Dave Filoni's movie not guaranteed to happen? | Andor writer doing more Star Wars Stories?

  Рет қаралды 5,303

Thor Skywalker Plus

Thor Skywalker Plus

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 152
@ryanb9749
@ryanb9749 14 күн бұрын
"I'm not going to defend the Acolyte or anything" - Thor Skywalker, 2025. Colorized
@jimdaniels7531
@jimdaniels7531 14 күн бұрын
I'm not bothered by the Mangold comments. I get it, the Skywalker era is a straitjacket of canon. Early Jedi era just gives him more flexibility to tell the story he wants to, and that's a good thing. Plus, Andor writer Beau Willimon is doing the script, so that's a good sign.
@AAhmou
@AAhmou 14 күн бұрын
I'm okay with the Dawn of the Jedi era comtent since nothing is set in stone there for canon. As long as he doesn't do something that'll get him flak like trying to explain too much of the Force.
@hawkingjim
@hawkingjim 14 күн бұрын
Hey Thor, I've been thinking about this for a while. That we REALLY need to pay attention to the Mandalorian and Grogu movie because if that doesn't do well... where does Star Wars go from here? If its two most popular characters cannot succeed, what chance does Rey Palpatine have, or *Dawn of the Jedi*, or Lando, or any of the rumored projects have?
@jdstudios1912
@jdstudios1912 14 күн бұрын
I think the better question is what are the chances any of these projects actually get made. Then we can talk quality and viewership.
@PixelKatana
@PixelKatana 14 күн бұрын
You’d be surprised what cleaning house can do. It’s like removing a tumor. ATP it is clear KK is above Iger for unknown reasons so the franchise has to collapse so that we have a chance at everybody there getting fired and getting new leadership. Maybe someone like Sam Witwer who understands SW closest to George’s vision more than anyone I have heard. Headland specifically said Filoni was a mentor to her during Acolyte. Chow consulted him for Kenobi. This means he has overseen 4 lightsaber stabs where the victim survives. This man can only think with cartoon logic. That’s all you need to know about where he stands and his actual understanding of SW. Let him make more animated shows on D+ in a corner.
@johna4371
@johna4371 14 күн бұрын
It's maddening because in my mind I could ALMOST say Mando S2 was the end of that story. That's decent head cannon. But...I LIKE the Luke training bits in BOBF. I want that. But I don't want Mando S3. It's a mess. I gotta learn to fan edit...
@Mouse_Metal
@Mouse_Metal 14 күн бұрын
I had to write my own version of Mando S3 which ends with Din as the new Mandalore and Bo-Karen as a corpse and food for cave lizards. Fan editing would not be enough to fix the mess Failoni made in the name of w0keness and j***ing off to his villainous pet Mary Sue. Now I need more advanced AI generator to be invented.
@justcast1429
@justcast1429 14 күн бұрын
Ahsoka was mediocre at best Dave Filoni proved that he's better at writing animated shows than live action shows, so much of that show wasted the viewer's time and intelligence. Also characters not telling each other important information pissed me off. These live action shows need a longer runtime or more episodes because these writers/directors can't use the time, they do have effectively
@achaudhari101
@achaudhari101 14 күн бұрын
Well the show is not done yet so he has time to improve on it.
@Mouse_Metal
@Mouse_Metal 14 күн бұрын
Failoni is a trash-tier fanfic writer. He has always been a dead weight to everything he has worked on.
@AAhmou
@AAhmou 14 күн бұрын
​@@achaudhari101 The foundations are shakier than the sequel trilogy's. Not much hope on that front.
@saberiandream316
@saberiandream316 14 күн бұрын
@@Mouse_Metal Yeah, people only think he's good because they're too lazy to read the better stories he ripped off for TCW.
@achaudhari101
@achaudhari101 13 күн бұрын
@ That’s subjective at best.
@twincast2005
@twincast2005 14 күн бұрын
I have low interest in Favreau's movie and mid interest in Filoni's movie, so I don't know what to think of this. Rogue Squadron was the last Star Wars movie that I remember having high interest in. Just give me more Skeleton Crew at this point. And yes, all the sequel-baiting has been annoying.
