CSE Prelims 2020 - Polity Discussion (Set B) By Shubhra Ranjan

[@geetbehera3593]

In Q 29, it is asking about MLA, so even if we consider the indirect relation that eligibile to vote as a criteria for being an MLA, he needs to be registered as a voter and also for MLA/MLC he needs to be registered as a voter in the same State & NOT any other state. Hence this also gives the answer as D

[@shubhamshukla8067]

Question 26 - D is also correct ma'am , please check this .

[@vikaspriyadarshi751]

How nicely u teach ma'am ...i never got a teacher in my upsc struggling life ...if i take coaching from u i qualified upsc...my all polity questions and history are correct.

[@kumarg8432]

Mam,Q.26: the option might be D....bcz preamble has no legal effect independently alone but,has effect when it is supported by other parts Eg: secularism, federalism... which has its legal effect when it is supported by Right to all religion,dpsp, schedule 7 etc....

[@shubhraranjan]

Secularism, federalism comes from legally enforciable part like fundamental part and Center State relations. Option D is irrelevant. Look answer from Supreme Court judgement.

[@anjanapu530]

You were right!

[@satyamagrahari5898]

Mam,the way u r teaching is really outstanding, million of student usually watch daily motivational videos for balancing of mind refreshment, but I think if anyone can watch your any videos regarding any topic , after that they will not require any motivational videos...

[@kch2810]

Madam is right…the Qs were quite easy comparing to previous years. The only Qs I find difficult was the Legal Service Authorities one.

[@shaurav8008]

mam most questions came from your class, you had discussed those topics, I was thanking you during exam itself.

[@anonymous_channel]

Mam i think the answer for the judicial reviee question is none of the above, because in the option its given " to preserve the ideals on which contn is based" N in what i understand the art 32 and 13 is given to preserve the FRs only.

[@rajatsharma7654]

Mam you are my favourite teacher of all time.🤗🤗🤗🤗

[@paoboisitlhou701]

Is eligible to vote is 18yrs,but for mos is years necessarily 25yrs

[@rameshpalsingh4628]

This is first time I m listening to u so soft tone ......encouraging thanks

[@manishsingh-uh2dz]

Nice explanation madam ji Isi prakar guidence dete rahiye

[@christych6245]

Beautiful Lecture !!! Thank You So Much Ma'am

[@shubhsandhu5829]

I have got all correct of polity but still scored only 88

[@amritsandhu9135]

Mam u r amazing....hats off to the way u explain things

[@RealMDHarish]

28:50 question 39 even I assume it is option 1!

[@PRESIDENT0991]

Ques No. 29, Statement 1 - Related to recently happened with CM Uddhav Thackeray. I think Ans : a is correct option. except option "d". Please advice.

[@harshvardhansinghsolanki1963]

Mam in Q3 you say all fundamental rights are not part of basic structure ?? Q4 preamble have legal effect when read it with other provisions of constitution??

[@walkcycledrive7995]

If there is any doubt in interpreting the provisions of the Constitution, then preamble can help in that. This was said by supreme Court. Directly given in lakshmikant book

[@Rockymy_pet]

Q 26 ans is D

[@hemantpawar11]

Precisely explained. Thank you very much Mam

[@vishaltomar9831]

2:51

[@shameel5037]

Very simple to understant your teaching style thanks mam

[@shubhammundhra5113]

but didn't gandhi had ideal of trusteeship that wanted end of private property . marx also said that private property leads to exploitation. on the other hand gandhiji in his letters to JLN said that state should not be separated from religion.

[@PrashantKumar-mt9qz]

Ma'am is a true inspiration. Tons of regards for you Ma'am.

[@Dark.eveything]

Q26 answer will be d...What legal effect it has wtout other independently?

[@shubhraranjan]

Secularism, federalism comes from legally enforciable part like fundamental part and Center State relations. Option D is irrelevant. Look answer from Supreme Court judgement.

[@pranjalmishra2651]

Answer is D , UPSC official answer key is out

[@upscaspirants6435]

Thank you so much wholeheartedly!!!

[@akhiltej4604]

Thank you Mrs Shubha Ranjan for UPSC CSE 2020 prelims GS-1 paper analysis 💎

[@anjaneyulukollipara699]

Good English language explanation...thank you ranjan garu...jai Hindh

[@ManishKumar-ss5es]

Thanks mem for these guidlines....

