China & India /Lively Debate - Professor Vaidyanathan (Part 4 of 6)

[@MrHinglish]

Congress has always screwed the basic fabric of India ...... So no more congress

[@MMaheshThakur]

Manish Khc congress is full with idiots and will be becoz of nepotism

[@venugopalbk4144]

True , Nehru is the architect of destroying Indian social fabric

[@coolFeb1984]

Watch The Tashkent Files movie. It happened systematically after Lal Bahadur Shastri's assasination. It happened in Indira's regime when communist taken over key institutions. India was on sell that time and KGB was running the country.

[@curiousguy3053]

But even without congress we have many hurdles like the judiciary collegium, parliamentary system , media & academic monopoly against negligible investment in own country's culture

[@ssrivastava4]

@Sandy Sandy If there is provision in constitution of India to file case against dead person it should be done for Nehru for his Anti India activities

[@suraj-op2bx]

India must also act in national interest Sir u said right but in India .if u r nationalist than u r called as MODI BHAKT It is the reason Modi will remain in power ..

[@mayankwagh6934]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/rJ25e3aYecebn9U Plzz watch and support this video

[@alpeshmittal3779]

You should not be right wing or left wing..just desh bhakt..no body else bhakt...who ever you elected is there to serve nation per requirement not your king. If your thought process is like this then you are alright. If you think you have elected a savior who was born to lead this nation and will do every thing right then you are BHAKT

[@priyanshudash7437]

I think present govt is little bit more Kshatriya type than previous govt.. and that is good for our nation.. thanks for this video!!

[@mukundshamlalshamlal5959]

vote BJP vote MODI for SECURITY and PROSPERITY for all Indians citizens The Congress thieves must be sentenced to jail soon to set an example to the future gaddar s

[@jaivijayful]

Although, I voted for BJP in 2014 and 2019. But the Modi govt needs not to be just a lil bit of Kshatriya but to be fully Kshatriya. The sheer no. of battles that are consistently breaking India from within will make a true Kshatriya go into desperation and depression. Not a single night goes when these demons don't haunt me.

[@sidmallya7421]

Congress is Vatican prostitutes

[@ಭಾರತೀಯ_ನಾಗರಿಕ]

@@jaivijayful LOL!! The leftists are going crazy and screaming intolerance for this lil Kshatriya govt by Modi. If a more Kshatriya person like Yogi Adityanath becomes PM, there would be riots and even civil war by the liberals!! They want to destroy Indian-ness at all costs..

[@MahirParekh]

Yeah but not 'Kshatriya' enough

[@kingaditya-pubgmandmore3644]

Rajiv ji boldly declared the truth ' We need a dictatorship.'

[@medialcanthus9681]

A benevolent dictator ?

[@kishlaybihan3790]

China is doing 2 the countries in africa, asia and east europe to what west did and UK did as in the form of subsidiary alliance. If we read 4 stages of subsidiary alliance history and correlate with chinese behaviour, modus operandi becomes clear. For pirva paksha we must understand chinese intent and capability clearly.

[@curiousguy3053]

Such a Frank, transparent & enlightening discussion. Even if they are disagreeing they are doing everything with mutual respect Wow... So far from embedded intellect talks.

[@PS-eu6qk]

I completely accept Rajiv ji's perceptions. India is sitting on a ticking time bomb.

[@Anilsinghvats007]

6 months back I watched many chines Christian advertisements on KZbin videos . That is why I agree with you that it there is a lot of underground Christian missionary is working in China.

[@ಭಾರತೀಯ_ನಾಗರಿಕ]

@MahaVakyas China may become weaker but won't get destroyed by the west. The westerners are facing a crisis of their own with mass Islamic immigration. Going by the current trends, we can assume the Europe falls before anyone else.

[@kingaditya-pubgmandmore3644]

@@ಭಾರತೀಯ_ನಾಗರಿಕ I think India will fall soon. Kashmir, Kolkata, Kerala. Its a lost cause.

[@kaustubhganorkar4958]

@@kingaditya-pubgmandmore3644 Yes bro , And also in South India ,where Hindu Peoples are facing a no of problems from Christian missionaries specially in Kerala and Tamilanadu and in West UP ,West Bangal ,Bihar where the Peoples are facing no of Problems from these Islamic Jehadis because of Large number of muslims . 5 Crore Bangladeshi Illegal Immigrants are living in Hindustan ,2 Lakhs Rohingyas which makes vote bank for Other parties .

