Minister Amit Shah's Reply | The Citizenship (Amendment) Bill, 2019

[@RebellionAgainstTyranny]

Set playback speed at 1.25 Thank me later...

[@nikhilprabhakar1730]

Sports Adda great tip

[@ammyroy6286]

I always use

[@Biswapradipdas]

Thank you Bro..

[@payalsonkar6518]

thnx alot

[@khushali09]

Thanks a lot

[@thadiyoor1]

*Amit Shah deserves high appreciations from all Indians. He is pointed, very critical and genuine in all respect. A Big Thank You Amitji for your efforts.*

[@last_hope6166]

Why r u becoming fools too easily

[@letterfake8319]

As a Hindu Nepali, I am very much happy for all Hindu refugees in India.

[@nikhiltiwari6923]

This is the time Hindus take their destiny in their hands. Hindu of India remained mute spectator when Indian land was shattered in 3 pieces that left Hindus of Pakistani India & Bangladeshi India vulnerable to persecution. This is why we need to wake up to Islamic mindset of encroaching non Muslim land.

[@chanchreang4892]

Yeah people are happy for Hindus refugees but no one is worrying for hindus of India who are not refugees .

[@letterfake8319]

gorkha Li Yes. It is sad. But the refugee from bhutan say they want to return back to bhutan. Giving them nepalese citizenship would be easy since they are ethnically nepalese and speak nepalese. I don't know if it has been proposed or advocated in the years.

[@Lumix861]

2011 census : 10,679,345 Muslims in the Indian state of Assam, forming over 34.22% of its population. This bill is desperately needed

[@kb9880]

That's NRC you're saying

[@BikashRoy-xh6se]

27:47 > Gandhi 30:00 > CM of West Bengal 53:52 58:02 > about Assam

[@19.divyanshutripathi3]

Lol Thank You

[@kuldeepchaudhary5901]

This guy is just awesome👌🏻👌🏻, loving the way he rebuttals these fake seculars ❤️❤️❤️😂😂😂,

[@ankitsingh-cl6yx]

Mota.bhai that's why u r ..my fav politician

[@himanshuraghav555]

I totally agree with you honourable Home minister sir...your each and every line is clear there is no discrimination between any religion. People should listen to this and accept it that in Pakistan, Afghanistan and Bangladesh, non-Muslim are suffering from Muslim community.

[@vinaykumar-jv1ku]

अमित शाह जी जैसा clarity से explanation और to the point बोलना बहुत अच्छा है। इनसे मुझे भी प्रेरणा मिलती है।

[@vandanasharma2159]

में सिर्फ इतना ही कहूंगी की ये देश मोदी सरकार का आभारी है और रहेगा। आप के साथ उन लाखों लोगों की दुवाएं है जिन्होंने मुस्लिमों कि यातनाएं सही इस्लाम कंट्री में। धन्यवाद।

[@jatinsharma6724]

Mam apki baat ko m appreciate krta hu... 👍 so don't worry kyuki hoskta h kuch log aab apko abuse krne aye cmnt section m kyuki apne muslim ka naam liya h... But v r wd u...apki baat ekdum sahi h.. 🙏👍be brave..jai hind

[@RAHULCHITTI]

इसको कहते है कह कर लेना , तर्क इसे बोलते है भाई लोग , कानून के बाहर नहीं है कुछ भी।। 🔝 पुराने जजमेंट सबूत है ।। और #CAB पास , बधाई हो हिन्दू , सिख , बोद्ध , जैन , ईसाई , पारसी भाईलोग ।। 🇮🇳💐

[@udaychatterjee4424]

If it is all about giving citizenship then why the detention centres are being made ? I didn’t get the point

[@avnish_rana]

detention centres have existed since 2000s. Its for illegal migrants not refugees. Example- an African national is randomly checked for his visa in delhi and is found out that his visa has expired, where will we put them ? certainly not jail. So it's for illegal migrants only.

[@abdheshsharma2333]

This has been made for the people which are staying here illegaly. Not for the Muslim or others. So pls dont create the rumors.

[@udaychatterjee4424]

Abdhesh Sharma what is the definition of rumour?? I didn’t impose my thought onto anyone. I asked a simple question and I am glad you people have cleared my doubts. Stop adding irrelevant foot note saying ‘stop spreading rumours’ . It was just a simple question!

