Historian Kate Lister Rates Historic Couples In Movies

  Рет қаралды 417,368

History Hit

History Hit

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 537
@megan5867
@megan5867 Жыл бұрын
I lost it when she said "that old move, he swept her off her feet. I had a partner that did that once, but he buckled" 😂😂😂 Same, girl, same 😂😂😂
@katfromthekong414
@katfromthekong414 9 ай бұрын
That was such an excellent comment, wasn't it! 😂
@Wladislav
@Wladislav 2 жыл бұрын
I fear the analysis of marriage and relationships throughout history is riddled with these _"this person was actually 10-14 years old at the time"_ stories...
@monmothma3358
@monmothma3358 2 жыл бұрын
I think you're right, unfortunately
@gloriamontgomery6900
@gloriamontgomery6900 2 жыл бұрын
Excellent point.
@Katw76
@Katw76 2 жыл бұрын
When you're dead by 30, 15 is middle-aged 🤷‍♀️
@RhosynGwyn
@RhosynGwyn 2 жыл бұрын
@@Katw76 Good point and we judge with modern eyes 13/14 was normal for girls to get married
@christinaandre6286
@christinaandre6286 2 жыл бұрын
Very correct. I despise Braveheart for the fact they made a love story between William Wallace and the princess, when in reality she was I think 2 or 3 years old when he was executed. Also, they didn't wear kilts in that century, but that's a different video lol.
@marykaygerrets6363
@marykaygerrets6363 Жыл бұрын
My grandmother was a 3rd class passenger on the ship that brought her to America. An officer requested someone who spoke Italian to be companion for a 12 year old girl who was traveling 1st class with her parents. Seems the young woman they had hired, backed out at the last minute. My grandmother who was 17 at the time volunteered and as a result spent majority of the time in 1st class. She ate breakfast & lunch with the family but could not attend the dinners since she did not have the proper dress, but the family arranged for her to have the 1st class dinners. One of my grandmother's favorite things to do was to eat it in front of her older sister who suffered from sea sickness.
@Disneyfilmily
@Disneyfilmily Жыл бұрын
That is such a cool story! Did she become friends with the first class girl? Or was it a temporary situation?
@marykaygerrets6363
@marykaygerrets6363 Жыл бұрын
No, both went their own way. The girl was from NYC and my grandmother settled in Ohio.
@rosemarie5489
@rosemarie5489 Жыл бұрын
Did you grandmother's family survived as well?
@vicente8749
@vicente8749 Жыл бұрын
The last part 💀
@kimberlyc1406
@kimberlyc1406 Жыл бұрын
i don't think they were on the titanic lol @@rosemarie5489
@an80smetalwoman66
@an80smetalwoman66 2 жыл бұрын
“Oh, he carried her, swept off her feet: I had a partner who did that once, but he buckled.” 😂🤣
@thebagelsproductions
@thebagelsproductions Жыл бұрын
In our defence, it's a good bit harder than it looks. Also, oftentimes a great deal of ale has been taken 😂😂
@leavoda3791
@leavoda3791 10 ай бұрын
​@@thebagelsproductionsthanks for being a good sport about it and for not losing your humor about it❤
@yevgeniyaleshchenko849
@yevgeniyaleshchenko849 5 ай бұрын
​​@@leavoda3791What are you thanking him for? I mean, such things are most often taken with humour.. or are you that insecure that yours is "buckling" too?🤔
@paramitch
@paramitch 2 жыл бұрын
I love Kate - she's hilarious and witty and so much fun. I'd watch anything she comments on.
@bryan7938
@bryan7938 2 жыл бұрын
Yes x
@beth3471
@beth3471 2 жыл бұрын
Her podcast is the BEST! I was hooked when she described Rasputin as “looking like he was drug through a hedge”. Funny and very true!!!
@AlexanderDeusvult
@AlexanderDeusvult Жыл бұрын
True 🙂👍🏻🇸🇪
@mazzaf7575
@mazzaf7575 Жыл бұрын
Alexander…bit of a nonce is genius😂
@yevgeniyaleshchenko849
@yevgeniyaleshchenko849 5 ай бұрын
That's just British humour and wit, aren't you familiar with it at all?
@RuletheWorldwithsong
@RuletheWorldwithsong 2 жыл бұрын
What makes me so angry about Anne Boleyn is that people always call her a master seductress. No! Henry was an entitled ass who wanted to sleep with any woman he wanted. Poor Anne was doing her job as a lady in waiting to Catherine and then here comes horn-dog-Henry. Anne told him that she would rather be his wife than to be his mistress probably thinking that that was the end of it but noooooo! Fuckin Henry!!!