[@coolFeb1984]

Professor Vaidyanathan is living in past and too generous on China like chinese are our younger brother!!!

[@coolFeb1984]

Although I am agree about opening 100 Chinese study center across country. It's shame for us if Yoaga is going via USA.

[@writeintent3936]

@@YS-tn9ur but they r a tiny fraction in China.

[@MithunSharma-ym7em]

See ,we can't dictate other country what they should or shouldn't do... But we can and are free to do what we want,but we haven't done. So no point in blaming them...

[@ಭಾರತೀಯ_ನಾಗರಿಕ]

@@MithunSharma-ym7em True, we shouldn't dictate anyone what to do or what not to do. But the USA is doing the same in the past 50 years or so.

[@jagdpanther2224]

Criminology 101 China is none of you indian business

[@s.sarkar83]

very engaging conversations and Shri Rajiv Malhotra sees everything from a very practical perspective which is actually very effective in this day and age. He is such a genius. Rajiv ji must be mass popularized by the State and our Indian Cultural ecosystem so that more and more Bhartiyas get influenced by hum & try to think, analyze and act like him to save our Civilization 🕉

[@kekandatta6286]

Al Capone

[@thrinethran2885]

From what I made of the discussion, Prof RV thinks that China is now testing the limits of its hard power , and that if we fix our end we can keep them at bay , and slowly influence them through soft power. But do we see this happening : Our academies are politicised and functionally mediocre , our judiciary is inbred , ideological, and functionally deficient , and so on. When realism trumps idealism, we have to accept Sri R M 's tough - as - nails assessment , that we have not just been overtaken, but run the risk of being economically and politically overrun.

[@RAJAT6555]

India is the world's first SJW nation. Social engineering is embedded in the fabric of this nation since the evil day of August 15, 1947. So we cannot expect 'culture' and 'civilisation' to win over China, at least not with the present 'empowered Indian youth'. What we can do, however, is develop through tech and outdo them. It may seem strange to hear this, but believe me, the real breakthroughs in tech will come not in the domain of flashy mobile phones, tablets, etc. Instead, they will come from the so-called 'dirty fields', i.e groundwater and soil remediation, waste recycling technology, etc. I have studied chemical engineering, and I can say with certainty that it is far easier to set up a mega plant dedicated to manufacturing potato chips, or even a semiconductor plant, than it is to develop a process for recycling, say, e-waste, and scale it up to a level where it can actually work on the principles of 'economies of scale'. Note that in engineering, the really high-end research comes from computational experimentation, i.e. modeling and simulation. If Modi pushes for supercomputing in a big way (which he is doing, although not enough), we can actually use M & S methodologies to leapfrog ahead technologically. Also, we must not push ahead with the way China has, rather, if we achieve expertise in environmental solutions, it might help us solve not only our environmental problems, but also, we could truly become knowledge creators again after a thousand years of decline. Note that in these areas, AI will have a negligible impact (also, it is important to note that AI is overrated, simply because the obscene number crunching capacities that ever more powerful machine learning algorithms require, cannot be achieved due to the fact that we have hit a wall as far as developing ever more powerful chips is concerned).

[@kamla9683]

@@RAJAT6555 I agree with you.research and development should be done in waste management,water management , replacement of plastic etc.But you cannot ignore the electronics industry for now as we cannot lose our Indian consumers and also the above projects requires huge investments and india is lacking money.These high tech projects not only require money but good governance(which cannot happen as our whole system is highly corrupt).

[@thrinethran2885]

Our sovereignty and security depend very much on economic power , so in no critical area can economic and technological independence from hegemonic powers be traded off

[@RajivMalhotraOfficial]

This is part 4 of a 6-part series. Be sure to keep up with the entire series as we release them here: bit.ly/ProfessorVaidyanathan Part 3 - Crisis in Europe - bit.ly/crisisineurope To donate to Infinity Foundation’s projects including the continuation of such episodes and the research we do: infinityfoundation.com/donate-2/

[@malmalhi007]

~Rajiv .. what you are doing for Bharat is immense.. I am a Sikh Hindustani and we want Hindus to come back to the richness of Hindu Culture and religion as it was before it got corrupted in the last two thousand years. Good luck fellow Bharatiya!!!

