[@MrSirAussie]

Fair and impartial verdict!....however, always there is room for improvement, resetting and re-engineer the fiscal, economic and social issues...let's pray 'Phir Ek Baar Modi Sarkar' will reduce the gap of the reality and the expectations ..thank you. ALL WE WANT IS A SAFE, SECURE, PEACEFUL, PROGRESSIVE & VIBRANT NEW INDIA. JAI HIND

[@mmmittal]

Agree with overall assessment of Prof. One important aspect missed is the huge improvement in internal security situation and tit-for-tat response to Pakistan.

[@coolFeb1984]

Yogi Adityanath should become HRD minister. Scrap everything and build from scratch.

[@adarshlal93]

Absolutely BRILLIANT

[@thestriker269]

Ram lala hum ayenge...Mandir whi baneyenge...Jai Shree ram

[@kamla9683]

Agree with you.

[@kamla9683]

@@thestriker269 😁😁😁

[@ankitgupta136]

@@adarshlal93 he indicted that i guess. He said today they might change their cabinet after elections.

[@josnau9790]

Sir is actually band on point. I hope Modiji do take a look into this matter in his 2019 term.

[@manasbora3495]

I wish Modi watches this talk,..

[@MithunSharma-ym7em]

He is a brain trust of Modi along with Gurumurthy

[@varga64]

Rajiv is NITI Ayog Chairman. So the feedback does go into ears of Modi

[@Tpb247]

@@phk999 PM Modi understands English. FYI

[@yogeshashwini]

@@varga64 Niti aayog Vice Chairman is Rajiv Kumar

[@nikhilsahay2]

First vote to modi

[@rajashrimurthy]

Deep and profound insights! Professor must be the advisor to the govt!

[@Satyam0701]

Huuuuuge intellect..... First time listening to this great person.... Hats off sir

[@dirgatimsina7103]

Really great conversation. Loved it

[@AronAroniteOnlineTV]

One of the best Interviews I has seen in recent times. Vaidyanathan is a treat to listen to.His candid presentation of facts at finger tips, his disarming sense of humor and very bold non-partisan critique of things Modi could have and should have got done are simply great. Modi must listen to such advisers.May Lor5d Shiva bestow a long life to both Vaidyanathan and Rajiv Malhotra.

[@binasharma332]

Education and judicial system ka bhartiyakaran hona jaruri h...

[@krishnanshgaur9322]

True

[@IndianTreasuryofWisdom]

Yes it is what the Nation needs, problem is that the Leftist organisations in our country

[@prasannar8958]

Yes

[@ravidhyani3074]

Absolutely correct

[@chandrandec31]

Yes, definitely it should be Indianized.

[@isan26]

VaidyanathanJi is very foreseeing guy. 1:55 how correctly he predicted trumps actions. Come out of WHO, non interest in G7,G8 other groups, inviting India to those groups etc.. Great. Namaste to both of you.

[@kishanmishra3245]

Modi (man of developing India ) is great.

[@spotzero_tv]

i am a follower of you since 3 years u have motivated me a lot Sir if anything i can do please order me

[@gopz4218]

Enlighten our youths about the breaking forces. That's what he would want you to do.

[@KGK1938]

deepak naik and y

[@kanu6637]

I'll pay tax if it's for development of India. Not for making Mrs Gandhi a Billionaire which I already did🤬. And his Son a PM

[@varkap7]

Modi for in full moajority for 20 years simple answer and Modi has to attempt it

[@bhanuganesh7457]

Good discussion- thank you. Why not set up Institutes studying Hindusium like Nalanda ? Is Swadishi Indology a formal course?

[@IndianTreasuryofWisdom]

It is definitely a Necessity today, glad people like you are there who think it is required for our generation

[@nikhilsahay2]

@@IndianTreasuryofWisdom we need it but we hv2 first fight against leftist n lobby of Congress

[@Curious0511]

Agreed.. But these left librandus will cry... Modi also has not shown any intention to change education system.. I hope he looks into this in the second term.

[@ssrivastava4]

Article 30A doesn't allow. Start raising your voice

[@liliesandtulips2000]

@@ssrivastava4 absolutely! Bloody anti hindu constitution

[@dilipshimpi6799]

Professor has commented about " not initiated any action " about a number of things. But government should not try to do too many things at one go. We are willing to wait & contribute for better times.

[@kamalkavyaras8270]

Hard question and honest opinion ...Solute to Professor and Rajiv Ji

[@ashwanidixit4327]

BJP is only available option India.

[@aswinsuresh1435]

Mark the Importance of churches-They are going to convert Punjab

[@misterlova5260]

Stop all evil belief. All foreign belief .

