IMPOSSIBLE COIN SORTING MACHINE - how to make

[@Andy-jq5yw]

The amount of "I don't have the correct tool, but I have *a* tool" that takes place in this video is staggering! Amazing craftsmanship when you've got so many limitations

[@Wellorep]

The correct tool is... the one that gets the job done..lol

[@bank8489]

There is no such thing as the correct tool.

[@areyouundoingthatorwhat9181]

Ingenuity comes hand in hand with over complicating stuff for the sake of it😁.

[@kevinsellsit5584]

I got a kick out of the 775 motor powered cut-off machine.

[@NetworkOverflow]

They always say: "A good craftsman never blames his tools" I say: "A great craftsman makes his own tools!"

[@stelvio5213]

Noi lo vediamo così...in 20 minuti ma c'è un lavoro dietro impressionante. Tra progettazione, manodopera ed editing video ci vogliono giorni per costruire un progetto del genere. Hai tutto il mio rispetto 💪

[@DanieleTartaglia]

Mi fa piacere che vedete anche il dietro le quinte, grazie 😀👍

[@florestankoenigs8274]

The idea with the transparent sorting mechanism from the laser cutter is genius. It looks like art and would be worth to be shown in a museum.

[@denniswoycheshen]

The bottom half doesn't even do anything really. All the sorting is done up top. It would be a little more elegant to incorporate the sorting into the laser cut section.

[@Trenjeska]

@@denniswoycheshen The sorting on SIZE is done on top, THEN the sorting on VALUE is done in the squiggly middle part. The bottom part just neatly stacks the coins.

[@denniswoycheshen]

@@Trenjeska sorry, in Canada the coins we use are different sizes, so there is no need to sort by value as well. :)

[@denniswoycheshen]

@@Trenjeska wait a minute, do you live somewhere where coins are the same size or something? The sorting is done first, the rest is just for show.

[@paulbritton187]

@@denniswoycheshen let's see your build then?

[@yedead1]

You could keep track of how many coins are in each stack instead of the total. You could also add load cells to keep track of each stack weight then when a user removes coins from the stack (as long as it knows the avg weight of each single coin, could easily be done with constants in the arduino program) then it could automatically update how many are left/total amount.

[@matthewhodge9748]

A small spring that Is attached to a bucket, every time a specific weight is reached it drops coins it will be enough to make a roll. This way you always have rolls in the count not uneven counts.

[@-_IT_-]

Doing it by weight would not work considering that coins pick up grime which can alter the weight. It just would not be accurate.

[@russelljazzbeck]

@@-_IT_-there should be a minimum weight, like if it's heavier than a pristine coin from the previous value, then it accounts for all the added grime. either way, it's totally possible to have a range, or even make predictions with formulas that account for variations in weight, especially since those variations are extremely small

[@yedead1]

@@-_IT_- That's why you take the average weight, doesn't need to the exact weight just a ball park number (something like +/- 10-15%). Also its not like the load cells will have exact result, there will be differences between each cell.

[@gianpietrovairo3557]

Daniele, non ho parole per i tuoi progetti! Archimede Pitagorico ti fa un baffo!

[@Uzwel]

Awesome video, very well made and edited, no unneeded redundancy, perfect use of speedups and jump cuts , very nice POV and amazing project made with minimal tooling 10/10 👏I subscribed and Rang the bell 🛎

[@kjellverbeke6058]

unneeded redundancy is my new favorite redundancy

[@TheMcSebi]

"minimal tooling" > boots up the laser cutter

[@JoseSilveira-newhandleforYT]

That is the weirdest and most impressive coin sorting machine I have ever seen 🙂 Well done!

[@elye3701]

You ain't seen nuthin yet. Behold no-moving-parts - - - kzbin.info/www/bejne/rIvEg5qDhNRgf8k

[@kevinsellsit5584]

@@elye3701 You were impressed by the US (4 coin type) coin sorter that required constant help from the operator to stack the coins because it did not have a vibrator function. Where this machine works flawlessly sorting 8 types of coins with one (1) moving part and counts them as well. Behold, I'm not impressed by this link.

