Defeat of Socialism in the USSR (Urdu)

[@MuhammadFarooq-ox6uq]

I wonder. how a well researched lecture of this caliber is free. It identifies that Dr Taimur Rahman truly loves the common peoples of this society. He conclude his lecture by saying that 'theoretical struggle is the most important struggle (toward a communist state)'. For this struggle we have to read Marx in the background of Pakistan. Thank you Sir for such a historical lecture.

[@Taimur_Laal]

As a Marxist I believe knowledge should be free and available to all.

[@MuhammadFarooq-ox6uq]

@@Taimur_Laal Long live Comrade.

[@inquilabi2811]

@@Taimur_Laalas ever, well put. Please watch this , they had this discussion after Dr Asatar Bair had a tweet about Stalin trending. I've commented there and mentioned you. kzbin.info/www/bejne/naGUaKGll6x9iJI

[@mohsinaziz8617]

Sir admire your courage and work. Allah Almighty give you strength peace and prosperity Amen

[@rohitrathor5273]

Thanks comrade for such a coherent view of history… Lal salaam✊🏻

[@HamzaAli-ee1oh]

Yes sir and you are doing marvellous work in theoretical framework. People are listening you and learning from you in far flung areas by watching your vedios. More power to you🚩🚩 Laal Slaam

[@AsjadBukhari]

Knowledge, information and intellect - right combination of these three factors is Dr Taimur Rehman's lecture and analysis. We are lucky to have professor like him in today's dark Pakistan Love this

[@Taimur_Laal]

And I am lucky to have you as a friend comrade Asjad. Thank you for your support over all these years.

[@farooqahmed809]

Speaking a bit too fast.

[@TheLight72]

ِبڑا اہم موضوع ہے۔ بطور سوشیالوجسٹ اور سوشلزم کے طالب علم کے میرے لیے یہ بڑا اہم سوال تھا۔ میں نے ابھی ویڈیو دیکھی نہیں ہے مگر موضوع دیکھ کر سامنے ہے کہ کتنی اہم ویڈیو ہے اور لازماً دیکھی جانی چاہیے.

[@mohinderkumar7298]

Dr.Taimur excellent point. We are looking for causes of collapse of Soviet Union in 1989 in the events of 1930s!! We barely analyse bogeys of Perestroika, Glastnot --the events that emerged out of nowhere just prior to the 1989 Collapse of USSR. Except Russia, barely any of the other 14 Republics shed parasitism. They chose to have RUTHLESS OVERDEPENDENCE on Russia for over 70 years. These 14 Republics themselves were burden on USSR and invited ruthlessness to quell their mediocrity and prolonged stagnancy. Russia was overstretched. Recall Stalin's birthplace Georgia on the eve of 1989 Collapse of USSR. Highly reactionary! They (Estonia, Lithuania, Georgia) as parasites took out HAMMER from the symbol of Soviet flag in 1980s to ape America's bogey of liberalism and individualism. The result?

[@mohinderkumar7298]

People often confuse "private property" with "personal property" or "personal objects"! The two are quite distinct.

[@TheLight72]

کامریڈ بڑے اہم سوالات تھے ذہن میں جِن کا آپ نے اِس ویڈیو میں جواب دے دیا ہے۔

[@mominakiran8662]

Sir u r an amazing teacher and an inspirational speaker.. i love your energy.. and your way of teaching.. keep it up sir!!!!!

[@mehrajqureshi7136]

Thanks sir ur videos r really helping

[@advocatehafiznasirmahmood5980]

Mashalllah ! I always wait for your informative talk

[@int.peacesociety]

You are the person of this era who can change and save pakistan

[@digitalfactory6502]

After seeing super power fail with this concept ...!

[@Batman0896]

One of the best video from you sir👍👍

[@mehrajqureshi7136]

Sir can u make a lecture series on subcontinent intellectuals of british india like sir syed , mau azad, Tilak etc It is in our kashmir university syllabus@ Pg pol science

[@RanjanKumar-bz2mh]

Very informative video And new perspective for us

[@Alburr250]

I must say that after listening to your lectures, I am gaining a completely different view on Communism and Socialism. In the West and also Islamic societies, Communism is seen as evil and anti religion. I believe we need to study Marxism, Socialism, Communism, Leninism, Maoism and Stalinism on their own terms and on their own merits and demerits.

[@musicisinmybones5771]

I love the way u explain the things...

[@mohinderkumar7298]

Dr. Rehman, your face resembles 90% with my elder brother Rajinder. 😃 My parents migrated from Kabirwala Trihaiyanwala Multan in 1947.

[@danishchaudhary2.0]

I am From Kabirwala😇

[@binod3386]

There is nothing in the face...... The face of our village cowherd resembles 95% to Mukesh Ambani....

