CURL TALK VS CAKE: AFFORDABLE PRODUCT BATTLE! Side by Side 3-Day Test of Popular Curl Stylers

[@deandrajohnson1973]

I am so addicted to Cake styling products. I used the cream and mousse today and I really don’t need much of either. Then I went for a drive in the nice weather with the windows down and my curls look great!! Later after I was all dry I tried the Cake Hot Mess texture mousse that’s to be used on dry curls and it gave me more volume! I’m hooked!!!!

[@TheFitCurls]

YAAAAS GIRL!!! THIS IS CAKELAND!! 🍰💕

[@laurettatelles3139]

I found your video today and I've watched it. I also chose the cake side. I will be watching more of your videos as I'm 70, short hair below the ears, very dry thin. Hopefully I can learn some tricks from you. I'm actually headed to the store right now to find some of the cake products. Thank you!

[@chillykisses6574]

I used not your mothers products & I just couldn't keep up with it. My hair had zero shine on day 2 & 3 even after I refreshed it. I tried the cake line & it's a WINNER🎉 I can't live without their curl next door conditioner. It's great for cowashing & as a leave in. Their curl defining cream is also a winner. You definitely picked the right product line❤❤❤❤❤

[@kimberlytownsend5323]

Thank you so much for talking about Cake! It is the only product so far that creates a cast on my hair. I love it!!

[@TheFitCurls]

I’m so glad!! I absolutely adore their products so I’m happy to share!

[@taraelmegreen5527]

Thats good to hear as I JUST ordered this offline! Ty!!!

[@NoName-yc4ts]

You are the only one that talks about Cake that I follow and I love those results! I think I’ll have to try it because NYM is just not working for me!

[@TheFitCurls]

Cake has been flying under the radar and I want to change that!! Definitely give them a shot - they’re a terrific alternative to NYM 💕

[@robyngraul2987]

I use all the Cake products and absolutely love them! The curl cream makes great curls whether I use the Denman brush or not.

[@aoiharuko8237]

I started a modified CG method back in March and have stayed clear of silicones because that's what it recommended. However, I might give the Cake line a try bc I use a clarifying sulfate shampoo to get rid of build-up anyway. I use NYM Curl-talk and it doesn't really hold my waves. Like you, my hair falls out before the end of the day and it becomes frizzy the next morning. Though I have to mention I have 2a-2b waves and am still learning what products work for me haha. I'm not against silicones per-se just wary of them. Some are actually water soluble! Anyway, thanks for the comparison review! I now know about an alternative to curl-talk!

[@TheFitCurls]

Yay!! As long as you clarify every 3-5 washes, the silicone (singular, low amount) in the Cake cream won’t give you any issues :) good luck on your curl journey!!

[@lydiapearl1127]

This was so helpful! I have both Cake and Not Your Mother's but never thought to test them side by side. I agree Cake has a tighter hold. I love the NYM line because it is so light and fresh. Both have their merrits

[@TheFitCurls]

Glad this helped!! I find side-by-side comparisons show me things I never realized before 🙂

[@Declanzplayz]

I need to go to bed and can't stop watching your videos.. Learned so much... Buying cake

[@TheFitCurls]

I’m so glad you’re enjoying the videos!! And I hope you love the Cake products as much as I do :)

[@DexterTheDestroyer]

I bought Cake because of her, too! Lol

[@lauraguenot6856]

I am definitely a curly girl blessed with bouncy curly/waves and even more so with red hair. Unfortunately, my hair never stays curly more than one day. Even after trying so many different products and ways to take care of my hair, it is always a mess on day two. I try to calm it down with product or some mist but it just looks like I shook my head all over the place. I agree with Not Your Mother's products being that great. I used them and my hair got so frizzy. I definitely want to use the Cake Beauty products! I like that they are affordable!

[@joannwood2854]

Walgreens has Cake buy 1 get 1 50% off! I’m ordering now 💕 thank you 🙏 your hair seems similar to mine. I haven’t found anything I like since Devacurl

[@starryeyedgirl87]

SUPER helpful review!! I especially love how you did the day after, most reviews skip that part. Much appreciation and love coming your way, I think I'll give the Cake a shot!

