CSDS Survey 32% Muslims Satisfied with Modi? Indian Lok Sabha Elections: Religion versus Economy

CSDS Survey 32% Muslims Satisfied with Modi? Indian Lok Sabha Elections: Religion versus Economy
• CSDS Survey 32% Muslim...
Join this channel to get greater access to Prof. Khan and to support the channel:
/ @profmuqtedarkhan
Click to subscribe to Khanversations. Press the bell Icon. kzbin.info...
Follow Dr. Muqtedar Khan on Twitter: / muqtedarkhan
Follow Dr. Muqtedar Khan on Instagram: / muqtedarkhan
Follow Dr. Muqtedar Khan on Linkedin: / muqtedar-khan-1500b85
Follow Dr. Muqtedar Khan on FaceBook: / muqtedar
Follow Dr. Muqtedar Khan on Academia.edu: udel.academia.edu/MuqtedarKhan
#loksabhaelection2024 #modi2024 #indianmuslim #khanversations #muqtedarkhan

[@teachingntraining]

I voted yesterday and my experience is that Election Commission is doing a wonderful job. Very strict and transparent arrangements have been done by EC. My wife was on election duty so I was with her in morning and late night when they were submitting all the materials to zonal officers. The process went on till 3.00 am this morning. I was really impressed by the hard work of all those involved in the process. Indeed, Indian election system is the best.

[@SaurabhSharma-vc3yv]

Sir I behalf oc my family would like to thank you both for your services to the nation . Thank you so much sir and pls extend my gratitude to your wife too. 🙏🏻❤️

[@AG-cv7fx]

The biggest beneficiaries of Centre's Public Welfare Schemes r actually Muslims, be it FREE RATION, of PM Awas Yojana (Housing Scheme), Ujjawala, etc and this is all above the Minority Scheme benefits.

[@rajiv1252]

सबसे बड़ी minority या सेकंड बड़ी आबादी, हर बिनिफिट मिलने के बाबजूद, वोट करती है बीजेपी को हराने के लिए, क्यों की नफरत सीखी है बचपन से।

[@alamsheikh7839]

One Nation One Election in 2029 😱

[@eliotanderson6554]

14:23 should have shown upper caste muslims and lower caste muslims as seperate to understand ground reality of how poor low caste muslims feel verus owaisi(new jinnah) like upper caste people who are politically strong

[@pedababu5075]

I too was thinking about the point you raised. However, if Mr.Khan shows such a data, he will implicitly be accepting that Islam is a caste-based religion. 🙂

[@user-rd8ec1ve8l]

Sitting in US you can't make judgment on these issues

[@Sameer-er3wz]

Sir, I am sorry to say, your biases and prejudices are coming out clearly. Ever since the Hamas attack, I feel you have become less and less objective. I am sure your own students could have come up with a better analysis of the data. Probably, time for me to unsubscribe.

[@pedababu5075]

Data he analyzed was provided by a survey conducted by The Hindu. It was not his own data 🙂.

[@AKumar-co7oe]

the issue is with the analysis not the data. this is piss poor analysis including bad mathematics

[@gopalramanathan7062]

@@pedababu5075And the so called “The Hindu” has totally degenerated to be the most Adharmic (anti Hindu)😠

[@gargi96]

Centre For the Study of Developing (not Democratic) Societies. It's in Rajpur Road, Delhi (not New Delhi).

[@kjumani]

I respectfully disagree with your analysis on this topic. Your conclusion on economy vs religion is based on potentially misleading data. The question of "most popular" and "least popular" initiatives requires a singular answer, but that doesn't mean that other initiatives were good or not. So if a group says Ram Mandir and another says Foreign Policy was what they felt to be the singular most popular initiatives, that doesn't mean that they feel the economy is being mishandled. So to reduce it to a religion vs economy election is, I think, is to oversimplify things. That being said, I appreciate the thought and effort you put in to talking about these things.

