Vocal Coach Reaction - Abida Parveen & Rahat Fateh Ali Khan 'Chaap Tilak' [Coke Studio]

[@ankitpant1982]

Did you see Rahat, one of the greatest singers of our generation sitting there quietly with his eyes down when Abida was singing! She is like the Queen! No one messes with her!

[@recker1130]

True bro

[@amishbhat3560]

I was thinking the same.... he was sitting there like a good boy in front of his boss......

[@rabiayounus1482]

Ankit Pant that's respect he is showing towards senior and leagendry singer

[@ankitpant1982]

Rabia Younus duh 🙄

[@arshadabueshaal]

Ankit, wow dude.

[@nimra85]

We are lucky to be born in an era where we get to hear a legend like Abida Parveen sing. Her voice shakes your soul, and I have no knowledge of music or singing. She is phenomenal and a true legend. I had the pleasure of meeting her in person once and she was truly the most humble person you could meet. God bless her.

[@arminius6506]

Only if Nustrat Fatah didn't die a premature death 😥😥😥

[@ghc2009]

Rahat fateh is better than abida parveen and nusrat was 1000 times better than these do . They are just chaps in front of nusrat ji

[@chiragagarwal8734]

In India, no one would dare judge these ustads. They aren't just your typical singers. They are ustads. They have dedicated their lives into training and practicing. Singing isn't just a part of their lives. Their improvisational dexterity isn't anything that could be seen in western musicians.

[@parveenahmed2166]

💯. They are legends and no one can match them

[@vjsays27]

Abida Parveen is a living legend. She is at the same level of Nusrat fateh Ali khan. They both are the jewel of Sufi (devotional) music not only for the Pakistan but for the world. You should hear more songs from Abida Parveen. One my favorite is "Soz-e-Ishq" from coke Studio pakistan. There is another wonderful song from Coke Studio India "Madari" by Vishal Dadlani. Cheers 😊

[@MikaalWahab]

Good to read this appreciation, neighbour.

[@chanwoothemood3536]

i respect ur opinion but i think rahat is like a student to abida but rahat is like you know the topper in the class

[@anshumanmurmu4708]

This is impossible to compare between these two nor critique

[@fatherindia4810]

@@anshumanmurmu4708 I agree. I gave up a long time ago.

[@toobanazjadoon5869]

Avida g singing level is not equal to rahat its something beyond ur judgement

[@shandoli]

no idea what they sang but that woman has a direct connection to god. absolutely amazing.

[@nassermj7671]

And then some - you said it!

[@keepinitrreal]

You got it absolutely right 💯

[@jays5186]

Bro..no body judges Abida.. Abida Judges you

[@thekidhartford5266]

Facts.....voice, talent and feelings are as deep as the Mariana trench.

[@aijazmir1831]

true that

[@khurramajaz3348]

Asha bosile disrespects Abida Ji in music competition when abida Ji was in India.

[@engr.h.mbasirijaz1249]

Yup

[@ankitpant1982]

Jay Sahay completely agree brother! No one alive dare do that

[@FahadNazir007]

I wish you could understand the true deep meaning and essence of this beautiful piece of poetry.

[@zabuza8548]

It's amazing

[@armaansingh8114]

its an enlightening experience...bhakti at its peak

[@happybunny2541]

Please translate for us

[@faizan8024]