[@lacybeam7121]

I ordered the cake curl cream and mousse today. So excited! I love your curls. 😍

[@TheFitCurls]

Yay! Thank you!

[@taraelmegreen5527]

Thanks sooo much for all your hard work! Before finding u I had NO idea and was totally frustrated!!! Shoulder length curly with some spirals, graying dry and not understanding what else to do!!! I appreciate u....keep up the good work!👩‍🦱

[@TheFitCurls]

Happy to help!

[@josiemendoza5974]

Tara, you just described me! Lol I have more gray on my right side and when it spirals with the rest of my hair, it looks awesome.

[@taraelmegreen5527]

@@josiemendoza5974 I love that!!!

[@jessicagalyon5840]

Just picked up cake cream & mousse on sale. I am low porosity but my hair loves certain proteins, low on list. I can’t do NYM cream anymore. Hope this one is ok! I’m usually ok w keratin or amino acids. But rice seems to sit on top of my hair making it brittle. Fingers crossed. I so love the bottles!

[@HSingMomto5Kids]

I have been using Curl Talk mousse pretty much for the last yr of my curly girl journey. I have really liked it but at the same time like when you mentioned day 2 hair that's exactly what happens to my hair too. I think I may end up switching from it to the Cake after this. I found your channel for trying to change my shampoo and conditioner and thinking about switching to cake. What do you use for your shampoo and conditioner? Thanks for this review.

[@sandranewman9963]

I had bought other products but when and bought the cake beauty my hair love it I saw 👀 a big difference yeah 👏👏😍

[@TheFitCurls]

Oh my gosh yayyyy!!! I’m so so glad! xx

[@taraelmegreen5527]

Yaaaaa......I actually took ALL my NYM back to Walmart...can't WAIT for my Cake order to arrive!

[@kathysmigen3927]

I have the same type of hair that you do but mine is colored ( gotta came those grays).I have found the same not so great results as you with the Not Your Mothers. I love your results with Cake and am anxious to get it and try it for myself.

[@TheFitCurls]

Mine is colored too! 😂 Cake is for sure my go-to brand no matter what so I hope it works for you too!!

[@Rebecca11287]

Do you like the cake shampoo and conditioner ?

[@outoftheklosset]

Bummed that Cake Beauty has aloe in it lol 😂 Question: how do you wash the silicone out? Do you need a sulfate shampoo tho?

[@TheFitCurls]

The silicone amount is so low that it doesn’t build up any faster than any other emollient! I use a sulfate-free shampoo and then clarify every 3-5 washes 😊

[@rebeccamay87]

Cake beauty is a winner for me

[@LarinaValarin]

I actually don't like the Curl Talk Cream. It seems to heavy for me, but using just the Mousse works well for me. I'd be curious to hear how you like it on it's own of in combination with other products. I am curious to try the cake though!

[@TheFitCurls]

I’ve used the Curl Talk Mousse in other combinations and had the same results - it looked good for a few minutes and then just fell flat and frizzy. It’s just not the product for me!

[@josiemendoza5974]

I feel like the Not Your Mother's Curl Talk cream is the one that makes my curls not hold up. If and when I apply it, I use very little. The mousse, I go to town with. Unfortunately, I do have frizz at my crown. So, I need to find a good oil to finish it all off. I just purchased the Cake Beauty mousse today and I'm very excited to try it out.

[@TheFitCurls]

I hope you love it!! And that’s an interesting thought about the cream vs the mousse. I’ve paired both with other products in different combinations since this and have realized that I just don’t like either one 😂

[@josiemendoza5974]

@@TheFitCurls I love your honesty! I do notice that I can actually feel the build up on day 3 with NYMC, I'm over it, but need to find a good replacement first. My wash day is tomorrow, I'll be trying the Cake beauty mousse. Thank you for your reply. I'm a new subscriber & enjoy your content.