[@AksGun]

@john doe It doesn't matter whether 3000 or 5000, the point is Indian civilisation is losing, no matter how slowly.

[@ajayrajreddy2397]

Aswin suresh PUNJAB IS BEEN RULED BY KHANGRESS HENCE YOU CAN EXPECT THESE KIND IF THINGS FROM THERE

[@DKSinha-gd1kp]

We need a strict Anti conversion bill with anti conversion force with hindu majority....

[@bmwman5]

Dharmendra Sinha What are you afraid of? Let the people choose whatever religion they wish to profess.

[@misterlova5260]

Professor Right on government should protect not running Temple.

[@thearyaflix8700]

I love the nature of this professor. The language, the way he expresses himself. It's so lovely to watch him

[@vikramrazdan5680]

Superb acronym WAR (Wisdom After Retirement) veterans, who are ex-Civil Service officers writing editorials and making expert comments on India's policies

[@sumedhamconsultancy3752]

All impractical

[@ravindrababu7231]

Senior citizens (WAR veterans )writing editorials and simply criticising govt policies should do more concrete job of guiding the country.

[@bhaskarsharma9130]

Excellent feedback and very good suggestions from Mr.Vaidyanathan .Rajivji pl continue to have more interviews with Professor.Thanks for the video.

[@mayarudra6410]

I would like just make a point. When GST was implemented, if we had waited to see everything was correct, we would have never been able to do it. I think PM took the risk to implement it first and making the corrections going along.which the previous Govt' did not have the courage to do. This in itself is a great achievement. Yes we had teething problems, slowly it's being solved. We cannot satisfy everybody and Modi cannot do it alone. Let's all participate in making this country great. I am sick of every body criticizing everything. Jai Bharat.

[@mayankgupta7172]

Excellent. Great Work!

[@ramaloke8377]

Vanakkam to sri.rajiv ji and prof vaithiyanathan ji, 1).lots fun in this videos 2).i think some of the areas u discussed was fits and correct. eg:religious conversations,education &research inst with breaking india forces, 3).i don't think pm modi and central govt having n controlling any temples or religious places, 4).pm modi is the one who has the experiences of a cm of a state for more12yrs, so he knew better to run the govt and politics, 5).hope its bit difficult to have the political party, competent in election n come to power n run the govt with "sapka sath sapka vikaas" than sitting and discussing how to run the govt, 6)he came from rss,hope he knew that for everything its need of a ground work before expecting to try new things and results, 7) a country of 125 crore ppl with different states, languages, religion, cultures and customers ,is that simple to run this country without any major issues even after demonetization, with peaceful, development track, hopes and trusts,without corruptions, 8).he too a human being not the god ram himself to make all the changes within a day or two, 9).whether the ministers will do something to their states or not, if the state doesn't get atleast a minister, no party will get the mp from any states then how to get full majority govt,?who will get 272 seats? So closing ministries may leads to local parties there won be a national parties, and support from other parties if needed in case because anyway they won't get ministers, 10)its looks something like a layman's critics of modi govt, so better u may deserve to get pappu's govt. And when he said/promised to give 15lks???do u have any evidence? ?? So like u too be fan of and believed pappu's lies of hit and run.

[@Icoconutz3]

True intellectuals - the conversation is so free flowing and thought provoking. This is how we should criticize the government..

[@vanhannu]

Naman to both the gems, Very very truely stated all the factors of the good governance. In one of the talk show Shri Vaidyanathan ji very well explains that how JATI and VARNA are in fact, needed for any society in this world to progress peacefully. We are not religious but a Dharmic people...every one on this land are born DHARMIC, irrespective of their faith or no faith at all. Totally agree that government should be kshatriya and not vaishaya in nature. Also, every community who is taking advantage from foreign land must immideatly quit. Its good for futhure of all of us . Urbal naxalism and missionaries and islaami activities governed by outside Bharat desh must be banned.

[@srinivaskini4704]

All expectations to be met in the first 5 years ? In a country with a population of 1.30 billion people? After the humongous decadence in the moral fibre of the country and the people over millennia? And with just one man expected to do all this? Phew?

[@justrandomperson6221]

He did say if the governmenr works ethically, it will be here to stay for the next 15-20years.

[@rajaramam]

it is not one man. There are ministries to do the job. When they or their bureaucracy aren't chosen wisely then expectations wont be met.

[@maninblack0258]

all true words ........ excellent conversation.

[@ScNathankk]

Very good discussions. Thanks. Deep and profound insights! Professor must be the advisor to the govt .

[@rakhihaldar154]

मोदी in his second term must include these honest wise people in his ministries for a better India. Love watching all your videos.

