CW of MA v. Karen Read Trial - Day XV

A short day but one that is sure to be eventful as Commonwealth witness Jen McCabe is one the stand awaiting cross examination by defense attorney Alan Jackson. Join @theshamingofJay and I as we invite back our special guest, Joshua Ritter, Skilled attorney and host of the hot new YT channel Courtroom Confidential! Josh has amazing insights and worked with Jackson for years to boot! Combine all of this with the fact that we have the best chat in the Tubes and its appointment streaming!
#KarenRead #KareReadTrial #JusticeForJohnOKeefe #Lawyer #LawTube #Defenses Diaries
Link to Joshua's new KZbin Channel: / @crconfidential

[@debrannanderson7657]

I’m an honest person blew my mind. Really, I don’t think you’re honest at all Jen. Liar, Liar, Liar!!!!!

[@emmy2417]

i don’t know what happened to john o’keefe, but now i’m pretty convinced that jen mccabe does

[@stef_anie777]

She didn’t want the kids to see anything in her text messages, protecting them in a sense. Yet volunteers her home and close ties with Proctor for all the “witness interviews”??? Makes zero sense

[@WhiskeyTangofoxtrot-zv5li]

If I'm concerned enough to text and look 5 times, I'm thinking I would just walk out there and ask WTF?

[@NoraWandyg-ro7xh]

Exactly!

[@BobSmith-fr5um]

Exactly!!

[@SamanthaLeigh7]

Jay imitating Lally on redirect, "what if anything were you having for dinner while eavesdropping" 😂💀

[@susanmorgan4003]

Avoiding answering every question isn't helping her credibility.

[@TRUECRIMESPTV]

There’s a pandemic of butt dials over there!

[@SamanthaLeigh7]

That's exactly what I said in the live chat, lol. The McAlberts have an epidemic of butt-dials. The only people out there who can butt-dial a phone with a 6 digit PIN at least 8 times in a 24 hour period.

[@LS-mj6ip]

Best coverage, hand down. Wouldn't miss a day with you guys!! ( Replay crew after work)

[@Lululovesradiohead]

She puts the Hos in Hostile …

[@Future-zx9ts]

Josh is GREAT! I found his channel last week after he was on STS, and I really enjoy his commentary. Hopefully he can join you and Jay again sometime during this trial.

[@JBfromFL]

What is "STS"?

[@Future-zx9ts]

@@JBfromFL Surviving the Survivor podcast here on YT (and other podcast platforms). Bob has also been a guest on that show several times.

[@Riverlife123]

Jen is going to be rehomed next .....

[@pooz1963]

😩

[@mariellel6342]

Pack your bags, you’re headed for Vermont!

[@marytracy7955]

Have you ever butt dialed 6x in a row without it going to VM?

[@leighbishop6213]

IMPOSSIBLE 🤦‍♀️🤌🏼🙌

[@eimyalbers7640]

Jen said during the 911 call that he got out of the car because Karen told her she left him at Fairview..but earlier she said Karen thought she left him at the Waterfall and didn't remember going to the house...

[@WhiskeyTangofoxtrot-zv5li]

She didn't mention a confession because she wasn't asked. But she answered MANY questions that were not asked TODAY. I find that interesting.

[@Lululovesradiohead]

Outstanding coverage Gentleman of this intense day. All three of you are uniquely intelligent, and make for a very talented and entertaining panel. Love having Josh Ritter here again. I’m shamelessly fan girling over his handsome looks and hipster shirt.

[@CRConfidential]

Thanks for making my day, Ashley! Appreciate the kind words and you taking the time to watch the video. Looking forward to being back on Bob’s show soon!

[@GwenShaffer]

There's a crime being committed by JM in so many forms, attorneys r confused on where to begin 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@NoraWandyg-ro7xh]

Rewatching, I’m a day behind now. I’m so sorry I missed the live, this is incredible! It was like Jen wasn’t going to get tripped up on her answer and wanted to read everything before she answered! 😮

[@GwenShaffer]

Poor BH never knew drunks were celebrating his birthday without him😂😂😂

[@rockfrangrances1]

She as caught off guard because the defense saved this theory for trial. No one was talking about it before!

[@rockfrangrances1]

Data and time. The only things liars can’t manipulate

[@inexplicablesusan]

I'm thinking about KR asking Jen "Did I hit him" "Could I have hit him"? Is this because Jen told her that John O. never came in the house, maybe even on the first phone call when Karen woke Jen up. That makes sense to me how Karen would get the idea that maybe she hit him if Jen told her he never made it in the house.

[@robinmaynard1640]

I'm innocent until proven elsewise all the way, meaning I withhold judgement until both sides have rested. However hard to see how this case was even brought or what the Prosecution believes happened. Rivering trial for sure

[@reneen4607]

I mean it's really difficult to butt dial from smart phones, and particularly multiple times

[@robinmaynard1640]

I agree w Bob. Some odd accident - slipped and hit the hydrant? BUT i keep get stuck on 'Wheres the blood?' Head wounds bleed tremendously. The leaf blower shows a minimal amount of blood. So where is it?