[@mohinderkumar7298]

@@danishchaudhary2.0 My maternal grandfather named Khan Chand was tenant share cropper of sone Muslim landlord in Trihaiyanwala village. Landowner had also alloted him a house in the village and land for tilling.

[@danishchaudhary2.0]

@@mohinderkumar7298 What was the name of that Muslim landlord? Actually we are not locals , wo also migrated from India to here!!

[@mohinderkumar7298]

@@danishchaudhary2.0 I don't know landlord's name in Trihaiyanwala village. My mother died in 2018. My grandfather's name was Khan Chand. Villagers might know which landlord had Khan Chand tenant whom the Landlord helped profusely even to the extent of arranging Tobacco, rice, roasted blackgram loaded on Mare for use / consumption on the way or for the time period of 1 month during which my grandfather with family stayed at platform of Khanewal railway station before train journey for Amritsar / Kurukshetra was arranged.

[@YasirKhan-ur6om]

I love your lectures , sir.

[@muhammadikram399]

The Soviet system was in the Museum of History. Now at present new system in Russia. Russian Republic not or no more Soviet Union. There is no more Berlin wall. This wall was destroyed by the common people of Germany.

[@aghakashifhussain968]

This lecture is powerful slept on capitilism.Laaal Salaaam Comrade Taimur

[@sameerahmed1797]

slept nhi slap hota hai

[@syedqalb-e-hydershah773]

This lecture was much needed. A powerful reply.

[@CR-bi9ug]

Lal Salam, from Kerala...India...

[@kingxkhan5007]

Our leader ,our love our dignity sir taimor Rahman❣️❣️❣️❣️love from pakhtunkhwa

[@swagatochatterjee7104]

Where can I find the other lectures you mentioned?

[@karl_marx3466]

Taimur Sir where can I find your book on fall of USSR which you mentioned earlier in lecture Please Sir

[@muhammadsaleem8048]

Sir, May I get Dr.Azeem's lecture on Marx's history you mentioned in the beginning of your speech? though I got reached your lecture late

[@saurabhinsaan]

Absolutely easy and informative video, specially for new learners.

[@HalaQureshi]

Sir dr syed azeem sahab k lectur jin ka ap ny zikr kia h wo kahan uploaded hen? Kindly share link.

[@dariusaasin5580]

Very helpful lecture but Dr. It would be really helpful if you can explain post Stalin period and post krushev period in detail. Also discuss about Cambodia, Cuban, Vietnam, Korea economic models too and why they are very different from ex-soviet and China model. Thanks in advance.

[@hangonsnoop]

I tried a search for the book "The Long March" that you have a picture of in the beginning of the video and I was not able to find it. Does anyone know how I could get it?

[@Taimur_Laal]

It is a forthcoming work. Not yet published.

[@khaan3278]

All people are equal in moral ethics but different in resources

[@VALANIFS]

Would please give the same lecture in English? ??

[@ramanbeniwal28]

Subtitles are required to understand your views completely. You've explained this concept very beautifully

[@bilallqureshii]

Sir please uyghurs ki history or current situation pe koi short video banen

[@amnaafzal4901]

Can you please explain domestic structures?? I have read somewhere that collapse of domestic structure was the main reason for the demise of Soviet Union likewise in Afghanistan Somalia and Sudan..rather than aggression from some outside force??

[@sabawonkarimi1495]

Now I have completely another idea of what ISSR was. Sir you have completely changed my opinons about socialism and specially the numbers of death of Socialism. I am now your big fan.

[@abdullah04_m]

Also learn from other side too...

[@mohinderkumar7298]

Free market Unfree citizens

[@michaelmappin1830]

I wish there were English subtitles.

[@zerinzinia8660]

Me too.

[@mohsinnawaz5972]

Hello Sir, Can u recommend any book regarding why USSR broke?

[@andrey-uf1tg]

Hello. Even though it's not a book, it might be interesting. This is a video (with English closed captions) reflecting the viewpoint of Russian Marxists. kzbin.info/www/bejne/onevZZZnna2VpKs

[@mohinderkumar7298]

Lessons for Pakistan :- Organize in groups/collectives in mind the individualised people to be conscious about their lost vision of citizenship. Feel like citizens, not subjects. Develop entrepreneurship in family. At the same time, organize socially to demand quality basic services from government, viz., safe drinking water, quality medical & health services and quality education. Dr.Taimur is right --this has to be done without shouting Zindabad Murdabad! How? Love Your "Neighbor" (I mean to say by neighbor not India who is your "Dushman Mukq" 😃. By neighbor I mean to say neighborer household in your Village and Municipal Ward). Develop social fusion. Help everyone in need. Develop cooperation. Mutual help and appreciation. Love your fellow villagers more than you exhibit love for Kashmir! Kashmir is here! Going nowhere! 😃Be confused, not!