@achaudhari101
@achaudhari101 14 күн бұрын
There’s “low interest” because we have seen really nothing about it in detail yet. That can change over time.
@jimdaniels7531
@jimdaniels7531 14 күн бұрын
Same here. Following Mando s3, I just don't care to see more of that kind of storytelling. I'll probably catch it on D+ eventually, but unless it gets seriously good reviews and word of mouth, I'll skip the theater. Same with the Filoni movie. This whole era is turning into weak tea.
@jdstudios1912
@jdstudios1912 14 күн бұрын
Couldn't care less for the mandalorian at all. Book of boba and Mando season 3 successfully killed any potential interest I had and I won't be watching either films when they come out. I'd prefer it if Disney stopped making star wars for 5-10 years while they clean house, restructure Lucas film and commit to writing a coherent story. Will any of that happen? No I'll keep an eye out but until this happens I'll never count myself as a star wars fan.
@achaudhari101
@achaudhari101 14 күн бұрын
@jdstudios1912 Two overhated shows. You only took out on them as revenge for Gina getting fired. That’s really where this hatred towards these two shows are coming from. To me, it’s a BS excuse to hope Favreau and Filoni fail and get pink slips.
@MossSteiger1530
@MossSteiger1530 14 күн бұрын
@@achaudhari101 "Overhated?" I'm curious to know what your standard is for appropriate hating...😉 Seriously, though - yes, I thought Gina's dismissal was unjust and disgraceful, but I can say very confidently that my dislike for Mando 3, Book of BF, and Kenobi has nothing to do with that. Zero. Nada. Rather, these shows are excellent examples of Disney's so-called "Star Wars" failing to be true to the movies that captured my heart and imagination in the first place. All three shows are littered with poor creative decisions, which in my opinion, bear no resemblance to established Star Wars. And it doesn't appear that they were even meant to. I can think of no bigger piece of the puzzle that it was important for Disney to get right, and I shake my head that you choose to discount it entirely. When I first heard of Disney spending $4B to acquire Star Wars, I thought it was a no-brainer that they'd make every effort to understand what made it successful in the first place. Find the best people to put on it, and to do everything they could to *not* screw it up. Well, evidently, a lot of people are disappointed. And I understand their disappointment. I'm not so sure that you do.
@moderndancingfool
@moderndancingfool 14 күн бұрын
TBH I don't want it with Filoni at the helm. Tony Gilroy and Jon Watts showed, in two different approaches, how you can make pre-sequel trilogy content great. The 'Somehow Palpatine Returned' of it all hangs like a dark cloud over it all and at least Gilroy, Watts & co. brought a little sunshine to it. Stop trying to wedge a story into the failures of the sequel trilogy. Maybe it's just time to take the IP, and begin again 10-20 years in timeline post sequel trilogy. If you want Ridley/Rey in it, fine. If you want Boyega in it, great. But put some adults with a vision in charge of it. At the end of the day, it's about light side vs. dark side. Take the building blocks of what made the original three great, and begin again. And don't wedge in representation in a preachy way - Skeleton Crew showed a diverse cast (with disability representation) and they didn't make a big deal about making a point with it. If you told me Tony Gilroy was doing the next three movies to start again, I'd be in lineup right now for it. Anyone who's a great writer - find them, and put them in charge.
@saberiandream316
@saberiandream316 14 күн бұрын
Tenel Ka was disabled representation as far back as the 1990s.
@rogerpalsgrove9678
@rogerpalsgrove9678 14 күн бұрын
My biggest fear about The Mandalorian movie is the Grogu effects.
@achaudhari101
@achaudhari101 14 күн бұрын
If it’s still a puppet, we’ll be okay.