[@Naik972]

Explain about the topics mam

[@pawanchaudhary1664]

Best teacher of polity🙏🙏

[@Rockymy_pet]

Constitution does not provide for judicial review So ques 23 and is D

[@darpanarjun6951]

Q28 about DPSP - statement 2nd says- they shall not enforceable by " any" court. They are enforceable in the " court of people_

[@anupsaraf786]

Good advice, paper is past now so look forward

[@adityakodi7399]

Good encourage ma'am

[@kumarsumit8096]

Thanku madam

[@sachinsinghadhikari8762]

question 24 is wrong i suppose. here is a excerpt from young india, july 2 1931. focus on last line To me political power is not an end but one of the means of enabling people to better their condition in every department of life. Political power means capacity to regulate national life through national representatives. If national life becomes so perfect as to become self-regulated, no representation becomes necessary. There is then a state of enlightened anarchy. In such a State everyone is his own master. He rules himself in such a manner that he is never a hindrance to his neighbour. In the ideal State, therefore, there is no political power because there is no State. But the ideal is never fully realized in life. Hence the classical statement of Thoreau that the government is best which governs the least -is worthy of consideration.”

[@aajazgazur323]

Hope you are doing well madem.. Recently Keshvanand bharti passed away and there was an article in Indian express on other day which mentioned that FR's are part of basic structure..?

[@kirtesh4852]

In Qs 24. What does 'Economic Determination' mean??

[@gauravmittal3943]

Mam you just looked at polity

[@priyagopu9888]

For q. 39 income ceilng varies for each state.. so 1st statement is wrong. See NALSA Faqs

[@praveshtiwari4440]

Ma'am question no 26

[@swaminathanps5078]

@shubhra ranjan ias Respected mam, thank you mam, request you to provide pdf mam

[@user-iq6wn8st6w]

Very nice guadiance mam .

[@chandrashekharkumar7300]

Great explanation mam

[@rohiniv9929]

Out of 20 questions nearly 8-10 are from samvidhan program of rstv

[@ranjithkumar4160]

Mam, Judicial review is implicitly present but there is no explicit provision by Constitution as such, whereas in question it asked "Constitution Provided"! Can you please clarify on this Mam! Thanks!

[@shubhraranjan]

Read the content of Article 13. It says that any law inconsistent will be void. Judicial review is implied in Article 13, 32, 131, 132, 133, 134, 136, 142 and so on. It is inherent in consitution, in US, it is declared by Judiciary.

[@Mayank24099]

Answer is D

[@05gopinaath]

Mam,regarding question 29:the non member becoming a minister ,the constitution by art 164{4},has no where mentioned the eligibility.only through import of articles ,the supreme court in B R Kapur case has verdicted that eligibility conditions like citizen of india and age 25,must be met even for non member.here the question is ACCORDING TO CONSTITUITON OF INDIA and NOT ACCORDING TO SUPREME COURT.please clarify . thak you

[@DeepakKumar-ro4vt]

Madam is bit confusing while changing slide of questions because its answer framing techniques

[@Bharati_0]

Thankyou verry much mam🥰...Literally Thanks😇

[@aryanmeena1434]

Ma'am ques 26 in UPSC's official answer key its Option D , please explain it.

[@onlinestudy9797]

Is your course available for hindi medium students??plzz reply 🙏

[@anupsaraf786]

best teacher of India for political science

[@143MAK]

Mam PS&IR for 2021 ur note is published or not? where we found it

[@rinkisahani3015]

ma'am u should upload your videos I love your video plz

[@rameshpalsingh4628]

Madam pls tell us how to deal with mains in such a meagre time pls

[@NITISHKUMAR-xi5zw]

I like polity thankyou Ma'am

[@sahanabr4458]

But mam, as per upsc answer key,for the question on judicial review the option is d) neither 1 nor 2 and not b.

[@mudassirtak5625]

Mam Rule of law is given by Dicey not by Aristotle

[@vritika2017]

🙏 Ma'am thank you

[@maheshsonawane1514]

Mam but only those are eligible to vote who are registered in electoral role of constituency...so indirectly it becomes right....

