LIVE JURY TRIAL | MA v. Karen Read Day 19 | MORNING | Witness #53

[@peterb2272]

Do you hear that "beep...beep...beep" sound? That is the dump truck of reasonable doubt being dumped in the jury's laps. AND THE DEFENCE HASNT EVEN STARTED THEIR CASE YET! Seriously, is the prosecution deliberately trying to make every witness commit perjury?

[@leannpetersfreeman8039]

It’s amazing how they can remember something’s exactly and others I don’t recall on others.

[@melissahanna2815]

I absolutely LOVE your passion, you make it bearable to see and listen to this poor woman being charged for the actions of the Albert’s and Mcabe families. Hope that Justice will turn the tables against the right culprits

[@smileymama04]

I agree 💯👏

[@AndreaPavlock]

How many of these jury members have been threatened to convict her... and are now scared out of their minds

[@sandralybrand9425]

Larry on another Law channel, there's a forty year career retired prosecutor that said this case should never have been brought against Karen !

[@katchristensen4211]

It doesn't take a retired prosecutor to see this should've never gone to trial. Hell, Stevie Wonder could see this. 😂😂

[@luciaayaso2260]

I have been wondering the same thing, ever since I heard about it. Only in times like these. The whole country is in trouble. It trickles down and we get kangaroo courts like this one. My prayers for Karen. She doesn't deserve this and all these crooked A-holes deserve what's coming to them.

[@experienceofchris1108]

Not only did the hard taillight supposedly bust into pieces when it “hit”,John, but it also fucking exploded and landed all over the yard😂

[@forpetessake3532]

yea …. rite …. NOT -

[@Sheila-hw4us]

Justice for Karen and John.

[@sundayschwein6162]

I am a retired RN. I worked ICU and CCU during my time as a nurse. The first time I started watching this trial there was a paramedic on the stand being questioned. He stated that John was intubated for breathing and that they started compressions. I may have missed that then they shocked him and gave epinephrine. I never heard him say that. If someone is straight lined, meaning asystole, then it doesn't do any good to try and warm the person due to hypothermia. If you can't get a heartbeat back means that the person is deceased. I was trained in advance cardiac life support. The ER doctor that testified sounded inept. My first thought after I heard the paramedic testify to what John's injuries were was, it sounds like John was beaten not hit by a car. And like I said that was the only thing I knew about the trial at that time. Please, if anyone heard that John was shocked and given epinephrine please let me know. I just don't recall it being said.

[@katchristensen4211]

Do you recall what paramedic it was on the stand?

[@AyNakoAlloyHaloHalo-jb9yg]

Someone testified early on that they have to warm then up because they're not considered dead until they're warm and dead.

[@TimParker-Chambers]

I think the 'doctor' mentioned giving a shot of epinephrine would be a course of action, but I forget if he said it was actually done... To be honest, I think he's either; a fraud masquerading as a doctor, or, a highly incompetent doctor moving from hospital to hospital, before the medical board revokes his licence to practice. That he didn't know 95f(35c) is the threshold for hypothermia was a *huge* red flag to me. He seemed to know enough to confuse a lay-person, but his *basic* medical knowledge was non-existent... (I spent the first 18 years of my life in and out of hospital and doctors offices, and have been reading medical texts since childhood: I may not be a doctor, but I guarantee that if I sat medical exams, I know enough to pass them...)

[@rickpearlstein6421]

Cross examnesia. 😂 How have I never heard that line before?

[@hillaryclinton1314]

Can't forget a truth you never experienced

[@frankiescherkenbach5553]

Love the watch the thin blue line squirm on the witness stand 😂

[@kristinerobb5109]

So the glass pieces survived on that bumper like that with all the driving, wind & snow??

[@ChanceNP]

Well, I drove from RFK stadium in DC to Richmond, VA with a half full can of Mountain Dew on the bumper of a car. No precipitation though.

[@ChanceNP]

I have some knowledge of maintaining a crime scene & it is unbelievable that they didn’t leave an officer or make some effort to protect the scene from weather. Tarps or a canopy could have been used.

[@trogers5814]

So she just said that the SUV got towed to the state patrol ""IN A BLIZZED"" and that hair stayed on the bumper in a BLIZZARD BE TOWED???

[@hillaryclinton1314]

Don't forget.. that between the first and second photo it tried to fall off.. damn lucky, eh?

[@LightningStorm73]

Thank you for another video.

[@londonparker83]

So... these people really want us to believe that karen not only ran john over in reverse they want us to believe that she dragged him too? And somehow john only received damage to his head and some scratches to his arm, no broken bones and after all of that she drove away with a broken tail light?