[@salam7376]

@@abdheshsharma2333 ok, and how do you prove someone is legal ? by producing documents. And if you don't have documents its fine , you can simply claim you're a refugee. Unless the individual is a muslim and that is the main issue here. Plus BGP leaders have long been saying that the muslims don't belong to India anyway ..so there you go. Its not a rumor.

[@saurabhbhavsar8896]

Interesting to see Hon. Minister of External affairs S Jaishankar `s reaction during debate.

[@குமரன்இளஞ்சேரல்]

whatt did you find dude????????????

[@designazad8432]

“वो हर व्यक्ति जो विकास के लिए खड़ा है, उसे हर एक रुढ़िवादी चीज की आलोचना करनी होगी, उसके प्रति अविश्वास करना होगा और उसे चुनोती देनी होगी।” - भगत सिंह

[@The_Trading_hacks]

Who watch full video Hats off mota Bhai 🚩🚩🚩🚩👍👍👍👍

[@rj34karauli38]

Real tiger mota bhai

[@Mukeysh4u]

Abba-Amit Shah Harmoniums- Opposition Agree like 👍 👍 👍👍 👍

[@sapnasweet5563]

Nice home minister amit Shah ji aap ki puri bhashan shuna jai hind sir

[@harshavardhansahoo]

People of India, see the Opposition and their behaviour in a respected House.

[@nityarao672]

I would urge you to watch Mahua Moitra's speech on CAB and watch their opposition's reaction then

[@ok_Thanx_1235]

अमित शाहजी मेरा एक और काम करे कि जनसंख्या नियंत्रण काणुन लाया जाऐ क्युकी कुछ डरे हुऐ नागरिक 10 से 12 बच्चे पैदा करते है

[@dolagobindabadi8375]

warna hum do hamare paentalis 45 aur sabke haat main AK saitalis (AK47)

[@vimalkumarupadhyay8439]

@HELL NAW What is UCC

[@amol44mankar]

amit ji population badane ke mood mai dikh rahe hai abhi to......hum log jo real indians hai unko dekhye amit ji bahar ke logo ko chodeye....hame aur sare refugees ko same right de ke hum logo pe kyu aatyachar kar rahe amit ji.

[@ok_Thanx_1235]

@@amol44mankar tum par kya aatyachar ho rha he bhai Tum kamake khila rahe ho kya unko Wo khud jo kam milta he wo kam karke khud ka pet pal rahe he Tum Pakistan me hone chahiye tha tab samjta ki un par kya bit he Jyada secular hona bhi bahut badi mahabhayank bimari he

[@asadsiddiqui6603]

Fir bhi wo log minority me he qke bahut sankhyak asli zimmedsr he abadi badhane ki

[@jayrammaths5935]

I supported this bill. 🇮🇳

[@bdigitalmedia2079]

Poi chaveda vadhoori ..

[@karankakkar4777]

What a great achievement. Must be very happy.

[@shewalisaikia939]

Agar 2 crore 70 lakh bangladeshi ko lakor apne state pe rakhne ka baat kiya jaye toh v aap support karenge kiya? This is not only hindu muslim problem. This is also a problem of assamese motherland. So feel about our emotion.

[@ginanaiding6264]

If you support this bill, why not we send the bangladeshis in your state???

[@ginanaiding6264]

It is not about hindu or muslim. There is so many problems in India: Poverty, unemployment and so many more. When our government cannot take responsibilities for the people of the land, how can they take responsiblity for the bangladeshis? They take the name of religion for justifying these. Does it even make sense?? We do not support any illegal immigrants be it of any religion. When we cannot feed our own stomach, how can we feed somebody else' ??

[@shreekrishnarao7955]

The role of the house speaker is that of a glorified class monitor for 50+ year olds. What a painful position to be in.

