I think she sounds wonderful. Not everyone is smart enough for Andor, don’t feel too bad

Well he's the one who has to like her, so it's not our problem. 🤷 But I do agree re the Andor show.

I guess a show that doesn't have a lightsaber duel or something blowing up every couple of minutes is beyond your ability to appreciate. Beyond that, you are just being a jerk, which pretty much tells everyone all they need to know about you.

Maybe you're watching the wrong channel. Maybe you should be listening to Jeremy if he's still about, or that theory tw@.

up

Tony Gilroy is definitely a better writer than whoever wrote that prequel novel. If it gets retconned it’s not a big deal.

@Pintoman101 But if it happens, it continues a bad trend with Disney ignoring its own Canon.

@ yeah it’s a problem and that’s bad when the retcon is inferior which has been the case 90% of the time so far. And it usually is because it’s Filoni who’s doing it who’s a hack writer. However this is Gilroy, a critically acclaimed filmmaker and screenwriter and creator of some of the best live action Star Wars ever made. If he retcons something from a novel that barely anyone has even read, then it’s probably for the better.

I know you will disagree with me on this but this is just and only how I feel is that the grey Jedi are with no doubt the way it should all be because Jedi they are too good but Sith are too bad and Star Wars should be where the Jedi and Sith are more human like instead of being at the extreme ends of good and bad

You're of course free to feel however you want about it (and I hope my reply doesn't come off as confrontational that isn't my intent) but I'm confused by what you mean when you say the Jedi are "too good". How can something be too good, or rather how can something that is too good be a bad thing? If for instance, we were all more kind, forgiving, and charitable with one another I don't see how that could be a bad thing. And to go along with that, in Star Wars (and the real world) what good comes from something that is bad or is of the dark side? If something is bad for you and others what good can come from it? If there is a force of nature like the dark side that is only there to cause pain and misery for everyone, what good could you get from it, for yourself or others? So with all that in mind, in Star Wars (and the real world) why would someone try to find the balance between the light and dark? The light does nothing but bring good and the dark brings nothing but bad.

@@jmsrex_1738 I understand what you mean but I was only saying more about humans in real life where they are naturally made with good and bad in them but to ignore one side exists or that one side is more powerful than the other imo is imbalance despite what the case is in Star Wars and all I was saying was that I wish that the Jedi and Sith can be more human like instead of at the extreme ends of good and bad because it’s too extreme I mean I might see it differently than you but my definition of too good is when people try to act perfect when they really aren’t and they try to pretend it’s true but really isn’t

I'm not surprised though, I loved bad batch, but it was a huge waste of potential. So much we never saw with the clones and a rushed ending

To be fair, that is pretty faithful to how the show would do it

I don’t mind, I mean the entirety of season 1 and half of 2 were side missions just meant for character development and telling random story’s. This just seems like a more chill one. I would like to see something either before or after the final scene of season 3. Maybe they hear omega is in trouble and they have to find her and the rebellion, could bring Rex back to

BB was successful, so Kennedy had to kill it obviously. It wasn’t one of her shitty projects

Amazing, every word of what you said was wrong.

Exactly.

And be kept far, FAR away from the EU. He breaks lore and always has, always will.

@@saberiandream316I get the concern, friend, but the EU hasn’t been canon for a while, so it’s free game for Disney and Filoni

@ He's still cherry-picking it and changing it in Disney Star Wars. Look what he did to Thrawn!

@@saberiandream316 and he’s had Timothy Zahn counseling him through the process, which, for better or worse, means it’s got Zahn’s stamp of approval. Look, I’m not disagreeing with you - Filoni has been flippant even with canon - but we’re gonna have to get used to EU becoming more and more an alternate universe, at least so long as management doesn’t change.

Just curious if you find the following popular criticism of _Ahsoka_ to not be specific enough: 1. portrayals of Ahsoka and Sabine seemed wooden and unreasonably awkward, especially in early episodes 2. underwhelming portrayal of mastermind Thrawn, who seemed more about running out the clock and basically just saying at the end, "It was my plan all along" 3. Sabine's recovery from lightsaber stab, though explainable, was an unwelcome contribution to lightsabers seeming less deadly 4. perplexing writing had Sabine not explain key details to Ezra upon reunion, which itself seemed emotionally underwhelming

I also dislike what they did with the Nightsisters. It's further butchering the lore that started out in the original EU, and from somebody who claims to be its greatest fan. This is why I don't buy Filoni's bullshit.

@@6.H.0.5.7 I agree with these as issues. Even my wife, who has only a very casual Star Wars interest, noted each of them.

⁠@@6.H.0.5.7 1. While I agree that Rosario Dawson was a bit stoic and reserved I think that was the point given that she’s been through a lot in Clone Wars & Rebels and is basically a wondering Ronin though I can understand how some might feel that way. But overall I think Dawson and Natasha Lui Bordizzo played Ahsoka and Sabine very well and felt like extensions of their animated counterparts. The only weird part was that they didn’t have a meaningful master & apprentice dynamic. The show mearly told us they did and shouted from the rooftops for us to roll with it. 2. I don’t what to say, I just don’t see it and you’re essentially parroting Thor’s “He basically ran the clock out and bearly escaped” criticism with no new spin on it. My main concern with Thrawn is how is one beat up star destroyer, a bunch of undead stormtroopers and some mysterious Nightsister cargo going to pose that much of a threat to the New Republic. 3. Yeah that was pretty dumb. 4. Duh 😒 that’s no surprise, even I who enjoyed the show has to admit that Sabine not telling Ezra how she found him was a bit of an odd choice. She keeps dodging the question because she’s understandably afraid to tell him because he knows that he may not take it well. But it never goes anywhere. It doesn’t ruin the show for me personally but it is a huge missed opportunity.