[@elye3701]

@@kevinsellsit5584 I have used a kiosk coin machine at a Japanese supermarket. Just load in the coins. Collect the rejects and hand the receipt to customer service in exchange for a voucher. This adds too much bling. I bet there is no service manual to troubleshoot this in case of problems. What do you do in case the lights go out? 8 is just twice 4. There is nothing to limit you if you carve one yourself out of a piece of plank. What would impress me is a computer program that would, given a set of coins, control a milling machine to carve a suitable sorter. If you give me the machine above, I wouldn't take it. In fact you would have to pay me to take it. We have 5,10,20 and 50 denominations of coins. 1 is obsolete but you can still find them in the coin donation boxes. Then the central bank released a new set. So we have 9 denominations in total. Added to this you can find 10cents Singaporean, 100Baht and various Rupee coins with an occasional UK coin. In reality those of us helping to count the church collection face up to 16 sizes of coins. I don't think that machine above can handle this real world sample. An in-between size would enter the next bigger slot and get counted wrongly. Not even close and and no cigar. You have a low bar. I am not impressed.

[@SecularMentat]

This was amazing. I love the ingenuity going on here. A lot of thought has been put into this machine.

[@____julia____]

After all that amazing precision work the amount labels were just stuck on and don't line up! My OCD hurts 😱😱

[@Mickeycuatropatas]

He could have done it with the laser CNC that he cut those cool coin roller coasters with.

[@nolegotube]

Beautiful project...as always! Thanks for sharing!

[@sammyjunior4168]

Non so se esistano campionati DIY su KZbin ma hai già vinto la coppa del mondo. Un abbraccio.

[@tracybowling1156]

This is a great coun machine. I really love it! The only thing missing from the video is how you get the coins out. That would be pretty cool to see.

[@frenchimp]

Actually you can't. The coins are lost forever. Unless the end section is open at the front...

[@unsearchablethings8167]

Sir, from one engineer to another, you have some mad design skills!

[@w8101]

Cool work ！ Just two things want to comment : - Future Coin edge design change (non cicular) - Non-euro coin (Else handling)

[@matsv201]

Most coin sorting machines use a tear system with typicallt 1-5 cent category, 10-50cent category then €1 and 2 category. This way the sorting can be split 3 ways two times. The first sorting is typicallt with magnetic indukction, (simply by roaling past a magnet) second by width.

[@bsvenss2]

and? What's your point?

[@jlucasound]

@@bsvenss2 This machine is better. Right OVER your head. Wow.

[@ferppasena4779]

Ótimo trabalho! Like sempre!!! 👏👏👏👏🇧🇷

[@marsim4150]

questa sorting machine è una eclissi totale per tutti gli altri video dello stesso tipo, veramente un gran lavoro :-)

[@robertlafata5154]

Rube Goldberg would be proud. Awesome build.

[@electronic7979]

Excellent project 👍

[@h-leath6339]

Either you have too much time on your hands or that was too easy for you, whichever is more frightening. Brilliant and beautiful! Thank you!

[@БогданФеджора]

Good job. 16:08 Oops, the coin is stuck.

[@centralappliance1]

You are amazing you should think about putting out projects for kids to do and learn about electronics. We need more of you in this world for sure... Simply amazing skills and craftsmanship... I can't say enough great things about you!!

[@vicvancen]

Is this just a hobby you have or are you doing this for a living? What did you learn to gain the skills you have to build something like this. I'm still pretty young, but what you're doing is inspiring to me

[@carloantoniomartinelli5418]

E' UN C A P O L A V O R O !!! mi compiaccio con Lei per l'ingegnosita', l'immaginazione, la perizia, la pazienza, la tenacia. BRAVO !

