Dasam Granth Controversy: Authenticity & Authorship with Dr. Kamalroop Singh

[@jagsanghera1810]

We need more discussion like this, very insightful. Thank you. 🙏🏼

[@RamblingsofaSikh]

More to come!

[@J.D.416]

This was the best podcast episode! I've listened to this three different times and have sent it to all my Sikh friends and urged them to listen to this. Please invite Kamalroop Singh or others that have researched the Dasam Granth! This has legitimately blown my mind. Thank you!

[@rb7341]

I’ve listened to this podcast at least 5 times. This is an incredibly informative and enlightening discussion.

[@harijotkhalsa9496]

"Until we don't honor Guru Gobind Singh's bani, we're going to be stuck in this rut" VERY well said! Once I attended a Sikhi camp where they would recite the cut choupie sahib as per sgpc/Basuria. I found it uncomfortable, started raising questions to other attendees, and ended up challenging the camp heads on the subject. The controversy wasn't resolved, but I made a resolution to never, under any circumstances, submit to the cut version. The next morning I saw something in my meditation: a colorful group of Sikhs crowding the complex of Harimandir Sahib, the sangat had a glow about them and were loving, chaupei sahib had been officially restored. The rut that Kamalroop is talking about will certainly be broken one day and the Khalsa Raj will begin to blossom. It shall happen.

[@jaipreetsingh6566]

Jaikara gajave anti dasam granth malecha nu bhajran paave!!!! Satt sri akaaaaaaluh!!!

[@bandar1982]

Such an enlightening discussion 🙏🏽 I really enjoyed this.

[@RamblingsofaSikh]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@wushuman426]

These podcasts are so interesting. Learning so much.

[@kevinsingh2815]

Wow. I am speechless. Thank you for this interview

[@J.D.416]

I find myself listening to this episode yet again! Please have on more Dasam Granth researchers!

[@RamblingsofaSikh]

We've got 2 more episodes relating to Sri Dasam Granth soon to be released, and another set to be recorded. Plenty more coming.

[@J.D.416]

@@RamblingsofaSikhthank you for your hard work brother!

[@justiceprovider9822]

@@RamblingsofaSikh your episodes are very good. Keep them coming, keep the quality high.

[@permvirsingh]

I don't understand why this pathetic book is promoted. This so called dasam Granth can only be used in toilet.

[@tejpalsinghsidhu]

This is Gold ! 🙏 GurFateh to You both for such deep insight !

[@khadkulyfe7266]

This changed my understanding on a lot of things especially Shaheedi Degh. Thank you for this, Amazing work.

[@MrSuchasoorma]

Very proud of both the host and Kamalroop. This Is great. Very impressed

[@hartejdutta6461]

Dhan Dhan Guru Gobind Singh ji❤

[@manvirsv]

Very enlightening. I really appreciate that you’re coming out here and elucidating some of the most obscured aspects of sikhi🙏🏽

[@ajsingh7946]

These podcasts are so eye opening 🙏🏽

[@indy061993]

This is so beautiful! Thank you so much 🙏

[@TheRangrez]

What a podcast! Incredible stuff🔥🔥🔥

[@tvaccount6896]

52:53 Gaj Ke Jaikare Jagave Nihaal ho jaave Dhan Sri Guru Dasam Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj Jiyan de charna nu bhave Satsriaaakaaaalllllllllllluh

[@intriguedsikh6848]

Great episode!

[@TheTurbanatore]

Amazing research, hopefully, this makes anti-Dasam Granth internet scholars second guess themselves

[@lordgawain]

I believe they are intentionally anti Dasam Granth

[@justiceprovider9822]

@@lordgawain those who question dasam and sarbloh, make us weak, I used to be one of them back in the day.

[@sahibsingh2036]

@@justiceprovider9822 Any ideas on why other sikh scholars reject dasam bani?

[@justiceprovider9822]

@@sahibsingh2036 they are too naive to understand the importance of Shri Charitropakhyan sahib and they see sikhi through a lens of sansari politics and find dasam granth sahib as a text that worships hindu gods which is not the case actually. This is all done in lieu of sansari raaj that makes them go against the guru himself, going as far as rejecting their bani. They haven't given their head and avoided paying to socities' opinions, rather are too hungery for kursi and proving others we are not muslim/hindu etc. Basically they have taken the soul, the spirituality out of sikhi and turned us into crypto Christians to prove we are not something xyz.

[@SagarSingh-zp7nd]

@@sahibsingh2036 read the answer written on quora by american professor he has great knowledge about Sikhism and to me he sounds fairly neutral and if u have time read his other answers as well here's the link. www.quora.com/What-is-the-controversy-of-the-Dasam-Granth/answer/Edward-Reddcliff?ch=10&share=79322f4e&srid=uPTWXY

[@lordgawain]

Thank you guys 🙏. Great podcast

[@tuhituhitu]

Really enjoying your podcasts 👍🏼

[@mohinderalg6551]

🙏 Enlightening, informative and thought-provoking. Well done to both. Need to listen more times and also should be more widely distributed in addition to podcast. WGJKAKWJKF

[@harveydhillon3682]

Great discussion

[@RamblingsofaSikh]

Thank you!

[@mdptg1990]

Would love to watch a podcast with any female researchers of the Dasam Granth. Would be extremely insightful

[@RamblingsofaSikh]

Robin Rinehart?

[@mdptg1990]

@@RamblingsofaSikh that’d be awesome. I’d love to watch a podcast on KZbin between you two. Only reason I bring this up is because I think the questions you raised about femininity and misogyny could’ve been discussed deeper here, which I believe a female researcher would be more inclined to do. 🙏🏽

[@Motionxvault]

🙏🏻👏

[@leisureish]

Brilliant

[@jaipreetsingh6566]

Akaaaaaaluh!!!!

[@DaljitSingh-ik1pu]

🕊

[@deeparya7218]

I guess from a linguistic standpoint, everyone has a DNA when it comes to writing. There's sentence structure, word choices and of course, their style of speaking (voice). This is one of many aspects used in these specific studies. This doesn't include ink, page dating, historical elements as well.

[@entirecosmos4335]

Siri Akaal mahakaal

[@nikkk7043]

RATED

[@prajalpi]

52:40

[@OMA407]

👍

[@AshleyKanda-kc5mn]

This is nonsense largely. People were not as sophisticated and educated as these children trying to make sense of it by todays standards. Keep it simple. All the gurus were Hindu and never stated they had started a new religion. Its easy, you do not need a PhD or big words. I agree with the part that they attempted to make it accessible to the common man and woman in Punjab who had zero education.