[@Watts_Up_K8]

1:22:32 Notice the pattern with the times so that theyre easy to memorise... Ends with 1, then 4, then 1, then 4. All with 10min intervals 😂😂😂

[@WestonLambert-k3c]

He explains this like this was a treasure hunt. We compared it all to a map.

[@moniqueschmucker7712]

1:49:07 securing crime scenes is ONLY optional in Canton MA!

[@beforeyourimmigrants8471]

Free Karen

[@sandralybrand9425]

Can't even hear anybody but the person on the witness stand! My phone is up all the way.Guess I'll come back for your recap.

[@Watts_Up_K8]

The third section is back to normal. From around 1hr mark 😊

[@ginasteglik9786]

What are the odds that after karen drove the car home, then then it was taken to police station that loose glass would still be on the bumper???

[@moniqueschmucker7712]

1:25:35 So, in other paraphrasing words, he told us exactly where he planted all of the evidence and exactly where we should go. Everything was strategically placed a few feet away from each piece and should be fairly easy to find if you aim to flashlight on them. 😬

[@dogfostermom2018]

So they are saying he was hit so hard that he went flying, his shoe went flying, the taillight shattered, and also went flying, yet there is no damage to his body. Does not compute. I don’t know much about Barnes, but never liked him. I wish Viva would disassociate from him but you’re right Viva will be the only friend he has left if he continues this behavior.

[@cynthiahotchkiss1597]

I just realized while Karen was asleep someone could have gone to her house and broken the tail light and took the pieces to plant them.

[@kennywoo9012]

Didn't have to they found all the glasses after the cops gained possession of the vehicle and thr tape from the canton police station when the Sargeant and Brian Higgins were present at the time it arrived is missing ...

[@williamp6800]

Her taillight was cracked but intact at 5:00am. It’s on video.

[@sandiekaye5241]

I read this is witness 54 of 86 for the prosecution. OMG We will never get to the end of the Prosecution. Did you see the judge smile at the end of the pictures of the rear passenger side ???

[@TimParker-Chambers]

3:18:37 Didn't put on gloves *first:* All those things were pre-contaminated *by her...* 🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️

[@laila-holm]

Æhhh... after so many days, I hoped Lally (the "dally") been told to speak louder. I cant hear what he say. Im far away here in Norway, but I hear all the others... 🙂 (+ today its a sort of bzz sound)

[@TimParker-Chambers]

2:16:51 Don't get excited, Counsellor; she describes incompetence to the level where all the forensics should be deemed inadmissible (due to her mishandling of, well, all of it)

[@LaLoniReilly]

Was it actually snowing? If so why was not his body covered in snow also since all of the glass and shoe is covered up with the snow???

[@luciaayaso2260]

I don't like this forensic scientist. The second she had a screw up, all her work prior should have had to have been looked over to make sure there were no other errors missed. I feel bad for anyone who was prosecuted with her findings. Very scary 😨

[@sundayschwein6162]

No I don't recall the paramedic. Sorry

[@forpetessake3532]

is that JUDGE buddies with these cops

[@TimParker-Chambers]

3:01:37 Which also somehow remained on the car rather than washed away by the blizzard... 🥴🥴🥴🥴🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️

[@univerzaltruth6481]

Lally has a cold. Maybe cold meds are messing with him. His stess level is apparent.

[@TimParker-Chambers]

1:47:05 Kudos for using one of my favorite words: defenestrate 👍👍👍👍 Wait till they get to the first forensics witness... 🙈🙈🙈🙈

[@beastshawnee]

I’d like to see a list of the cop tricks they used to pull this one off. What I have seen so far: Write down an incorrect house number if it’s a cop’s house. I can see someone inverting numbers or mistaking the number -but for every single form to have the wrong address? nah-That’s a policy. Notify your fellows if an order of protection for cell phones is on the way to their house-so they can all trade in their cells and destroy evidence the DAY BEFORE. Timing like that- that’s a favor. Allow all the cops and cop family to stay hidden away inside the house while conducting a murder investigation just outside in the yard. That’s blatant protectionism. Blow crap around the site and contaminate all physical evidence by ignoring gathering protocols using improper storage to then sitting on some evidence. That’s conspiracy and collusion, frankly. In my local town- they covered for the murder of a Native American man inside the jail. Conspiring with the forensics. Labeling it a death from alcohol poisoning when clearly he had been beaten to death by cops. they hid his body for four days which forensics did notate. It’s like he wrote down the injuries and the late arrival of the corpse but then was bullied to write alcohol on cause of death. No one was willing to fight the good ole boy system here. Cops and judges and prosecutors think everyone is guilty and act en force together to convict … BUT when something goes wrong on their end and laws get broken- they will break a hundred more and conspire to make cops look like heroes. Looking at these cops in this trial- mainly I am struck by how many are stupid lushes.