​@@happybunny2541 Title: All trace of me Language: Braj I’ve staked all I have - my wealth, my body, my very soul And good fortune has showered its blessings on me Everyone makes a play of devotion Devotion Devotion Devotion Everyone makes a play of devotion But true devotion is not achieved You will know the true meaning of devotion When you devote yourself to your spiritual master Master O my master Khusrau, the game of love If I play with my dear one If I win, my sweetheart is mine If I lose, I’m still with my dear one You have snatched away all trace of me With one glance of your enchanting eyes You have snatched away all trace of me With one glance of your enchanting eyes You have snatched away all trace of me With one glance of your enchanting eyes With one glance of your enchanting eyes With one glance of your enchanting eyes With one glance of your enchanting eyes Whether or not you agree to speak to me Whether or not you agree to speak to me Whether or not you agree to speak to me Whether or not... Whether or not you agree to speak to me Whether or not you agree to listen I will not leave your side, my swarthy beloved With one glance of your enchanting eyes With one glance of your enchanting eyes With one glance of your enchanting eyes With one glance of your enchanting eyes You have snatched away all trace of me With one glance of your enchanting eyes You have snatched away all trace of me With one glance of your enchanting eyes With one glance of your enchanting eyes With one glance of your enchanting eyes You have snatched away all trace of me With one glance of your enchanting eyes You’ve intoxicated me with once glance of your enchanting eyes You have snatched away all trace of me With one glance of your enchanting eyes The night of the Prophet’s celebration has dawned The night has dawned The night has dawned The night of the Prophet’s celebration has dawned Come and let his slave dye you in his hue Whoever’s veil he chose to colour Blessed became his fortune Khusrau forfeits his life in Nizamuddin Auliya’s love In Nizamuddin Auliya’s love Nizamuddin Auliya Nizamuddin Auliya Nizamuddin Auliya Nizamuddin Auliya Khusrau forfeits his life in Nizamuddin Auliya’s love You’ve made me a radiant bride with just one glance of your enchanting eyes You have snatched away all trace of me With one glance of your enchanting eyes Your enchanting eyes Your enchanting eyes With one glance of your enchanting eyes

[@tanveerrazakalani]

I was about the write it but saw your msg... only if he knows the meaning he can understand emotional and spiritual voice its coming from. really appreciate your words and understanding of music

[@Sammy86]

The moment you said Jesus, seconds after listening to Abida Ji's voice is completely expected. She brings the listener very close to a divine truth and we all react according to our rearing.

[@thekidhartford5266]

I've probably watched this 100+ times. Abida has a depth and character that cannot be described. Rahat is special but he cannot match what is coming from her heart and soul.

[@SmartThiefPlays]

Agree the depth in her voice is monopoly.

[@truthseeker7027]

Poet was a friend(Auliya) of Allah. human's souls remain restless untill they find true Love for their true creator. When they find the truth in heart. They find peace. Amir Khusro and Nizam uddin Auliya were muslims and that's why Islam means peace but one comes to know this truth when their souls experience it but later on they deny the truth because shaitan never wants them to accept the truth due to many reasons. peace :)

[@defencebangladesh4068]

exactly

[@ZubairKhan-pv5lr]

You get it.

[@nassermj7671]

You have such refined taste. Impressive.

[@abhi7936]

GOD DAMN!! WOMAN! If she was a footballer, she would be Ronaldo with Messi's left foot.

[@fahimshehzad2113]

This could not be explained better

[@prateekrawat1041]

Stewie said that

[@ashrafsaikh7937]

The best explanation

[@mithunvasudevan7796]

Wow now that's the perfect description bro

[@rabiayounus1482]

No! she would be couch

[@arslansarwarhussain]

9:04 his face was like "kaisay kar lete ho bhai? 😂😂😂

[@AkshardhamNewDelhi]

😛😃

[@MuhammadYaseen-ch2vz]

😂

[@dfallenking1043]

😂😂😂😂

[@AB-hq6kw]

What does it mean?

[@peezmol]

@@ayeshatassadaq891 hahahahaha....😍😍

[@awais.khan1]

These traditional drums are called a ‘tabla’ in this part of the world

[@arpitamukherjee6495]

Though all the lines are a precious specimens of art, but to me the best line is ' jit gayi to piya more, har Gaye to piya ke sang'... Very deep meaning.

[@incarnation8187]

I have tears when I listen to.this line, the kind of dedication u need to dilute yourself. Just amazing

[@sasbttrr]

this guy can't even fathom the LEVEL OF SINGING they just did!! THAT WAS 1000000LEVEL OUT OF 10(that you know).