@999999SkyGuy
@999999SkyGuy 10 күн бұрын
Perhaps he means that they have puppy flip-floppy who is my Poppy again (S3 E8 Grogue vs the red guards from TLJ)? As it looked ridiculous when Grogu wheels away inE2 from Mando Season 2, too😂 Furthermore Disney tend to reveal every mystery about all species. As George pro-claimed that Yoda's cult is rare & rather unknown in the galaxy. Since 2019 they are afraid of another J. J. Abrams disaster & therefore tend too >>constantly tell us instead of show
@khal7702
@khal7702 14 күн бұрын
agree they can't raise the dead unless they do something epic
@jimdaniels7531
@jimdaniels7531 14 күн бұрын
Yeah, Mando & Grogu feels rather mid scale, and I'm skeptical this strategy will drive a large audience turnout. It could be the next Solo -- a decent movie that few people asked for, undone by Disney's budget control problems and general audience apathy. But an epic new trilogy could spark renewed interest in SW, assuming they can still manage to make good movies with compelling stories. Especially if it's a clean slate that doesn't rely on existing characters and plots from the underwhelming sequels and Mandoverse shows.
@jdstudios1912
@jdstudios1912 14 күн бұрын
​@@jimdaniels7531 if they do a new trilogy it'll have to be pre prequels because nobody is going to touch a post sequels film at all.
@essbe7158
@essbe7158 14 күн бұрын
The only movie i want to see is the one where KK is defeated and removed from office.
@achaudhari101
@achaudhari101 14 күн бұрын
A movie successfully making people happy and is profitable is what will make her leave.
@essbe7158
@essbe7158 14 күн бұрын
@@achaudhari101 So never, is what you're saying :D
@achaudhari101
@achaudhari101 14 күн бұрын
@ No that was one of the rumors going around. The only way that the movie can succeed is where Kennedy isn't heavily involved.
@kingofthesharks
@kingofthesharks 14 күн бұрын
Im nervous about the structure of Andor S2 as well, but given that HotD S1 (the better season) worked with time jumps im hoping that it wont be as jarring to go thru different stages of cassians life and seeing how the prior arcs have changed him or luthen, etc.
@miragewizard
@miragewizard 14 күн бұрын
I remember when STAR WARS was a sure thing in the 1980s and Star Trek was anything but a sure thing, and we were hoping that the movies did well so that Star Trek would continue because it definitely had potential, and Star Trek fans wanted it to continue. Now, Disney Star Wars is in the same spot that Star Trek was in in the 1980s - it may not continue if it doesn't do well at the Box Office. But the problem with Disney Star Wars now as opposed to Star Trek back then is - does it have potential? Disney not only has to make a successful movie but they have to give us a reason that there is more potential down the road, and there is reason to be excited about future Disney Star Wars. They have to win the fan base back over.
@datguy3581
@datguy3581 Күн бұрын
I'll be looking forward to the Mando crossover whether its in theaters or on Disney+. I think there is a ton of potential with getting these characters together.
@istari0
@istari0 14 күн бұрын
I am very much interested in Andor S2. I have some interest in The Mandalorian and Grogu. Beyond that, I'm skeptical about everything else except the Rey movie(s), which I want nothing to do with.
@btecbradford5079
@btecbradford5079 13 күн бұрын
I loved watching the animated shows when not many people watched them, now the characters are in everything and in live action it's killed it for me a little
@victorpavymusic
@victorpavymusic 14 күн бұрын
Funny how I see The Mando & Grogu flop at the box office. It looks like no one cares anymore about Star Wars and I feel it will be more a Solo in terms of revenue than a Force Awakens. Could be wrong of course and misjudge the apathy of movie goers regarding Star Wars
@PsychedelicDude
@PsychedelicDude 14 күн бұрын
I agree series are way better for the big events and culminations. Movies should mainly be for shorter adventures featuring fewer characters. I don't get why movies are held as something more fancy than series. Who wouldn't rather have a 9/10 series with 10 hours of content than a 9/10 2 hour movie?