@ladyofnoxus6733
@ladyofnoxus6733 2 жыл бұрын
Actually no, Henry didnt have many mistresses, and YES Anne was a master Seductress, what else are you doing if you are playing hard to get but still leading on a man. (in her case a very powerful man) to get what she wanted. She was not a victim. the only victim is Queen Catherine of Aragon.
@RuletheWorldwithsong
@RuletheWorldwithsong 2 жыл бұрын
@@ladyofnoxus6733 the historian just said that he had a lot of mistresses. Henry has a many mistresses as well as illegitimate children. Including Henry Fitzroy
@maia_gaia
@maia_gaia 2 жыл бұрын
@@ladyofnoxus6733 love that you think that only one woman could be the victim
@ladyofnoxus6733
@ladyofnoxus6733 2 жыл бұрын
@@maia_gaia I not once said that. But you think what you want.
@elizabeththequeen57
@elizabeththequeen57 2 жыл бұрын
@@ladyofnoxus6733 I can agree with you, except for the fact that Anne actually fell victim to either her own or her family's ambition, which have been planted and preserved by her courtly education; that and Cromwell's intrigues, as well as Henry's changeful temper eventually lead to her downfall. It's not like she was free in her choices. She knew there's no way of saying "no" to the king, so she wanted to take advantage of the situation, unlike her sister, but paid an ever bigger price for it than what anyone could have seen it coming. Catherine of Aragon at least had the entire Habsburg Empire rooting for her and threatening Henry with invasion, while Anne was the career ladder for her cousins and relatives for many years and who couldn't even protect her, given they would want to do that for her (which most didn't want to do, they've chosen the safe path). One born privileged, only to lose her privilege based on supposed fertility issues on her part and one guy's opinion; the other being brought up in the ranks for perceived youthfulness and sex appeal, only for it to be used against her and accused of infidelity, despite being innocent (at least evidence now suggests that).
@nette4307
@nette4307 Жыл бұрын
Please folks, MORE videos with Kate Lister! She is witty, strong, funny and very blunt in just the right way! Watching anything she does is a great experience. She so clearly knows her subject, and she makes history come alive. KUDOS!
@yevgeniyaleshchenko849
@yevgeniyaleshchenko849 5 ай бұрын
How do you know if she's "strong"? Do you personally know her? Why throw these words around?🤨
@newgabe09
@newgabe09 26 күн бұрын
@@yevgeniyaleshchenko849 This can mean strong in her opinions and way of expressing herself. Which can be seen on video without knowing her personally.
@idab2605
@idab2605 2 жыл бұрын
"Don't cry, go find your self another king" Motto of the life.
@theorderofthebees7308
@theorderofthebees7308 9 ай бұрын
Lol
@yevgeniyaleshchenko849
@yevgeniyaleshchenko849 5 ай бұрын
Sure... You'd wish.
@KittTheHistorian
@KittTheHistorian 2 жыл бұрын
"Go get yourself another king!" is possibly the single best quote I've ever heard about a royal favourite 😂
@sabrecrafted7409
@sabrecrafted7409 2 жыл бұрын
That bit about looking up young Henry slayed me 🤣🤣
@Sam-ql4ze
@Sam-ql4ze 11 ай бұрын
Interesting fact Anne Boleyn was Queen Katherine's lady in waiting and Jane Seymour was Anne Boleyn's lady in waiting when Henry 8 started to cheat on her. Textbook "How you get them is how you loose them."
@Maazzzo
@Maazzzo 2 жыл бұрын
Please do a part two with Kate, she's amazing.
@JJONNYREPP
@JJONNYREPP 5 ай бұрын
i'm basically wanting a castle and, maybe, the whole of east anglia, wessex and scotland.
@moonlily1
@moonlily1 Жыл бұрын
No, you're right about the makeup. Rouge and powder, that's it. Maybe a homemade version of eyebrow pencil and mascara that you wouldn't admit to using. Molly Brown's blue eyeshadow was definitely not a thing.
@no.3royston612
@no.3royston612 2 жыл бұрын
Loved this! More of Kate please - she's brilliant!
@sidney7129
@sidney7129 Жыл бұрын
I like how she give her comments to these movies in such a simple direct way like we're gossiping with her..
@brontewcat
@brontewcat 2 жыл бұрын
We do not actually know for how long Mary Boleyn was Henry’s mistress. When Henry was courting Anne, there was a rumour that Henry had slept with Elizabeth Boleyn as well as Mary, I think by an ambassador. When Henry was told of the rumour he reputedly said “Not the mother,” which implicitly admitted to an affair with Mary. Cromwell or Wolsey was with him at the time, and apparently added “Not the sister either.” This implies that the affair was not that well known so as to be possible to cover it up. This suggests it was of relatively short duration.
