Derek O' Brien's Remarks | The Citizenship (Amendment) Bill, 2019

[@mab.sen2018]

Go on Derek sir.

[@debasmitabalchamadia5678]

17 mins. Must watch... Morality vs majority government.. proud to be citizen of such country where there's such MP

[@oogeshwar9299]

Must watch after 17 mins too Debasmita. 18:48 .." all his family members in Pakistan are converted to Muslim..and gone" So..please first listen completely after make a conclusion.

[@mesinjana]

@mahesh deshmukh what do u know about Bengalis and bengali culture. Please excuse us the gyaan.

[@62133004]

@@mesinjana You people supporting the same people who have broken the great Bengal into two pieces.. that is the culture of Bengal today.. Bengal at one time was a very great community.. but today.. they are nothing but a bunch of people who just know how to do darnas and who are rapidly converting to islam.. Bengal is the other kashmir in the making... most of the Bengalis have fled Bengal and are living in the south.. they do not want to go back to this Waste Bengal and call south India their home... just because of the current culture that is prevalent...

[@Tout-Le-Monde02]

@@62133004 at least our community was great .... ur community was always crap and will remain crap .... keep on drinking gau mutra ..... the whole world will come and piss on u

[@Tout-Le-Monde02]

@mahesh deshmukh aur kitne din mulla, christians, porkistan, china etc sab ko doshi thehrate rahoge???? tumhara feku to economy ka ma behen kar chuka hai .... saala chaiwala chowkidar ko pm karoge to aisa hi hoga

[@jefffreeman2648]

Derick you are really a great speaker not only audio but also kept records well of all that went on accompanied with dates and events not even our late President and chief could put it across the way you did ... These are the multilingual angloindian I am really proud of congrats looking forward for less government and more governance faster the BETTER. BATI BACHOW! they form half the votebank and belong to the home ministry. Women are the backbone of every man. As the saying goes "behing every successful man there is always a woman."!!!!! keep up the good work jhn

[@dominicalvares6384]

Superb speech. Full on facts and real issues.

[@johngates2602]

I oppose CAB. It's unconstitutional.

[@that_complicated_guy]

#IndiaRejectsCAB #WeOpposeCAB #NoToCAB

[@RahulRawat-kj4zs]

funny thing is no one from opposition said anything about tribal/indigenous people.they all are just asking why muslims are excluded from cab

[@that_complicated_guy]

@@RahulRawat-kj4zs that's a poor thing. But, we still oppose CAB.

[@RahulRawat-kj4zs]

@@that_complicated_guy yeah you can oppose cab in northeast you have full rights...but do not forget how lakhs of bangladeshi and rohingya came there ..not only in northeast but to j nd k also and who helped them ..aftr this nation wide nrc is needed with greater efficiency

[@kshdevika4606]

Rahul see the reality.... And the remember if muslim became majority forget about fundamental right u enjoy today

[@SudipBhattacharyya]

Proud of you, Derek O' Brien. Regards

[@youthindian1593]

We oppose CAB

[@mohisinas4286]

dis govt failed to help migrant workers... but it want to help others now.. the question is. do they want to really help?or agenda?

[@rupanjanamitra9969]

🔥

[@wiseperson1851]

India khatre me hai is" true"! But because of government not foreigners/refugees!

[@radioactivedetective6876]

Correct

[@samsudeen4406]

Very good.... Now All politics members is speak in our own language in parliament... This victory of Tamilian people and Dravida munnettra kazaham.

[@biswajitduttajuwel3214]

We support cab

[@mdmobarakansari5193]

Bhakto bas tumader hobe

[@saumyaranjansethy1798]

Yes sister we all Hindu support NCR. We all the people of odisha support NCR

[@rudranarayan6053]

@@saumyaranjansethy1798 ame odiya mane support karuchu but ame amo tribal luko ku bhuli jauchu. Bengali muslim ju mane excluded Hebe tanke amo area re posi paranti. Amo tribal culture ku hele protection darkar. No hole amo culture haji jivo. Amo govt ku aita uthayeba kotha

[@saumyaranjansethy1798]

@@rudranarayan6053 hann bhai apana pura khanti katha ta kahile. Ama odisha sarakaran Ku eai samasya upujiba purbaru sachetana hebaku padiba. Sarba prathame ame janasadharana sajaga heba uchita. Jay Jagannath bhai.

[@pyrthat4659]

But not in North East.. it my land not someone else...I would not allow any ousider To step foot and take what our right and desturb the future of my commununity.