[@nevernever5063]

For me, today's testimony and evidence photos proved beyond ANY doubt that John was definately attacked by the dog. Why did the dog attack him? Who knows why and what came next ?????

[@TimParker-Chambers]

2:48:26 I would guess a near-horizontal blow from something an inch and a half round (like a nightstick... I'm sure Popping Taillights is a required class at 'the academy' 🤭🤭🤭🤭)

[@ginasteglik9786]

My feeling was John was in the house took his shoes off in that mud room, a fight happened, they picked him up drug him outside found his phone threw it under him but could only find 1 shoe when looking among all the others

[@sandralybrand9425]

Larry it's hard to hear whats being said and I have to read it.Can you move the comments after reading so we can see whats being said? When you're talking it makes it harder to keep up since we can barely hear the defense questions. Thanks! Sandi in SC

[@Andrew-ho6uj]

I think Higgins told JO about Karen kissing him and JO had to defend her honor and JO got beaten up by Higgins and others in the house

[@EddyA1337]

Naw if whenever a guy tells another guy his GF is doing stuff like that there is no fight, because the Bro Code was upheld. I think drugs were involved in some form or fashion. Hypothesis 1. The perpetuators were high (cocaine makes people overconfident and aggressive, combine that with alcohol and you have a recipe for fighting) Hypothesis 2. JO had mentioned to the Alberts that Colin Albert was selling drugs, which led to a confrontation in the basement. There could be elements from both hypotheses. Either way, KR is innocent.

[@Daisy-Girl0021]

I disagree about the "bro code" If I was kissing my husband's friend there would be zeroooo bro code and the friendship would be over as well as our marriage... I 1000 percent believe that Higgins was jealous over KR and it was set the f*ck up to have him come back to the after hours at Albert's house..It went wayyy to far and they k*lled him and dumped him and the saga continues 😡 JM tried to get Karen to go with her...for what reason She was HUVERING over KR outside the bar when everyone else was still inside 🤷‍♀️ Doesn't add up!!

[@EddyA1337]

@@Daisy-Girl0021 By flirting with KR and letting that kiss happen he by definition didn't follow the bro code. If he had hit up JO as soon as she was flirting it would all be different. But he didn't, cause he is an insecure loser.

[@Amontillado72]

"Tell them the guy never went into the house" Matt McCabe.."Colin was not at the house when John was there" Ally McCabe "Hos long to die in the cold" Jen McCabe ..butt dial after butt dial....and one cute little hair on a car that made it miles and miles without falling down despite of a blizzard. Hos long does it take to turn a tragedy into nationwide comedy? 😂

[@laila-holm]

😅😅😅

[@Daisy-Girl0021]

I personally find it absolutely disgusting......what garbage these people are!!! Lol damn they make my blood boil

[@catrandal6046]

3:00:00 I had a gut feeling that this DA was just phoning it in as the cool kids say... After this I am starting to feel He does not want to be here

[@catrandal6046]

How many times if any... have you watched Roadhouse ...and if you did ...do you , if any have an opinion of the antagonist Brad Wesley

[@catrandal6046]

I'd bet without looking there is a Canton Water advertisement Something like DRINK CANTON WATER SO YOU WON'T RECALL

[@catrandal6046]

3 DASH1 But The large person who was standing over me and helped me I don't recall if any person stood over me But I swabbed everything that they said to swab but I don't rcall who the large person was that told me to swab what i perfectly swabbed

[@TimParker-Chambers]

3:14:50 Which means he was not... 🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️

[@TimParker-Chambers]

5:54 Boosh meant about the chick you're schmoozing to try and get into court (it's a joke utilizing implied impropriety) 😆😆😆😆

[@emileeleewolfe4192]

I'm thinking about the federal investigation... Can someone be charged with murder if someone else is currently on trial for murder?

[@TimParker-Chambers]

4:31 Because your boy Yannetti likes making statements knowing full well they will be objected to and sustained, so he can drop the notion into the juror's minds: You know this, as you have praised him for doing so... 🤭🤭🤭🤭

[@wallywrench9844]

If Karens Lexus was evidence brought to the PD sallyport and camera footage is missing would that break the chain of custody?

