Vocal Coach Reaction - Javed Bashir & Akbar Ali feat. Aamir Zaki [Coke Studio]

[@cookie-cs2zp]

Pakistani singers are really awesome. Love from India 🇮🇳.

[@ABasit-Arid-]

❤️

[@Shabana-zs2du]

Indian singers are also great...Pakistan💖

[@umarhasan6796]

Same for our indian brothers...♥️

[@arrehmanar5665]

❤

[@helmet212]

You haven't seen a quarter of Amir Zaki's musicianship in this video. Coke Studio got him only to reach a milestone and the producers of the show wanted to give him a tribute. Amir Zaki had bipolar disorder. There was a time when he burnt all his guitars and he was a guy who gave his life to music. He was the first Jazz guitarist from Pakistan when he produced his album Signature. May he rest in peace.

[@sonyhellboy6]

thank you for the info man. So bad that he had Bipolar. May his soul rest in peace.

[@supra_gliflozin]

RIP Amir Kazi was a Genius

[@zainabidin7577]

Javed Bashir is also known with a nickname "autotune" in Pakistani music industry as he picthes so accurately

[@bandalvi]

Im a Pakistani British, and I started to listen to Pakistani music because of you Carl.

[@dannyzee4]

Real Ummy I am too and his videos have got me back into music from there (and India) as well

[@mnaveed47]

Welcome to the world of real music. Coke studio is next level. Start from the first season. You will be on a journey of pure bliss.

[@durrayshawar4345]

so u now proud of ur culture bcse some englishmen praising it???

[@farazKHi]

Why didnt you listen before cause of inferiority complex 😂

[@ккє-о6ц]

Same dude. I had no idea what to listen to and where to start but these video helped so all the rude replies to this comment can stfu.

[@kumarmadhur1664]

Naina morey is the title of this song...😅

[@Julia-LArt]

kumar madhur 🤣

[@Julia-LArt]

@Carl John Franz, ohhh Carl you're so funny 😂🌺💟

[@kumarmadhur1664]

@@Julia-LArt 😅😅😋

[@Julia-LArt]

kumar madhur😂Naina, where arrree youuuu? ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

[@kumarmadhur1664]

Naina is under a hot shower right now...🤣🤣🤣 Asking for her towel...forgot it outside... Oh god...she is abusing now....gotta go😀

[@miram8821]

There is a song "chap tilak" by Rahat Fateh Ali Khan and Abida Parveen. Do check it. Plz

[@Skeptic_arun]

I strongly recommend ☺

[@JunaidMalikPlus]

Yesss plz

[@shahalamansari9448]

Highly recommended...amazing vocals

[@zenderbender1960]

Yes and Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan + Michael brook, Creast from Night Song Album. kzbin.info/www/bejne/eILWfnirgs6ne5Y One of best Music by NFAK on international stage.

[@BulletproofGOAT]

THIS ONE!

[@MariellaEnergy]

Carl, this is such an amazing interpretation. I'm not even especially into Eastern music but I knew that whatever you would bring would be worth hearing. Thanks ♥

[@kamranking4332]

Mariella La Cunza dear believe me he doesn’t even bring one drop from ocean that reach music we have here.

[@MariellaEnergy]

♥

[@manishgupta712]

if you want to see real magic of subcontinent singing listen 'Rang, Rahat Fateh Ali Khan & Amjad Sabri, Season Finale, Coke Studio Season 9 ', ...this song can take you to another galaxy ...

[@arslanahmed9685]

Rang from Fareed Ayaz and Ali Muhammad is better. Coke Studio Season 5

[@zurainshah2035]

Na this one is better

[@gadgetsnation6118]

Pakistani Singing*

[@nippon49]

I think it is amazing how you are able to select some the best, yet most underrated videos from coke studio. (Trust me, it has churned out some really average stuff off late as well). Tells you something about your amazing followers base (who are probably suggesting these reaction videos) and the great taste in music that they have.

[@abhayjagtap4310]

Both vocalists are real Brothers! Javed Bashir is famous in India as well since he has sung many Bollywood songs just like Rahat Fateh Ali Khan, Shafqat Amanat Ali and Atif Aslam!