[@briannaprieto3043]

@@josiemendoza5974 how did it work out??

[@josiemendoza5974]

@@briannaprieto3043I liked it a lot. I also purchased Cake curl cream at a later time and it is so silky. However, it is too silky for my thin hair so I have to use a tiny bit. My combo under $10 is the Cake curl cream, NYMC talk gel, with a thin layer of NYMC mousse.

[@briannaprieto3043]

@@josiemendoza5974 thank you!! I’ll be sure to check out the ones you recommended :)

[@disneyknitter9189]

If I understand, the NYM Curl Talk Cream is not CGM friendly. It threw off a lot of people because all other Curl Talk is CGM friendly, but the cream is not. It's got isoparffin, I believe was the ingredient. That said, I haven't tried Cake yet because it's not easily accessible to me. But I have tried NYM Curl Talk shampoo, conditioner and mousse and I felt like I had pseudo okay results for weeks, got better with adding Uncle Funkys Daughter Curly Magic (which if you havent tried that for your channel, I'd like to see you do that- maybe even a UFD vs Jessicurl curl stimulators) but then suddenly my hair went very sad, limp, stringy. I started using other things, and when I used even one product from the Curl Talk line, I have problems. So I think I've officially given up on it. It can be hard to tell on video but, would you describe your hair as fine and thin? If so, I'd start labeling your videos as that because I have fine, thin hair, definitely thinner than yours and finding a channel that is fine, thin, and specifically tries lightweight products and techniques to help with clumping, volume...very hard to find!

[@TheFitCurls]

OOOOH a new product battle idea! I am HERE for it, girl!!! I am a fine curly fo sho and will take that suggestion to heart ❤️ thanks for sharing your Curl Talk experience!!

[@calip08]

Will the silicone in the cake curl cream build up on hair?

[@debracook2012]

Can u tell me more about the oil at the end. Is it a cake product?

[@chillykisses6574]

Hi beautiful. You have gorgeous curls & I agree.... cake cake cake is the winner.

[@3bRanchMom]

Thank you for your videos. I have a knock off Denman brush, I’m wondering if there’s a difference between it and a Denman?

[@TheFitCurls]

Honestly? Yes. There is a difference. But without seeing the brushes side by side I can’t tell you what it is 🤣 I had a similar knock-off originally but the bristles and pad shape were different enough that I didn’t get the same results AT ALL. I always think it’s worth purchasing the real thing!

[@wendycrauwels5970]

First of all, wauw!! How do you dry detangle with the brush? Even with a pinapple sleep, my hear is tangled and I almost need to re-wet it completely :-(

[@TheFitCurls]

Aw, thanks!! 🥰 I find sleeping in a silk or satin bonnet helps fight the tangling A LOT. For dry detangling, especially for refresh purposes, I suggest going clump by clump from the ends to the roots, gently rotating the brush in the direction of your curl. It will help the clumps to reform and then you can add water/product/steam/all of the above :)

[@luvastandardbred8270]

Why do you use cream and mousse together? I usually use one or the other. 🤷

[@cowjuice7818]

can you show us the side on the cake more next time??

[@mrsds252]

Have to try and get some cake to try I’m in Ireland so not all products are readily available

[@TheFitCurls]

I hope you’re able to get your hands on them!!

[@Star-dj1kw]

Great Video 👍🏼

[@julianacesaro5150]

Cake beauty is the winner for sure

[@TheFitCurls]

Amen!!

[@saram1503]

I was seeing a lot of good things about NYM i was about to buy it bc Im trying to get back my natural curls that i didnt know they existed hhhh but now i will think about Cake products now TYSM❤️❤️ It really hard to choose 😂💔

[@TheFitCurls]

Congratulations on discovering your curls!!!! I hope you love Cake as much as I do 💕

[@mconstable9966]

Cake is the best tried both

[@TheFitCurls]

I (obviously) totally agree - I’m a Cake girl for life, especially after this experiment!