[@aryagangopadhyay]

He is the Hon'ble Chairman of Rajya Sabha and also the Vice President of India

[@National__Motivation_0007]

ईश्वर प्रेम से भरपूर रहे आप मोटा भाई पर।

[@vinaykumar-jv1ku]

अब भारत माता अपने सभी पीरित बच्चों को अपनी आंचल की छाया में रखेगी । भारत माता की जय 🇮🇳 वन्दे मातरम 🇮🇳

[@jokerking486]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣wat a joke bro tuj jaise ko rakhe gi

[@आलोकगुप्ता-छ4ष]

जो मैं सोचा करता था वह बिल आज वास्तव में आ गया अविश्वसनीय अकल्पनीय अखंड भारत हिन्दू राष्ट्र

[@shilpisinha9411]

Amit shah jii patel sahab ki kamii puri kr skte h... Bharat mata ki jaii❤❤🙏🙏🙏

[@nican8709]

Love from assam to amit shah bjp

[@Abhishek-rq6kz]

@@toklagaming1182 jal gayi🤣🤣

[@nipurnadwievedi1771]

BHAI TUMHARE YAHN PE LOG PROTEST KYUN KR RHE H JBKI WAHAN TO CAB NHI H..

[@PrincessComet16]

Immigrant found

[@amol44mankar]

keep all illegal migrants in your state dont send them to maharashtra...then i m ok with it pls its a request

[@anirudhrajkhowa385]

Chup Kela sudurbhai

[@ChauhanJPL]

54:07 Hum t isi desh mn jnme hn yahin mrnge👏👏👏

[@niranjanbiswas6029]

Thanks for saving hindu bengali.. Many innocent hindu can fulfill their dreams.

[@PrincessComet16]

NIRANJAN BISWAS how do you feel after savouring Tripura?

[@XRay5633]

Oh coming illegally in Tripura like thief and occupying our land and now ua thanking mota bhai we wl neva accept u all

[@upanidesh]

The bill is for a good cause and does not support Hindu-Muslim divide. So those who think that they can harm Muslims now, or those who think that it is nonsecular and wants to make a "Hindu Rashtra", should stop spreading hatred, as can be seen in various comments made before.

[@upanidesh]

@@anuragsaikia6919 Bhej do bhai..no problem...I am from UP,..but before sending also make sure that you create consensus among majority of the people of my state and your state.

[@Thisiskukreja]

Dude respect for reply

[@jatinsharma6724]

@@anuragsaikia6919 mere m bhej bhai... Haryana sonepat ka hu... Bhej dekhu kitna dum h tere mein...aaja mere bete.. Bhej mere state m👍

[@baburoy3444]

I really support you mota bhai.....you are my favourite leader.....love from West Bengal.....but bengal wants a leader just like you , you can drive away tmc ,cpm etc

[@amol44mankar]

keep all illegal migrants in your state dont send them to maharashtra...then i m ok with it pls its a request

[@moulibanerjee7517]

True..no bengalis wont let illegal migrants b in bengal any more

[@pateldrupesh]

Look at chidambaram who shamelessly sitting in front row and laughing after being in jail for 106 days.

[@amol44mankar]

thug life

[@oliktamut]

This shows modi govt stupidity

[@venkatkumar812]

@@oliktamut Yes they should have kept him inside forever

[@spreadlove5940]

He was under Judicial custody. He is in bail now. No one has PROVED HIM GUILTY.

[@venkatkumar812]

@@spreadlove5940 omg!! I thought bail was given to those, who have been convicted. If cases against him was false, he would have come out freely not in bail!!!

[@kuldeepchaudhary5901]

Aa gya smjh Idea of INDIA, inko😂😂😂😂, this made me laugh so hard

[@vishwanathkaviraj2222]

The great leader I have ever seen in my life

[@anandverma9298]

अंधेरे में कमरे में देखना की मोटा भाई से डर लगता है कि नहीं।😁😁😁

[@sagarikatamang4665]

Hypocrisy of this guy seriously Why is the nation suffering The audacity 🤝

[@anantadas268]

Really good speech and clarification for the confused people. It is clear that it is not for harming any Indians (not even non-Indians). It is just a constitutional right to those who are already staying in India (not by law, may be forced to come to India from neighboring country)

[@gordhanbhaichhatrala3486]

p

[@meditationmusicfree9313]

Amazing decision by Indian government 👍👍👍we salute u sir for the daring decision 🙏🙏🙏

[@kundankatrina]

I am really impressed how calmly honourable external affairs minister S Jaishankar is sitting behind Amit shah. Calmness, one of the traits of a true civil servant.

[@RaviGupta-xt5qj]

When congressi is coughing पीछे बाबुल सुप्रियो is like that ऐ... हटा सावन की घटा...😅 Love you Babul n Shah ji... 😊

[@nice-eg9dx]

बिलकुल सही है...अमित शाहजी की बात..... मैं समर्थन करता हुं ...बिल का ....