@graphiquejack
@graphiquejack 2 жыл бұрын
Henry VIII had only one confirmed illegitimate child by Bessie Blount. He didn’t ‘take care’ of Mary Boleyn’s children and he never acknowledged any as his own. In fact, it was Anne who became Henry Carey’s ward, and she originally helped her sister when she was in a bad financial situation after her first husband died. It’s unlikely, in my view that Mary’s children were Henry’s but I suppose it’s possible her first child, a daughter, was. Just because she named her second child (which almost certainly wasn’t his) Henry means nothing as it was just considered smart policy to name your children after powerful friends and obviously the royal family.
@TheBeetress
@TheBeetress 2 жыл бұрын
The myth that Henry father to some of Mary's children is that Henry gave Mary's husband money and/or lands. But Mary's husband was part of his court and many other men granted money and land too. It's interesting that none of those other men's children are similarly thought to be the kings
@Luanna801
@Luanna801 2 жыл бұрын
Very true. The comments about Henry having loads of illegitimate children and loads of mistresses are both inaccurate - or rather, if he did, we have no solid evidence of it. The only confirmed mistresses we know of other than the Boleyns are Bessie Blount and Jane Seymour (before she eventually became his third wife).
@ladyofnoxus6733
@ladyofnoxus6733 2 жыл бұрын
@@Luanna801 THANK YOU! I was going crazy reading some of these comments and the "historian" didn't bother to help or debunk.
@thebagelsproductions
@thebagelsproductions Жыл бұрын
Royal bastards were often openly acknowledged, the name Fitzroy means issue of the king more or less. I'm not sure how universal this was or the historical period this applies to the most. I'm happy to hear details about it
@Ashbrash1998
@Ashbrash1998 Жыл бұрын
I don't think we will ever know for sure how many bastards Henry had, whether ot was kept secret, he never cared, or the cases of unsure paternity.
@captaincurtains4804
@captaincurtains4804 2 жыл бұрын
This woman is awesome. "Alexander, bit of a nonse 🤷‍♀️" Love her ❤️
@quimenga
@quimenga 2 жыл бұрын
I love Kate's analysis, reactions, and commentary!! very hilarious and witty, and still informative - i love it
@Wen1515
@Wen1515 Жыл бұрын
Kate is so watchable and makes history so accessible! Love her!
@Henry-dt9ht
@Henry-dt9ht 2 жыл бұрын
My father and mother worked in museums for most of their lives. My father was a classical Sculptor and did work at the Smithsonian making figures for the various displays and Halls. My mother was a museum curator and was involved in the management of museums. My sister and I or needless to say given an education in natural and human history. One would think that this would be a great advantage and in some cases it was however when you went to a drive-in movie or to any other form of Hollywood entertainment that had anything to do with history most of the time we'd end up laughing at what we were watching because it was so historically inaccurate. So I empathize with her reaction to the movie Titanic you like the movie but historically speaking it's a bomb. For us the movie in question was the Vikings with star and Kirk Douglas. Our family was almost ejected from the drive-in because we were making too much noise laughing and pointing out all the historical errors and untruths that literally flowed from the screen into the car. Was a good thing it was a drive-in.
@ChiChe555
@ChiChe555 Жыл бұрын
I would HONESTLY love to watch movies with you and your family 😅
@emilyb.8219
@emilyb.8219 11 ай бұрын
That sounds like an interesting and enriching childhood, I'm jealous!
@cSquaredFactotum
@cSquaredFactotum 2 жыл бұрын
Aw, I thought this was a part 2. Since this was originally uploaded I've completely binged her podcast (Betwixt the Sheets). Love her!
@TheBeetress
@TheBeetress 2 жыл бұрын
I discovered the podcast first- I'm glad to be able to put a face to the voice
@horstyoutube6413
@horstyoutube6413 2 жыл бұрын
Came here in hope for a part two. Please make one (or 20, I‘ll watch them) more video with her! Or maybe a double feature with doctor Janega?
@mattmcguire1577
@mattmcguire1577 2 жыл бұрын
There is a double feature. Look up the title - What was sex really like for medieval people?
@anthonyhebisen
@anthonyhebisen Жыл бұрын
The car , the Renault , make and model was absolutely on the RMS Titanic . Its inventory even accounted the vase with the flowers inside the carriage . However , the car was more than likely completely crated and would have been impossible for anyone to enter
@JJONNYREPP
@JJONNYREPP 5 ай бұрын
surprised she didnt scrutinize the little malcolm film and the inept stance the lads took with a vulnerable woman..... which is kindda the attitude deeply religious males take with women per se - hysterical, to say the least. i have no concet re: the attitude nuns have regards the opposite number... maybeit's of a similar hue - myth and whimsical notions being put into play to erase the inclement thoughts that have been induced?