[@parthmishra5348]

React to "Rang" from coke studio...its greaaatttttt....

[@Skeptic_arun]

I Strongly recommend it.

[@JunaidMalikPlus]

Nice suggestion dude. I'd love that if he reacts on your recommended song

[@Jokyl989]

Yes please!!!

[@aghaalirazapathan475]

Plzzzz do a video on Chaap tilak song by rahat Fateh Ali khan and abida Parveen coke studio season 7, it's requested

[@fatmaatma5280]

U have to give a reaction to 'saari raat' by Noori on channel rohail hyatt. I want to know how you asses Ali noor.btw great reaction coz u know about music n its interesting to see professional take on thing. So these qawal singers eat Paan to damage and open up thier vocal chords. It damages thier chords and they have to do riaz a type of singing to heal the bocal chords. Can u imagine. That is how they practise. That throaty frog like texture is by hurting vocals by eating pan then practising riaz. Its supposed to give heavy chesty voice to you. Nusrat was a qawal too. Im so glad u noticed.

[@nikamakhan4766]

noori fan spotted.... indeed sari raat was a totally master piece as u hae heard the original one

[@nomimalik2436]

Waoooo those two guy Akbar and javed belong to my city (shahdara town) .. you guys are proud of my city

[@bisaamamir1307]

Naina Moray is not some female backing vocalist. This is the name of the song. "Naina moray" means "my eyes".

[@euhassan]

Naina moray is the theme of song which means "my eyes" The violin-like instrument is called Rubaab Or Sarangi

[@cwehden]

Thanks for info 👍🏻

[@PaapiPasito]

"this instrument sounds lovely"... That's a sarangi. The tradition is almost dying. Very few people play the instrument. Was very commonly used in the background during dramatic scenes in old Bollywood movies.

[@MuhammadZeeShan-fk8mp]

Hi bro .. You react very well... please react to coke studio song "Allahu Akbar" .... it's really very deep in layric with awesome voice

[@wellwisher5808]

Absolutely

[@hashimshah7738]

Yes plz react on that

[@Noormajeed200]

Chaap tilak. By abida paveen (female) and rahat fateh ali khan (male) on coke studio

[@TheGamerboy9]

Aamir Zaki was the one of the best guitarists of Pakistan, he was a virtuoso.

[@bkadnan786]

Yes yes mate Amir Zaki was top guitarist

[@mianfaisal7610]

Late not mate

[@hk19478]

These are maestros. No one could possibly judge them, certainly not anyone who doesnt understand the language, cultural context. You could have all the conventional vocal coaching in the world and it still won't reach close to the skill and feeling Javed Bashir and Akbar Ali have. They are showcasing ancient words and skills here that have taken a lifetime to develop. Cannot be replicated by coaching.

[@iTalha]

Dude please please react to Kangna by abu fareed coke studio

[@dhksmt]

That's the best coke studio performance for me.

[@iTalha]

That performance is not from this world.

[@anarishakari8627]

These are the singing music maestros. Who dedicate there whole life learning these techniques. Now the time to made impression. Great.

[@zohrajabeen2784]

Naina moray is the title of this song...

[@mehrabkhan6249]

Zohra Jabeen .hey .aaj kal nazar nahi atay aap

[@iTalha]

Guys please vote for this request, it time for him to know ultimate skills of Javed Bashir. Yaad by coke studio is one of best art designed by Javed. He is humongous in it.

[@rachelsamuel9087]

Thank you for introducing Indian/Pakistani music to your part of the world. Most people are stuck on one song that stereotypes us...

[@amankhan03ak]

Music, voice texture and variation in their voices is just marvelous 💯👍👍👍👍👍👍

[@zainabbatool6104]

Instrument you said was lovely is a sarangi. Beautiful eastern instrument almost that's near extinction. It's been a long time since the sarangi had been used in compositions. Kudos to coke studio producers and composers for bringing it back.

