Sir, I find your comments quite reasonable, but in this case, I believe you are quite mistaken. Let us be clear about one thing. Pakistan has illegally occupied a portion of Jammu & Kashmir since 1948. It is India's right to take back control over PoK. I also notice that you have not spoken about the Hindu Kashmiri pandits being ejected from their homeland. Maybe you should reconsider comparing India with Russia and China.

Always great to hear u sir

It's interesting in the sense that in your commentary, one can see your negative baisness for India coz it's run by Hindus😮

13 th May

For us you are abrahamic idialogy. Islam, Iran and Israel are in sright line

Indian (BJP) politicians saying that they want to capture POk is just election rhetoric. it’s not based on reality and indian politicians themselves know it. so India would never try to conquer POK. I think Dr. Khan is making a bigger deal out of it

Sir I think this issue must have discussed beforehand with USA. If not then also USA should support this because it will help to counter increasing Chinese influence in the region. If USA want to take help of India to counter China then it should not hinder India's growing interests. This is the immediate neighborhood of India, so USA should India handle this matter .

In my opinion the nation state paradigm will change with change in global power with that the most vulnerable status will be of people who are following peaceful religion.

99 percent population in Azad Kashmir is Muslim. They all either want to merge with Pakistan. Some of them want to have an Independent Kashmir comprising of IOK (Indian occupied Kashmir) and the Gilgit Baltistan. China has already worked on CPEC through Gilgit Balitstan and by 2028, the CPEC will be operational which is already operational by the way. The Gaward port is already active and the only things that remains is the building of motorways that will connect China with Gawadar. Any attempt to attack on Azad Kashmir will result in a pro longed war like Afghanistan which may result in disintegration of India into more pieces. India is already stuck in IOK with over 0.7 million army depoloyed. Even If India try to capture Kashmir , it will result in nothing for India. This Old Uncle does not know what is happening in Ukraine. The damage Russia has taken is beyond recovery. What happened in Afghanistan is in front of every body. It is very obvious that India will attack Pakistan in coming future possibly between 2026-2030. Let it happen and then see what this Uncle has to say then. By the way, this Uncle does not talk about a new country which is about to merge on Map of the world that is Khalistan. The referrendum is already taking place all over the world. Sooner, It will yield some results.

Khab sab completely confused and unable to decide on which side he must give biased view!

This man is trying to show India as an expansionist country. Creating a rift between friendly neighbors of India, like Bangladesh. He is a basxxrd

In INDIA as of now *nobody isn't interested nor discuss or talk about AKHAND BHARAT* or do they have any kind of agenda. INDIA'S need of POK & GB belongs to INDIA That's our agenda, dream & wish.❤🇮🇳

Indian land size increased when Sikkim joined India. India also gave up some land to settle the border with Bangladesh. So border changes were happening. BJP is not actually interested in POK as this will increase radical people size. India is already suffering from remnants of PFI, IM SIMI. Some report says that Muslim size in India is over 17%, If this crosses 40% then India will become like another Pakistan. The ideology of most Indian Muslim and Pakistan's are same.

Dr Khan very realistic analysis though as a Indian I would like POK to become part of India but still your analysis looks pretty correct in modern days but in future things can always change.

Dr. Saab u will c it will happen very soon. It reflects Pakistani🇵🇰 dard in your words. But nobody else either China nor America will dare to protect Pakistan🇵🇰 because i will tell you neither Chinese🇨🇳 nor Americans🇺🇸 are safe from terrorised country Pakistan🇵🇰. And don't forget this is new bharat. And more than 100 crore population behind Modiji. Don't give us threat of this 2 country's We dont care who is China, America . They will never dump their economy by taking punga with modijis BHARAT.

Islam teaches them deception and treachery .

The two nation theory was probably the only political truth spoken in the Indian subcontinent in the past century. There's no compatibility between muslims and Hindus. Your sympathies lied with Pakistan and you despise Bharat and the Hindu civilization. India should find some solution to this muslim problem or time and necessities would impose their own crimson remedies .

India should not take military initiative to take back PoK, but I disagree with reasons provided by Mr Khan. First of all US is last country to have any principles such as opposing aggression. Secondly, the UN resolutions on Kashmir are non-binding and Pakistan is in continuous violation of them by not withdrawing all its forces to pave the way for so called plebiscite. What has UN done to Pakistan?? Why all rules are for India only. The situation in Manipur is completely different, it is a 3 way conflict between two major tribes and those coming from outside. It is not between Hindus and Christians. It is not divided between 2 different countries unlike Kashmir. Overall an average analysis.