[@mandeepraghuvanshi9104]

It's a best example of data manipulation to spread misinformation because economy not a single head term and terms like employment,infrastructure,poverty alleviation etc are part of larger term economy. So you just show fragmented data of economy to show ram mandir data larger

[@rohitbasuthkar9914]

Absolutely agree , it is a classic example of data manipulation . Of course I don't blame the professor as he has not designed the survey. But if he would have highlighted this observation I would have appreciated his analysis much better

[@AmalTan]

Most important reason for this fall is the complacency induced by "Abki bar 400 par" slogan among the BJP cadre and voters. They think BJP is already winning so why vote, instead enjoy the holiday. Reminds of 2004 India Shining fiasco. Also the more recent Chhattisgarh Congress loss in December 2023, where CM was too confident of winning 75 out of 90, instead got voted out.

[@pedababu5075]

I agree with you. "Abki bar 400 par" may turn out to be a self-inflicted wound. 6 more phases to go. I am keeping my fingers crossed.

[@FreddieMurphy746]

Sir, let's give the EC it's due. There are a couple of States that are known for their political violence and the state's police forces are ineffective at controlling it. Hence, they depend on the central reserve forces; only a limited amount of force can be deployed on the election duty; That could be the reason for this extended duration to conduct this process.

[@zyxraoxyz]

India goes to extreme lengths to make sure that everyone can vote. A polling booth must be provided within 2 KM of every voter. In the US, the emphasis nowadays seems to be in finding innovative ways to gerrymander and to suppress voter participation. After having lived in the US for 30 years, I laugh aloud whenever western media casts doubts on Indian democracy.

[@santkumartibrewal4430]

I sorry to find that inspit of highly qualified persons like you can not come out religious mind set why you are interested in division of in society sir you never discuss discuss who are the people who attacked Bangalore eatry and why

[@rajiv1252]

जो लोग जिदंगी भर नफरत का पाठ पढ़ते रहे वह कभी भी निष्पक्ष विश्लेषण नही कर सकते। क्यों की मन में नफरत भरा रहता है जो बचपन से पढ़ी और सीखी है

[@tsanarayanan5032]

You can't even add properly. Hindu SC and Hindu ST are satisfied

[@chakdeamerica]

Mark Twain is credited with popularizing the quote, “There are three kinds of lies: lies, damned lies, and statistics."

[@BhartiyaVatsalyaPatel]

Professor, Based on NUMBERS, You can simply come up with NARRATIVE you may like to. Best of Luck for Your vLog... .

[@vitastablues1070]

There is a Heaven an Hell difference between the numbers of American voters and Indian voters. Indian General Elections and their conduct is certainly something that should be studied by countries wh hope to becoming vibrant democracies. Secondly, people in India vote very intelligently. Therefore, to predict what an election outcome will be is not a joke. Let mebe very clear, the Hindus in India lo e their religion, but religion is not the final thing as far as they are concerned.

[@AmalTan]

2:20 Voting percentage has risen by 2-3% in some states in comparision to this table according to updated data. However it remains lower than 2019 by 5-6%.

[@soumyamaitra6132]

its interesting to see Hindutva gets 5% whereas Ram mandir gets 25.. so there is a hope that common Hindu Indians are not at least anti-minority. people should maintain the religious harmony and its not an option.

[@sanjivgupta1418]

Ram Mandir is not about Hindu Nationalism, rather it is about recognition of civilization and history of India that is Bharat.

[@vipulmalhotra6426]

Also how contentious issues which no ther govt was able to solve were sorted. jnk also...it brings conviction in bjps manifesto...they fulfill what they promise

[@Sameer-er3wz]

11:01 it is a question on most admired. Does not mean they do not admire other things.

[@PramodTan]

CSDS's Track record has been terrible during the last ten years; nevertheless, a tight contest is good for democracy. You must know that you, as well, are deeply biased against the BJP.

[@JaydipSarkarKolkata]

The Sample size is too small ... only 10019 out 91 Cr voter

[@29041982kamsha]

May be people are happy with present government and hence lower turnout voters.

[@Vishnus610]

People got the mindset that Bjp is going to come ...so those who vote for opposition are skipping...