[@NoraWandyg-ro7xh]

This is so tense!😬

[@KCKR710]

This was intense.

[@photozombies238]

Does the way Jackson hits a subject, leaves it, comes back a few times, does this somehow help put it in the jury’s long term memory vs short term? I feel like I have much better memory on these items he has circles a few times.

[@pooz1963]

Whether or not KR is guilty, JM was horrendous on the stand, she lied throughout and got caught, and she seriously is the FIXER, Read will never be convicted....BUTT dials rule the TRAIL!

[@CollDott]

🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@mariellel6342]

I think I’d have to retire from practicing law after cross examining Jen McCabe. I’ve had to take 4 breaks today just from listening to her evade yes or no questions lol.

[@fairmaidenwinds]

Looking forward to the rest of this…much has been illuminated :) ❤️

[@Youtubereplies]

So she doesn’t want to risk her kids reading her texts but takes her daughter with her to prep? to be questioned?

[@MsMarple]

Bob/Ali/Jay, this is a lot to take in. Would love your synopsis at this point.- in say an hour episode?

[@photozombies238]

I am pretty certain that only the little circle saw the jeep pre 1:45

[@CollDott]

Got to say, she got a very nice wig!! Only thing i cant deny!! 😅😅😅

[@simpinainteasyRHEC]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@fairmaidenwinds]

I never delete, why do it? ❤️

[@fairmaidenwinds]

And the snowfall from God muffled the ring❤️❤️❤️

[@CollDott]

A nightmare to haunt aberts and associates for rest of their lives!!!

[@paulamaher8215]

The kids were petrified!

[@cindymarksberry8128]

That was sumthin else, man.

[@marytracy7955]

He may have been beaten up outside too, or in the basement. Kids may not of seen him

[@leighbishop6213]

He absolutely wasn’t laid dying on the front when Karen even arrived back home was he! My opinion was Matt was waiting for him……because of Jen

[@ktburr120]

Jay, Bob: I have a good idea for tomorrow. Can we have a time stamp on the screen so when I'm replaying this I know where to stop? Thanks love yall

[@Regina_Filanji]

Wait ...for Jay...you have seen accidents... taillights you think a tail light pops out perfectly like that?😊

[@mariabengtssonviking]

Im sorry guys, but i don't see how you can say that your viewers are split over this case, i have read all comments about this case and about 90-98% are not confused, they have been seeing the same witnesses as you and know what they know .......❤

[@fairmaidenwinds]

…bummer..take a dinner break and next time :) ❤️❤️❤️

[@fairmaidenwinds]

Closing will get the recipe in step by step. One Step Ahead of You 🎵a song

[@marytracy7955]

Data doesn’t lie.

[@Pinkdoor507]

Data can be manipulated.

[@simpinainteasyRHEC]

Where in the world is Megan Fox (investigative journalist) and her bullish button?! Bullshit

[@Halei_from_the_show_me]

Where is Mrs Motta?

[@fairmaidenwinds]

Group think is a real thing that some adult manipulates their bubble world, and innocent are the target that’s expected to take the fall??

[@fairmaidenwinds]

So butt dials were them actually trying to hear/find John’s phone?

[@kc-6837]

Yes.

[@josephineftrott]

That’s what the defense attorney was suggesting so the jury would have the thought in mind that Jen knows more about John’s death than she’s admitting and perhaps decide on reasonable doubt Karen isn’t a murderer.

[@LiamATL007]

What an absolute shitshow

[@fairmaidenwinds]

The chats are really down on L, but as someone commented to me “patience Grasshopper” ❤️❤️❤️

[@Neelie-848]

I thought she explained "she's telling them everything" and "good" response to my satisfaction. They believed immediately that Karen killed John and hate her for it. No Joshua.....lets not text about it....means what it means. Are you really saying you never texted an inappropriate opinion or language.

[@hughholt121]

Where is your eyewitness that John O Keefe went into the house at 34 Fairview besides Lying Karen?

[@JBfromFL]

I don't think there is one?

[@robinmaynard1640]

I'm curious why you call her lying Karen? I only know what has been in court.

[@hughholt121]

Cops did it....LMAO

[@Pinkdoor507]

I disagree with you guys. The phone ringing I agree is weird. BUT for me doesn’t overcome the taillight and dna evidence. Karen read has said on the news she told them the taillight was cracked

[@leighbishop6213]

Biased! Are you listening to the actual evidence? Disagree all you want but for Johns sake wrap it up until closing

[@fairmaidenwinds]

Karen never called 911..she used the others, and she played a part imho ❤️

[@NoraWandyg-ro7xh]

Rewatching, I’m a day behind now. I’m so sorry I missed the live, this is incredible! It was like Jen wasn’t going to get tripped up on her answer and wanted to read everything before she answered! 😮