[@justint931985]

Amit Shah was clear and crisp!

[@sivakrishna6300]

Correct

[@ashokakkinen2620]

Jai Hind... Amit Shah sir aur humare Modji 👏👏👏👏👏👏

[@vishwanathkaviraj2222]

I Vishwanath kaviraj support this bill and I personally want thank Shri Amit Shah

[@spsharma8108]

Please bring population control bill without any further delay and then implement that law in letter and spirit.

[@vikashprasad1666]

Common civil code too But controversy tb v hogi

[@krishnavamsi4102]

population control bill is very important

[@ansumandas8832]

The following facts are based on complete political research and does not associate me with any political party. 1)CAB is an amendment bill to the Citizenship Act of 1995 .Where in under the provisions listed under sections 3, 4, 5(1) and 5(4) of the Citizenship Act,there are four ways in which Indian citizenship can be acquired: birth, descent, registration and naturalisation. This highlights the fact that the CAB as it is well known is not going to affect the current or the present citizens of India irrespective of wether the citizen belongs to any particular religion, minority ,majority,atheist,Theist,agnostic Group(Article 15-No discrimantion will be made to any citizen of india on the grounds of religion,race,sex,birth place,caste). 2)CAB is a bill that is in continuum to the partition of India.Noted that the British India got divided into two dominion states India and pakistan(west and east)on the basis of 'Religion' and subsequently in 1971 the East pakistan separating from the west as the independent state of Bangladesh. 3)CAB is in continuum to the NRC in Assam that was done to root out the illegal immigrants in the state. 4)The amendment is clearly meant to provide citizenship rights to 6 minorities group(Hindu ,Buddhist,Sikh,Christian,Parsi,Jain)of three states namely Pakistan,Afghanistan and Bangladesh. Thus justifying that the inclusion class is not religious in nature rather minority in Nature. 5)Reason behind selecting only pakistan ,Afghanistan and bangladesh is a) These are countries that have Islam as their state religion unlike India that has no state religion. b)Being Islamic state clearly mentions that these are Muslim Majority countries. c) Minority groups in such countries are being discriminated against their religion and statistics reveal that there has been noteworthy decline in the minority population. A direct resultant of forced religious conversions and other inhumanly and discriminatory actions over the years. Eventhough Sri Lanka and Bhutan are Neighbouring states having buddhism as their state religion but cases such as discrimination on the basis of religion has been minimal in such states when compared to the later and most importantly migrants from both the countries are lesser as in comparision to the vast majority from Bangladesh ,Pakistan and Afghanistan who have fled from their home states on the grounds of religious discrimination and want us to help them .Moreover, several provisions or amendment have been made to the Citizenship act(Nine Amendment as of record) in the past years that were specific in nature to address specific issues like of Sinhalese tamil(Sri Lankan tamil),Indians who were persecuted in the 1972 expulsion of Ugandans of Indian origin, and Indic-origin religious minorities. Under the Indian law, multiple groups that are generally accepted as legal refugees includes Tibetans, Sri Lankan Tamils, 6)The amendment act will also take care of the north eastern states under Article 371 repecting their inner permits along with preserving and protecting the ethics,culture,belief ,population and traditions of the protected tribes. 7)The government is also reluctant that,it will also provide citizenship to any muslim immigrant who's been discriminated and can produce the necessary @t the govt had done in its last tenure providing 566 muslim immigrants citizenship rights. 8) Keeping vote bank and politics aside,Instances such as parsi community that was religiously persecuted from Iran settling in Gujurat of India highlights that India has always opend its gate for people who have been religiously persecuted in their home states. To Conclude the amendment act does not discriminates the right of any present citizen of India rather it will be correct to say, It deals with the minority community of some specific state justifying the reasonable classification and not violating Article 14. Thus no religious discrimination is being done and it will provide or ease the process for those immigrants who were not included in the NRC of Assam due to their liability in producing the legal papers and largely depend on our country for their legal rights. "Where there is love there is life" as said by Mahatma Gandhi, As a human and belonging to a country that stands with unjust. The only humanitarian action that can be taken without compromising National security is to accept these minorities group and provide them with legal citizenship but citizenship should only be offered after a thorough evaluation as it deals with National security and to add on rather than concentrating the mass in one state or some states over India there must be talks with states that are ready and are in position to accept the masses because the addition will not only add to population of a particular state but will also have equal share in in evrything.For instance addition to the Gross food,power,employment,Reservation demand and will also be conducive in worsening the already worsened GDP at the present.