[@RAMAKRISHNACPNilAPRAMEYA]

I WAS NOT KNOWING Mr. VAIDYANATHAN STAYING IN MY AREA. YESTERDAY I SAW WITH HIS PET @ PANDURANGA NAGAR BANGALORE SOUTH. GREAT PERSONALITY. knowledge bank.

[@MeetYourArchitect]

But considering the half empty glass of water as half full... we must be thankful to god for giving the command of this country to Modi and also bringing people like you to the masses. The revolution has started, the gentle giant, the great white elephant of the Indus, the Hindu, has woken up.

[@proudindian5117]

*_Ms sir.... What a wonderful man love ❤️_*

[@nandu9773]

Good Job

[@venkatraman7396]

Expectations of the people from this government have increased because they know that Modi is the one who can fulfill their wishes. They just want to make hay while the sun shines. Also, they are in a hurry - as we don't know if we'd ever get such non-corrupt government whose heart beats for the nation. They did not have high expectations before because those governments were busy with scams and people had reconciled to their condition. Have great respect for Prof Vaidyanathan's views.

[@meditationmusicfree9313]

Eye opening insightment..superb sir ..I really salute ur deep understanding of our countries multiple aspects ....🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@vishwas5554]

VERY CORRECT!!!

[@powerlinkers]

thank you.

[@paramasivamnatarajan1345]

In second term Modi will fulfill many aspirations. First 5 years for consolidating his position by concentrating in Development and helping poor.

[@kulbhushanphaudhary]

Professor Vaidyanathan has very well rightly analysed and elaborated the malady in Indian system prevalent, helping break India forces.I understand the BJP Govt think tanks are listening these discourses.The Strong BJP Modi 2019 with absolute majority needs to be reelected again, and do all the corrected measures in next term.

[@rajaramam]

This is a great interview. Hope the likes of Piyush Goyal and Narendra modi watches this so that they can rectify this next time. Saw your earlier deleted interview with Piyush Goyal and the views he had about temple control were really disappointing. Hope the next Nanrendra modi ministry takes each of these points and builds on it.

[@deepikakumaravel]

He’s right. We need freedom from govt for our temples

[@ven657]

Why not have a presidential form of government ? Only 2 party system. The peesisldent appoints his team from a pool.of Industey experts.

[@msms9146]

Great analysis

[@samyakjain584]

26.7 parties are real curse for this nation.

[@kasinathan9489]

🙏all lectures are telling the problems of mother country central government take it very seriously and solve it🙏

[@RajivMalhotraOfficial]

This is part 6 of a 6-part series. Be sure to watch the previous episodes here: bit.ly/ProfessorVaidyanathan Part 5 - Breaking India - bit.ly/BreakingIndia To donate to Infinity Foundation’s projects including the continuation of such episodes and the research we do: infinityfoundation.com/donate-2/

[@arimardansingh1185]

Nice sir

[@saratsaratchandran3085]

Giving recognition to deserving people in the country and celebrating them is definitely one of the functions of the Government. The prof is an economist and his vision of a country may not have any value of arts and culture. But civilization needs arts and culture.

[@shwetasawant6782]

Sir but a lot of foreign money is curbed right?? that is only reason these #urbannaxals are so rattled these day

[@shwetasawant6782]

Sir why don't you work with PM or Dr. Swami who are in position to do these tasks to dismantle these institutions🙏

[@somapaul2663]

Wonderful Sir

[@vasuk5291]

Rajiv ji thanks a lot for well research & with lot of enlightenment...prof 's war acronym was awesome

[@sukeshchandersharma2832]

I am sure if some of the points as suggested by Sh Vaidyanathan as soon as possible we will achieve most goals soon.

[@antaresbnv3350]

Good conversation, Raajeev sir moodhi is a gods gift to this country.

[@RajRaj-hv4yh]

Good topic. However, Modi has set the Mindset and means to collect revenue, which is required to do grand schemes. Hope his next term can give the means to do the expectations(maybe they are doing it under the ground for last 4 yrs because of sensitive issues involving religion and foreign governments.)

[@SandhyaRani-wm4yv]

Very good show

[@rakeshkharta21]

Brilliant discussion

[@Hallo-c1s]

Great

[@sciencesquare1561]

I'm totally agree with you sir

[@MrHinglish]

Yes true about so many ministries .. planning commission should abolish

[@mmmittal]

Planning Commission has been abolished ... but replaced by Niti Ayog.

[@vishwanath861]

Why they cannot declare money thrashed abroad as national wealth.

[@maarirs12894]

Fantastic sir.

