Vocal Coach Reacts to GiGi Yim x Janice - "Million Reasons" Live Stage｜Gigi

[@tfylhk]

Quoted " really great, both of them, really really great "對一位只有15-16歲小女生是很大讚賞

[@言森]

Hi Rosette, thanks for the reaction. Gigi was only 16 while performing this song during a singing contest organized by HKTVB and she won all the awards finally. Janice was her adviser during the contest. You may easy feel that her voice was a bit tight and tired under high stress of the contest. They performed the song again in a concert one month after the contest and you may find that Gigi sang it much easy under no contest pressure situation: Million reasons(Concert live)start at 05:40 kzbin.info/www/bejne/mae4qq2rfbtsbKMsi=2sDBmMUEp7YwP4HR BTW, you may also enjoy her cover of “Perfect” while she was only 15. Her voice could be so sweet with lovely country mood: Perfect(pure raw recorded by iPhone) kzbin.info/www/bejne/aYGZnGxpisZ0e6csi=wOZNiLXuJOMPOYlI

[@keungchan9174]

老師真係非常專業及作出適合真實的評語,對閣下十分敬佩。 這《聲夢傳奇》是一個比賽又是一項培訓學員的節目,比賽可長達半年以上時間,這視頻中Janice 是導師, gigi 是參賽者及學員,視頻中janice不是參與比賽,只是協助學員合唱一曲,評判只會對gigi給于分數及評語,而這次比賽她取得全部三個獎項冠軍,立刻視為未來超級新星。這視頻已是三年前16歲的gigi,在15至16歲約半年時間比賽中唱了多首歌,絕大部分都超過百萬點擊,甚至3、4百萬,她的音樂可塑性太多太豐富,其實她每首歌都思考不同演繹方式,是個多變聲線的歌手,希望兩位男女主持能推介更多gigi近期及早期的參賽歌,都是那麼迷人吸引❤

[@teresalouie7408]

Thanks for your reaction to Gigi. Love her voice and singing. The video was taken 3 years ago and she was only 16. During that particular session, Janice acted as her in-program coach and provided assistance with her singing. Hopefully, you will have the chance to hear her more recent singing soon. Gigi has shown significant improvement since winning the competition.

[@zyli7083]

Thank you teacher for the reaction to Gigi’s performance when she was merely 16 well before her debut as a singer. What intrigued me most is your comment on Gigi’s “wildness rawness of the early 2000 singers” indeed she possesses an “old spirit” in her voice and you can find that abundantly in her later performances as a singer. Look forward to more of your reactions to Gigi !

[@Sunny28888]

Thank you teacher said ：Both of them are really really good👍 Now Gigi is the best young singers in Hong Kong and mainland China 👍

[@paulchan2591]

Gigi was 15-16 back then and her singing skills have improved a lot in the past couple of years! She was already very good then. It would be great if teacher can comment on her performance of ‘Fei Fei’, which has over 7 million views now! Or some more recent performances🎉

[@jwong952004]

Thank you for reacting on this performance. This was back to 2 years ago when Gigi was doing a singing contest and Janice was there to help (coach and sing). Gigi was 15/16 years old at that time, after learning singing for 3 years.

[@daniel-giyimfans]

兩位都係我喜歡聽的歌手，衞蘭很穩很札實，炎明熹仍在進步中，但她每次演唱都有不同變化，所以常會期待她的演唱，片尾老師的演唱也很利害，謝謝老師的點評，另我對喜愛的歌手演出認識多了。

[@ccw1595]

支持我們的火星女孩gigi🥰🥰🥰

[@bno6513]

Looking forward for this reaction, and there are more recent live preforments for more reaction too. 好期待Thanks

[@cky5218]

Finally, I was hoping you would do a reaction on Gigi Yim. She was 15/16 when she sang with Janice back then. Hope you would do more of her recent performances but it’s a start.

[@dyl7571]

Janice!!! My favorite female singer from Hong Kong!