[@srishti626]

Mam plz tell about psir course

[@ankitamishra4875]

Thnk you so much Mam🙏

[@princesingh4553]

Mam questions 26 ka option d Correct hoga n

[@SachinGupta-cy8lc]

Mam, Does eligible to vote is just to mean a citizen of india?

[@ashoksekar8300]

Thanks Teacher 🙏

[@ankitsaxena6925]

Ma'am prelims & mains test series 2021 plz provide schedule

[@VickyKumar-yp7nz]

i perform good.

[@narayanbanagar6021]

Rule of law-AV Disey

[@Richaa24]

hello mam, how can i contact with u ... regarding the GS foundation course 2021 i tried calling the academy multiple times but couldn't connect over the phone. thankyou !

[@ayushchaturvedi6696]

you can watch mam's videos of polity

[@MSK-wn8co]

Thanks alot ma'am

[@riyasharma6887]

Thank u ma'am ❤️for discussing the paper 👍😋

[@dharmendrakumar-cx2gq]

Mam kya jo aspirants gress marke se pass hua hai kya bo ish exam ka liya eligible hai plz help me mam plz

[@shauryajain4851]

Mam easy Kaha tha😅😅

[@taniyakanwar1805]

23-D upsc answer key 26-D

[@Royal_Tungar]

Mam Which Book Prefer For Polity

[@Tom-bf6up]

You are great madam thank you

[@pavankumarvakulabharanam6717]

Ma'am isn't 1st and 2nd options contradictory in nalsa question, if all persons below 1 lakh income are eligible , then why transgenders have limit upto 2 lakh

[@himanshuyadav535]

It cover wider range so that more transgenders are included(if limit is 1lakh only then some will cover if you increase the limit some more will also included...jo 1or 2lakh k beech me h).

[@upscwithankitasingh5930]

Thanks a lot mam

[@anupsaraf786]

Excellent answer

[@shauryajain4851]

Mam when is the crash course starting? Plzz reply please🙏🙏🙏

[@rajeshbhadu3767]

Mam fees of psir crash course

[@suntzu8014]

Thank you mam❤️

[@shashankmishra1987]

In question no 30 if the parliament shall meet at least two times in an year then at least for 2 days is should meet. It has been not mentioned anywhere in option 3 that it has to be written in constitution. pls clear this

[@shauryajain4851]

Mam what about psir crash course Can anyone tell me 🙏🙏

[@yashpallandge8003]

I remember maam said "Gandhi's Ramrajya is Marx's Communism".

[@ammanannavelpula7644]

Provide download link mam plz

[@Tripti751]

Thanks a lot@mam❤❤❤❤

[@ThekingintheNorthhh]

From Official ans key...Judicial Review wale question ka Ans D

[@muhammednadirpt8781]

Thank you mam

[@FIGHTERUPSC12]

Mam pls hindi me bhi batch suru kijiye

[@nipunkrishna3387]

Hi Sir.This is my last attempt age wise and attempt wise.Will I get another chance kindly suggest me Sir

[@manishkryash]

Mam ofline optional polity ke liye classes kb se chalengi???

[@shubhraranjan]

Hi Masti Ka Panchnama, We are providing online classes because of the pandemic. Thankyou

[@nagarathnamreddy]

Super mam. Love u . Tq mam

[@geographylive9287]

For MPLADS que ,plz guide ... MP can donate the fund to disaster mgmt,but that doesnt create durable asset,but question mentions MUST word. For que about min no of days parliament required to meet,acc to constution,there should be Meeting once in six month.doesn't it states implicity that min two days meeting in a year ? Plz guide

[@abhi4917]

The preamble question can really be decisive,except Mam everyone has given D as right answer but I think Mam is right.

[@jananis5372]

Hi mam, I want to join PSIR Optional classes in your institute.will you provide offline classes?kindly reply.thank you mam

[@shubhraranjan]

Hii Janani, Offline classes are subject to government guidlines. We are providing online classes. PSIR batch will start from 4th jan 2021. Thankyou

[@bidhanmahato9695]

Madam I want to join your optional polity course.please inform me about this.

[@CooLMaN-zg2zw]

I have not appeared and i am getting 11 out of 20 here. should I prepare for 2021 seriously??