[@paharipant2]

RajivJi watch Red Reign(2013) on China. They kill their prisoners to sell their organs and use as slaves...that's how they have manufacturing edge.

[@adityarajan592]

@H P I think the Chinese government views Indians as potential western tools to threaten it

[@adityarajan592]

Rajivji I disagree with you when you said India has not had a violent episode, what about partition? What about the famine under British rule? You see neither India nor China's violent episode was in itself beneficial, they lessons they learned were beneficial. The difference is they seemed to have learned something from that and changed their ways, whereas we have not

[@shivanshivan5507]

Rajiv Malhotra Official I am from USA what is your take one USA economy and its future

[@vainateyghadigaonkar4172]

I would urge every Hindu to donate to his Foundation - The Infinity Foundation. I saw so many of his lectures and dialogues that I contributed to his foundation.

[@sadenb]

Prof VK's idealism is clashing against RM's pragmatism. I got to side with Rajiv Malhotra on this one. We need more people like him and Prof VK to lead our nation.

[@GreatMan_from_East]

Yes

[@katiesethna]

Our whole fight for independence was passive aggressive. We need to be aggressive openly for what we want.

[@watchme9463]

Our fight for Independence was hugely aggressive but our books tells us it was hugely passive so our brain in conflict of the two thinks it was passive-aggressive. But that's not the truth, it was hugely aggressive and books will always tell us it's passive because that's what the West wants to know

[@srividyadhardantu6]

For God sake allow Prof to speak

[@RAMAKRISHNACPNilAPRAMEYA]

MALHOTRA IS MORE CONTEMPORARY THAN PROF.

[@babajikijaiho7641]

Its a discussion not an interview....

[@spachkhe]

I tend to agree more with Mr Rajiv Malhotra than Professor. It is much easier to garner soft power when you are a superpower. One major way to tackle rise of China is by innovations. One of the advantage we have over China is we might not have to import scientists and researchers like China as we have plenty of them in India. All w need is more investments in R&D. Something like doubling the number of IITs, IIMs, More investments in BHUs, Bhabha automic research centers, etc.

[@mihirghosh6224]

On this topic i am 80% with Mr. Malhotra, Prof Vaidyanatham made a good point and it shows that China is going to go through an identity crisis which is why catholics are moving in China.

[@kamla9683]

I agree with you .but focussed on local engineering college student should also be made.remember apj Kalam were from local college.These student should be granted scholarships etc.

[@kamla9683]

@@mihirghosh6224 identity crisis will happen to all those who are atheists after they have gained materialistic gains

[@watchme9463]

That's basically what we need.

[@k.bhatta4257]

@samudra gupta More coolies for the West! Indeed.

[@akshayabatdasguru6414]

Our leaders should start thinking introducing varnashram as envisaged in Manusmriti into new constitution. We should value our social system which run through centuries keeping indian values still alive.

[@dayananddhyani4466]

चाइना भारतीय उपमहाद्वीप जिसमें सिन्धु घाटी की सभ्यता और संस्कृति व तिब्बत व कैलाश भी शामिल है को तुरंत खाली कर दें नहीं तो हांग कांग में ही सिमट जाएगा, यह ईश्वरीय निर्णय है - कल्कि अवतार

[@kaivalya9625]

After your series with Professor Vaidyanathan sir, i went ahead and watched many of his lectures & videos on youtube. I must confess that I wished he should have been my economics teacher during my school/college days!

[@kushaq1173]

I agree with professor everybody want to be businessman. 👍👍👍

[@nihaarbs8050]

Mr Malhotra you have clearly explained what China is actually doing. I am an Indian stu dent studying in China and i agree with every word you said👍👍

[@rubyYT333]

Both of them makes sense for me. Because what prof is also true and partially not to see here from China as an Indian and Rajiv sir super !!! His interview and his responses are much better than prof sir.

[@JG-qy6fe]

As always, Rajivji's concerns are spot on..very pertinant discussion. 1 year ago, indians did not take china seriously enough, due to their cheap consumer products. However post Galwan, Indians will seriously try to compete with china, with a vengence.

[@ivarhakuse8572]

This is a very important point to translate our simple texts such as amarchitra Katha. I lived in China and Japan and had 1 Amat Chittagong katha translated into Japanese. The translator said it was fascinating. I told Ananth Pai but that was the end of that.