@HannahTLee
@HannahTLee 2 жыл бұрын
Love the commentary and facts dropped throughout. Also, she does and amazing job tying in modern culture references without seeming to try too hard 😂
@ladyredl3210
@ladyredl3210 2 жыл бұрын
As an amateur Victorianist, this is making me cackle and I haven't even started yet. This historian is fantastic.
@phoebeel
@phoebeel Жыл бұрын
She actually wrote a book about the history of sex which is highly entertaining!
@ladyredl3210
@ladyredl3210 Жыл бұрын
@@phoebeel thank you! I’m on the hunt now
@ads2686
@ads2686 Жыл бұрын
if you like her she also has a podcast called betwixt the sheets that is very funny.
@ladyredl3210
@ladyredl3210 Жыл бұрын
@@ads2686 thank you! Yes I love it
@misterhoeflak
@misterhoeflak Жыл бұрын
Dear History Hit, give Kate and Eleanor their own series already. 😊
@bodacioustness5054
@bodacioustness5054 2 жыл бұрын
Reportedly, Henry had relatively few mistresses by kingly standards and didn't have very many illegitimate kids. He had a loving first marriage. But, who knows - none of us were there. The Other Boleyn Girl was a god awful mess. PS - I love your look, Kate!
@maibouchot9573
@maibouchot9573 9 ай бұрын
Not the pause to google young Henry!!! 😂🤣😂
@Theturtleowl
@Theturtleowl 2 жыл бұрын
I adore Kate. Love the way she talks about herself, history and the movies.
@LauraLopez-sv4dk
@LauraLopez-sv4dk 2 жыл бұрын
Kate is just wonderful! Loved this and Betwixt the sheets is fantastic too.
@NoOrdinaryRabbit93
@NoOrdinaryRabbit93 2 жыл бұрын
We need more Katie Lister on the channel, she's brilliant. Love the pod too, look forward to seeing part 2 👌
@judithweiss6727
@judithweiss6727 2 жыл бұрын
Speaking of Eleanor of Aquitaine .... it would have been fun to rate "The Lion in Winter."
@melenatorr
@melenatorr Жыл бұрын
I believe that the reference to Mary Boleyn being called "great mare" by Francis was reported in 1585 by Nicholas Sandor, who generally wrote in a negative light about Anne Boleyn, spreading the report of her extra finger and other injurious details. I don't think there's any contemporary reference to "great mare" being applied to Mary Boleyn (just like there was no contemporary reference to Anne of Cleves being called the "Flanders Mare"). We have to be careful about these kinds of remarks, when they were applied and by whom.
@sputnicksteerpike
@sputnicksteerpike Жыл бұрын
"I think I was still doing beer bongs in the park in my early 30s." ... 😂
@sarahkiernan3358
@sarahkiernan3358 Жыл бұрын
I LOVE Kate Lister! More of her please. She should have her own show. Xx
@abigruber
@abigruber 2 жыл бұрын
I must know her lipstick colour and brand! And also, more vids with her because she’s unabashed and knows her stuff!
@sweetmusic3821
@sweetmusic3821 8 ай бұрын
14:40 "Thee up?" 🤣
@danmay7234
@danmay7234 4 ай бұрын
kate lister is incedible! funny, knowledgable, down to earth... thoroughly enjoy her historical commentary... up the north!!!!!!!!!!!!!
@ukallii
@ukallii 2 жыл бұрын
The car on Titanic would have been in a crate, and likely would have been disassembled. Also, the car would have been in Cargo Hold #2 in the Orlop Deck section, which is not accessible via a door from the boiler rooms. That's Cargo Hold #3, which was not used for any 1st Class baggage. 1st Class baggage had it's old hold next to the mail room and post office on G-Deck and the Orlop Deck, so the entire car sex scene doesn't work.
@history_loves_anime8927
@history_loves_anime8927 Жыл бұрын
It could've been whole. There are ship wrecks in the great lakes that have entire cars assembled at the bottom of Lake Huron.
@christyokie3305
@christyokie3305 Ай бұрын
I love how she has such a sweet reaction to these couples getting it on. It's quite moving. I wish this was the standard reaction because. It's such a loving way for people think of each other--sympathizing with what their hearts are asking for.
@Canuck13
@Canuck13 2 жыл бұрын
About the Titanic, James Cameron took artistic license in order to move the characters between the classes. While it’s not accurate, it was more of an illustration of the times.
@MrShnier
@MrShnier 5 ай бұрын
Love Kate lister and her sense of humour, please do more videos with her!