[@ryanmichelz94]

Prof. Rahman, I know you are a very busy man. I'd love to hear something like this in English. You are a great teacher

[@HamzaAli-ky9ms]

H4

[@drrukhsanamangi5905]

It's very important lecture

[@digitalfactory6502]

why its a already failed ideology ...

[@muhammadshahrukh3009]

Plz answer Sir, The world is progressing with the passage of time. Like racism is there but has been reduced, misogyny is there but lower than before, there are the UNO and Amnesty Intl for human rights and there is democracy instead of monarchies. My question is that if the world is accepting overwhelmingly those ideas which are beneficial for humanity and Socialism is good for humanity instead of capitalism then why is the world not accepting socialism? What are the obstacles?

[@Taimur_Laal]

The whole of 20th century is the advance of socialist ideas.

[@muhammadshahrukh3009]

@@Taimur_Laal ...thank u sir..

[@faizanrana8363]

Sir Dr syed azeem ka lecture kaha upload ho ga?

[@Taimur_Laal]

On NSF page.

[@faizanrana8363]

@@Taimur_Laal can you please mention the page or link?

[@sherazshoukatma-eng9972]

God bless you sir.. love you soo much..❤️

[@junaidnoor]

Sir kindly upload the lecture of Syed Azeem which held before you. Regards

[@Taimur_Laal]

That will be uploaded from NSF page.

[@junaidnoor]

@@Taimur_Laal Thank you sir please don't forget to share the link when it upload.

[@MuhammadAhmad-xw2jq]

Dr. Taimor Sir,,,, glamour of Lahore

[@mohinderkumar7298]

I think title may be "Defeat of Whatever in the Name of Socialism in USSR" Or "Defeat of Experimental Socialism in USSR" Or Defeat of State Capitalism in USSR".......

[@AsifKhan-hk3ck]

Sir aap ki baat Russian sahi k wo capitalism ki terf aya to inko noqsan Howa lekin China to yahi capitalism akhatyar inki tarqi aap ko malom ya Kia waja hai

[@khaan3278]

"How small of all that human hearts endure that part that kings or laws can cause cure" Samoule johnson

[@Vivacious_Lenin]

Hi Taimur. Can you please release a version of this video in English? Or perhaps add sub titles?

[@Vikas-zd1rj]

Great explaination

[@sujalthapa7887]

The child in 9:30 so cute.

[@skmathew]

Comrade, Can you do this video in english?

[@Taimur_Laal]

Sure. But soon. I have to finish my series on Arab-Israeli conflict first.

[@skmathew]

@@Taimur_Laal ok. Comrade. Thanks

[@hangonsnoop]

@@Taimur_Laal Looking forward to it.

[@akshitparikh635]

Great explanation! 🙇🏻‍♂️

[@khoslapp]

What was role of Lack of free elections in Soviet Union in it's down fall?

[@anandarupa5959]

Sir you are amazing

[@shabbirahmeddar7765]

Also speak about economic hitman book which is ghost written .

[@usamasaeed6516]

Excellent Sir.

[@inquilabi2811]

Where can I get your book? I'm very interested in the "salary system" during the Stalin period. The Trotsky bit was quite interesting. About his Euro centrism, Trotsky critism about Stalin was also about the nature of his "brutal Asiatic" rule. I remember reading some long essay about Stalin by Trotsky and he made a big thing it. Was a while back now, I should revisit it. Even Stalin himself referred to himself as Asiatic. His daughter called him Asian in this old UK interview I was just watching. Must of been some significance attached to this, asians been seen to be authoritarian by nature. Unenlightened and undemocratic unlike Europeans. kzbin.info/www/bejne/iovaZKaEab2YhNE Oh there is a book called Oriental Despotism a comparative study of total power written in 1957. Not read it but the title tells me that feeds into the stereotype too. There's actually an interesting blog called The Oriental Despot by Jay Tharappel where he has an article called Anti-Stalinism is left wing racism .

[@Aniket7Tomar]

Sorry, this one was dissappointing when compared to your other videos, seemed like a lot of hand waving and presentation of an incomplete picture which is understandable given the time constraints. I would love to see a more rigourous presentation of these arguments maybe in a series of videos like the Arab-Israeli one, if and when you can get the time.

[@raiikhankhan1912]

Great sir.

[@57NAEEM]

Dear can you enlist some primary books to understand Marxism?

[@A.SMotivation-ii1wk]

❤ love you 😘 sir

[@SajjadAhmed-no4ec]

Decolonizing ke liye socialism ke pass kya hai?