[@rashminpatel8137]

A worth, notable eye opening discussion. I completely agree with RM. We need autocracy or dictatorship. Our history should be re-written by RM and taught to us all to understand such complex issues in right perspective so that to enable us tackle other part of the world. Congress, other small regional political parties, Gandhian philosophy and their nuisance followers, leftist, have made this nation weak, slow and visionless, always fighting within. We can overcome the situation by only way of acting on RM thoughts. India has to gain hard power all possible way and simultaneously refine soft power and use it to influence other part of the world in our favour.

[@haribhansingh9582]

I support Rajiv ji fully and politely differ with due respect with professor sb.

[@curiousguy3053]

The history books should be descriptive not prescriptive. If it's written that Subhash Chandra Bose us freedom in 1943 & Gandhiji gave a huge (but evil) political organisation for an official excuse for the the British to flee, that would give us that fiery spirit.

[@bgkarkera2111990]

allways good conversations bet.these two prof. vaidyanathan and mr Rajiv malhotra worth to follow.

[@jaivijayful]

I agree with boh R Vaidyanthan and Rajeev ji on many points. If India is to be saved, the only way is to restore the Kshatriya Dharma of atleast the Kshatriya population of India. Currently, every person is running after their personal interests and in this scenario it is no wonder India is in such a sorry state. Modi ji should appoint Shankaracharya of Puri Peeth Swami Nischalanand Saraswati ji as the advisor of Govt. I have been following him for many months on his youtube channel and the way he gets the root of all he problems of India, be it security, politics, religion, is brilliant. It was the conspiracy of Western nations especially British Kingdom to remove the Shankaracharya from the respectable position they used to hold in earlier times as they knew that these wise men can within months bring back India to its old glory. The Shankaracharya has also advised for Kshatriya Dharma encouragement on similar lines as the speakers above.

[@hxjkavavjjehekkww1872]

Best economic analysis by these two. Nice . We should think for our country.

[@tiwari86graphene]

Prof. has very clear vision about China . I worked for few days in China

[@shashwathsbharadwaj4841]

What an extraordinary discussion! Privileged to be privy to this thanks to the KZbin

[@goodperson9845]

What a nice debate...Great!!! I like you Sir.

[@badripoondi5181]

If two big brains come together we need a heightened capacity to receive the ideas that are in dynamic debate. Lot of inputs and inspiration from the duo. thank u channel

[@PrakashSharma-ez1ce]

We Indians believe in 🐢 turtle philosophy, The Chinese believe in Rabbit philosophy.

[@VivekYadav-pn8zm]

Namaste Vaidyanathan sir

[@busybeenature9092]

Our society WAS organised. For the last 10-15 years we are fascinated by western culture, and following their culture, which has left us nowhere.

[@RaghunathAS]

Rajiv ji has become a TV Anchor. Not allowing his guest panelist to speaks. He only puts his view points.

[@rbk9915]

Sorry to say, professor Vaidyanathan’s understanding of China situation is lackluster.

[@acjust688]

I agree with professor more than RM. I do not agree with RM's thinking here... strong leader... yes, but sacrificing generation and sacrificing human rights... no way, I do not agree with that. Yes, it looks right what China is doing at the moment, but their way of handling it will backfire and turn against them in the future. I agree with professor that we have very strong cultural base than China. It may look kaotic at times, but that is our asset and I do not want to sacrifice that. If we change our identity/culture so we become someone else in order to do things faster; well then we don't have our country any more, and what good is that for?

[@abhi3710]

China deserves respect for it's development.

[@jnanabhaskara-shivoham5850]

Professor has good points!!

[@gopals9928]

If we were to see the relationship between India and China, dispassionately, its been an unmitigated tragedy. and we cannot hold any one country solely responsible. Many of the points raised by Rajivji is so pertinent. Sometimes I wonder at the caliber of our external affairs officials. I still feel the lack of pride in our history, the self loathing of our culture, the brain-washing by the left leaning intellectuals and missionaries of the Abrahamic faiths, have all contributed its mite in the absence of self-interest in our intellectuals. That point where R.M says that we Indians behave and command the rights of the west prematurely is so pertinent. We can talk of human rights, once we turn human.

[@MMaheshThakur]

Sir plz do yoga and increase life span. We don't have people like u. U r only one in this field. Plz plz. We seriously need u.