@blinard1
@blinard1 2 жыл бұрын
You should do a historian talking about the history of KZbin channels reuploading videos and simply changing the name.
@onemysore6120
@onemysore6120 Жыл бұрын
12:00 Hilarious. Love the breaking of the 4th wall bit 😅
@lorencappelson6475
@lorencappelson6475 2 жыл бұрын
The guy playing King John is Oscar Isaac! So YES, quite sexy! Even if historically inaccurate.
@VoidOfShadows
@VoidOfShadows 2 жыл бұрын
Kates a great guest, would love to see more critiques from her!
@VenomHalos
@VenomHalos 2 жыл бұрын
Regarding Alexander- the Irish accent was very much on purpose! All the Macedonians had Irish accents (to varying degrees… looking at you, Hephaestion 👀) to set them apart from the Greeks in a way that emphasized the sort of “class difference” (not quite that, but idk how else to describe it). Aristotle and the other Greeks have fancy RP accents, and they look down on the Macedonians, who for effect have Irish ones.
@thebagelsproductions
@thebagelsproductions Жыл бұрын
I don't think the Irish accents worked at all. They could've indicated the class differential in a number of ways.
@daytonapeanut
@daytonapeanut Жыл бұрын
16:11 Thank you. Letting a person like Jack into 1st class at that time would have been the scandal of the century. They would have chucked him overboard before they let that happen!
@benburkin7942
@benburkin7942 2 жыл бұрын
I love Kate's videos, always entertaining and enlightening 😎👍
@kballetk
@kballetk 9 ай бұрын
I just want to watch this woman reviewing movie scenes forever! 😂❤
@killiansirishbeer
@killiansirishbeer 2 жыл бұрын
Wow, first video with this historian and she is just great 🤩😂 and so funny!
@mazzaf7575
@mazzaf7575 2 жыл бұрын
There is one with both of them in! It’s called Medieval Pleasures: What was sex like in the Middle Ages? and it’s on History Hit.
@zachary6706
@zachary6706 6 ай бұрын
We need more of Kate, I loved this video
@vintagearisen
@vintagearisen Жыл бұрын
Okay so as soon as she said Henry VIII was a fine piece of man in his youth I googled it while leaving the video running and then went back to the tab and the video had accurately predicted my exact behavior, kudos
@TomIdelson
@TomIdelson 2 жыл бұрын
Bless you for pausing and showing us young Henry VIII because I was just about to do it! (for a second there I thought my computer was reading my mind 🤣😂)
@RheverendJ
@RheverendJ 3 ай бұрын
Just the thought of lying in bed at 11:30 and hearing my phone go off… “Thee up?” 🤣🤣🤣🤣💀💀💀💀
@aliciahowell9617
@aliciahowell9617 11 ай бұрын
Henry’s mistress Bessie Blount gave him a son that somewhat legitimized and later considered marrying to Elizabeth. He gave him a title but he died young.
@gemstonesparkle7915
@gemstonesparkle7915 2 жыл бұрын
The searching Henry VIII picture part got me 😂
@katieedwards5926
@katieedwards5926 Жыл бұрын
“But he buckled.” That’s it, I’m in love.
@megansimmons1485
@megansimmons1485 8 ай бұрын
Kate Lister is a goddamn treasure. I found her books first and this is exactly how I imagined her. 👑🧡👏🏼⭐️ More Kate please!! 🥂🍻
@monicavernon2976
@monicavernon2976 Жыл бұрын
This was such a fantastic show. More please!
@laurahare653
@laurahare653 2 жыл бұрын
Oh I love her! Please feature Kate again
@bryan7938
@bryan7938 2 жыл бұрын
Brilliant. Very watchable and on point 👏
@BrittanyCocchino
@BrittanyCocchino 8 ай бұрын
I could watch this woman do this all, damn, day. What a fully entertaining person to listen to !
@jaymees6637
@jaymees6637 Жыл бұрын
Love Kate!! She makes history fun!!
@throughthelookingglass5973
@throughthelookingglass5973 11 ай бұрын
I agree about the inaccuracies of the Titanic film. The early 1910s were very much about staying in your class. The 1st class would even look down on what they call "new money." Something the film is correct about. James Cameron himself remarked about how he took creative liberties to show the audience all the classes of Titanic and noteworthy rooms because, in the end, the story is about Titanic, its crew members, and passengers. Not the love story of Jack and Rose. EDIT: The car is not inaccurate. It actually existed on Titanic and still was not found in the wreck to this day. I think what Kate was recalling is that only two versions of this car were ever made.