[@regypillai8620]

Sir, 21+36=57 and 17+41=58. How does this become less than half , when you talking about SC/ST data?😮

[@tkrabc9999]

What you are missing is comparison with previous years ? I would bet that poor are happier compared with congress governments ( free ration, direct bank deposit etc )

[@PramodTan]

21+36 is 57%, not less than 50%, the same as ST. I know why. I hope you know the CSDS full name of their head and his debates. Hindu's N.Ram even suggested to block BJP coverage to stop them.

[@SouthindianNarendra]

All people staying here are Indians not muslims or hindhu. I request you also feel American not Muslim

[@kbmehta4208]

Your interpretation at around minute 15:10, that ST, SC satisfied with the Govt is less than 50%, is wrong. Both %s in the table are over 50%. Those satisfied with Govt in these categories number 57 & 58% respectively. Though, I also feel that if BJP wins 272 seats this time it will be a great achievement.

[@Samuel-ts5dh]

Sir, Ram Mandir is definitely a major achievement of BJP promise. But if if you see in overall India, South is not much concerned about the Mandir, but other factors much more. Anyhow BJP outweigh in overall among the alliance for sure.

[@PramodTan]

India had the lowest average inflation during the last ten years; that summed up this survey. I can take this seriously unless it has a biased sample.

[@AmalTan]

15:05 Dr Khan you made an arithmetic mistake here. SC(21%+36%=57%) and ST(17%+41%=58%) satisfaction levels are well above 50% and closer to 60%.

[@vipulmalhotra6426]

It's his jaundiced eyes

[@srirampundi6391]

Which expert told you that Balakot strike increases voting in india. You are full of dillusion

[@Harsh-ci8cd]

international image? masses should not care about outside and be unconsiously rooted

[@YashSrivastavaYT]

Sir Nice Video👏👏

[@chakdeamerica]

The only thing that matters is actual counting on June 4.

[@sunnysingh-vy5mg]

i think lack of strong personality in opposition bloc is main reason. for last 10 year congress attempting to re-brand Rahul gandhi but all in vain. its not like they do not have leaders but sticking to one person or family is main cause for weak opposition. though substainial no. of people not satisfied with govt but its unlike to convert into votes

[@Pyasa.shaitan]

This is India, it’s not a parliamentary democracy like US but a representative democracy like UK. Don’t be fooled.

[@mahenderpalsingh7509]

Just one thing Cry😭 More 😂

[@AG-cv7fx]

The sample size of these surveys doesn't even represent 0.01% of INDIA' s population + most of them r conducted in urban areas; while the biggest votebank of the current govt resides in semi-urban & rural areas (excluding the Casteist & Minority votebank). Also in developing economies like INDIA, issues related to culture, nationalism always dominate the socio-economic issues, this is also true for advanced economies to some extent.

[@pinakidash2730]

This is the most boring election ever. Opposition, cadres & it's voters are demoralised and not venturing out to vote in hot summer. What else to expect when the debate is not about who is winning but whether NDA will surpass 400 seats!

[@Harsh-ci8cd]

i think we need social media sovernity only for indian languages and indians, and mass media and art and entertainment sovernity from foreigners. to protect ourselves from psycho socio perception and to protect our psycho socio cultural deposites and original rooted unconsious development of our culture

[@sandeepshetty1589]

I do not think that the election will be about religion vs economy. I do not think that people who are unhappy about the state of the economy think that Congress will do a better job in that regard. The election may be about religion vs democracy.

[@keshavchinna9602]

Sir bjp will get 411seats Congress alone will get below 50 seats

[@realplusimaginary244]

Sorry but of late I have started to suspect the real motives of this professor after being a regular visitor here.

[@abhishekkumartiwari5191]

Sir this year election will be very tight definitely congress performance will better for sure. Sir Rahul gandhi has done tremendous work by doing bharat jodo yatra some policies of him is not correct in my sense but Rahul gandhi has improved alot and we wish him best of luck for this election

[@shrikantpalekar6529]

People are really worried about environment. Modi's agenda for development is at a cost of environment, which people do not like.

[@gokul1255]

The basic flaw in your argument is you are thinking economy and religion are independent. They are not. There's clear overlap in both people happy about ram mandir and concerned about inflation. Question for the voter is who is best fit to solve the problems and deliver on promises.