[@storyteller236]

Habibi these two are the singers who have learned singing since their childhood, normally we call in our language USTAD or masters. somebody by whom you could learn singing ... and this is typical classical singing in our culture what these two gems of pakistan have performed... anyways i have always enjoyed your reactions.. you are geniounly someone who has command over singing techniques... :)

[@muhammadtayyab4797]

Please react to Chaap tilak by Rahat Fateh Ali khan and Abida Perween Coke Studio :)

[@hennakhan4587]

Charkha Nolakha by Atif and Qayaas. Khaki Banda by Ahmad Jahanzeb and Umair Jaswal (Qayaas's vocalist)

[@usmanshah5862]

"Some of that movement is too quick for me", that's what I think too. He inherited some qualities from Ustaad Salamat Ali Khan shb. Superb

[@pakiboyhadrou]

Usman Shah too quick is not very pleasing? you see nusrat and rahat had control on it and they did not do it so quick just so much that it's really fluent and sweet

[@usmanshah5862]

@@pakiboyhadrou not trying to disrespect. But I've heard not a single instance where nusrat had done such a thing.

[@engr.h.mbasirijaz1249]

@@usmanshah5862 different genres bro

[@bhatki_gaayika]

One of my coke studio favourite songs...

[@niazibahi8284]

When are you gona react to "Qirat" of quran...the true vocalist to hold their breath for nearly 1 mnt

[@arcane6067]

I cant control my tears while listening to this song. Its unbearable

[@hariskhattak1522]

react to the "ultimate human voice ever recorded " Ustad Naseer ud din Saami's rendition, Mundari on Coke Studio . thanks me later .

[@bkadnan786]

Coke studio music is best & your reaction also best mate doin great job great taste of music 👍🏽🍺

[@kamranki]

I absolutely love the way you dissect different parts of the song. Very informative! Thanks a million!

[@rishabhchanana6979]

the movement is quick because this is lethal Indian classical music brother, takes years of practice and dedication brother.

[@Rao0786]

please do a review on the below song from the coke studio. Allahu Akbar By Ahmed Jehanzeb & Shafqat Amanat

[@JatinderSingh-qh4rg]

Wow what a classical song, superior

[@krushnajadhav9681]

Mr. Franz!!! I must say u r growing on me day by day!!!! Perfectly spot on with both your reactions and your theories. Two things.......... Fast movements... how they do it? - Practice... Years of it!!! and the lovely instrument... its called SARANGI. Its a traditional Indian instrument that is often used in both movie music as well as performances. If interested in listening to fast movements (BTW they are called as TAAN- Fast moving notes.), lisen to the likes of Ustad bade ghulam ali khan, Pt. Bhimsen Joshi, Pt. Jasraj, Ustad Amir Khan , etc.

[@AjaySharma-sc5eo]

Amazing man here we can see the power of classical music he just stopped pressing the spacebar around 10:48

[@hunbbelmeer6600]

Thank you! That song was my request. Have a great day.

[@akeelhussain3790]

Hi Carl thanks for the reaction Javed Bashir is a beast some of his other songs on Coke Studio are incredible you were spot on with the Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan comparison he actually trained under Khan Saab so has a good background keep up the good work

[@SuperDexter212]

Nice to see one of your coke studio reaction of two as you promised. Javed is the best after the Nusrat, Farrukh and Rahat Fateh Ali khan family legacy of living legends of music in sub continents. Aamir is the one of the first finest gutarist in Pakistan, but unfortunately he is no more in this world(RIP). "Naina morre "is the song name not the lady. You need to see Nusrat, Farukh and Rakhat first performance in 1985 at London's " world of music" or simply called as "WOMAD". Luckly it is still availabel on youtube. It's old and lenghty videos but you need to see how much british people went in to this magical voice of Nusrat and group. Carl this is beautiful reaction video from you. Waiting for the other video from you.

[@housekinokuni903]

This is one of my favourite coke studio songs along with mai sufi hon and paar chana de

[@insafsial5567]

"Naina morey" is the name of the song. It means "my eyes" in urdu.

[@muazqamar]

I would love to see you break down Shikwa, Jawab e Shikwa from Coke Studio

[@Mangosteencountry]

I love your breakdown of this long piece Carl. It is informed and discerning. Very educational for us who are not musically-trained.

[@muhammadahmed415]

04:27 - 0430 was so brilliant but Mr expert was just landing in crosswinds with his own comments

[@aamnahere6250]

Yep!