@kevint1911
@kevint1911 13 күн бұрын
If the comments section of any Star Wars related video has taught me anything its that if there’s 1 thing that Star Wars fans can agree on…… its that Star Wars fans can’t agree on anything. Having said that, perhaps it’s a testimonial to the variety of content, media, games, merchandise and stories available to fans in the Star Wars universe. There is something for everyone but not everything is for everyone. We are very fortunate that we have this amazing diversion from the reality of our daily lives and should probably appreciate that a little more instead of bashing the content we don’t like. There are things in Star Wars that aren’t my thing……comic books for instance. I don’t hate them but I’m not into them. I choose not to read them because they don’t appeal to me but I’m glad they are available to those that want them. There’s a show I didn’t like either and I will not watch it again, but I know it has its fans and I’m glad they have it to enjoy. I’d rather spend my time enjoying the things I like then hating the things I don’t. I think it’s better for my mental health, to be happy rather than angry.
@Theworldaccordingtohans
@Theworldaccordingtohans 14 күн бұрын
Maul at the end of solo was setting up for the canceled Kenobi trilogy.
@wickdaline8668
@wickdaline8668 14 күн бұрын
Really? For rlz?
@Theworldaccordingtohans
@Theworldaccordingtohans 13 күн бұрын
@wickdaline8668 Yes. But they gutted the whole thing and made the terrible show instead.
@Theworldaccordingtohans
@Theworldaccordingtohans 8 күн бұрын
@Bean-s7o Yes, he would. Tha5 alone does not make the show better.
@michaellane5381
@michaellane5381 14 күн бұрын
Am i the only one annoyed we don't get "Mixed" media? Like the Anime series "Oshi No Ko" pretty much STARTS with a movie, why do they keep stretching existing movies to 8 TV episodes instead of making a series supporting/ed a series and then release what they think makes sense for the budget they have?
@QuestionMan
@QuestionMan 14 күн бұрын
"Loosely based on Heir to the Empire"? Yeah, because screwing with the Zahn Trilogy isn't worse than simply ignoring it. Sure, that'll win me back.
@EnragedTofu
@EnragedTofu 14 күн бұрын
Hey Thor & Naboo, three things that I thought about after the finale: one was that Jod warned them they didn’t know what they were doing removing the barrier, which implies that Jod knows something ominous may be coming for the treasure planet far more threatening than just pirates, which would be imperial remnants, which leads into the second thing, which I believe beggars the question: why did the communication halt after Order 66? That would have to have been the Emperor‘s doing for a nefarious reason. The third is something cute I thought about, that was Wim & Fern’s parents starting to notice each other as obviously Wim’s dad is a widow and we can assume Fern‘s dad is not in the picture because he wasn’t present for the entire series, which would make an amazing family of Wim & Fern becoming siblings in the future.
@QuestionMan
@QuestionMan 13 күн бұрын
They shouldn't tease something that isn't set in stone. If the payoff depends on the financial performance, then just leave it out. Here's a thought: shoot the teaser, then release IT as the announcement for the new film once they officially green-light it. THAT would create hype.
@MumRah
@MumRah 14 күн бұрын
Hey Thor, what do you think about these types of movies/shows like Mando and Skeleton Crew being the way Disney can course correct (if it's even possible at this point) or at least go forward? I know some people complain that SWs without jedi etc isn't real SWs. Personally, I think if the executives like KK stay out we can get good products like we've seen. There is so much more opportunity for interesting storytelling and characters in a giant galaxy such as this. P.S. really enjoy the videos. Keep it up. 👍
@DarthSharp
@DarthSharp 14 күн бұрын
It could also have to do with Bob Iger too...he is the one who has been insistant on feature films and spread everything out. I'm not saying that Disney/Lucasfilm didn't face some challanges with first the pandemic, and then the actors/writers strikes (and the past decade has been filled with mergers and aquisitions) and I obviously some shows didn't do as well, but I still feel like Iger has been singing this song since the last time he was chair. But now he is leaving again, so perhaps whomever the new chair is wants to go back to streaming or maybe even Filoni feels it's a better format for what he has started??