[@chakradharmahapatra1958]

You are doing a show on Indian elections, but don't know the number of Indian voters. It’s 968 million, not vaguely saying over 920 million.

[@saurabhdharmadhikari4874]

Is it not possible that Ram Mandir is bored because the issue was at last settled. Not about religion. I know many who just wanted it to be resolved, it has been dragged for a very long time.

[@cossack9588]

There is no heaven or hell below. Jai Hind.

[@pinakidash2730]

A country with 80% Hindu population. Why shouldn't Hindu issues be an election issue? Where else should it be an issue, Pakistan, USA?

[@vinaypathak5980]

Thanks khan sir,please hindi me bhi kijie.

[@drawingwithaditisingh1556]

Prof I had written earlier. Bjp muslim will.vote for tham Not ur age group U r generation is in haye group type

[@propertyforsale-sj6bp]

You need to reeducate yourself on democracy in general and Indian democracy in particular We understand in Pakistan you have little opportunity to learn

[@ProfMuqtedarKhan]

I am a professor in USA. Your hate is blinding you.

[@abhishekkumartiwari5191]

Sir Ram mandir is important but not only Ram mandir is something that can make public going to cast their votes for bjp

[@valvirchauhan6127]

We are Indians. Irrespective of our faith. We will vote who ever and for whatever reasons. It’s none of the business of those who surrendered citizenship. Stop influencing our elections. We know islamists , western countries and their agendas. You are not different either.

[@Harsh-ci8cd]

sab westernization and social media ki galti h

[@Sameer-er3wz]

12:13 It is a wrong conclusion. Inflation is not the only measure of performance of economy. Also Inflation has been controlled pretty well. Also, problems and challenges will always exist. We have to choose who is the best person to address the problems.

[@Harsh-ci8cd]

bjp keeps the westernized upper class people out of power thats the best thing for me, this kind of people self image should dissolve and no more like such should be made

[@sforme3344]

I'm minority we want BJP. BJP develop our country, respect, infrastructure. GDP. Jai BJP

[@qazianeesuddin930]

Hard to believe about your sense.

[@RajKumar-bq9hb]

​@@qazianeesuddin930Namakharam never belives reality They believe earth is flat😅

[@HaryanaGaushala]

एक बुद्ध पुरुष को मुस्लिम देशों में प्रवेश करना बहुत मुश्किल है - लगभग असंभव है, क्योंकि वे अभी भी असभ्य हैं। सभ्यता कहीं भी नहीं हुई है, लेकिन ऐसे देश हैं जो थोड़ा कम असभ्य हैं और ऐसे देश हैं जो अधिक असभ्य हैं। सभ्यता अभी भी होने की प्रतीक्षा कर रही है। यह आपके लिए होने की प्रतीक्षा कर रहा है: आपको सभ्यता के झुंड बनने हैं। लेकिन मुस्लिम देश समकालीन भी नहीं हैं। वे मोहम्मद के समय से एक इंच भी आगे नहीं बढ़े हैं। चौदह शताब्दियाँ बीत चुकी हैं और वे अभी भी सोच रहे हैं कि कुरान पवित्र पुस्तक है। शेरियत पुस्तक में निन्यानबे प्रतिशत सिर्फ बकवास है। एक प्रतिशत आप कुछ आध्यात्मिक अर्थ देने का प्रबंधन कर सकते हैं, बड़े प्रयास के साथ, अन्यथा इसका कोई महत्व नहीं है। मोहम्मद कुरान के प्रति वफादार रहे हैं। वे किसी की सुनने को भी तैयार नहीं हैं। मोहम्मद तर्क नहीं जानते। वे कोई दर्शन नहीं जानते। उनका एकमात्र तर्क तलवार है। या तो उन्हें मार दो, या उनके द्वारा मारे जाओ। जो भी मारा गया वह गलत था। यह अजीब है। सुकरात को मारना बहुत आसान है। मुहम्मद अली जैसा कोई भी मूर्ख सुकरात को बिना किसी कठिनाई के मार सकता है। सुकरात पहलवान नहीं है, वह मुक्केबाज नहीं । भारत में बहुत मुस्लिमो राजनेतिक , सामाजिक , धार्मिक , शेक्षेणिक सम्मान देकर देख लिया । वो सभी जेहाद छोड़ने को तयार नही 😂😂

[@RajKumar-bq9hb]

Satya vachan❤

[@star2trek9]

T

[@ashishtrivedi8253]

V sad analysis.... speechless...