[@talhajunaid5578]

the whole conclusion is that for including about 1.9 millions of people in which approx 10 lakh or above are belonging to hindu community shall be given citizenship because of their persecution in that particular country .but for excluding muslim u take the names of muslim majority countries why u don't take tamil hindu who also persecuted in sri lanka .and for ur kind information the HFAC & USRIC issued a notice against amit shah and others 5 leaders for passing it as a discriminatory rule of law and modifying it by taking and taunting "persecution" it is same for all whether it is hindu muslim whatever.we live in a secular country which has some moral values our shia and as well as those who does'nt support any violence muslims also persecuted in pakistan in myanmar in tamil in china in afghanistan only exception is bhutan where its safe in all it's neighbouring countries ........the rule which u r talking about is self contradictory it's based on census of population and it's a long process we have to maintain all records of birth and death a;so it has to be update in records .refugee is refugee u gave them tag of religion and made them legalize citizen.well played majoritarian of whole gubernatorial power of making this "illogical bill".in thus type of politics we are only a base on which they stand but they forgot that without making strong base u never made multistory.and one think no one in this entire country could exclude muslims because if we eliminate then u will have no other options to debate on fuck about pakistani fuck about communalism I AM SIMPLY UNDERSTAND THIS THIS IS THE COUNTRY OF "HINDU".AND IF U WANTS TO WIN THE ELECTIONS PLAYED THEM IN THE NAME OF RELIGION AND CHANT "JAI SHREE RAM".THIS ATTRACTS BILLION OF VOTES ...GOOD IDEOLOGY "THE MAJORITARIAN".the hon.SC RULED OUT THIS AND ERADIACTE THIS EVIL OUT OFF AND BRING THE PEACE SOONER

[@ansumandas8832]

@@talhajunaid5578 Talking about the history ,Congress led by Indira Gandhi govt did make amendment to the Act to include the bangladeshi refugee,so was in another case when sinhalese Tamil were given.So it clearly suggests that the previous amendments were not only specific in their selection of country but were also specific in the community of refugee or immigrant that they provided citizenship.If in the present case we consider all our neighbouring countries then clearly then there will be no refugee in the country without citizenship and when question such as what is the reasonable classification for providing citizenship rises the simple answer is "Refugee in general" I fear this might raise eyebrows as it completely compromises the Nation's security.Thus creating an image that settle in India as a refugee the govt is there to give you citizenship.Yes, a refugee must be seen as a refugee but India has always been a country that has potrayed as a land of just and if we dont do it today then again people wil say we have cone way across our moral and ethics.

[@ansumandas8832]

Lets not discuss politics ,we are far more from it.As a human being our primary religion should be humanity."Something is better than nothing" Atleast we are working together for helping afew of the millions.Let's hope for a better bill if the judiciary rules down the later.

[@harshanand127]

Well,let me say something sir,u first said it is not based on religion,but correct me if i am wrong that the bill cleary named a few and left the other specific one,which cleary means it is including religion as a basis,so which further means isn't secular...it would be secular if it din't mention any thing related to religion and just mentioned those people as illegal immigrents,so yea,it is against the ideals of our nation which never includes religion as a basis of choosing someone over the other....second,if you say that only these communities are oppressed in our adjacent countries bcz islam is prominent there,and u have no prejudice against them,then i guess if we considers neigbours,china is more of a neighbour than afganistan,and there, the muslims are also in dire situations,and much worse than what we see in pakistan or bangladesh treat the so called minority there,why not include them...third,in a country with such poverty and decreasing growth rate and illitrecy and few job oppertunity,who's gonna pay for their subsidies,who's gonna leave his job oppertunity to let them have it,i am not being cruel,but just practical.are u ready to pay more income taxes and more gst,are you willing to leave a better job so that some one who was not indian a year ago took it ,which requires the indian nationality,or you think that after making some meaningless statues and other "religious architectures",and losing growth rate and continuously losing it,govt still has enough funds for it,and if they have,why does this fking govt just spends mere 2.7 % of its gdp in education,why is there a need to privatize our railways,and the list goes on,how much i am supposed to say..4th and the also most important about this bill,it isn't even saying what will happen to those who are'nt considered a indian citizen,bcz bangladesh cleary stated that they wont take them back,so where do they stay?,are u gonna keep them in detenrion camp...lakhs of people???? How are we considered kind hearted if we just let one part of the group to misery while other get the citizenship(i am saying a part bcz i consider all of them as a community called humans,),what the govt should actually be discussing in the parliament is how to solve these problems about there habitat,jobs,health so that the natives there dont get mistreated anyhow..and not to recognize them based on their religion and give birth to another communal conflict....but since these idiotic nincompoops sitting there are not capable of solving the real prblms,all they can do is this ,so the people dont even understand the real prblms and praise them....and thats all that they want...