[@drsumonroy]

tan man dhan baaji laagi re I've staked all I have - my wealth, my body, my very soul dhan dhan more bhaag baaji laagi re And good fortune has showered its blessings on me laagi laagi sab kahen Everyone makes a play of devotion laagi Devotion laagi Devotion laagi Devotion laagi laagi sab kahen Everyone makes a play of devotion laagi lagi nah ang But true devotion is not achieved laagi to jab jaaniye You will know the true meaning of devotion jab rahe guru ke sang When you devote yourself to your spiritual master maula Master o ji maula O my master khusro baaji prem ki Khusrau, the game of love جو میں کھیلی پی کے سنگ jo main kheli pi ke sang If I play with my dear one جیت گئی تو پیا مورے jeet gayi to piya more If I win, my sweetheart is mine jo main haari pi ke sang If I lose, I'm still with my dear one chhaap tilak sab chheen li re You have snatched away all trace of me mose nainaan milaaike With one glance of your enchanting eyes chhaap tilak sab chheen li re You have snatched away all trace of me mose nainaan milaaike With one glance of your enchanting eyes chhaap tilak sab chheen li re You have snatched away all trace of me mose nainaan milaaike With one glance of your enchanting eyes nainaan milaaike With one glance of your enchanting eyes mose nainaan milaaike With one glance of your enchanting eyes mose nainaan milaaike With one glance of your enchanting eyes mose bol nah bol Whether or not you agree to speak to me mose bol nah bol Whether or not you agree to speak to me mose bol nah bol Whether or not you agree to speak to me mose bol nah Whether or not… mose bol nah bol Whether or not you agree to speak to me meri sun ya nah sun Whether or not you agree to listen main to tohe nah chhaaḍoon gi ay saanware I will not leave your side, my swarthy beloved mose nainaan milaaike With one glance of your enchanting eyes موسے نیناں ملائیکے mose nainaan milaaike With one glance of your enchanting eyes milaaike nainaan With one glance of your enchanting eyes nainaan milaaike With one glance of your enchanting eyes chhaap tilak sab chheen li re You have snatched away all trace of me mose nainaan milaaike With one glance of your enchanting eyes chhaap tilak sab chheen li re You have snatched away all trace of me mose nainaan milaaike With one glance of your enchanting eyes nainaan milaaike With one glance of your enchanting eyes nainaan milaaike With one glance of your enchanting eyes chhaap tilak sab chheen li re You have snatched away all trace of me mose nainaan milaaike With one glance of your enchanting eyes matwaari kar deeni re mose nainaan milaaike You've intoxicated me with once glance of your enchanting eyes chhaap tilak sab chheen li re You have snatched away all trace of me mose nainaan milaaike With one glance of your enchanting eyes raini chaṛhi rasool ki The night of the Prophet's celebration has dawned raini chaṛhi The night has dawned raini chaṛhi The night has dawned raini chaṛhi rasool ki The night of the Prophet's celebration has dawned rang maula ke haath Come and let his slave dye you in his hue jiski chunri rangdi Whoever's veil he chose to colour dhan dhan uske bhaag Blessed became his fortune khusrau nijaam ke bal bal jaiye Khusrau forfeits his life in Nizamuddin Auliya's love khusrau nijaam ke In Nizamuddin Auliya's love nijaam ke Nizamuddin Auliya nijaam ke Nizamuddin Auliya nijaam ke Nizamuddin Auliya nijaam ke Nizamuddin Auliya khusrau nijaam ke bal bal jaiye Khusrau forfeits his life in Nizamuddin Auliya's love mohe suhaagan keeni re mose nainaan milaaike You've made me a radiant bride with just one glance of your enchanting eyes chhaap tilak sab chheen li re You have snatched away all trace of me mose nainaan milaaike With one glance of your enchanting eyes nainaan Your enchanting eyes nainaan Your enchanting eyes nainaan milaaike With one glance of your enchanting eyes

[@mightyfist]

Sumon Roy thanks very much🙏🏽

[@zahidamustafa6962]

Dr Sumon Roy lovely. Thanks for the translation

[@asherbashir7777]

Thank You!

[@SY3D7]

Thanks!

[@abdullashahil4820]

Wow thanks brother ♥️👌👍

[@rva]

Congrats on the 100.000 subs! ♥️☺

[@cwehden]

Thanks!