*Akhand Bharat is real possibility if China* attempts to wage war on Taiwan and gets into a conflict with US & it's Indo-Pacific partners AUKUS and SQUAD! In than scenario... China will disintegrate and US will be drained out. Pakistan will also disintegrate along with China - its Iron brother. That will give *Easy-Peasy Picking opportunities for India and Russia.*

Abhi kacche hap geopolitics. E Mr. M

It was interesting but you compare Kashmir with Ukrain, Taiwan etc . Did any of these states sign instrument of accession? Were they formally and legally joined like Kashmir did ? I think you went overboard to compare Kashmir with the situation in other countries…

👍🙏🙏🙏

Abki bar 400 par!! POK and G&B will be part of Bharat

"Changing world order" not "collapsing world order". You need to change you spectacles khan.

But sir pok was the part of india and they had took it from us pok did not belong to Pakistan

Kashmir will never be a free country. Even if it will be, it will be like Syria between India, Pakistan and China. It is best for It to join either India, Pakistan or China. Best for them would be to join India to enjoy democracy and more freedom than the other two.

शरीया लाओ, देश बचाव

Sir I had thought someone as educated as you to be different, but you are the typical Indian muslim, placing religion above humanity and nationalism.

Kya bakwas hai.. What about those 800 usa bases And balochistan mai aag kaun laga hai .

India doesnt claim any akand bharat as a country, its a geographical identity otherwise refwrred to as the indian subcontinent. Some Hindu suprimist megalaniacs may harbour such fantasies just the same as islamist fanatics dream about a islamic world order .

Your analysis is ill-conceived about PoK. It seems you don't want India to claim its own territory. Why USA and China will attack India to save Pakistan? In fact you tried to prove that whatever Amit Shah said about PoK was a bluff to garner votes of hardliners. If you have already reached on that conclusion, there was no point in building logics.

Sir if ukrain tries to regain its territory lost to russia , will u call it expantion

Pok statement is an election rhetoric and nothing more !! The cultural and economic risks of annexing POK are too high and India wont fo it. However good chance that Pak will fragment by itself.

Professor, you lost your mind. You call India Irredentist!

Israel is right way

You are Pakistani lover

How about Gazwa hind

India is not interested in expanding its borders...It only wants back POK -GB which is legally an integral part of India...!!For God's sake nobody in India wants the garbage country in our west border...Akhand Bharat is more of a cultural concept which acknowledges the fact the people living in Indian subcontinent have a common cultural heritage...!! The materialistic West will never understand the Indian cultural values...!!

How come you don't want to talk about china occupying Manchuria, Tibet, mangolia and east Turkmenistan?

The only difference between the fight Argentina has with Uk and the fight that India HAD with Portugal is that we reclaimed our land long back. But to now say that all borders are settled and anyone seeking a change to borders is an irredentist is hypocrisy. UK has no right to the Malvinas.

Mr khan I can understand why it’s difficult for you to understand view of BJP as a Muslim, anti Hindu American propaganda agent 😂

Pakistan is going to implode into 4 pieces. Why are you so surprised about this , professor sahab ? This is not only imperative but absolutely necessary for the benefit of the human race. Bangladesh economy is solely driven through the largesse of the Indian government. They can be managed any day..isn't that geo politics ? ..very disappointing to hear a very religiously biased view on PoK.

Dear sir , it would be interesting to look into reasons why India did not offer now Bangladesh to merge with India after 1971.

India is not expanding into POK. Pakistan has illegally occupied our territory. Mr Khan please first think like Indian first and then like a Muslim. India is secular because it is a Hindu majority country. Can you show me a secular Muslim majority country. Indian Muslim community should become secular first and put their country first if they expect the Hindu's to follow the secularism. You are living in a secular country and all muslims want to run to secular countries because they feel strangulated in their own country. Show some patriotism.

Had India wanted, she could have gobbled up Bangladesh after defeating Pakistan. But strangely you guys never accept this remarkable character of India of helping it's neighbours. And strangely you guys never mention China's annexation of Tibet for reasons best known to you.

US doesn’t care about consistency of arguments. All they care about is their interests. Which is why they seem so hypocritical. Eg. Israel and Russia

Some bustards are so involved in defaming India. Government must stop giving visas to these so called intellectuals

In our puran it is said there will be 6 fronts upto April 2025 ,2 or say 3 fronts have opened 3 more will be चीन ताइवान, रूस जापान, भारत -चीन पाकिस्तान । we already know it

China wants to change the order as the current order makes sure that the commanding heights of finance and technology remains with the west and if China is to be allowed to compete fairly then the current order would not allow it to compete fairly.

You geopolitical analysts is so poor, due to your so short view. 1. Before 2014 no one can even think that 370 can be abrogate , but very soon you will see UCC in india also . What you says on it ? 2. POK is a legal part on india as according to instruments of acsation of J&k which is illegally controlled by Pakistan . It is also accepted by all nation that it is by lateral matter between india and Pakistan 3. You are well known that where is Islam there are no democracy due to Islam religious thought even in Turkey, they just . POK people like democracy because they feel themselves as Indian .