[@prabhunathg7026]

Again and again Prof. R.V prooves he is a good teacher. Unorganized Govt. vs Organized Society. How beautifully he highlighted the strong point of India - Organized Society. We have lots of testimonials to this. Family as a binding Force. Family business. Society formed out of castes Still these are making our culture strong. These are the strong forces which are at least making our children born out of wedlock. WoW professor, blessed to hear from a great teacher.👃👃👃

[@tushar8524]

It's true that we are long run horse bcoz we discuss everything. I agree with professor.

[@mmmittal]

I sense a feeling of awe in Rajiv ji when discussing China. Another reference is his recent tweet about Chinese doing path-breaking work in AI (Artificial Intelligence). I do understand his angst at the short-sightedness of large Indian soft-ware companies as also GOI's lack of strategic initiatives in such futuristic endeavours. But, at some point, it starts to sound like hero-worship. India is India and China is China. We have had our history and they have had theirs. There is much to learn from Chinese about how they gamed Western technologies and money-power to their own strategic advantage. But we should never forget they have authoritarian rule. Democracy has its own pitfalls. Our country has had more than its fair share of idiotic leaders since Independence (even before that too). However, there is some ray of hope in the last 5 years, and also for the future. All said and done, I could never ever think about living in the muzzled dictatorship that is China, in spite of superlative economic/material performance.

[@kamla9683]

Why you think we are living in democratic country? A country where school and colleges opened by businessman, banks and even a aircraft company is taken over by government from the Hands of business person.People are not able to express their opinions without any fear.People cannot buy land ,car or open shop without govt permission.Many shops are closed just like that without any reason.

[@ravindrababu7231]

The discussion is fantastic. The relations of civilisational neighbours is under studied by the contemporary nation-states, Republic of India and !Peoples Republic of China. (Of course, Republics are under turmoils or undertransitions Iin either states.) Both have their weaknesses and strong points in understanding each other’s. Nearly seventy years of their independent statehood’s did not evolve them into a pragmatic entities or relationships. Hope your discussion might lead them both into a viable foundations for tomorrow’s sustainable development. C3S, Chennai under Prof. RS Vasan is a great work in that direction. Thank you.

[@venugopalbk4144]

India didn't get independence, The British transferred the power to Nehru, who blindly followed the British colonial style of functioning

[@kamla9683]

People even have not realised they were under dictatorship rule till 1990s.Real Democracy has started in reality from 2016 when social media came in India.

[@k.bhatta4257]

You hit the nail on the head; the same colonial parampara continues. Indian Constitution is NOT Indian; it's anti-Indian. The same colonial institutions continued with Brainwashed Brown Sahibs with the addition of communists. This is true right from the preamble! Ie., It's neither secular nor socialist, but should have been a Dharmic Rastra…….

[@alex-sv8ru]

Yes, Nehru always wanted to follow a secular socialist fantasy.

[@vinaykumar-me6kj]

Sir I am Impress with your work , and the Knowledge you giving removed many of doubts of mine . one thing i want to know is what is Kshatriya Govt Looks to be in Small context please

[@mayankgupta7172]

Excellent. Great Work!

[@shubhamkulkarni4805]

Sir you mentioned once that you are looking forward to train Indian youth to challenge so called western Intellectuals on their own grounds. Are you still on that quest ?

[@AksGun]

Great discussion. Two diverse viewpoints on dealing with China. Didn't really like the insertion of varna terms towards the end though.

[@apsingh18]

Rajiv ji is right

[@yashraj97]

Don't be scared Sir. India is like an Elephant. It seems harmless. Even a pride of lions thinks a hundred times before attacking, most of them fail. This is Naya Bharat.

[@abhijeetm29]

The best part of the video starts from 13:50.

[@sureshveeramachaneni91]

I have been telling to learn Chinese language and they are linto it. Great conversation!

[@govindn3536]

Very informative and eye opening talk!

[@brothru41]

I believe, democracy will be backed with Sustainable developed nation. It may take time, but will sustain for long time.. the history of our nation has proved it that though a benevolent dictator did it's part in developing this country as a superpower.. over the time, we lost it all... So the development via dictatorship may be long lasting, but not truly sustainable... For a sustainable development we need people involved, united with right narrative. Educated with essential books 'like Bhagvat Geeta' which will help the people know their duties and actions associated to it.. what government should then do is create a environment of balance between the same... We need united Bharat.. A nationalist when given a chance gives rise to another nationalist.. that's what make the country proud and united. This phase of our country assures this unity. Provided people like Shri Rajiv. Keep up with such acts of awareness... Thank you

[@RAshok-rh1xq]

Respected Rajiv ji - unintentionally you did not allow Vaidya ji to speak freely. There were too many interruptions.