[@jaiprem7413]

Let's hope that changes will come in the second term of PM Modi , OTHERWISE INDIA WOULD NEED A STRONG BENEVOLENT HINDU DICTATOR TO TAKE THE ARMY AND SEIZED THE COUNTRY IN ORDER TO FIX ALL THESE PROBLEMS AND GALVANIZED INDIA INTO A HINDU RASHTRA !!!

[@sudhachinni]

So well explained.... Our think tanks r destroyed by British.

[@sudhachinni]

Our whole history textbooks need to be changed from primary classess

[@somabhattacharjee3613]

Sir keep on giving these advices time will take care of

[@mukundshamlalshamlal5959]

Respects to the economist and Dr Rajiv ji. would like to work with you. for the proper teaching of India wisdom to our new home USA. we must make a proper and effective solution to the people of USA. this is our home. we should help USA. SECURITY in the world. its good for the country and the world

[@thedroidbha]

Expectations?? No one in this world can fulfill everyone's expectations... Modi works what's good for the country as a whole.

[@vijayghunowa6160]

They must become think tank of BJP ASAP जय हिंद भारत माता की जय वंदे मातरम आनंद काल तक l प्रणाम

[@125bbna8]

Pls dubb professor vaidyanathan vid in hindi so that u can connect with masses. He is a great scolar

[@niraj2020]

Need to call each cabinet minister and dept. to get their feedback as well as give your valuable input and peoples perception through well researched ideas and shortcomings. This will improve overall action and governance in favour of majority

[@vilasmarathe4470]

Very true sir!!! Unless these things are chabged, Hinduism will not flourish.

[@vikramrazdan5680]

The federal structure of India's internal economy needs to be changed by formation of Trade blocks (a group of states which complement each other in a geography). This will ensure better oversight, more synergies and reduce Govt. expenditure.

[@mylaramravindernath5711]

Are you listening HRD babus and Ministers and PM.

[@jagdishchandrapant1605]

This video should appropriately be called “Critique of Modi government” rather than as “Critique of Modi”. My take on “ Prof Vaidyanathan explains that there has been hardly any corruption at the top levels and the economic growth rate has been excellent. “ is that perhaps, it is not realized that Modi has had to exercise a vigil 24 hours a day to ensure that his flock adheres to the dictum of “zero tolerance to corruption” and sustaining this vigil for the last five years of his current tenure, in a system of governance steeped in corruption for the past 70 odd years, is nothing short of a miracle, which in my view is only possible due to divine blessings and Modi’s personal commitment. His government has been blessed with perhaps, only about half a dozen competent ministers, the rest being average time servers, who have been more or less compelled to function only under the broad guidelines of the policies laid down by his cabinet and a near slave-driven supportive top bureaucratic system. His next major challenge is to reform the BJP, which is a heterogeneous mixture of all kinds of people. His singular other personal achievements amongst others have been, the International Yoga Day, the Swachch Bharat Abhiyan, and making India surplus in power, so essential for economic growth, which has also enabled electrification of all villages and households in the country, not forgetting opening of bank accounts of over 30 crore people who had no bank accounts so far. As far as what more should have been achieved is concerned, there is always scope for improvement, also keeping in mind a highly critical main stream media which is constantly trying to divert government's and peoples' attention, not to forget the need to try hard enough to get another term of governance. The kind of issues for which his government is being chiefly faulted in this video can only be addressed by a committed bureaucracy whose minds are appropriately decolonized, which appears to be a far cry as of now.

[@sgtalageri]

"There has hardly been any corruption at the top levels". Really? can anyone name a more corrupt act in the whole history of independent India than the issuing of electoral bonds, and allowing foreign multinationals to donate funds to Indian political parties and keeping these contributions secret and even beyond the scrutiny of the judiciary?

[@venuopaliyer4024]

HRD ministry should watch this and act and show some courage to reform.

[@chandrandec31]

By wisdom of hindsight, we can now say in the last 5 and half years the govt has covered a lot of ground. One most important is getting all institutions under purview of RTE or remove the restrictions on majority institutions.

[@iq_6-4.39]

So correct vaidyanathan sir

[@narsingha2024]

The Professor has good points but seems ignorant on the importance of preserving the sacred of Indian classical music.

[@AksGun]

No I think his point was to create institutions in music which can flourish, instead of just giving people awards.