[@Shahidkhan-qj5cy]

Oh damn we meet again Rebecca. This guy is serious stuff for sure

[@tarandeepsingh7093]

How can u even see it They're hidden

[@KNVBsakanable]

Rebecca would you be kind enough to react on the same video? Thanks in advance

[@reapwatusow1512]

Carl you are doing such an amazing working bring different cultures together at this era of wars and hate....kudos to you brother

[@muazqamar]

Amen

[@MuhammadAliFaraz]

I met Abida Parveen in Islamabad in October of 2019 and she was so down to earth and made me feel so special that I was moved to my core. She has not a shred of pride. She has no arrogance. She is humble she is love she is amazing as a person.

[@randomdude245]

hey bro i haven't seen her vids or her this is my first time i am not an expert in music in any way but i done some research but why is she soo famous ? and her speciality that people know her for

[@MuhammadAliFaraz]

@@randomdude245 Her voice is moving. Her pitch is perfect and she never misses a beat. Keep listening to her and you will get it.

[@devanshapril]

Abida Parveen is a legend! One cant possible compare Her with An Adele or contemporaries of Adele. She is a league of her own. Such legends are born rare. She resonates with Late MS Subbulakshmi as they have divinity in their voices. Abida Parveen sings and one can visualize divinity.

[@spreadlove6277]

Abida Parveen has a different kind of energy. It's pure light 💛

[@speeddemon9616]

wow that was just waw you could feel the music although i dont speak their language I could almost understand

[@ameerosamakhan8599]

that's true music man, there is no language but it touches your soul.

[@Balerion_The_BlackDread]

This is a school of music. Two legendary singers together. This is not just singing, it's spirituality. You loose yourself and surrender and transcend to another world.

[@prabeshuprety2872]

we started our school from A,B,C,D .these ustad's started from sa ,re ,ga , ma and sargam .we can only appreciate them cuz we can't understand the level and "kaam" they are doing on each note and "alaps"

[@TheSeharKhokhar]

I get goosebumps hearing her! You need to listen to “tune deewana banaya” and “yaar ko hamne ja baja dekha” by abida parveen

[@zenlytattoos]

The thing is that they have been training since so many decades everyday without missing a single day. This makes them so skilled and confident with their pitch. Even now I know they must have done their practice or as we call it (riyaaz) session for the day. In this side of the world singers treat their singing as a religion and they devote themselves to the craft.

[@ikkhan2581]

🇩🇪from Germany Frankfurt am Main : Waw Waw Waw what a great great Song. Two Legends on the same pitch 😳. This combination make me crazy and it brings to cry 😢. So high and so deep. Nothing is better then to listen these both for hours and hours. And I listen this song for so many times, but it is still not enough to stop listening 🙉. My mind. Great job 👌🏻

[@tauqeerkhan360]

you cant judge Indo Pak music with westen music book rules...Abida g is living legend and Rahat Fateh Ali Khan is prodigy of great legend

[@zahraamin164]

Your comments are so fascinating and bring another unique layer of appreciation to music I already love so much. Thank you.

[@JaySinghIsImmature]

"Sufi" icons: Their compositions often pay homage to a relationship with God as one's lover, spouse, etc. It's an often misunderstood and misinterpreted devotional art form. These singers are masters at aligning the power of the lyrics with specific notes, melodies, and rhythms to deliver maximum emotional and spiritual impact.

[@kartiksharma7113]

I just watched you reaction to 'Afreen Afreen'. And then this, you are truly, no disrespect, in a position to judge these maestros.

[@yusha5728]

You should turn on the captions to enjoy the lyrical beauty. some of them have english translated subs

[@afifakimih8823]

"Two legend "💜💜💜🇧🇩🇧🇩

[@DailyDipto]

🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩

[@printerboy571]

Abida has the depth to her voice...and Rahat has emotion in his voice

[@saadrasheed187]

Now you found the core of eastern singing.... keep searching and growing

[@faizaaziz3263]

He is not judging guys... no one can judge abida g... its only his reaction... he is a nice person...

[@PS-qv7xv]

Wow. The beginning of the song, the intro by Abida Parveen. Wuaw. Brought tears to my eyes

[@Rosannasfriend]

Rahat Fateh is my new favourite singer. He's like a jazz singer in his delivery. Total beast!