@sealionstudios8597
@sealionstudios8597 9 күн бұрын
Well now we know what to do: we have to make sure Mando and Grogu doesn't succeed, because I genuinely can't take any more of these Dave Filoni vanity projects 😐 Look, I love Clone Wars and Mando Seasons 1 and 2. I love them to bits; but PLEASE stop bringing those characters back when they don't belong in the New Republic era and just make something NEW. Look at how good Skeleton Crew was for crying out loud.
@goufr3540
@goufr3540 14 күн бұрын
I can understand why the Filoniverse movie would be tied to the success of the Mando movie, cause that will be the movie to see if Disney Star Wars has any future at all. Considering the downward trend their D+ series have gone and how horrible Mando S3 was, is there enough of a base left to make the Mando movie even worth it?
@saberiandream316
@saberiandream316 14 күн бұрын
Not an adaptation of Heir to the Empire - Filoni rewriting a better writer's stories to selfishly be what he wants.
@ericbrown8627
@ericbrown8627 14 күн бұрын
Star Wars is dead as long as the sequels exist.
@TheLeatheryman
@TheLeatheryman 14 күн бұрын
Can tell you I’ve watched SOLO many many times.. TLJ and ROS? Count on one hand and that’s too many…
@blitzwinger999wright6
@blitzwinger999wright6 14 күн бұрын
PLEASE let it get cancelled. I’m drawing the line a Disney touching Embo. He’s my favorite bounty hunter and my god you’ve already ruined Boba Fett and Cad Bane, don’t come for my boy.
@scifiguy26
@scifiguy26 14 күн бұрын
They're going to make a movie so you can hear baby Yoda talk 😆 if Dave filoni is directing this I've seen Ahsoka & no thank you
@achaudhari101
@achaudhari101 14 күн бұрын
Except Ahsoka is not done yet. You really can’t let the guy cook can you? He did that with Clone Wars and he can do it with this show.
@scifiguy26
@scifiguy26 14 күн бұрын
@achaudhari101 your that "I love Luke Skywalker so much I want to have his babies" guy 🤣 get out of here you're a joke 🤣
@achaudhari101
@achaudhari101 14 күн бұрын
@scifiguy26 Are you Michael Kohl who also said the same thing even though I never even said that at all let alone even remember saying it? Munchkin.
@scifiguy26
@scifiguy26 14 күн бұрын
@achaudhari101 munchkin? You're the one that's munchkin all over Dave filoni 🌰🌰😆
@QuestionMan
@QuestionMan 14 күн бұрын
I'm in a place where I find that I don't think I care all that much about Mando either (S3 didn't help). All the off-screen Disney/Lucasfilm drama has left a really bad taste in my mouth and hearing all the news about all the exciting "new projects" just make me groan. Gee, maybe I am burned out with Star Wars fatigue-but of a different sort.
@-AtomsPhere-
@-AtomsPhere- 14 күн бұрын
We need to be asking: Is Dave Filoni a FILMMAKER? No, he’s not. I like a lot things Dave Filoni has done, but I think they should have proper directors doing Star Wars. I feel like Filoni would shoot the whole movie on the volume and it would look as flat and uninspired as Ahsoka.
@SwaggerLikeUz
@SwaggerLikeUz 14 күн бұрын
Jon Favreau's writing and/or imagination is mid. The Mandalorian for me died via Book of Boba Fett & Mando season 3. I don't care anymore! Filoni's inexperience in filmmaking was exposed in Ahsoka. Although Ahsoka's lore was fantastic. Hopefully, Filoni's writing improves by bonds & the tonality takes a more mature approach. Ahsoka season 1 wasn't good. The cartoonish tonality didn't work in (live action. As a Filoni fan that was very disappointing.
@gmarshall1942
@gmarshall1942 14 күн бұрын
If andorr season two and the grogu movie, don't deliver, Star Wars will be dead. I have no faith in disney.
@marknovak6498
@marknovak6498 14 күн бұрын
Star Wars conundrum Disney is a story about how billions of people faught and die to defeat an empire in yhe ending they died in vane.
@QuestionMan
@QuestionMan 14 күн бұрын
Making a Mando movie is an act of desperation, not creative direction. Lucasfilm must be in a silent panic. The film will probably be okay. I'll most likely watch it (assuming the state of the studio doesn't send it spiraling completely off the rails), but this is no passion project. That worries me. I wish the suits could've left Mando alone.