[@pmtabhogal4386]

Some of the early season Coke Studio gems are well worth a listen- Danah pe Danah, More Kangna, Naina de Aakhey Lage, Rang Laaga, Yaar vekho ....and of course, Jugni

[@saminazakia3278]

Beautiful song, lovely meaning and amazing singers. I enjoyed it

[@Farmaneali]

Naina morey is title of the song.

[@tlcservisesfbtm2271]

The eastern string instrument that you couldn't recognize is called Sarangi. It best expresses pathos and pain in all genres of Indian and Pakistani classical music.

[@adhominemsis-t.australisensis]

Naina more taras gaye...My eyes are yearning. It's a standard of the Patiala school of Hindustani music, in the traditional, light classical genre called Dadra, in a Raag, or melodic framework, called Jangla Bhairavi (scale is that of the harmonic minor in ascent and a mixture of the Aeolian and Dorian scales in descent). Here it is presented in a more contemporary form, of course, and is amalgamated with a secondary composition in a Raag called Jaunpuri (based in the Aeolian scale). The poetry of traditional Hindustani music is almost always in the female voice, by the way, even when composed by men, as they invariably were. Please check out the rendition of this tune by the late great Ustad Bade Ghulam Ali Khan, one of its original performers, and possibly the greatest vocalist in Hindustani music of the 20th century.

[@gurjotsingh8934]

No it's not the typical gayaki of Patiala gharana

[@adhominemsis-t.australisensis]

@@gurjotsingh8934 I didn't say it was typical gayaki of Patiala. The composition is standard of Patiala.

[@gurjotsingh8934]

@@adhominemsis-t.australisensis hmm ok got it.

[@Shabana-zs2du]

The best thing is that you turned on the captions💖

[@fatecursedking]

Finally ! Much awaited reaction from your side ! Thanks mate !

[@zakiramad]

The song's called Naina Moray @Carl

[@samiaanis2869]

You are a humble person. True to art

[@hamzajahangeer3348]

Both of the brothers (yes literally brothers) are masters of their own style

[@MakHash420]

You sir, who have the knowledge to review these songs. In Every video of yours, you explain and understand everything. Keep it up.

[@userunaemu]

I think what sets Pakistani and Indian singers apart is that they use their whole body as a means to project their voice. Posture, muscle tension, and hand movements all add to their sound and control. Akbar Ali is a master of control. When I try and sing his parts, I notice it doesn't sound right unless I change the tension in my core. More tension in the body coincides with less tension in the throat. It becomes intuitive when you start to incorporate everything together.

[@mrtogether6492]

it does'nt get any better than this....even 2 years later !

[@bawasajjad2979]

"naina moorey" was sung by ustad "bade ghulam Ali" he was a great classical singer and music teacher in the subcontinent. and the other song is "man atkeya " sung by nusrat fateha ali khan. it was a nice reaction. plz react on " aj rang hy" by rahat fateh ali khan anda amjad sabri coke studio.

[@Dr-Hafiz-Sohaib-ENT-Surgeon]

I wish you cud understand how intense the original urdu/punjabi lyrics are, in terms of feelings...

[@shortislamicvideos4850]

You can't even imagine that what exactly they are doing

[@mnaveed47]

Javed and Akbar are brothers. JAVED was a student of Ustad Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan. But didn't manage to finish his 10 year scholarship, he did about 7-8 years until the master passed away.

[@ikkhan2581]

Brother Carl you should make a video on one another legend female singer The great Abida Perveen. She also sing many songs in Coke Studio. You can choose any of them. Personally I like the song Aqa from Abida and Ali Sethi. Yes I know that you listen and you make a video on Rahat and Abida. But check this also. Please 🙏🏼

[@sherazkhan-ed3vs]

aaj latha naeeo by Javed Bashir is the best of coke studio. It is totally raag song with 2 verses and it is brilliant. You must listen to it, even if you don't wanna react. Cheers!