[@abdulmohamin992]

I've met Abida once and she has that Angel aura around her. Took a pic and went my way. She genuinely is an angel.

[@abhaykkmail]

What you said ... These guys have reached a level of efficiency that anything don't matter now.. the fundamentals of music are embedded in their DNA.. whatever they sing is beyond normal human reach 🤗

[@Moosa_Says]

After watching all these people doing reactions on music videos you are the best one and real one ! original understand music and really not over acting ! Love you bro :)

[@Envision007]

Agree👏

[@Nav0410]

Just watch a video...COKE STUDIO.."Rang" by Rahat Fateh Ali Khan and please react..Love from India

[@caesar6890]

1.40.. the way you looked at the cam in shock! Genuine.. you are awesome..please keep listening deep.. respect to you sir!!!

[@preranatd]

It's nice that you're exploring different music styles. Just one suggestion: Hindustani classical music stresses adequately on the importance of posture. When you begin learning, even though one is required to sit crossed legged, one is reminded enough about posture to open up the air passage. One is required to sit with their backs straight and chest open. Rahat Fateh Ali Khan is an accomplished musician who has, over the years, evolved his own style, but you will notice that Abida Parveen's stance is very different and straight. I'm not sure, students would be wise to question the importance of stance (unless one has a physical limitation) before learning how to sing like the maestros.

[@iota6075]

Meet abida parveen in person, She is such a great soul!!

[@MuhammadZeeShan-fk8mp]

Bro you are sooo nice ..... Also react to "Allahu Akbar" from coke studio

[@Skeptic_arun]

Agree

[@khurramhameedofficial1311]

Yup plz react on Allah huakbar song thanx

[@hiteshpanchal1324]

Traditional Set of Percussion are "Tabla". It appears at 5:45 of Video being played behind Abidaji...What A Great Singer...

[@sshakababy]

I linked this video in the comments of another of your reaction videos. I'm so glad you enjoyed it. Keep up the great work. 👍

[@sadafasim4960]

Abida's singing is effortlessly,no one can compete her in sufi singing... she is a our living legend ❤️

[@pmtabhogal4386]

I have watched and been a die-hard fan of Abida Parveen since her debut on PTV many years ago. I would say that despite both being such genius singers this is one of the performances that I least like. Too dry and clinical. The song dates back to the 14th century, by Amir Khusro. As with many ancient songs/ poetry on the subcontinent, they are still chart-toppers and can be reeled off by the common person on the street!

[@cwehden]

Thanks for info! 👍🏻☺️

[@nikkunshu]

Raag " Malhar" was sung by Tansen on the darbar or the court of the king to make it rain. Tansen had the power of bringing rain to earth with this Raaga . This video will give you a glimpse how in modern times also we are attached to the roots (somewhat)

[@haula251]

Lionel Messi’s football, Abida Parveen’s voice... Just carries me another world 🙌

[@yasirtoor6378]

The love abida parveen g is getting from across the border is tremendous and so powerful and good to see at least we are at one page when it comes to music.

[@hasnainraza8881]

Two living legends infront of each other ❤

[@shravanbhan3862]

This song always makes me cry. Not because of the lyrics but because of the intensity and emotions of their voices. Love Rahat sahab

[@KhanBaba-zw3kq]

They are living legends love from🇵🇰

[@Imranahmed-tk9ci]

love your reaction truely natural like rahat and abida singing only a true musician can understand all that without understanding the language hats off to you one thing i wish to you you witness rahat fateh ali khan its something else :) i witnessed it live in the uk and its lifetime experience great channel subscribed

[@zohrajabeen2784]

Was waiting for it.... Now plz react to Rang by Rahat Fateh Ali Khan and Amjad Sabri

[@bkadnan786]

Zohra Jabeen my favourite 2

[@khushbuhkhan1622]

Yes please

[@NotyPlanetWish]

@@khushbuhkhan1622 ok

[@haula251]

Fir uske baad??

[@happybunny2541]

I just love your comments and opinions on the sound.

