CSN 2012 Carry On/Questions

[@goodfoottoo]

I am 71 years young and saddened that David is no longer with us. Thank you, David, Stephen and Graham for the wonderful music you shared with us since I was 17!! I’m grateful that I could see you in person many times during my life and will always remember your wonderful music.

[@frankdove5421]

Éternellement dans nos coeurs.

[@fredmoore8661]

I'm 80. We agree.

[@petertooth4538]

I am 73 and only saw the band live once--in the late 80s in Lincoln, Nebraska just after DC got out or rehab at what was thus a kind of joyous reunion for them all. What a fantastic concert they put on! And long! Amazing acoustics and sound! Up their with the greatest live musical events of my life!

[@harrywiebe]

I'm totally with you on that. I too am 71 and their music brings back so many memories. So sad to hear of David's passing. Their harmony was so unique and it belongs to only them. So memorable.

[@comegetsome6518]

67 here (2023) SOMEDAY MUSICAL TALENT WILL ONCE EMERGE AGAIN. TODAY'S AZZHOLES HAVE NO CLUE. ROCK ON 🎸 THE RIGHTEOUS

[@joeperrymk]

I am 17 years old and am proud to say that I know who these artist are and play their music! I will not give into the musical "oppression" of Pop and Rap and all others. I will always stay true!

[@Paltekko]

Kennedy for president....:-)

[@newworldlubbock]

Fight the good fight, my friend!

[@1thaleb]

Good for you young man. THIS is music

[@tixximmi1]

We're all 17. Some of us for the 45th time. Good music stays true. As Zappa would say, MITB. Music is the Best.

[@glennmiller1754]

Matteo Kennedy your wise beyond your age...

[@chanchan5349]

October 2024. Needed this so much. In WNC during the devastating floods, mudslides, you name it-it happened! Finally found a Starlink outdoors so I could connect.

[@rogerandsally]

R I P Brother David and GOD bless your wife and Loved ones. Thanks so much for the WONDERFUL music !

[@lasalamandraradio]

One of the greatest groups of all time.

[@thierryjulien572]

And then they were three ! RIP David always in my heart since I discover CSN&Y IN 4 WAY STREET live album. ❤

[@kevinmcgiffin10]

Damn these guys are great. Grew up with these dudes back in the early 70s WOOO GET IT STEPHEN !!! The harmony is god given and beautiful to the ears 😉🎶👏🎶👏🎶👏🎶👏🎶👏🎶👏❤❤❤❤❤✌

[@comegetsome6518]

I was 17 when this came out now 67. Ooh the memories of doing a bone and having my girl laying her head on my shoulder

[@Aristilus]

For what it's worth, I think Steven Stills is a fantastic guitar player.

[@Kawwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww]

Lol, I liked that one!

[@Michchamps]

Whats that sound?

[@timemachinefan]

There's something happening here.....

[@richardroof2638]

What it is ain't exactly clear...

[@georgedatum8132]

@@richardroof2638 Carry On

[@frankbillingiere8888]

i almost remember seeing these guys twice!

[@bctruck]

I’m told I went to a Pink Floyd concert in 78.

[@computeraddic2410]

This is a very good live version of that lovely old song!

[@warrengboca]

Released in 1970. Great back then . Great 45 years later in 2015. Time goes on but you have to Carry On. yes!!!

[@christinesmall9180]

Great to see Stephen Stills looking so well. I Love these guys & their music and their politics :)

[@wolfedavid3700]

not much on their politics...................i was there in 60s.............yes NAM too...........remember jane fonda............traitor to all GIs............

[@garyhighley9022]

so many critics...and most of you have no idea what it takes to be a good singer...these men are great singers even now!

[@gushutchinson8758]

I like it loose and clumpy. The feel is all .

[@larryhall2805]

Well, I'm a big fan of these guys, too. But why all the extra Bob, Dick & Harrys on stage. Some of the harmonies were good, some were poor. Pardon me, I noticed.

[@larrywhite2574]

I agree, Stills solo is great.

[@timemachinefan]

Awww man, luv their harmony.. Just beautiful!

[@charlesgorman9830]

My older brother turned me onto this band in 1973 when I was in 7th grade. I knew that I was way ahead of my friends musically at that point. Got into the Band and The Dead right after that. Never looked back. I was hooked on Classic Rock and Roll.

[@danthemanful59]

Me to Charles, right on !!!

[@niceassinspector]

Charles Gorman thinkni was in the 1st i heard these guys all my life , and knew their name ,

[@veronicalake2751]

Charles Gorman : My Parents were Hippies & this Music is part of my life & Always will Be.! It’s Real Music & Hard to Find good music like this Today.!!! Life was Real Then.! Now, today People go around & have no idea what life is.??? They all Lost The Lord God & Have No Idea what’s Wrong.??? ☹️ 😢

[@muttlee1213]

Steven's guitar playing is so underrated! He's fabulous!