[@AsitShouldBe]

Ammazza! gran bel lavoro davvero, non è un lavoretto da fare in un pomeriggio questo!!

[@DanieleTartaglia]

no, neanche in qualche giorno 😣

[@frenchimp]

You have achieved perfection, Sir! Next project would be a coin generator...

[@gemer84]

"The project is very complex and complicated" The not explaining how you do it really helps!

[@cliffmathew]

Well produced video. Amazing craftsmanship and creativity!

[@MarcoDiBattistafaidate]

Oltre all'intelligenza e le capacità vedo delle ottime riprese, le prenderò come spunto per i miei tutorial ,complimenti Daniele

[@DanieleTartaglia]

Mi fa molto piacere, grazie 😜👍

[@bjharvey3021]

Danny Tenaglia is an amazing DJ. Famous the world over.

[@stevenightfox6022]

Nice machine👍 As idea for version 4.0: A mechanism to roll the right amount of coins in a package for the bank, maybe checked by weight like the bank does😊

[@AxGryndr]

That custom saw using a cut off wheel blade is amazing!

[@onorator]

Un lavoraccio per un risultato da capogiro. Immagino le notti insonni a progettare, la ricerca dei materiali, la previsione del risultato. Se non fosse così.....verrei a scassarti tutte le macchine per la gigantesca invidia che mi susciteresti fino a soffocarmi. 🤣🤣🤣🤣. Comunque sia, un bell'oggetto....i miei complimenti (mannaggia) 😂😂😂

[@DanieleTartaglia]

Ti ringrazio, ma ci penso già io a scassare le macchine quando non lavorano come si deve 😂comunque un' aiuto mi farebbe comodo

[@carlubambi5541]

Un bello lavoro.Greetings from Toronto .

[@masterkingblast9819]

I hope you will get 1 million soon

[@MatteoGhibelli]

Favoloso! Bellissima la discesa delle monete a layer sovrapposti! Sempre una grande fonte di ispirazione!

[@shrikantjalihal1544]

Waw, very nice and exhaustive work. But your patience is highly appreciated, nice project.

[@PupettaZoccola]

Questo è il nostro Daniele diResta, si resta fino alla fine a guardare i suoi video, grande Daniele

[@appaio]

Sei sempre fonte di ispirazione. È un piacere vedere costruire cose tanto elaborate

[@spidertube4642]

Davvero notevole !!!! ho sempre pensato che meccanismi così complessi si potessero fare solo con riconoscimento ottico della moneta ed invece in effetti basta il diametro. Al limite poi girando la scanalatura principale al contrario si potrebbero scremare le monete NON EURO in quanto non intaccate dalle linguette dei diametri, ma per il resto è un'automazione a livello professionale.Hai un metodo di lavoro preciso, pulito e chiaro da capire. Complimenti davvero ! tanti like x te !!! :D

[@DanieleTartaglia]

Grazie mille. Purtroppo non è possibile scremare altre monete non Euro perchè le misure prima o poi quel diametro viene comunque riconosciuto.

[@spidertube4642]

@@DanieleTartaglia caspita e' vero hai ragione non ci avevo pensato. L'unica e' la pesatura oppure il riconoscimento ottico della facciata B della moneta.

[@DanieleTartaglia]

@@spidertube4642 Esatto, ma non è alla portata del fai da te riconoscere monete diverse dal' euro. Una soluzione c'è, almeno è quello che mi è venuto in mente. Quando smisti la moneta, esempio quella da 1 euro, devi fare un' altro stesso percorso con con due lamelle: Una leggermente piu grande e quella settata per quella da 1 euro. Se la moneta non è euro, ma non ha le stesse identiche misure, o viene buttata dalla prima lamella perchè leggermente piu alta oppure, se piu bassa del' euro, va nel reparto delle monete non EURO. Però è troppo dispendioso e non vale la pena.