[@TheMehta23]

So true what you said about breaking rules when skill level is so high

[@charmoss_q8701]

I don't understand what the words uttered but I really love hearing it,,,something my soul uplifts,,,I really appreciate this music,,its just wow,,,

[@kaukabshehzadi1492]

Abida madam is Queen of queens... Respect...

[@foodicado3136]

Abida Parveen have such soulful voice her voice hit the soul direct. Legend she is.

[@roshaan]

I really enjoy your reactions and the feedback that you give along the way. Please keep it up :)

[@brummie6950]

You're commentary enables one to appreciate the quality of the singers a lot better

[@xanny3963]

Nobody is good enough to judge these two legends 😍😍

[@FariaMasood]

Arsal Sunny he is not judging them. He is a teacher making his listeners learn music from abida and rahat

[@ArnobMD]

This song is so touching, especially Abida. Got me into tears.

[@ankitatantuway3900]

Only if he knew the meaning of the song he would have cried.. ... A lot... 😭. It's just a blissful song. It touches the soul

[@hashbrowns363]

Hi, dude your reactions are pretty amazing and professional than others... I wish you listen more to pakistani legendary singers. Thanks

[@muhammadnaveedtariq9315]

Rahat was looking kid infront of living legend Abida Parveen

[@vivekjoshi914]

carl...i dont have any knowledge of music per se....i just enjoy music...and your reaction my friend are not just reaction...you explain, describe and compare things better...love to hear you...keep up the good work ( not that you need my appreciation :P) loads of love and respect brother!!

[@sarahusman6123]

Adiba parveen is living legend of Pakistan.

[@UsmanBabar28]

@Carl, Normally I dontwatch reaction videos at all. Just started watching reaction videos 2 days ago, watched few people who don't have any idea or technical knowledge, they just overreact. You're the only guy with technical knowledge and very decent feedback. More power to you mate

[@bkadnan786]

They legends mate they doing singing training all day all night so much hard work and dedicated people anyway great job can u plz do reaction on coke studio Allah ho Akbar Thnks

[@Barkat90]

Totally agree

[@moon-tf6si]

Basically both of the singers r legends and u can call them Master of music art Abida voice and devotion for music is out if this world

[@Codetutor-DemystifyCoding]

You should have enabled captions.. Codestudio always do a very good job accurate translations. You would have been able to appreciate it even more. Next time if you are reacting to anything from Codestudio, always enable captions.

[@SunoArbabSaood07]

See the respect for each other by both legends 🙂❤️

[@PodPerk11]

Yu should go for Rahat fateh ali khan feat Amjad sabri (late)

[@shafaqbukhari9573]

When ABIDA PARVEEN JI sings your soul listen to her your body got nothing to do with it that's why you feel connected as if you knew her your entire life. She is something else It's my dream to listen her live.

[@BrajeshKumar-ez8zs]

Don't try...don't even try!

[@tajofalltrades]

really interesting that you said that Abida Parveen's voice has so much depth it feels like you have heard it your whole life and are listening to it again. I really do feel that way and have felt like I knew who she was based off of just her voice

[@osamaalam7685]

Pakistani musicians are levels ahead from other musicians in subcontinent, which is why they are as famous in rest of the subcontinent as they are in Pakistan, and this is the primary reason our Bollywood composers steal their music without giving an iota of credit to original singers,lyricists and composers, what a shame!!!

[@shubhendranathsingh9888]

I think Bollywood songs are very bad currently and has been like this after 1970 but quite original. I don't think Indian or Pakistani non movie music are much different. All come from the same roots. People talk about poets but forget that most of them were born here in India(pre 1947). If you think every piece of music/poetry is Pakistani in coke studio then you are wrong. Khusro was Indian.

[@osamaalam7685]

@@shubhendranathsingh9888 there was no Pakistan or India at that time but nizame dehli , Mughal empire and other such empires existed. Amir khisro was the disciple of nizam ud din auliya of Delhi sultanate and at that time whole modern day Pakistan was under it but you can't say that whole modern day India was ruled but Delhi sultanate, south was ruled by different empire at that time.

[@shubhendranathsingh9888]

@@osamaalam7685 What? This statement doesn't make Amir Khusro Pakistani as you are stating in your original comment. In India all the religions reside. The language of the poetry is also Hindavi.