[@chandrareddy2790]

The reason why we Indians as a people are so selfish and self centered is because of the trauma which was inflicted on us by oppressive regimes who ruled us for so long. Essentially, we suffer from this phenomenon of post traumatic stress disorder. We were transformed into a fearful society, just focused on self preservation. The Kshatriya spirit in us was ground to dust. But, I notice, that behavior is gradually changing. One example, is, the behavior of our national cricket team. It doesn’t tolerate bullying by these other big teams and stand their ground and give it back in many cases. What we need is to spread awareness of our rich culture, our valor, our contributions to the world during the Vedic period and so on so forth. I really think we should be exposed to our past to order for us to completely understand ourselves and heal the wounds inflicted on us. 🙏🏼

[@abhisheikpathak5180]

I loved the example of soft power and hard power approach given by Rajiv jee . Very well explained, sir. Chinese have a world agenda , let alone agenda towards India. I can only say Dr. Vaidya has a wishful thinking pattern and his approach on China is erroneous and misplaced and rife with danger. China can only be aligned if we are of any use to them OR we are too powerful. Budhhism and cultural ties have no buyers in China. Its a ruthless , aggressive,, mind driven , Confucius fed country that has no conscience. I agree , we need an all out Kshatriya approach to tackle the future demons building up to annihilate Bharat. We are too soft now to even imagine these challenges . What we need ! Is to sacrifice a whole generation in this furnace to emerge as a MIGHTY and LETHAL race with heart of steel. JAI HIND 🌈

[@sadenb]

India should focus on education as No 1 priority for the next 20 years.

[@sadenb]

@Ramachandrula Rambabu B. Com That money is not enough. 6% of GDP share has to go towards education not just basic education but high end R&D . We need to develop large amounts of original research which is really missing in India at a scale which is equivalent to the size of India.

[@akarmaaction]

What insight! Amazing.

[@jaypeeprakash393]

what a best great debate

[@nethrakanagasabai1040]

Excellent discussion. India must be more aggressive - whether in the world play or in promotion of religion and culture. No point pandering to the minority religions of India all the time . We are loosing so many significant things with this attitude .

[@uradhai]

Really do not know what our highly esteemed Mr. Rajiv Malhothre means by other super powers have done great(human?!) sacrifices whereas India has not done any!! Also continues to say that leaders should go ahead of human rights,! This was published one year ago! I am really curious to know Mr. Rajiv Malhotra”s views on this doomsday context, esp. about China! I appreciate Prof. Vaidyanathan’s patience & modesty during the discussion(if ever you can call it so!)

[@zekiyegok5747]

Namaste sir 🙏🙏 God bless you 🙏🙏🙏

[@abhaydeshpande8464]

With all due respect Rajiv Sir, please let the interviewee speak to his heart's content.

[@thrinethran2885]

The Indian State must confront its internal enemies much more vigorously. Something that Prof RV says impliedly is crucial. That a free and aware society has the potential to rise and defend the nation better than a subdued and submissive society. First , we must expose the false - liberal champions of Anti-India forces , who are constantly agitated about endangered Indian democracy and secularism. Some of them are curiously Sinophile Hinduphobes .

[@sureshrao9568]

Rajiv vs Vaidyanathan. Rajiv wins!

[@jacobcantrell82]

The French Revolution and American War of Independence have nothing to do with economic modernization. That happened like 80 years after the later and 40 years after the first.

[@CommonAadmi]

More Centres for Chinese studies should be matched with equal number of centres for USA studies also, so that the momentum for next 20 years gallops with the global trends and will help to balance it on both sides.

[@ramarajug3502]

Hat's off Rajiv Malhotra Sir... Aur ek Baar Modi Sarkar

[@padmapadma2258]

JAI GURU DEV #R#R

[@vikramrazdan5680]

Vaidyanathan says that Coca Cola and Pepsi had a tacit understanding with China not to publicise anything against China. Its not called understanding, its called enforcement on control of speech.

[@Shp-ch]

Prof. Vaidhyanathan has absolutely no clue about what hes saying. Rajiv understands this complex issue very well. But vaidhyanathan is way behind. Amar chitra Katha? Really? C'mon now.