[@jessicagalyon5840]

NYM cream is non CGM approved btw :)

[@paytonjade1323]

looks like im adding cake products to the cart

[@TheFitCurls]

I hope you love them as much as I do! xx

[@SheilaSisco12]

Would it be possible to do a full plop? Or would that mess it up?

[@TheFitCurls]

You can absolutely do a full plop! I don’t because my fine curls on the bottom tend to get wonky if I do a full plop but if that works for you go for it!

[@SheilaSisco12]

@@TheFitCurls I'm more of a 2c wave and my hair goes to my waist... I've been plopping and it works, but I do think I'm going to give cake beauty a try!

[@prettylittleinvestor]

Why both the curl creme and mousse? I own the nym curl creme but was expecting mousse results - that obviously didn’t happen, but I didn’t know I could use both and why. Thanks!! 🙏🙏

[@TheFitCurls]

We have all been there, friend!! I always recommend layering your products - one for moisture and 1-2 for hold! That’s why I use both cream and mousse. The creams add and seal in moisture while the mousses add hold to help the style last for multiple days (or not for me where the NYM products are concerned 😂). I highly recommend trying both types of products together!

[@annaburns5382]

I tried cake mousse and cream on my hair and I got terrible results. It did not work for my very fine hair. I applied it and it looked great to start with but after it dried and I scrunched out the crunch, all my waves literally slid out of my hair. Within a few hours, my hair was limp! I was bummed. I actually only tried NYM mousse and I didn't like it. It felt as if there was a plastic coating on my hair. I hate that feeling. I never tried the cream. My hair is super fine and I have a hard time finding products that don't weigh it down, but give it light hold. Still looking.

[@TheFitCurls]

Thanks for sharing! Sorry to hear you had a poor experience with both brands 😭 if you’re experiencing your curls dropping like that frequently, especially with all sorts of different products, it might be time for a protein treatment!

[@annaburns5382]

@@TheFitCurls I have protein in most of my products and I do a protein mask every week! My hair is so, so fine and it frustrates me so much! So difficult. I have been told in the past by stylists that my hair is the most difficult they have ever worked with due to it's fineness. Products really weigh my hair down. ;-(

[@christinacolongne2951]

Try less moose on the curl talk side, less is more.

[@dreyddog19]

cake. by far

[@SoulfulSerenity-888]

IMO NYM is WAYYYYY over rated. It's because NYM is chasing and sponsoring literally EVERY single influencer who cut ties with Deva. I don't know why everyone can't see through that. These influencers don't even use NYM behind the scenes. If you watch their insta stories etc and look in the background....none of NYM products are in their showers or on their counters. I bought the entire line and it's just ehhhh. Not terrible but def not worth the hype at all. My hair feels greasy afterwards, the shampoo dries my hair, conditioner has no slip, the cream does nothing, the gel leaves white flakes everywhere. My hair doesn't last longer than 4 hours.

[@TheFitCurls]

I feel so much the same way! I was bummed that I didn’t have the same wonderful experience as my curl influencer friends, but I also am glad that I get to share my honest opinion so others with my experience can know they’re not alone!

[@sketcharts]

I agree with all this

[@valyusha98]

Girl same!! I bought some shampoo and conditioner from them and it dried the fuck out of my hair 😂 my mom used the gel and it frizzed out her hair too and when it was time to sotc it wasn’t soft or as defined as the Aussie instant freeze for example. I just bought the cake one lets hope it works!!! 😀

[@Nfriesen91]

The Not Your Mother's Curl Talk curl cream is not cgm approved it contains a wax that is not cgm approved

[@TheFitCurls]

Can you tell I don’t follow the CGM? 😂

[@Nfriesen91]

Ya that's fine. It was you said in the video that it is cgm approved

[@valenboby]

Not your mother's did not work for me and my curly friends 👎🏽. I want to try to cake

[@TheFitCurls]

I highly recommend Cake for people who wanted to love NYM but didn’t! And...well for everyone 😂

[@angiect3791]

Neither look as good as your normal routines I have seen on you.

[@TheFitCurls]

It’s that middle part, man 🤣