[@shadabqureshi6283]

That's I love Bengal. Always speak For nation

[@mdmobarakansari5193]

Thanks

[@empoweringself4386]

From the real live vdo .. something is missing..from this vdo some important points have been cut🤯🙊🤐

[@humayunmondal8519]

I oppose the cab

[@RahulRawat-kj4zs]

18:48 so he is supporting cab 😂😂😂

[@Awesomeite4life]

Seriously!

[@mesinjana]

He is praising our constitution the same constitution which some cheerleaders want to replace by manulaw

[@RahulRawat-kj4zs]

@@mesinjana lol how it is manulaw??? do you even understand him ?? he supported cab by his cmnt

[@xcalibur5872]

To All the CAB supporters..I hope u all will be snatched by those illegal immigrants

[@62133004]

keep dreaming idiots..

[@rohanthakur5898]

He is comparing Past India to This. He talked about Unemployment, Demonization etc. But he doesn't talk about why this bill should not be implemented? He is taking idhar udhar ki baatein. He is trying to bring emotional touch here but not talking about the actual point? 😂 Not talking about the actual problems😂 how is it against Indian Citizen!!

[@rohanthakur5898]

@@mightydestroyer7360 : I am neither a Bhakt nor a Chamcha. But just look at you. You don't even know what am I talking about!!! You are talking about my shakal who doesn't even have a face. Your handle name says "liberal thinker" and your brain is full of shits because instead of actual point here "tune muh se hagna shuru Kar Diya"

[@mesinjana]

Unemployment, demo is not idhar udhar ki batein. Its the real problem. CAB is the idhar udhar ki bat that govt is using to hide its flaws. Inflicting tragedy on ppl for covering up their flaws. At this rate India will surely become 5 trillion next year (fui last line was sarcastic)

[@rohanthakur5898]

@@mesinjana : But this debate is all about CAB and instead of talking about "idhar udhar ki baatein" All the MPs and MLAs should address and ask the real question about this specific bill and address the concerns of North East because this is about to become the law. And There would be other Occasion where Govt. should be asked about economy, unemployment and all..

[@radioactivedetective6876]

@@rohanthakur5898 But Derek O'Brien too said what u r saying. That CAB is not eye wash to cover up economic failure, it is the agenda, and it has to be addressed. He brought up demonetization in the context of the home minister's 'assurance' and 'promise' that "kisi ko darne ki zarurat nehi hai" - coz p.m modi's promise before demonetization was broken (one example) - if the p.m makes and breaks promises, how can we trust the home minister's promise? He talked about demonetization in context of bjp's track record of making and breaking promises, and the lack of credibility

[@radioactivedetective6876]

@@rohanthakur5898 Actually, about pm's lack of credibility he could've mentioned another point - pm said he wont ever forgive pragya thakur, apparently enquiry hoga - what happened to all that? Gave her a ticket, made her member of defence committee - had to remove her from said committee too, but what about the disciplinarian action?

[@oogeshwar9299]

I think Derek is little bit confused. He oppose it. Or support it. 18:35

[@Oogwaylaugh]

Because of this secularism and Communism, West Bengali hindus will face same fate like Kashmiri pandits and Bangladeshi hindus who enjoyed their secular 1971.

[@deeptangshusarkar3450]

Old Monk Oogway say the same about Indian democracy 20 years later...gawars always realize late

[@Oogwaylaugh]

@@deeptangshusarkar3450 yea, gawar always realize late just like Bangladeshi Hindus, kashmiri Pandits who trusted their Peaceful religious neighbors. Democracy protected kashmiri hindus very well i guess. As a Kafir If i have to choose, anyday ill choose to live in my religious ancestral homeland over the so called Democracy where me and my family have to face another genocide like Kashmiri Hindus.

[@Tanmay_Bhattacharya]

Says a non-Bengali😂..My family is staying here for more than 8-9 decades..They never felt like this..if you are speaking about Marichjhapi incident, then Bangladeshis were told to go where they came from. But they didn't when police was sent they attacked first..so it is obvious that police will retaliate..so massacre happened in Marichjhapi. If you slap me it is natural that I will punch/kick you as I am a living being and not Gandhi that I will forward my another cheek to you. You must have thought that before slapping.

[@mekayashwanth650]

Bjp IT cell is in full force on the comments

[@sushantchatterji7228]

Surprisingly Derek revealed that he is neither indian nor Hindu . Tabhi to tmc me hai

[@radioactivedetective6876]

No, he isnt Hindu. But why do u say he isnt Indian? He was born in India before all cut off dates, his parents were in India before 19th july, 1948. According to all criterion of citizenship, including the newly passed CAB, he is Indian.