[@spidertube4642]

@@DanieleTartaglia troppo articolato come schema. Hai ragione. Però questo tuo progetto e' xfetto x un contamonete domestico. Anche se però per evitare inceppature e' d'obbliogo risolvere il problema della "moneta estranea". Cmq ancora complimenti per tutto quanto ! 👏👏👏👏👏

[@stevebabiak6997]

@@DanieleTartaglia - awesome machine. I was going to ask about how foreign currency is handled, but I see you have already conceded that it could be done but at a greater level of effort. v4.0 maybe … The only thing for those of us with other currencies is that this is euro only - us non-Europeans would have to make some changes for our native currency.

[@kevinsellsit5584]

Impossible Coin Sorting Machine: Apparently not. Impressive Coin Sorting Machine: Absolutely! Note: Don't worry, nobody noticed the stuck coin at 16:09. (Probably fixed itself when next coin fell.) Technology these days is truly amazing. The fact that your electronics were able to auto-detect and self-program (and only be off by 1.0 decimal) is mind-boggling. ;) Insane machine and awesome video!

[@masterwood2636]

da brevettare subito anzi prima di subito, complimenti sempre oggetti interessanti, che stupiscono, come la tua bravura

[@SergioPendola]

Pazzesco che lavoro, complimenti

[@pescareinsardegna8437]

Sono a dir poco impressionato. Veramente bella. Rimarreri tutto il giorno a guardarla.

[@npcwill283]

It will either last a week or the grandkids will marvel at paps's genius !

[@alvintechnology49]

Watching my friend full support❤👋👍

[@Xedef885]

Che figata questo 3.0 è strabiliante, la complessità dei pezzi,rende ancora più fantastica la cosa.

[@cetesan9541]

You are super innovator!!!!!

[@primemac3dstudio18]

Just a few things. 1 I think a little bit faster time-laps would be a bit better. 2. A 3D print of this design would be sweet. 3. 3D modeling this design would be very interesting challenge. Good video over all.

[@heartsky]

Meticulous work, and a joy to watch!

[@lorenzomazzocchetti9735]

È fantastico vedere la dedizione e la massima cura nei particolari che metti in ogni piccola grande opera. Grazie di condividere le tue opere d’arte. 🤩🤩

[@stevecann3394]

Amazing craftsmanship as always♥️😃

[@DiegoSiqueiraMenezes]

Isso é incrível! = It's incredible!

[@rainer6662]

100 Thumbs Up cool Project

[@torant]

solo una parola....GENIO!!!

[@Xexxy]

This is awesome. When time is not an issue...

[@samuellehman914]

Interesting and cool to watch it work. I like your mini chop saw at 14:40 do you have plans for how you made it?

[@maykd4481]

I honestly dont have enough coins to made this worth it. Sadly. Great project and video.

[@_username_]

bestiale, pensa averlo progettato, realizzato e montato il video, se non è passione questa... mi sarei fermato già all'idea

[@DanieleTartaglia]

la passione, nel' essere umano è il motore di qualsiasi cosa 😂 comunque alla fine mi sono tolto una gambe e mi sono preso a calci nel sedere per aver ideato questa cosa...la volevo chiamare la machina delle madonne.

[@onigate]

90 minuti d'applausi!! 😮👌

[@Rgb78]

Top! Vedo che ormai voli sempre più alto... Mi chiedo dove arriverai 😁 complimenti

[@DanieleTartaglia]

Si, ma di questo passo finisco come Icaro 😂

[@Rgb78]

@@DanieleTartaglia sono sicuro che costruirai ali più robuste 😁

[@swimmer0284]

Un GENIO!!!! Non c’è altro da aggiungere.

[@KennethRosenstroem]

Looks like you had good fun on this project. Well done!

[@CheapCheerful]

Watching you work is wonderful. Great stuff, and hello from your friends in Australia! :)

[@richardshaw3094]

Nice job...cool project

[@giannilorusso9924]

Un mostro 😱😱😱 di bravura. La macchina per stampare i soldi non l'hai invetatata ancora 😁😁😁?