@jdstudios1912
@jdstudios1912 14 күн бұрын
I won't be wasting my time on the Mando movie. Dave filoni is a talentless hack and I don't trust him or anyone else at Lucas film to produce anything beyond slop except the andor team. Don't care who they bring in for Disneys attempt to reboot with rey palpatine I will never engage with it or any sequel related crap.
@achaudhari101
@achaudhari101 14 күн бұрын
Except one, this is far away from the Sequels. Two, Favreau is directing the Mando movie and I fail to see why he needs to be crucified by people like you. Three, the hatred towards Filoni is overblown.
@michaelkohl2250
@michaelkohl2250 14 күн бұрын
Pls stop the Filoni stuff. He should make kids cartoons for Disney Channel but nothing for adults since he CLEARLY has no clue how a grown up brain works
@achaudhari101
@achaudhari101 14 күн бұрын
Neither do you.
@michaelkohl2250
@michaelkohl2250 14 күн бұрын
@achaudhari101 oh mister "I love Luke Skywalker so much, I wanna have babies with him" is back to defend his childhood hero 😂 grow up dude! Man i really hope you're not over the age of 12 or so, otherwise I feel bad for your people
@achaudhari101
@achaudhari101 14 күн бұрын
Is it because of the profile pic even though it’s something people like? Sure.
@davidfrederiksen3185
@davidfrederiksen3185 14 күн бұрын
@@michaelkohl2250why are you sounded like a angry 7 year old
@michaelkohl2250
@michaelkohl2250 14 күн бұрын
@achaudhari101 no, it's because you ALWAYS are the first whos on the fence defending your lord and saviour Filoni. But since you mentioned it... having fictional characters as profile pic is the epitome of "I'm 12 years old"
@Mouse_Metal
@Mouse_Metal 14 күн бұрын
Nobody wants any Failoniverse crossover of all of his pet fanfic OCs. The Mandalorian & Grogu movie can only be successful or semi-successful if all dead weight is removed and it´s really about Mando and Grogu, it is a standalone story with a clear ending, and there is no Bo-Karen, Dangerhair Wren, Ahwoka or any other Mary Sue Failoni is able to make up only to have his pet OC in it at any costs.
@achaudhari101
@achaudhari101 14 күн бұрын
I really can’t believe people want Favreau and Filoni to fail and get pink slips despite these two keeping the franchise from not completely dying.
@NisGaarde
@NisGaarde 13 күн бұрын
The Mandalorian was never a "fantastic" show. It was OK at best (up until Seaon 3 when it dropped off a cliff completely). If LucasFilm think they can save Star Wars with (let's be honest) Grogu's cuteness I think they're gravely mistaken.
@MichaelLynch-zs9mr
@MichaelLynch-zs9mr 14 күн бұрын
Don’t threaten us with this DF don’t give us another reason not to watch Mando 🤪
@achaudhari101
@achaudhari101 14 күн бұрын
Why do you want Filoni and Favreau to get pink slips for the dumbest of reasons?
@ledinyourwalls
@ledinyourwalls 14 күн бұрын
​@@achaudhari101because it's popular to be on the filoni hate bandwagon
@MichaelLynch-zs9mr
@MichaelLynch-zs9mr 14 күн бұрын
@@ledinyourwalls or he gives me good reason to not enjoy his work. Sorry but did I like everything George wrote no, the Christmas Special still makes me wonder how it ever got released but his good work out weighs his mistakes and Ashoka just doesn’t make me confident that DF is worth my money
@achaudhari101
@achaudhari101 14 күн бұрын
Yet he and Favreau and Gilroy are the only ones keeping this franchise alive still.
@Mouse_Metal
@Mouse_Metal 14 күн бұрын
@@ledinyourwalls He has done that to himself.