[@smitpatel1417]

Woahhhhhh

[@tolstoyeducation]

Great

[@bibhuprasadparida7287]

U r exposing urself Mr o brien and don't include odisha in ur statement. We know what to do.

[@alokalok1127]

Mr Derek I believe that it is obvious that to prove your citizenship you do need a piece of paper

[@radioactivedetective6876]

ঈশ্বর আমার বিদ্যাসাগর ঠাকুর আমার রবীন্দ্রনাথ রাম আমার রামমোহন কাজী আমার নজরুল ফকির আমার লালন 👆loved this

[@batashkrsakta737]

Infact that's true, but the other party wants us to go back to pre enlightenment age

[@radioactivedetective6876]

@@batashkrsakta737 Yes. The do not understand the ideas and ideals of Bengal Renaissance, which was a landmark in the formation of modern India

[@kausthubh7541]

The main point at 16:30.

[@bibhuprasadparida7287]

If everything is /was fine then why there are two bengals??

[@imakesense4456]

"They converted to Islam" Why? to avoid persecution and not by choice.. So that means being a muslim saves you from persecution in pakistan When even the O briens could not survive with their religion and identity intact in pakistan...how can you expect a poor hindu to survive there...muslims are not persecuted so no citizenship... He agreed unknowingly🙏

[@Tout-Le-Monde02]

no he didnt. his relatives were forced to convert in porkistan. but india's constitution protected his christian identity.

[@juleenac5601]

Forced conversion is not allowed in Islam. Because the Qur'an clearly states that to any individual first of all to Study and then to Identify and Realise by yourself and at last when you find true to Believe. Still I don't understand why some people force their fellow brothers and sisters to convert into Islam. If somebody does that then he isn't an umma of prophet Muhammad (s).

[@user-it9fy8sw5s]

The Hindu daily had published a statistics depicting religious persecution in South Asian countries including China. The statistics clearly says that India stands top on the persecution list.

[@radioactivedetective6876]

No he didn't. His relatives having to leave or convert in Pakistan just proves how bad Pakistan is. His point is that India is stronger, better. At least till now... CAB + NRC is based on religious categorisation. He pointed out that India is stronger and better because it is secular.

[@Shetmalbhav]

Juleena C With due respect to knowledge of Quran doesn't it tell to kill or put jaziya on those who don't believe in Allah. Why it is mentioned to spread Islam by doing jihad by any means. Doesn't it tell to lie to defend Islam what is known as takiyya.

[@RajuRjRahul]

😁😁😁

[@Sbebuli]

Why am I feeling like slapping him?

[@mightydestroyer7360]

Why i feel like kick ur ass ....

[@mightydestroyer7360]

@@RahulRawat-kj4zs well product of thresome calling other product of halala . Is it new india

[@RahulRawat-kj4zs]

@@mightydestroyer7360halala products are crying this in new india ...rohingyas and illegal bangladesi muslims nikalo pheli furast se

[@SD-kr2ou]

liberal thinker well at least before speaking in public it would have been better if you had checked your English. It’s even worse than O’Briens logic.

[@abdulhakam2589]

14:40

[@baluanna1]

ha ha ha o brien ji aap tou minority ho dekho ye bill ata pehle hi tou kiska fayda hota....

[@nilesh382000]

Is he high???...what is he even saying???

[@ayanbanerjee5517]

bohut pukti paka

[@Klimkrisnaynamah]

He is representing collective foolishness of all who voted for TMC in Bengal

[@radioactivedetective6876]

Actually his opening salvo was spot on in capturing the heritage of bengal and Bengl Renaissance I dont know if u understand bengali, but he pretty much summed up all that bengal is proud of through the names of 5 great personalities.

[@Tanmay_Bhattacharya]

@@radioactivedetective6876 WB will always be underrated..because of ego and jealousy and arrogance of non-Bengalis..France came to know Satyajit Ray before India did..that's the difference..Einstein knew Satyendranath Bose before India did. When Satyajit Ray got Oscar after that he was given the highest Indian Award. But before..I don't think any non-Bengali knew him.

[@Tanmay_Bhattacharya]

@@radioactivedetective6876 I can name more than 20 on spot.

[@indranilmondal5509]

What a crap logic....no logic at all 😄

[@natweracharya5605]

1st comment 😀