[@gerardoorcullo6655]

I think Stephen Stills you mean sir.

[@massimogaraventa86]

I do not think he is underrated, he has always been a great one. His fencing with Neil young, are unforgettable

[@donatodonati5947]

but his lead vocals are so bad

[@jakealexis9032]

Sorry to be so offtopic but does any of you know of a trick to log back into an instagram account?? I was stupid forgot the account password. I would appreciate any help you can give me.

[@kylocallum3739]

@Jake Alexis Instablaster ;)

[@timmyt603]

Stills has a voice that never changes. Although it's a little different from back in the day, hearing this without video anyone who knew his voice could still pick him out.

[@timmyt603]

On that same note, Graham has always been my favorite of the three but seeing Stills step up to tear it up was hawt. I can only imagine the success, the accomplishment, the pride that must run through these guys to know they still got it, still draw crowds, still fucking rock!

[@LeoraLaGraffe]

I really can’t think of any other vocalist whose voice I love more than his. Amazing singer, amazing guitar player, amazing songwriter, amazing human being. We are so lucky to have him on our planet.

[@OscarTheMaker]

Too bad about stills' hearing problems though. I still really enjoy this video, but his lisp throws me off sometimes.

[@sandrosaez8078]

They would be wonderful beyond life. Not complaints about their amazing armonías. I just listen those songs this year, after I heard about them in Peru by a friend of mine who brought a few LPs and cassettes from overseas when I was 12 years old. I didn’t pay enough attention and concentrate on British bands as Zeppelin or ELP, Yes. So, now…I love them more than any other band in the whole world! That legacy is unforgettable for all generations that appreciate real music and fabulous interpretation and lyrics.

[@mikeroark3639]

No matter... Greatness. Loved 'em ever since that night in 1974 at the old Cap Centre in Landover, Maryland... A lifetime of music from one of the voices of our generation.

[@debbieedwards711]

Perfection!!! S. Stills is an amazing guitar player. I still play this album all the time. Please get back together dudes.

[@larrywhite2574]

Stills has a way of turning his guitar that I call a Stills tune .

[@JamesJones-zt2yx]

A great song from a great group. The vocals kick serious posterior, and Stills is an incredible guitarist.

[@darrellhambley7245]

10 years ago, I saw that tour. Favorite band ever.

[@yetivanmarshall1473]

Rip David. Thx for the music.

[@keithhelton3178]

Great music for many years....RIP Mr. Crosby...carry on, sir....

[@zbigniewkosior2517]

Some of the best times partying and dancing to their awesome music ,forever in my soul,rock on !!!!

[@elmagodelmaryahoo]

What a STILL _“groovy”_ Live Performance… with CSN now in their mid-to-late *70s!!!* And with lyrics so very relative after *50+ Years* ....!!! The Fortunes of Fables are able To sing the song Now witness the quickness with which We get along To sing the blues *you've got to* live the Dues And Carry On.

[@gwynenglishnielsen8596]

Great tune. I saw CSN twice in concert. Both times, they were amazing.

[@danilofausto3134]

Thank you for your music on GS PROM. 1976.❤️

[@gc4917]

God, i love these three old men so damn much. Carry on!

[@alainpaum]

This guitar of Stephen stills is fantastic ! It is the trade mark of the band and of course those voices !

[@sarapinsky315]

This is such a lovely song. I do think this live version is better than the ones I've heard from 1974.

[@georgejeffries3566]

Steve Stills plays with such feeling. Im really impressed.

[@dkjazzz]

No a offense but, I hate when people say underrated 😡. He’s not underrated! He may be under appreciated, but nobody who plays or appreciates guitar would under rate Steven Stills .

[@debberube8726]

Still great. They are legends!

[@danddstorytime232]

I paid $400 to take my kids to see the 2012. Concert in Erie, PA. They are my band and symbolize my teenage years and beyond. I would go see them even if they just stood there and played a tape and pretended to sing. I would love to have a weenie roast with guitars and them and me singing. What I would give. No autographs. Just fun singing for the pleasure of it. Best music ever. Maybe in heaven.

[@theduke3919]

I had the pleasure of seeing these guys open for Tom Petty the year before! I think I was 23? at the time. Great memories from that show!

[@miyubail]

They were so so good!!! I grew up with their music. I'm 61.

[@joeflip2993]

8 folks don't like this? prayers to those folks. they need it

[@worldspacechina]

Amen

[@wesmahan4757]

They live in their parent's basement. Ignore them.