[@tehseenfatimasyeda3082]

ڈاکٹر تیمور کیا میں آپ سے فون پر رابطہ کر سکتی ہوں،؟

[@JawadArifAwan]

What about the soviet Afghan war. Why did soviet union invade? The drug addictions really did pile up during that time. What was the politburo thinking then ?

[@umayr2935]

Sir ye Khalid sb kon hain?

[@ukkashahshaikh7227]

تیمور رحمان چینی انقلاب پر بھی ایک لیکچر سیریز بنایئے۔۔

[@NaveedJan834]

zabardast ❤️🚩🚩🚩❤️

[@CCCP_Again]

Superb

[@shoaibkhattak3511]

I feel or my understanding after the lecture is that "socialism is initial stage of capitalism".

[@openup7652]

Excellent

[@tahiraziz9168]

great

[@jamshadkhan4066]

✌✌✌✌✌

[@imrankhattak8032]

sir Mig biggest helicopter in world first computer invention when u say these to capitalist they are shocked even today russia uses most weapons and design of soviet era

[@sheikhhashimi5082]

شکست ✓ ہوئی ناکام نہیں ہوا✓

[@umeramin7150]

NSF means ..?

[@zainulabdin33]

National Students Federation

[@NSFOfficial]

NSF abbreviated as National Student Federation represents the deprived students, farmers, workers, women and minorities of Pakistan.

[@dattatrayanalawade2016]

Did STALIN followed Lenins PHILOSOPHY ?

[@yugdarshan]

No

[@manahylgilani355]

❤❤❤❤

[@digitalfactory6502]

System comes later , first come the purposses of life and objective of life , without right concept of life every system should be failed today or tomorrow because it doesnt fit with the nature of human being because its emanate from a flasehood (wrong concept), which has happened in case of USSR.

[@monasunny692]

I m communiest

[@sonusukkur998]

ایک شکست خوردہ نظام کی تعریف میں رطب اللسان ہونا اپنا وقت تو ضایع کرنا ہی ہے دوسروں کا بھی ضایع کرنا ہے، سیدھا اس موضوع پہ بات کرو کے اس نظام کو شکست کیسے ہوئی، وقت کے ساتھ کیا کیا اصلاحات کرنی چاہیے تھی، مذہبی معاملات پہ پابندی لگا کے زبردستی مذہبی امور سے روکنا بھی ایک جابرانہ کام تھا سوشلسٹوں کا، اور بھی وجوہات ہونگی، دوسرا اس طرح سوشلزم کے اوصاف بیان کرنا یک طرفہ بات ہو جائے گی، سوشلسٹس اور سرمایہ دارانہ نظاموں کے حامیوں کو چاہیے کہ آمنے سامنے بیٹھ کے مقابلانہ انداز میں ایک دوسرے کو غلط ثابت کریں۔

[@piyushsingh9334]

North Korea 😂😂 Socialist Country 😂😂😂aur Democracy kya mazak karte ho Comrade 😂😂😂

[@sabawonkarimi1495]

1:05

[@dattatrayanalawade2016]

Pakistan fauz 4 jange harne ke baad bhi nahi sikhi.

[@jfrorn]

I'll even take subtitles.... :(

[@jfrorn]

I can't find that book, is it available in English?

[@Taimur_Laal]

@@jfrorn no. It is a forthcoming publication. I haven't completed it yet.

[@jfrorn]

@@Taimur_Laal Let us know, based on the title it sounds like a must read!

[@sadiqhussain157]

کس لیے گھڑے مردے اکھیڑ رھے ھو بھاٸ فاٸدہ نہیں اسلام پر ریسرچ کرلٕں آپ نہایت ذھین انسان ھں

[@salahsabri2925]

Absrurd arguments. The speaker is clearly biased in favour of what he believes.

[@allaboutknowledge6069]

Ap ko Pakistan k hr sher ma apnay comrades k zarya kr Wana chaiye.

[@naseemshekhani]

great NSF

[@zafarjaved907]

Pakistani "Tarraqi pasandon " ka safar " KARL MAX SE NAWAZ SHARIF/ FAZAL UR REHMAN TK"

[@ritiklingayat9850]

Long live capitalism long live free market econoy

[@Ab16161]

Huh?

[@ashrafalam6075]

Less than 1% own 99% and rest 99% own 1% in capitalist countries. Please watch these kind of break ups in USA, Western Europe and even in Middle East

[@aman_insaan]

Long live People! Long live the Love! Long live Revolution!

[@asadali-ze9jy]

As he said in this video , " leave the politics of slogans and start actually reading books "

[@googleme682]

waise ye baat mujhe hazam nahi hui is hisab se modi india me 2 baar bahut votes se election jeeta iska matalb wo sahi hai aur sab pakistani media pakistan army galat bhala ye to wo baat hui apna ullu sidha karne kuch facts ko ignore karo kuch kosach mano