[@KTpstan]

Love Gigi voice..looking forward to react on her latest performance and her own English song Crystal Clear …thank you❤

[@heichan2082]

Thx for react gigi, she is a young and good singer, love her so much❤

[@RC-uw9wf]

終於等到啦😂😂😂❤❤❤

[@wafflecoffee4909]

Love this performance❤ Gigi has a lot of potential and is improving everyday, loves her voice , kind of agree most of your comments thanksss👍🏻

[@homanhong4777]

It is a good start. Hope you will react Crystal clear by Gigi Yim later. Can't wait to watch this.

[@lionhead-ex4bw]

支持G G衛蘭

[@lwlee777]

Looking forward to seeing your reaction to Gigi - hope you can locate some of her recent performances- you’ll be amazed with her growth 🎉🎉🎉

[@VE_HK]

Gigi has further enhanced singing performance of Million Reasons in Summer 2021 group concert relative to this performance she was only 16 years old (1 month after her bday) back then! Bravo Gigi!

[@李东宇-g3l]

终于看到卫兰了

[@danielwong1764]

Should do some reactions to Janice 👍

[@ccw1595]

多謝老師的評語和分析，雖然當時是16歲的gigi，但老師的意見對gigi來說依然是難能可貴。希望老師能分享gigi較為後期的歌曲，讓大家一起見證這位充滿唱歌熱誠的女孩成長之路，感激萬分！💖💖💖🙏🙏🙏

[@marial1463]

Support Gigi! She is great. Love her.

[@Jojo4wowo]

Many Thanks for your reaction to Gigi. 😊

[@genieinavocal685]

One of the best singer in hk! Please react Janice more and more

[@qinqi6043]

非常感谢您直白的点评。

[@keungchan9174]

好多謝老師讚賞Gigi 這新生代歌手,這視頻已是3年前的比賽,16歲完成比賽後成為歌手,她所唱的每一首歌都大受歡迎,更受到馬來西亞及加拿大等各地華人關注及歡迎,上年十月及今年四月中都有自己的演唱會,她是一個實力及偶像级歌手,在內地已大受歡迎,成中央電視台近兩三年邀請表演的熱門歌手之一❤

[@Jiminjiminhan]

華語新天后💜💜

[@yatkwonchin-db9vk]

老師其實想講『雙非炎零實力夾住把柒聲扮可愛，不過志矮俾咗錢我，夾硬捧佢幾句喇😊』

[@setosir-du4vd]

​@@yatkwonchin-db9vk🪳🤏

[@SO移動]

​@@yatkwonchin-db9vk捨得躝未啫 含加慘🤣

[@norahschan1753]

Thanks so much for your reaction. Looking forward to seeing more reaction to Gigi💜 1. Crystal Clear (2023) kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z2PSp6etfZl4f8Usi=r-ofmRAtJLEt7O8K 2. 蜚蜚 (2022) kzbin.info/www/bejne/gGm9YquLjthnerssi=Wc7sLnnHuo6_zkGC 3. 網絡安全隱患 (2023) kzbin.info/www/bejne/g3-kanmtetKhlaMsi=J4x5Z8Rx2nEX9Asw

[@marcoma61]

Looking forward to GiGI Yim and Janice performances

[@elmomo696]

我都係因呢首歌而開始鍾意咗大舊G，一失足成千古恨，萬劫不復了！😅入咗無底深坑呀😂😂

[@klw5585]

期待有衛蘭更多的歌

[@lamhop5040]

全力支持Gigi 炎明熹唱英文歌特別好聽💪💪💪😄🔥🔥🔥💜💜💜👍👍👍👏👏👏♥️♥️♥️😍

[@keungchan9174]

Gigi當然肯定沒有内地很多歌手那種澎湃力量型,但聲色藝幾乎是全面,在舞台上魅力非凡,如果這老師能觀看gigi更多舞台視頻,好肯定會令閣下感驚喜👍

[@Jiminjiminhan]

Gigi 的聲線是比較全面的，不是一味好似某啲人咁靠高音同嗌歌出嚟吸引人😆

[@hollandbankchq]