[@4evernate28]

It’s possible they don’t like it because of the key drop. Lord knows I can’t listen to Phil Collins do ANYTHING live…

[@carlgibbons5777]

@@wesmahan4757 Crosby, Stills, Nash, and Young are Democrats so your "right wing" typical insult doesn't hit like you think it does. lmao!

[@carlgibbons5777]

Last time I checked, music is subjective and nobody needs your prayers. You like to pray, have at it. Don't push your agenda on others.

[@DaveM1260]

My favorite song when it came out. And "Carry On" was, coincidentally, the official motto of our high school graduating class at Reseda High in 1971.

[@margiemurdock6871]

Reseda 1971, you say? You played for the LA city championship in high school basketball that year, and you lost to my high school. Do you remember that?I was the school district chess champion that year.

[@michaelcrowson3174]

Music was great between 1955, pre chuck berry, then elvis till Michael Jackson. Period.50s, 60, 70s, 83.

[@davidmckenzie420]

@@margiemurdock6871 Yes, we had Greg Lee, City Player of the year. He went on to be Bill Walton's teammate and roommate in College. Chess camp, huh? That's great. My current hobby is woodworking, and I have made several chess boards.

[@margiemurdock6871]

@@davidmckenzie420 I remember Greg Lee, he went on to marry our head cheerleader, Lisa P. The Bruins haven't rewarded us with a title since 1995.

[@loudseywillingham5522]

Saw them in Aug. 2014.10 years ago already!! They were fabulous!!!

[@chrisshenzo2594]

Massive talent and a great tune delivered in a most perplexing manner.

[@williambutterfield7551]

Buffalo Springfield NAILED it with Stills lead singing about what we were going through in the late 60s😎

[@dadisaliveandwell]

I love these guys and consider them The best American band ever--because it's not just good guitar licks or catchy tunes. It's the harmony, its the message in the lyrics. To me they are tops because they have been socially aware all my life, and pointed out evil along the way--and when I say American that includes Canada (Neil.) Fortunate to have lived in San Francisco and Mountain View CA near Shoreline --for years Neil did 2-3 days of benefit concerts for The Bridge School. Went to these almost every year. Always had greats play--Simon and Garfunkle even reunited for this cause. Fortunate to have met Steven and on another occasion, to party with the Cros. Thanks God.

[@dashound6457]

Crosby stills & nash are music the 3 of these men together are so special an amazing gift they are

[@ivangorowitz9729]

Great then; still great. Stephen Stills is amazing.

[@spencershidner2125]

I'll be seeing these guy on the 4th of July in Paris, France! Been listening to them before Woodstock. It will be too great!

[@jnorthr]

With class beyond that of mere mortals, these three rock Gods urge us to ‘Carry On’ !

[@medgasguy]

This is the best version I've heard of this song...Too bad Neil wasn't there. Stephen Stills guitar is phenomenal...And of course RIP David Crosby we will always miss you.

[@Ramesses52]

4 Way Street

[@sportsretrospective6759]

That famous California Sound of the 60s! Unforgettable!

[@danr5105]

It is "not just" that the music takes you to a time/place you enjoy,it is pure and certainly not simple, good music.

[@JMichaelCunningham]

Amen. I can listen to them play all day. It just hurts when they start to sing, I still have the vinyl, i still play the music on my 12-string, it is just hard to hear the decay of the years when they step up to the mic.

[@MaryAnnDaniell]

I think you are being too hard on them ....

[@whitneymacdonald4396]

Great version. Powerful.

[@davidmcclellan6958]

outstanding. amazing. one of a kind. never to be repeated.

[@jhankemeeyer1970]

This song got me through the deaths of too many friends

[@FaustoRamosLugoTheBeatleman]

One of my favorite bands in the world, it was hard to find this particular song live, thank you for postining

[@Chernobylgames]

no words, just amazing

[@SPAC3MANxSPL1FF]

The higher you get while listening, the more far out this song becomes.

[@danypotrel6728]

Carry on my favorite song. So good sound. Awesome atmosphere and wonderful memories. Rip DAVID GROSBY. grosby still Nash and young forever....Woods legend !!❤❤❤

[@danypotrel6728]

Woodstock legend........

[@ralfgroh2719]

One of the best - legendary!

[@samizi1]

STEPHAN STILLS SOLO AT 06:00 IS THE TRUTH OF LIFE!

[@baberbegone1085]

Thanks for this quality up of Classic American Rock! Like this !

[@Retroearthling]

HOLY F that guitar solo at the end! HOLY S!

[@markgigiel2722]

Still got it and Stephen was always underrated.

[@michaelcrowson3174]

Greatest trio ever. Beegees were great.

[@Gazpacho8]

Crosby and Nash still sound quite good for 70, Stills voice has suffered worse but he doesn't really need to prove anything at this point, still a guitar great.