[@talhajunaid5578]

@@ansumandas8832 truee brother 100% i'm agree with ur concept of humanity just in the name of muslims we don't make any muslim discrimination i'm sure that u must have some muslims friends and i also have hindu friends .but in politics they play wid our emotions and made everything in the colour of religion cuz only religion in this whole world is the drastic prob.which can'nt be cure in lucid way .if they take muslim also in this scheme it's better this is the only solution but they don't take in the name of "islamophobia" .make citizens all people who are persecuted in various regions don't give the color of religion to this serious issue

[@tapasghosh5320]

The honorable members of The Parliament MUST observe DECORUM in the houses. It must be kept in mind that this is not a place for street fight.

[@vishwanathkaviraj2222]

Amit Shah is face of God for those who face tremendous problem becoz they migrate from Bangladesh

[@pdc19]

70 saal ye logo ko desh chalane diya hota to desh ki bahot progress hoti , These people and Government are Most Patriotic and Best tough decision Makers and implimentors Great work Jai Hind Jai Bharat

[@sathyanathanmenon7778]

Mota bhai ne opposition ka har saval ka ithna acha jawab diya.😍

[@SANJEEVKUMAR-ok6mi]

100 percent right sir...

[@kankanjana9006]

Excellent explanation. Sir Amit Shah addressed each and every query clearly.

[@litanroy2106]

If there's a living tiger politician now in India, that's Amit Shah sir. Respect & admiration.

[@EditAudios-br2rz]

😂I'm only watching Dr. S Jaishankar sir coz its 2023 he's the legend now

[@perspectiveswithjonah1054]

The comment section shows how easily it is to get the people deluded by the power of a speech. In reality he never addressed any of the questions asked by the opposition. PS: He smoothly skipped Chitabaram's 4 questions

[@quantum3712]

Swamy cleared legality.

[@virajwaghanna]

He did. You can ask him 10 times he will answer 100 times

[@bikramjit3371]

Though religious based,but it makes sense,logic is not wrong

[@safalghosh]

Minority does not mean religious minority only.

[@pinkipandey9513]

I did not know if he justifies himself or his decision well though the only thing i know and believe in, i truly believe and support BJP (Modi+Amit Shah) in each of their decision coz they are the ones who thought of the welfare of each and every Indian and their problems

[@rahultiwari987]

Very very thank you amit shah ji

[@sinchankumarroy8240]

thank you modi jii

[@kavangowda5895]

Well done motubhai

[@binaykumarbagh6909]

I support CAB..its not against religion... good decesion by govt..

[@prateekrai6260]

@@ginanaiding6264 hahaha

[@pankajmandal698]

Lakho lakho namaskar amitji &modiji. From WB.

[@ruchisinghparihar2290]

One man show.......... 🔥 🔥 🔥 🔥 🔥

[@Ashu_amazingworld]

One man army

[@vikramg346]

one anti tamil hindu also. bjp is manipulating by saying this bill saves hindu but left sri lankan tamil . if u dont like tamil hindus please leave us from india. we will be happy to go out because of ur vengeance towards tamil hindus.

[@Ashu_amazingworld]

@@vikramg346 You will also be included sometime, This country belongs to hindu and no hindu will be discriminated in bjp rule, don't worry. Make faith in this government

[@vikramg346]

@@Ashu_amazingworld its not about faith or unfaith. its about time, bjp says this bill protects hindu at the same time excluding south hindus. think from our side what our people think. they already start asking are we hindu or not and it creates anti bjp sentiment even stronger. our politicians are using this as an anti bjp rhetoric to gain in their elections. its a big mistake that bjp done .also please dont say like you will be included in future it frustrates when u try to legitimize ur actions of misrepresentation. u purposefully left sri lankan tamil refugees u will pay the price in future u never going to achieve anything in tamilnadu hereafter please take notes of it. this will be taken as political weapon by our politicians and they are going to frame it as they want. atleast they should take this bill for rectifications.