炎明燾係可以有power，例子是 Bad Romance。但更多時間佢唱高音，類似王菲嘅風格。要度身訂造一首歌才可以同時顯示兩種風格，等待中，來日方長。

[@ccpp4733]

Gigi❤❤❤

[@phchan3558]

小妹妹十五六歲參加電視台唱歌比賽,雖然有許多改進空間但她能給人留下深刻印象,勇於嘗試而且唱法獨特❤

[@shootingstarsxxk6522]

Thank you for reaching Gigi's performance!💜

[@yingwong]

老師唱得好正好有力❤❤😍 依兩位歌手我也❤聽

[@cky5218]

Thank you for reacting to Gigi and Janice

[@ccw1595]

明白老師的reaction是要排隊，就有勞你們幫gigi再來排隊吧，可以嗎？🌷🌷🌷🍭🍭🍭

[@kinyu3038]

我想知道大約需要幾耐？

[@ccw1595]

​@@kinyu3038唔知呀，因為太多粉絲要求老師react自己偶像嘅歌，老師今次react Million Reasons，我都好意外，亦替gigi感到榮幸，好希望快些有下一次💕💕💕

[@MOZyanyi]

I’ve been waiting it for long time!!Finally!!!

[@wongallon4945]

這是未出道前的gigi，多謝老師中肯的評價，希望有機會老師可評評gigi 的“願”（個人很喜歡這首）及近期啲歌

[@EddieSLLeung-wj2ig]

Great performance for Gigi who is only 15-16years old when joined this singing competition. ❤❤❤

[@nirvanaprajna9516]

Looking forward for reacting GiGi english song "crystal clear"

[@userightme_luk9977]

Janice is one of the top female singers in Hong Kong, who is a singer with a strong singing style, can sing both Chinese and English.

[@ooooo2211]

Support Gigi ❤❤❤❤

[@twbestbest8945]

第一次聽到衛蘭唱的是(大哥) 好聽~

[@keungchan9174]

或者再聽聽Gigi 不同音樂,可能會發現她的音質清澈多變,可以唱出西方式的音樂,也能演繹中國式仙女音樂,就算一首歌中都會呈現不同音質聲線,加上各式音樂技巧,真係一個天才歌手❤

[@manting8912]

火星女孩👍👍👍

[@luckycat5362]

support gigi ❤

[@boooooo3794]

Support GiGi , thanks for your comment

[@wingchung9272]

oh thats Gigi performance 3 years ago when she was 16 years. i love the texture of sound of Gigi sound, but hope she can strengthen her high notes on B4 or above. Hope teacher can giver her good comment❤

[@ccw1595]

3年前青澀有瑕疵的演出，今天或以後回看，都會很有意思，support gigi🍹🍹🍹🥰🥰🥰

[@danfans]

Awaiting your show❤

[@chandanny6234]

期待老師評Gigi crystal clear

[@Andywusuilung]

期待❤

[@Benelmogigigem]

gigi終於有機會係度出現了！😍

[@keungchan9174]

Gigi 竟然同老師有一個共通點,就係非常喜愛周深,可惜周深可能永遠不知老師評論過,反而gigi很好彩在23年的第三季ㄍ聲生不息》節目相遇,gigi怕羞尷尬非常可愛,有機會兩主持給老師欣賞,了解gigi可愛火星女孩一面😂

[@keungchan9174]

老師提出一個很有趣觀點，就係成熟老練, gigi 當時只有15、6歲參加比賽,但唱歌竟然非常熟練穩定,同衛蘭導師也異常融合和唱,令老師也错覺這是比賽嗎？也感謝老師讚賞這小妹妹表現出色。其實gigi不只學習西方歌手音樂,也涉獵不同歌唱音樂,也鑽研唱歌技巧,其豐富多變的聲音,已有自己獨特的gi腔唱法,加上舞台表演生動出色,令粉絲們沉醉當中❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@whoeverwhat9919]

老師說的成熟老練是說衛蘭。老師都有讚Gigi,讚她fresh

[@keungchan9174]

​​​​​​​@@whoeverwhat9919我說成熟老練是觀點,而成熟一詞白痴都知是年纪比較大啦！我只是說Gigi熟練穩定,這是我的感覺,明未?