@Henry-dt9ht
@Henry-dt9ht 2 жыл бұрын
At that time as well as before, the classes were separated by locked Gates. In some cases the gates prevented individuals from saving their their own lives in the event of a sinking. I don't know if this is true with the Titanic itself. Given that this happened on other vessels I would be very much inclined to believe that was the way it was on the Titanic.
@MorganChaos
@MorganChaos 2 жыл бұрын
Actually, we know the answer to this. The gates were not routinely locked on the Titanic, though someone did lock them in the source of the evacuation; this did not stop anyone because the gates were only waist-high and easy to jump. The reason so many from lower classes died is because they were not told there was an emergency to get out of bed for until the situation had been ongoing for awhile, and there weren't that many employees assigned to getting third class passengers out of their rooms and moving. But they did get as many third class women and children onto life boats as they could.
@TinyJem101
@TinyJem101 2 жыл бұрын
"but he buckled" just killed me hahahaha
@Kiki-cs8xv
@Kiki-cs8xv 2 жыл бұрын
Would Rose and Jack have got together? Putting aside the question of whether they would have met, the Titanic sinking was only 16 years before Lady Chatterley's Lover was published. The story was controversial because it's about an English Lady in an unhappy marriage, then having an affair with her gamekeeper. So yes, there was some awareness at the time that the aristocracy sometimes ran off with the serving classes.
@sitcomchristian6886
@sitcomchristian6886 Жыл бұрын
I've read the book. The affair is a slow burn, not a sudden whirlwind like Jack and Rose. It's really one of the most incredible novels about depression I've ever read.
@BigHenFor
@BigHenFor 11 ай бұрын
I love Kate Lister. She makes social history fun.
@DanBrown96
@DanBrown96 10 ай бұрын
21:16 I mean, technically, Rose DID use Jack as a life preserver, the poor sod! Lol
@elle_rose_xx
@elle_rose_xx 2 жыл бұрын
Kate is hilarious bring her back 😂
@rickynieves3144
@rickynieves3144 Ай бұрын
Rose would have used Jack's body as a lifeboat! 😂😂😂 What a great way to put it! 😂😂😂
@OfficalRichardd
@OfficalRichardd 2 жыл бұрын
This was a good video. I laughed so much when she said Alexander was a bit of a nonce lmao
@richardcanedo1614
@richardcanedo1614 2 жыл бұрын
I knew the woman I was dating was the one for me when, while watching Jack's death scene in Titanic and listening to the audience sniffle and stifle sobs around me, I glanced to my right and caught my (now) wife rolling her eyes at the clichéd lines. I am a romantic and I cry at movies readily, but the combination of 1) historical inaccuracies, 2) dramatic clichés and 3) gaping plot holes had just lost it for me as I watched. Examples: 1) In spite of James Cameron's much-trumped boasts of historical accuracy, there are many little things wrong, like women's makeup (as Lister points out), and big things like the way people relate to one another, more like the 1990s than the 1910s, or "steerage" on the maiden voyage of the biggest luxury liner on earth being full of immigrants and their livestock rather than, say, a shopkeeper and his wife going on a 25th anniversary trip -- which is what "steerage" would have been on that ship on that trip. 2) Clichés like Jack's best friend Fabrizio who, having done his character's job of established that Jack is not a weird loner, completely disappears from the movie and its plot, except to reappear momentarily as the ship sinks so that someone we "know" can die; or Jack and Rose being the first couple to have sex in the back seat of a car -- ha, ha!; or almost everyone in first class being catty, nasty, elitist gossips, while those in steerage (none of whom are ever developed as characters) are gregarious and happy. 3) More than a few plot holes (some of which Kate Lister notes -- how did Jack get onto a 1st class deck in the first place?), but the only part of the plot that seemed to make sense to me as I watched was that Rose kept the "Heart of the Ocean" diamond (her family was now poor, remember) and used the money from it to live the wide-ranging life of travel and adventure her photographs indicate she had lived. She then somehow still has the diamond -- so how had she afforded all those things? Then, even though it had plenty of negative "Cal-related" associations for Rose (it was Cal's way of "buying" her as a bride; it was used to frame Jack and lock him up, which is why they ended up freezing in the water; it was technically still Cal's, so stealing it and then hocking it makes perfect sense), Rose nevertheless kept it for 80 years and then for no clear reason throws it "to Jack" in the ocean. Why? He didn't give it to her, and it caused her nothing but trouble, so it would make sense to sell it make a life of adventure possible for someone so poor. Then it became the most honored film (in Academy Award terms) in Hollywood history, tying with Ben-Hur from 1959. Sorry for the rant: Titanic is a visually spectacular movie, and there are good actors (if not performances: I didn't even mention the dialogue or 2-D characters) in it, but the gap between this film's popularity/awards and its flaws, as noted above, just exasperates me.