[@davidperry7271]

He has gone deaf

[@juleocisar]

AMAZING, GREAT BAND, VERY GOOD VERSION !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@JS-zk2xb]

Truly a class apart!!! Love CSN!!!

[@60s70sVintageRock]

Saw them on this tour at Ravinia, outside Chicago... last time was mid-70's :)

[@franciscocalvo9371]

Elegant Stills riffs,,,

[@jeremyhoke8186]

Opening riffs always reminded me a little of "Cat's Squirrel".

[@jamesmackinlay4477]

Man what a incredible performance thanks for the upload.

[@ManiacalMusicFan]

They still sound fantastic.. awesome :)

[@sambassbo93]

Their harmony is unmatched

[@beingagainstfascismisagood104]

."Unmatched" you say???

[@chrisb587]

James Raymond keyboard right (Crosby's son), Shayne Fontaine (acoustic), Kevin Mccormick (bass), Steve Dislanislao (drums) - all from Crosby Nash band and Todd Caldwell (keyboard left)

[@dwalkmusick]

Yes, excellent band. AND using their voices, too: doubling all the CSN 3-part harmonies.

[@cherylgrec9701]

Great performance, true talent!

[@deeks145]

Incredible performance

[@paulstephenson5913]

RIP David. Let the good times roll

[@niceassinspector]

carry on love is coming to us all... Amen and Hallelujia !

[@andrewkrauth1966]

2nd favorite band of all time next to the Beatles. Nobody plays like Stephen Stills

[@gregoriocalderoni6392]

now that's a top 2 i can get behind!

[@fractuss]

@@gregoriocalderoni6392 He was a fine guitarist.

[@davidperry7271]

@@fractuss was?

[@fractuss]

@@davidperry7271 Correct, he was a fine player. And he is still pretty derned good.

[@caseynelson7355]

Same here!

[@rasafoodtruck9227]

Rest easy legend! David Crosby 🎸

[@shannonb9700]

Legendary!! Very Beautiful!! ✌

[@gilbertramos6039]

Great use of the 'Cat's Squirrel' riff throughout 'Carry On'.

[@hansschutijser9519]

Glorious old times

[@patrickb2127]

Love to see this with Neil Young. Sounds like they are playing the 80's remix , one of my favorite.

[@maratdamas]

A minha banda preferida de sempre, A 1ª vez que os ouvi..fez-se um click, que se mantém até hoje ligado! O que é impressionante, é que ainda me conseguem surpreender e emocionar! CS&N the Best!

[@charlesgorman9830]

Danny, I hope we aren't a dying breed. Rock on!

[@Milesthegamercool]

THIS IS ABSOLUTLEY THE MOST UNRATED ROCK SONG EVER

[@maurepalrenan]

LA MEJOR BANDA DE MI NIÑEZ, ADOLESCENCIA, JUVENTUD, ADULTEZ, ETC. TREMENDOS ROCKEROS.

[@mitchfelding2661]

And, they still shine...

[@Gazpacho8]

You should see Crosby sing "almost cut my hair," at the rock and roll hall of fame concert. He sounded really great.

[@terryblair966]

The greatest❤❤❤

[@michelgervais1874]

DAVID CROSBY R.I.P. WHERE ARE THE GOOD TIMES GONE....

[@giorgiobardi313]

fantastic!!!!!!!

[@michaelklein4005]

i saw them 3 years ago ;)

[@kadriyucel73]

Bu şarkıyı 50 yıldır dinlerim doyamadım,biz 68lileriz....... ne şanslıydık CSNY dinledik keep CARRY ON this dirty bad world

[@christopherraymond4826]

...funny thing about change...some things never...do...only the cord line, while harmony is exactly that... resonance of beauty...pure magic...

[@DavidSmith-to3zw]

Sounds better than ever

[@stevedrums1675]

Really, Dave?

[@DavidSmith-to3zw]

+stevedrums Yeah absolutely man. Stills gets to stretch out and almost double the length of the guitar solos. Jimi Hendrix wanted Stephen for his own band on the "Cry of Love / First Rays of the New Rising Sun" album. I love hearing one of my favorite guitar players kill it. These men are in their 70s and still kicking ass. Do you have some better opinion to offer?

[@mikeys6336]

Try to imagine CSN without David Crosby always punching that interesting harmony in the middle...flawlessly Anyone who cant see what a wonder he is needs to try and do what he does for a single day.

[@jtownshend]

Thanks for sharing!

[@fabiocopponi9586]

....hats off....

[@jesseclifford7365]

Nash’s voice carries the vocals.

[@dannymcrooster4089]

The 70s, golden time, then, the darkness arrived

[@happycanuck5080]

Nothing better....that's it.....nothing better.