[@kishannakum3288]

11:20 classic example of how to make things complicated. BTW love your video.

[@alphonsereitz]

Even with words, this video was fun to watch. Thank you.

[@COMPANTO]

Che dire....qui non c'è da dormire neanche la notte. L'ho visto fino alla fine non tanto per il risultato che da te già si sa ma effettivamente come già detto il lavoro che c'è dietro. Tanto di cappello. P.S. il video l'ho girato a Elon Musk 😁😊

[@pascualbeldapenades3504]

Hi, incredible video!! What's the white and black material that slides more than the wood?

[@rattehalliravishankar5606]

Excellent machine. You are the master

[@PhG1961]

Great ingenuity and beautifull too !

[@TheChosenBlade]

Very nice! What kind of laser cutter do you use?

[@claudioerasmo]

Fantastico 👏👏👏👏👏👏😁😁😁👍👍👍👍

[@vairen]

👍 отличное исполнение👍 ещё бы поставили оптический датчик на монетницу которая бы при окончании монет отключала бы вибропривод

[@gymy20]

Very interesting! Nice job!👍

[@lorifairhead8124]

You could add another layer just after the coins are sorted for size to weigh the coin and if it is not right then reject it. I was not quite sure from just looking how coins get into the right level of the reorder mechanism so they come out in order of value? Very interesting project!

[@eduardoviggiano5811]

Che mostro che sei. Non so che altro dire. Complimenti

[@wfroemgen]

It looks great, especially when considering it's build with very basic tools. An inspiration.

[@knightwish1623]

The machine looks and works great and the video was fun to watch, but I don't consider a laser cutting machine as a BASIC tool. For me basic tools are those which are not electrically powered

[@vladimirsagabalk1364]

It's really cool! For continue need create a packaging-mashine for sorted coins and creatу an own bank. :)

[@MarcoGuardigli00]

Veramente un bellissimo lavoro! Bravo Daniele! Mi piace molto la pulizia del progetto, l’accuratezza della lavorazione, e anche le sequenze che hai deciso di montare in modo interessante, chiaro e non pesante. Complimenti anche per i tanti attrezzi autocostruiti che hai presumibilmente fatto! Complimenti!

[@jamesrohland4383]

Fun project if you have an abundance of specialized tools.

[@vittoriob9182]

Fantastico e strabiliante come sempre!

[@fredyy]

Are you using interrupts for the sensors? or are you just checking them individually in a loop?

[@euroscoin6577]

Increíble me encanta ver lo bien que haces las cosas

[@lucatassella]

Wow....sei un Genio !! 🤓

[@francored4166]

Beh, sei un genio, che macchina fantastica, complimenti per l'ingegno

[@pierre84820]

amazing video ! Really nice the copyright in the background I like it ! (it could be even more visible)

[@lightbody232]

very satisfying to watch and am sure it's even more when building.

[@blaster-zy7xx]

I understand that the sorting is all done at the top. Is the mid section only to change the order at the bottom?

[@TheLablujan]

Spettacolare, Daniele !!

[@edwillsmith9845]

Это просто шедевр , автор очень креативный человек . Я ваш кумир )

[@ergoncardia]

Very spectacular indeed !!

[@aldogubinelli5684]

Complimenti!! Come sempre insuperabile, particolari curatissimi e precisi, ti invidio😂

[@enthusiastguy2799]

That is incredibly satisfying to watch. Great work!

[@marcotaticchi5343]

A M A Z I N G ! Bravo!

[@GrowlyBear917]

With all the tools and circuitry needed to make this project, it's a wonder you still have some coins to sort. In the time it took to design and construct this, you could have sorted 4,846,643,456 coins by hand.

[@tonyhardcastle7119]

So cool. Next you might try loops

[@angelocalevro3786]

Bellissimo lavoro

[@eventideaccanove2945]

Giù il cappello Daniele! Figata spaziale!!!