@monmothma3358
@monmothma3358 2 жыл бұрын
Omg you must be my twin soul or something! Titanic came out in my teens, so I was in the target audience (it was _definitely_ made for teens..), AND I am a romantic who cries at everything, but I never liked that movie, and I so vividly remember that feeling of hearing sobs around me, while I roll my eyes, getting annoyed at the terrible script and two-dimensional black-and-white characters. Seriously, that script is so bad. Remember when Rose tells the ship's engineer, Mr Andrews, whom she "happened to" be able to talk to, that she had noticed there didn't seem to be enough life boats? Or when Cal chased the Lovers with a gun, no less (a scene originally intended to be much longer). A few years ago, when the 3D version came out, I decided to give it another chance with my husband, who had never seen it. I ended up apologizing to him as I hadn't remembered exactly how bad it was. I think James Cameron is a bit like George Lucas: He has very specific strengths and weaknesses. He's great at tense action, visual effects, and he doesn't feel threatened by strong females. I love Terminator and Aliens. However, he doesn't really know how humans work. He should stay away from stuff meant to be realistic and/or based on real events. I find it slightly insulting that he imagined a real ship to be full of cartoon heroes and cartoon villains.
@richardcanedo1614
@richardcanedo1614 2 жыл бұрын
We’ll said - and a lot more briefly than I did!
@MorganChaos
@MorganChaos 2 жыл бұрын
Re: the first class deck thing, I think the story was that Rose had descended to a lower-class deck, because it was closer to the water and none of her people would think to look for her there. The movie probably doesn't explicitly say so, but I always assumed that was the intent of the writing. (Idk how she got him up to dinner though.)
@ladyredl3210
@ladyredl3210 2 жыл бұрын
The more history I learn, the more I hate Titanic.
@potocatepetl
@potocatepetl 2 жыл бұрын
@@richardcanedo1614 for someone who likes to criticize, you don't seem to have the same expectation of precision from yourself...
@MultiCappie
@MultiCappie Жыл бұрын
"He wasn't sexy. He was a redhead." That's an official ouch from me!
@JBunny7482
@JBunny7482 Жыл бұрын
I need more of her!!!!
@lily21207
@lily21207 2 жыл бұрын
Kate is absolutely amazing! This was hilarious 😂
@sweetb2750
@sweetb2750 2 жыл бұрын
All I could think about was she looks like she is related to Drew Barrymore
@4Mr.Crowley2
@4Mr.Crowley2 Жыл бұрын
Kate - compare Rose and Jack to Evelyn Nesbit and Henry Thaw plus Stanford White who designed Madison Square Garden…Evelyn was supposedly the beauty that inspired Gibson (other than Gibson’s own wife) and a chorus girl who was tossed between the much older super wealthy White who himself was later shot to death by Evelyn’s young, very rich (like Billy Zane - PA steel wealth) husband Henry Thaw who managed to avoid serious prison time.
@DiabolicDistortion
@DiabolicDistortion Жыл бұрын
Lol, the 3 AM "thee up?"text
@eliskadvorakova1717
@eliskadvorakova1717 2 жыл бұрын
I think I found my favorite historian right there...
@vegansrirachamac
@vegansrirachamac 10 ай бұрын
This is my first time seeing this video/channel and I love Kate.
@Khatoon170
@Khatoon170 2 жыл бұрын
How are you doing mrs Kate actually iam Arabic lady we are in Arabic countries generally avoid to talk about sexual relationships it’s shame either young or old I just read about your profile you are dr Kate lister university lecturer writer , blogger you have project on sexuality and history of sex accessible board member for sex work research hub in vagine museum in 2017 you won sexual freedom award and vagina museum is first in world and mortar about female reproductive system project based in uk, opened in 2019 and sexual education is compulsory in all untied kingdoms elementary schools . Iwish we too in Arabic countries to teach our kids since very age risk of Rape and sexual abuse have code word can use when they feel unsafe yes we as Arabic countries and conservatives societies have good manners any way thank you for your efforts stay safe blessed good luck to you your family friends.
@Khatoon170
@Khatoon170 2 жыл бұрын
I mean since very early age iwrote in hurry
@jmc7034
@jmc7034 2 жыл бұрын
I love the way Kate approach’s this subject. Makes it such a pleasure to watch
@alexger85
@alexger85 Жыл бұрын
kate has quickly become my favourite person on the hh channel ♥
@oneangel77x3
@oneangel77x3 2 жыл бұрын
I love your commentary!