[@biswadyutiroy8146]

Regulator comment is tremendously appreciated

[@timestuber]

Development and Sanathan Dharm....both brought PM Modi to power. To achieve development in all areas for a nation like India is solid, focused hard-work and then patience. PM Modi is doing ALL of the above. However, PM Modi could have done a lot more to Santhan Dharm by taking care of a few policies and providing good politics to bolster that. Not much hard work is needed to rejuvenate Sanathan Dharma. It is surprising that PM Modi did not chose a much easier path that would have cemented him and his party at the center for the next decade and beyond. This time the Sanathan Dharm will allow him to continue....but for 5 years later....it will be difficult. AGRICULTURE is one area......where development model has not been applied. Agriculture in India makes HUGE BUSINESS sense if it is handled in terms of the development model.

[@ansar9374]

Hindu wakf board like system...and digital membership required..help each other..integrate and think like ummah for Hinduism is necessary sir....

[@straightforward8219]

You great people's I'm afraid of yours intelligence as I witnessed same in India against corruption movement

[@SurashKan]

How about a cap on the personal wealth? what will happen if we have a cap on the personal wealth? The cap can always be revised depending on the time and may be revisited every year if that necessitates...(the wealth from the business entities are not counted as personal wealth). I see this very important step, as a starting point, towards better co-existence, inclusiveness of the deprived, dignified living to the maximum people possible, and of course our very Dharma - As human existence depends on the whole nation and the people cannot exist and live as individuals without the support of others.. for example, one cannot produce his own food by doing agriculture, build his own house (and enterprises) and stitch his own clothes etc etc (END TO END) ...... and second.. how about having a higher tax rates for the higher income slabs, raising the rates for them up to 50%.. just some thoughts... but for me, these are very fundamental in a the context of social Dharma and a truly civilized nation...who cares for and knows the inter-dependency of men and societies at large... that will have an major cascading effect and the refinements in the proportion of access to fundamental needs of food, clothing, shelter to the maximum people in a dignified way...

[@binasharma332]

Modiji is our great p.m.... Jai maa bharti...

[@GaneshKumar-my4md]

Though the presenters speak of so many things that the Government should have done, it is important to know whether the Government has been able to do the most needed things during the last 4 years - a country like India, which has been under foreign rule, which has changed the mentality & attitude of our people for centuries - would it be possible to have a magic wand and change the people. I remember my grand mother saying in the 50s that they were better under British rule than in Independent India. People resist any change, even if it is for the good - as it is the law of nature. We, Indians, need a couple of decades for the good to percolate to the lowest level, as we would like to do it in our democratic way, unlike some other countries with force, which have seen remarkable progress in a very short period. It is imperative that with our vote we should give absolute mandate to Modi at least for 2 more terms..

[@abhishekgiri2723]

We need many more people like Rajiv Malhotra

[@just4humanity]

He is a brilliant man.

[@gopalagrawal3038]

Prof. Vidyanathan forgot to speak about Smart Cities, 15 lacs, 2 Cr Jobs, Article 370, Kohinoor, 1 minute loan, Startup India, Make In India, etc. One more thing Government is doing Vaishya Job and Public is doing Shudra Jobs. We should have 100% Indian system, public should be staunch Hindu. But why these super intellectual juggernauts are speaking in English....they should converse in Sanskrit. Namaskaram 🙏

[@gopalagrawal3038]

@Yogarishi Srīnivās You are true follower of these juggernauts. 😂😂🤣🤣

[@SaketM9]

Prof RV the usual rockstar

[@rex007king]

I want to raise one point here, Can "not doing corruption" be a yardstick to measure success of Governments or any Organisation ? That's the minimum standard expected from any of them. That's the norm, isn't it ?

[@mmmittal]

Valid point -- but when corruption is in the veins of majority of my countrymen, and when for 10 years of UPA we heard of humongous scams involving lakhs of crores of rupees, a non-corrupt Government is a whiff of fresh air and needs to be appreciated.

[@ankushs6448]

Prof- 'i call them WAR veterans' Malhotra- 'yeah' Prof- 'that is, Wisdom After Retirement' hahhhahahhahaa i'm friggin dying!! omg!

[@ramaloke8377]

When pm modi said to give 15lk prof vaithiyanathan has to see pm modi video (that particular video reg) again,and correct himself,

[@msms9146]

What a great person with a great knowledge... Most of the ministries can be scrapped...to get good revenue...

[@ananthsethuraman8921]

At t = 11:00, Rajiv mentions that foreign countries are attempting to influence India a generation from now by means of think tanks. The employees of the think tanks are sons and daughters of important government officers.

[@dhanrajmohan701]

Public comments .your body is a unique form of life . the power of control the mind depend on balance force of controlling the mind .man have to realize life is the highest form of nature and self realisation is the key to sustain a happy life while you enjoy nature and existence on earth care for it .you depends on everything that evolve around you . pure water air sun fire eath all these things are very vital for your survival .your health is your wealth and joy in life .