@geraintthatcher3076
@geraintthatcher3076 14 күн бұрын
Filoni is an overrated hack. He relies on nostalgia bait and video game side quests, and that's it
@Mouse_Metal
@Mouse_Metal 14 күн бұрын
And his pet Mary Sues shoehorned into everything, which is IMO the worst part of his modus operandi.
@TheLeatheryman
@TheLeatheryman 14 күн бұрын
It has Embo instead of Cara Dune. It doesn’t look good
@user-so1kr1yx2q
@user-so1kr1yx2q 14 күн бұрын
So they will really have a useless baby as one of two protagonists in a movie? And is it really going to be called “the mandalorian and grogu”? I thought they understood that naming shows after a character is terrible.
@achaudhari101
@achaudhari101 14 күн бұрын
Deadpool and Wolverine said otherwise on the names alone. Why not this? Also have you seen recently how not useless Grogu was?
@user-so1kr1yx2q
@user-so1kr1yx2q 14 күн бұрын
@ Andor a prime example. It could work if the movie is focused on the named character’s development but if it’s like Andor where the story is really focused on something else, I don’t think it’s a good idea. And Grogu. How was he useful? He managed to jump? I’m just questioning Grogu’s capacity to carry a movie. He could live on his cuteness and the mystery of his fate before but now he’s just Din’s baby.
@jimdaniels7531
@jimdaniels7531 14 күн бұрын
The name sounds so generic. Makes it feel like a desperate studio move to cash in on their one show that's been an unqualified hit. Hopefully I'm wrong, but after the underwhelming Mando s3, I'm not optimistic. Disney is wise to do a wait-and-see on the Filoni movie.
@achaudhari101
@achaudhari101 14 күн бұрын
@user-so1kr1yx2q Andor was sometimes about Cassian but it was more on the stuff that either was surrounding him or other people like Mon Mothma and the Empire’s control. As for Grogu, he saved Din a lot of times, tamed a rancor, and held his own against Praetorian Guards. I hardly would say he’s useless now.
@Mouse_Metal
@Mouse_Metal 14 күн бұрын
Grogu is not useless, he is OP.
@gator7082
@gator7082 13 күн бұрын
Star Wars is dead. Sorry but at best it's receiving CPR with no chance of success. Filoni blew it. Mando S3 was stupid. Ashsoka was stupid. BOBF was stupid. Kenobi was stupid. The only coherent things put out were Andor S1, Mando S1 and maybe S2, and I'll even give Skeleton crew a pass but it's a kids show. As longs as the current leadership remains at Lucasfilm Star Wars, as we once knew it, is somewhere in the past never to return. We've been having the same conversation over and over and over and over again since The Last Jedi.
@ledinyourwalls
@ledinyourwalls 14 күн бұрын
The filoni hate Boner stuff I so ridiculous as most of the people constantly hating him have never watched most of his work and therefore don't know what he's actually capable of in the right circumstances, filoni can't work by himself just like George, he needs people to filter his ideas through so we don't get redundant ideas. People especially in this comment section seem to treat him like the devil incarnate which is hilarious, personally I think he really isn't that bad although he needs other people around him to let him know when he's going a bit too far in a few places
@geraintthatcher3076
@geraintthatcher3076 14 күн бұрын
I have seen his stuff. He's a hack who relies on nostalgia bait and video game quests
@achaudhari101
@achaudhari101 14 күн бұрын
@geraintthatcher3076 A hack despite making some of the best SW stuff in recent years?