[@Ashu_amazingworld]

@@vikramg346 please be patient, whatever actions were taken and bills passed till now like eradication of article 370, supreme court's decision in favour of Ram mandir or it is CAB or NRC they all are in our favour. Al least we can faith on this party to be thinking at least about our beliefs, want to save our hindu culture. You have not got your citizenship, it's late this time but it is never in this country that will happen and cause you to think that your decision was wrong coming to this country as a hindu. You will never be discriminated here, as this country is for hindus. It was more pity conditions of all the hindus who came from bangladesh, Afghanistan or pakistan than you all. Also NRC will also be implemented after this bill to send all infiltrator muslims back, who came here not with a purpose to reside but to disturb our religious beliefs and make it a islamic state. So, it was necessary for these three countrie's people to be taken care of as soon as possible, in government' s 5 year term or it may happen in 2 or 3 years that government loose its majority in rajya sabha. So it became very important.

[@thundermonkey4249]

Bring all the immigrants to UP and Gujarath only.

[@ajaybais]

जय श्री राम....🚩🚩🚩मज़ा आ गया !!

[@edwini1234]

Economy pr bol tu apne baap ko baat kre

[@Mangotree-t]

There is no problem if Amit Shah can accommodate all in his residence coz we hv no land or job for foreign.

[@darkinferno4687]

BJP ending votebank politics Hats off!!

[@rohitdas9068]

Jo sahi hota he sahi hota he.... Mota Bhai jindabad.....

[@changinglife9319]

We are with you shah ji.....we support CAB

[@ginanaiding6264]

It is not about hindu or muslim. There is so many problems in India: Poverty, unemployment and so many more. When our government cannot take responsibilities for the people of the land, how can they take responsiblity for the bangladeshis? They take the name of religion for justifying these. Does it even make sense?? We do not support any illegal immigrants be it of any religion. When we cannot feed our own stomach, how can we feed somebody else' ??

[@ginanaiding6264]

Those who support CAB, we will send those immigrants to your state. Lets see how you accept them??

[@ginanaiding6264]

@akhil kumar i also have soft corner for those people ofcourse. Most of the labours who build roads and bridges are them. But the thing is if every other state took equal responsibility in providing shelter to them then i dont think there would have been uprise against this decision. But they are largely concentrating lakhs of them in Assam which is a small state in itself and overpopulated too.

[@syed-apienergy2802]

if you combine CAB and NRC ....nobody needs to prove their citizenship except Muslims because when NRC will be done and all people of different religions who don't have documents will say that we are immigrants who are persecuted in Pakistan, Bangladesh and Afghanistan but when Muslims who have lived here for generations say that they dont have documents to prove it then what will happen to them???

[@angelchow9613]

The most indecent and ill behaved are the minister from West Bengal. The people of Bengal must see whom they are sending to represent them. Being such educated state their ministers are the worst

[@zindagiwithJyotsna]

Logo ne yu hi afwah faila rakhi h jabki sarkar sirf in sarnarthiyo ko hak dene ke liye hi yh amendment kr rhi h

[@DevRaj-bf9yv]

Everything is politically correct.

[@nityarao672]

Ek tarfa speeches se opinion mat banaiye. Opposition k arguements bhi sun le.

[@narpatprajapath3425]

Right

[@ALONEBOY-f2u3v]

Jyoti singh sis. they are also people. like us and not M Not H But Bjp is H.