@fosterfuchs
@fosterfuchs 2 жыл бұрын
"Thee up?" 😂😂😂
@SofiaGonzalezMusic
@SofiaGonzalezMusic 2 жыл бұрын
i never knew I had a dream job until now to be honest. Kate is amazing
@6Tulips
@6Tulips 2 жыл бұрын
Oh my gosh, I listen to Kate on her awesome podcast “Betwixt the sheets” and love it but to have visuals and actually see her, well that was just amazing. Kate is my hero.
@JaneEasterbrook-bn3ux
@JaneEasterbrook-bn3ux 8 ай бұрын
Mary Boleyn is my ancestor through her daughter Katherine Carey Knollys.
@theorderofthebees7308
@theorderofthebees7308 9 ай бұрын
‘Rose would have used Jack”s body as a Life boat” 😂😂😂
@m4ni3czk4
@m4ni3czk4 4 ай бұрын
Amazing, love the historian, she is a queen
@animerlon
@animerlon 7 ай бұрын
Not even a minute & a half in & had to comment. The sarcasm is already flowing, i believe this is going to be a very bumpy, but highly entertaining ride. Am totally ready for it. LOL & Carry On.
@eveningstar1
@eveningstar1 2 жыл бұрын
more of Kate!! fascinating.
@cynhanrahan4012
@cynhanrahan4012 7 ай бұрын
Titanic - There was plenty of room on Rose's float for him, too. Killing him off was for the drama.
@Henry-dt9ht
@Henry-dt9ht Жыл бұрын
It has been proposed that King Henry's ill-temper and obesity have a direct cause in a riding accident. He loves to Jost and it was well joesting that he was unhorsed and fell into a deep coma. Queen Anne took great care of him while he was unconscious. When Can Henry regain consciousness his personality had changed abruptly into that of a tyrant. The second riding accident resulted in his leg becoming seriously injured. It was that injury that develop into a sore that never healed and the leg proved to be extremely inflamed and painful.
@OpalLeigh
@OpalLeigh 11 ай бұрын
I think this was a factor too. He went from being a bit too haughty- to being absolutely unhinged 😬 I think he had frontal lobe damage. He wasn’t actually that bad of a king when he was younger 🤷🏻‍♀️
@Henry-dt9ht
@Henry-dt9ht 2 жыл бұрын
When it comes to historical figures and their personal relationships We must remember the context that these relationships . We can't use our modern day biases and our modern day moralities. Even from one contemporary civilization to another Cultural differences or tremendous compared to our and it's near global civilization. Misinterpreting ancient relationships causes A misrepresentation and intent Of individuals in those personal relationships at that time.
@thebagelsproductions
@thebagelsproductions Жыл бұрын
Here here!
@_Kyprioth_
@_Kyprioth_ 2 жыл бұрын
‘You get your lesbian on’. Love it. Absolutely love it lol
@Kolkholzkola
@Kolkholzkola Жыл бұрын
Ah god bless ya, Kate! You’re always a fun time ❤️
Sex Historian Reviews Iconic Female Characters in Hollywood Movies
29:54
What Were Georgian Attitudes Towards Sex? | Georgian Pleasures
47:22
1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9 🙈⚽️
00:46
Celine Dept
Рет қаралды 113 МЛН
The Ultimate Sausage Prank! Watch Their Reactions 😂🌭 #Unexpected
00:17
La La Life Shorts
Рет қаралды 8 МЛН
The Singing Challenge #joker #Harriet Quinn
00:35
佐助与鸣人
Рет қаралды 46 МЛН
Top Tudor Historian Rates Famous Movie Scenes
17:46
History Hit
Рет қаралды 865 М.
Fashion Curator Reviews Historic Costumes In Famous Movies
27:25
History Hit
Рет қаралды 440 М.
Criminologist Reviews Serial Killers From Movies & TV | Vanity Fair
29:12
The Rivalry Of Anne Boleyn And Katherine Of Aragon
38:28
Chronicle - Medieval History Documentaries
Рет қаралды 83 М.
Top Medieval Historian Reviews Famous Movie Scenes | Part Two
18:10
History Hit
Рет қаралды 1,3 МЛН
Napoleon's Sex Life Uncovered
33:48
History Hit
Рет қаралды 345 М.
Tudor Historian Joanne Paul Breaks Down Tudor Films & TV Shows
24:08
Penguin Books UK
Рет қаралды 1 МЛН
What Were Medieval Attitudes Towards Sex? | Medieval Pleasures
33:51
The Complete History Of The Roman Empire In 4 Hours | Empire Without Limit (Full Series)
3:53:17
Odyssey - Ancient History Documentaries
Рет қаралды 11 МЛН
1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9 🙈⚽️
00:46
Celine Dept
Рет қаралды 113 МЛН