[@TimParker-Chambers]

In theory 'no', because back in the day, not everywhere had cameras everywhere, so the lack of footage wouldn't be an issue. However: In this case, if there's footage from other times but none from that specific point in time, then that in itself is a damning thing, because it means the footage was destroyed. That all being said, IMHuO *none* of this forensics evidence should be admissible, because it was sloppily collected, sloppily analyzed, and seriously cross-contaminated to the point of uselessness... The first forensics lady, is *way* too sloppy with her practices; she should be out of a job (and every case her work touched, should be re-examined due to unreliable forensics) 🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@ServantWatcher]

What about the tire tracks in the lawn? Where were they if any...

[@laila-holm]

Found a sneaker??? Why have we not hear about that before?? - another lie?? Ohh... You have your beautiful cat in your lap as well 🐈 😍

[@cynthiahotchkiss1597]

I’m waiting for them to put those pieces together to see if they would even fit her vehicle.

[@forpetessake3532]

they do. because cops broke the taillight. at the station then took the pieces back to the scene and planted them O SO PERFECTLY

[@MsAlbertaBound]

Her work is in question, so why is she on the stand? What a crock of crap. Hope the jury takes her shit with a grain of salt.

[@TimParker-Chambers]

7:50 He doesn't want his Iegs broke by the McAlberts... 🤭🤭🤭🤭

[@ReinaLovesLaw]

Your hair looks amazing in this video

[@donnaallen3815]

If the judge keeps shutting air conditioners off- you would think to get a better microphones to hear Lally & witnesses. ( look at that thin cheap microphone! )

[@hillaryclinton1314]

13:29 seven on scene. Yet investigation not actually done. O v e r f u n d e d

[@TimParker-Chambers]

1:25:50 Sounds like Tully's in the McAlbert's pocket...

[@TimParker-Chambers]

1:57:23 They don't need a warrant for anything 'in open view' (or is the term 'in fair view) from the street... If you don't want your yard being searched by the p¡gs, put up a solid, 10 foot high fence around the perimeter. Has to be solid; no chicken-wire or boards with gaps between... If they can't see it, they can't search it (without a warrant) under the 'in open view' allowance... 👍👍👍👍

[@cherylmiller9964]

Wouldn't the glass on the bumper bounce out of the SUv on Karens way home,.

[@Jeff-ft2vo]

Hear ye, hear ye? THE HONORABLE WHO?Who made a judge a fu$$ing God? This is why our country has and is going to hell. We place names on human beings that just boost there egos even more.

[@Remmysage]

She’s said that a few times.

[@TimParker-Chambers]

3:14:06 ¿Was *he* wearing gloves! He, may have contaminated the evidence merely by trying to help... Nothing from the car should be admissible, due to this cazy lunt's sloppy working practices... 🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️

[@TimParker-Chambers]

3:54:47 To be fair, some podcasts hosts *request* that questions be in all caps so they stand out in the feed and are easier to read 👍👍👍👍 Sure it was an accident in this instance, but some do request it 👍👍👍👍

[@sandiekaye5241]

We watch Elsbeth. There is an Officer Smollen ? on that show. I don't know who plays that part, but he would make a good Allen Jackson when they do the movie, and they will.

[@normcaissie5598]

Your talking is way louder than the video. We have to crank the vol to hear it then you talk and blast the speakers.

[@sandiekaye5241]

You can barely hear both prosecutor or defence, but Lally is always the hardest.

[@billrowan1957]

Why's he constantly making zoo landers "blue steel" face

[@donnaallen3815]

Larry, So between the leaf blower, brooms shovels & solo cups- couldn’t have helped to keep the crime scene intact- making shovel marks getting to any evidence. ( doesn’t help the true facts of what really happened.

[@MadisonD941]

At 1:41:03, the how many feet discussion, 3 feet is just 36 inches, a yard stick. That's very close together.

[@TimParker-Chambers]

1:48:11 Because he doesn't want his Iegs broke by the McAlberts...

[@lindagliott5838]

Remember the detective told him what was out there

[@charlie15627]

ALT+F4 closes the window

[@sandiekaye5241]

That explantion about evidence..only answer not the question is evidence...very odd. What is behind that?

[@BelindaJ-ldc1215]

She said she was sent to Canton on 2/2/22, why her notes say 2/1/22, who had 5 days of access to the SUV??