[@ebutyou]

the guitarist sitting on the balcony is the composer . great job by him

[@MrR188749]

Do coke studio Krewella

[@xxainraza]

The most difficult song of coke studio ever

[@libsoric6693]

I recommend looking up Unleash the Archers, their singer Brittney Slayes has a really powerful voice. As for the song probably Awakening or Tonight we Ride for the best examples of her range.

[@mhamzachohan]

A pure classical music Carl. Identity of sub continent as every music produced n invented from it here. People took decades to learn classical.

[@alinewaz17]

At 10:53 , the tone exhibited by Akbar Ali is taken and learnt from Ustad Salamat Ali khan from one of his Sindi Bhairvi thumri. If you want to actually find out what human vocals can do, find some time and listen to the Ustad Salamat Ali Khan's raagas of the 50s,60s and 70s. Your mind will be blown. Cheers

[@AsadAli-jc5tg]

Legends say, he's still searching for that mystery lady, Naina Morey in the song.

[@kasana_gujjar]

“Naina Moray” is song title which means “My Eyes” , Naina is also a name of girl which means eyes ... Thanx for reactions , 💖 from Pakistan 🇵🇰...

[@navo21]

Naina Moray is not a lady, it's the name of the song... Akbar Ali was singing the Naina Moray (my eyes) song and Javed was singing Mann Atkeya song...

[@sumairafalak6665]

Watch older coke studio pakistan seasons like sari raat by noori. Dasht e tanhayi . Etc etc etc there are so many gems

[@Ssyed-zahran]

Thanks alot for reviewing this song. Its my one of the most loved track! Please review "Ghoom Charakhra" from Coke studio session 11 too I am sure you'll be pleased alot...

[@muhash14]

Consider looking at 'Khaki Banda' from Season 9. Personally one of my all time favourites, and features a terrific duo of singers doing s composition that's truly spectacular.

[@TabeshKhan]

"Naina Moray" is the Song, you can miss her if you can't step back and appreciate the mastery as a Whole.😊

[@yousafrafique2194]

Hit like for Allah hu akbar coke studio reaction👍👍

[@wasifwahid9066]

Missed Aamir Zaki so much, was magic in his hands, Magical mind

[@hammadhussain5107]

This is one of the compositions of Kaavish. Please check out his other works. :)

[@alinisar6435]

I was waiting for you to listen to this masterpiece... effortlessly sung and music was icing on top. Your reactions were always on the cards. 😊

[@2096prashant]

It's the Classical Indian music , and it is the best in the world for me suebto the attachment of emotions in notes and expression of feelings through this ! And you'll take ages to get this !

[@iTalha]

Dude thank God you reacted to it. Loved it!!

[@SHaBBiR-619]

Love to watch ur reaction cos u understand well enough to explain vocal quality as well as instrument 🎺

[@iszaq]

Naina Moray is the title of the song. Your reactions are the best! Really appreciate the western perspective on eastern music. A lot of this style of music is heavily based in classic poetry and the repetitive "chorus" alludes to the overall theme or mood of the song, i.e. in this case the protagonist is missing his beloved and wants someone to or some way to get a glimpse of his beloved

[@besurasinger]

yah that quick movement is they work on so much , very quick transition from one note to another.

[@bhattichannel7509]

This is one of my all time favorite Coke studio songs

[@d_phenomenon]

Carl you really need to listen "Ambwa Taley - Javed Bashir and Humera Channa Coke Studio Season 7 Episode 4" to feel the richness what subcontinent singer has to offer. Its a criminally underrated song.

[@sumayyabintiayub2813]

Sir please react to CHA RAHI KALI GHATA coke studio you will see the peak of talent

[@selssm]

I would love to see you react to Saari Raat by Noori -- Coke Studio

[@TheRudheer]

@Carl John Franz, do a reaction video on 'Abhi Mujh mein kahi' by 'Thaikkudam Bridge'. They've used a 7-beat rhythm cycle, unlike most musical compositions (most of them use 8-beat or 6-beat rhythm cycle). You'll love it, trust me! :D Also, big fan! Keep up the good work! We all love you very much :D

[@AjaySharma-sc5eo]

Akbar Ali is his younger brother n both are trained in QAWWALI and CLASSICAL music.

[@Music-ge8gk]

That instrument is Sarangi and it is indeed lovely.