@geraintthatcher3076
@geraintthatcher3076 14 күн бұрын
@achaudhari101 The best starwars in recent years was Andor which he had nothing to do with
@ledinyourwalls
@ledinyourwalls 14 күн бұрын
​@@geraintthatcher3076he's referring to the animated stuff, which has all been great
@geraintthatcher3076
@geraintthatcher3076 14 күн бұрын
@ledinyourwalls No it hasn't. Rebels was awful where he invented time travel in Starwars to save his pet character and Bad Batch was boring as for Tales of the Jedi etc eww He claimed credit for the best episodes of Clones Wars even though he didn't write them though he did write the worst with the Sisters arc
@fredlusyk6741
@fredlusyk6741 14 күн бұрын
《The Mangolorian & Poodoo: Folie á Beau》 👽 🖖 🤖
@Voxxyvox
@Voxxyvox 14 күн бұрын
If it's a loose adaptation of heir to the Empire it is going to be very loose however it can be done problem is is I don't think anybody wants Mark Hamill to return his Luke Skywalker he's damaged himself let alone the name personally me I think they should go way back Old Republic but honestly I don't want Disney to do anything because Disney does not understand Star Wars I need to bring George back in and fix everything
@the-point-bearer6689
@the-point-bearer6689 14 күн бұрын
Just recast Luke by Sebastian Stan because Mark is already getting old, and as long he doesn't do criminal acts like Ezra Miller, it'll be fine.
@jimdaniels7531
@jimdaniels7531 14 күн бұрын
I just don't want a watered-down Filoni-ized version of Heir to the Empire.
@ledinyourwalls
@ledinyourwalls 14 күн бұрын
People will still complain if they do this.​@@the-point-bearer6689
@saberiandream316
@saberiandream316 14 күн бұрын
@@jimdaniels7531 Yeah, he'll have Ahsoka take over Luke's story.
@jeffreyguyot1277
@jeffreyguyot1277 14 күн бұрын
Filoni doesn't deserve or is he capable of writing and/or directing a quality live action project much less a film. Many SW fan claim to hate DEI, yet this chucklehead keeps get opportunities to fail upward and dodge scrutiny. Make it make sense.
@ledinyourwalls
@ledinyourwalls 14 күн бұрын
One of the main things with the filoni hate bandwagon is just to completely ignore everything good filoni has written and focus exclusively on the bad. Doesn't help most of the these people don't actually want to watch his good shows and would much rather complain about how much he sucks on the internet
@jimdaniels7531
@jimdaniels7531 14 күн бұрын
I'd have a lot more optimism if Filoni had a proper writer's room and left directing duties to someone else. Much as he did for the animated shows, which were generally great. Be like George Lucas with ESB -- serve as executive producer with "story by" credits, and delegate the rest to talented people.
@jeffreyguyot1277
@jeffreyguyot1277 14 күн бұрын
@ I've been anti-Filoni for more than 3 years. His interjection of himself into the lore, his habit of bringing filler episodes to live action and him playing with Force cannon to serve the characters that he created. He weaseled himself up under GL, then he cozied himself up under KK. I've been here since '77 as an 8 year old, my disgust for Filoni isn't a recent thing, I challenged Thor years ago about his blind faith in that fraud. So miss me with your condescending uninformed take Peaches.
@jeffreyguyot1277
@jeffreyguyot1277 14 күн бұрын
@ Filoni has been a willing participant in KK destroying SW and reducing the greatest IP in entertainment history mediocracy and failure. SW fans have been going at each other for their allegiances to the OT, the Prequels or the Sequels. And the powers at LucasFilm has exploited our in fighting to continue produce slop for us to fight over. Filoni included.
@achaudhari101
@achaudhari101 14 күн бұрын
Except your hatred towards him makes no sense since he’s one of the few people keeping the franchise from being completely dead. Not to mention he has more hits than misses.
Disney is doing what with the remains of the Galactic Starcruiser?
10:20
Thor Skywalker Plus
Рет қаралды 2,4 М.
So Cute 🥰 who is better?
00:15
dednahype
Рет қаралды 19 МЛН
Analyzing Evil: Dave Filoni From Disney Lucasfilm
14:29
J.J. Plagiarisms
Рет қаралды 52 М.
Ranking Star Wars Films With The Critical Drinker
16:34
Ben Shapiro
Рет қаралды 678 М.
How Dave Filoni Ruined Star Wars’ Continuity
10:09
Noach
Рет қаралды 44 М.
"Skeleton Crew" Creators tell all about Jod Na Nawood
13:13
Thor Skywalker Plus
Рет қаралды 3,3 М.
Our Culture is Collapsing: The Future of Storytelling
16:22
Real Life Fake Wizard
Рет қаралды 14 М.