[@ericcheung6793]

💜💜💜💜💜💯💯💯💯💯

[@keithloi1348]

Janice has been a professional singer since 2004, while Gigi was a secondary school student at that time. Janice was one of the tutors of Gigi in the competition.

[@chunlamlee9758]

Nah,gigi born in2005

[@alanwong9134]

仲有一首希望老師評測。今生今世 kzbin.info/www/bejne/pHW8hpmlorpljJofeature=shared 😊❤

[@ErenLam]

最鐘意gigi😁

[@ray888wong]

Gigi was just show her talent in this competition, better performance after this show, she was growth up and much better now, you might react her recent performance, thanks

[@wongallon4945]

似乎很多人也很期待老師的評語，且個個都很有信心似的 講真，我也等了很久，剛剛想留言希望老師可給GIGI意見，但按入嚟就見到這篇了，慳番😂 希望這只是開始，往後多些給GIGI意見，等GIGI可更全面成長 多謝老師

[@tiklokwok6670]

多些給GIGI意見, 怕唔怕又俾gigi block ig.

[@wongallon4945]

​@@tiklokwok6670 我只怕小人的

[@setosir-du4vd]

​@@tiklokwok6670点呀 小人

[@yatkwonchin-db9vk]

老師其實想講『雙非炎零實力夾住把柒聲扮可愛，不過志矮俾咗錢我，夾硬捧佢幾句喇😊』

[@setosir-du4vd]

​@@yatkwonchin-db9vk🪳🤏

[@Gigisuperfans_0409]

Thx for appreciate Gi

[@WaiMingPoon-k5w]

Gigi, keep fighting 💪❤️👍

[@user94133]

Why didn't the person who did the intro of Gigi mention she was 16 despite the quiz from the vocal coach...

[@bno6513]

Happy 19th birthday to Gigi🎉

[@yiu6206]

希望可評論gigi 蜚蜚

[@Insaneee0]

finally got janice！！she is the diva of cantopop❤

[@拾伍-c8q]

Thanks for reacting gigi 🎉🎉

[@mxstar14]

哇！卫兰！Janice！终于轮到她了！

[@tunglok8156]

👏👏👏

[@skyhill33]

明心見性

[@ccw1595]

suppprt Gigi always❤❤❤

[@VE_HK]

Still remember it was so touching to hear Gigi's singing this song back in SA show in 2021 when she was 16 years old! Really like Gigi's deep emotional story-telling rendition of this song! Agree with the Vocal coach's comments & Gigi did enhance her singing skills in summer concert 2021.

[@Gary-xo1de]

老師說得很好，Gigi當時只是15-16歲追尋夢想的小女孩，Janice 是她的導師去幫助她，發揮她的天賦，她的聲音很獨特，這個表演真的很贊，令我成為Gigi 的粉絲，她是香港樂壇的希望❤！

[@yatkwonchin-db9vk]

老師其實想講『雙非炎零實力夾住把柒聲扮可愛，不過志矮俾咗錢我，夾硬捧佢幾句喇😊』

[@Gary-xo1de]

@@yatkwonchin-db9vk 我係咪要笑架？

[@kennyw381]

​@@yatkwonchin-db9vk你個七頭皮有狗糧食😅

[@kyusadan]

@@yatkwonchin-db9vk 😂😂

[@frienddear-km7dh]

@@yatkwonchin-db9vk 你都唔識英文老作是人都知，而且你是煌獨上老冇得夠。

[@rabbitman5441]

Gigi have a good voice 💜

[@loveavril1022]

我台灣人，我也超愛衛蘭! GIGI是最近看新聞女王才知道她的，唱歌也很好聽

[@bno6513]