[@oneforallah]

What he meant was making China's younger generation know about Indian civilization and thus make us allies, do you really take everything literally ?

[@kingaditya-pubgmandmore3644]

@@oneforallah dude chinese youngsters cant do shit to affect their foreign policy.

[@historybuff1085]

Rajiv Malhotra ji, I mostly agree with you but for your point that we never had an aggressive struggle, unlike the American revolution or The French. Actually, we did. It started with the rise of Chhatrapati Shivaji, when the entire India was ruled by Turks, Mongols, Afghans and Persians. And that movement gained a massive momentum, and turned pan-India with the rise of Peshwa Bajirao. By 1750, Marathas had already reclaimed 75% of India from the aforementioned Muslim rulers, and fought multiple enemies like Mogals, Nizam, Afghans and the Portuguese simultaneously. It was a Hindavi Swarajya- a Hindu self rule. And it was only a matter of 50 more years before Marathas freed the entire India, although the British made a mess of it. The point here is that it's factually incorrect to say that we never had an aggressive fight for freedom. Yes we did. What Chhatrapati Shivaji started was a cultural renaissance- a Hindu resurgence. If you compare today's map of BJP Hindutva strongholds with the Maratha map of 1750, it's almost the same. As for Bose, we are extremely appreciative of his contributions towards our rashtra, but it's noteworthy that he ideologically was very westernized. He leaned left and also admired fascism. If you read him, you would know that he considered the Mogal rule as an Indian rule, and also believed the Muslim separatism to be a mere political problem and not a religious one. It's also interesting to note that a large chunk of the INA was Muslims and communists. Even the British Indian army at the time was dominated by the Muslim community, which is why Savarkar, alarmed at the situation, had started a "whirlwind propaganda" during the WW2 to encourage Hindu youth to join the army, and he brought up the Hindu percentage in the army from less than 50% to about 65%. And he was proved right when almost all of the Muslim armymen went with Pakistan in 47, and had Savarkar not increased the Hindu percentage in the army, the Pak army would have reached Delhi, forget Kashmir. So the point is that history is not black and white.

[@sheeteshaswal]

Rajiv should have allowed prof. Vaidyanathan to say his point.

[@praveenrai6965]

Rajiv ji's mind works like a game theorist; he is a consummate strategist who believes in eternal vigilance in this civilizational survival game. Yes, one has to be a paranoid & cease to be an optimist in this game of survival. There is no place for altruism, pacifism & complacency in the form of "oh, we have survived so long, let's wait for China to make mistakes." No doubt, patience is virtue. But that trait needs to be complemented by proactive strategies to fill the competency voids (China is galloping technologically). India has to make huge investments in every technological arena (AI, biotechnology, nano...) and compete with the current tech powers. If not, when the eventual tech singularity arrives, we will be among the slave nations to the few master nations like China and the US. The thing is, while we can keep giving excuses such as democracy, internal conflicts, compromised leadership, indifferent elites/biz men etc., that should not stop us from making some key investments in important areas. If Modi ji comes back to power, a "Civilizational Revival" ministry can be created to formulate & execute multi-pronged strategies to address the areas of weakness & make targeted investments in areas where India can compete on par with other major civilizations. (This ministry should be the liaison between sci-tech, infra, education, military, culture ministries with one goal: push the agenda of Civilizational Revival from all perspectives)

[@vikramrazdan5680]

Best comment by Rajivji "Pakistan is a useful idiot"

[@SK-nx9go]

Sir I would like to know for whom you make these videos - for western world, for a part of Indian population who understand English or only for english literates of India?

[@ravindrababu7231]

Breaking India vs cementing China and vice versa does it happen? Civilisational roots (India China) do they work out?

[@k.bhatta4257]

Doubtful. Minotity-ist govt and demographics reinforce each other.

[@dokyungsoo4300]

If India had got independence because of SUBHASH CHANDRA BOSE and BHAGATH SINGH's ideology just like Kshatriyas , today's scenario would have been different. What Rajiv sir said is 💯 right that we Indians have lost our fighting spirit in our blood... 😑

[@ramesh_iyer]

Good discussion n debate between Prof RV & Mr Malhotra. Indeed, India bet on the wrong horse, so to speak, by backing a Bania who raised fasting to an arm form. In a different KZbin channel I'd recently heard about how MKG converted 'Satyagrah' to 'Hattagrah' over time and pretty much got away with many things by being a nuisance to the British administrators in India. That was totally different from how Subhash Chandra Bose confronted the British boldly. Had India backed SCB instead of MKG n his crony Nehru, India would have had a strong foundation as a self-respecting self-sufficient nation.