[@nifty50hand]

Pm Modi's another bogus interview to ANI and Asianet....Khan sahab....more bogus interview are in pipeline.... what's is your view please share....

[@ProfMuqtedarKhan]

The ANI was interesting only because of the ownership that Modi took of the Electoral Bonds and his threat against those who opposed it.

[@mbsingh4597]

Dr. You are going to be disappointed on the June 4th. So keep the scotch ready to lift the mood. BJP will get around 325-335 seats and NDA around 360-370

[@rahulreddy1799]

This guy is extremely biased and of course ignorant.

[@nileshpatil5001]

Sir Congress manifesto is a economic disaster

[@RajKumar-bq9hb]

Its not a manifesto but more of it MOMINFESTO

[@raviprakashbajpai196]

Those 32% will also won't vote to BJP.

[@dhairyasheeljadhav5144]

U r labsa

[@Humanslovedjknnn]

Islamist khan 😂😂😂😂😂 if u read hindu and other leftist news then ur are far from ground reality.

[@alamsheikh7839]

BJP is known as Central Election Machinary. After 2024 Election End of Oppositions 😔

[@hukmukanin5076]

Fula lusi

[@Suryanarayana-mx8mh]

The conclusion more or less accords with the situation on the ground. BJP will do better but not much better.

[@pranayakumarpurohit3925]

You are totally out of ground realities dear. God knows from where you get the survey data.

[@Pyasa.shaitan]

You have any authentic source, we can trust?

[@RajKumar-bq9hb]

Musalman he no matter how much educated , he built false narrative every time

[@user-ys2wc3on9n]

Bhai kl voting percentage bahut km hua hai please go and vote for bjp warna pachtaoge 😢

[@hatmc8507]

For winning election you need people on booth who can bring people out of theirs home and get theirs votes. I have worked on booth level

[@benigopalbang1463]

Sorry to say you are so anti BJP, that the long pending issue of India resolved is only related to Hindus

[@ravikumar-fh8ow]

CSDS is bias against BJP. C voter also somehow biased.

[@Hawkkkk2023]

Ek simple sa sawal, dunia ke kis kone main muslims are statisfied and are not seen as a challenge to local ppl??

[@ProfMuqtedarKhan]

In 55 countries. More than 25% of the world is Muslim and that share is enlarging day by day. In fact you can say that in Akhand Bharat there are Muslims who are not a challenge to local people in Pakistan, Bangladesh, Afghanistan and Maldives.

[@scvijay]

Good for RaGa to spend much undue footage on him. Most people in India dismiss him as the national Pappu

[@Hawkkkk2023]

I just wonder who are those 27% who see a leader in Raga, a person who is not able to speak, a person who does know anything about any topic, he takes days to mug up something and then keep repeating it daily 10 times for months.....he cant even speak a single word without making mistakes ....

[@DrDang540]

Bharatvarsha must follow Israel model. All Muslims of Bharat must be forced to leave .

[@ProfMuqtedarKhan]

This is true Hindutva values (hate) coming to the surface.

[@DrDang540]

@@ProfMuqtedarKhan Absolutely ! Last time I checked it was your peacefuls who had Bharatvarsha split into three countries. The Hindu population in East/ West Pakistan was reduced from 19% to less than 0.5%. Truth bites, does it not??? That is the real reason why you are deleting my comments.

[@Landofcorruption123]

I'm a Christian and I don't support bjp... Rahul is best he can bring people together in one roof. I hate one religion one nation phobia 😅

[@RajKumar-bq9hb]

So you can also hate pakistan & Israe ?

[@Landofcorruption123]

@@RajKumar-bq9hb Israel is a peaceful place unlike Pak n India. 🐽