Gigi 的"複雜"也很好聽 is a very touching song

[@edwardtsai9158]

衛蘭超多作品都超級好聽，IT'S OK TOO BE SAD、一格格、街燈晚餐、愛你還愛你、伯利恆的主角、低半度、心亂如麻.....，太多了，而且他唱現場LIVE真的是我聽過最強的香港女歌手！

[@jfky]

👍👍💪💪❤❤

[@KC-pv5cr]

Gigi😊😊😊

[@priscillaso0831]

多謝老師支持香港樂壇，其實仲有好多唱得好聽嘅歌手，我最欣賞聲夢2黃洛妍Janees唱功勁好捧👍，當時參賽歌曲《溝渠暢泳》Janees將首歌發揮得淋漓盡致，聽出耳油完全感受到Janees對音樂熱誠及愛載，希望老師都去聽下Janees唱嘅《溝渠暢泳》歌曲。

[@lemonstar5308]

Gigi😘

[@marcolau3271]

Janice ❤ !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Please do more reviews for Janice who is well known for her pure and angelic voice !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!❤ p.s. Janice is highly influenced by Mariah Carey and you can tell from her singing ❤

[@ericlo6370]

Gigi is a rare breed in HK Cantopop scene. She has her own unique and signature singing style and intonation that is very cool and chic! She is becomimng the pillar of HK Cantopop scene for sure. Not about riffs and run, oone just drawn to her unique voice ! Janice was her mentor who is in a match mode of duet singing with contestants' mentors. Janice is seaoned, almost too lubricated , but in a great way!

[@jill55jill]

nice !!

[@lk1872]

唱完起碼無講 We did it 先啦~🤣

[@Man-bv6ms]

相信Gigi 聽到您嘅評語一定會謙虛接受❤ 另外，唔好再喺度話咩佢係百年一遇嘅天后啦，咁樣會令佢好大壓力，亦只會招黑。🙏🏻

[@ccw1595]

同意，gigi只係一位向著每一個舞台前進，盡力做好自己的歌手❤❤❤

[@hhllee307]

I look forward to seeing your reaction to Gin Lee, she is Gigi‘s teacher in that singing contest. Gin Lee is also one of the most powerful female singer in Hong Kong, she has a really good voice, stable performance and outstanding technique in singing❤

[@impsper]

Gigi is a new star in HK Now is even maturer

[@athomenotavailable]

终于轮到 炎明熙了。 几时也和Rozette 分享曾比特，肯定被圈粉。

[@kklocker]

Janice 字句細膩處理 非常厲害

[@raventaylorsonvt4204]

開心 終於有衛蘭 可唔可以評多少少衛蘭 香港隱藏天后 可惜沒有回去內地發展導致很多人不認識她

[@PANda-ecpP]

👍👍👍👍

[@Sunny28888]

I would like to remind you during this competition Janice was a vocal teacher

[@ryanchok6428]

Gigi真的是現今香港有實力的新星之一，但現在香港有很多人因為政治因素，只要歌手藝人們不在自己政治立場內的地方演就會去否定或排斥他們，Gigi也算是其他一位，還有一位很有實力的男歌手(曾比特)，希望老師也可以點評一下他的唱功🙏🏿

[@dicolee1]

終於等到這位老師評GIGI了....可惜是參賽時仍在緊張狀態下,狀態不穩時的表演 , *補充一點,GIGI唱這歌運用的基本是西式唱法 , 沒能展示他的GI式唱腔(即絲滑的真假轉音)* *補充多點...^^"如果選聲夢比賽的歌曲來鑑賞 , 我個人會選(說故事感強烈),或(唱歌與身體舞姿融合得非常好,賞心悅目)* 我個人較建議老師可以參看下面這段,澳門現場LIVE,,個人認為是完美,天籟之音. -現場觀眾收音版 kzbin.info/www/bejne/j3nUfK2VqtaJpas -官方後製版 kzbin.info/www/bejne/qGbGZ36ghb6VnMU