[@saveenvironment3542]

Listen carefully all the fact related to CAB and clear ur all doubts.... 🙂 Full support CAB bill ✌✌

[@iphone9217]

How can a citiezen can show documents of 1970s is it possible???...okay all the muslims has to go pak..than they will take minorities from pak ryt..who will give citiezen ship for them...govt..so govt can provide citiezen ship for other countries people...but they cant give to the people who born and live here...thats one.. Next if this bill passes..can it applicable for same thing for christians..sikh and all other minorities later??? Defenitely they can...one they will ask to produce the same thing.. than..only majority people will exist ryt...so religeos issue will close.. Than next what will happen??? Language will come...everyone should follow the majority language eg hindi...again protest will happenss ..continues....at last same thim it can be done for majority language. Finally...same thing can be applicable for same religion in hindus...ie cast systemm...agan dalits like people will suffer....nice..already india is not developed ...still developing country...for this kind of things from here only we have to stop. .other wise.. again india will goes to 1970s

[@vijaydabgar8834]

Wah Amit bhai wah bahu j saras sachu bolya

[@madhavsolanki4975]

Gjjjb Mota Bhai Shandarrrrr I impress

[@abhilashreddyGCS]

Illogical Explanation by Home Minister... If you start Citizenship based upon the Religion India will lose our Spirit...

[@riyuzakhi]

chootiye read about what bill is being passed ... its for immigrants not people residing in this country..

[@prateekrai6260]

Apna ilaj karwa...mental u want pakistan Bangladesh muslim to settle in India...

[@dailydoseofmath]

awesome speech . dislike is from congress supporter.

[@JAYANTDASHER]

Amit Shah should also consider to help Jaitley to join to improve better too !

[@mayurtade]

Ek kaam karte hai ye Pakistan ko bhi India me merg kar lete hai.. phir sub log Indian citizens hai.. 😂😜

[@jatinsharma6724]

Sir india m kachra phle hi bhot h phir or import kyu krna... 😁

[@AMTales]

Where is the survey on the basis of which only the people from these particular religions have been included in the bill?

[@annuraj3906]

Love you sir & Salute Amit Sir ❤️

[@safalghosh]

Reasonable classification cannot be based on religion, because the religion is a matter of personal faith.

[@FreefireBoss-b4t]

Thank you rajyasabha tv

[@vishalbhadauriya2758]

Our second iron Man of India after sardar Patel

[@gaihiamngamful]

We NAGAS people never trust political leaders said .. political n politicians will keep on their own prodigious

[@riyuzakhi]

thats why that area is never developed...grow up and globalise idiots

[@lalchandmondal8966]

Great job thank you Mota vai

[@kulkarnivishkha]

Hindurakshak Amit shah ,modi!

[@binoychandrabarman3199]

Mota bhai you are really great you and Moodiji are real politicians

[@parikshitde3147]

See 46:38...Sri Ami Shahji,,, had CAB been inclusive and empathetic enough, it would have kept provisions for Rohingyas (one of the most persecuted minorities in the world as described by UNITED NATION in 2013) who were in pathetic situations in Myanamer (again one of our neighbouring countries) and in search of a safe shelter and already came in India before 31st Dec 2014...in fact CAB should defer the date further to include most of this troubled minorities....it should not matter how they came/ have come inside India as long as they are looking for shelter to lead a decent and modest lifestyle...So please amend the current CAB and make it inclusive. The right sense of fraternity irrespective of religious identity can definitely make that possible.

[@vikashprasad1666]

Aapko job v chahiye and share v karna , 2no saath nhi ho sakte.

[@tapanjena1707]

For a moment i read it like Sinister instead of Minister and thats more accurate.

[@VishwajeetRStudy]

Jai Hind

[@ravirajgurjjar7023]

Kya ye hi liking tha

[@adhunikmanav2638]

Is hamaam me sab nange hai. Chahe congress ho ya BJP

[@azaadbharat6625]

CHANGE THE CONSTITUTION Make Bharat a HINDU SANATAN DHARMA NATION

[@Goulaltonxing]

Fool

[@Kunal1255]

Asshole

[@jayanjay6030]

Amithbai..motabai. Jai jai

[@truebeliever5761]

No religious discrimination.... Rohingya Muslims kobhi Citizenship dedo then no one oppose this bill.

[@toldyou1178]

Neta kisi ka nahi hota, Ye to dhobi ke ... hai bhaiyo, man marzi se left se uth ke right me baith jaenge and vice versa. To khud padho samjho. Jai Hind.

[@vajrapani6604]

Amit Shah is amazing. Congress Party stands fully exposed in their Hinduphobia!! What they have not done in decades, NDA has done in the beginning of 2nd term.

[@meenadevi3116]

The past is only weapon to save oneself

[@BD-xf7yn]

Why congress party gets upset when talk about Pakistan atrocities towards minority, congress party need to think about Bharat if they want to be a strong opposition party and wants to be leader of Bharat