[@anonymousaccount6737]

very hard questions Rajivji

[@jagdishchandrapant1605]

In the short run, we can only think of being strong enough to repel any Chinese military adventure. The next priority should be opening of centers of China studies for more and more people to people contacts in order to build on the cultural links of the past. This is a long drawn process which has to start sometime. Genuine Indian/Hindu Gurus should be visiting China to talk of 'Adhyatm'. Economically, China is far ahead of us, though its rate of growth is appearing to peter out, while India's appears to be accelerating. China has an increasingly aging population, with gradually declining productivity while India's population is going to become younger and more productive for the next 50 odd years. Internal dissent in China will keep on mounting every day while India's democratic polity will ensure a stable society. We have to balance the pros and cons of the present situation to build on the future..

[@nagamanjunath2102]

Damn. Rajiv Malhotra is outstanding. He's a true pragmatist. India needs more people like him. Modi should appoint him as a cultural affairs minister in india to KO the whole world of sickular-libtards.

[@Noname-user2468]

Its a good discussion but I felt that interviewer is not letting Professor to express the opinion uninterrupted. Everytime he is speaking something he is intervened by the interviewer.

[@mrkumar7181]

Its a debate

[@CommonAadmi]

Please remember we lost half a million people in the Indian war of Independence of 1857. However, we were overpowered at that time. The 1947 was a result of that only.

[@narsingha2024]

Bad idea of proposing dictatorship in India. Instead, Indian govt should focus on education & training customized for Indians that can create an indigenous society. There is no need to replicate a western model. It is easy to say that human rights can be sacrificed. We borrow from others what we must and create an Indian “cryogenic” system for the population. This can happen only if the PM is able to shake the tardy Indian bureaucracy.

[@kamla9683]

In manusmriti it is said that Vedas are self implemented.proof is women were not given equal right to study and work and here we are .please learn how women get rights.In the same way which is wrong should be uprooted otherwise it will be uprooted but in different way and loss too will occur.

[@medialcanthus9681]

10:30

[@isan26]

This is best debate I've seen on youtube. You both seem to be on opposite sides, but look how both of your words have come true. Great deerghadarshis you both are. What RajivJi told about Nepal (2:33) have come true. And also VaidyanathanJi's words on how China imposes restrictions on lz1am (4:50) have also come true. Also like your friendship and humour sense very much. 😊

[@GTR-93]

WE MUST FOCUS ON INTERNAL INDIA. THE CIVIL WAR IN IRAQ & SYRIA WAS STARTED COZ OF UNIVERSITIES IN ALEPPO & DAMASCUS AND LATER ISIS COLOR WAS GIVEN TO IT BACKED BY SAUDI & QATAR. LATER AMERICA SUPPORTED IRAQS KURDISH FORCES & RUSSIA SUPPORTED SYRIAS BASHR AL ASADS ARMY

[@abhinavsaket1194]

We should have monarchy in india Time has come for Ramachandra jee to rule over us as a suzerain king

[@originalideas9617]

good discuss. need some bowls of rice after the energetic discuss ?

[@gowriradhakrishnan7048]

Thaiwan is number one in microchip manufacturing for computers & smart phones.

[@oneforallah]

Rajiv Malhotra Ji he is again and again and again and again telling you we have never even studied China properly (always looked at it through Western lens) and he is right there is no Indian university that does such things, nobody to fund, nobody to handpick nothing.

[@tunkamtungkhang2465]

Chinese acceptance of india as elder brother is based on civilizational linkages of these two nations which is true but both has failed to convert these linkages to economical and political advantages.

[@Jhonnycomelate]

Civilizational ? The culture, history and civilization of China has been more or less wiped out and destroyed by it's own people during the cultural revolution. China aspires to become a "celestial power", the greatest hegemony of all time, as most Han chauvinists would put it. It doesn't give a shit about India or any small historical ties they have between the two in the past.

[@ghanvedsingh8946]

Because they only want do not want to give so there is too much BOP gap in our trade that is not trade they want to squize us of our foreign exchange