[@osamaalam7685]

@@shubhendranathsingh9888 you are hallucinating it seems , i didn't mention anything about amir khusrow at all in my main comment.

[@shubhendranathsingh9888]

@@osamaalam7685 Pakistani musicians, this is the word you used. If you meant about the instrumental music then you should check some history. Indian instrumentalists are way good. We don't need to steal music of Pakistani musicians we have our own musicians.

[@IrfanA7861]

Thanks! waited so many days for this video

[@asg1183]

There only 2 rules with singing. 1. Closed eyes 2. Open heart 😋

[@ramishbashir1956]

You're such a great reactor.. You pin-point all the notes.. I love your reactions.. You have sense of judgement.. Keep doing reaction videos you have my support 🤗

[@tarunmakwana645]

Biggest fan of rahat fateh👌👏🎶🎶

[@keepinitrreal]

I love your reaction. You are a genuine guy 😁

[@manishreal8095]

Abida Ji from another world just connects our heart

[@MaggieGueder]

I agree with you, some coaches are always talking about your mouth and jaw and neck and posture... And there are so many singers who sound amazing even if they are laying on the floor

[@manjivsharma8892]

Dude posture is extremely important in Indian classical music but as you said it yourself the better you get the more rules you can break. They may look completely laid back but both of them have decades of training and practice to be able to present themselves like that.

[@manjivsharma8892]

@haider ali bahadur dude honestly, music has no borders you can't appreciate something while throwing hate.

[@shubhamvatsvats9]

@haider ali bahadur This song was written by Indian... And there nothing like Pakistan classical music... 70 years of origin mein kya classic layega bhai... Its all indian classical, raag, 7 sur sa re ga ma Everything.. Accept it or not

[@shubhamvatsvats9]

@haider ali bahadur bro amir khusro was born in India and died in India... And his language as you can listen is almost like brij... So please stop spreading hatred... You can accept it if you want to

[@shubhamvatsvats9]

@haider ali bahadur hindustan is india... FYI

[@shubhamvatsvats9]

India is the oldest civilization in the world... And we are the only one in the world who protected our culture while having extreme amount of invasion from everywhere...

[@jaskiratbamrah13]

Even punjabi , Indian loves him at exceptional level .no words to describe

[@chaudharywalter4694]

WOW. Please react to "Saari Raat" CokeStudio.

[@Shahidkhan-qj5cy]

Cheers Carl for reacting to Pakistani traditional music! Coming from a Pakistani household I've shared l have always ignored this music because of personal issues. Watching your videos made me appreciate them. Keep doing what you're doing

[@bhupindersingh-yd6rl]

I laughed so hard when u said some of the coaches in west tend to constrain from such singing and often don’t pay much attention to these sort of singing at this high pitch cause after all humans are singing , not machines and the reason being west coaches doesn’t go out of their confort zone and haven’t master such singing yet. Perhaps one day.. waiting

[@pemadamdul]

Music in this part of the world has been polished over few thousand years compare to few decades of the western pop music. Don't think they'll understand much. It's like 5 year old who just learnt to bike criticizing a professional bmx biker because it looks dangerous.

[@SomebodySaid]

@@pemadamdul well said ❤️

[@Grandmaster-Yas]

These are some supremely talented folk. Great vid mate!

[@A-G-23]

The best part of the song was given to the chorus :D

[@fahadsami1590]

Just keep this in mind you are listening probably 80 to 90 years of singing experience between these legends. That's classical eastern trained voices or if you go even back for rahat then they are probably the 5th to 6th generation of a singing family. They are called as ustads( maestros) you or anyone just don't qualify to judge them. What you're listening is absolute ROYALTY.

[@azeemmoh.2399]

Reaction please for Rahats amazing Performance of the nobel price for Malala !!! You should do it !!!

[@SheikhAT]

So much depth in her sound.. Finally you said it! ❤️

[@nadeemahmed1694]

So awesome

[@realhuman7908]

Rahat fateh and Aabida parveen have raised to such a high level where they can make their own rules. specially aabida parveen is counted in few legends of indian classical and sufi music.