[@moniqueschmucker7712]

I heard a recording between the tow truck driver and another guy interviewing him and he said “I towed it right to the police station. I didn’t tow it to my shop or nothing. I took it from that house right to Canton and they were with me the whole time. There’s more to that story than what they’re saying because I didn’t see no damage on it. I would have taken a picture. If there was damage on it the state police would’ve taken pictures long before they called me if it had damage on it. They would’ve taken a picture right there in the driveway if it had damage on it.” He must’ve said it several times before the end of the call. My question, why hasn’t the defense called this guy in yet? I don’t even see his name on the list of witnesses. Did I miss something?

[@jeanmariesmith1224]

The defense hasn't presented their case yet.

[@forpetessake3532]

@@jeanmariesmith1224 but he’s saying that guys not on the witness list

[@shawnpoe6060]

Okay, Am I daft or what... After seeing pictures and videos of the House, Yard and Street.... There are No Curbs in these pictures. However, a video I watched yesterday there are, in fact, Sidewalks and A Curb across the street where house number 41 resides. There are no Sidewalks and Curbs in front of 43. 🤔 Why do they keep saying " up against "the Curb""... instead of up against the snow burm? I grew up in Snow, deep snow, and we didn't have sidewalks and Curbs, I am baffled by their use of those terms 🤔🤣🤷‍♀️

[@TimParker-Chambers]

2:00:34 It sounds like a tier of payment... $2000 might be something like 'superhero costume of choice to wear during the abseil'... As for capes; they're a snag/choking hazard if it fouls with the lines... 🙈🙈🙈🙈 Buy yourself a Spiderman morphsuit from Amazon to wear; much safer ''NO CAPES!!!'' - Edna, in The Incredibles

[@Snowman23510]

This judge is a joke, She wants to make sure she is notice since, there will be a documentary, she is making sure they will portray her. ! She needs to be reprimand, on her behavior towards the defense!!! Breaking into the questioning when Jackson is asking questions, & stops so she can take a break!!! Larry who can we complain about this *** judge Why do they call her auntie Bev?

[@WestonLambert-k3c]

Exactly gonna locate means = search with the exact intent to find those specific items it wasnt an investigation it was a clear staging

[@WestonLambert-k3c]

He said had not requested yet to respond. He knew he would request to be at the scene and had talked to this officer before hand about it ?

[@shawnpoe6060]

Was that a huge Aunt Bev *sigh* 😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@WestonLambert-k3c]

X marks the spot we knew exactly where to look for these pieces of tail light we were told to look for. We got a pizza party if we completed the quest

[@WestonLambert-k3c]

So your telling me this officer was told what evidence to look for in an investigation?

[@juliefishburn8455]

I've noticed the judge isn't getting on lallys case about not speaking up like she was with that witness the other day....

[@MsAlbertaBound]

I can smell the B.S. from here. His lips a tightly pressed together hoping to remember what he was told to say.

[@WestonLambert-k3c]

Did he just say he found the sneaker on day one ?

[@ginasteglik9786]

Karen hit him how fast to knock his shoe off and into the street?????? In the snow and not feeling the hit ???????? I think a field trip demonstration is in order

[@cullenfamily4312]

what type pf force does it take to beak that type pf tail light?

[@TimParker-Chambers]

The remaining elements of the tail-light suggest that it was broken by being hit horizontally, by something about an inch and a half thick (like a nightstick)

[@adriennem7927]

Why is lally the only one who doesn't need a mic???

[@Ieezeca]

Is Larry awake?

[@kristin1227]

How do I donate?

[@nevernever5063]

Does anyone know if hair would freeze in a blizzard?

[@jeanmariesmith1224]

😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@kelliegrase4658]

Omg I can’t take Maureen’s eyebrows! Half of them are literally shaved off 🪒 🥺

[@AndreaPavlock]

I don't hear any taping

[@WestonLambert-k3c]

I need to know where you want us to search and what you want us to find . Wow im surprised by how blatantly hes admitting to making every crime scene a planted stage

[@TimParker-Chambers]

1:34:32 No; based on his *suggestion...*

[@ginasteglik9786]

Couldn't the defense get a person that could figure out at the temp outside what the speed of car had to be I don't think it is going to break at less then 25 mph and if karen was at a stop to let John put how fast could she be going by time of impact

[@SherylBarker-im3eu]

Have you heard anything from the jerk that said he was coming after you for talking to the HALES?

[@TimParker-Chambers]

3:14:33 ¿Was the helpful p¡g wearing gloves!

[@loismarch8343]

I don’t hear any tapping.

[@TimParker-Chambers]

It's subtle, but it is there (I'm listening through good headphones) TBH, it's not as irritating as Larry is making it out to be; he'a just being whiny...